r/DMAcademy • • Apr 02 '20

The most overused word in D&D, and how to overcome the damage it causes to a party:

15.1k Upvotes

After a few sessions of DMing, I'm sure everyone eventually runs into the experience of seeing a player feel discouraged about how their character is doing. After I went through an entire night never rolling higher than a 6, I realized what was bothering me. It wasn't that my rolls were bad (though I did sentence those dice to life in shadowbox memorabilia priosn).

I didn't have fun because my character wasn't a badass for an entire session.

I made this wonderful character, I spent weeks on the backstory with tweaks, research, maps, drafts, everything. My wife joked that I knew more about that character than I knew about myself. He became an important part of the group, and a pivotal character in the world's development. He was quirky, arrogant, reckless, and had an eye for rooting out corruption. But for one solid night, he was Clumsy McDropkins of the Butterfinger clan.

When I played back the session later that week on my commute, I learned something that changed the way I DM forever.

I realized (again) that as a player, I didn't want to be part of the game anymore not because I had a night of bad rolls, but because my character's story and integrity changed forever. That night the DM had tried to be more creative with his storytelling. Before that session, a missed roll would trigger the narration of "No, a 12 doesn't hit, anything else with your turn?" That night, it changed to "You swing your shortsword and.... miss." Over and over and over and over again. My character is not a clumsy, reckless, whirling tornado of aimless slashes; I didn't like what it turned into.

The next session I DM'd I tried a creative solution, this time with the tables turned.

My DM was a player, and I told him I was going to attempt the same creative narrative approach he had tried. I had a post-it note on the back of my DM screen and all it said was "THE PLAYERS NEVER MISS". We got into our first combat, and I couldn't have asked for a better chance to practice. Two of our party never scored a hit, and I didn't roll very well myself. So I went to work narrating three level 2 characters fighting a small group of cultists.

I brought the battle to life despite low rolls, and created an epic battle on accident.

Miss = "You swing your greataxe, but the cultist quickly steps to the side. He whips his scimitar through the air, and pushes your greataxe away. Your greataxe smashes through the floorboards." Miss = "You fire an arrow from across the room. The arrow archs expertly through the beams and hanging herbs in the kitchen. The cultist moves away from the barbarian's greataxe, coincidentally stepping aside as the arrow whizzes past his ear. He shoots you a look of mixed shock and releif." Miss = "You leap at the cultist in tiger form. He raises his scimitar and braces for the impact. Your sheer weight knocks him off balance, but he struggles and twists against your feline form. You land on your feet beside him."

By making a miss something the enemy did TO the players, they felt motivated to try again. It worked just as well in reverse.

Miss = "The cultists charge towards you, fighting to protect the gemstone. The first slashes at the barbarian's head, but he catches the attacker's sword-hand by the wrist and roars in his face. The second throws a dagger at the ranger's chest, but a quick whip of his bow deflects the projectile harmlessly to the side. The third swings at the druid's tiger ribs, who dodges with actually-cat-like reflexes.

Bad rolls for the enemy weren't close calls, they reflected the martial prowess of the characters.

The combat lasted against three cultists lasted for 12 rounds. It was a loooong combat. By the end of it, the Barbarian scored every hit, every killing blow, neither other player had succeeded on any attack, but it was beautiful. Phones were down, players cheered, and they waited their turn every round, and took their turns efficiently and decisively. The way it wrapped up amazed me, and I have never felt so proud as a DM. Our barbarian hated roleplaying as a character. He liked numbers, statistics, probability, and to him D&D was a fun way to flex the meta-game into a tangible battle against random chance. He started roleplaying with the last cultist, and pursuaded the cultist to denounce the cult and join the team.

The 'I hate roleplay' player later told me, "The way that scene played out, I felt the numbers become fictitious, and I became my character."

We use the word 'miss' too often. I've since committed to avoid using 'miss' as much as possible when I DM. A shield blocks. A sword parries. A character dodges. And yes, rocks still might fall. The dice are not the opponent for your players. The NPCs are the beings the PCs interact with. The DM isn't god, god is an NPC. The DM is the narrator, the director, the silver screen.

Provide scenes that make even the worst of times about the characters' progress, and every story is an epic adventure.

--------------------------------------------------------------

For those who brought up Critical Fails and asked about my homebrew Crit Fail table, here it is:
https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/e/2PACX-1vT-TpNHenduO3SY3_subiyITGRPWu6zdobGPF6UAF4XWE0VNEyrW3h-FkZTzzb_86OWEVCNd8Yap_sG/pubhtml?gid=0&single=true
I wasn't able to make it as print-ready as I wanted to, but I hope you enjoy it.


r/DMAcademy • • Jul 24 '21

Need Advice 1st time DM. My 1st session ended instantly. Within the 1st minute of it starting, with a TPK.

11.3k Upvotes

I started DMing at my local game store last night. It was my 1st time DMing, so the campaign started in a Tavern as usual. All started at level 1. Bard, Rogue, Fighter, Druid, and Sorcerer.

It all started and they introduce themselves. The rogue starts with that he may not be all he seems. The sorcerer casts detect magic at the table they are all sitting around. I roll for wild magic. He has to roll on the wild magic table. He rolls a fireball on himself. Rolls almost max damage. He instantly kills not only himself, but the entire party, and most of the people in the tavern.

We were all speechless. As a new DM I didn’t know what to do. The other DM in the store just said that can happen sometimes and I should just let it play out the way it happened and let them roll new characters and continue the campaign.

I am not sure though, that was crazy. How do I continue a campaign where the white party died within the 1st minute?


r/DMAcademy • • May 22 '22

Offering Advice Stop hitting your high AC players

11.3k Upvotes

I see so many posts here along the lines of "my player has 22 AC, how do I hit them? And then people say "use spell saves" or "just give the goblins +7 to hit"

STOP

Your player maxed out their AC. They want to tank. LET THEM TANK! Roll a ton of attacks against them and let them feel powerful. Let them smirk as your gang of kobolds only land one attack in 8. Let them feel untouchable.

