r/ContraPoints • • 9h ago

Contrapoints book club

28 Upvotes

A lot of Contrapoints videos reference interesting books. I thought I'd make a list of ones I've read because of her:

  • Fierce: The History Of Leopard Print

  • Sexual Personae: Art and Decadence from Nefertiti to Emily Dickinson

  • Class: a guide through the American status system

What are some books you've read because of her? What were your thoughts on them? I want more perspectives.

Above is the post topic. Below, as a post primer, are my personal thoughts for each.

  • I liked "Fierce: The History Of Leopard Print". I feel like the Opulence video undersold how informative and interesting this book is. It's actually one of my favorite humanities books.

  • "Class" is indeed funny. But I feel like it loses something to an american audience. You know how in a sci-fi film, part of the experience of an alien language is needing the subtitles? Pre-existing comprehension robs this book of a little of of the shock value.

  • Regarding "Sexual Personae", I actually liked it. I also have thoughts and comments.

    • Natalie is right about Paglia having coke fiend energy, because every page feels like a line was snorted about 30 minutes ago prior to Paglia writing it.

    • That said, maybe it's the audiobook version I bought, but this works MUCH better in print form.

    • Natalie is very right to contrast this book to the Beauvoir / Butler branch of gender theory, but I feel like there's more to it than the point she brought up about the contrasting points of "Discourse constructs the sexed body." vs. "The sexed body constructs discourse.". I get that Paglia has been in a flop era for a while, but there are some ideas that she is adjacent to that I thought warranted discussion:

      • The Beauvoir / Butler lineage is much more focused on conflicts between gender, discrimination, the toxic intersection between gender and race, etc. These are all real social problems that we should work to address, even though it's a pipe dream. That said, in the pipe dream where gender discrimination and sexism are wiped out, both classifications will, presumably, still exist. Paglia kind of provides a look at what gender could be in that pipe dream world. Paglia does use a classification system of gender, such as men being associated with architecture and certain kinds of religion and women with nature and boobs. But Paglia also points out that these roles can be crossed. I see Paglia's writing as less "saying no to a broken and torturous system" and more "saying yes to what we like about men and saying yes to what we like about women". If you've ever read Butler's work, well, it's very dry (Laganja Estranja voice: "kinda like your vajoina"). Paglia's writing has a passion that Butler's just doesn't. Maybe it's because Paglia has the coke fiend energy that Natalie mentioned, but I think there's more to it. I think it's because Butler hates sexism and discrimination, so their work is very analytical; but Paglia seems to like men and like women and want a better acceptance of our own nature and passion for both, so the result is the passion about saying yes.

      • In the Twilight video, Natalie discussed the difference between Erotica, Romance, and Porn. Natalie pointed out that it's basically only marketing driven; in that Romance is for good girls, Erotica is for sluts, and Porn is for men. In Sexual Personae, Paglia does not have a distinction between the 3. All are labeled as porn and all are celebrated as porn. I think Paglia is onto something here, because in this worldview, although one can still be prudish, an artificial classification built on sexism is basically eliminated. Followers of the Beauvoir / Butler lineage of gender theory already understand to ask "Who benefits when we classify people based on this system", so we should also understand to ask "Who benefits when we classify media under this system?".

      • Paglia describes what she calls "mental transsexualism" among great artists, with the concept that you need an understanding of different sexes other than your own in order to portray them. This might sound a little odd to some people, but we've all heard "she breasted boobily", so Paglia at least has a point here. That said, I think Paglia is underselling this concept to restrict this to art. Shouldn't empathy itself be able to handle the reality that other people can be different? Should civilization therefore be built on this? Isn't the whole point of heterosexuality that your partner is different, and therefore, doesn't healthy heterosexually require the appreciation of the view of someone different from you in a fundamental way?

Also, I'm just now realizing those titles all have colons in them.


r/ContraPoints • • 1d ago

Thinking about pronoun circle gate after someone said he’s suspicious of any queer or GNC person without pronouns in their bio

52 Upvotes

Like I guess I’ve found out some people use pronouns in bio as a litmus test on whether or not someone is a good person and this person seemed to be putting even more weight on if someone is gender non conforming or queer and putting pronouns in bio. He says he assumes they’re transphobic. Then saying it’s so hard and annoying if they accidentally misgender them if they haven’t made their gender clear. Think there’s an issue where people make rules on what’s right and wrong without empathy and saw that a lot when Natalie got cancelled over saying how she feels about pronoun circles

