r/CubeWorld • u/Faangzzz • Oct 02 '19
This community's response to Cube World fills with with the desire to Go To Sleep
Hi, I'm a game developer from a small studio. I have a few things I'd like to say, since a lot of folks have been having questions and making takes that I disagree with. A lot of these show a lack of understanding for how game design works. There are a few common questions that I've seen voiced, which I can answer.
"Why doesn't Wollay add skill trees? It'd be an easy change, and we want it!"
Given the limited scope of Cube World's skill system, it didn't make sense for the game to ever have skill trees in the first place. Skill Trees are useful in circumstances where you want to offer players choices in buildcraft. Cube World's buildcraft comes first from your class, and second from your subclass; while both classes and subclasses provide new mechanics for a player to use, the skill trees only add numbers. You really want player choice to be about the mechanics they have, since mechanics are how the player is going to interact with your game. The numbers your skills have will continue to increase regardless. Adding skill trees would do nothing to the game's core design.
2. "Why are my items useless after I leave a region? Region-locking's dumb!"
Every rpg with level progression has the equivalent of region-locking. If you log into WOW or Final Fantasy or a Dragon Quest game and play the game for 10 levels, you get all the best gear and do the content for those levels. Then you reset. You go to an area for level 11-20 players and the gear you just got is functionally equivalent to when you started. When you go to the new level 11-20 area, you're now level 1 in a level 1-10 area again, but the game's telling you you've made progression. The difference in most rpgs is that your progression is marked by the addition of new mechanics; a healer starting a game only with Heal and Ward spells might have a Resurrect or Empower Attacks spell by the time they've gone to the new area. Cube World's a bit different, since it doesn't have very many mechanics to give you. A mage isn't going to learn new spells because a complicated combat system just isn't currently in the scope of the game.
3. "But I want skill trees! And I don't want regionlocking!"
That doesn't make skill trees good design, and it doesn't make the way regions work bad design. What you're asking for is a different pretty paint over the exact same game systems in place currently. Would it really make ya feel better if the game showed other regions as level 11+ after you beat the first one? It'd be exactly the same as it is now.
4. "The Alpha was so much better! Why does the beta suck?"
The Alpha was almost completely devoid of any content or objectives. The game didn't have anything to do. You could run around aimlessly killing things if you wanted and get shiny slightly higher-statted gear. That was it. Now it has a ton of variety, enemy types, and cool flavorful quests.
5. "Can Wollay sell this game to a company who knows what they're doing? Give it to X Dev they'll fix it"
Fuck you. I wouldn't work on a game from a dev whose userbase treats them like they're disposable. It wouldn't be safe for me or anybody working on the project. Seriously, all you people getting riled up that your bucks didn't get you your nice perfect dream game aren't worth listening to. Specifically you are the people whose opinions we discount when we're considering feedback because your opinion is worthless.
6. "Why are you being such a bitch? I just want the game to be good. Can't you be nicer"
Seeing people treat Wollay like dirt over the years has filled me with an indescribable fury. Start treating him like a fucking person, because the way you've talked about Wollay and Cube World will be the reason it's never the game you want it to be.