But then

"The kobolds get tired of clanging their spears off your helmet and turn their eyes towards the frail cleric behind you"

If the tank wants to tank, they'll need to learn how to tank. Go after the rest of the party. Split their attention. Its the tank's job to stand and block the rest of the party from being attacked. Don't introduce enemies that are strong enough to kill your tank. Introduce enemies that fly over your tank, or burrow under, or sneak around. Your tank player should feel like a wall, but walls are slow and need to be positioned right to be effective.

Thank you for your time.


r/DMAcademy • • Oct 04 '20

Guide / How-to Opinion piece: The dice are not the skills of your players

10.4k Upvotes

Often I see when the players roll a 1 that the DM explains how horrible the players were and how they failed miserably. Even when they would have a +5 on a skill, the dice decided the player failed.

However the dice are the world and the circumstances.

A thief rolling a 1 on a lockpicking is not bad skill, but just not skilled enough to pick this rusted lock that doesn't give

A bard rolling a 1 on a performance is not a bad song, but a cart driving by and a loud newsbringer screaming through it, thus the people didn't notice it

A Monk rolling a 1 on acrobatics is not a bad move, but a loose rock that twisted a vital balanspoint

Please don't make your players feel like losers by telling them how horrible they are at things they thought they would be hero's.


r/DMAcademy • • Sep 15 '20

Guide / How-to Pro Tip: Use More Kids

8.7k Upvotes

Children are the ultimate Swiss Army knife of enabling role play situations. Need to make your players feel bad ass? Have some children vocally fawn over how cool they look. Need to give your NPCs depth, or make villains sympathetic? Give them children they care about. Want to introduce the idea that a certain race a player is playing is unusual? Have a kid ask them an innocent question, like if a Water Genasi eats anything other than water. Just having children around is a chance for players to show off their characters. Think of a scene from the first Guardians of the Galaxy, when a group of poor children move past the heroes. Quill says “Watch your pockets”, Gamora smiles at them, while Groot cements his role as a kind soul by stopping to give a little girl a flower. It will be well established throughout the game how your player characters deal with villainy. Give them a chance to show how they deal with innocence as well.

Edit: Wow, my first award! Thank you!


r/DMAcademy • • Jan 21 '21

Offering Advice I beat the Bard at his own game.

8.6k Upvotes

One of my players made a bard for the first time, guess what kind of bard he roleplays as? That's right: seduction machine.

Its generally harmless, he always asks if there are any ladies in the tavern and wants to make persuasion rolls to chat them up...he has occasionally attempted the seduction of female NPCs that are antagonists. He's a good guy/player and its all in fun but it has drawn some heavy sighs and eye rolls from me as he hits on every single NPC of the female persuasion.

However a devious idea struck me when he asked if he had won the favor of a particular barmaid he'd repeatedly tried to charm in the tavern the PCs had been regularly frequenting...

Yes, in fact...He had in fact won her over at last. The bard charmed her right into bed. The bard rocked her world. Now, she's obsessed. She turns up everywhere, at inopportune times. She fawns over him, she clings to him, she'll do anything for him...but he sticks to his RP, he's committed to being charming and having women pay him attention. So he strings her along despite being sort of annoyed by her.

Eventually the PCs get hired to infiltrate a prison where magic users are sent by lawful evil Inquisitors who have a lot of political clout in the Kingdom they are in...they decide on disguises and their high charisma to bluff their way in (almost the whole group has high charisma...bard, sorcerer, paladin and a stray ranger)...

PCs decide however to make their deception complete they need a fake prisoner...who does the bard want to ask? Why his obsessed stalker of course...he assumes correctly that this is a dangerous mission, and if something where to happen to her...well...he might not be that sad.

She agrees! ...but has a condition, to which he (before even hearing what she wants!) promises anything at all...she wants him of course, she wants marriage.

You should have seen, my fellow DMs, the look of agony blooming across his face as he realized he was cornered. Trapped between the RP he had established for 8 months worth of sessions and the Dungeon Master. He lead her on and lied to her and told her everything she wanted to hear because...well...seduction bard.

He eventually agreed, and too bad for him the lawful good Paladin offered to marry them (Ceremony ritual).

Now they're on a boat to the prison island, and the Paladin has told me between games that he's going to make it his business to ensure the bard's wife survives. Because she's doing them a big favor, and marriage vows made before his god shouldn't be taken lightly.


r/DMAcademy • • Apr 24 '21

Offering Advice Want to freak out your players? Have the enemies drag away their unconscious bodies! (not OC)

8.2k Upvotes

I don’t recall where I heard this idea first (a much more experienced DM than myself certainly) but I hadn’t tried it until my last session, and oh boy is it effective.

My players were fighting a bunch of devils inside a dormant volcano in an effort to retrieve a powerful artifact they need. The party is currently five 8th level PCs and their 7th level NPC guide. They were fighting a group of bearded devils and a couple hell hounds, along with a single bone devil.

The bone devil hits hard and our gnome sorcerer left himself open to an attack. I hit on all three attacks and rolled a crit on the devil’s sting attack, which was nearly enough to kill him outright. The turn after he dropped, two bearded devils appeared out of a portal behind the party (which they knew about) and started to drag the gnome towards it. The players lost it. Dropped everything and charged to save their friend. Which they did handily, but it was a great moment at the table.

Give it a try some time, the look on their faces was worth it!

Edit: spelling!


r/DMAcademy • • Mar 24 '20

How to not sound like Donald Trump when DMing?

8.2k Upvotes

I’ve DMd a few times and so far I hate how I sound when I do it. I try to describe a place or situation and I end up sounding like trump.

“So this village is a small village, very small. Lots of houses, they’re small too. And uh, it’s a very nice village the nicest village in the land probably, good people, the nicest people”

When I’m a player I can RP fine and everything comes out smooth, but unless I plan every line out when I DM I find myself not able to say anything right.


r/DMAcademy • • Nov 20 '20

Offering Advice I Changed an AC on the Fly

8.1k Upvotes

I have a player who's been having a shit time. Every week, her young daughter, who doesn't sleep well and is very demanding, crawls into her lap and tries to take her headphones off, or will demand to go to sleep on her, or else just makes her leave the game while she tries in vain to get the kid to go to her partner. It's just a phase, but it's meant she's having no fun.

