r/DarK • • Aug 25 '24

[SPOILERS S3] I don't like the ending and here's why Spoiler

0 Upvotes

The most intriguing aspect of this story is its infinite, looping nature - an endless, unchangeable knot. You could easily make a 10+ minute montage of various characters repeating lines like, "everything that happened before will happen again, ad infinitum." But the ending completely undermines this concept, hurriedly introducing a whole other dimension to the story.

In the last episode, the "knot" is essentially thrown out the window. Suddenly, we learn that things can be changed, and then this only gets explored for like 40 minutes in a show that spent 3 seasons stuck in a knot! This for me cheapened the concept as a whole. If things can be changed, it's not much of a knot, now is it?

It would have been nice if the origin world and ability to alter the knot come into play much earlier. We could have had an entire third season where Adam and Eva both know about this anomaly and try to use it to their advantage. Imagine watching each iteration slowly shift in favor of one or the other - a never ending game of tug of war, where it's later revealed neither of them can ever win, because they're still bound by the knot. Any changes made were futile, everything was always part of the knot, destined to be altered and unaltered forever. IMO that would’ve made for a much more eerie, satisfying conclusion and better suited the themes of the show!

Instead, the conclusion we get feels rushed. To make matters worse, we're given such an insultingly short epilogue where the knot doesn't exist. We should have gotten to see every character's "unknotted ending"! Man, it would've been great to see what Charlotte, Helge, and the others were like in that reality, but we never get that closure! (Edit: People have helped me understand that we're not supposed to get an alternate ending for these characters, they got thanos'd as well. Well, I wish we could have at least seen that.)

It's frustrating that a show that often drags out other episodes with excessive close-ups hurried through such a pivotal conclusion. What a missed opportunity.

Anyone else feel the same?


r/DarK • • Aug 05 '21

[SPOILERS S3] I don't think I've ever been more disappointed in a finale than this show. The message that undermines the characters of previous episodes. Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Season 1 and Season 2 were, without looking in retrospect, some of the best TV. If the show was stupid and made all the most frequent errors of time travel I would not have had such high expectations and when they revert to this, incredibly disappointing.

They could have taken some parts of Season 3, I think it was episode 7 that summarised everything in the original loop, and put that as the finale to season 2 and left it there. Great TV, mostly excellent physics when you accept the conceit. would've been one of my favourite TV shows. A tragic piece about no matter how hard you try the loop is self correcting, or self caused. No need to explain why the loop began as the conceit of that style of time travel requires the universe to invent itself a closed loop anyway.

However, season 3, ok they introduced two worlds, not great. And then they introduce four loops (the inner and outer loops of each world), getting worse. But because of how well they had demonstrated an understanding in seasons 1 and 2 I kept with it. Also from a meta perspective, while it was easier to follow the single loop in seasons 1 and 2 I had, and I imagine many in the audience, a significantly harder time keeping track of the two/four timelines that most of season 3 had (universe 1a: the Jonas stays in his (to become Adam to kill himself), universe 1b: the Martha kidnaps Jonas one and there's no Jonas or Adam, universe 2a: where Martha doesn't kidnap Jonas, universe 2b: where Martha brings Jonas in), but whatever, complexity is not a reason to do it. It could have been fine, the season explores the different worlds and then closes the loop anyway, even three worlds as long as the loop remained closed because that was the message of the show.

And then in the finale, we get the most idiotic of sequences, that goes against the whole fucking point of the first two seasons, where we had clear dialogue of the characters acknowledging that there was no change. But at no point do any of these characters other than Eva, mention anything. Adam at no point says "if we succeeded in closing the loop then I wouldn't be talking to you", or Martha asks how they could be there to stop the car and tell them the bridge is closed, if there is no time travel. Remember all the scenes with Adam, Eva and HG discussing time travel, so rare in a show. Then the scene with the gold dust? As if humans are some special entity, if they closed the loop (assuming that it's even possible for the loop to close itself by, without leaving the grandfather paradox which I dispute) then what physical law do you think means that when a universe ends then people turn into gold dust? How about all the air particles and atoms changed by their presence?

NOT ONLY THAT, by demonstrating that people are able to change their past, and that all that happens will be that you turn to gold dust, then it makes no sense why Jonas couldn't shoot himself, even seeing his future self. All that would have happened would be his future self turned to gold dust. So even if you can resolve it it undermines the whole message of the loop, and basically means that Jonas didn't try hard enough to kill himself or do anything to enact change.

I cannot remember what movie it was but they had time travel in it and the guy was in jail and wanted to prove to his cell mate he could travel in time, so he stabbed himself in the past and his skin changed before the eyes of the cellmate. It's almost at that level of idiocy. [ found it https://youtu.be/i1XXIXfxaMY?t=72 ]

I saw this photo posted: https://i.imgur.com/NPJmekx.png Which obviously doesn't work, there can't be an infinite loop and change, and the loop can't cause itself to not exist (that was of course the whole point of seasons 1 and 2, Adam couldn't shoot himself because he already existed, and then the show says actually he could have done that at any point, because you can change the past (according to the show's own logic), but I digress. QUICK EDIT: Obviously this can all be resolved with new universes being made, but that still ruins the point of having a show about a loop. At any moment Jonas could've made an alt. timeline then.

