r/CriticalThinkingIndia • • Oct 03 '26

Law, Rights & Society The Indian Govt is an RSS proxy. Current India is fascist state.

0 Upvotes

Sunil Joshi: RSS activist (Dewas/Mhow area). Linked by investigators to Samjhauta Express and Ajmer Dargah blasts. Killed in 2007 (before full trials).

Sandeep Dange: RSS pracharak. Named in Samjhauta, Mecca Masjid, and Ajmer cases. Remained absconding in earlier reports.

Lokesh Sharma: RSS-linked. Accused in Samjhauta and Mecca Masjid. Arrested; later among those acquitted or benefiting from weak evidence chains.

Devendra (Devender) Gupta: RSS pracharak. Convicted (with life imprisonment) in the Ajmer Dargah case along with Bhavesh Patel; also linked to Mecca Masjid. One of the rarer sustained convictions.

Bhavesh Patel (Bhavesh Bhai Patel): Linked to RSS circles. Convicted with life sentence in Ajmer Dargah bombing.

The RSS killed Gandhi

It believes in NAZI fascist Ideology openly

Manusmriti the worst book on the planet is followed by the RSS as the lawgiver of the world -Govalkar said this

Hemanta Biswa Sharma CM of Assam has also worked for terrorist organisation - ULFA

CM of up Yogi Adityanath statement -“If they kill even one Hindu, we will not go to the police; we will kill 10 [or 100] Muslims.”

Gujarat butcher Modi is the PM

If the govt itself is like this does the Constitution hold any value ?

Why is the RSS not registered as an terrorist organisation or at least banned ?

Sanathan santha vhp and rss linked assassination

Narendra Dabholkar

Gauri Lankesh

Govind Pansare

M Kalburgi

Fun fact everyone accused of killing them is out on bail

Police couldn't find half of the killers - Other half granted bail

rrests: Multiple accused charged (including alleged shooters and conspirators).

Convictions: 2 (the alleged shooters — Sachin Andure and Sharad Kalaskar) convicted by a Pune special court in May 2024 and sentenced to life imprisonment + fine.

3 others (including alleged key conspirator Virendrasinh Tawade) were acquitted for lack of evidence.

Current status: Both convicts later received bail from the Bombay High Court, with their life sentences suspended pending appeal (Kalaskar in 2026; Andure in August 2026). The case is therefore only partially resolved at the trial-court level and remains under appeal. Not fully “solved.”

2. Gauri Lankesh (September 2017)

Arrests: 18 named in the SIT chargesheet; 17 arrested; 1 (Vikas Patil) still absconding.

Convictions: None.

Current status: All 17 arrested accused are out on bail (the last one released by early 2025). Trial ongoing since 2022 in a Bengaluru court (multiple judges have handled it; hundreds of witnesses listed, with a substantial number examined but many still pending; some witnesses have turned hostile). Not solved.

3. Govind Pansare (February 2015)

Arrests: Around 12 named; most (9+) arrested over time; some suspected shooters reported as absconding in earlier updates.

Convictions: None reported as final.

Current status: Most accused (including overlapping ones from other cases such as Tawade, Kale, Kalaskar, Andure) are on bail. Trial ongoing and slow. Not solved.

4. M.M. Kalburgi (August 2015)

Arrests: Overlapping set of accused with the Lankesh and other cases.

Convictions: None.

Current status: All accused out on bail. Trial progressing very slowly (few witnesses examined relative to the total listed). Not solved.

The courts work to justify Hindu fascism and nothing else


r/CriticalThinkingIndia • • Mar 12 '26

Ask CTI Why do people mock PM Narendra Modi for selling tea as a child? Isn’t that just poverty shaming?

0 Upvotes

I have to start this by saying that each and everyone on this Nation have some problems with PM Modi and his policies, People have the right to criticise his policies and have problem with the ideology is fine and does not cross any moral grounds, And are free to interpret and debate around it.

People making joke around his statements, That is also totally fine, But then i see people making jokes about him being Chai wala, That is where i find it a bit disturbing.

We all know that our Prime Minister used to sell tea as a Child in Train Stations and Bus Stops and use to live in poverty, People making Fun of this should be categorised as Poverty Shaming. The fact that people joke around his childhood poverty just because they do not agree with him, Tends to show the subvert mindset of people making Fun of Poor people. This needs to be called out. What do you guys think about this ?


r/CriticalThinkingIndia • • Mar 23 '26

Philosophy, Ethics & Dharma Japan made Attack on Titan. America made Sicario. India made Dhurandhar. Only one got called propaganda

0 Upvotes

In 1942, George Orwell (one of the greatest writers of the 20th century) was working at the BBC's radio department. His job was simple — write newsletters - In one of those newsletters, he claimed that the Japanese were plotting to attack Russia. It wasn't true. He didn't believe a word of it either. But the logic was brilliant in its cynicism: if Japan does attack Russia, Britain gets to say "we told you so." If Russia attacks first, Britain blames Japan anyway. And if nothing happens at all, they claim Japan was simply too scared to try. Every outcome was already accounted for. The truth was irrelevant.

Orwell knew exactly what he was doing. And at the end of it, he famously wrote: "All propaganda is lies, even when one is telling the truth. But I don't think this matters, as long as one knows what he's doing and why."

He was stating a fact about how narratives operate. Every powerful nation on earth manufactures its own story. They must. And the ones that survive are the ones that do it without apologizing.

Japan understands this. The Attack on Titan is one of the most-watched anime in history - over 200 million people have seen it.