She's also had some really shit dice luck, and has ended up trying to Intimidate hostile enemies because she's convinced she just can't hit them. And she's a Barbarian.

So she rolled a 14 to hit an enemy with an AC of 15. It was early in the fight. I wracked my brains but I was confident nobody had rolled a 14 yet, so it was plausible. And I just had to remember "14 is a hit".

And then she rolled 14 after 14 for the rest of the evening. What would have been one frustrating near-miss after another became a torrent of glory. Nobody else rolled 14s. Just the big stripy tabaxi barbarian with the axe, chopping down one leathery-winged avian after another. Incredibly satisfying.

The trade-off? The party had a slightly easier time of it than I'd planned.

100% worth it.

I don't really know why I'm making this thread; I guess just as an example of how to act when there's stuff that's more important than the rules in your gaming evening.

ETA: for anyone reading this in or after mid-December 2020, the phase is passing. Kids are great fun and hard work. Don't forget to love each other, and remember, it's you I like.


r/DMAcademy • • Apr 30 '19

The REAL Matt Mercer Effect

8.0k Upvotes

I've seen a few posts lately about the "Matt Mercer Effect", and I really wanted to offer a counterpoint. You know the one, where a player or group watch Critical Role and have crazy high expectations and ruin the game for everyone, berating other players and/or the DM, who feels like shit because they're not Matt Mercer. We've all seen these posts. Matt himself has commented on them at least once (probably more).

I'm here to tell you about the REAL Matt Mercer effect. My group and I have been running for a year now. I played a bit of 3.5 way back when I was a kid, and had a handful of sessions with a work group before it fell apart, so I was the one chosen to DM. I did a modest session zero with a basic dungeon and a few sparse NPCs (inspired by Colville) and we all had fun. We decided to continue. Some players and I started watching Critical Role around the time we started playing, and that's when the Matt Mercer effect kicked in.

Inspired by Matt (but I've always enjoyed this aspect of the job), I work my ass off to present an awesome fantasy world for my players to romp about in. I spend probably 10 hours a week fleshing out the world, the lore and history, the NPCs, the story that the players are building, etc. I try to work on my own (terrible) voice acting skills by voicing NPCs differently and coming up with creative and distinct voices for my favorite NPCs. I've even started working on this skill as an extra hobby and have considered trying my hand at getting a job (even one job) to jokingly say I'm a "professional voice actor".

My players have it as well. Many are constantly working to improve their roleplaying, build out character backstories, and make interesting things happen. The ones that aren't into roleplaying still join in and do what they feel like doing, and aren't pressured to come up with an elaborate backstory or personality. They are all humble, hardworking, and caring toward my time and the other players' time. They all try to give one another the spotlight (sometimes too much so and no one wants to take a leadership role). No one expects other players to be as invested than they are themselves, they just want each other to have fun.

THIS is the Matt Mercer Effect - a table full of great friends rolling dice, telling an awesome story together, and sometimes just plain goofing off. THIS is what Critical Role inspires in people. Those other guys? That's just the Wangrod Effect. We should all collectively come together and stop attaching the name of an awesome DM to a problem with dickbags who would just find some other way to ruin a game.

I realize that no one probably cares about my opinion, but I just really wanted to say that Critical Role is by far a force for positivity and I don't see enough people creating threads saying how the Mercer effect has improved their game (and in some cases, lives).

Next day edit: I wasn't expecting this to blow up quite so much and I really appreciate all the kind (and constructive) dissenting comments as well as the positive agreements. By no means did I intend to imply that my experience means problems that have arisen for others are invalid or wrong. I simply think that its unfair to lump Mercer in with what is at its core a player problem. My title was meant to be a little tongue-in-cheek and a little hyperbolic, obviously (kind of a reference to the "No True Scotsman" fallacy).

I am mostly requesting that we start changing the "Matthew Mercer Effect" negative connotation to more accurately address the player at the center of the problem, rather than the medium that influenced his or her problem behavior. After all, we don't have posts about the "Dungeon Master's Guide Effect" when players want to be overly rules-lawyering and argue with the DM about their calls. We should start appropriately calling this the "Wangrod Effect", and instead of laying blame at the feet of someone who is, by all accounts, a force for good in our hobby - lets find constructive ways to address player behavior and manage expectations accordingly, like fucking grownups (or in some cases, near-adults). Remember to spread peace and love to everyone. May your sessions be filled with wonder and excitement.


r/DMAcademy • • Jan 14 '20

Advice [ADVICE] Don't make your guards powerful, make them effective

7.9k Upvotes

"Wait a minute. This city guard, one of fifty or so street guards in this city, has +8 to hit and does 2d8 + 6 piercing damage? How much are they paying this dude to keep the peace?! He's almost as powerful as we are and he's just a guard?!"

A long time ago I tried to keep my lovable murder-hobos in check by describing how brilliant and impressive a street guard's armor was to my party, which was quickly followed up by the rogue asking, "does he notice me? Because I'm about to..." After a push came to an NPC murder, I had three passing guards finally confront my party about what exactly just happened in this particular, body-strewn tavern and my party decided to...ahem, defend themselves from the long arm of the law. My party were bullies and I was ready to teach them a lesson with my unreasonably buff guards and after hitting the Fighter with a roll of 12 my party started asking a very obvious question: "why are these guards so strong? Wouldn't they be living a life of adventure or be the personal body guards of a king or queen? We're level 6 and this city guard is beating the hell out of us."

Don't make your guards into Bad Ass Rambos who also work a job that is one step above a Strong Arm-ed Thug because that indeed doesn't make sense. Instead, make it so that your guards are extremely regimented and accountable. Everyone in [CURRENT TOWN OR CITY] knows not to mess with the guards; not because they can beat you up or overpower a group of five level-six PCs, but rather because each and every guard knows each other on a first name basis and they know when they are supposed to check in with a shift supervisor and provide an "all is well" status report. If it so happens that they had a problem, were openly disrespected, or turn up missing, then the alarm is sounded and the King's/Lord's/Mayor's heavy hitters are on the case and they squash dissent harshly and brutally. The King/Lord/Mayor very much needs to show that they are in control and they do not tolerate disrespect, even to their relatively weak-looking street guards.