I said some people don’t wanna put an extra target on themselves and potentially out themselves to everyone online. Some people are just questioning and wanna do that privately. He then insisted it doesn’t do that, so I said ‘if I put they in my bio, it will out me’.
He then said I’m making something about myself that isn’t about me and me putting they them in my bio isn’t as much of a target on me as a non passing trans man. Just making it a game of oppression olympics that’s tbh more offensive than people without pronouns in bio, which includes a few trans people I know


r/ContraPoints • • 5d ago

I really hate the kind of bitterness that letting go of your emotional reliance on queer/leftist online spaces for community creates in you, after you realize it's unsustainable and always has been

121 Upvotes

it's just an experience I've seen her talk about a lot, that kinda hit close to home (sorry if I'm bad at formulating sentences)


r/ContraPoints • • 6d ago

It’s Meow vs Woof

Post image
666 Upvotes

r/ContraPoints • • 6d ago

ADHD problems (?)

Post image
579 Upvotes

r/ContraPoints • • 7d ago

For once people chose puppies for everyone

Post image
881 Upvotes

r/ContraPoints • • 7d ago

We're they trolling him with those questions

Post image
85 Upvotes

r/ContraPoints • • 6d ago

”Bernie Sanders and Zohran Mamdani are effectively social democrats”

0 Upvotes

This statement was made by ContraPoints from the liberalism tangent, and I think calling Mamdani and Sanders “effectively social democrats” blurs ideological distinction and also minimizes what socialism actually means.

Socialists can obviously support reforms that social democrats also support: universal healthcare, stronger unions, public housing, higher wages, etc. But sharing policies doesn’t mean sharing the same political goal.

Democratic socialists sees those reforms as steps toward fundamentally changing ownership and power in the economy, rather than simply making capitalism more humane.

That’s why I think “effectively a social democrat” is a misleading way to describe someone who explicitly identifies as a democratic socialist. It takes the parts of socialism that are already acceptable within liberal politics and uses them to define the entire ideology, while leaving out the more fundamental socialist goal.

And the same logic raises a consistency problem with Hasan Piker. He identifies as a democratic socialist and has supported candidates like Zohran Mamdani, who is a member of Democratic Socialists of America, and Bernie Sanders, who describes himself as a socialist.

If supporting social-democratic reforms makes Mamdani and Sanders “effectively social democrats,” then why wouldn’t the same reasoning apply to Hasan? If it doesn’t, then what is the actual distinction?

I also think this framing has the effect of minimizing socialism by essentially translating it into something liberals already recognize: a stronger welfare state within capitalism. Whether that’s intentional or not, the result is that the specifically socialist part of democratic socialism gets minimized.

By simply saying “they’re effectively social democrats” because they support reforms that social democrats also support doesn’t really engage with their stated socialist goals. It just re-labels them in a way that makes those goals easier to dismiss or overlook.


r/ContraPoints • • 9d ago

Is it stoicism, inner peace, or depression? Scholars remain divided

Post image
465 Upvotes

r/ContraPoints • • 9d ago

trying to find the video about trans women on 4chan

19 Upvotes

edit: found! it was the incels video, 22:40 timestamp

hello, i'm completely new here. i remember watching contrapoint's video where she talked about trans women on 4chan and how miserable the community there was. i'm unsure if it was a segment in a different video or if it was the sole topic of it, i can't find it at all. was it deleted? did i dream of it?


r/ContraPoints • • 11d ago Regret

Has there there been any discussion on how "millennial cringe" is 90% getting mad a women for doing a little dance or silly voice?

100 Upvotes

Just search millenial cringe on YouTube and it's like the same few women who dared to be a little silly.


r/ContraPoints • • 11d ago

God I miss her 8 hours long elder scrolls streams 😭

Post image
479 Upvotes

r/ContraPoints • • 12d ago

Sad small violin noises

Post image
1.6k Upvotes

r/ContraPoints • • 11d ago

I think the perspective offered by Natalie in her most recent tangent was massively skewed & distorted by utterly unrepresentative social media actors. Tonight's data reveals Democratic Socialist voters actually are the most staunch Dem supporters in the entire country

Thumbnail
gallery
167 Upvotes

The 2024 Exit Polls didn't ask about socialism so maybe things have changed, but this data is simply incontestable. Like even LGBT+ voters & Black women are less staunch Dem supporters than Democratic Socialist voters are. Dems would have lost these Midterms by 8 points without this massive staunch support from Democratic Socialist voters.

https://www.nbcnews.com/politics/2026-elections/exit-polls


r/ContraPoints • • 12d ago

Nothing beats a Pokemon Go to the polls

Post image
436 Upvotes

r/ContraPoints • • 12d ago

Where to find fans?

