So, you want to take the plunge into cEDH. You've seen some gameplay, maybe from a YouTube channel (such as playing with power), or at your LGS, or maybe your play group has decided to try it and you're not sure where to start. Regardless, you’re here and you wanna find a deck. With that in mind, this is a guide I’ve written up based on my own experiences getting into cEDH.
First, there are a few things to note about cEDH that are important when looking for a decklist.
cEDH decks are often thousands of dollars, with cards such as the original dual lands taking up vast portions of the price, or cards like timetwister single handedly pushing a deck into 4 digit ranges. Don't worry. You won't have to sell your car for a cEDH deck. While some prefer and do use real cards, the community as a whole supports the use of proxies. Just how proxies are handled will vary depending on your group, but overall proxies are widely accepted and encouraged for the sake of accessibility.
cEDH as a format has a single-minded goal of using the best cards in the best decks. Thus, while again personal taste will account for some variation, cEDH does not hold the same stigma against "net decking" that many other formats may have. If a list has proven to be the most optimal build for a commander, that list should be used, whether just for playing or for as reference when brewing a new list. This brings me to my next point…
There is a vibrant and dynamic meta in cEDH (Oracle hulk excepted). Many come into cEDH feeling that it's a "solved" format of the same couple of "best decks" that only minorly receive changes. This is far from the truth. There are dozens of cEDH viable commanders and for each commander, there tend to be a handful of lists tuned and updated. For a better picture of what the cEDH meta looks like, and for finding decklists in general, the cEDH database (https://cedh-decklist-database.xyz/primary.html) is an excellent resource for looking at what commanders work for cEDH, and what an optimal list looks like.
Now, with all that out of the way, how does one pick a cEDH deck?
(Note, this is my personal take, as someone who fell into the cEDH scene and took a long while learning about decks, and finding what I liked)
The first step to picking a deck is understanding the 3 essential components of a cEDH deck. These are
Their win con
Their style
Their color
These are not the only ways to evaluate a cEDH deck, but these are the first three things I consider when trying to decide if I want to play a deck.
First, the win con. Remember when I mentioned how cEDH has a meta? It also has a few well defined and thoroughly explored, tried and true wincons. Because so many decks will use variations on the same "shell" (a term used to describe the parts of a deck that go with a wincon. Draw spells, ramp, and counters make up the shell, along with deck specific cards such as the madness cards used in Filter Anje) I like to evaluate a deck on its wincon. I don't want to get into every win con there is - that is a far larger scope than I want to touch on today. However, if one goes to any deck in the cEDH database, almost every decklist will tend to have a primer explaining how to play the deck. In that primer one can find the main win con of the deck. For now, I will say that a few common win cons are: food chain, isochron scepter imprinted with dramatic reversal, demonic consultation with a lab man effect, or the worldgorger dragon loop.
If none of those terms mean anything, don't worry
As I said, the primers of decks will tend to explain exactly how the deck wins. All that matters for now is that the first step to examining a deck is its wincon. Some wincons are easier to use than others. Some wincons are only applicable in certain colors. However, the main difference between decks with similar wincons is how one gets to that wincon.
Transitioning nicely onto our next aspect to evaluate a deck on is what style of deck it is. There are 3 main kinds of decks in cEDH: proactive, adaptive, and disruptive (note that these are not exactly comparable to aggro,mid-range, and control, but if it helps think of them that way).
Proactive decks are aggressive, looking to beat other decks by simply winning before other decks are set up. These decks use their speed to make up for a lack of control, and are often seen in sans-blue shells.
Adaptive decks are the most prevalent. These are decks that can threaten a win early, or grind out card advantage and win in a long game through disruption. These are the most common decks, and as such also the most diverse.
Finally, disruptive decks look to slow the game down and stop other players from winning, often utilizing staxs and a great deal of counter magic to thwart early wins while grinding out an advantage before finally winning once other decks are exhausted.
Now, when choosing a deck one must note that all 3 of these styles are equally viable. The choice becomes, how do you want to play. Again, this is a personal choice, but how you want to play effects the kind of deck you choose.
Finally, the last aspect of a deck that one can base their decision on is the color identity. While color isn't the most competitive metric, color plays a large role in how we define our personalities in magic. As such, one should know that some colors are going to have to play a certain wincon, and certain styles only work in certain colors. This is why I push for people to figure out what wincons and styles they want to play first, as certain wincons are only available in certain colors. Lastly, not all colors are playable in cEDH. By nature of the format, colors like boros or orzhov simply aren't viable. They cannot play a competitive enough level. However, one can often find decks in those colors at a power level just under cEDH power levels.
So, there you have it: a 3 part process for picking a deck.
First, decide on a wincon that seems fun. Second, decide what style of deck you want to play. Third, pick your colors. With these three ways to filter, you should have no trouble picking a deck that you want to try, and that you know why you want to play it.
Because I don't want to just throw you into the world of cEDH, here are 3 decks, broken down by these three guidelines, that I personally find easy to pick up and learn. While cEDH as a format is some of the most complex and hard to play Magic in general, these decks all use simple win cons that are fast, efficient, and effective.
Filter Anje - https://tappedout.net/mtg-decks/loop-zoop-filter-anje-cedh/?cb=1576897809
Filter Anje is a proactive combo deck based around the worldgorger dragon loop, intending to make infinite mana and infinite draw, finding an outlet that allows you to deal infinite damage to the table. Based in Red/Black, this deck aims to be as fast as possible, using Anje’s low cmc and unique ability to rummage through as much of your deck as possible, as quickly as possible.
2. Consultation Kess - https://tappedout.net/mtg-decks/consultation-kess-a-primer/
Consultation Kess is an adaptive deck aiming to win through demonic consultation and a lab man effect, typically thassa’s oracle. With Kess at the helm, the deck gains a unique combo line that allows one to use consultation to tutor for thassa’s oracle before recasting consultation thanks to Kess’s ability. This deck isn’t the fastest at the table, but running blue gives one plenty of counters and control. This combo is also very hard to stax out, making it one of the leanest and most efficient decks in the format.
3. Heliod Ballista - https://tappedout.net/mtg-decks/im-walking-on-sunshine/
Heliod Ballista uses the one card combo of Heliod, Sun-Crowned plus Walking Ballista to deal infinite damage to the table. Because of it’s mono-white nature, this is a disruptive deck that looks to stax out opponents, stifling tutors and denying mana while slowing down it’s opponents until it can find Walking Ballista.