r/DMAcademy • • 1h ago

Need Advice: Other Opinion on homebrew item for two specific characters

2 Upvotes

I'm running a 2014 5e campaign. Party is level 8, soon to be level 9; the campaign will run through level 12. We have a dao warlock (melee), land druid (mountain), twilight cleric, fighter/barbarian, gloomstalker ranger, and watchers paladin. The paladin and the ranger are the two specific characters this item is intended for. The paladin is intentionally built as a damage sponge - 21 AC, max CON, only 12 STR/CHA. He likes to throw out Warding Bond, but generally only uses his spell slots for smites. The ranger has max DEX, 14 WIS. She almost never uses any spell slots, the one exception being the very occasional Hunter's Mark.

The paladin and ranger are essentially oathsworn platonic companions - they traveled together before meeting the party, and they roleplay their relationship consistently. Given the chance between saving her friend or saving the world, I'm 100% confident the ranger would let the world burn.

I want to give the ranger a reason to use her spell slots, and building on her connection to the paladin seemed like a good way to do it. This is the item I came up with for the two of them:

Rings of the Unbroken Bond

Ring, Rare (requires attunement by two characters)

This pair of platinum rings is engraved, one with a bow and arrow and the other with a mountain. When two characters are each attuned to one of these rings, they are aware of each other's general direction and overall state of physical well-being while within 1 mile of each other.

In addition, while within 30 feet of each other and can see each other, they also receive these benefits:

Bolstered Will. Each attuned character receives a +1 bonus to their armor class and saving throws.

Bond of Support. When one attuned character takes damage, the other can use their reaction to intercept part of the damage by expending a spell slot of 1st level or higher. Roll 1d8 plus the reacting character's spellcasting ability modifier, plus 1d8 for each slot level above 1st. The triggering damage is reduced by that total (minimum of 0), and the reacting character takes the prevented amount of damage. The damage reallocation occurs before the ally takes damage. This transferred damage is the same damage type as the damage prevented and cannot be reduced by resistance or immunity.

I'm already used to dealing with Twilight Sanctuary most combats, and I'm not terribly concerned about the interaction between these rings and that feature. I feel like it's reasonably positioned as a Rare item, given that it's a slightly nerfed Cloak of Protection with an additional feature, plus a ribbon, but I could accept it as a Very Rare item; either way, the loot budget has room for it.

Does this item seem reasonable for the party level? Overpowered? Underpowered? Just dumb? I think I've found a balance between utility and resource cost. The party has recognized and distributed character-themed items before and everyone really enjoys them, so they're unlikely to end up with the warlock and druid or whatever. I'd appreciate any opinions or suggestions anyone wants to offer.


r/DMAcademy • • 3h ago

Need Advice: Worldbuilding Nothing seems bad enough

2 Upvotes

Hi chat,

I'm requesting assistance with building the framework of a modern urban fantasy (think like deadlock's universe esk) mystery campaign based around a commissioner gathering the party as a part of an elite task force and sending them to some town or somewhere far away to solve this major case.

Big plot twist is that they are sent there to build evidence against themselves, slowly over time they will contaminate and add themselves to motives and crime scenes etc. until the commissioner (the actual criminal who did all this) accuses the party of committing the crime and uses the evidence they created against them.

I was maybe thinking some kind of "murder" except the victim was actually like turned into a shadow or something idrk.

My main request is asking what crime fits this narrative? also if you have general comments and criticisms that would also by very appreciated.

Pls help

-a girl trying her best T^T


r/DMAcademy • • 3h ago

Resource Printed Laminated Maps Giveaway! - For Dead in Thay Adventure

1 Upvotes

I printed every single room of the Dead in Thay dungeon and laminated it. Each square is 1-inch and can be put together like a puzzle at the table.

Made this a while back while running the adventure Dead in Thay, and now I’m trying to get rid of it. Came here to ask if anyone would be interested in taking this entirely printed and laminated megadungeon.

Just DM me if you would like to get in touch and receive all of this. Thanks :) I rather give it to someone than throw it away. It took too many hours of labor to just throw away. 🥲

Dead In Thay Megadungeon

-
Folders containing each zone of the dungeon

-
What the prints look like

-
dnd figures on top of map grid


r/DMAcademy • • 6h ago

Need Advice: Worldbuilding Do you think Pestilence should be conquering Feywild or Upper Planes?

