r/DMAcademy • u/Archaias06 • Apr 02 '20
The most overused word in D&D, and how to overcome the damage it causes to a party:
After a few sessions of DMing, I'm sure everyone eventually runs into the experience of seeing a player feel discouraged about how their character is doing. After I went through an entire night never rolling higher than a 6, I realized what was bothering me. It wasn't that my rolls were bad (though I did sentence those dice to life in shadowbox memorabilia priosn).
I didn't have fun because my character wasn't a badass for an entire session.
I made this wonderful character, I spent weeks on the backstory with tweaks, research, maps, drafts, everything. My wife joked that I knew more about that character than I knew about myself. He became an important part of the group, and a pivotal character in the world's development. He was quirky, arrogant, reckless, and had an eye for rooting out corruption. But for one solid night, he was Clumsy McDropkins of the Butterfinger clan.
When I played back the session later that week on my commute, I learned something that changed the way I DM forever.
I realized (again) that as a player, I didn't want to be part of the game anymore not because I had a night of bad rolls, but because my character's story and integrity changed forever. That night the DM had tried to be more creative with his storytelling. Before that session, a missed roll would trigger the narration of "No, a 12 doesn't hit, anything else with your turn?" That night, it changed to "You swing your shortsword and.... miss." Over and over and over and over again. My character is not a clumsy, reckless, whirling tornado of aimless slashes; I didn't like what it turned into.
The next session I DM'd I tried a creative solution, this time with the tables turned.
My DM was a player, and I told him I was going to attempt the same creative narrative approach he had tried. I had a post-it note on the back of my DM screen and all it said was "THE PLAYERS NEVER MISS". We got into our first combat, and I couldn't have asked for a better chance to practice. Two of our party never scored a hit, and I didn't roll very well myself. So I went to work narrating three level 2 characters fighting a small group of cultists.
I brought the battle to life despite low rolls, and created an epic battle on accident.
Miss = "You swing your greataxe, but the cultist quickly steps to the side. He whips his scimitar through the air, and pushes your greataxe away. Your greataxe smashes through the floorboards." Miss = "You fire an arrow from across the room. The arrow archs expertly through the beams and hanging herbs in the kitchen. The cultist moves away from the barbarian's greataxe, coincidentally stepping aside as the arrow whizzes past his ear. He shoots you a look of mixed shock and releif." Miss = "You leap at the cultist in tiger form. He raises his scimitar and braces for the impact. Your sheer weight knocks him off balance, but he struggles and twists against your feline form. You land on your feet beside him."
By making a miss something the enemy did TO the players, they felt motivated to try again. It worked just as well in reverse.
Miss = "The cultists charge towards you, fighting to protect the gemstone. The first slashes at the barbarian's head, but he catches the attacker's sword-hand by the wrist and roars in his face. The second throws a dagger at the ranger's chest, but a quick whip of his bow deflects the projectile harmlessly to the side. The third swings at the druid's tiger ribs, who dodges with actually-cat-like reflexes.
Bad rolls for the enemy weren't close calls, they reflected the martial prowess of the characters.
The combat lasted against three cultists lasted for 12 rounds. It was a loooong combat. By the end of it, the Barbarian scored every hit, every killing blow, neither other player had succeeded on any attack, but it was beautiful. Phones were down, players cheered, and they waited their turn every round, and took their turns efficiently and decisively. The way it wrapped up amazed me, and I have never felt so proud as a DM. Our barbarian hated roleplaying as a character. He liked numbers, statistics, probability, and to him D&D was a fun way to flex the meta-game into a tangible battle against random chance. He started roleplaying with the last cultist, and pursuaded the cultist to denounce the cult and join the team.
The 'I hate roleplay' player later told me, "The way that scene played out, I felt the numbers become fictitious, and I became my character."
We use the word 'miss' too often. I've since committed to avoid using 'miss' as much as possible when I DM. A shield blocks. A sword parries. A character dodges. And yes, rocks still might fall. The dice are not the opponent for your players. The NPCs are the beings the PCs interact with. The DM isn't god, god is an NPC. The DM is the narrator, the director, the silver screen.
Provide scenes that make even the worst of times about the characters' progress, and every story is an epic adventure.
--------------------------------------------------------------
For those who brought up Critical Fails and asked about my homebrew Crit Fail table, here it is:
https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/e/2PACX-1vT-TpNHenduO3SY3_subiyITGRPWu6zdobGPF6UAF4XWE0VNEyrW3h-FkZTzzb_86OWEVCNd8Yap_sG/pubhtml?gid=0&single=true
I wasn't able to make it as print-ready as I wanted to, but I hope you enjoy it.