I hope this advice helps, thanks for reading!


r/DMAcademy • • Apr 16 '21

Offering Advice Spice up your loot by giving players magic items that they can't use

7.8k Upvotes

First off, let me clarify: No, I don't mean "Be an asshole and give the players super cool magic items that have some kind of restriction making them unable to use them".

Now: I'm sure a lot of you, like me, have run into the issue of providing good loot. Saying "You find 50 gold pieces, 27 silver, and some gems" gets boring over time, and makes every encounter start to feel the same.

What I started to do was sprinkle in some magic items that a party of adventurers would find useless, but an NPC would be willing to pay top dollar for. The first time I experimented with this was "the staff of Demeter". It was an intricately carved wooden rod, covered in runes, which the players found in an abandoned old castle. Upon using "Identify", they found out that, when stuck in the ground in a specific manner it had a similar effect as a long term "Plant growth" spell: all agricultural crops within a mile radius grew twice as fast over the course of a year, so long as it remained in that spot. Obviously, that didn't do much for them, but a local noble with a good sized farm was willing to pay a large amount of coin for it.

Doing this also gets the players more invested. Rather than just grabbing some gold, and heading off to spend it, they had to figure out a potential buyer, and potentially make some kind of skill check to haggle over it. I never mentioned any prices, so those were up to their own negotiating abilities.

This also helps the world feel more alive. Of course, in a world full of magic, people are going to use it to solve a lot of their daily issues, and improve their lives. Having almost every single magic item be some kind of weapon or armor is ridiculous. By filling the world with items like these, it makes it come to life a bit more, and adds a (tiny) bit of realism.


r/DMAcademy • • Mar 13 '21

Resource Very Rare Never-Ending RPG Music Spotify Playlists for Your Games

7.5k Upvotes

I posted these a few months ago and they were well received. Here's an updated list of never-ending (up to 35 hours long now [the longest was 12 hours last time I posted]) RPG music Spotify playlists for your TTRPG games. I'm still actively adding/cataloging/indexing individual tracks to these (not whole albums at a time) from games, movies, and shows. There's a playlist for almost every occasion. Having music that matches the moment really adds to the immersion in my games. Traveling up to a mountain peak? Delving too deep? Long lost brothers reunited? PC died?

There's a playlist for that. Subscribe today! Shuffle for best results.

Overland Settings

General/Travel/Wilderness/Reflective https://open.spotify.com/playlist/5Dal47JLiMtg1huB85DEQe

General/City/Busy Town - https://open.spotify.com/playlist/0iC9WDTW1RxlynyCtI9zXC

Tavern - https://open.spotify.com/playlist/6kN4WBNUyO2jKCnwQfSgpL

King's Palace/Regal/Noble/Posh - https://open.spotify.com/playlist/3s6q3jJgmS2hPOksOK6aXc

Church/Shrine/Peaceful/Choirs - https://open.spotify.com/playlist/7emQXTzkhZ3jTRDUWR1NFW

Wizards Tower/Classical/Surprising - https://open.spotify.com/playlist/2hyY2iYRwjzMZtXtOMDXZM

Elven Lands/Feywild/Majestic - https://open.spotify.com/playlist/3BExVHC239QUifHdXwPeNu

Dwarven City - https://open.spotify.com/playlist/4sqXXHCoGgJiA2eHKwV9L8

Halfling/Shire/Celtic - https://open.spotify.com/playlist/4MdQhChLi3CWcW2m3Bhmq1

Gnome Village - https://open.spotify.com/playlist/2lOxqyLZ3suEJiFU7mXzxT

Desert/Tribal/Badlands/Wastelands - https://open.spotify.com/playlist/4CJtbhA7nmNfFw3VKoDBi0

Arctic/Mountain/Frozen Tundra - https://open.spotify.com/playlist/1mlDvm4IAFRZZrD8OegQaa

Western/Outback/Frontier - https://open.spotify.com/playlist/3WArZKhEP4aOL7LW9Ix7OM

French/Spanish/German/Italian/Romantic - https://open.spotify.com/playlist/7DfREz417VeYZVpuusZ72u

Other-Worldly/Dream - https://open.spotify.com/playlist/4v4CnqyPvma2RfoLKny4q5

Nine Hells/Terror/Dystopia - https://open.spotify.com/playlist/6YU0cD3NZ1B8WD6AW0PkXO

Scene Settings

Danger Suspense/Dungeons/Caverns/Enemy Territoy - https://open.spotify.com/playlist/40nShPZ7g03R7JIXeohiYN

Evil Suspense/Undead/Creepy/Tomb/Graveyard/Crypt - https://open.spotify.com/playlist/3fco0rrNvLpwTt0LOHbvJe

Adventure Suspense/Heroic Acts/Chase/Action - https://open.spotify.com/playlist/5VOChExkjKvlkcnkCpgXCa

Intrigue Suspense/Puzzle/Mystery/Dragon’s Lair - https://open.spotify.com/playlist/3Mb3oz4fLYOYiTd64Iz1XJ

Delving Deep - https://open.spotify.com/playlist/0N6Pfpz4dZie93Hkyzf2Br

Epic Suspense/Boss Room - https://open.spotify.com/playlist/5KqhFkFrI98KsacsNOrHdk

Events

Combat - https://open.spotify.com/playlist/7oSgyTQSblSA0K5l9sXsDP

Boss Fight/BBEG - https://open.spotify.com/playlist/34g2goSq63sV1AgNSEmFfZ

Hell Battle - https://open.spotify.com/playlist/0hVoVFkeaD34Wr8vCbG6y6

Uplifting/Inspiring/Happy Moments - https://open.spotify.com/playlist/5yLW2TzHLvmIgerTmJczLK

Sappy/Emotional/Romantic Moments - https://open.spotify.com/playlist/1zNTzVrLljLj75aXnkAlvX

Sadness/Loss/Tragic Moments - https://open.spotify.com/playlist/2ialHGHKmEjAK522BxXEfH