Also, another issue that if some old clockworker can invent time travel in his bunker then it's going to get invented 1000x in the next hundred years. At least with a nuclear accident you can imagine that no one is going out there way to replicate that, and few people have access to nuclear power plants, and they require committees to fiddle around with, so maybe time travel wouldn't be invented for 1000 more years when people have personal nuclear reactors. But this guy did it in 30 years in his basement with 1950 technology.

Edit 2: Since obviously this is a fan sub, 99% of people will lap up explanations just like people like explanations for Back to the Future or other inherently contradictory time travel, but surely there must be critique, not everyone will just believe an explanation because the guy said quantum twenty times?

Edit 3: Also, HG isn't gonna become a good father just because his son came back when he was mad. In fact his daughter-in-law already told him he'll come back. So from his perspective nothing changed. It took the death of his whole family for him to be a "good" father, at least Charlotte never said any complaints though in Martha's universe she's a cheater so maybe not raised all that well too.

Edit 4: I can't believe I forgot about the cringe time tunnel too, I cannot believe the last episode was written by the same people who designed that beautiful loop

Edit 5: Also while Jonas has had his life twisted for a good year in the final scene Martha has basically had her world unravelled for a few days and spent less than that actually involved in it so her emotional involvement is really undersold. Why they invented a Martha who had no history with Jonas I do not understand because it undermines their scenes when you just think "She met Jonas 10 hours ago", e.g. when she sees young Jonas, unlike Jonas who lived his whole life with Martha.


r/DarK • • May 22 '22

[SPOILERS S1] I tried watching the 1st episode Spoiler

1 Upvotes

I have 5 minutes left. I understand nothing. I mean basic things like the characters, who are they and how they are connected to one another, what is going on between them, how come they are all receiving a phone call at the same time and from whom, what did the old lady read in that letter and who the f is she. Who wrote the letter ? I watched the first 30 mins or so without subtitles. Maybe I should rewatch the entire episode ? or this show is just not for me. I should mention that this never happens to me. I usually understand almost everything.

Thanks.


r/DarK • • Apr 17 '24

[SPOILERS S3] To be fair, you have to have a very high IQ to understand Dark

12 Upvotes

To be fair, you have to have a very high IQ to understand Dark. The setting is extremely complex, and without a solid grasp of theoretical quantum mechanics and time travel most of the story will go over a typical viewer's head. There's also Adam's nihilistic outlook, which is deftly woven into his characterisation - his personal philosophy draws heavily from the actions of his future-self, for instance. The fans understand this stuff; they have the intellectual capacity to truly appreciate the depths of the Winden family tree, to realise that it is not just incest - it says something deep about LIFE. As a consequence, people who dislike Dark truly ARE idiots - of course they wouldn't appreciate, for instance, the meaning in the relationship between Charlotte and Elisabeth, which itself is a cryptic reference to the Bootstrap paradox. I'm smirking right now just imagining one of those addlepated simpletons scratching their heads in confusion as Papa Baran and Mama Jantje's genius unfolds itself on their television screens. What fools ... how I pity them. 😂 And yes by the way, I DO have a Dark tattoo. And no, you cannot see it. It's for the ladies' eyes only - and even they have to demonstrate that they're within 5 IQ points of my own (preferably lower) beforehand.


r/DarK • • Mar 03 '26

[SPOILERS S3] How much of this community was actually disappointed with the ending? Spoiler

1 Upvotes

Hey guys.

I just finished Dark. The whole show hooked me from the start. I kept watching at the edge of my seat waiting for the next paradoxical plot twist. It was great.

Well, one think that stood out to me about this show is that, differently from any other time travel fiction story, this one is big on the Bootstrap Paradox. The whole spiel is about how if anything happens, it has happened before, and will happen again. It is great how the whole show something pulls the characters to do exactly something they were trying to prevent. Egon's death, for example, great.

Then, quantum superposition happened. And I wasn't even that bothered by it, until the very last episode where they decide that the quantum superposition exists outside of the main story loop.

They literally changed rules to give the audience a happy ending, that shouldn't exist at all in my opinion:

  • The old rule: If you go back to kill your grandfather, the gun will jam. You can't change the past because your existence proves you failed.

  • The last episode: Jonas and Martha go back, save the family, and then fade away like Marty McFly in Back to the Future.

I like to reference Back to the Future here because the show looked like it mocked those kind of time travel fiction premises from start until the very last couple of episodes. It was jarring to be honest. But they decided that the quantum superposition was above the whole deterministic universe. Here is what makes sense: quantum superposition exists like the rest of the universe (it looked like they were going that way, with B timelines Jonas and Alt-Martha) deterministically. Instead, we got a "get out of jail free" card to justify this poor ending.

It doesn't make sense that this quantum superposition thing allows Jonas and Martha to act outside of the loop. And even if it did, there were infinite cycles were that was never discovered, so it should remain undiscovered, or the whole show premise would be ruined. And that's what they did.

Then, they save Marek. This fucking show spent 2.9 seasons convincing us that that is impossible. By the show's own logic:

  • Outcome A: Marek dies to Machine built to Jonas/Martha born to They save Marek.

  • Outcome B: Marek lives to No machine to No Jonas/Martha to Marek dies.

