Disclaimers
I'm going to say a lot of things here that people may disagree with or even find personally insulting, and that definitely is not my intent. I also don't really want to create a discussion here - it's not like I'm going to go back to this deck and if people are already comitted to playing Urza then I doubt they'll listen to me anyway. My intent for this post is only to share my experiences playing Urza and my revised thoughts on the deck so that people can draw their own conclusions. So let me say a few things before I begin:
I don't hate anyone in this community. I especially don't hate Sigi, Lerker, Sickrobot, or Shaper, who have been doing a fine job with the decklists and primers for Urza. I may be critical of some of their opinions in this article, but I don't mean any of them as personal attacks. All four of these men are knowledgeable, skilled players, good content producers, competent moderators and administrators on this subreddit and the CEDH discord, and generally nice people, and our community is lucky to have them. So I don't hate them because we disagree on a few decks. I HATE THEM BECAUSE THEY'RE A BUNCH OF FUCKIN WEEBS. jk, I don't hate them at all.
If Urza has been working well for you and you want to stick with it, good for you. If this is the case, then you may just want to stop reading here, because it sounds like I'm not going to convince you of anything, and you definitely won't convince me of anything. I also just generally don't want to read a lot of "idk works for me" posts. If I wanted to read those, I'd go to a tech support forum. Again, this is mostly about sharing my own experience and less about creating a discussion.
This is going to be long and meandering and go more than a little off topic at certain points. WOTC market research once showed that Magic players are afraid of any textbox that contains more than 6 lines of text. I've already passed that point and I haven't even said anything important yet. So don't panic, I will create a tl;dr for this post. It will either be at the end of this post after the conclusion or as a post in the comments.
Introduction
Not too long after [[Urza, Lord High Artificer]] was spoiled, there was a thread asking whether or not is was better than [[Teferi, Temporal Archmage]]. Having played Teferi as well as a few other mono-blue decks for several years, I offered my own thoughts on both decks based on my initial impressions of Urza. I highly recommend you read this post (or at least the tl;dr summary I did) before going on because I will be referencing it CONSTANTLY here, and I don't really want to repeat what I already said there. Overall, most of my opinions are the same now as they were then, but I do have some new thoughts that I will share later. My main regret from the original post is the direct comparison to partners. Obviously Urza is worse than partners, everything is worse than partners. So although I do discuss some relevant things in that section, directly comparing them was probably futile. I should have tried harder to show how Urza is also worse than the decks that are only slightly worse than partners but still super powerful (Zur, Kess, Gitrog, Najeela, FCFS), which is part of what I hope to accomplish here.
But that's not the main reason why I'm writing this article. I'm writing it because of a chain of events that started the following day on Discord.
If you've read the post I linked earlier, you'll see that one of the things I say is multiple times that mono-blue is a limited color identity and that the ceiling for mono-blue decks is not that much higher than the floor, or at least not high enough for it to compete with the best decks in the format. If you really want to stretch these words around, you could say that I think that Urza is not meaningfully better than Fblthp. For the record, I think Fblthp is terrible, and I always thought he was worse than Urza. Regardless, when I went on the CEDH Discord to talk about a card from M20 that I saw and immediately fell in love with, [[Flame Sweep]], Shaper was laughing about someone who thought "Urza is not meaningfully better than Fblthp".
Now, I still don't know if Shaper was actually talking about me (EDIT: He wasn't) or if that was a statement made by someone else (EDIT: It was, but I won't link it), but at that time I thought it was about me and I became upset by the perceived idea that they were talking shit about me behind my back. I started arguing with him about it and he didn't seem to be taking it seriously, which only caused me to be more frustrated and argue harder. I sent a link to the post I made about my thoughts on the Urza, and Shaper responded with:
If you're not going to playtest the card/deck and make vague dismissive statements and demand respect for those untested opinions ... I just don't know what to tell you
At the time, this seemed fair. Looking at it now though, there's a sort of logical fallacy here. It implies that someone is incapable of forming a valid opinion on a deck unless they've playtested it extensively, regardless of prior experience with similar decks or general knowledge of the format. If you really want to stretch this statement to the breaking point, you could say it about decks that are obviously quite weak, like the [[Feather]] control deck. It is good that through this quote, I now have a defense to throw at people who think my [[Niv-Mizzet Parun]] deck isn't competitive once I finish writing the primer.