Raining - https://open.spotify.com/playlist/0urJhIKNzy3JHIF6JVlxnH

Works in Progress (<2 Hours)/Niche

South American/Latin- https://open.spotify.com/playlist/1fjS5fSLKTRHeFlOr6rxjR

Asian/Oriental - https://open.spotify.com/playlist/5TA0al0OadtCsWPVcQXeQE

Arabic/Middle East/Indian/Persian - https://open.spotify.com/playlist/3AZvJXgbm8SOdZAqYWgbx7

Russian/Eastern Europe - https://open.spotify.com/playlist/7cU6OkeR5gf0ykIXdcUSTT

Jazz/Big Band/Early Modern - https://open.spotify.com/playlist/4rdLqakxMHqg4O0UhUPpAR

Cyberpunk, Future, 80's, Synthwave - https://open.spotify.com/playlist/54IUIuyAdoMV4YJkaANVy9

Nautical - https://open.spotify.com/playlist/2n7tdzF6jLPOibNnZm1FvG

Heist/Planning a Scheme - https://open.spotify.com/playlist/7s6D0fGwGX0KqFZBvFGpP0

Epics/Building Suspense - https://open.spotify.com/playlist/3E9ykatx4NLViW2ackh7IV

Ambient/Environment Sounds, No Music - https://open.spotify.com/playlist/53xlDUkBlBLYIRPU0BUpY6


r/DMAcademy • • Oct 09 '20

Question My players are gonna find a wizards library full of smut books, help me come up with titles!

7.5k Upvotes

Hi all!

As part of a little side quest my players will find a wizard tower with multiple floors. One floor will be a library with many books, where they will have to pull out several books in a particular order to proceed to the next level. I'm planning on making a picture of several bookshelves, where titles of books can be read. But I want all books to have smut titles like 'tusk love' from CR. I've thought of a few but I need your help!

A few titles I have thought of are:

The Wizards staff

The Barbarians Raging Bone

Dwarf Wrestling for Dummies

Mind flayers: other uses for your tentacles

Orcs raided my village and now I'm pregnant

Any help would be appreciated!


r/DMAcademy • • Jan 22 '21

Resource Everybody Tells How to Create a D&D city. Nobody tells you what buildings and professions bring life to a city. So I made a list for you!

7.4k Upvotes

So here's my list of possible Business Establishments and possible professionals, employees and artisans you can find there.I am not in any case claiming its complete, but it's an extensive list nonetheless. Depending on economy, size and population of your hamlet, village, town or city, you can put up as many establishment from this list and decide the size of staff you can populate it with.

https://imgur.com/gallery/j9alkO7

hope this helps you all!

E: Thanks for the award! You guys are so nice!


r/DMAcademy • • Nov 07 '21

Offering Advice Friendly reminder that the "Running the game" series by Matt Colville exists and will most probably solve 95% of the problems you have at your game. (links below)

7.2k Upvotes

The number of times i had to link a video of his in a "need advice" thread is... surprising at least.

I'm not saying that he's the best at anything (he wouldn't agree either) but just spreading the word for anyone that isn't aware of the existence of his channel.

Here is the link to the playlist!

I know that it can be daunting, it's a long series after all, so i made a compilation of my favorite videos if anyone wants to start right away.

  • Different kinds of players

  • The Sandbox vs the Railroad - a discussion on types of campaign, also known as: "How would "The Hobbit" and "Lord of the rings" look like if they were a D&D campaign?"

  • Bad guys! - Foolproof method of making BBEGs

  • Information - How to talk properly to your players when you DM

  • Surrender - (one of the most common issues i see being brought up in this sub)

  • Let's start in a tavern! - Foolprof/standard method of starting a campaign

  • Problem players - (THE most common issue at any table)

  • Break Your Heart - AKA: "The reason why people make their own worlds, and why maybe you should too"

  • Roleplaying - (my personal favorite!)

  • Action oriented monsters - aka: how to spice up your combat and make it fun! (third most common problem IMO)

  • Downtime - Matt Colville's own favorite video: "Why we play D&D and what makes it special."

  • Engaging Your Players - how to make a campaign engaging (and fun) for everyone, including you as the DM.

  • "No." - second most common problem: Why setting boundaries as a DM is not only important, but critical for a fun and healthy game for everyone at the table.

If this helps even a single person, i'll be happy! I think Matt Colville has made me the DM that i am now, so i want to exchange favors!

I'm also making this for personal use, so i can link it to my friends once they'll want to join DMacademy!


r/DMAcademy • • Sep 08 '21

Offering Advice That 3 HP doesn't actually matter

7.2k Upvotes

Recently had a Dragon fight with PCs. One PC has been out with a vengeance against this dragon, and ends up dealing 18 damage to it. I look at the 21 hp left on its statblock, look at the player, and ask him how he wants to do this.

With that 3 hp, the dragon may have had a sliver of a chance to run away or launch a fire breath. But, it just felt right to have that PC land the final blow. And to watch the entire party pop off as I described the dragon falling out of the sky was far more important than any "what if?" scenario I could think of.

Ultimately, hit points are guidelines rather than rules. Of course, with monsters with lower health you shouldn't mess with it too much, but with the big boys? If the damage is just about right and it's the perfect moment, just let them do the extra damage and finish them off.


r/DMAcademy • • Jun 27 '20

There👏is👏 nothing👏wrong👏with👏starting 👏in👏a👏tavern👏

7.2k Upvotes

Absolutely nothing wrong AT ALL with that. Fucking Star Wars started in a tavern. Taverns are where you meet people, its where the townsfolk go to chill out and it stands to reason that's where all the jobs are posted. Not only is it a tried and true classic start to a story, it holds nostalgia. If anyone ever puts you down or you ever feel inadequate because your campaign started in a tavern know this - The lower you start the more impressive it is when you get to the top. So I say start your game in a damn tavern amd end it in the lowest level of Tarterus after slaying the evil demon Nadrak The Destroyer. Absolutely nothing wrong with starting in a tavern.