But they go in the past, save Marek, and vanish into thin air. I don't care if it's a third world, quantum superpositioned Jonas and Martha, it's the whole Grandfather Paradox, that they mocked the whole show, and slapped our face with it once they realised they had created a cage so perfect there was no logical way out.

It abandons the "Nothing can be changed" premise out of nowhere. It introduces a new rule (the loophole) at the 11th hour to solve a problem that was supposedly unsolvable.

And Claudia can't never "pass a little bit more" of knowledge each time (I know some people believe that) because each time is the first time, always, but the show's own rules.

Okay, that was a bit of a rant. Looking in this subreddit, people don't seem to agree with me. Most people actually like the ending. Why do you think that is? Did I get something wrong? Is it like Game of Thrones, that people don't really care about the ending, because the rest of the show was so good? Let me know your thoughts!

EDIT: Maybe I wasn't to clear. I don't think I have any questions, and, again, if I got something wrong, please tell me. My goal here is straight up accusing the writers of poorly writing the ending. And I want to know your thoughts.


r/DarK • • Nov 17 '24

[NO SPOILERS] Why are people so snooty about subtitles?

0 Upvotes

I was talking with a friend about how seemingly impossible it is to convince people to watch this show and he made some remark implying that people who don’t like subtitles are culturally lesser. I’ve similarly warned some people against the dub because I think it’s a bad dub, but they immediately assure me that they would never do something so vulgar as to consider a dub.

I’m being hyperbolic about their comments, but, guys, who likes subtitles? Like I have to miss so many visual details because I’m trying to read and watch the action at the same time. Plus, people can’t read as quickly as they can hear, so translation has to be compromised a bit to keep the word count low.

I get that it’s a bummer that non-English-language media doesn’t get more attention, but it’s okay for people to not enjoy the experience of translated film/TV.

ETA: Wasn’t expecting so much backlash. I’m just saying that it sucks to have to rely on translation at all. I’ve considered learning German so that I could kind of experience Dark as intended; I wish I knew Japanese because Haruki Murakami is probably my favorite writer. I want everyone to watch Dark and consume as much non-English-language art as possible; I’m just saying that things ARE lost in translation and we shouldn’t assume that people are uncultured just because it’s hard for them to read fast enough.


r/DarK • • May 31 '24

[SPOILERS S3] Finished the show for the first time - My thoughts Spoiler

1 Upvotes

DarK is definitely not the best show I've ever seen, but it's better than average, and great in many regards.

It's going to sound like I'm a hater. I'm not. I actually quite like the show, the negatives just stand out to me more than the positives for any viewing experience. I also hope to be corrected in any areas where I'm wrong or could be granted a new perspective.

I'm not hating, I enjoyed it! But here we go.

Timeline Integrity

What I appreciated most about the show is the integrity of the event mapping. It's pretty clear to me that they knew every step from the beginning.

However, something that would've made this more smooth would've been a one-off moment of someone from "another world" making an appearance way in advance of the s2 finally. But done in a way that it wouldn't be understood on a first viewing. This would make a rewatch more thrilling and would cement the idea of everything being a cycle that was known by the writers from launch.

If there are any timeline issues, I'd love to hear about it. It's always fun to investigate those things. I couldn't see any.

Twists

I didn't find myself surprised much in the show. I've probably seen too many movies and TV shows. There wasn't much that I would consider a real twist that took me by surprise. Once time travel is introduced, my dark mind assumes the weirdest nonsense. For example, I kept expecting someone to have to go back in time to sleep with their parent to maintain the timeline. Or something much worse. And I'm glad it didn't quite go that far.

Something that takes away the excitement for me is that we already see the future, so in many ways I don't fear the consequences of anyone's actions if I know their outcome. It seems they try to get us to feel some concern for characters who we know will be fine, or even better off down the line. It just derails the intensity for me personally.

The only two times I felt surprised was the end of season 2 when a new world was introduced and when the third world was introduced.

Worlds

The introduction to a world at the end of s2 for me felt like it pushed the boundary of how much sci-fi I'm comfortable with. I didn't really like that direction, and I think I would like the show more without it.

I did like the introduction of the 3rd world because sets of 3 had been alluded to many times throughout the series and I almost facepalmed and thought to myself "Obviously! How did I not see that coming?". It was a pleasant surprise.

Confusion

I find confusion to be a good thing. For some reason though, I thought Hannah and Martha looked very similar at the start of the show, so it really messed with my head. And because Jonas' hair looked different in a couple of scenes, I thought he was 2 different characters. That's not the type of confusion I enjoy, but I think that's a me issue. By episode 3 I got a hang of who was who. But I did reference this character map after every few episodes. That helped a lot.

Plot

The plot was driven mostly by a lack of communication. Typically, I find that to be the worst way to drive a plot. However, at least DarK has an excuse of characters being careful with their words to keep the timeline on track. I still don't love it. That's why one of the best characters is Franziska. When she called everyone "incompetent", I felt that. It was probably the most I aligned with a character during the show.

I'm still not completely sold on the convergence of timelines (the whole figure 8 concept). I don't think they bring that up earlier in the show, so it felt out of place and shoehorned in... maybe kind of a pointless avenue to go down.