1 Upvotes

Alright, I believe all of you familiar with the therm of four horsemen of apocalypse. Pestilence, War, Famine, and Death.

I'm planning to make each horseman conquer each Planes of Exitance to harness their power.

Death will be conquering Shadowfell and War will be conquering Lower Planes (Since you know, Demon have general and something like that)

Now here's the problem, I don't know if I should putting Pestilence in Feywild or Upper Planes? I mean, Feywild is nature theme and Upper Planes is Celestia theme with Mount Celestia, Elysium, and something like that.

What do you guys and girls think?


r/DMAcademy • • 6h ago

Need Advice: Encounters & Adventures How can I reward this players build in a boss fight without devaluing the rest of the party?

6 Upvotes

I’ve got a really big boss fight coming up, and I’m a pretty experienced dm. The next session will hopefully be one big lethal end of arc battle that we’ve been building to for a while, so I want it to last at least, like, 5 or more rounds for it to be suitably epic. One sorcerer has built basically his entire kit around save or suck charm/frighten effects and mental manipulation shenanigans. It’s been a really cool build, suggestion has come in clutch a couple encounters for life saving moments, and balancing hasn’t been too hard since they’re normally fighting multiple enemies, meaning that if he gets a few, combat can continue. But, this fight will inevitably be all of them vs 1 guy.

Hence the dilemma - he has no real damage spells, and one weak heal spell. The rest are save or sucks. If he gets a successful suggestion off on the boss, which could happen turn 1, that could end the encounter, as the boss might be forced to just sit peacefully for hours. If this happens on later turns - none of the damage the rest of the party did would matter at all, it all just came down to a Wis save. If I make the boss immune to charm, I’m kind of screwing him over specifically and giving him very little to do. I could give legendary saves, but I’ve always hated legendary saves for feeling cheap, and sort of giving a boss two unrelated health bars, and whichever one runs out first again invalidates the progress done to the other one.

So- I’m trying to find a way to make charm effects contribute to progressing towards victory for the party if the boss fails a save, without ending the encounter immediately so that the rest of the players can have fun in a big combat session.

Im open to literally anything, homebrew is fine. To provide flavor, simply put, the boss is a crazy old wizard in his tower. He has no shortage of ancient magical mumbo jumbo that he’ll be throwing at the players, but is rather squishy and is more trying to avoid getting hit with magical defenses than soaking hits. My goal is for the fight to feel like fighting someone cheating with random bullshit hax abilities. So literally any idea y’all have mechanically or lore wise I can probably justify very easily.

If anyone takes the time to read through this and help me out, thanks a bunch! I think I’m just stuck in my own head about it and need another perspective.

Edit: thanks for all the ideas everybody! These are wonderful


r/DMAcademy • • 6h ago

Need Advice: Encounters & Adventures Killed an enlarged Duergar, now what.

0 Upvotes

My group fought and killed a Duergar while in its enlarged state, and I can't find a ruling to say if it's body would resize upon death. It's not a concentration based spell, according to many so I assume it stays in Large size, right?


r/DMAcademy • • 8h ago

Need Advice: Other Need help with finding a specific book/resource

3 Upvotes

Hello everyone,

very random question.

I've been looking up some stuff about dying Gods and Deities and I believe, that I've come across a book on some of the consequences of that happening...

Unfortunately I can't seem to (for the love of God) find it now.

Is it a real thing or am I going crazy?

Thank you for your help and wish y'all a good day! :))


r/DMAcademy • • 10h ago

Need Advice: Encounters & Adventures Descent into Avernus - Cemetery

1 Upvotes

Quando i personaggi si recano al cimitero di Hellturel per recuperare l'Elmo della Visione di Torm, si imbattono nella Cripta dell'Ascensione, dove dei demoni, aiutati da Bafometto, stanno aprendo un portale. I miei giocatori sono arrivati ​​sul posto esausti e quasi senza slot incantesimo, avendo dato la priorità alla velocità per impedire ai demoni di organizzarsi e lanciare un assalto all'Alta Sala. Ho modificato l'incontro basandomi sulla versione "Alexandrian Remix": l'elmo si trovava al suo posto (area G11), mentre il Granduca rimaneva all'Alta Sala, incaricando i personaggi di recuperarlo. Mentre discutevano sulla loro prossima mossa, un personaggio si è avventurato nell'ossario e ha scoperto una presenza demoniaca oltre la porta.

