r/CubeWorld • • Sep 06 '19

New Tweet Release this year and Steam confirmed!

Thumbnail
twitter.com
7.6k Upvotes

r/CubeWorld • • Sep 25 '19

Cube World Needs Horizontal Progression

3.9k Upvotes

TL;DR at bottom, this will be a bit dense


Hi I'm Duuko, and I've made a hobby of game theory/mechanic design - mostly for board and card games, but video games as well. I've seen a lot of posts from players suggesting fixes to the game and decided this was something I could offer another perspective on. Ok so...


I'll be talking a good bit about some different types of progression so here's all the ones I'll be talking about listed and defined:

  • vertical progression: character progress centered around empowering a static toolset (health, attacks etc.) to overcome more difficult obstacles.

  • horizontal progression: character progress centered around adding different tools to increase build diversity, flexibility and synergy to overcome more difficult obstacles.

  • scalar progression: constant progression in which the strength of the character is increased after each obstacle (enemy, puzzle, test) is overcome. (Diablo, Borderlands)

  • static progression: progression in difficulty matching player skill over time. (Portal, Super Meat Boy)

  • stepped progression: micro-progress is lost after overcoming an obstacle, but rewards a lasting macro-advancement which allows the same obstacles to be overcome easier, or harder obstacles to be approached for greater reward. (Rogue, any rouge-like/lite)


The State of Alpha

Cube World alpha used vertical scalar progression, which is no surprise as this was and is by far the most common progression system for RPGs - you're weak, kill slightly stronger things for slightly stronger loot and 'xp', become slightly strongerrepeat. It also had some horizontal progression with customization to gear design, choice and skill tree. These coupled with pleasant passive exploration and decent procedural encounters to make it a pretty damn solid, safe game even with its flaws. And it did have flaws, a big one being imbedded in its progression system - and is a problem in almost every other vertical scalar: endgame.
Wollay chose one of three routes and went with capless character and encounter scaling, so relative stagnation. This meant that one could always continue to progress, but all that really changed was bigger hits and healthbars, along with bragging rights over lower level friends. It is clear now that Wollay didn't like this part of the game and this is almost certainly why we have seen such drastic changes to the core progression system.


Problems

Cube World beta moved away from vertical scalar and took a swing at vertical stepped - a much harder but, as I'll explain later, much more rewarding and repeatable progression loop. Wollay NAILED the core progression system, but made an abysmal execution of making a fun game out of it. The good news is that the hardest part of the game to change and tune is rock solid, the bad news is there really are an impressive number of failures that would need fixing for it to really show how good of a core design it really has:

  • the gameplay loop that the player goes through to get a macro-advancement (artifact) is not engaging or variant enough to sustain more than ~5 loops.

  • the artifact received is not enough of a jump in progression to warrant the time it takes to obtain or the 'reset' (regional loot) aspect of the stepped game design.

  • as much as Wollay wants Cube World to be an exploration rpg, it isn't. Safe and fast regional exploration is locked behind exceptionally difficult combat encounters, most of which require gear to overcome. As a combat-centered rpg, combat encounters and permanent progression do not have the depth to let Cube World beta be a good game.

  • lore, region, dialog and quest generation does not have the depth or variance required of a game which encourages exploration, npc interaction and combat advancement. A player must want to see what's in the next biome, how the next combat encounter fights or what that artifact does even after each are fulfilled. There could be all the content in the world to complete, but no one will reach it if they do not feel it is worth reaching. Do you really want that next level of gear to beat that level 1024 ogre that fights like a radish, like a golem, like a... you get it.

  • in a combat-centered game, permanent progression must be combat-centered, beta offers far from useless but far from interesting progression in the form of ability to climb, glide, ride, swim or...not drown (I know, I know 'deepsea loot').

  • resetting gear by region is not problematic and, further, is a brilliant way of dealing with endgame loot stagnation, but the process of obtaining loot is not currently variant, exciting or engaging enough to warrant doing so knowing that it will be weakened or lost.

  • pets are currently mounts - they are homogeneous and effectively the same save what they look like and like to eat. This goes back to making the player want to progress - do you want the monkey that gets oneshot? What's wrong with your one-shottable corgi? In alpha different pets did different things well, collecting more pets didn't make you stronger, it enabled strategizing, which was fun. This was an example of horizontal progression in alpha - this is important.

  • each class has 3 or so abilities, and will use those three abilities from minute 1 to hour 1000, the only variance being how quickly you attack and how large those attacks are. First Person Shooters like CS:GO have more ability variance to explore than this game - an rpg.