I may not fully understand. This convergence happens because it just has to happen sometime, or because that's when the bomb goes off with the door of time being opened?

Why does alive Schrodinger's Jonas seem to interact with people in dead Schrodinger's Jonas dimension? Shouldn't alive Schrodinger's Jonas have a world of people who are also in the closed Schrodinger cat box world? I guess we could consider that Jonas was the only person in the cat box, and everyone else is the observer? If not, then I don't quite follow this, and I'd love to hear an explanation.

I really like that they do include explanations that let us know why we're seeing the various quantum concepts. Unfortunately, it did feel a bit like the Matrix architect scene at times; it could've been more subtle. But it at least showed us that there's logic behind the writing.

Character Issues

Jonas cries a lot. It's fine, I actually like that he was consistent. I just found it was overdone and it didn't any evoke emotions after the first 10 times. I'm not an emotional person, so I guess it never really hit, but it was exceptionally weak by the end.

Everyone is a deviant. I get that people cheat in real life. But oh my goodness. It felt like every version of every person was cheating, prostituting, visiting prostitutes, oriented divergently, or so easily getting it on with someone else. I just don't think that's reflective of the general population, so I didn't find it believable. But, hey, it's a small town, people get bored... I'm sure in some small town, somewhere, it's like that. I just have an aversion to some of those behaviors, mostly the betrayal and cheating.

Character Thoughts

Regina and Katrina just got wrecked. Ulrich probably had some of the worst of it, but he was a little bit scummy. Katrina and Regina just got thoroughly decimated. That's life, but it was kind of sad to see.

Noah is an interesting guy. He's got the most memorable quotes in the series. I like when he discusses the cosmological argument for God with Mikkel who is young, but obviously naturally inclined towards wisdom. I don't agree with human endeavors of bad means for a good end, but I'm not sure I'm convinced that he's outright evil. Maybe just confused, or compelled by an understanding so firmly that he's led astray. Once the timeline is resolved, he probably didn't do all of those things, so we are only left to assume his morality/ethicality in this 3rd [first] timeline. Intriguing fella, nonetheless.

Ines was awesome and caring.

I like Bartosz. Not sure why. It was like they abandoned him in the writing at times. But then he'd show up, high and playing video games, or completely blown away by the chaos happening around him. It's kind of funny.

I like Hannah's slight redemption arc at the end of saving her daughter and going back to her family.

Charlotte is fully incompetent.

I really like Mikkel, he's a charming guy with good intentions.

Jana's relationship story was so short lived, but incredibly intriguing to me.

I like that Magnus felt like someone I would've hung out with in 2007.

W. Clausen felt inspired by Twin Peaks and I found his character to be a really fun dynamic. I just wish it followed through to the end and had a bit more screen time. Probably my favorite character.

Other Thoughts

It was funny to me how 3 times people tried to wash blood off their hands in the same manner. I don't know why, but it just tickles me a bit.

Seasons 1 & 2 were solid. Season 3 started off as a slog, but the ending was excellent. A little too sci-fi for me, but still quite good.

Probably an incredibly unpopular opinion: I did NOT like the music and slow motion at the end of episodes. Once per season, maximum. That would've been okay with me. It wasn't terrible, it was fine, it's just not for me.

The atmospheric and theme music throughout the rest of the show is wonderful! Perfectly captures the environment and energy of the scenes.

From the beginning, I expected that it would end with the intro scene, and I'm glad that expectation was diverted.

Normally I ask for decaf, but they got my order wrong today. So here I am at 2am going off. Anyway, I hope it was entertaining to read.

Great show. It executed a concept that seems always should've existed, and it was written the way it needed to have been written. I'm glad I finally watched it.


r/DarK • • Jul 12 '20

[NO SPOILERS] Disappointed about the lack of diversity in this show

0 Upvotes

Hello, I just finished season 1 of this show. I really like the show so far, and me bringing up this topic is not meant as something to hate on the show, but just something that bugged me a little.

I've noticed a lot of shows these days, particularly on Netflix have been making an effort to have a diverse cast of different races and also represent LGBT characters. Given this, don't you think Dark stands out with its cast of exclusively white characters? If I 'm not mistaken there wasn't a single non-white character.

I realize it is Germany, but I've been to Germany and there are definitely Middle Eastern people and other minorities there. Additionally, shows like Black Mirror are set in the UK but make an effort to represent Black characters and other minorities quite well.

So yeah, I don't know why Dark decided to have the cast it did. Just a minor gripe in an otherwise great show!


