r/ContraPoints • u/Alan_Conway • 6h ago
Contrapoints book club
A lot of Contrapoints videos reference interesting books. I thought I'd make a list of ones I've read because of her:
Fierce: The History Of Leopard Print
Sexual Personae: Art and Decadence from Nefertiti to Emily Dickinson
Class: a guide through the American status system
What are some books you've read because of her? What were your thoughts on them? I want more perspectives.
Above is the post topic. Below, as a post primer, are my personal thoughts for each.
I liked "Fierce: The History Of Leopard Print". I feel like the Opulence video undersold how informative and interesting this book is. It's actually one of my favorite humanities books.
"Class" is indeed funny. But I feel like it loses something to an american audience. You know how in a sci-fi film, part of the experience of an alien language is needing the subtitles? Pre-existing comprehension robs this book of a little of of the shock value.
Regarding "Sexual Personae", I actually liked it. I also have thoughts and comments.
Natalie is right about Paglia having coke fiend energy, because every page feels like a line was snorted about 30 minutes ago prior to Paglia writing it.
That said, maybe it's the audiobook version I bought, but this works MUCH better in print form.
Natalie is very right to contrast this book to the Beauvoir / Butler branch of gender theory, but I feel like there's more to it than the point she brought up about the contrasting points of "Discourse constructs the sexed body." vs. "The sexed body constructs discourse.". I get that Paglia has been in a flop era for a while, but there are some ideas that she is adjacent to that I thought warranted discussion:
The Beauvoir / Butler lineage is much more focused on conflicts between gender, discrimination, the toxic intersection between gender and race, etc. These are all real social problems that we should work to address, even though it's a pipe dream. That said, in the pipe dream where gender discrimination and sexism are wiped out, both classifications will, presumably, still exist. Paglia kind of provides a look at what gender could be in that pipe dream world. Paglia does use a classification system of gender, such as men being associated with architecture and certain kinds of religion and women with nature and boobs. But Paglia also points out that these roles can be crossed. I see Paglia's writing as less "saying no to a broken and torturous system" and more "saying yes to what we like about men and saying yes to what we like about women". If you've ever read Butler's work, well, it's very dry (Laganja Estranja voice: "kinda like your vajoina"). Paglia's writing has a passion that Butler's just doesn't. Maybe it's because Paglia has the coke fiend energy that Natalie mentioned, but I think there's more to it. I think it's because Butler hates sexism and discrimination, so their work is very analytical; but Paglia seems to like men and like women and want a better acceptance of our own nature and passion for both, so the result is the passion about saying yes.
In the Twilight video, Natalie discussed the difference between Erotica, Romance, and Porn. Natalie pointed out that it's basically only marketing driven; in that Romance is for good girls, Erotica is for sluts, and Porn is for men. In Sexual Personae, Paglia does not have a distinction between the 3. All are labeled as porn and all are celebrated as porn. I think Paglia is onto something here, because in this worldview, although one can still be prudish, an artificial classification built on sexism is basically eliminated. Followers of the Beauvoir / Butler lineage of gender theory already understand to ask "Who benefits when we classify people based on this system", so we should also understand to ask "Who benefits when we classify media under this system?".
Paglia describes what she calls "mental transsexualism" among great artists, with the concept that you need an understanding of different sexes other than your own in order to portray them. This might sound a little odd to some people, but we've all heard "she breasted boobily", so Paglia at least has a point here. That said, I think Paglia is underselling this concept to restrict this to art. Shouldn't empathy itself be able to handle the reality that other people can be different? Should civilization therefore be built on this? Isn't the whole point of heterosexuality that your partner is different, and therefore, doesn't healthy heterosexually require the appreciation of the view of someone different from you in a fundamental way?
Also, I'm just now realizing those titles all have colons in them.