  • players are not permitted to 'theorycraft' and examine different solutions (gear+abilities) to overcome obstacles, because there is no relevant variance in enemies, abilities, gear or pets. Let alone the fact that players will have no incentive to farm gear more than they must given it will be lost if they want to progress in a lasting way.

  • the carrot tastes better when you know you earned it or you recognized how rare it is that you got it out of shear luck. Inversely, the stick becomes more painful when its use is not expected or understood. It is objectively poor design to take something a player spent time earning without an appropriate reason, and better yet - make it a choice with the promise of a carrot if they choose to take the stick. Losing hard earned gear when crossing a region border just 'because' is unacceptable and just feels bad to experience. The player must want to lose their temporary progress (gear) for longer term progression (artifact). As of now, every player that crosses a border thinks 'wait this doesn't feel right, WHY do I have to give up my gear to leave with my artifact?'

  • Wollay has designed encounters so that they may not be approached let alone overcome without having the matching tier of gear or above. This means that enemies and gear of different tiers need to have significant gaps in power between them, creating multiple problems such as being oneshot by an enemy a tier above you, or on the flip, being able to manhandle every encounter you come across when well equipped. This yields the worst of linear progression endgame without the benefits of linear scalar progression - in short, its really bad.


Solutions

I'm going to skip over most of the obvious fixes such as quest, pet and dialog diversity for my own sanity and focus strictly on progression-related solutions.

  • there are a lot of players complaining about the removal of xp gain from mobs, but I think this is actually a good thing - I think that scalar progression is overdone and in the case of 'xp per obstacle' it can be a crutch or even a cop-out to engaging early-midgame play. Players are complaining about lack of combat related progression when compared to how steep the obstacle difficulty scaling is (difficulty of enemies at different tiers), not xp specifically. So again, the core progression loop of getting gear, fighting and exploring through a region, acquiring an artifact and moving on to restart in another region does not need to be fixed - it is the core identity of Cube World and is really what sets it aside in my mind as a well designed game.

  • there must be a reason for why loot is weakened or lost when it leaves a region - perhaps enchanted gear is tethered to its origin of enchantment, or borders are protected by a 'veil' which keeps magic of any kind from passing through to protect artifacts, but the player character is unique in a sense that they can 'drain' and conceal the power of artifacts and bring them with them through the veil - but enchanted gear must stay behind. Anything works really as long as it is somewhat interesting and coherent. Make the player feel POWERFUL for being able to bring artifacts to other regions, rather than weak for not being able to bring their enchanted gear. which leads to my next solution...

  • let traveling gear such as hangliders through borders. I see why Wollay went for the BotW style regional unlock system, but BotW is not an infinitely scaled rpg. After ~5 loops the privalage of convenient travel will be vastly outweighed by the chore of playing easteregg hunt for each individual mode of transport in each region.

  • make enemies distinct in how they fight alone and in tangent with other enemies. For encounters to be engaging indefinitely, challenge must come from the mechanics and interactions of the enemies more than bigger stats. Slay the Spire does an excellent job of showing how a game can have nearly limitless replay value by creating simple, yet distinct encounters and chains of encounters.

Now for progression - I have a specific vision for how this could work best but keep in mind there are many solutions to this design problem and this is certainly not the best.

  • this game begs for horizontal-focused progression. This means that as players progress they may get slowly stronger in stats, but more dominantly in the number of tools they have access to.

  • artifacts should not grant flat combat stat bonuses, and a limited number of artifacts should be able to be equipped at once. This should be done to move the focus away from just dealing more damage or hitting harder unconditionally - as this progression is easy but unrewarding when the player inevitably out-scales all available content.

  • instead, there should be three types of artifacts:

    • 'red' artifacts which grant active abilities when equipped based on class - for example an artifact which lets a ranger mark a target to damage surrounding enemies when attacked.

    • 'green' artifacts which offer passive abilities that grant conditional bonuses or synergize with other effects - for example an artifact which causes critical hits to cause a bleed effect.

    • 'blue' artifacts which grant bonuses to non-combat tasks for players who want to gear up in zones without engaging with combat encounters - for example increased crafting quality, riding speed, the ability to sell items to any npc, or ability to locate and unearth rarer loot etc.

  • these artifacts would not be created equal, as one of the aforementioned bleed artifacts may deal more damage per tick, while another lasts much longer - all depending on how variables roll within a set range. The important thing is that even with the 'best' rolled artifacts, the player is not powerful enough to walk gearless through foreign zones. The power comes from skill in fighting different encounters and synergy of builds they create from different combinations of artifacts, along with flexability to adjust their build to be strong into certain dungeons/bosses/challenges. This is the beauty of horizontal progression - the game gets more involved and exciting the longer it is played. In this way players are able to express and form a unique and powerful play style to their own taste AND to the gear that is dropping in the region they are in, which leads to the next point.