r/DarK • • Jul 30 '24

[Spoilers S3] The truth about Dark's ending Spoiler

0 Upvotes

In Adam and Eva's worlds, nothing can be changed. Everything is predetermined, and nobody in those worlds (full universes by the way) has any free will or control over his actions. "Causal determinism forbids it", as Tannhaus says. I want to make this very clear, because little to no people understand this about Dark and its ending. For years prior, people have made theories about how Dark's ending makes sense, and have extrapolated so many details to make the puzzle pieces fit together. But that is exactly the problem, and it is the show's (probably only notable) flaw. The ending to Dark makes no sense with the show's rules. It will never make sense, and it never can. Claudia's actions cannot be explained with the show's rules; she cannot suddenly gain free will when her previous selves never did, and she cannot suddenly realize there is a third world (universe) from which Adam and Eva's worlds originated. People have said she could've used context clues and/or logical guesses to figure out the Origin existed, that it was Tannhaus' doing, and that he split his universe in two some sort of experiment, leading to the creation of the Knot. But the problem with that theory is that she would have already figured out those things infinite cycles ago. There's no reason she would suddenly have all that information in the particular cycle in which Season 3 happens, or have the free will to act upon that information within a predetermined universe. People have also said that it was the book, and that all the information was there to finally break the Knot. But again, the problem with that theory is that the book should've already had that information infinite cycles ago, and would've told Adam about it then. There is no way you can break free of infinity, so the writers had to contradict the show's rules in order to end it, and that is exactly what bo Odar and Friese did. Claudia's information and free will in 3x8 "The Paradise" were given to her by the writers, and that's the only way she could've broken everyone free of the loop. I'm sure some people will deny this after reading it, but it is the truth.


r/DarK • • Dec 12 '21

[SPOILERS S1] Weird stuff has been occurring since I saw this show. Spoiler

3 Upvotes

I put "[SPOILER S1]" Because I wasn't sure if talking about time travel is a spoiler or not. I don't see it as one but others might.

So I got home from work 2 nights ago and searched for time travel shows, found this, then proceeded to watch over my 2 days off.

Yesterday I was at the start of season 3 and later in the day took a little cat nap.

As I was falling between awake and asleep I got this vision of all these gears turning inside a clock tower. As if I was looking out from the face of the clock but behind the gears. And they were cloaked in red.

(This is unrelated to my recent experiences) I had a similar vision experience when I was 14 where I saw a bunch of floating clocks and time sped up and it was suddenly morning. But that could be sleep depravation hallucinations, as I had stayed up all night talking to a friend. We were talking about time travel for like 4 hours so that might have combined with sleep hallucinations.

Then just last night, I had a full on time travel dream where I somehow became different to my relatives. Like instead of being someone's cousin, I was their sibling or something like that.

And finally, we get to the strangest one.

I went back to work today, after binging this show on my 2 days off.

At my work we have these company specific radio stations. I don't quite know how they work because I'm not in charge of them. But not even 1 hour into my shift THE FREAKING SONG FROM THE SHOW STARTS PLAYING. I'd never heard that song anywhere before seeing the show.


r/DarK • • Jan 11 '23

[No Spoilers] Is season 3 worth watching?

0 Upvotes

I've watched the first 2 seasons and they were very good, but I kind of didn't like the ending of s2 and read really bad reviews on IMDb about season 3. I'm probably still gonna watch it, but I've lost any motivation to watch the show. Is season 3 on the level of the first 2 seasons?


r/DarK • • Mar 15 '18

r/Dark users are being driven away due to new users repeating the exact same things over and over

6 Upvotes

There has to be solution to this. Users actually not returning here because it is like all the things they have already discussed to death just being repeated every time someone new comes. It's not the newbie fault, nor the older users. It's the reddit format.

Will anyone discuss this for the betterment of this sub? We talk about a lot of complex issues which even develop their own terminology. There must be a way to keep THAT part going while not having all the threads pushed down after one day then someone comes with a new thread to simply 'RESET' everything others were building upon.


r/DarK • • May 06 '23

[SPOILERS S1] Am I a god in human clothing, or was it clear to predict? Spoiler

1 Upvotes

I’ve just finished season 1 for the first time, and wow, what a brilliant show so far. Pretty early in the show (around 2-3 episodes in I think), I put some things together and was confident that Michael was an older Mikkel, and that the stranger was an older Jonas. There were some other smaller things too, but I feel that these were the 2 main reveals.

I seem to have a knack for predicting shows/movies, and I was elated when I was shown to be correct, but was it actually obvious and not really all that impressive that I predicted it?

Tbh, obvious or not, I’m still somewhat proud of myself haha. Can’t wait to see what s2 and s3 have in store.

Please don’t spoil s2 and s3 in the comments :)


r/DarK • • Jul 01 '25

[Spoilers S3] I think this show is kinda bad. Change my mind. Spoiler

3 Upvotes

Well I did finish the series so it's not that bad, but vaaastly overrated.

Look, I know I'm coming to a sub where people love the show, on a website where disliking someone's favored media is a mortal sin. (And fair warning, I'm kind of snarky because it's more fun that way.) But I'm not saying anyone's wrong to like it. And I mean what I said with "change my mind". If my criticisms are inaccurate or unimportant, I'm game to understand what I missed.

That said, I think the writing was pretty bad and will explain why:

1: Technoblather that made me facepalm harder than Ulrich hit Helge

Someone really should travel back in time and tell writers that the technobabble makes everything worse. It doesn't sound good and it's not necessary.

Say that characters travel through a cave and come out in a different year and that's fine. I'm on board. But no, they couldn't leave it. A fission reactor detected a (fist-sized) god particle that creates dark matter which functions as an Einstein-Rosen bridge across a black hole. And also quantum entangles another dimension like Schrödinger's Cat.

Oh, and the time travel is 33 years because that's when the lunar calendar syncs back up with the solar calendar. (But we'll ignore that after it's too restrictive to resolve this mess.)

I guess I admire their restraint for not cramming "blockchain" in there somewhere.

