r/CompetitiveEDH • • Jan 22 '25

Discussion Effective immediately all direct links to Twitter or X will be removed automatically.

3.1k Upvotes

In an effort to remain consistent in our broad "Nazis and Nazi-adjacent individuals are bad" policy we will be joining a number of communities across reddit in blacklisting x and Twitter links.

We recommend BlueSky as an alternative site if you feel so inclined. There are a number of cEDH creators who have already migrated over.


r/CompetitiveEDH • • May 26 '25 Popcorn

Discussion SLC 10k Drama

1.6k Upvotes

I don't know who all watched the recent SLC 10k stream but the finals took around 11 hours and ended in a draw. The majority of the game was on a single stack over a cloud of fairies that the Rog Thras player attempted to play. The Rog Thras player played fast and decisive. It was a large stack but that was not the issue. The issue was that one player, Golden Sabertooth kept on talking. I mean hours of talking. He would take 10+ minutes on decisions. All of this is fine and ok, however he would antagonize the Rog Thras player non stop. He would insult him and would try to bully him into making decisions faster than he should. Go back and watch the video, it gets pretty gross at times. He was not being competitive, he was being an asshole.

All of this is topped off by Golden Sabertooth having a flight early in the morning meaning they had to put a timer on the game just for him. He stalled for 5+ hours just to force a draw in a finals game. He even tried to convince the pod to let him win at the end instead of declaring a tie. The game would likely of gone to the Rog Thras player if there was no timer.

Why care? Because toxic behavior like this should not be tolerated by the community. Spending hours on end arguing with people and then insulting them is not ok. Golden Sabertooth is also a big part of the community. He makes amazing art and contributes a lot to the scene. However, playing like this should not be tolerated in any way.

I encourage everybody to watch even just a 10 minutes section in the later half of the tournament and it will all make sense. This is not to cancel anybody, more so point out that people should be better and that judges should call this behavior out.

UPDATE

A message from MindOverMeta:
To our loyal viewers. Over this past weekend we learned the hard way that YouTube doesn’t save VODs longer than 12 hour. This was our first time streaming and unfortunately we had some errors. We are learning along the way. What does that mean for us? That means our 19-hour stream from Day Two was not rendered from YouTube. We weren’t able to preserve any of the VOD footage, and we’re incredibly heartbroken to lose what is a historic moment for the Magic community. Despite our best efforts to recover the footage, it is permanently gone. This was a tough lesson, but at present we’re updating our workflow with redundant backups to make sure it never happens again. This weekend was an honor to be able to bring the community directly to the table. We’ll be continuing to bring you the best content we can. - Chris8


r/CompetitiveEDH • • Apr 04 '24

Discussion The CEDH Discord server has been hijacked and is no longer affiliated with this community.

1.2k Upvotes

Update 3: We've spun up a new discord for the time being. This in all likelihood will be the new place going forward, we hope it feels like home still.

Afternoon folks, I come bearing some unfortunate news for the community. I know many of you have not heard from me in a long time. I stepped down as lead both here and on discord in January 2020, but recent events have prompted my return.

Last month the team at PlayEDH reached out to the admin team on the r/CompetitiveEDH discord to discuss a merger between their discord community and ours. PlayEDH is a paid service platform that facilitates EDH games via webcam. They offer ELO tracking and some tournament support and wanted to expand their numbers to include more of the CEDH community. Our discord team felt like this would be a good opportunity to breathe new life and fresh ideas into our community and moved forward with initiating a merger. Agreements were signed for some of our admin team to join PlayEDH's business and server ownership was transferred to the PlayEDH. Our admins were assured that if at any point the r/ team wanted to halt and back out of the merger it would be no issue. Unfortunately that did not turn out to be truth. All of this happened before the broader community and moderator team were informed or even polled about their interest in this merger.

