r/CompetitiveEDH • • Jun 20 '24 Bravo Heart of Silver

Discussion Could we not gatekeep so much over budget in this sub?

0 Upvotes

It’s really frustrating to see and just generally makes this a less welcoming place. I know there are some good points (I’ll address below), but things like “this isn’t cEDH” or “go to another sub” and all those low effort snarky replies are not helpful to anyone.

To address some of the points:

  1. “Just proxy.” This is good advice, but they may be playing somewhere that doesn’t allow it, or with people who just won’t. Or they may just prefer not to. Either way, I think it’s good to encourage proxying, but if they say they can’t/won’t we can still give them helpful advice and not just flame.

  2. “That’s not cEDH.” This is not good advice and is just generally unhelpful. I feel like this gets pushed the hardest by the new generation of players who don’t have much context and feel like everything has to be black or white. Yes, cEDH stands for competitive and it does mean trying to win is the primary goal, much like other competitive formats like Legacy, Vintage, or Modern. But what’s missed- and again I feel like this is probably people who only know EDH and have never played any other format- is that in general, outside actual regional tournaments with prizing, lots of people play other competitive formats with budget constraints. That doesn’t make them “not Modern” and other format subs don’t turn people away or flame them for looking for budget brews. That’s fine for playing at your LGS, even for prized games. Lots of Modern players and other competitive format players are just playing with what they can reasonably get their hands on, and it’s absolutely fine for cEDH players to as well. You guys need to quite gatekeeping over this, because it’s not how it works with other competitive formats and it shouldn’t be for cEDH, either.

In general I just wish if you guys can’t be helpful to new players, you wouldn’t comment at all instead of downvoting them and pushing them away with shitty comments.

And if you haven’t played other competitive magic formats before, please check yourself. You’re pushing for an ideal you don’t even understand.

Cheers.

Edit: Unsurprisingly, the comments here prove me unequivocally right about the shoddy state of this community. I’m talking about budget decks, and I have dozens of comments from people flaming me for defending unviable/jank deck lists, which is not something I’m talking about or defending. It’s telling about the quality of this community that there can’t even be a good faith discussion about this topic without it immediately devolving into disingenuous straw man arguments.


r/CompetitiveEDH • • Sep 23 '24

Discussion Dictating How Commander Should be Played

9 Upvotes

‪Biggest gripe is that CRC showed they can dictate how they think commander should be played by banning cards. People will say, “But rule zero.” You can support and promote rule zero by not banning cards. Put these cards in a list of suggested talking points vs banning them outright.

“The philosophy of Commander prioritizes creativity, and one of the ways we have historically reflected that in the rules and banlist is to encourage a slower pace of game than traditional formats. This gives decks time and space to develop and do different things. We have a goal to make it easier for players who enjoy slower, more social games to have an environment for them to explore.”

This is achievable without bans. This is achievable through rule 0. Separate the formats if you’re going to impact the player base like this.


r/CompetitiveEDH • • Sep 26 '24

Community Content Counterpoint: cEDH Doesn't Need to be Separated. Casuals Do.

Thumbnail reddit.com
32 Upvotes

r/CompetitiveEDH • • Jul 14 '26

General Discussion / Question Hot take: Separating the format is actually fine, and we might actually see it happen.

62 Upvotes

For any ban discussion, you need to provide a reason for why it needs to be banned for casual, especially since there's already a gamechanger list for those who don't want to play against them.

cEDH-only players often forget that commander is fundamentally a casual format, and they really are the minority that shouldn't be focused on for any rule or policy changes.

Separating cEDH into its own format and curate its own banlist is the only answer.

We've already seen WotC separating casual brawl and competitive brawl on arena with different banlists, so I don't think the "cEDH is EDH" argument exists anymore.


r/CompetitiveEDH • • Jul 04 '26

Community Content Starting a cEDH series, the first episode is on Nick Fury. Is he just the best 5c turbo shell ever printed?