2: Actually the fact that they're all inbred makes a lot of sense.

Kids are missing. There are notable nearby caves that kids often visit. But no one figures they should, y'know, explore them or anything. Any sensible community would either seal it off or have it mapped the first time anyone gets lost. This town is like "eh, let's interview one of the mothers again."

Also people are really slow to recognize faces or figure out context clues. There's a saying among writers that "audiences love slow thinkers," and that's because it allows the audience time to get ahead of them. But it's over the top.

Like 3x01. I'll forgive Jonas having trouble grasping that he's in a world where he wasn't born. George Bailey didn't get it that quickly either. But c'mon. He goes to the classroom where his peers are, because it's the same class with the same teacher that he knew. And then afterwards he has to ask what year it is? If I found myself in my 11th grade History class I'd have a lot of questions. But "What year was I a HS Junior?" wouldn't be among them.

One they get over the long initial period of being dumbfounded, the characters sure lose all their skepticism though.

e.g. Jonas wants to stop his dad dying and accepts that he wouldn't be born. Then Claudia walks in (somehow knowing he was there) and says it isn't better that way. And Jonas says "OK lady I've never met, I'll abandon my plan to save the world now." (Yes, I know he was thrown by what Michael said. Doesn't change anything.)

Which leads me to...

3: OK Boomer

Adam (and Eva, and Claudia) lived long lives with lots happening. And I'm willing to believe they have a perfect memory of it all, including dialogue and timing, even for things they weren't part of. That way they can trigger others (or their earlier selves) to do it again. But still it's just one life each. They're not Dr. Strange. They're not an expert in every possibility. Yet when one of them says "It has to be this way" or "this is the final loop", it's accepted with the weight of someone who knows everything.

Now they could have used the big pointless meeting room to show that they've documented lots of cross-dimensional attempts somehow. Some ledger that's thousands of years old because it keeps getting sent back in time. That's less hard to swallow than a lot of what we got, and much more useful than just having a place to hang Adam and Eve paintings. Maybe they could have squeezed it into the runtime by cutting out the 13yo love triangle and sex scene.

Claudia's journal came closest. She's smart and proactive and she put a focus on studying the situation. But if that needs to contain bombshells like "the baby Charlotte that disappeared and the baby Charlotte that appeared are actually the same baby", there's not a lot of room for details like "Life 217: put birth control pill in Hannah's coffee. Didn't work."

But they didn't even lean in on that. They had the chance in the finale, when Adam asks what everyone should have asked all along: "How do you know?" Then via the next 12 hours of voiceover we get the plodding explanation "I spent 33 years looking ... there were puzzle pieces ... over and over ... same family tree ... both worlds are cancer ... came from someone else ... there's another ... an outsider ... "

That doesn't answer how you know. Again, I'm on reddit. I know what it looks like when someone claims expertise and then avoids questions about it. "I know because I know". Claudia might as well have said "Um, why don't you go Google it?"

And that wouldn't explain stuff like Eva not being shot and saying "It never happens like this". Oh, did the script say that? How the heck do you know Zombie Mads doesn't come shoot you in 2 minutes? For that matter, why did Adam even do the gun fakeout? At least Eva explained that she found her own body and intuited the rest. Who told Adam what he was "supposed" to do at this time?

4: Oh you're not even following your own rules.

There's an explanation about two worlds tied together, using the infinity symbol, that almost made sense. A time loop can be alternating and still be fixed. A classic example would be that I go back in time to stop my parents meeting. Thus I'm not born, so I can't go back, so they do meet, so I'm born, so I can go. Various time travel theories would have to deal with this paradox, but in a multiverse theory you just get an alternating pattern. That's fine.

Except the show already had two worlds, and then used this to say that Jonas can be shot but also be alive. Yeah no, that's a 3rd world right there if you have alternate paths. You can have a third world if you want. But then you can't act like the Triquetra means anything when you want to end with yet another divergent path. (It doesn't mean anything anyway.)

And it's completely unnecessary. The show didn't have to shoot him, only to retcon that he's also still alive. And then it tried to claim the plot armor was also fate armor, as if introducing the idea of "some things can't be changed" helps the story in any way. Not only does "You can't kill me" contradict "you can kill me but Schrödinger's Cat kept me alive", they're both stupid.

(If you really want to resolve it with this multiverse theory, every time the gun misfired could be considered a new "world" and we just followed the story where Jonas survived. But that further undermines the "two paths" nonsense.)

5: Yadda yadda yadda I'm really tired today

All the pivotal stuff basically happens off-screen, with only the tiniest nod shown. In order to have Adam and Jonas at odds, or Eva and Marta, there must be some crucial turn where the younger character decides that they were wrong and the older person who lied to them / shot their lover is actually the person they want to be. That's huge. It's probably the biggest character moment in the entire show. Where's the giant unforgettable scene where that happened? No room for that I guess. But I got long chants of "The end is the beginning ... and the beginning is the end ... we will birth them and they will birth us ... the cycle remains intact".

Or this divide between Claudia and Adam (and I'm not even clear if Eva was a third side). That's huge. It should have been central and clear how both were opposing viewpoints. We were told that they oppose. Light and darkness. Claudia was apparently the "White Devil". Maybe we could have witnessed this ideological struggle instead of "something vague" vs "something else vague". They could still keep secrets. I'm not saying Adam's plan for a cosmic abortion had to be stated in advance. But give us something to define the points of view.