Regardless, this statement lit a vindictive fire inside me. I was determined to prove myself right and defend my opinion. After giving up on Teferi in the fall of 2018, I swore that I would never go back to mono-blue again. But anger makes us do things we never thought we would do. So on that day I became determined to get as many games playing Urza in as I could. That's right, my goal was to play 30 games of Urza and I was motivated purely by spite.
What people don't know is that this isn't even the first time I've done something so petty. The whole reason I started playing Niv-Mizzet Parun was borne of a grudge I had with people who disagreed with me about [[Teferi, Temporal Archmage]]. At the time, I was frustrated with Teferi and thought he was terrible and getting worse and worse every set. The main reasons that I cited were that Teferi had almost 0 board presence in the early game, that [[The Chain Veil]] combo was too expensive and slow to keep up with other decks, that Teferi couldn't outgrind Tymna and Thrasios even if he had stax in play, etc. Others assured me that having part of your win condition in your command zone in a color that had access to counterspells was so valuable that it outweighed these massive disadvantages. So I started playing Parun since he also has access to counterspells and has several one-card combos. Parun is also in a better color identity than Teferi and has access to additional stax pieces, board wipes, removal for creatures and artifacts, more ways to pressure life totals, and is a giant uncounterable dragon that passively draws cards. Parun is only just barely competitive despite having all these edges over Teferi, yet the prevailing attitude at the time was the opposite. What's funniest about all of this is that at that time, Teferi had enough going for him that his weaknesses were supposedly negligble, but when Urza was printed, people were suddenly pointing out all these weaknesses, like having 0 board presence, being slow, and not being able to grind well. "Those statements seem so familiar," I thought. "Where have I heard them before?" I guess hindsight is 20/20, huh guys?
Anyway, back to Urza. As I said, my original plan was to get 30 games in on Cockatrice. I ended up getting in only 17 games with a final record of 4 wins and 13 losses. There were 3 main reasons why I stopped playing were:
I got a new job and had less time to jam games.
I just couldn't take it any more. Playing Urza was too often a frustrating, miserable experience for me due to its lack of tools and overall low individual card quality. This is what happens when you cave into peer pressure and force yourself to play a deck. It was affecting my mental state considerably too. During games, I became more easily frustrated and angry and lashed out at people who I considered friends. To those people, I apologize for my behavior. Urza did this to me. I don't recommend anyone else force themselves to play any deck for any reason, ever. That is the path to madness, and I was getting pretty fucking mad.
[[Paradox Engine]] was banned. I'll write more thoughts on this later, but it influenced why I stopped because I didn't want to have to split my analysis between pre-ban and post-ban and I didn't want to have to start over.
You may be concerned that people who opposed my viewpoints on Urza will now discredit my opinions because of the small sample size or because it was before an important card was banned. Don't worry though, even if I had gotten hundreds of games in and PEngine was still legal, I have the utmost faith that they'd still find a way to disregard my opinions (if I had to guess, I'd say they'd pursue the "confirmation bias" angle). So although I know that the most vocal Urza supporters won't listen to me, I am still going to post my own opinions on the deck. We're at a point in this community where people are afraid of speaking up with their opinions on decks or cards because they are afraid of backlash. Skilled players are writing primers for decks and not posting them because "many people will give it shit for not being a deck made by a mod". That's really sad, and it's not the kind of community I want to be a part of. If you take away anything from this disjointed mess of an article, it's not anything about Urza. It's to not be afraid to share your opinion. At the very least, you will be exposing people to your viewpoint so that they can draw their own conclusions.
We're 1700 words in, so let's finally start actually talking about Urza.