<Spoilers start>

The story is set in a world where humanity has been pushed to the edge of extinction. Giant humanoid creatures called Titans roam the earth, devouring people. The last survivors live behind three massive walls, believing they are the only humans left alive. For a hundred years, they're told the Titans are a natural disaster, that the outside world is empty, that their small existence behind the walls is all there is. Then the walls break. And as the protagonist Eren Yeager ventures outside, he discovers the truth — the Titans aren't mindless monsters. They're actually humans, transformed by a rival nation as weapons of war. The "natural disaster" was political. The "empty world" was full of civilizations that wanted his people dead. Everything he was taught was a carefully constructed lie designed to keep his people passive.

And when Eren discovers this, he doesn't sit down and write a letter. He builds an army. He strikes first. He becomes the very monster the world accused his people of being — because he concludes that a small nation surrounded by enemies who want it erased cannot survive on good intentions alone.

<Spoilers ends>

Japan made this story while sitting under American military bases that have been on their soil for seventy years. A country that was forced to write pacifism into its own constitution after World War II. A country that has spent decades debating whether it even has the right to maintain a real army. Attack on Titan is Japan processing that tension - the rage of a nation that was told to be peaceful by the very people who dropped two nuclear bombs on it. Everybody in japan knows what "Attach on Titan" stands for.

Nobody called Japan propagandist for making it. It won global awards. It got called a masterpiece.

America does the same thing. Sicario is a film about the American war on drugs along the Mexican border. The protagonist is a young FBI agent who thinks she's been recruited for a clean, legal operation. She slowly discovers that the entire mission is 'off the books' - a CIA-run assassination program designed to destabilize one cartel so another, more controllable one can take its place. There is no justice in the film. No courtroom. No handcuffs. Just a former prosecutor named Alejandro whose wife and daughter were dissolved in acid by a cartel boss — and who now crosses the border to execute that boss's entire family at their dinner table. Children included. The film doesn't condemn him. It shows him as the inevitable product of a system where the rules stopped working a long time ago.

Critics loved it. Called it "unflinching." Called it "necessary." Three Oscars nominated. Nobody asked America to be more balanced.

Now look at India. Dhurandhar comes out — a story where an Indian agent is sent undercover into Pakistan, makes morally devastating choices, risks the life of a child to maintain his cover, and ultimately uses the death of a child to enter the gang. A story that refuses to give you a clean hero or a simple answer. And immediately, a section of our own people labels it propaganda. Not because the film lied. Because it showed an India that fights back, and that made them uncomfortable.

Where did this discomfort come from?

It didn't come from the Mahabharata. The most righteous man in the entire epic — Yudhishthir — lied on the battlefield to get an advantage in the war. He said "Ashwatthama hatha," knowing Dronacharya would interpret it as the death of his son. It was technically true, and emotionally a complete deception. The Pandavas broke every rule they held sacred. And the epic doesn't frame this as failure. It frames it as the cost of survival. Dharma in the Mahabharata was never about being pure. It was about carrying the weight of difficult choices and still standing.

The discomfort didn't come from Chanakya either. The Arthashastra is a manual for statecraft, 1000 years before kids like Machiavelli were born. It talks about spies, assassinations, economic warfare, strategic deception — written by a man who dismantled an empire and built another in its place. This is Indian thought. Original, unapologetic, and sophisticated beyond anything Europe was producing.

So where did the flinch come from?

It was installed. Carefully. Over generations.

When British scholars rediscovered Ashoka in the 19th century, they had a choice about how to present him. They chose the version that suited their purposes. They emphasized the remorse after Kalinga. The Buddhism. The renunciation of violence. The "transformation." What they left in the footnotes: after becoming Buddhist, Ashoka ordered the execution of roughly 18,000 followers of the Ajivika sect because one of them drew a picture he found offensive. The man didn't stop being an emperor when he picked up Buddhism. But colonial historians needed a pacifist India - an India that was spiritually rich and politically docile. An India that meditated while they administered. So they built Ashoka into a saint and handed that version to us through our own textbooks.

And it worked. It worked so well that now, when an Indian film shows an Indian character making the same kind of hard, ugly, morally complex choices that American and Japanese characters make on screen every year, we don't just critique it - we feel guilty for watching it. We distance ourselves from it. We perform a kind of borrowed shame that none of our ancestors would have even recognized.

The French don't spend their evenings debating whether Napoleon was problematic. The British built a museum out of stolen artifacts and put a gift shop at the exit. Learn how Winston Churchill is celebrated in UK while we know about his contributions to Bengal famine which killed ~ 3 MILLION people. America constructed the most powerful narrative machine in human history — Hollywood — and they call it entertainment. They all protect their stories. They all frame their past in ways that serve their present and future. And none of them lose a second of sleep over it.

But Indians are supposed to add a disclaimer every time they feel proud. We are supposed to whisper about Sanskrit and shout about everything foreign. We are supposed to treat our own philosophy. We treat the most widely-read philosophical text on the planet, which opens on a battlefield where God tells a warrior to stop hesitating and fight — as though it's something to outgrow. Something provincial. Something that needs a Western stamp of approval before we can take it seriously.

Orwell understood that every nation runs on narrative. The ones that thrive are the ones that know exactly what story they're telling and why. The ones that collapse are the ones that let someone else write their story for them and then defend that version out of habit.

India has been defending someone else's version for long enough. With the quiet, settled knowledge of a civilization that has been here for five thousand years, has seen every empire rise and fall around it, and is still standing. The only thing left is to stop flinching at our own reflection. We are a land of wise and warriors. Take responsibility, do your duty.