PlayEDH moved in their own mod team and began implementing wide changes, deleting channels and adjusting rules to "better comply with Discord TOS". Some of those changes were reasonable. Many were not. This naturally created some pushback as the CEDH team attempted to halt the process long enough to actually discuss the physics of the merge. The community poll we put out showed less than a third of the server members even being interested in the changes, with everyone else being largely apathetic or outright against them. We did not feel this merge had enough broad support to be worth doing and reached out to PlayEDH to tell them this. Unfortunately, because server ownership had been transferred already we were at a significant disadvantage in this exchange. We asked on several occasions for server ownership to be transferred back to us so we can pause things and discuss the merger details on more even footing. Our only point of leverage would be publicly disavowing the merger which would benefit nobody. After a couple weeks of PlayEDH dragging their feet and denying our request, they finally agreed to hand the server back to us if we compensated them financially for their lost investment and time, and if we maintained the cross-server play queue that was set up. We agreed and began immediately working on restructuring the CEDH team to put more active people back in leadership roles so we can properly engage with PlayEDH and other competitive communities out there.

Unfortunately as of Monday, PlayEDH has decided they will not be handing the server back. They've accused us of allowing transphobic and homophobic messages to go unmoderated in the last month as well as putting undue pressure on their Ukrainian member of the team while they dealt with the war. This is enough justification, they claim, for PlayEDH to take the server.

The CEDH team was not moderating our server during the last month because the PlayEDH team had been moved into those roles already. Its particularly galling to accuse a mod team that is majority LGBTQ+ that we are failing to adequately protect those members of our community. They have also accused us of not being accommodating to their Ukrainian member. On several occasions this last month the war in Ukraine was used as a reason why communication was slow and why things couldn't get moved over to us due to power outages and shelling. We would have preferred to not involve this member at all to save them any additional stress, but the server ownership had been transferred to them specifically. We delayed our own decisions and discussions to accommodate these awful circumstances whenever we were asked. It was, however, quite frustrating to see public changes and communications come directly from this member during periods of time where it was apparently impossible for them to communicate with the CEDH team.

Here is a link of all the communication myself and our other representative, Spleenface, had with PlayEDH's team. The original communication between CEDH Admins and PlayEDH can't currently be shared by us due to the contract PlayEDH had them sign at the outset of all this. If PlayEDH would like to share those, they can. This is just what I have access to.

So now what? Honestly, I don't expect PlayEDH to give the server back. We'll likely have to set up a new one. I don't expect the existing one will remain for much longer, it will be in their best interest as a business to siphon as much of the community as possible into their sphere and only moderate a single server. They previously made promises about not doing that and maintaining a Free-to-play CEDH queue. At this point none of the circumstances around this situation give me any confidence in their word or character. You all are free to do what you will with this information. I've been horribly disappointed in this process and the PlayEDH admin team with the exception of Sigi/Lobster, who I felt tried their best to work with us in good faith.

Quick Update: PlayEDH is already banning discussion on the server about this and deleting all public discourse. They seem to think if they insist everyone use modmail things will just go away. I've already been timed out for talking about this.

Update 2: Here is an excellent writeup of events done by The Queen of Cardboard over at Commander's Herald. I encourage everyone here to make their own conclusions based on the screenshots we've posted and the information outlined in this article.


r/CompetitiveEDH • • Apr 02 '20

Here's Why You're Wrong About Lutri, the Spellchaser

1.1k Upvotes

Not you, personally, just the royal you, which includes everyone except for You and I. We're smart. We get it. Here's the card:

Lutri, the Spellchaser

Here's why everyone else except us is wrong about Lutri, the Spellchaser. Here's why the RC banning this card in 20 minutes is exactly the right decision, and here's why that decision has NO bearing whatsoever on the banning of any other card (cough, flash):

  1. Lutri is not designed for commander. The mechanic is beautiful in 60-card formats, encouraging deck diversity and strange brews. It is non-functional in commander, offering no restriction at all. It simply doesn't work as intended.

  2. It is *overwhelmingly likely* confirmed that the RC was given a brief heads-up about this card before it was released. The RC made a decision with time to think, and vote. It is fair and reasonable for WOTC to make a single card for other constructed formats without worrying about the implications for Commander.