Mi sono trovato di fronte a diversi possibili esiti:

  1. ⁠Non succede nulla, il che non sembrava plausibile, dato che un quasit faceva la guardia all'ossario.

  2. ⁠I demoni uccidono il personaggio (coerentemente con la loro natura), ma poi il resto del gruppo probabilmente sarebbe andato a cercarlo, solo per essere massacrato dai demoni mentre era completamente a corto di risorse.

  3. ⁠Ho pensato che, dato che questo funge da "secondo fronte" segreto aperto dai demoni per accerchiare i diavoli e lanciare un contrattacco, il quasit potrebbe "alterare" la memoria del personaggio.

Questo porterebbe il personaggio a riferire che non c'era niente nell'ossario, spingendo il gruppo ad andarsene e dando inavvertitamente al portale più tempo per vomitare altri demoni.

P.S. Gideon è morto, ucciso da un personaggio che, secondo il suo passato, era suo amico, ma che ha concluso che Gideon era già corrotto e irrecuperabile.

Cosa ne pensi? Ora sto riconsiderando la coerenza interna di questa cosa e se forse sono stato troppo indulgente o "gentile" con il gruppo.

Il gruppo aveva appena finito un buon combattimento, collaborando e aiutandosi a vicenda – usando ogni risorsa disponibile – per recuperare l'elmo. Mi è sembrato inutilmente meschino aggiungere ulteriori complicazioni alla situazione.


r/DMAcademy • • 11h ago

Need Advice: Worldbuilding I'm looking for ideas of monsters I can add to my campaign that have come from the Feywild.

0 Upvotes

I feel like this could go under the Encounters & Adventures flair or the Worldbuilding flair, so I went with the latter.

I'm building a campaign where the Feywild is slowly spilling out into the mortal world. This world is filled with creatures you can find (or could have found) in our world like boars, snakes, giant spiders, dinosaurs, and some D&D creatures like dragons and owlbears. What I would love is getting some help with coming up with monsters that could potentially be seen as having come from the Feywild. Some monsters I'm thinking of are blights, displacer beasts, pegasus, dryads, pixies, etc.

I know blights, displacer beasts, and pegasus aren't Fey monsters, but they're not really monsters that would exist in my world either which is why for the purposes of my campaign, I want to use them as monsters that are spilling out into the mortal world from the Feywild.

My question is, what other monsters could you see coming from the Feywild? I have access to the Monster Manual (2014 & 2024), MotM, Volo's Guide to Monsters, and Heliana's Guide to Monster Hunting parts 1 & 2.

Thank you for your suggestions and your help!


r/DMAcademy • • 11h ago

Need Advice: Other I have a really weird queston, what's your line with AI?

0 Upvotes

I'm a new DM and I've been working on my first campaign,

The problem i encounter is consistency and organization, I tend to lose notes and struggle to catch every detail that i write into a story which causes plot holes, and if you can tell by my writing here, I have a very disorganized mind, I tend to think about all ends at once, and struggle with translating my thoughts to text

I've been adapting a video game story to ttrpg setting (this is known and welcome in the group, and this is a chance for me to try my hand at a dm experience), not 1 for 1 at all, but rather I've been going down the quest lines, then rewriting them to work in dnd, then trying to come up with ways that players would naturally want to subvert these things, towns and locations are remade and world scale is increased.

I found in this process I was forgetting some names, or some plot points as i was writing, then losing myself finding them in notes, I was also losing the same stat blocks over and over, or struggling to code npcs into dndbeyond's homebrew monster builder for encounters

So, I input my actual work, Something basic I would point at would be swapping the races and weapons of some bandits after going through the appendex and races, then having the ai translate my changes into a coherrent stat block with a graphic. I did also dabble in asking it to check CR since i'm new and dont have an eye for that, but i dont think it's good enough for that yet, so I guess i'll have to earn my lumps

the only other portion i use is when i have a town I'm introducing, I'll have it label all the buildings in town that i designate as locations that i intend, and then have it designate what that building is for, who lives or works there, and such, or i'll input any npcs i have come up with into it so that i can quickly ask that thread which npc it was that i had assigned as a shopkeeper, or the name of a town guard the party might like, or more importantly, which one of these 30-40 npcs that i've written is the one with the important item, or backstory related ties.

most of the key NPCs i've written, I put into the reference on that thread, then asked it to look for descrepencies that i may have missed, It has helped me identify some majorly stupid plot holes... I assume it missed multiple others, but i missed more

I'm under the current impression that the raw tools is ok, but i wanted to check that.