Ref

https://orwelldiaries.wordpress.com/2012/03/14/14-3-42/

https://observer.co.uk/news/archive/article/george-orwell-argues-for-indian-independence-in-his-first-observer-article-1942

https://archive.org/details/ajivikas00barurich/page/68/mode/2up

https://books.google.co.in/books?id=9jb364g4BvoC&pg=PA32&redir_esc=y#v=onepage&q&f=false

https://www.polygon.com/2019/6/18/18683609/attack-on-titan-fascist-nationalist-isayama-hajime-manga-anime/

https://www.wsws.org/en/articles/2015/10/15/sica-o15.html

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Fo9YuTeiqeQ


r/CriticalThinkingIndia • • May 29 '26

Critical Analysis & Discussion Read more about the Umar Khalid Case.....and now I beleive the case is judged on wrong or incomplete facts...(Read the post before lashing out)

Post image
263 Upvotes

Spent the last few days reading through FIR 59, court orders, witness statements, speeches, timelines, forensic reports, all of it. And after a point the thing that stays with you is not even the conspiracy theory itself.

It's the imbalance.

Because look at how this story actually starts.

In December 2019, Parliament passes the Citizenship Amendment Act. Supporters call it a humanitarian law for persecuted minorities from neighbouring countries. Critics argue it fundamentally changes the idea of Indian citizenship by explicitly excluding Muslims.

The protests that follow are massive. Shaheen Bagh becomes the symbol of it all: Muslim women sitting through winter nights for months, blocking a road in protest. Universities across the country join in.

And then the political rhetoric starts getting uglier.

Anurag Thakur leads crowds in chanting “goli maaro saalon ko.” Parvesh Verma says Shaheen Bagh protesters will enter homes and rape women. Kapil Mishra repeatedly frames the protests as a threat building inside the capital.

None of them are prosecuted.

Then comes February 23, 2020.

Anti-CAA protesters block a road near Jaffrabad Metro Station. Kapil Mishra arrives at Maujpur Chowk alongside a Delhi Police DCP and gives the speech that basically becomes the defining image of the riots:

“We will remain peaceful till Trump leaves. But after that, if the roads are not cleared, we will take to the streets ourselves.”

According to police records themselves, stone-pelting begins shortly after.

What follows over the next six days is the worst communal violence Delhi has seen since 1984.

53 people die.

Most of them are Muslim.

Muslim homes, shops and mosques are burned across northeast Delhi. Videos emerge of mobs checking names and religion before attacking people. Human Rights Watch, Amnesty International and the Delhi Minorities Commission later document the same broad pattern: the violence was deeply asymmetric and Muslim localities bore the brunt of it.

There were Hindu victims too, and pretending otherwise would be dishonest. Vinod Kumar, a Hindu man, was reportedly killed after rioters spotted a “Jai Shri Ram” sticker on his motorcycle. Fear spread on both sides.

But the larger pattern remained obvious enough that multiple independent reports said it openly.

Then there were the police allegations.

Videos surfaced of officers beating injured Muslim men lying on the road and forcing them to sing the national anthem. Witnesses described police standing alongside mobs or refusing to respond to calls for help. Complaints against BJP leaders largely went nowhere.

And then came FIR 59.

This is where the entire thing changes shape.

Because instead of mainly pursuing the people visibly carrying weapons or leading mobs during the riots, Delhi Police built a much larger conspiracy case under UAPA, India's anti-terror law.

The theory was that the riots were not spontaneous at all, but part of a coordinated conspiracy by anti-CAA activists designed to embarrass the government during Donald Trump's India visit.

And the people who became the centre of that conspiracy case were not politicians.

They were protest organisers.

Students. Activists. Academics.

Umar Khalid. Sharjeel Imam. Natasha Narwal. Devangana Kalita. Asif Iqbal Tanha. Gulfisha Fatima.

The prosecution's case relied heavily on WhatsApp groups, protest coordination meetings, speeches and protected witnesses claiming there had been a larger plan behind the unrest.

The central case against Umar Khalid revolved around his February 17 Amravati speech.

And here's where things get complicated in a way social media usually hates.

Because the speech was provocative. The Delhi High Court later called it “obnoxious.” It attacked the government sharply and called for protests during Trump's visit.

But the speech itself also repeatedly invoked Gandhi, civil disobedience and peaceful protest. It was public. Uploaded openly. Not some secret recording discussing weapons or attacks.

And Khalid was not physically present in northeast Delhi during the riots.

No weapons were recovered from him. No money trail linking him to violence was established. No video placed him at riot sites.

A huge amount of public perception around him also came from the 2016 JNU controversy, where videos circulated claiming he raised anti-India slogans.

But later forensic analysis found multiple clips aired by news channels had been doctored with edited audio overlays.

And yet the label stuck anyway.

That's the thing about public memory. Once somebody gets branded “anti-national,” every future accusation arrives pre-approved. The correction never travels as far as the original outrage. Human attention spans are basically goldfish with WiFi.

Then comes the UAPA part, which honestly changes the entire moral equation of the case.

Because under UAPA, getting bail becomes extraordinarily difficult.

Courts at the bail stage are not deeply testing evidence or cross-examining witnesses. They largely look at whether the prosecution story appears prima facie plausible. If yes, bail is usually denied.

Which means if the investigation drags, the accused just remains in prison.

And this investigation dragged endlessly.

Supplementary chargesheets kept coming year after year. Hearings kept getting adjourned. The prosecution delayed. The defence delayed too sometimes, which is true and should be acknowledged honestly.

But in a normal criminal case, delays happen while the accused is out on bail.