  3. Wish cards exist and are useless in Commander, this is not unprecedented. It's okay for our format to not have one or two mechanics. I don't miss Grandeur.

  4. This card goes in every single u/R/X deck, forever. Boring! It is impossible to make a case for not running it.

  5. Starting the game with 8 cards in hand is fundametally broken. The advantage of having a counterspell/value fork in EVERY opening hand, regardless of mulligans, is insane. Any deck without blue and red is at a huge disadvantage. I believe this is significant enough to make Najeela/Kenrith better than Thrasios and Tymna, full stop. It's that powerful.

  6. If your deck is in blue and red, you can restrict your opponent's lines simply by having this card in your "out of game" zone at the start. Anyone attempting to cast a win-con now has a tax effect of needing an answer to Otter at all times, since all your countermagic can be copied. It must be played around by the entire table, and this problem gets worse when you have multiple u/R/X decks

  7. It's extremely difficult to make a case for any non-UR commander in cEDH and casual. I can't picture a commander outside u/R that is better than u/R/X commanders with a Dualcaster "partner." Having access to the otter tilts the whole format significantly in favor of Izzet decks.

Banning this card is a NO-BRAINER. It breaks so many aspects of cEDH and regular EDH that it has the potential to warp the entire format. It's an unfair advantage to dozens of commanders and it adds a premeditated element to all stack interaction, ever.

Flash should be banned, I am in total agreement, but Flash doesn't fundamentally break the game outside of cEDH. Flash doesn't add a completely unrestricted advantage to half the decks in the format. It's just not the same story. It's apples and oranges.

Let's not tarnish our reputation and clout with our allies on the CAG and RC by conflating this banning with Flash or trying to "call out" some perceived hypocrisy. It's extremely clear that this card is a different species, a corner case exception to the normal banning process and banning it is a GOOD DECISION by the RC.

Thank you for coming to my TED Talk. I'll take my downvotes now.


r/CompetitiveEDH • • Dec 12 '20

Discussion cEDH/High Power games are the only games I've played where people are almost never salty

897 Upvotes

I've gotten into cEDH quite hard over the last year, thanks to the PlayEDH discord server and webcam games with my playgroup.

I have social anxiety and one thing that made commander really difficult for me in the past was salty or angry players, this balanced with the fact that I truly love combo decks lead to some pretty bad interactions at my LGS (pre-covid). I had players freak out because my slightly upgraded Inalla precon combo'd out on like turn 9 and I had a long patch where I was building decks I didn't really like or cutting cards I did like because I was nervous of how people would react to them.

Eventually I discovered cEDH and found a group locally that enjoys high-powered games and are cool with proxies and I've just not looked back. The games are fast and interactive and people almost never get salty no matter what happens! Similarly, the games I've played on the High and Comp channels on PlayEDH have been pretty great, whereas I've had some pretty unfun games in Mid because eventually a dispute about what's acceptable breaks out and it gets tense.

Sorry for this all of this rambling, I'm just happy to have found my place in the Commander scene


r/CompetitiveEDH • • Aug 23 '26

General Discussion / Question Shoutout to the guy at my first cEDH tournament who chose honesty over placement

854 Upvotes

I was at Breach the Bay 2 as my first cEDH tournament ever, and overall had a good time. Almost made it day 2 but my lack of skill and experience got it in the way.

But this post isn't about me. In one of my games, a player who I'll call Pinochlo passed his turn to Ob Nixilis who one hundred percent had a win on his turn with like 20 cards exiled but without the mana to use it yet. Pinochlo made a hand gesture of handing off his turn in the direction of Ob player, and verbally said he passed. I said "on your endstep, I cast final fortune." A stack battle ensues, I win and final fortune resolves. Then Mr. Pinochlo decides he never passed and calls a judge. My dude starts making up stories, he never made the hand gesture, never said pass, and said "I'd like to attempt to move to endstep." Me and him go back and forth with the judge for a bit and honestly I'm a bit mad I can't believe my ears. Eventually Ob Nixilis chimes in and says "I'm going to be the better person here and just say you didn't say any of that, you did say you passed the turn, and you made the hand gesture."