  • weapons need to be more distinct in how they play - I think mage is in an okay place for this. Beyond this, individual gear needs to have distinct enchantments and effects that invite the player to build around it with the artifacts they have access to. "wow this mace lowers my cooldowns if i crit - wait I have this artifact that would be so good with this..." That is fun, and makes each 'loop' unique in how you approach it to get another artifact, and in turn another option to build around. This is really how it should be done.

  • artifacts should have a cost to exchange slots, whether this is an actual gold cost, a quest to complete or a location to go to, the decision to redesign your character should feel important - this also prevents players from swapping out their kit swiss-army-knife style for every encounter, which allows lazy buildmaking and breaks gameflow.

  • once artifacts in every region of a kingdom are collected, the player should be able to go to a 'boss' region - in which are more difficult enemies, challenging obstacles and a final encounter to obtain the kingdom's artifact. Lore from different regions in the kingdom could point to an overarching conflict in the kingdom - as simple as a lich who is raising an undead army - bam, after you collect the kingdom's artifacts you are deemed strong enough to enter this region, and fight again from nothing just like every other time to defeat said lich. The reward would be completion of the kingdom, access to all undiscovered lore in that kingdom's regions, and an additional slot for artifacts. This would be the point of infinite scaling. After enough playing a character would be able to equip enough artifacts to trivialize content, but by then they have gotten plenty of playtime in progression, and may even consider starting a fresh character from the bottom because it's fun to start from nothing and see how your progression path plays out next time. Or perhaps players can opt to reset the same character with a standard 'prestige' mechanic which allows the player to express the number of times they've reset to other players. Prestige should feel prestigious, as obvious as it sounds it is an often misused and unused mechanic of macro-progression. This is an example of how players can be objectively stronger than other players via the number of 'slots' they have unlocked - but more dominantly through their build design and mechanical skill.

  • gear 'skins' of items they have designed or edited should be available to players so they may express their style or interesting items they have acquired during their play. After a few loops no one will bother caring for or editing their gear if it aesthetically disappears after the region is defeated.


Power to you if you made it through all of that - I really am excited for the game's potential because, at its core it really is a gem. You've got this Wollay!


TL;DR:

  • cube world beta has a really exciting core design that was poorly executed.

  • alpha was fun but wollay was right that the end game progression was flawed and needed fixing to appeal to players other than diehard fans.

  • he chose to try a stepped vertical progression: you take two steps forward (grind), fall back a step (region locked loot), but earn the ability to take three steps before you fall back one next time you loop (artifact).

  • the design is really solid but the artifacts are not rewarding and the grind is not fun enough to encourage looping.

  • region locked gear should be kept, but there must be a reason thematically which makes the player feel powerfull for being able to bring artifacts with them, not weak for having to leave gear behind.

  • make artifacts grant unique passive and active effects which can be combined in a limited number of 'slots' to synergize with playstyle, abilities and whatever gear has been dropping in your current zone.

  • make a 'boss' region accessible after all relics in a kingdom are acquired - defeating this final region grants an additional 'slot' for artifacts.

  • listed many other problems and solutions which are not worth mention.


as requested I have reformatted and posted the above to the Steam community. Join the other side of the discussion here.

additionally: my first plat, gold and silver, thank you.


r/CubeWorld • • Sep 30 '19

Today, a legend retires

Post image
3.6k Upvotes

r/CubeWorld • • Oct 05 '19

Meme It has almost been a week since release...

Post image
3.3k Upvotes

r/CubeWorld • • Sep 24 '19

Beta This game is good. Here's how to make it better:

3.2k Upvotes

Beta spoilers.

I originally had a novel written. I'm just going to make it into a TL;DR and reply to comments if anyone has a question or counter-argument.

I am enjoying the beta. It's not amazing, it's alright. Alpha had great takes that never finished development, and the beta has some alright, unfortunately over-developed ones. I hate reading long posts, so should you. I'm going to get straight to the point, here's my observations and opinions:

  • Players like skill trees. Even if they're linear like in the alpha, the choice between two trees it's better than no trees at all. Big lack of combat progression.

  • Region-based items being forced is garbage. There are ways to make this interesting; I will explain further below. All items being region-based, however, is awful.

  • Non-combat progression sucks. It should be fun and just an extra to get those upgrades, like icing on the cake (hang-glide speed, mount speed, climbing stamina).

  • Artifacts are currently a slap in the face because they are non-combat progression (which is boring as stated in previous point), yet they are the rarest items in that region. Least interesting reward after putting in hours into explorating a region.