Something i worry about is, I've been inputting my plans into the story, having the ai actually digest what my concept is point by point for the general campaign, then asking it to walk me through it and point out areas to flesh things out. I actually roleplayed the entire campaign having the AI DM my entire story, then adjusted details in the lore as i moved on, Didnt hit all the combat yet, I'm still looking through the monster manual and assessing the party powers.

another example is I told the ai that I intended ona skill challenge for an important spot in the campaign, and that i wanted it to be an extensive series of challenges relating to xyz, the then attempted to give me challenges, I commanded it to instead ask me questions on what i should be paying attention to in these challenges, so instead of its absurd idea, or my fundamentally fleshed out idea, I was reminded to ask myself what things i wanted to see or reward the party for leading me to put more teamwork bonuses into the challenge, and to remember to check the sheets of players to make sure they have the tools to complete these challenges.

biggest line ride in my mind is that i did ask for it to put into DND legal text a way to write a mechanic i came up with for a fight down the line, Because i had no idea how to put about 3 paragraphs of concept into two abilities that worked together, and it got it down to a single line of text (it was basically a cleave ability contingent on movement)

What i'm not doing: Having the AI write quests for me, lore (though i did outsource that to this video game universe honestly), invent npcs/regions/maps/items/dungeons. It's also not writing encounters,

Am i way over the line? am i riding it? or am i in the right mindset, I want to know early on so i can shift my approach as i move forward. I dont think the group particularly cares either way, pretty sure if i had the fucking thing write the entire story for me they'd love it honestly because we're mostly about hanging out.. but my goal is to be a better dungeon master, and to find ways to work with my organizational and formatting issues, or to help me recognize what people may do instead of what i generally hope them to do, since if caught so off guard I run the risk of cornering myself and fucking it up for them at this stage of my experience. Obviously mistakes happen but theres multiple ways to learn, and painless for the party is my aim.


r/DMAcademy • • 13h ago

Need Advice: Other Mayonnaise (not a joke)

6 Upvotes

So recently I've been looking at what the alchemy jug can actually do besides the popular (to our group at least) oil, water, acid, and basic poison, and I saw it can make a good amount of mayonnaise, and put up a vote to see what they wanted to make, and unfortunately there's a decently high chance it might win, so I've been looking around for a while to find a price or use for it, but I've found nothing besides the usual "it can be used in sandwiches" thing and the "Is Mayonnaise and instrument?" joke, so that only is really there for RP aspects, (not a bad use, just kinda a waste because it will go bad before we can use it all) so I'm hoping that someone could give me a suggested price for it that could potentially match the base d&d values of other items (we keep a flask or two flavored as a mason jar, and sell the rest, because every day we can just make more if we need to)

(Not only helps as a player, but as a dm, since basically every person in the group is a dm for their own campaign, including myself)

edit: was hoping to sell the excess but these ideas are honestly pretty great


r/DMAcademy • • 13h ago

Need Advice: Other Therapeutic Program W/ DnD

15 Upvotes

Hi DM’s, I’m in my final year of college studying to be a Child and Youth Care Worker (CYCW). Currently, I am working my first placement at an agency and I have been implementing a Dungeon and Dragons one shot. My supervisor has provided me with a lot of resources because they believe that this program can have a lot of therapeutic value.

There are 6 youths, with a new addition arriving next week, and a staff member helping me out as a player and Co-DM. In total, soon to be 8 players — excluding myself. The age range is a variety, from 9 years old to the oldest being 16, and the most recent addition being 17. All this being said, the program started as a one shot session but has turned into a one month long slog where we have only gotten half way through the dungeon this week.

I have only two hours and fifteen minutes to run the program session, however, I have convinced my supervisor for another day in the week, recently, due to my struggles with the time limit.

At the moment, each room/encounter of my homebrew dungeon has turned into a complete slog. I’ve incorporated turn timers, (one minute for each youths turn), averaging enemy health and attack damage, introduced them to utilizing bringing and writing in their notebooks each session to organize their turns (with an extrinsic reward of an inspiration dice each session). Still, turns are taking too long.

Additional problems are some of the youths feeling uncomfortable talking to anyone else outside of their close immediate friends, and three, out of the seven, not role playing.

I have seen vast developments in social and organization skills amongst most of the youths but I would still appreciate any tips from more seasoned DM’s that have helped them greatly with a large table?