In a UAPA case, every delay means another stretch inside prison before guilt is ever proven.

That's what makes the arithmetic feel different here.

At one point the Delhi High Court granted bail to three co-accused — Natasha Narwal, Devangana Kalita and Asif Iqbal Tanha — and literally warned that the state was blurring the line between protest and terrorism.

But Umar Khalid and Sharjeel Imam stayed in jail.

And after nearly five years, the central conspiracy case still had not properly gone through a full trial.

No full examination of witnesses. No complete testing of evidence in open court. No final verdict.

Just years passing inside Tihar while arguments about adjournments, chargesheets and procedural timelines kept expanding around them like legal fog.

And hanging over all of this is one fact that never really goes away no matter which side of the debate you're on:

The people accused of organising protests were pursued using anti-terror laws.

The politicians whose speeches immediately preceded the riots were never seriously prosecuted.

That imbalance is why this case refuses to leave public debate.

The right sees FIR 59 as a legitimate conspiracy investigation into protests that escalated into organised violence.

The left sees it as a warning about how terror laws can turn into tools for indefinite incarceration while politically connected figures remain untouched.

But outside ideology, one reality still sits there uncomfortably:

Five years is an extraordinarily long time to imprison people before fully testing the evidence against them.

And the longer that gap stretches, the more the process itself starts looking like the punishment.

Not conviction.

Not acquittal.

Just suspension.

A person placed in legal limbo while the country keeps arguing over what they symbolise.

Would highly recommend going through this PDF. It contains the full case chronologically, point by point, along with sources and references compiled from material available publicly online:

https://drive.google.com/file/d/1JpXVFqAROYxIfSSkcCVoL1kNrZS5qeCB/view?usp=drivesdk

Sources referred to:

Delhi High Court Orders

https://www.barandbench.com/news/delhi-high-court-grants-interim-bail-to-umar-khalid-for-3-days-to-visit-mother-in-hospital https://www.ndtv.com/india-news/supreme-court-adjourns-hearing-on-umar-khalids-bail-petition-in-uapa-case-4360669

Supreme Court Hearings / Orders

https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/hearing-on-umar-khalids-bail-plea-in-uapa-case-adjourned/articleshow/103597557.cms https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/india/supreme-court-adjourns-hearing-on-umar-khalids-plea-seeking-bail-in-uapa-case/articleshow/103382807.cms https://www.hindustantimes.com/india-news/supreme-court-rejects-umar-khalids-review-petition-to-seek-bail-in-2020-case-101776691028909.html

Human Rights / Civil Liberties Reports

https://www.hrw.org/news/2021/03/08/india-police-failed-protect-muslims https://www.amnesty.org/en/latest/news/2020/08/india-delhi-riots-investigation-targets-government-critics/ https://www.state.gov/reports/2020-report-on-international-religious-freedom/india/ Delhi Minorities Commission Report https://archive.org/details/delhi-minorities-commission-report-2020

Media Coverage

https://thewire.in/law/umar-khalid-delhi-riots-uapa-case https://caravanmagazine.in/crime/delhi-riots-conspiracy-case-umar-khalid https://scroll.in/topic/104290/umar-khalid https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2022/10/18/india-court-denies-bail-to-activist-umar-khalid https://www.outlookindia.com/topic/umar-khalid

Legal Tracking / Analysis

https://www.scobserver.in/cases/umar-khalid-v-state-nct-delhi-delhi-riots-conspiracy-case/ https://lawchakra.in/tag/umar-khalid/


r/CriticalThinkingIndia • • Feb 03 '26 Heartwarming

Critical Analysis & Discussion Modi hain toh mumkin hain.

6 Upvotes

Our Great Savior Modi ji has done it again.

We have been given just a teaser trailer about the Indo-US trade deal thats been finalized.

The Indian govt. under visionary leadership has reached a historic deal with the United States. In the face of Trump’s temper tantrums, Prime Minister Modi ji stayed true to his vision and ensured that India’s powerful position in the world economy as a rising autonomous power was ensured. He also stayed true to India’s non alignment policy in True Modi fashion.

Here is what we will get thanks to Modi ji!

  1. India agrees to stop its purchases of Russian gas. We don’t care if the price is cheaper, after all it’s really the consumer’s problem not the government.

  2. Who cares that Russia is a staunch ally of ours when America threw us under the bus. With Modi ji leading us everything is possible!

  3. Modi ji has magnificently calmed down Trumps temper tantrums and the US has dropped its tariffs on Indian goods from 500, 50, 25% (who even knows) to 18%! Amazing!! In return India has agreed to reduce the Tariffs and Non Tariff barriers on the US to 0%! Amazing job again sir!

  4. Following up this amazing job, Modi ji has agreed to import more than $500 billion worth US energy (technically Venezuelan), coal, technology and agricultural products. Modi ji had said he would never compromise the interests of Indian farmers and started a trade war but that was then, this is now. Let’s Make in India by importing everything from abroad!

This is such a great achievement by the hard working Government under our visionary PM. I can only wait with baited breath what he will do next!

Modi ji wah wah!

Ra Ga ghar ja!

https://www.hindustantimes.com/india-news/india-us-talks-live-updates-donald-trump-pm-modi-phone-call-trade-deal-tariffs-sergio-gor-latest-news-101770048581326.html


r/CriticalThinkingIndia • • Oct 12 '26

Ask CTI Himanta Biswa Sarma issues an open challenge to Rahul Gandhi and the Congress to resign from their seats and hold a re-election.