  • Combat is still fun, but lack of skill descriptions (brings us back to first point).

  • The procedurally-generated content is really cool and well-done. Not many people talking about how impressive it is due to the out-rage about other issues, but it's very cool. Being overlooked at this moment.

My personal proposition that would solve most, if not everything:

  • Bring back skill trees. That's good progression. Make us earn our new skills, also allows Wollay to add new class content to keep combat fresh. Also I seriously want to know what my class does. The ninja class still gains 100% critical strike chance on their next ability after a successful dodge, just like in the alpha. However, there's nothing in the game that tells you this. Every class has a problem similar to this.

  • Equipment (hang-glider, boat, reins, etc) need to be universal. The game kicks you off mounts and boats as you cross borders. Insanely stupid. There's no way to make region-based equipment interesting, sorry.

  • Back to last point: instead of picking up a new hang-glider/etc equipment in every new region, it should be: getting another hang-glider, boat, reins, etc., increases its efficiency. Hang-gliding gets faster, less stamina; boat sails faster; pets gain stats and riding is faster; climbing equipment instead of removing stamina costs, continues to reduce costs. This means every region has a chance to unlock these cool equipment items, but there's still a very good reason to continue finding them when you go to new regions. I would personally love going out of my way to seek out more reins to increase my pet's level or riding speed.

  • Artifacts: with last point's propositions, artifacts should now increase combat-based progression. 5% reduced universal stamina consumption. 5% more damage, 5% reduced universal cooldowns. Literally anything other than the current 6% reduced diving stamina consumption after spending 5 hours in one zone.

  • Puzzle items can stay region-based, such as the harp, flute, etc. Not a big issue, adds reason to explore and unlock new opportunities in each region. I don't see an argument against this; keeping key puzzle items would be detrimental to the exploration and discovery gameplay. However, it would be neat to have more variety and more randomness. I don't want go through a checklist every time I enter a region, I want to discover and explore what the region has to offer.

  • Gear should be universal by default. However, make this gear objectively worse than region-locked gear, as well as harder to find. This makes exploration and finding new gear worthwhile even if you already possess great gear. For example, a 5-star universal weapon will always be around 10-15% weaker than region-locked gear. Or perhaps, if a region contains a certain tribe/cult/race, make region-locked gear deal extra damage to that specific enemy. Just suggestions. Anything other than this current gear system.

  • Pets are weak and only serve to be mounts now. Bring them back to alpha gameplay, where each had their own uses, such as turtle drawing aggro and having a substantial health pool. Why does my dog die in one hit over and over. It's sad. Gameplay-wise, and sentimental-wise.

  • Otherwise, the rest of the new content can stay. Randomly generated lore, puzzles, exploration, really amazing and can be interesting. But the other parts I mentioned are weighing it down.

In conclusion I'm just a slightly disappointed, but still-having-fun player. Wollay has created something amazing with the procedurally-generated game that produces infinite content, but resetting us back to zero with terrible non-combat stats doesn't make up for it. As I'm typing all this, I'm a little dead on the inside knowing I'm just writing a fan-fiction for a game at this point. I only wish I could play the alpha version of Cube World with this amazing new randomly-generated content. I hope that one day we will eventually get a game that was worth waiting 6 years for. I believe in Wollay, he's incredibly talented and clever creating this new content, he created the alpha. We just have to see if he listens to the community.


r/CubeWorld • • Oct 17 '19

I created a mod that adds scaling to items/enemies & changes artifacts to boost combat stats

2.8k Upvotes
Introduction

I started developing a small mod for Cube World a couple weeks ago that contains some changes that my friends and I thought would make the game more fun. It's far from perfect, and there are at least a few bugs, but I figured that some other people might enjoy the mod too, so I'm going to release what I have so far.

 

Changes
Region Lock

I've removed the region lock for both equipment and special items (with offsets from Geordan9's cheat engine table), so gear will now work in any region you visit.

 

Item & Enemy Scaling

I have also changed the way progression works by adding hp and damage scaling to items and creatures.

When you first join the game with the mod on a new character, you have an undefined "center point". This point should be set once per character with the "/setcenter" command. As you travel away from this point, the hp and damage of enemies and NPCs will steadily increase. Item drops from these further out regions will also have increased stats.

Note: Attacks from wand and staff enemies now deal 60% damage.

Here is an example of what combat might look like in full epic/legendary gear, a little over 600 regions away from the center.

 

IMPORTANT: If you do not use the /setcenter command after making a new character, any items you receive will act as if they are from the center region until you do (no scaling).