My experience as a DM is that I ran a 1 and a half year Lost Mines of Phandelver campaign with 8 of my friends after COVID. I can provide the veterans with any further information — while maintaining confidentiality of my relational practice.


r/DMAcademy • • 14h ago

Need Advice: Other Those who have run the Icecrown Citadel module, what are your thoughts?

2 Upvotes

I haven’t run it yet but I’ve read through it and have my thoughts. There are some things I want to alter, but I wanted to get your perspectives if you have run it and what changes you made if any.


r/DMAcademy • • 14h ago

Need Advice: Other Sentient Weapon Alignment & Personality

4 Upvotes

I’m making a magic revolver called Silverwing. The weapon has been passed between revolutionaries/outlaws that fight against authoritarianism/tyranny. I’m mixed on what alignment and personality I want to give it.

Initially I imagined a calm and peaceful monk type woman that sees violence as a necessity.

Then I also considered a rebellious punky cowboy type woman who sees violence as an easy solution.

Any recommendations?


r/DMAcademy • • 16h ago

Need Advice: Encounters & Adventures Looking for advice in creating a puzzle that involves harvesting an internal organ from a giant spider

4 Upvotes

So by way of context we are playing a Science-Fantasy themed camping. The basic premise is that technology from an extremely ancient, long-dead race has been found in a typical fantasy setting. The campaign is set about 200 years after this tech started appearing and a big part of the world-building is how the different races have reacted. Think a bit like Planescape or Tides of Numunera.

We're using 2014 rules and an unofficial 3rd party supplement.

The party have found themselves in a situation where they are exploring a laboratory where a group of one of the dead races were working on trying to find a cure for a disease that wiped them out. They were trying to genetically engineer the spider creatures so they could use their organs for a cure. They were nearly there but the spiders escaped, killing them all. The lab hadn't been opened for thousands of years but the technology still works, albeit the lab was full of the spiders.

The party found out that an NPC they had been working with is one of the thought dead people (but the NPC didn't realise they weren't human and they don't yet know how she's there).

They're on the cusp of killing the spider boss which has the generically altered organ inside it, which they can use to finish the cure and stop the NPC from dying (she's afflicted with the same disease).

With all the background out of the way, I'm trying to create a puzzle involving the actual act of harvesting the organ (I.e. making sure they don't damage it, harvest the correct one, that sort of thing) or the creation of the cure (making sure the correct amount is used, ratio with other ingredients etc.). I'd like there to be a legitimate risk of failure which would have knock on consequences but I don't want it to be just down to rolling a medicine/survival roll.

The NPC is currently elsewhere working on a translation so I thought she could leave some clues before falling unconscious (the basis for this has been established already). I'm just a bit stuck on what clues she could leave and how to make it interesting for the players.

I have previously described his how corpses of smaller spiders were left on autopsy tables with organs removed, thinking that would be a hint as to how to go about the removal but the players didn't really investigate that too much. They have also picked up a tool that was used to during the autopsies to cut through flesh etc. but it's lost power so just looks like a dagger handle with a piece of metal sticking out of it. They haven't spent any time trying to work out what it is or how to power it up so they have no idea of it's use.

This is my first time homebrewing a dungeon so I've perhaps set myself up to fall but it's too late to back out now haha.

Really grateful for any suggestions or advice


r/DMAcademy • • 17h ago

Need Advice: Encounters & Adventures How much damage would sticking your whole arm only inside a gelatinous cube do?

0 Upvotes

My players are locked in a prison that used to be a dungeon a long time ago and their innmates believe it's haunted by the ghost of a young guard.

What actually happened is that the young guard in question, while sneaking off in the night to talk with a prisoner they became friends with, was absorbed and killed by the gelatinous cube that roams the halls (that's why there's no one guarding the cells by nightime and why the halls are always spotless despite no one cleaning).

Now from the prisoners' perspective the slowly decaying body of the young guard floats around in the night and burns (in this case chemical burns) everyone that tries to reach for it.

Thing is the young guard was carrying the cell's keys with him when he died and the players need to reach for them when the cube passes in front of them.

Now, I know throwing a gelatinous cube at a level one party is rather deadly but i figured if they were to submerge only one arm at a time, while beying beyond bars, they would take less damage (at least they wouldn't risk their life for it) and have no real risk of being sucked inside the cube.