My Games With Urza
As I said earlier, I played 17 games with Urza, won 4 and lost 13. Throughout these games, I changed a few cards around here and there. I don't have every iteration of my list available, but I do have my final list available here along with a mostly complete changelog. My original goal was to play 30 games with the deck, and in those 30 games I wanted to also test out different backup win conditions. The plan was to test [[Voltaic Key]]/[[Manifold Key]]+[[Sensei's Dining Top]]+PEngine for 6 games, then [[Future Sight]]+[[Etherium Sculptor]]+Top for 6 games, then [[Retraction Helix]]+PEngine for 6 games, then [[Power Artifact]]+[[Grim Monolith]]+[[Stroke of Genius]] for 6 games, and then finally to spend my last 6 games without a third win condition and instead play value cards like [[Tezzeret, Artifice Master]] and stax like [[Storage Matrix]]. Obviously this didn't end up happening, but I did want to mention it to show that I did test multiple win conditions. For what it's worth, the version with Future Sight had the highest winrate (3-3), but those wins actually had nothing to do with Future Sight (in fact, I never drew the card at all and only saw it once off an [[Impulse]] and didn't pick it). Playing Cage and Future Sight in the same deck has never sat well with me, but I guess it's not the worst case scenario. I don't want to comment too much on the other win conditions because I never used them, but obviously the ones that require PEngine are no longer valid.
Notable cards I did not test include:
Power Artifact: Like I said, I didn't have time. That's really the only reason I didn't test it.
[[Legacy's Allure]]: I honestly can't remember why I didn't test this. The card seems totally fine. I think I was running [[Reality Shift]] instead, probably for [[Timetwister]] looping purposes.
[[Howling Mine]]: LOL
[[Key to the City]]: Unlike Howling Mine, this draw engine actually seems pretty decent. If I were still to test this, I'd probably run it in place of TAM, though it's hard to say which is better. Obviously Tezzeret has a higher initial cost, but draws more cards and doesn't require a mana investment. However, Key comes down earlier and produces mana, which TAM can't do without wasting a turn making a thopter. Key is probably the right choice between the two of them, but I can't say for sure.
[[Saprazzan Skerry]]: I get it. UU in the casting cost of your commander can be awkward, and you want to get to 4 as soon as possible. But after turn 3, this is the worst land to draw in your entire deck. If you have [[Back to Basics]] out, the card is completely dead. I'm just not sold on this card at all.
[[The Tabernacle at Pendrell Vale]]: Tabernacle is an incredibly powerful card, but since you always want both Urza and the construct in play, it seems like too much of a tax on your mana. That and the anti-synergy with [[Sai, Master Thopterist]] makes it a less attractive card to run in this deck than in Teferi or Baral. Maybe I was being too cautious, but it just didn't sit well with me.
Back to the games, of the 17 I played, I think I played most of them pretty well. There were 3 games that I lost to punts and one game that I feel I won simply through luck:
The first punt was on my literal first game with the deck due to me not tapping Static Orb on the turn before mine. Whoops. This left me with insufficient mana to deal with what Gitrog was doing and the Gitrog player won. It was my first game with the deck, but that's not really an excuse for such a boneheaded play.
The second punt was due to a mis-sequencing. An opponent had mana to cast [[Mana Drain]] and I suspected that they had it in hand (it's been too long and I don't remember if it was because they had revealed it to us or if I was just paranoid). I had the option to play either Sai or Urza along with about 3 other artifacts. Not fully thinking my turn through, I played out my artifacts followed my Sai, and then immediately realized my sequencing error. The extra thopters Sai would have given me would have let me have additional mana to stop the Graftmage Hulk player, so it was a big mana shortage on my part and I should have thought through my turn more.