Edit – Alright so I guess I have to write this - Star Wars did start in a tavern “no it started on the Tantive IV” ok well in that case it actually started around 4 billion years before the battle of yavin around the creation of the universe. Because we could keep going back and back and back saying “well this is actually where the story began” At least im pretty sure that’s the canonical starting point I’m not certain and I don’t feel like looking it up because its such a trivial point. What I was eluding to is the fact that the first place where one could find the majority of the major heroes of the series was in a tavern. It was one sentence guys. Get over it.


r/DMAcademy • • Sep 16 '21

Offering Advice "Do I see anything?" How my players simple question became the best moment in our campaign and changed how I'll DM PC deaths/near deaths in the future.

7.1k Upvotes

Our gnome wizard got a bit separated during a fight with a black dragon. In a highly targeted round of claws and a bite, he fell unconscious. And proceeded to fail the death saves. Not a huge deal. At level 13, our cleric can handle that no problem.

It will take our cleric at least 3 turns to get to the wizard. Which is fine cuz revivify is 10 rounds. While we are finishing up the fight and the cleric is running, we get to the wizards turn.

"Unfortunately you have died last round so we are just gonna skip over too......."

"Hey before you go on, do i see anything?"

'Internal brain wracking for what a non-religious wizard might see'

"Make a perception check." (buying time)

18. Ughhh, the weave, he sees the weave.

"Okay what you see is mostly complete blackness. Except for a long ribbon of light. As far as you can see to the left and right. It moves a little and tiny lights of every color and some you've never seen pop off like sparks from a fire. On occasion it folds on itself. Bending and twisting locally to for a Helix, or even impossible geometric shapes."

"I want to move towards it."

"Okay you can 'fly' up to your intelligence score x 3 towards it"

a whole round goes by.

"So this ribbon, do i know what it is?" Religion check, 23. I explain what the weave is and a bit of Mystra.

" So basically this is the source of all magic. It is pure and all powerful arcana."

"Ok i go closer"

whole round goes by. "Do I know what would happen if i touch it?" Insight check.

"You would become one with the weave. Your body and soul returning back to pure magic that will live on in infinity that future magic users will draw from. Also, it's at this point you feel something pulling at you. Back to the Material Plane (revivify started)."

"Okay, but do i think my understanding of magic would grow if i touched it?"

"Well, you would BE magic, so yes in a sense."

10 second of silence..... "I'm gonna touch it."

5 jaws at the table drop and I've never been so proud of a player.

When dealing with death, I have now written a "heavens gate" specific to each player. The one avenging their families death hears those voices. The super religious cleric sees Moradin's Forge. Even the "evil" Warlock can bring her soul to her patron to strengthen it. Thinking it through, this makes death matter more at high levels when the solution is a spell slot, and some money.


r/DMAcademy • • Aug 03 '20

If a player goes through the effort of adding flavor to their action, like describing how they use components when casting a spell (i.e. grabbing a spider off the wall to cast spider climb), don't shut them down by making them roll a "Luck" check.

6.7k Upvotes

When a player is just adding flavor to their actions making them roll to succeed with that flavor just shuts down their creativeness and willingness to say more than "I cast spider climb"


r/DMAcademy • • Jan 31 '21

Offering Advice Attack the Players' STRENGTHS, not their Weaknesses

6.6k Upvotes

I love making combat encounters. I have a lot of advice on how to make them, but there's one point that I come back to more than any other:

Attack the players' STRENGTHS, not their weaknesses

If you have a fire-focused wizard in the party, don't throw a fire elemental at them. Throw a swarm of treefolk at the party instead, a terrifying encounter that the party can only overcome because of their wizard. Give the wizard a chance to shine, fireballing swarms of enemies that take double damage from fire.

Which encounter do you think they'll enjoy more? Fighting the fire elemental, or fighting the treefolk swarm?

So often DMs ask forums for help figuring out how to negate their players' coolest abilities, ways to stop the players from playing their characters the way they envisioned them. They try to disable or negate the players' cool feats, builds, or strategies. If a ranger has a favored enemy that gets them a bonus when attacking orcs, don't take orcs out of your campaign. Add more orcs. Make a major boss an orc! Stack the deck against the players, but give them chances to shine with their special abilities.

There's psychology underlying this. On a player's turn in combat, they're looking for opportunities to do something cool and useful. If they can't find something that seems valuable, they get frustrated. If they see a perfect opportunity to use a key spell or class feature to huge effect, they've found what they're looking for. This makes them satisfied and happy, it gives them a chance to shine.

If your paladin is immune to charm, throw an enchanter at the party that attempts to charm everyone - so the Paladin gets to feel good about their immunity. If your acrobatic rogue can do massive burst damage, let them know that if someone risks climbing onto the monster's back they could get automatic critical hits stabbing it in the back of the head.

Give your players opportunities to shine, and cool stuff to do that's way better than normal. Give them chandeliers to drop on enemies, give the clerics undead to turn, and give them foes that take triple damage from their favorite damage types.

Then mix it up with a foe that has some resistances or immunities to all their favorite toys, just in very small doses. The one time that Sleep magic shows up in a campaign shouldn't also be a special magic that also affects the warforged (which are normally immune to sleep spells).

Attack the players' strengths, not their weaknesses.

EDIT - Since people seem to like this advice, I do a podcast called The GM's Guide too. #shamelessplug


r/DMAcademy • • Apr 27 '21

Offering Advice Holding Out for a Hero: What the best scene in "Shrek 2" taught me about running a "storming the castle" sequence

6.5k Upvotes

Storming the castle is a time-honored part of adventure fiction. Whether it's Westley, Inigo and Fezzik trying to rescue Buttercup, Vox Machina taking back Whitestone, Jack and Wang Chi assaulting Lo Pan's lair, or the crew of the Normandy mounting their assault on the Collector Lair, the big attack on the enemy's base is a climactic moment of heroism.

However, in D&D, it can often get bogged down and turn into more of a slog, with repeated encounters with enemy mooks feeling less heroic and more like busywork. But these encounters need to exist to drain resources from the players, so it's unavoidable, right?

What if I told you there was another way?

Learning from the Finale of "Shrek 2"

Shrek 2 is one of those rare movie sequels that manages to completely surpass the original, IMO. It also climaxes in a genuinely great scene that still holds up to this day: Fairy-tale-ified Shrek, Donkey, Puss in Boots, and others storming the castle to rescue Princess Fiona, all to a great cover of "Holding Out for a Hero."