6 Upvotes

I just started a cEDH series and this is episode 1, we would love feedback on it. https://youtu.be/0IzKD8ZJO4k

The episode is about Nick Fury and how his deck might be the best five-color turbo shell/deck we've ever seen. He has Rog Si speed, but the white and green upsides(Silence, Grand Abolisher, Crop Rot, etc.) are basically free. My take is he has zero identity, just cheap and 5 colors.

I think he's potentially a health problem for the format.


r/CompetitiveEDH • • Sep 28 '24 Diamonds are Forever Heart of Silver Take My Silver Polished Silver Turd

Discussion In depth thoughts 1 week post ban

87 Upvotes

Personal attacks are stupid and counter productive. No room for hate. However, the community has been very dismissive of its OGs. Those of us who have been playing for over 20 years and got the commander format started in our local areas. Many people first got cards they valued and enjoyed banned out of the blue, then they go on twitter and there’s hundreds of people saying “your stupid for buying them” “magic isn’t an investment” “your fault for spending money on it” etc. kicking people when they are down is just so uncool. You think the guy who just lost a thousand dollars on his cards and had his favorite cEDH deck destroyed needs a bunch of people also telling him he is stupid for even having invested in those cards in the first place. People like myself took to twitter because we hadn’t seen a ban in years, and the RC seemed to say that they had no interest in banning stuff just a few weeks ago. Then to have not just 1 but 3 high value cards, all played heavily in cEDH, which has a solid player base now, go at the same time is bewildering. I was looking for justification and all I was seeing was people posting, “your a dumbass for spending that much on cards” “fuck cEDH, that’s now how commander should be played,” etc, etc, etc. I’m a calm person by nature, and I have enough money to absorb the loss of my textured foil jeweled lotus, green and yellow neon crypts, and my dockside.

However, this still bothers me in so many ways.

  1. A handful of people banned cards in a format that millions of people played because it went against “their” vision of what commander should be, based on “their” playgroups and “their” followers who reach out to them. I travel a ton for work, and every LGS I visit has a healthy cEDH table. I would say roughly 1/5-1/6 of the players at most LGS play cEDH now. To completely ignore the fact that you’re devastating (massively warping) their format is not ok.

  2. There was zero consideration for the value of these cards. I don’t think ban decisions should be made based on card value, but it should factor in to how we approach these issues. Having a watchlist and then signaling “we are looking at these cards and will make a final decision in a year from now. That lets the market stabilize more reasonably, and people holding them at that point are doing it knowing it full well could be worthless. That’s just one of many options to foreshadow that “hey, don’t spend crazy money on these cards at the moment unless your willing to loose it” because some of us have had cards like crypt since commander was a format, and a ban of it was unthinkable.

  3. Unlike other formats, commander is much more player driven, and so are all the commander offshoots. Josh Lee Kwai put a poll on his Twitter after the ban that had 20,000 people vote, and it was 50/50 in favor of the ban. Likely, had that not included Nadu, I’m sure it would have skewed more in opposition. Why couldn’t the RC have done some community polling ahead of time? Why did they feel that they could not trust people in the CAG as much as people in the RC?

  4. CAG was not consulted on this and they didn’t care about their input, the magic community as a whole was not consulted about this and their input was not considered, some members of the RC, Olivia specifically, were not in favor of this. So then why would they make this decision?

  5. Sol ring is a worse offender, especially for casuals, than crypt. Everything wrong with the other banned cards can be said about sol ring, and often it can be fetched up with things like urza’s saga and there is no disadvantage to it. It’s arguably worse than any of the cards they banned. Crypt was rarely played at casual tables, and when it was, it was not often. Sol ring is very often played.

  6. The ban changes NOTHING! There’s hundreds of cards that allow crazy explosive starts, sol ring, mana vault, grim monolith, mox diamond, mox opal, chrome mox, lotus petal, mox amber, culling the weak, spirit guides, rituals, 0 cost commander (rograk) with things like phyrexian tower, you have ancient tomb, gemstone caverns, lake of the dead, scorched ruins, Gaea’s cradle, Serra’s sanctum, metal worker, etc. so it begs the question why the specific cards they chose? I could be wrong, but I don’t believe there’s a shit load of casual players slapping down jeweled lotus and crypts with their high powered commanders and looping dockside for a quick win…..if there are a ton of casuals playing these cards, then it means they like them! So why ban them in a fun format.

