Spent the last few days reading through FIR 59, court orders, witness statements, speeches, timelines, forensic reports, all of it. And after a point the thing that stays with you is not even the conspiracy theory itself.
It's the imbalance.
Because look at how this story actually starts.
In December 2019, Parliament passes the Citizenship Amendment Act. Supporters call it a humanitarian law for persecuted minorities from neighbouring countries. Critics argue it fundamentally changes the idea of Indian citizenship by explicitly excluding Muslims.
The protests that follow are massive. Shaheen Bagh becomes the symbol of it all: Muslim women sitting through winter nights for months, blocking a road in protest. Universities across the country join in.
And then the political rhetoric starts getting uglier.
Anurag Thakur leads crowds in chanting “goli maaro saalon ko.” Parvesh Verma says Shaheen Bagh protesters will enter homes and rape women. Kapil Mishra repeatedly frames the protests as a threat building inside the capital.
None of them are prosecuted.
Then comes February 23, 2020.
Anti-CAA protesters block a road near Jaffrabad Metro Station. Kapil Mishra arrives at Maujpur Chowk alongside a Delhi Police DCP and gives the speech that basically becomes the defining image of the riots:
“We will remain peaceful till Trump leaves. But after that, if the roads are not cleared, we will take to the streets ourselves.”
According to police records themselves, stone-pelting begins shortly after.
What follows over the next six days is the worst communal violence Delhi has seen since 1984.
53 people die.
Most of them are Muslim.
Muslim homes, shops and mosques are burned across northeast Delhi. Videos emerge of mobs checking names and religion before attacking people. Human Rights Watch, Amnesty International and the Delhi Minorities Commission later document the same broad pattern: the violence was deeply asymmetric and Muslim localities bore the brunt of it.
There were Hindu victims too, and pretending otherwise would be dishonest. Vinod Kumar, a Hindu man, was reportedly killed after rioters spotted a “Jai Shri Ram” sticker on his motorcycle. Fear spread on both sides.
But the larger pattern remained obvious enough that multiple independent reports said it openly.
Then there were the police allegations.
Videos surfaced of officers beating injured Muslim men lying on the road and forcing them to sing the national anthem. Witnesses described police standing alongside mobs or refusing to respond to calls for help. Complaints against BJP leaders largely went nowhere.
And then came FIR 59.
This is where the entire thing changes shape.
Because instead of mainly pursuing the people visibly carrying weapons or leading mobs during the riots, Delhi Police built a much larger conspiracy case under UAPA, India's anti-terror law.
The theory was that the riots were not spontaneous at all, but part of a coordinated conspiracy by anti-CAA activists designed to embarrass the government during Donald Trump's India visit.
And the people who became the centre of that conspiracy case were not politicians.
They were protest organisers.
Students. Activists. Academics.
Umar Khalid. Sharjeel Imam. Natasha Narwal. Devangana Kalita. Asif Iqbal Tanha. Gulfisha Fatima.
The prosecution's case relied heavily on WhatsApp groups, protest coordination meetings, speeches and protected witnesses claiming there had been a larger plan behind the unrest.
The central case against Umar Khalid revolved around his February 17 Amravati speech.
And here's where things get complicated in a way social media usually hates.
Because the speech was provocative. The Delhi High Court later called it “obnoxious.” It attacked the government sharply and called for protests during Trump's visit.
But the speech itself also repeatedly invoked Gandhi, civil disobedience and peaceful protest. It was public. Uploaded openly. Not some secret recording discussing weapons or attacks.
And Khalid was not physically present in northeast Delhi during the riots.
No weapons were recovered from him. No money trail linking him to violence was established. No video placed him at riot sites.
A huge amount of public perception around him also came from the 2016 JNU controversy, where videos circulated claiming he raised anti-India slogans.
But later forensic analysis found multiple clips aired by news channels had been doctored with edited audio overlays.
And yet the label stuck anyway.
That's the thing about public memory. Once somebody gets branded “anti-national,” every future accusation arrives pre-approved. The correction never travels as far as the original outrage. Human attention spans are basically goldfish with WiFi.