The final game I lost due to punts was not due to a single punt but a series of punts. For starters, I kept a relatively bad hand that had [[Grafdigger's Cage]] and not much else going on. It couldn't even cast Urza on turn 4, that's how bad it was. But with two Hulk players at the table (Shuffle Hulk and Graftmage Hulk), I wasn't going to turn away a Cage, despite all my rage. So whether or not this is a punt was kind of debatable. What was a more obvious punt came later in the game. I had the option to either play Urza, then Static Orb, then Gilded Drake a creature (my main targets were either a 6/6 [[Toothy, Imaginary Friend]] or [[Seedborne Muse]]), or to play it safe and only Gilded Drake a creature. I chickened out and went with the second choice, but the even bigger punt was that I chose Seedborne Muse anyway when I could have had a huge Toothy. I should have tried to land the Static Orb.
The stroke of luck I had was in a pod with Shuffle Hulk, Consultation [[Golos]], and [[Ob Nixilis, the Fallen]]. I mean no disrespect to the Ob-Nixilis player, but it was almost certainly going to turn into a 3 player pod due to the rather lacking nature of mono-black. But it actually ended up effectively being a 2-player pod because the Shuffle Hulk player mulled to 4. The game wasn't a cakewalk - the Ob Nixilis player had a [[Dark Impostor]] in play with a ton of mana which made casting Urza before the combo turn rather awkward - but it still felt easier than it should have.
If we discount these 3 dumb decisions and 1 extreme display of luck, my record goes from 4-13 to 3-10. Funnily enough, this doesn't change my win percentage much - it goes from 23.5% to 23.1%. What can I conclude from all my games and results? A lot of things. I'll start with a conclusion that surprised me.
Urza is not as bad as I thought
I honestly didn't expect to say that going into this. I thought that Urza would be completely unbearable and miserable every game and get dumped on by the other decks at the table, but that only happened a few times. To my surprise, Urza held his own reasonably well against several of the top decks in the format. Being able to effectively have doubled my mana from casting Urza and keeping him alive until my next turn was a big deal and breaking parity on orbs really helped let me keep up with my opponents. There were also several other cards in the deck that really impressed me with how well they worked, including:
The construct token: This thing is a weapon to surpass Metal Gear. It gets huge very quickly and does an excellent job blocking any grounded creatures your opponents try to throw at you. It can also get to the point where late game you can use it to pressure players' life totals and force them to throw their mana dorks in front of it so that they don't take 9. It's a big deal.
[[Static Orb]]: I have to admit, I initially undervalued Static Orb. It was definitely the card I was most happy to see in my opening hand, and any hand that could cast Urza and also had a Static Orb was a snap keep. Static Orb isn't always super backbreaking, but the fact that it has such a low opportunity cost makes it an invaluable card here. But [[Cursed Totem]] is still better.
[[Spellskite]]: This little guy is great. One of the biggest problems in Urza is that you will cast Urza and someone will steal it to double their mana and rob you of your best mana source and win condition. Protecting your stax pieces and misdirecting [[Oblivion Crowns]] is also pretty valuable, and since this deck doesn't extensively use life as a resource you can redirect all day. And he blocks Tymna and taps for mana. It's everything you'd want in a utility creature!
[[Sapphire Medallion]]: This is a solid card in any mono-blue deck, but it's especially good here, and I don't think I need to explain why. Still, when I noticed just how good it was I was a little blown away.
Sai: In addition to being a 1/4 who can block Tymna, Sai's ability to not only double up all your artifacts but also turn the less useful ones into cards in the mid-late game makes him probably the most important creature in the deck.
[[Trail of Evidence]]: Similar to Sai, it creates tons of artifacts very quickly and can turn them into cards. It was so good for me that if I were to go back to other mono-blue decks (which I won't but let's pretend for a little bit), I would make sure to test it, because in a deck with ~30 instants and sorceries it would be a great way to keep up with partners.
[[Recurring Insight]]: Why did we cut this from Teferi again? This card is amazing. It should probably be in every mono-blue deck.
I'm going to marry [[Narset, Parter of Veils]]: While playing, I finally got my first taste of Narset+[[Windfall]] and it was one of the best moments I've ever had while playing CEDH. Narset is simply incredible. She warps the game around her in a way that few other stax pieces do and can still be cashed in for additional card advantage if needed. Being able to [[Mind Twist]] your opponents while still getting a new hand is one of the best ways to get ahead in a low-color blue deck. She's what got me into Oathbreaker, even though she'll probably get banned from Oathbreaker. I don't have a whole lot else to say about how good she is - she's great, she's amazing, she's beautiful, she's perfect, I love her, she's muh waifu, and I want her to step on me.