I end up converting my final fortune turn, so Ob gave up his guaranteed win for integrity. I checked the standings after and he would've made day 2 at Breach the Bay 2 if he had either kept silent or agreed with the liar.

Shoutout [Hooligan] Michael whoever you are, you a real one. Was a great sport even after losing, which I found somewhat not as common. I honestly think I would not be back for a second cEDH tournament ever if the liar got the judge on his side.


r/CompetitiveEDH • • Dec 10 '21

Competition Wow. Y’all were more than right

791 Upvotes

This is my tribute to a community I have no right to belong in. I posted here a few weeks back about whether my Gitrog/Jarad was viable. I got a lot of negative feedback and I fought back.

Boy was I wrong. Did one fun $7 night at the LGS and played two Codie decks. Not only did I get smoked I got embarrassed. This is an apology to anyone and everyone in this community. Y’all play a different game and I am so sorry for even thinking I was close to this.

Keep doing your thing and enjoying cEDH. EDH is fine by me. Leaving the subreddit with nothing but good vibes. May your mana vaults and moxes always be top decked. May your opponents never have a Force of Will or Mana Drain. Or interrupt your Stax.

Signed,

A sincerely humbled EDH player


r/CompetitiveEDH • • Sep 24 '24 Heart of Silver Take My Silver

Banlist Update and RC Discussion Megathread

682 Upvotes

Okay y'all had a comfortable 24 hours to post threads, but we're seeing a lot of repeat conversations and nearly identical takes, so its time for a megathread.

In case you live under a rock, Dockside Extortionist, Mana Crypt, Jeweled Lotus, and Nadu Winged Wisdom all ate bans yesterday per the RC's quarterly ban updates.

Keep it civil in here. I got called a slur and told to kill myself about 45 minutes into my day yesterday, I have very tiny amounts of tolerance remaining for people being assholes to each other.


r/CompetitiveEDH • • Sep 05 '24

Discussion I am the new cEDH RC. Ask me anything.

657 Upvotes

Hi my name's Chet and I live in Cleveland, Ohio. Pretty much my whole life I've known that I'm better than most people and I certainly know what's best for everybody. I've always had political aspirations and dreams of being a local assemblyman, mayor, or maybe some new kind of position that only I'm qualified for.

Anyway, I figured I'd get my career started with something I know I've always been good at: telling other people what to do. I know it may seem jarring at first because none of you know me yet, and you may be asking yourselves why I'm dipping such a big finger into this thing that this community has already been enjoying for many years, and stirring things up and expecting you all to respect me and take me seriously as the rules committee (not RC member btw it's just me) and for that the best I can tell you is shut the fuck up and don't worry about it. You don't need to know me, just understand that from now on, Chet from Ohio has a say in all the cEDH games you play at your LGS, online tournament, and your kitchen table.

I know what you're probably thinking, "dude I've been enjoying cEDH just fine for the past couple years and I don't care what some self-appointed douche canoe thinks."

Wrong again. I will personally come to your house and paint the walls if you don't adhere to my authority completely and absolutely.

Best,

— Grand Arbiter of all things cEDH (aka Chet from Ohio)


r/CompetitiveEDH • • Jul 21 '25

Metagame Tell people to shut the f*ck up more

646 Upvotes

Hey just posting to let folks know that in any tournament setting or FNM you can call a judge on someone for talking too much! Normalize letting people know "hey man you can't use up our entire round trying to mind control everyone, take a game action or put a sock in it."

Commander is a social game, even at tournament levels. Letting someone bully the table using their words is not something you have to allow! Tell them to shut up and call a judge!

If you find yourself in a tournament in which the judges and TOs allow this sort of non-stop table talk and politics, NAME & SHAME! That makes us all look bad and tells the greater commander community that we are not serious. That horrible meme game that was like 11 hours? That was because of bad judges and a bad TO.