0 Upvotes

Political rhetoric is at an all-time high as Assam CM Himanta Biswa Sarma and opposition leaders trade challenges of resignations and re-elections. But beneath the drama lies a fundamental question of democratic credibility.

Opposition handles demand CJI resignations after CJI Surya Kant refused informal memoranda, asking them instead to follow due legal process. Meanwhile, despite claiming to have "mountains of evidence" regarding election irregularities, no formal Writ Petition has been presented in court.

  • If re-elections were granted today, would the opposition stand by the outcome, or would a loss simply restart the "vote theft" narrative?

  • Why focus on street marches and social media trends rather than submitting evidence under oath in the Supreme Court?

  • Is the opposition genuinely ready for a 1v1 test of popular support in battlegrounds like UP?

please do not do it cell, do that, why not this or that, stick to the topic/


r/CriticalThinkingIndia • • May 28 '25

Ask and Think India🤔 He will pay more than the annual subscription.

Post image
0 Upvotes

Many people argue it's unfair for ANI to charge creators hefty amounts for a 9-second clip, and I agree with you all. However, it's not for the internet crowd to decide how corporations build their business models.


r/CriticalThinkingIndia • • Jul 05 '25

Religion, Faith, Value System The reason India is a democracy is because of secularism not Hinduism

0 Upvotes

If Hinduism was so compatible with democracy then why the hell are there so Hidnu kings in the history of India but nowhere near the number of Democractic states?

The reason why India is a democracy is because its religions were kept tied up and not able to influence the working of the government. It is the secular nature of the constitution that allows India to be a democracy not some Hindu value.

Just look at Nepal. It was literally a "hindu rastra". And it only became a democratic state after 2006 and even though their are protests to try and bring back the monarchy. If hinduism is inherently democratic then why did it take until 2006 for their to be a democracy in Nepal?

Even last year when BJP lost its majority their Hindu supporters started talking about how modi needs to become a dictator.

Islamic countries used to be more liberal and secular and democratic like in Iran until USA overthrew their leaders.

All religion are the same at their core. It is the people that are different. There is nothing inherent about Hinduism or any other religion that makes it good or bad for democracy.


r/CriticalThinkingIndia • • Oct 09 '26

News & Current Affairs Inframe: Dhruv Rathee confirms he will join tomorrow’s Delhi protest, (Quick question can he get arrest because he is basically german citizen)

0 Upvotes

r/CriticalThinkingIndia • • Sep 05 '25

Ask CTI Faith for me, fraud for thee?

0 Upvotes

Funny how the rules change depending on who’s holding the mic. When we spread our faith, it’s celebrated as Sanatana Dharma expanding. But the moment someone else spreads theirs, suddenly it’s “rice bag conversion” or “forced mulla.” How does that not scream hypocrisy at the highest order?

If spreading religion is noble for us, why is it dirty when they do it? And if it’s dirty when they do it, why should we get a free pass? You can’t have it both ways, either spreading faith is everyone’s right, or it’s nobody’s. Anything else is just plain double standards dressed up as morality.


r/CriticalThinkingIndia • • Sep 12 '26

News & Current Affairs Since the right wing now is quoting BBC articles for an anti-congress narrative, going forward BBC can be considered a valid source right?

2 Upvotes

The right wing has been pushing the narrative recently, with the BRICS conference ongoing now, that India was so bad in 2013 that it was considered to be replaced by Indonesia

Their source? This article by the BBC - https://www.bbc.com/news/business-21921593

Now, anyone can have an opinion, and that’s fair enough, but the right wing in India has been claiming for several years that the BBC is an extremely biased and anti-Indian organisation, spreading western and foreign propaganda in an attempt to malign India’s image. Yet, in this case, it seems that such an attempt to spread an anti-India narrative was perfectly acceptable

One would almost think that the right wing doesn’t actually care about the BBC being anti-India, just it being anti-BJP ( sarcasm, for the usual suspects whose heads this will fly over )

If the right wing had actually bothered to open and read the article they’re spreading ( hilarious, I know ), they would realize it’s a completely nonsensical opinion piece. There’s no actual criticism of the Indian economy there, and no one who voices the opinion that India should be replaced

> "The government has had a lot of political dramas, with corruption scandals unfolding over the last few years, and opposition parties stalling economic reform at every juncture," he says.
"But fundamentally, India's economy is still stable, its medium-term growth drivers are intact. Some policy momentum is visible these days."

> "But replacing India doesn't make sense from any perspective. It's the first year in the last 15 years that Indonesia's real GDP grew faster than India. There's a dynamism in the Indian economy - in manufacturing, agriculture, services - that just isn't there in Indonesia."

My advise to the BJP - fire your new IT cell guy, he’s an idiot. But hey maybe it doesn’t matter because so is the intended audience


r/CriticalThinkingIndia • • Feb 07 '26

Critical Analysis & Discussion I vote BJP, but I want a strong opposition — here’s what I think they’re getting wrong.

0 Upvotes

I’m a BJP voter, but before anyone jumps to conclusions: I don’t want a weak or broken opposition. A healthy democracy needs pressure, debate, and real alternatives. One-party dominance might feel comfortable in the short term, but it’s bad in the long run.

As a voter, here’s what I wish the opposition (especially Congress + allies) would seriously rethink:

1. Stop being “anti-BJP” and start being “pro-governance”
Most opposition messaging sounds like outrage without substance. Criticism is important, but where is the clear alternative vision? What exactly would you do differently on economy, infra, defense, welfare, tech, jobs?