5: The emperor is naked. And rambling incoherently

When you have 30 characters, each with 2-5 versions, it's understandable to get confused. I think they could have done more to clarify it. Like throwing names into dialogue more. Or replacing the kaleidoscope intro with a family tree type of graphic. But I'm not annoyed by that, because like you I signed up for an intricate show that benefits from rewatch.

Instead, I think that this reasonable confusion encourages people to give the show undeserved leeway for all the above nonsense. Like "Oh, well I was confused whether that character was Hannah or Silja or middle-aged Marta, so maybe it's my fault that I spent the whole series not seeing why Adam hates Claudia." And I just want to say that if anyone has ever thought "This plot is smarter than me", well no it isn't.

There are elements that have promise. Time travel is fun. The ultimate idea that all this is a side effect to Tannhaus is pretty interesting*****. Pornhub has a whole section on incest so clearly there's a fanbase. I like the playing at religion with the biblical names. Adam and Eve are a bit obvious, but points for not stopping there. Noah was gathering the select people. Jonas is presumably Jonah, who tried to escape his fate and suffered for it. Hannah prayed for a son and promised him to God. Martha is ... Superman's mother? I don't know if it holds up past there.

My point is not that there's anything wrong with liking it. In some ways it's a puzzle, and I understand the appeal. But it gets spoken of as a "masterpiece" and one of the greatest shows of all time, and it just isn't. This isn't even the best Sci-Fi series I watched in the last month. (Andor. Don't @ me.)

6: I'll shut up soon

I don't even like the title. What does "Dark" have to do with anything? It should have been called "The Travelers". Or "Sic Mundus". Or "How I Met My Aunt." It's all like one person came up with the name. Another had a cave idea. Someone later wanted an apocalypse. And eventually some guy had to tie it up. And if so, kudos to that last person.

But like I said up top, I didn't seek out fans to tell them they're wrong. I watched in German so it's entirely plausible I missed something. I never read that Goethe novel they referenced so maybe that ties it all together. If someone can explain to me why the things that seem vague and contradictory are actually necessary, I'm open to it. I would appreciate the attempt to change my mind.

(But nobody's going to convince me that referencing the "god particle" wasn't stupid.)

* Addendum:

Actually I don't want to damn it with faint praise by calling this part interesting. The core idea (as I understand it is):

Tannhaus is distraught after losing his family. He builds a time machine that will eventually cause an apocalypse. In attempting to prevent it, eventually someone has the idea to give him his book so he builds the machine on their schedule, and a baby so he doesn't need to travel himself. Unfortunately the catastrophe still happens, and now there's a looping bootstrap paradox so you can't look at the existing world and tell how it all started. The story works from the inside out so the idea that nothing in the loop actually matters to the original problem is a difficult conclusion to reach - especially for a person who only exists in that loop.

I think that's really cool. But it needed to be fleshed out, clarified, and cleaned up. Which incidentally is what I said about Tenet. Both had clever time travel ideas. Both needed a lot of polish. And where Nolan had a bad sound mix, this has overbearing narration.


r/DarK • • May 21 '18

Finished season 1

4 Upvotes

I felt so disappointed! No problems were solved! No one was brought to justice! No satisfying answers! No one rescued! We just came full circle! I had little idea what the creciendo was going to be in the final episode. My only hope was some problem was going to be solve or some antagonist had to die. Anyways this is all very subjective but I’m sure some people loved it but I felt let down in a way.


r/DarK • • Sep 29 '24

[SPOILERS S3] DarK challenge (mostly season 3). Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Every time you hear words like "versprochen" or "es tur mir leid" or when Martha cries, you drink.

I promise you, you will be completly wasted in 30min, specially in season 3.

It was so overused (specially in season 3) to the point that I started to laugh or just be annoyed, when I heard/saw those things.

I trully thought that crying Will in last season or Stranger Things was super annoying, because he was crying just simply ALL the time. But Martha in season 3 is at least on the same level. I'm trully surprised that she was not dehydrated from that.

Everyone promised 1000 things ("versprochen"). Everyone is sorry for 1000 things ("tut mir leid").

And Martha cries.

ALL! THE! TIME!

EVERY SCENE.

EVERY MARTHA.

I love this show, but it was really annoying at the end...


r/DarK • • Jan 15 '26

[SPOILERS S1] I have tried FIVE TIMES to get into this show Spoiler

0 Upvotes

I have kept hearing that this show is great. I LOVE supernatural mystery shows (Lost, Stranger Things, From, Manifest S1). 4 times in a row I clicked on it all ready to get hooked and I just couldn't keep my mind on the show.

The 5th time, I decided to watch it while I was on the treadmill, so that no matter how tempted I was to open another browser or look down at my phone I couldn't. When I had tried before, every time I looked away or even spaced out I missed the subtitles. Then when I changed to English audio, the audio dubbing completely took me out of the experience.

It took 25 mins to get hooked - and its not like I was enjoying the show, it just felt like there was so much mystery that I needed to get to the bottom of.

A few impressions so far I have to get off my chest so far (currently watching S1 finale):

  • They really overuse the musical motif. It's a great musical motif though otherwise.