Use your words, call a judge, and name & shame these awful TOs and judges. We can take cEDH back from the bullies, but we have to fight to do it!


r/CompetitiveEDH • • Apr 03 '20

[IKO] Drannith Magistrate Spoiler

643 Upvotes

/img/okorn1dmmmq41.jpg

Edit: As written, this card stops commanders from being cast from the command zone.


r/CompetitiveEDH • • Jul 30 '26

General Discussion / Question GoldenSabertooth is literally stealing art for profit...

629 Upvotes

https://imgur.com/gallery/goldensabertooth-is-literally-stealing-art-profit-063pmQA

Im not a big fan of GoldenSabertooth, not after last years controversy over his 11 hour game and the way he treated other players.

Now i dislike him even more... he is stealing art to try and make a quick buck. Not only did he steal the art for the Crystal, Inhuman Princess playmat, he stole it from the wrong superhero! Its fkn Rogue, not Crystal...

Absolute CHUD move.

EDIT - He has now retroactively tried to give credit to Jim Lee because he was getting called out by the mtg community. This is a band-aid, and i hope he issues a formal apology for the mistake.

EDIT 2 - ill stand by that this felt shady and sneaky, but he has, as of around 4pm, issued an apology for the parody missing the mark and the confusion and backlash it caused. Ill be closing this post and you can all form your own opinions on the apology, which seems to be genuine.


r/CompetitiveEDH • • Oct 01 '24

Discussion "It is extremely important to me that the cEDH community has a seat at the table ... We acknowledge them as a community and huge part of the game." — Gavin Verhey, On the future of commander.

600 Upvotes

Seems like for the first time, the new RC will not ignore cEDH.


r/CompetitiveEDH • • 27d ago

Tournaments & Meta The recent Dackposts are so laughable

595 Upvotes

Basically:

-> Dack presented in their meta.

-> Never considered adjusting their interaction suite for more creature counterspells or removal for rocks.

-> Stuck believing "interacting is putting other players ahead thus bad."

-> Refuses to mulligan and politic responsibly against turbo.

-> Loses to Dack.

-> Wizards plz ban Dack.


r/CompetitiveEDH • • Oct 29 '20

Discussion [CMR] Jeweled Lotus

587 Upvotes

/img/hdd33dm8u3w51.png

Jeweled Lotus (0) Artifact T: Sacrifice ~: Add three mana of any one color. Spend this mana only to cast your commander.

This seems pretty insane to me on first glance!


r/CompetitiveEDH • • Mar 03 '26

Competition High NSFW

586 Upvotes

Would I be immediately disqualification for being high?


r/CompetitiveEDH • • Oct 30 '20

In Defense of the Indefensible

582 Upvotes

Alright boys, time to lose some karma.

Also first of all, not touching the topic of price. I think that is its own topic and can be explored in its own thread. This is just about card power level.

I think jeweled lotus is a fine card for cEDH. Not that it should have been printed, or that it isn't horribly broken, but that it's a fine card.

In some sense, our format is made up of horribly broken cards that should have never been printed, or cards with unintended consequences with 40 life. You could argue that the more egregious Mana positive artifacts shouldn't have been printed. Oracle was an obvious mistake. Ad nauseum gets pushed to an insane power level by 40 life. Underworld breach is laughably broken in any format containing LED. Also wizards once decided let you have your pick of 2 commanders of your choice, giving you up to 4 colors you can customize, and one of them is an infinite Mana outlet.

This format has some obviously broken in half cards. Lotus is just another one, even if a bit more broken than the others. However, it does do some good. It is another tool for frog, or the mono green decks, or Godo, or even Urza that's been struggling as of late. I can't see the other, stronger lists excluding it, but disproportionately it breathes life into a lot of decks that have taken a backseat in the meta recently. Also, there's a lot of brewing space that could go around it.

...but holy crap I'm not looking forward to even more turn 1 Najeelas. As a naus player I can't tell you how not hyped I am about turn 1 Najeelas.

