As someone old enough to remember life before the internet - I remember how depressing scanning through the newspapers as a child used to be. Apart from Sports and Business pages, every page was full of negative headlines and crime and corruption and such.
The news was the same, be it Aaj Tak or NDTV it was all full of terrible things happening everywhere in the country.
But I also remember when there would be one massive breaking news - maybe 26/11, maybe the Aarushi/Nithari cases, maybe just the first T20 World Cup final - watching the news felt like suddenly only one thing mattered. There was no more countless news reports of rapes and murders and maoist attacks - just continuous reporting on that one big breaking news.
And I realized information can indeed be a curse - filling your mind with all the bad stuff going on around the country has absolutely no use other than making you feel like everything is doom and gloom. And given there's nothing you can personally do to affect this, what's even the point of starting or ending your day by filling your mind with negativity?
The fact the country had a long way to go was obvious, but it was also obvious that the problems were complex and often interconnected in a way that could be traced back to the very fabric of society - and ultimately the biggest hurdle was always the scale of population, the hundreds of millions in poverty, the hundreds of millions illiterate. It was never going to be easy.
When i was a kid I remember very clearly from the 2001 census, India's literacy rate was in the low 60%s. Today it's in the low 80%s. If you told kid me we would come this far in 20 years I would be elated. But today even that 20% feels like a massive number and being told to believe it'll be close to 100% in another 20 years feels like selling us false promises. But that's literally how progress works in a country so massive.
So feeling miserable about the state of the country today isn't surprising. Every generation since independence has likely felt this way and yet we have slowly but surely progressed. India's literacy rate at the time of independence was 14%.
But what has changed is that we have the internet now, the world feels smaller and more connected. And the news in India no longer stays within India, it quickly reaches abroad, and given the size of the Indian population and the millions of immigrants abroad - the news is somehow very relevant even in distant countries. WHne previously Indians abroad would deal with only ignorance and casual racism, now people abroad are armed with constant updates on the terrible goings on in the country - now their racism feels justified, and they no longer feel ignorance. But as they say, 'little knowledge is dangerous'.
And another unfortunate consequence of this globalization is that Indians feel like they represent their country to the world, and hence feel responsible for every single negative event in India - like they owe foreigners an explanation. But the truth is there is no easy explanation which doesn't sound like excuses - India is a unique country in every single way, but it is judged very severely against other countries foreigners, through their ignorance, might perceive to be similar to india and somehow doing better.
So what do you do when you're constantly feeling responsible for every bad thing happening in your country? Especially when given the size of he population, even ignoring other factors, it is simply far more statistically likely for negative news to come out of the country. Outsiders dont' care about nuance, that sounds like excuses. And so at some point, we as Indians begin to believe them - we begin to feel like every legitimate reason for the country's condition is just an excuse - we might feel a different government will magically change things, or we might simply resign and say we as a country are destined to fail and have no hope.
This is going to sound like a bizarre analogy, but this psychology exists also in sports fan discussion. Take football, a club spends a £100m on a footballer - all your rivals have their eyes on this player and are waiting for him to fail. And then the player doesn't perform - at first it's obvious to you there are multiple factors out of the player's control affecting his performance - maybe the team as a whole is struggling, maybe he's low on confidence given his new surroundings. But when the player's progress is too slow to keep away the criticisms and the valid justifications begin to feel like excuses even to the person who previously believed them, they soon turn sides and join the rivals in calling the player a flop. Even if the player has actually improved a fair bit over time, it's just never good enough. And it's much easier to simply give in than keep arguing.
An easy solution in this case is to simply stop caring about the noise and focus on supporting the player because you know that's the best way to help him perform and help the team. But we are so addicted to the internet and the endless opinions on it that we cannot cut off.
This is where I feel like China played it's greatest card. By insulating it's internet during it's period of development, it bred a population which was more focussed on solving internal issues as a nation rather than wasting their energy defending their country to outsiders and eventually resigning themselves to agreeing with the outsiders.