I recently had the opportunity to run a "storming the castle" sequence of my own, and I used this scene as inspiration. It worked extremely well, and I want to share what I learned in 4 key tips.

Tip 1: Set a Time Limit

Players are often very cautious by nature. We all know the party that will take a short rest after every goblin fight, right? Not only do those slow down gameplay, they interfere with the natural draining of resources you're trying to accomplish. The solution is simple: Have your players race against the clock. Perhaps the bad guy is about to activate his doomsday device, or perhaps Princess Fiona is doomed to be enchanted when she kisses the fake Shrek.

Giving your players this timed objective will push them to take risks and keep the encounter moving.

In my campaign: One of my players wasn't able to come for a couple of sessions due to RL issues. With her permission, I decided that her character, a wayward princess who'd run away from home seeking romance and adventure, would be called home by her parents only to be kidnapped and told that a marriage had been arranged for her. Unbeknownst to her character's parents, this arranged marriage was the result of a major villain's scheming, who gave her a cursed "wedding ring" that would enable them to carry out their evil plans through mind control when the wearer had their wedding blessed.

Since she was held far away through magic, the party had no choice but to wait until she was at the cathedral before crashing the wedding. If they were too late, their party member would be permanently cursed. (That was a lie; the villain was prone to exaggerating. They didn't know that.)

Tip 2: Give the Players Whatever Resources They Want (Within Reason)...

Shrek's plan to interrupt Princess Fiona's wedding was greatly helped by the aid of a giant gingerbread man on his side. And Fezzik sure made good use of that flaming cloak to scare off the guards, right?

Giant gingerbread men nonwithstanding, give your players time to prepare, and let them spend their money on powerful resources - potions, magic items in high magic settings, and the like.

Now, this doesn't mean you should let your players all purchase Vorpal Swords. Use your better judgment to not let this sequence have lasting ramifications for the balance of the rest of your campaign. (Unless this is the final battle, in which case feel free to go nuts).

In my campaign: The players stocked up on ball bearings, a potion of invisibility, plenty of tools like rope, crowbars, and so on alongside the typical healing potions.

Tip 3: ...But Let the Enemy Figure Out How to Counter Them

Yes, Shrek has the help of Mongo, But after the catapults fail, the guards at the wall are able to pour boiling milk down on the gingerbread man, destroying him. Mongo helps breach the wall, but gets no further than this.

Whatever tricks your players come up with, have them work - but only once or twice. This lets them get use out of their preparation and have it feel worth the investment, without having them rely solely on this one trick to bypass the entire encounter sequence. Afterwards, have the enemy adapt to it - this makes the guards feel like more of a threat and more competent.

In my campaign: The player who drank the invisibility potion slipped past a few guard patrols with it. Eventually, however, one of them realized, and shouted out "someone's invisible!" The guards then shut open doors and splashed water on the floor, meaning they could hear and see the invisible player's footsteps if he traveled down certain hallways, forcing him to try different options.

Tip 4: Assume Success. Roll for Consequences.

This, more than anything else, might have been the single biggest contribution to achieving the feeling of a fast-pased, high-octane castle storming: Assume your players are going to succeed on every roll.

This can feel completely at odds with the whole concept of D&D. If there's no failure state, than you're just sitting around playing make-believe, right? But I promise you - this will work.

Narrow success in an adventure is one of the most exciting parts about fiction, but it doesn't always translate well to D&D. What happens if Shrek fails his Dexterity check to slip into the drawbridge in time, or if Donkey fails his Athletics check to jump over the guards? Puss in Boots holding off the guards is a great scene, but imagine how slow that would be in D&D - roll initiative, roll attack on the guards, the guards roll attack on you, etc. The players failing can instantly throw a giant bucket of ice water on the excitement of this climactic scene.

So, what I did was this: I assumed (almost - more on this later) every interaction and thing they tried would succeed, and informed them as such - this made them want to do crazy things, which was fun. I still had them roll, but the roll did not determine whether or not they succeeded - the roll determined what success cost them.

In Shrek 2 terms, let's say the Shrek player rolls poorly on his check to get inside the drawbridge before it closes. He still gets inside, but fumbles the landing and takes some extra fall damage. Also, the guards wound him before he knocks them out.

In my campaign: I turned every interaction into a straight up or down (or, if guards were involved, contested) roll. Based on the outcome, I then judged what the players lost. Perhaps the wizard casting Wind Wall took some damage, lost her concentration, and had to expend an extra spell slot. A "puss in boots" scene where the swashbuckler Rogue held off the guards was a simple him-vs-guards roll, and his natural 20 meant he fended off the guards with minor injuries (but still a few scrapes).

This meant that time wasted on, say, checking the saving throws of individual guards, was greatly reduced, the players all felt like heroic adventurers, and most importantly, I was able to drain them of resources like HP or spell slots before they rescued their comrade and, of course, had a big boss fight against the villain herself.

(This really does require a big battle waiting them at the end of it, so that the resources expended aren't just recovered after a long rest. At least, in my experience.)

*The one exception to this rule: Charisma checks. Don't let your players bluff their way past the guards. Maybe one or two bluffs to get them into a hallway is okay, and rewards Face-type characters, but otherwise this just becomes a way to get around everything.

Anyway, I hope this helps you put on an excellent climax for your players!

Have fun storming the castle!


r/DMAcademy • • Nov 18 '20

Offering Advice Why PCs Don't Care About The NPC You Put Hours Into; Why They Love That Random Goatherd You Made Up On The Spot; Why They Ignore Your Plot; And Why They Do Weird Things

6.5k Upvotes

Every DM has this experience. Either you put a lot of work into something and your PCs just don't care, or the big thing they care about is some random inconsequential detail that doesn't matter at all in the big overall story. Or both!

There's a single concept that explains this. It comes from improv theater.

When an improv actor says or does anything new, that's called an offer. I did an improv class one time where we just practiced accepting offers. I said "Let's invade Kentucky!" and this other guy said "I'll get my camo hat!" The idea is just that the first person would put out an idea and the other person would pick it up and build on it.