Then comes the UAPA part, which honestly changes the entire moral equation of the case.
Because under UAPA, getting bail becomes extraordinarily difficult.
Courts at the bail stage are not deeply testing evidence or cross-examining witnesses. They largely look at whether the prosecution story appears prima facie plausible. If yes, bail is usually denied.
Which means if the investigation drags, the accused just remains in prison.
And this investigation dragged endlessly.
Supplementary chargesheets kept coming year after year. Hearings kept getting adjourned. The prosecution delayed. The defence delayed too sometimes, which is true and should be acknowledged honestly.
But in a normal criminal case, delays happen while the accused is out on bail.
In a UAPA case, every delay means another stretch inside prison before guilt is ever proven.
That's what makes the arithmetic feel different here.
At one point the Delhi High Court granted bail to three co-accused — Natasha Narwal, Devangana Kalita and Asif Iqbal Tanha — and literally warned that the state was blurring the line between protest and terrorism.
But Umar Khalid and Sharjeel Imam stayed in jail.
And after nearly five years, the central conspiracy case still had not properly gone through a full trial.
No full examination of witnesses. No complete testing of evidence in open court. No final verdict.
Just years passing inside Tihar while arguments about adjournments, chargesheets and procedural timelines kept expanding around them like legal fog.
And hanging over all of this is one fact that never really goes away no matter which side of the debate you're on:
The people accused of organising protests were pursued using anti-terror laws.
The politicians whose speeches immediately preceded the riots were never seriously prosecuted.
That imbalance is why this case refuses to leave public debate.
The right sees FIR 59 as a legitimate conspiracy investigation into protests that escalated into organised violence.
The left sees it as a warning about how terror laws can turn into tools for indefinite incarceration while politically connected figures remain untouched.
But outside ideology, one reality still sits there uncomfortably:
Five years is an extraordinarily long time to imprison people before fully testing the evidence against them.
And the longer that gap stretches, the more the process itself starts looking like the punishment.
Not conviction.
Not acquittal.
Just suspension.
A person placed in legal limbo while the country keeps arguing over what they symbolise.
Would highly recommend going through this PDF. It contains the full case chronologically, point by point, along with sources and references compiled from material available publicly online:
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1JpXVFqAROYxIfSSkcCVoL1kNrZS5qeCB/view?usp=drivesdk
Sources referred to:
Delhi High Court Orders
https://www.barandbench.com/news/delhi-high-court-grants-interim-bail-to-umar-khalid-for-3-days-to-visit-mother-in-hospital https://www.ndtv.com/india-news/supreme-court-adjourns-hearing-on-umar-khalids-bail-petition-in-uapa-case-4360669
Supreme Court Hearings / Orders
https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/hearing-on-umar-khalids-bail-plea-in-uapa-case-adjourned/articleshow/103597557.cms https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/india/supreme-court-adjourns-hearing-on-umar-khalids-plea-seeking-bail-in-uapa-case/articleshow/103382807.cms https://www.hindustantimes.com/india-news/supreme-court-rejects-umar-khalids-review-petition-to-seek-bail-in-2020-case-101776691028909.html
Human Rights / Civil Liberties Reports
https://www.hrw.org/news/2021/03/08/india-police-failed-protect-muslims https://www.amnesty.org/en/latest/news/2020/08/india-delhi-riots-investigation-targets-government-critics/ https://www.state.gov/reports/2020-report-on-international-religious-freedom/india/ Delhi Minorities Commission Report https://archive.org/details/delhi-minorities-commission-report-2020
Media Coverage
https://thewire.in/law/umar-khalid-delhi-riots-uapa-case https://caravanmagazine.in/crime/delhi-riots-conspiracy-case-umar-khalid https://scroll.in/topic/104290/umar-khalid https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2022/10/18/india-court-denies-bail-to-activist-umar-khalid https://www.outlookindia.com/topic/umar-khalid
Legal Tracking / Analysis
https://www.scobserver.in/cases/umar-khalid-v-state-nct-delhi-delhi-riots-conspiracy-case/ https://lawchakra.in/tag/umar-khalid/