2. Leadership clarity matters
Whether people like Modi or not, BJP offers a clear leadership face. The opposition feels confused — too many power centers, too much internal politics, no single accountable leader. Voters don’t trust chaos.

3. Merit > dynasty (this really matters to young voters)
You can’t keep talking about equality, opportunity, and fairness while leadership looks inherited. Promote leaders who’ve built credibility on the ground — CMs, MPs, administrators — not just surnames.

4. Ground connect > Twitter activism
Online outrage doesn’t win elections. BJP’s strength is booth-level work, local presence, and constant voter contact. Opposition still feels elite, urban, and disconnected from daily realities.

5. National interest issues need maturity
On defense, foreign policy, internal security — knee-jerk opposition hurts credibility. Critique failures, yes, but avoid sounding like you’re rooting against the country just to score points.

6. Be selective, not reactionary
Every issue doesn’t need a protest or press conference. Pick battles that actually affect people’s lives: inflation, jobs, education quality, healthcare delivery, local corruption.

7. Regional parties shouldn’t just unite to “defeat BJP”
Coalitions formed only around hate for one party don’t last. If there’s an alliance, it should be based on a minimum common program, not just seat-sharing math.

8. Respect voters’ intelligence
Labelling voters as “misled”, “brainwashed”, or “uneducated” is political suicide. People vote for BJP for multiple reasons — welfare delivery, leadership perception, stability. Acknowledge that reality first.

I’ll probably still vote BJP unless the opposition genuinely improves — but I want them to improve. Strong opposition makes governments better, more accountable, and less arrogant.

Curious to hear thoughts from others — BJP supporters, opposition voters, and fence-sitters alike.


r/CriticalThinkingIndia • • Sep 16 '26 Regret Bravo

Law, Rights & Society 3 Weeks’ Bail After a Physical Assault and open confession; 6 Years Without Bail for Khalid and Imam in a Speech-and-Conspiracy Case with no proven acts of violence.

Post image
173 Upvotes

As far as I understand the two cases are somewhat different. Bhardwaj was charged with a bailable offence (although the SC/ST act is non-bailable) but his lawyer argued that the SC/ST act was for "political reasons" and somehow the court just accepted that.

Khalid and Imam made political speeches and were charged with UAPA along with other charges. UAPA is a special law which requires only prima facie "connection" with some crimes - which could be completely unrelated - and the court may be satisfied without any actual proof of crimes. Unlawful Assembly and Preventive Detention are not this routine in most democracies. In India, it is used at an alarming rate against government critics - which is the argument which Bhardwaj's defense counsel actually made for SC/ST act.

I will leave it up to the good people of this sub to provide well-researched legal and political commentary. Will not tolerate low effort post about what Khalid or Imam appeared to have said in doctored videos which were inadmissible in court. They have published books and articles - read them up.

Look up the two cases and let's have a sane discussion in a wonderful democratic sub. Let's go.

Case 1: https://www.livelaw.in/news-updates/delhi-court-grants-3-weeks-interim-bail-to-swatantra-bhardwaj-in-cjp-protester-assault-case-550115

Cases 2 and 3:
Link a: https://www.livelaw.in/top-stories/umar-khalid-sharjeel-imam-bail-denied-delhi-riots-uapa-539937

Link b: https://www.livelaw.in/news-updates/delhi-court-umar-khalid-sharjeel-imam-bail-539919

Edits with some data:

UAPA: NCRB's official court-disposal measure states that conviction rate was 46.6% of completed trials in 2023, but 92.9% of UAPA cases before courts were still pending. If instead you compare persons convicted with persons arrested in the same calendar year, the figure was 4.05% in 2023, and approximately 3.21% across 2019–23. The Supreme Court relied on the latter series in Andrabi in 2026. Source: https://data.opencity.in/dataset/40449a25-7fb3-4e38-91b9-f834af6078e2/resource/7ac7f9fc-7567-4c5d-8a24-9777b9f47519/download/cb95d6e0-f96a-41df-80c0-92ab2fbd74f5.pdf?utm_source=chatgpt.com

Sedition (§124A IPC): Across the NCRB's 2014–2023 completed-trial figures, there were approximately 8 convictions from 88 completed trials, or 9.1%. There were no convictions recorded among completed sedition trials in 2021, 2022 or 2023. But §124A was put substantially in abeyance by the Supreme Court in 2022 and ceased to be part of the IPC/BNS framework when the new criminal code took effect in 2024. Source: https://staging.opencity.in/dataset/9b250d95-7d93-4ccf-93f2-124b3c356ebc/resource/1f56c6c1-70dc-4ecc-9b18-e5b83e77f5c3/download/f8e60e94-9226-4c9e-bd30-3a5692adca02.pdf?utm_source=chatgpt.com


r/CriticalThinkingIndia • • Oct 21 '25

Nature & Environment 95-99% of NCR pollution is local. AQI shot up from 300 to 1800 at places after Diwali. But who gets blame as scapegoats? Farmers, because they can't buy media like government to shift blame away from Diwali.

Post image
3 Upvotes

r/CriticalThinkingIndia • • Jan 03 '26

Geopolitics & Governance This is what real Super Power looks like...

30 Upvotes

I always find it so cool about Americans and it's only them nobody else in the world does this. Peak display of absolute unapologetic behaviour. Even when they fuck up they own it. Ofcourse they can afford to do this afterall they are a superpower but it's a psychological thing as well.

They have always been like this since the birth of their country. Always unapologetic, ruthless and precise. Yes, sometimes they end up in really bad situations but if you notice it's often by their own miscalculations rather than someone else being able to outpower them.