Should lotus have been printed? Probably not. It is broken beyond belief? Oh hell yes. But so are a lot of cards in our format, and at the end of the day that is what defines our format. Metas will shift, cards will come in, and sometimes they'll have a massive effect. If our format can handle dockside, it can handle this. Also, at least it doesn't cast opposition agent.


r/CompetitiveEDH • • Apr 20 '20

Discussion Casual EDH needs cEDH, and we need them. Format splitting is a terrible idea.

574 Upvotes

I want to preface this by saying, I love casual EDH and cEDH. However, I play less casual EDH due to the incredible toxicity around what is and isn't cEDH.

I understand there's bad blood between these two communities, but we need each other.

I've seen a not-insignificant amount of people here and on the main EDH subreddit advocate for a format separation, and I can't help but think about how disastrous it would be. A format separation would only cause more confusion and animosity among these two communities and none of us need that. To clarify, the difference between cEDH and casual EDH is a difference of power level alone.

While a format separation would maybe result in a more cEDH-centric banlist, there would be no centralized committee or authority on which banlist is the "official" one. Also, among the casual EDH community there would be even more confusion on what is and isn't cEDH. If there were two separate formats there would be so much heat generated about cards like Cyc Rift, Armageddon, etc and whether or not those are too "cEDH" for the format. There would need to be constant clarification on whether or not a given gathering was EDH or cEDH. They need us to remind them what cEDH actually is. Casting a Cyc Rift on turn 7 is not banworthy, not cEDH, and I've seen it called both of those things many times at casual tables.

Let's not forget though that we need them. We need casual EDH because I know for a fact that most of us love casual EDH as well. Most of my problems with casual EDH is the people who persecute others for playing a certain deck or playing a certain way, and I know that many of us share that sentiment. We should be working to heal this divide instead of widening it. We cannot forget that cEDH is EDH, and we grow when EDH grows as a whole.


r/CompetitiveEDH • • Jun 16 '22

[2X2] Imperial Seal Reprint

Post image
571 Upvotes

r/CompetitiveEDH • • Apr 20 '20

Discussion Flash Ban Megathread

566 Upvotes

All discussion regarding the ban of the card Flash with the April 2020 Banlist Update goes here. Questions such as "What does the format look like post-ban" or "how should I change this deck because of the ban" should use this thread.

https://mtgcommander.net/index.php/2020/04/20/april-2020-rules-update/

"Flash Speaking of exceptional decisions, we are banning Flash (the card, not the mechanic). Enough cEDH players who we trust have convinced us that it is the only change they need for the environment they seek to cultivate. Though they represent a small fraction of the Commander playerbase, we are willing to make this effort for them. It should not be taken as a signal that we are considering any kind of change in how we intend to manage the format; this is an extraordinary step, and one we are unlikely to repeat.

We use the banlist to guide players in how to approach the format and hope Flash’s role on the list will be to signal “cheating things into play quickly in non-interactive ways isn’t interesting, don’t do that.”

We believe Commander is still best as a social-focused format and will not be making any changes to accommodate tournament play. Taking responsibility for your and your opponents’ fun, including setting expectations with your group, is a fundamental part of the Commander philosophy. Organizers who want to move towards more untrusted games should consider adding additional rules or guidance to create the Commander experience they want to offer."


r/CompetitiveEDH • • Apr 14 '20

Discussion So, You Want to Pick a cEDH Deck...

562 Upvotes

So, you want to take the plunge into cEDH. You've seen some gameplay, maybe from a YouTube channel (such as playing with power), or at your LGS, or maybe your play group has decided to try it and you're not sure where to start. Regardless, you’re here and you wanna find a deck. With that in mind, this is a guide I’ve written up based on my own experiences getting into cEDH.

First, there are a few things to note about cEDH that are important when looking for a decklist.