So playing the deck changed my mind about a lot of things I thought about Urza. I do now think that there is a pretty big gap between Urza and the second best mono-blue commander, and that Urza can sit at a table with the best decks and do reasonably well, even if it's not exactly favored. However, there were still some areas that I found Urza to be lacking.
...but he's not as good as the hype.
Let's go back to the winrate. 23% is close enough to the expected average winrate of 25% that I don't want to say that Urza is below average. But is it what you'd expect from a deck that people are lauding as one of the top decks in the format? I don't think so. I'd expect it to be more like 30% at least. A 25% winrate is something from a deck that people were saying was as good as, like, Godo, not a deck people were saying is as good as Kess, Zur, Najeela, etc.
But that winrate is just me. I don't think I'm a bad player, but I'm not the best player in the world either, and as I said before, I did punt a few games. How are other people doing with the deck? Well, I don't know. I couldn't find any data on any other players' winrates with Urza - not on PlayEDH or on CEDH Ranked - so I have only my own experiences to look at. If you would like to share your winrate with Urza, please feel free to do so, but I would also like to know what the pod composition of each of your wins was.
Speaking of pod composition, let's talk about matchups next. I'll skip the partner matchups since I talked about them extensively before. Instead I'll talk about what I consider to be the other best decks in the format, as well as my other game losses.
Najeela: In my previous post I said that Urza and his construct are good at blocking 2 warriors but bad at blocking 10 warriors. This is true and it's a relevant weakness, but it's ultimately not why I lost 2 games to Najeela. One loss was because the Najeela player was able to dump his hand into play turn 1, get WUBRG by turn 2, and play a protected Derevi turn 3. Another loss was due to a Najeela Aluren deck. The line the Aluren player was using was to find [[Cavern Harpy]] and [[Derevi]] to make infinite mana, tutor [[Lightning Helix]] with [[Spellseeker]], and loop it with [[Eternal Witness]] and [[Shrieking Drake]]. So one loss was to a conventional line and was was to an unconventional line. But you know what card could have stopped them both? Cursed Totem. And you know what stax piece Urza can't run? Cursed Totem. So although Urza is probably the best choice mono-blue has against Najeela, it's still an uphill battle.
Gitrog: Speaking of decks that get shut down by Cursed Totem, two of my losses were to Gitrog. Mono-blue tends to struggle with Gitrog because the combo is so reslient, can be done at instant speed, and there are about a dozen ways for them to protect it. Mono-blue really needs to stop frog when it gets cast, steal it when it's been around for a turn, or play Cursed Totem to stop them. Since Urza can't play Cursed Totem, losing to [[Cavern of Souls]], [[Savage Summoning]], and [[Autumn's Veil]] seem all but unavoidable. On top of all that, the construct can't beat Gitrog in combat because of Deathtouch (because a 6/6 really needed deathtouch, apparently). So this is another deck that I think Urza will really struggle with going forward.
First Sliver, Kess, Zur: Weirdly, I didn't play against any of these while testing. I don't really know why and I can't draw a ton of conclusions about the matchups, but if I had to guess I'd say that they're probably even at best for Urza with Silver being the hardest to play against. Sliver is only affected by a few of Urza's stax pieces, and they mostly only hurt it if they're not on a Food Chain line. You still basically play the same way against all three - counter their threats, make sure they don't get too much value out of their commanders (this part shouldn't be too hard against Sliver lol), and try to win before they can.