How much damage would it do and what DC would taking the keys be?


r/DMAcademy • • 17h ago

Need Advice: Other How do you handle sub-dividing a space on the fly?

1 Upvotes

I'm running a point crawl and the PCs have reached a crossroads town with a few small businesses. The NPCs in town that aren't crooks or outlaws are used to living with them so everybody's got an angle.

The players are carrying items and treasure that will definitely get noticed and depending on what they do, they’ll likely face a robbery attempt. Now, its a small town and if that happens and they decide to go looking for their stuff, there's only a few places/NPCs they can check/suspect.

I got to thinking ahead of our next session about the different possibilities and i realized none of the buildings or businesses I've designated are anything more than a general description and an NPC. Naturally, PCs may want to investigate the buildings to find their stuff and I'll have to create rooms, maybe traps, etc.

That got me to thinking about other situations where a space i had created might suddenly need more detail on the fly to expand it for PCs.

How do you handle that?

tldr: what to do if players decide they want to investigate a space that should naturally have multiple areas but those areas dont exist yet?


r/DMAcademy • • 17h ago

Need Advice: Rules & Mechanics Shops and gear

2 Upvotes

I need advice on setting prices for magical items, non-magical items and adventuring gear. I have a big problem setting a set price thinking it’s either too low or too high. How do other DM‘s figure out how much gold gear of varying rarities sell for?


r/DMAcademy • • 20h ago

Need Advice: Rules & Mechanics [2024] Blind condition, are the mechanics too bare bones?

0 Upvotes

How do I make a better blind condition without creating an environment that's too unfair or outright unplayable?

What I have though of doing so far:

Upon being blinded, a creature can move as normal, but to "find" other creatures it needs to perform a perception [Search Action] on its turn.

Here's what bothers me. Even if a blinded creature performs a good search action, how does it distinguish friend from foe if they are mixed together? Should I ask the player to simply "pick" a square? I mean in practical terms its impossible to enforce on the table/vtt if its for a single person, otherwise I'd have to block the vision of every single player.

At the same time, I want the condition to invoke some kind of reaction, its one of the more forgiving conditions in the game, same as grappled, but I don't think it should be, since you are losing a sense you've relied upon your whole life.

Does anyone know any alternative established rules that I can get some ideas from?


r/DMAcademy • • 1d ago

Need Advice: Rules & Mechanics Need some rules help

6 Upvotes

So my warlock player just got to level 10 and wanted to take teleportation circle. Rules as written though it says as soon as he takes it he knows two location to use it with. But so far in my game they havent even seen a teleportation circle once yet. So how would I be able to follow the rules but also follow my story so far? Plus currently they are in the fey wild atm so whatever place they would know they couldn't get to atm. Any thoughts?

edit So I dont have to write this a lot. First thanks for all the replies. I think I will have the patron give him the location of two teleport circles. One of them will be near the location of a memory core (the players pact with the patron is that they would hunt these down to get the patrons memory back). If he gets them he gains boons but if he does he also gets more paranoid (the patrons paranoia leaks to him, this was the players ideas)


r/DMAcademy • • 1d ago

Need Advice: Encounters & Adventures How much do you guys free ball it?

5 Upvotes

I usually download modules off of DM guild or buy a book and really just use those as guidelines and just make stuff up. I have a whole bunch of random notes on shit I got to remember now though but how often do you guys let the table just kind of evolve and go off script? I had a comment from a player who ran a module in the past that I was running say that I did it wrong.

To be fair it was just supposed to be a haunted mansion turned smuggler ring that I then may have added a little flare of lost gods and other planes leaking in.

What do you guys think?


r/DMAcademy • • 1d ago

Need Advice: Encounters & Adventures Higher level area

6 Upvotes

Hi,

So I do a homebrew campaign and I have mistakenly made my players lean towards the main plot sooner than I wanted (my fault, it's my first time DMing). I planned this area with monsters of a higher difficulty.

Now, my question is, do I let them go that way but warn them that it could be lethal to all of them (they are near level 2)? If so, do I tell them with the help of my in-game characters (I think for now that it's my best option)? Or do I tell them in person, outside of the game, my mistake and offer them something else? Or do I make the monsters weaker (goblins, orcs, less orc berserkers and even less orc shamans)?

I planned side quests at every area they had been and every area they will go before this main area. I could make them focus on these, but it would go a little against the plot (here is my mistake). The character that made them go created a little sense of urgency.