  1. cEDH decks are often thousands of dollars, with cards such as the original dual lands taking up vast portions of the price, or cards like timetwister single handedly pushing a deck into 4 digit ranges. Don't worry. You won't have to sell your car for a cEDH deck. While some prefer and do use real cards, the community as a whole supports the use of proxies. Just how proxies are handled will vary depending on your group, but overall proxies are widely accepted and encouraged for the sake of accessibility.

  2. cEDH as a format has a single-minded goal of using the best cards in the best decks. Thus, while again personal taste will account for some variation, cEDH does not hold the same stigma against "net decking" that many other formats may have. If a list has proven to be the most optimal build for a commander, that list should be used, whether just for playing or for as reference when brewing a new list. This brings me to my next point…

  3. There is a vibrant and dynamic meta in cEDH (Oracle hulk excepted). Many come into cEDH feeling that it's a "solved" format of the same couple of "best decks" that only minorly receive changes. This is far from the truth. There are dozens of cEDH viable commanders and for each commander, there tend to be a handful of lists tuned and updated. For a better picture of what the cEDH meta looks like, and for finding decklists in general, the cEDH database (https://cedh-decklist-database.xyz/primary.html) is an excellent resource for looking at what commanders work for cEDH, and what an optimal list looks like.

Now, with all that out of the way, how does one pick a cEDH deck?

(Note, this is my personal take, as someone who fell into the cEDH scene and took a long while learning about decks, and finding what I liked)

The first step to picking a deck is understanding the 3 essential components of a cEDH deck. These are

  1. Their win con

  2. Their style

  3. Their color

These are not the only ways to evaluate a cEDH deck, but these are the first three things I consider when trying to decide if I want to play a deck.

First, the win con. Remember when I mentioned how cEDH has a meta? It also has a few well defined and thoroughly explored, tried and true wincons. Because so many decks will use variations on the same "shell" (a term used to describe the parts of a deck that go with a wincon. Draw spells, ramp, and counters make up the shell, along with deck specific cards such as the madness cards used in Filter Anje) I like to evaluate a deck on its wincon. I don't want to get into every win con there is - that is a far larger scope than I want to touch on today. However, if one goes to any deck in the cEDH database, almost every decklist will tend to have a primer explaining how to play the deck. In that primer one can find the main win con of the deck. For now, I will say that a few common win cons are: food chain, isochron scepter imprinted with dramatic reversal, demonic consultation with a lab man effect, or the worldgorger dragon loop.

If none of those terms mean anything, don't worry

As I said, the primers of decks will tend to explain exactly how the deck wins. All that matters for now is that the first step to examining a deck is its wincon. Some wincons are easier to use than others. Some wincons are only applicable in certain colors. However, the main difference between decks with similar wincons is how one gets to that wincon.

Transitioning nicely onto our next aspect to evaluate a deck on is what style of deck it is. There are 3 main kinds of decks in cEDH: proactive, adaptive, and disruptive (note that these are not exactly comparable to aggro,mid-range, and control, but if it helps think of them that way).

Proactive decks are aggressive, looking to beat other decks by simply winning before other decks are set up. These decks use their speed to make up for a lack of control, and are often seen in sans-blue shells.

Adaptive decks are the most prevalent. These are decks that can threaten a win early, or grind out card advantage and win in a long game through disruption. These are the most common decks, and as such also the most diverse.

Finally, disruptive decks look to slow the game down and stop other players from winning, often utilizing staxs and a great deal of counter magic to thwart early wins while grinding out an advantage before finally winning once other decks are exhausted.

Now, when choosing a deck one must note that all 3 of these styles are equally viable. The choice becomes, how do you want to play. Again, this is a personal choice, but how you want to play effects the kind of deck you choose.

Finally, the last aspect of a deck that one can base their decision on is the color identity. While color isn't the most competitive metric, color plays a large role in how we define our personalities in magic. As such, one should know that some colors are going to have to play a certain wincon, and certain styles only work in certain colors. This is why I push for people to figure out what wincons and styles they want to play first, as certain wincons are only available in certain colors. Lastly, not all colors are playable in cEDH. By nature of the format, colors like boros or orzhov simply aren't viable. They cannot play a competitive enough level. However, one can often find decks in those colors at a power level just under cEDH power levels.