D&D is not like that, but D&D does have offers, and they mostly come from the DM, especially when a game is getting started. If you say to the players "you discover that Count Vampire McVampire from Bonjovia is behind the murders!" this is an offer. People often think that it is guaranteed that players will care, but it is not guaranteed at all. And if the players ask a guard for a directions, and you randomly mention that the guard has a mustache, that is also an offer. You might assume that it is guaranteed that the players will not care about the guard's mustache, but you will learn otherwise. The mustache is an offer, and some PCs will ignore the BBEG and seize on the importance of the guard's mustache.

Often the best way to have a good game is to rebuild your entire plot to be a conspiracy about mustaches, because that's what the players have chosen to chase now, and they will chase it whether or not it exists.

If you think of D&D as a thing with a plot and a story that the DM provides to the players, the whole mustache conspiracy factor will exhaust you.

So don't think of it that way. That mental model is unfortunately a reasonable interpretation of the way people write up adventures — but it'll just make you crazy, or at least tired.

Instead, think of D&D as an improv game where every player can put out offers to the other players, but most offers are going to come from you, the DM, and the players are going to reject most of those offers.

The number one mistake that DMs make, especially beginning DMs, is assuming that the players will take the "right" offers and ignore the "wrong" offers.

Instead, just say "I'm going to throw out a bunch of offers and see where the PCs want to go." And instead of planning a whole storyline ahead of time, build out a few different directions. If they take up the Count Vampire McVampire offer, have a followup offer like a vampire hunter looking for a magic amulet, or whatever. But be prepared for them instead to want to find out more about who the victim was in the latest murder, and set up an offer there as well — maybe a widow seeking revenge, or something.

The big win here is if you set up a couple different offers per game, but they don't take you up on every offer, you'll have a bunch of extra stuff ready for those weird occasions when they get obsessed with the guard's mustache.

edit: wow, this blew up! thanks for the response everybody. I didn’t perfectly communicate what I was trying to say, but I’m glad if this helps people!


r/DMAcademy • • May 20 '20

Japanese Storytelling Saved My Campaign

6.3k Upvotes

I'm a forever DM, and a couple years ago, I was feeling super burnt out. DMing was so much work, my players were so unpredictable, and it just wasn't fun anymore. I watched Critical Role and thought, "I can't do that."

I am also a writer, which means that stories are something I engage with constantly. So why did D&D suck so much?

Then I discovered this traditional Japanese storytelling technique called kishotenketsu. Essentially, it works like this:

  1. Ki, or introduction. E.g. There's this really amazing magical city.

  2. Sho, or development. E.g. They practice human sacrifice, which most players will try to stop.

  3. Ten, or twist/divergence/false appearance. E.g. The sacrifices were actually keeping a tarrasque miles below the city from waking.

  4. Ketsu, or resolution. E.g. You must now fight a tarrasque, or otherwise solve the problem (see edit)

Here's another example:

  1. A man is very skittish and inarticulate. He might tell the PCs "Not fwiends!"

  2. He pickpockets people out of habit. He acts childish or animalistic.

  3. He is actually a very talented thief in the local thieves' guild but was hit by a Feeblemind spell during a major heist of the mage's college.

  4. He will owe a favor to anyone who cures him. He will remember how people treated him when the effect wears off.

The main difference is that there isn't necessarily conflict. There's no climax, rising action, falling action until the players create it. The first three parts are simple facts in the world or inevitable events. The resolution is the result of player action. If players act differently, the resolution might not be a fight. It's way easier than Western storytelling because Western story structure is all about the characters and their journeys, which the DM has no control over! It leads to railroading, improv, and other things that (to me) are simultaneously more work for the DM and less fun for players.

After a little trial-and-error, I now use kishotenketsu almost exclusively. I made a 100-page document of cities and towns with adventure hooks based on this story structure (which I'll eventually share here), and it's going great! It doesn't get stale because not all "ten" are equal (e.g. a baker who puts sand in his bread vs. another who puts orc poison). My players are more predictable because they know every location has some kind of secret to uncover. Or rather, they know there are several secrets, and they want to find the best one.

It's also way easier to start and stop sessions because each step is interesting in some way, and my players aren't just waiting for the next fight. They're always uncertain about where the fight will come from and trying to find creative ways to get around the twist.

Kishotenketsu also made a lot of other changes easier. For example, my players do way more active roleplaying because they're more engaged with my locations.

My NPCs are more interesting because I use the same principle: first impression, character development, hidden secret, things the NPC will do if the players help/harm them.

My boss fights as well: monster appears, monster attacks, monster has secret ability or relationship to environment, players defeat or run away from the monster.

Most importantly, both my players and I feel like we have control. Again, kishotenketsu isn't about characters. It's about the world and events. The story is already there, and players get to uncover and affect it. I feel like I am in complete control of every situation while my players feel like they have complete control over the resolution. They can go wherever they want and have a fun adventure. I now DM about 10 hours per week and don't feel burnt out at all. My players and I are both excited for the next session.

Sorry for sounding like a bad advertisement. I hope other DMs find this technique useful. I love D&D!

TL;DR I stopped planning stories. I made an interesting world with lots of false appearances, and my players are having fun uncovering the "truth."

Edit: resolution includes everything after the twist. Defeating the monster, collecting the reward, pouring drinks with the NPCs, etc. But most of that is player-driven, and all the components are in place from the earlier stages, so the DM doesn't need to worry about it as much until it circles back to introduction for the next adventure.

Also, this is a simplification of kishotenketsu as I've adapted it to Dungeons & Dragons. Please don't take this as an essay on the entire body and spirit of Japanese literature!

Finally, the beginning of my journey was probably my experience with the first Dark Souls game. The story already exists in the world, and players can engage with it as much as and however they want. I try not to make things quite that opaque, but the overall approach is comparable.

Final edit: By popular demand, I have uploaded a short sample of what my book looks like. It's by no means complete because a lot of my document is written in shorthand (this would normally be about 3 pages instead of 10), but hopefully it gives people some ideas!

Link: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1y0hrHHyRWgFOY5RoO5L-csu-n2nh9mOFcVfjaqdL1VM/edit?usp=sharing