  • The average scene length is probably like 27 seconds. Like seriously I love it overall, but it gets a little obnoxious to keep seeing scenes of someone doing something mundane in a mysterious fashion for 24 seconds, and then seeing something get revealed that communicates 20% new info but 80% new questions like every fucking scene. I think it would be better with a little more coherence between scenes

  • The scene where we saw the mikkel/michael are the same person gave me absolute fucking chills. So well done with the "don't open until" setup.

  • I almost stopped watching when Jonas finally found Mikkel and was stopped from talking with him. I get the necessity for the story there, but there really needed to be some sort of payoff for the audience there with Mikkel having suffered all alone for so long to see a familiar face. That was frankly lazy writing for an otherwise well crafted story.

  • I have really like the slow reveal of the theme about affairs being connected to the disappearances (still not 1:1 correlation at the moment), and have really liked the reveal of Urich giving that other guy his scars (cant remember his name, Egon or something idk). That combined with Mikkels monologue about "not how but when" I think is really setting this up to be a powerful commentary on how lots of seemingly justified actions are the result of perpetuated vengeful actions..

Edit: If it wasn't clear, I love this show so far.

Edit 2: Also weird observation, all these TV supernatural mystery shows invoke some wild property of electromagnetic radiation: Lost had the EM radiation in the cave, Manifest had the lightning gamma radiation, ST has the exotic matter and wormhole and lights flickering. idk just wild lol


r/DarK • • Apr 13 '24

[Spoilers S3] Finished the show. But that ending was very dissapointing. Spoiler

18 Upvotes

So I finally finished Dark. I really liked it, but the ending was dissapointing. People had hyped this last episode up, that it would explain everything etc, and I expected my mind to be blown, but I just really wasn't.

Like I think season 1 is fantastic, but then it kinda went downhill. Season 2 I think is solid but I really feel they jumped the shark with season 3. You reach a point where being confusing isnt charming or enhancing the mystery or story anymore, and I think they went beyond that point.

Which gets us to the ending. Like up until this point, Dark I think had been one of the most well thought out, well written, complex shows I had ever watched. Like as I said, it got a bit to much even sometimes. So I expected the ending to be of the same quality, and to be even more crazy and mind bending and complex. But then it's the most cliche, standard ending you could have imagined.

Like if you have a time loop story, what's the first ending you would come up with if someone asked you? "Ehh maybe they travel back in time to prevent the guy who made the first time machine from making the time machine by stopping someone he loved from dying, and then they stop existing". And that's what they did. Not like it's a bad ending, like it's a nice touching story, and the romantic in me love that whole side of it. But it's like the most simple, non confusing, non complex, cliche expected ending you could imagine. And I'm just shocked and dissapointed that's what we got.

Like I get endings are hard, and I couldn't have come up with something better myself, but because of the complex and subversive writing up intil this point, my expectations were just really high.

So I expected this series finale to like take this show to the absolute next level, and instead it honestly took it down a level from me.

I don't know, maybe I missed something in this last season/episode that makes it better. But what did you guys think of the ending?


r/DarK • • Dec 07 '23

[SPOILERS S2] Season 2 seems very different

0 Upvotes

Just started season 2 and have only watched E1. This jump to a future imagined timeline makes the show feel very different and dystopian, and I’m not sure I like it. Getting Handmaid’s Tail and Mad Max vibes.

Did anyone else feel this? And did you get over it?


r/DarK • • May 11 '22

[SPOILERS S1] I think i found a mistake in the show. Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Ulrich goes to 1953 and he left his jacket with his phone in H G Tannhous's shop. But in the Season 1 finale, when future Jonas goes to check if H G Tannhaus has had any progress with the machine, he brings out the "device" which is the phone and it somehow is still alive and shows Ulrich's wallpaper. But there is no way that phone could be alive after 33 years right? Or I am being dumb and I missed something?


r/DarK • • Nov 14 '23

[NO SPOILERS] For a "Lexi watching Dark for the second time"

3 Upvotes

Sign the petition to get a rewatch with Lexi...

https://chng.it/qsVYTp4M62


r/DarK • • Feb 16 '23

[Spoilers S3] Should I even keep watching the show? Spoiler

0 Upvotes

I am actually only on the second episode but have been loving it so far. I like to go on the post-episode discussion post on Reddit to see others thoughts, but accidentally clicked on the rewatch discussion post and found out the mysterious stranger is an older Jonah. I am so mad that I don’t even feel like watching the show anymore. I understand that it’s brilliantly shot and scored amazingly but I was falling in love with it for the mystery and now feel like that is gone. Should I keep watching?


r/DarK • • Oct 25 '25

[SPOILERS S3] shes the prettiest one in this show Spoiler

Post image
6 Upvotes

r/DarK • • May 01 '24

[SPOILERS S3] The Bootstrapped nature of Dark annoys me

1 Upvotes

There are some things that I would like an actual real answer for such as:

Why Mads, Eric and Yasin were chosen (I like some of the theories on this)

Why the bunker had creepy colored wallpaper and 80s music

There are way more but I can't think of them at the moment. It seems people just to random things because their older selves did. I understand WHY they do, buv it still annoys me. I WANT ANSWERS.