 

Artifact Stat Boost

Artifacts now provide a boost to combat stats. The old stat boosts are still in effect, but they are not displayed anywhere.

 

Item Spawn Rates

I have also decreased the spawn rates for higher rarity items, and increased the spawn rates for lower rarity items.

This means that legendary items are much less likely to drop. When a legendary item does drop, however, it has a small chance (~5%) to become mythic. These mythic items have increased stats compared to legendary items (25 - 50%), and also have a + on the end.

Note: There is currently a bug that causes some items dropped from bosses or found in logs to not be affected by this change.

 

PvP

I have added player vs player combat as an optional feature (off by default). You can decide whether or not you would like to be able to attack other players with the /pvp command.

 

Configuration

Configuration options, such as the pvp toggle state and center region, are stored in a file in the game directory called "modcfg.txt".

 

The mod allows the use of commands (case sensitive) to modify configuration options. You can open the chat window with the return key.

  • "/pvp" will toggle the ability to hit other players on and off

  • "/getcenter" will print out the current center coordinates for your character (e.g., "-6623, 11148")

  • "/setcenter" will set your current region as the center region for your character

 

Multiplayer Information

This mod was created to work in both singleplayer and multiplayer. The only requirement for multiplayer compatibility is that every player have the mod installed.

IMPORTANT: The center regions are not networked, so every player should ensure that their coordinates are the same (using the /getcenter and /setcenter commands, or the config file if needed).

 

Installation & Setup
  • Download the latest release from github and extract all the files into your game directory ("steamapps/common/Cube World", where cubeworld.exe is located).

  • IMPORTANT: Make sure to select "Replace" when prompted for FreeImage.dll.

  • Launch Cube World from steam and create a new character.

  • Synchronize your center region with any friends you would like to play with.

 

Note on new characters: This mod will modify any items that your player has on them, so I would recommend creating a new character if you wish to use this mod.

 

Removal: If you want to remove the mod, simply use Steam's "Verify Integrity of Game Files" feature to replace the overwritten mod loader dll (FreeImage.dll).

 

Source Code

The source code for this project is available on this github page. Feel free to modify or use it however you like.


r/CubeWorld • • Sep 25 '19

Meme Thank you Wollay, very cool!

Post image
2.8k Upvotes

r/CubeWorld • • Oct 02 '19

The big questions

Post image
2.7k Upvotes

r/CubeWorld • • Oct 06 '19

Leveling systems

Post image
2.6k Upvotes

r/CubeWorld • • Sep 26 '19

Desert and enchanted forest makes for an aesthetic environment

Post image
2.6k Upvotes

r/CubeWorld • • Sep 24 '19

It actually be like that

Post image
2.5k Upvotes

r/CubeWorld • • Oct 05 '19

Meme Iz da truth..

Post image
2.5k Upvotes

r/CubeWorld • • Oct 07 '19

It do be like that

Post image
2.4k Upvotes

r/CubeWorld • • Sep 29 '19

Me showing my friend the Cube World beta for the first time

Post image
2.4k Upvotes

r/CubeWorld • • Oct 09 '19

Meme Goodbye

Post image
2.4k Upvotes

r/CubeWorld • • Oct 12 '19

truth

Post image
2.3k Upvotes

r/CubeWorld • • Sep 23 '19

Discussion You all need to chill out

2.3k Upvotes

Game has been out for roughly two hours and you're all already complaining, blaming and even hating on wollay and pixxie... Seriously wtf ?
Y'all need to calm down and be civil.

Pixxie is trying to help on Steam and all you do is post hate messages about her being rude and all when all she's trying to do is help.
No wonder why Wollay isn't communicating, poor dude had a depression because of jerks like you. I sincerely hope he won't have any other issues because of your hate.

Just chill ffs.

EDIT : Alright just to make things clear. I'm not saying you can't think the game is bad. I'm saying there's other ways to voice your opinion. You can say you dislike the game without insulting, harassing and generally shitting on it.


r/CubeWorld • • Oct 15 '19

2013

Post image
2.3k Upvotes

r/CubeWorld • • Oct 01 '19

Other Please, say something :(

Post image
2.2k Upvotes

r/CubeWorld • • Sep 26 '19

It really do be like that sometimes

Post image
2.2k Upvotes

r/CubeWorld • • Oct 14 '19

for a second time, REALLY.

Post image
2.1k Upvotes

r/CubeWorld • • Oct 24 '19

It just be like that sometimes

Post image
2.0k Upvotes

r/CubeWorld • • Oct 01 '19

A beta thingy

Thumbnail
imgur.com
2.0k Upvotes

r/CubeWorld • • Oct 03 '19

What happened?

Post image
1.9k Upvotes