So, there you have it: a 3 part process for picking a deck.

First, decide on a wincon that seems fun. Second, decide what style of deck you want to play. Third, pick your colors. With these three ways to filter, you should have no trouble picking a deck that you want to try, and that you know why you want to play it.

Because I don't want to just throw you into the world of cEDH, here are 3 decks, broken down by these three guidelines, that I personally find easy to pick up and learn. While cEDH as a format is some of the most complex and hard to play Magic in general, these decks all use simple win cons that are fast, efficient, and effective.

  1. Filter Anje - https://tappedout.net/mtg-decks/loop-zoop-filter-anje-cedh/?cb=1576897809

Filter Anje is a proactive combo deck based around the worldgorger dragon loop, intending to make infinite mana and infinite draw, finding an outlet that allows you to deal infinite damage to the table. Based in Red/Black, this deck aims to be as fast as possible, using Anje’s low cmc and unique ability to rummage through as much of your deck as possible, as quickly as possible.

2. Consultation Kess - https://tappedout.net/mtg-decks/consultation-kess-a-primer/

Consultation Kess is an adaptive deck aiming to win through demonic consultation and a lab man effect, typically thassa’s oracle. With Kess at the helm, the deck gains a unique combo line that allows one to use consultation to tutor for thassa’s oracle before recasting consultation thanks to Kess’s ability. This deck isn’t the fastest at the table, but running blue gives one plenty of counters and control. This combo is also very hard to stax out, making it one of the leanest and most efficient decks in the format.

3. Heliod Ballista - https://tappedout.net/mtg-decks/im-walking-on-sunshine/

Heliod Ballista uses the one card combo of Heliod, Sun-Crowned plus Walking Ballista to deal infinite damage to the table. Because of it’s mono-white nature, this is a disruptive deck that looks to stax out opponents, stifling tutors and denying mana while slowing down it’s opponents until it can find Walking Ballista.


r/CompetitiveEDH • • Sep 30 '24

Discussion WotC Announcement: On the Future of Commander

549 Upvotes

Just dropped right now. WotC is taking a more direct hand in the format.

https://magic.wizards.com/en/news/announcements/on-the-future-of-commander


r/CompetitiveEDH • • 24d ago

Tournaments & Meta Dack Player last night at my LGS was salty

535 Upvotes

So the new Dack Fayden is making rounds in cEDH. I normally run Sisay tutor. My local group knows a lot of lines I play. Last night, Dack player casts Dack from the command zone. Do I counter him? No. I instead activated Sisay in response to Dack being cast and tutored for Elesh Norn, Mother of Machines.

He was pissed.

Was best game in a while.


r/CompetitiveEDH • • Sep 27 '24 Take My Silver

Discussion Rant: played cEDH for the first time yesterday, had way more fun than casual

535 Upvotes

While waiting for my buddy at my lgs I ask to join a random 3 pod I saw. They were cool with it but told me they were playing cedh so it’d be different. I told them that’s fine, I had a deck that may be close to that (I built a mostly-proxy Memnarch a while ago to pull out if someone joined a pod and intentionally didn’t match the group’s power.)

Now, I’ve been playing commander for about 10 years on and off (started right before the first planeswalker decks came out) and my biggest gripe is only about 2 of my friends build decks that even border on the upper limits of casual, which I’ve figured out is where I sit, and winning against people who run almost zero interaction just feels hollow. So playing in games where-

•interaction is expected (no one’s scooping the instant you counter a boardwipe)

•nobody is complaining that they would have acted differently if they knew what combo you were setting up

•games are FAST, not one game lasted more than 30 minutes that whole night

-just feels refreshing to me after all this time. I didn’t win a single match but it was so much more fun than I’ve had with this game in a long time, and it’s probably what I’m going to be building decks for from now on.

*sorry for any formatting issues, I’m on mobile