20 Upvotes

I have been watching ContraPoints videos for years now, and I often rewatch them, not just for comfort, but because I find something new to chew on each time. I find these videos so intellectually stimulating and entertaining; they often inspire me to write essays and poems, and overall just spiral into thought for days on end.

I can't help but think: wouldn't this all be so much better if I had someone to talk with about it? I want to get second opinions; I want to have my ideas bounced around and sculpted. I have friends who I'm emotionally and intellectually intimate with, and I've tried to put them onto ContraPoints, but to no avail. No one in my life has the philosophical depth, political breadth, and queer-internet literacy required to appreciate these videos. I just feel like I have to put in all the effort to introduce people to the concepts she presents, and I just wish we were on the same page.

I'm not saying I'm some kind of superhuman, it's just that I'm very much on this wavelength, and as for those around me - they just aren't. This could be because I'm a cis male, or maybe it's something else. I put out a message on Instagram to my entire (very large) university, but nobody responded. Where does one find fellow ContraPoints lovers in real life? I feel like I'm losing my mind. It's like she's a figment of my imagination, haha. Please help.


r/ContraPoints • • 13d ago

Then

Post image
412 Upvotes

r/ContraPoints • • 13d ago

Oh he thinks he's Darth Vader now

Post image
641 Upvotes

r/ContraPoints • • 12d ago

Where is the Liberalism video?

7 Upvotes

Is it only available on Nebula or something? I haven’t been able to find this video everyone keeps talking about.


r/ContraPoints • • 15d ago

Klein/11 is actually a radical act of Palestinian liberation

Post image
692 Upvotes

r/ContraPoints • • 14d ago

Is the Saw video deleted?

9 Upvotes

At least, I’m not seeing it anywhere


r/ContraPoints • • 15d ago

Yet Another Post Asking for Help with Music (Envy and Conspiracy)

12 Upvotes

What is the classical music that is playing when Natalie walks up to the magic mirror in Envy? It's also at some point in Conspiracy but I can't find it right now. I thought it was "Ride of the Valkyries" but it is not.


r/ContraPoints • • 15d ago

Meow meow meow!!

Post image
348 Upvotes

r/ContraPoints • • 15d ago

The internet is a toxic hellscape right now. A vent about Natalie, politics, and coping mechanisms

18 Upvotes

Hey guys, hope everyone is doing okay.

I've been thinking a lot lately about Natalie and the internet. Like, did her recent back-to-back cancellations plus the internet just being a toxic hellscape finally make her tap out of IRL politics?

I mean actual day-to-day stuff. Not just talking about social movements as big concepts, but the actual policies that mess with rent, healthcare, transit and all that. I know she gets it. Conspiracy and the Liberalism tangent proved that.

But idk, looking at her recent tweets, the gaming streams, the Saw video and some of the stuff she said about being cancelled... I'm getting this weird vibe that Mother's attitude is just "fckit, if I can't please anyone, let it all burn"

Don't get me wrong I will stan this Queen till the day I die and I'll defend whatever she does. My biggest question is just like, did we (the community) and the haters literally break her?

This whole train of thought started with that tweet about Trump 2.0 "not being that bad". As a Latina with a very Latina name and face my immediate reaction was literally ARE YOU FCKNG KIDDING ME?. I get the US system lets him hide massive atrocities behind even bigger ones. Like the whole Maduro kidnapping for oil getting totally eclipsed by Iran. WTF?!?!?!?!

So yeah I get it. The US bubble feels like a dead end rn and everyone is just at each other's throats. It gives major pandemic collective madness vibes. I know it could just be a coping mechanism or a shitposting doom spiral. Maybe some people genuinely think it isn't that bad (But it is. It's H1tler-level bad, please don't kid yourselves).

But better days have to come. If us in the Americas don't take a stand against this stuff everyday, then honestly what's the point of even watching Contra anymore? You can't have a struggle without hope.

Anyway I think I just really needed to vent. Hope u guys get where I'm coming from and I hope Natalie gets it too. She's not alone in this and neither are you if you're reading this. We're in this together.

Let's go together. 🖤


r/ContraPoints • • 16d ago

Accurate

Post image
307 Upvotes