Anyway, I don't feel stuck, I have a stealth alternative if they still want to go there. I'm only asking for advice or a second look about this.


r/DMAcademy • • 1d ago

Need Advice: Encounters & Adventures The Twin protectors !

3 Upvotes

Hello fellow DMs !

I am in need of any kind of inspiration for a short adventure (3 sessions max) involving a specific setting !

It's for a classic High-Fantasy D&D 5e campaign that has lasted for a while, we're in the final arc :

The BBEG succeeded in rising to Godhood and is the only living one walking the earth of the setting, and my players got wrecked, they have to navigate a world where things are looking bad if they do nothing to end the bastard !

Typical situation where they are gathering allies, building a resistance yada yada yada...

There's a quaint little place in my Homebrew world where a small village has been spared from many catastrophes for a few centuries.

We're talking : War broke out, the village remained unscathed. Plagues never got there, bands of brigands vanished when they attempt to loot the place !

There's no documentation of why, just that... it does !

The village has no militia, no crime, people are happy, the crops are bountyful. You can leave, you can get in without problem. As long as you don't cause trouble or harm anyone, things are fine. Most of the villagers don't know why, just that it's always been like this since the time of their grandparents.

A few people learnt why and they refused to try testing the watchful guardians there by revealing the secret :

Before the village started being prosperous, a humble woman there treated a simple wanderer with kindness and over a few years they fell in Love over each other's beutiful soul. The result of which were twins.

As you can guess, the wanderer was a god, the twins became gods too, but upon rising, they refused to be of those high and mighty tyrants or follower gathering morons. They had a simple life, of Love, Compassion and Humility. When their physical shells died, they ascended and are now watching from the stars, protecting nothing more than their childhood home, refusing to intervene anywhere else.

The only "awful" thing is that they keep their mother alive. We're talking "Mama Coco" style old lady that is just here but completely demented and just... alive. They're not ready to let her go in the great beyond for mortals.

My players are heading there to seek help from either the villagers or learn the secret that protects them to us it against the BBEG...

My question is : What can I do when they get there? What would you do, where you would you go narratively?
I have been running this game for a couple years, having great fun. I threw more complexe scenarios than I can think of, some clichés here and there, and I don't know what to do with it that I haven't done already.

There's no stupid idea (beside mine...) !

I need suggestions, even about things I have already done... I'll see if fresh eyes can help on that one !

Cheers,
-SK


r/DMAcademy • • 1d ago

Need Advice: Other Player is frustrated with how sessions play out

69 Upvotes

At the end of last session, a player said: *"Every encounter is the same: we spend 30 minutes talking to someone just to attack them."*

I feel I was offering real choices.

Context:

We are playing a rebellion/sabotage arc with several factions within Curse of Strahd. The one that matters here is a group of devils that has taken over Vallaki.

The session:

- The party reports to a faction leader (Urwin), plans their next move and heads out.

- An explosion and a new beam of light draw them across town. On the way, a Rakshasa tells them "they" are open to talking, despite the party's past actions against them.

- They find cultists of Levistus killing commoners in the street, guarded by Legates and a Night Hag. The bodies are for a ritual inside. The party feels outnumbered (it's balanced), so they talk instead of fighting while people keep dying. Eventually they go inside and leave the remaining innocents behind.

- Inside, a Cambion stands in front of an opening rift and offers a deal. The devils have their own goals and plan to leave Barovia. If the party leaves them alone, the devils will let them leave too once they're done, and will protect them from Strahd while they're in town.

- While they talk, the devils quietly surround them.

- The wizard, who is bound to a dark god, hears that he could convert the rift to his patron. That would cripple the devils and summon monstrous allies.

The options:

  1. Fight for the Wereravens: hard, but good.

  2. Fight with the dark god's help: big advantages, morally murky.

  3. Let the ritual happen: easy, comes with perks, evil.

The session ended with them going back and forth for a long time, leaning toward fighting. I guess begrudgingly for some.

I feel like the options were there. Honestly, I was surprised a Paladin was fine walking past devils sacrificing innocents because he was nervous about the CR of the encounter (they're fresh from long rest and DNDBeyond says it's Medium difficulty...??) But I run the table and want to meet my players partway. How can I structure encounters so they don't feel like "talk, talk, fight"?

I know that 2/3 of the options are to fight, but the players have been pretty anti-devil (because duh). This was my way of placating their tendency while also noting to them, "Hey, you *can* side with them if you so choose".