  7. The premise of banning in a casual format is sketchy at best. It’s casual and fun. If people don’t want to play against certain things, they can rule zero. It’s easy to say “hey, our table does no sol rings and mana crypt’s”, which has happened to me many times. All good. It’s much more difficult to rule in a banned card, people will say well that’s banned, or even if they let you, they probably didn’t bring their own and include it in their deck since it’s also banned, so it lopsides the power off the bat. CEDH also has organized tournaments with many players and they publish decks on mtgtop8 and elsewhere, so you can really rule zero in banned cards at organized, competitive, tournaments with prizes and stuff. Ideally, commander should just be everything is legal save for a few truly undesirable cards, cEdH guys do their thing, and casuals can do whatever they want under that umbrella. They don’t have to build with, be okay with, etc. they can choose to rule out cards, or even not play with a problem player.

  8. The RC should be more accountable to the players. They are not a vast organization that’s reaching all the populations involved and collecting data etc. they aren’t even consulting their handful of CAG people on their decisions. They assume the few of them are good making massive changes in their own? They have almost no justification, and almost no follow up. Then doubled down on a bad decision. Although wizards makes bad decisions too, as a very large organization with like 1,500 employees across almost all continents, they can actually make better ban decisions. They can make data driven decision where a small RC cannot. It would be wiser to have a list of cards that attain a certain power level, or “the following are generally discouraged from casual play” and then list them.

  9. At this point the RC feels like a small playgroup. (Our little playgroup thinks these cards aren’t that fun, so we will just ban them for the entire vast EDH community, without any warning, any consultation, any feedback, etc.)

  10. Bans have always been made to ban cards that people are forced to play but don’t want to. When a meta is 60% 1 deck because it’s clearly the best due to 1-2 specific cards, so you either have to play with that card or against it, and you don’t want to. That’s bad. That’s what bans are for. This was the opposite, people liked to play with crypt for example because it was good and fun, it could slot in literally any deck, you could play many more decks because of these. It’s counterintuitive to what bans are meant to do.

It’s been a disappointing week. I’ve seen people freak out online, I had a guy walk into our game store earlier this week, throw his cards on a table and walked out and said fuck magic im not playing anymore, he just left all his cards for random people to take. I’ve been playing magic with him since I was in highschool 16-17 years ago. Personally, I put in a massive order of proxies this morning. Pulled all my high value cards out of my decks, and I’m deciding whether or not I just use proxies permanently going forward. I love rare and valuable cards, I take pride in owning them, I think it’s cool that although magic isn’t meant to be an investment it can be. Every collectible is like that, old comics, old toys, old sports cards, and of course magic.

My favorite deck that I owned was imskir. I tailored the whole deck out, foiled it out, and had fun with it. It’s the one deck every time I played people with it, they would go out of their way to tell me how cool it was and how much they liked to see it play. It was very unique and cool. This ban destroyed it. I needed all of those cards to make it playable. It wasn’t cEDH, but it was high power. I played it exclusively at high powered tables. Had to take it apart today. It’s a hard pill to swallow, an RC that puts their vision of what commander should look like over what the player base wants. Loosing a lot of super valuable cards, seeing my LGS take a huge hit, seeming people quit the game, loosing my favorite deck, having the cEDH meta shrink to less decks and less blue, less big cmc commanders, and on top of it all, watching the plethora of petty people reveling in other losses online. How are hateful people created? Take things from them without reason, make them feel like their opinion doesn’t matter, insult them, etc, and you will push people to the extreme.

A lot of us nerds escape a difficult life with our games and hobbies. I had a rough upbringing and magic has been a huge part of my life for 22 years now. I think this leads to their being a lot of people who are mentally unwell or on the borderline. When you take their voice away, disregard their opinion, cause them to loose money, hit the deck or format they liked, and tell them they are stupid and dumb for even liking those cards or owning those cards. People are being pushed to the edge, it’s the catalyst for mentally unwell people to flip. There would have been much less vitriol had people not been kicking others while they were down.


r/CompetitiveEDH • • Feb 20 '24

Community Content Should you LIE in cEDH?