One day they can preach about sovereignty to the whole world and the next day go on to bomb nuclear sites in Iran. Pick up the dictator of a country in less that 2 hours. This is a flex man 😭

China so badly wants to invade Taiwan but they are shit scared. Imagine a small island right in front of their mainland and they can't touch it because of a country that is on the other end of the Pacific Ocean. On the other hand this is what US does on a regular basis without any resistance.

Only Russia can do something like the Ukraine invasion and even that has become a pain in the ass for Putun or maybe he wants this to go on forever. But still the war is on their border.

And here in India people started crying during op sindoor as to why are we doing this. We don't want war... Brother wake up and smell the coffee. This is how superpower behave. They use their military might, it's not just there for 26 jan parade.

Obviously we can't be US but why not use it in our local influence area. Specially for pakistan, who keeps on attacking us. When people say this the most common rebuttal is that then why not against china? I think we have shown in recent time that we are ready for a fight even with China. The doklam standoff and in the galwan clash.


r/CriticalThinkingIndia • • Jan 27 '26

Miscellaneous When Dalits face brutal discrimination, beaten to death, humiliated, forced to drink urine, or denied entry into temples these people stay completely silent, but the moment even one law comes in favor of Dalits, they lose their minds.

345 Upvotes

r/CriticalThinkingIndia • • May 19 '26

Critical Analysis & Discussion Dont get deflected.....Please read the entire post before forming opinion

Post image
121 Upvotes

People keep saying Modi was fully justified in ignoring Norwegian journalist Helle Lyng because an Indian PM doesn’t owe answers to foreign media.

And honestly, taken in isolation, that argument is fair. Accountability should primarily come from Indian citizens and Indian journalists.

But that’s exactly why this incident became a story in the first place.

If Modi regularly held open press conferences in India and answered unscripted questions from Indian reporters, then a foreign journalist being ignored in Norway would’ve been meaningless. Nobody would’ve cared.

The issue is that this pattern exists everywhere.

Twelve years as Prime Minister and still no proper unscripted press conferences. So when he walks away from a journalist abroad, it doesn’t come across as strength or sovereignty. It just looks like continuity.

Meanwhile, Norwegian PM Jonas Gahr Støre finished the joint statement and casually returned to speak with reporters. That’s simply normal democratic behavior.

Some people brought up the Epstein comparison, saying Indian journalists could similarly corner European leaders about uncomfortable subjects. Fair point. Many leaders probably would avoid those questions too.

But that doesn’t make avoidance admirable. “Other politicians also dodge scrutiny” isn’t much of a defense. It just lowers the standard for everyone.

Then came the conspiracy theories around Helle Lyng herself. Apparently she criticised Trump, wrote positively about Chinese EV companies like BYD, referred to China as a superpower, and discussed labour issues, therefore she must somehow be connected to the CCP.

But none of this is remotely unusual for a Scandinavian journalist.

Criticising Trump is mainstream across much of Europe. Calling China a superpower is just acknowledging reality. Writing about BYD outperforming Tesla is business reporting, not espionage. And labour rights are a central political issue in Nordic countries. People are acting like they uncovered an international intelligence operation because a journalist wrote about electric cars. Civilization truly is held together by tape and caffeine.

And even if someone believes all of those theories, the supposed “operation” still makes no sense. She shouted a single question while Modi was leaving the room. That required no elaborate coordination. Any journalist present could have done the same thing.

What the conspiracy narrative really does is shift attention away from the actual issue: why does the PM consistently avoid unscripted questioning altogether?

The same thing happened when Sabrina Siddiqui questioned Modi during the Biden visit. Instead of discussing the question itself, large sections of the discourse became focused on attacking the journalist personally.

That’s the larger pattern here.

The outrage repeatedly becomes the existence of uncomfortable questions rather than the absence of answers.

And that’s not confidence. It’s the opposite.

For people unfamiliar with the context: Modi is currently on a five-nation tour. During his Norway visit, he and Norwegian PM Jonas Gahr Støre delivered joint media statements. There was no Q&A session afterward. Støre later returned to interact with journalists. Modi left the venue, and as he was walking out, Norwegian journalist Helle Lyng called out: “Prime Minister Modi, why don’t you take questions from the freest press in the world?” Modi did not respond and continued walking. Lyng later clarified that she never actually expected him to answer.


r/CriticalThinkingIndia • • Jul 06 '25

Dharma - That Which Is Righteous Organized propaganda being spread by communists and Islamists nexus

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

This is clearly the work organized propaganda.


r/CriticalThinkingIndia • • Jan 31 '26

Critical Analysis & Discussion PM Narendra Modi in Epstein Files | United States Department of Justice

7 Upvotes

The idea that an Indian Prime Minister would “dance and sing” to please another country sends the wrong message. India is a proud, sovereign nation, not a stage where its leader performs to win applause from foreign powers. Our prime minister’s job is to stand tall for India’s interests, not to look like a dancer who’s there to seduce his foreign counterparts.

  1. How are we supposed to defend our leaders when they want to be treated like courtesans of the American Supremo?

  2. Do you think the government should offer a clarification instead of trying to bury it like it always happens?


r/CriticalThinkingIndia • • 25d ago Bravo

Critical Analysis & Discussion Neha Bora reply to her viral video

1 Upvotes

From her Instagram: For regressive forces like the RSS-BJP solidarity beyond communalism is an incomprehensible concept, hence, they've now resorted once again to the old tactic of circulating doctored videos and manufacturing outrage around it.

A video of mine is being circulated out of context by the Sangh IT Cell as me extending solidarity to regressive forces in Bangladesh, ironically by the most regressive communalists of our own country.