My other losses: I lost one game to another Urza player, but I don't remember much about it. I lost one game to a Yawgmoth player, but mostly because I had to mull to 5 and the player playing GW Sisay Pure Stax got a turn 1 [[Null Rod]]. A lot of people think Null Rod doesn't affect Urza. That's not true. It just affects him less than it does other mono-blue decks. I lost one game to a 5C Sisay Stax deck that was basically 5C Blood Pod. The Blood Pod matchup has never been good for mono-blue, and when you lose Cursed Totem and they go up a color, it gets even worse for you. Urza doesn't change that. And then I lost one game to Yuriko because he swung with 2 ninjas and flipped 26 damage worth of nukes to burn us out. #JustYurikoThings
Since I talked about cards that impressed me above, I'll talk now about cards that I was underwhelmed by:
Lands that don't tap for blue mana: I never thought [[Buried Ruin]] would disappoint me, but it has. Who would have thought that UU would be hard to get to in a mono-blue deck? And yet there were several games I lost because I didn't have enough colored mana sources early on to actually cast Urza in a timely manner.
[[Tezzeret the Seeker]] - I guess I'm only disappointed in this because of the years I spent playing Teferi, where Tezzeret was effectively a second copy of The Chain Veil. If he started at 5 loyalty he would have been fantastic here, but since he doesn't he's a little bit underwhelming, especially if you already have Static Orb in play. I probably expected too much and I know that mono-blue is very lacking in tutors, but I just don't like him here.
So a lot of what I said previously about mono-blue being a limited color identity still applies, and, as strong as he is, Urza doesn't really help fill in the holes. He also opens up some new holes since he can't play Cursed Totem. Previously I said that Cursed Totem is one of the best stax pieces in the format. I no longer believe that. I now think that it's THE best stax piece in the format. Cage is second, and although there isn't a huge gap between them, it's still a noticeable one. Some people may say I love Cursed Totem too much, but you know what? Ever since I threw out my old mattress and replaced it with a pile of Cursed Totems, I've gotten the best sleep of my life.
Pour One Out for Paradox Engine
The banning of Paradox Engine was unfortunate for Urza, both because it shut off several alternate win lines and because it just makes the deck less effective at accumulating value. There seem to be two opposing schools of thought on how much Urza is actually affected by PEngine's ban. In one corner we have Chicken Little, who thinks that this ban spells doom for this deck and that the sky is falling, and in the other we have The Immovable Object who thinks that the ban doesn't affect Urza at all. I'm in between these two groups. I think that the loss of PEngine makes it harder for Urza to win since now he has to rely on two-card combos, and tutoring 2 cards is harder than tutoring 1 card (twice as hard, in fact). However, a lot of other decks that were affected by this ban were hurt just as much, if not more, so Urza's overall position in the CEDH meta at large isn't really going to change.
Conclusion
Ultimately, when I think about how good a deck is in CEDH, I ask my self "Would this deck be good going into a meta blind?". The answer to this is definitely yes for Shuffle Hulk and CST, and I'd probably say yes to Zur too, but I can't answer yes for Urza. If the answer to that is no, I ask "What meta would this deck be good in?". I can think of metas where Najeela, Kess, Gitrog, and Sliver would all be good, but I still can't think of one for Urza. Urza is definitely the best mono-blue commander, and he can sit at a competitive pod and do reasonably well, but he doesn't do enough to be one of the top decks of the format. I definitely wouldn't put him on the level of partners, and I also wouldn't put it on the level as the big 5 (I'm tired of listing them out, you should know who I'm talking about by now). Urza is definitely better than Parun, which is more than I can say for other mono-blue commanders. I'm not even sure Simic Partners is better than Urza anymore - they're probably about the same. I'd put Urza on the same level as Breya, Godo, Jhoira, or Yisan - all of them can thrive in the right environment, but in a high stakes situation I wouldn't play them. I wouldn't play Urza in such a situation, and I can't recommend them to others either.
So those are all the thoughts I have on Urza right now. I don't particularly care if you agree or disagree with me, what's important to me is that whatever conclusion you came to, you came to on your own based on what you've read from both the pro-Urza side and me, as well as your own experience playing with or against Urza (if you have any). And I hope that if any of you have an unpopular opinion about a deck that you're not afraid to share it or talk about it. Thank you.