We stand with the oppressed fighting for democracy, human rights and against religious fundamentalism.

You attack us with lies because you are afraid of our movement for voter rights and democracy. You fear that the people of the country know the truth about SIR, Gyanesh Kumar and how you use both to disenfranchise 13 crore people!


r/CriticalThinkingIndia • • Sep 03 '26

Business & Economy The "2.6% real growth rate" claim: a hilarious demonstration of economic ignorance on National TV.

8 Upvotes

Error #1: Take a nominal GDP number from the old series and compare it with a nominal GDP number from the new series.Divide one by the other and proclaim 2.6% "growth."That is comparing apples with oranges.

Fact: When GDP series are revised, historical numbers are re-estimated using the same methodology to ensure an apples-to-apples comparison. Such an ECON 101 error!

Error #2: Use nominal GDP arithmetic to challenge a real GDP growth rate of 7.8%, while ignoring double deflation, a globally accepted methodology that India now adopts, and the actual constant-price estimates.

Error #3: Treat routine revisions, based on improved data and methodology, as "manipulation." Historical estimates are revised precisely because new data arrive and better information becomes available.

Such revisions happen routinely, including when the person making this claim was in Government.

Error #4: Claim consumption growth was negative by committing the same errors, when official data show real private consumption grew 7.1%.

The 2.6% number is not the growth rate under the old GDP series. It is not the growth rate under the new GDP series either. It is simply the percentage change obtained by dividing a number from one statistical system by a number from another statistical system.

Think of a company switching from Indian GAAP to US GAAP. Suppose last year's profit was reported as ₹100 under Indian GAAP. When the same underlying transactions are restated under US GAAP, the comparable number becomes ₹90.

That does not mean the company somehow became ₹10 less profitable last year. You cannot go back in time and change what happened. The same economic activity occurred. Only the accounting framework used to measure it has changed.

Now suppose this year's profit, measured under US GAAP, is ₹100.

What is the correct growth rate?

₹100 compared with ₹90: 11.1%.

But suppose someone compares this year's ₹100 under US GAAP with last year's ₹100 under Indian GAAP and declares growth to be zero.

What has he calculated?

Not growth under Indian GAAP. Not growth under US GAAP. Just a meaningless percentage obtained by comparing numbers produced under two different accounting systems.

That is precisely the conceptual error behind the 2.6% claim.

And for an even simpler example: suppose last year your weight was recorded as 100 pounds and this year, after changing the measurement system, it is recorded as 45 kilograms. Dividing 45 by 100 does not tell you that you lost 55% of your weight.

The same principle applies here. You cannot calculate GDP growth by comparing apples and oranges: GDP estimates produced under two different statistical series.


r/CriticalThinkingIndia • • Jul 31 '26

Ask CTI We are celebrating 29 billion in smartphone exports despite placing 176th in the environment index. Our priorities are in the dustbin

0 Upvotes

.Just scrolling through the news stream today and the difference is truly crazy. One side we have people cheering about how manufactured in India phones are going worldwide and we are hitting tremendous export statistics. And then there is the environmental performance index putting us at 176 out of 177 countries. And Assam is almost flooding again with 75 dead so far. It’s almost like we as a country have agreed that development solely means GDP figures and IT exports. When the world rankings come out and we are near the bottom in pollution or health care, we get so protective and it's automatically foreign propaganda. But then you step outside and choke on the air or watch entire states go underwater every single monsoon because of zero city planning and proper drainage.

A growing economy means nothing if the basic quality of life is this bad. We are generating wealth but living in a toxic wasteland still I really don't get why citizens are not holding local leaders accountable for clean air and water instead of arguing over which political party gave a better speech in parliament. When did we just accept this trade off man? Is this the India we want?


r/CriticalThinkingIndia • • Aug 20 '26

Miscellaneous I m done with these clown twitter right wing idiots.

0 Upvotes

First off! I m a nationalist and I used to like BJP simply because of that and infra pushed they used to do. But these shit fuckers that rise of BJP has given limelight to is now making my blood boil.

It is the idiotic IT cells of the right wing that keeps abusing muslims for being disloyal and anti national to this nation. And then when they make an effort and join the army, you have these mfs saying their dad is looking like a terrorist. These kids of dimwit who sit at home with oppo/redmi phones in hand peddling hatred have the audacity to comment on family of a soilder who is about to fight for this nation? No its not funny.

I always hear a lot of defence analyst talk about the 2.5 war front where the 0.5 is present in our country. These assholes that destroy the fabric of Indian society are part of that 0.5.


r/CriticalThinkingIndia • • Sep 05 '25

History & Culture Science gives us wings, dharma shows us where to fly.

Post image
0 Upvotes

Only in India will you see the perfect union of ancient wisdom and cutting edge science. This photo says it all, the Agni-V missile, one of the most advanced strategic weapons in the world, being blessed through a traditional puja before its induction.

Far from being a contradiction, this is India’s strength. A civilisation that has nurtured spirituality, rituals and dharma for thousands of years is also producing world class technology, space missions and defense systems. Science gives us the power, culture gives us direction.

This is what makes India unique. We don’t need to abandon our roots to move forward. Our traditions aren’t a burden, they are the foundation on which we build the future. Every prayer, every ritual, every chant reflects the belief that human effort is strongest when it’s aligned with higher values.

Welcome to India, where missiles are blessed before launch, rockets are prayed over before takeoff and science is never seen in isolation from culture. A country armed with knowledge, guided by dharma and rooted in timeless civilization.