0 Upvotes

https://youtu.be/4aZPHkh_CBE

Yo it's Ganesh from Deck Check, I've made an educational video on a recent Top 16 situation, the MTG rules on lying, and cEDH culture. Please let me know in the comments your thoughts on this issue. :)


r/CompetitiveEDH • • Nov 21 '25

Discussion Stopping wins is a trap

0 Upvotes

I see so many people talk about picking decks that can stop other people from winning and that is like their main priority.

Everyone can play what they want but this strategy is just extremely suboptimal in a 4 player game. Most experienced players seem to understand this after a while. This is a fast format, most decks only need a single opportunity to win. Building your deck around stopping wins is futile.

There is a reason when talking about the best decks in the format it's the ones that can win games. Not the ones that prevent it.

Stop being scared of someone else winning and be the person that puts win on the stack. I see this in every comp game I play to be fair. People play too scared in general because they are scared of making mistakes or losing.


r/CompetitiveEDH • • Apr 11 '25

Discussion The bans were the problem not rhystic study.

1 Upvotes

Ever since the bans, the best thing in the game to do is to sit back grind. There's far less options for winning quickly, boiling down to almost only breach and Thadsa's Oracle. People complain about the long grindy games but the problem isn't suddenly rhystic study is better The problem is all the other win conditions are worse. There's no way to push a win on turn three as easily. Should certain turbo enablers be unbanned? or should rhystic study be banned?

EDIT: loved the discussion and i apoligize for the grammar it was written with voice to text, i just wanted to get out my thoughts on the matter and see what people thought of the bans. I think the bans were overall healthy to the format. However the massive downgrade to turbo decks and getting rid of the best card to punish big greedy plays did contribute to midrange hell. Thanks for all the support!


r/CompetitiveEDH • • May 27 '25

Community Content Cheating and Cheaters

49 Upvotes

I’ve been thinking about this a lot recently, and with everything happening, now seems like as good a time as any.

To start, I want you all to know who I am, because I stand behind what I’m about to say. My name is David, aka Bowlfish, and I’ve been playing cEDH since the Flash ban in 2020. I’ve been attending and grinding tournaments since the end of 2022. I was lucky enough to attend the Topdeck Invitational and Land, Go TimeTwister Invitational last year, and I was at the Black Lotus Invitational this weekend. My Topdeck profile will be linked below for anyone who wants to bash my win rate or my conversion rate.

Now that everyone knows who I am—on to the matter at hand: cheaters in cEDH. First, cheating in a game of Magic: The Gathering is an awful thing to do, and I do not condone it in any way. I believe cheaters should be DQ’d from events per WotC guidelines. However, I don’t see any reason why someone who has cheated in the past should receive a lifetime ban for a first offense. Everyone makes mistakes, and to quote the TO from this weekend: "This game and these events are my blood. I believe with that blood, as others do, that if I were to judge an individual on a single or few instances of the total of their life, I'd be greatly undervaluing a person..."

With that being said, there have been a lot of calls for lifetime bans for players who cheated just once. I believe that anyone who wants a chance at redemption and acceptance back into this community should be given that chance. Someone who is caught cheating will wear the badge of “cheater” for as long as they play, and there is no shaking that stigma. But in the case of this weekend, Temujin spoke with the judges and some high-level players of his own accord to tell them what he had done and who he was before the event started. He knew that might cause issues, so he took responsibility for his actions and let people know. The judges watched him closely throughout the weekend and found no evidence of him cheating.

All this to say: people on here seem incredibly quick to write others off entirely for a single mistake, as if they themselves are without fault. Anyone who is openly trying to redeem themselves—and is willing to own up to and fix their mistake—will always have a seat in my pod and in my games.

Topdeck: https://topdeck.gg/profile/0xtjvh4eBRX61KamPNkYFcFufWI3


r/CompetitiveEDH • • Sep 23 '24

Discussion Jesus, some people here are entitled

0 Upvotes

This recent banlist is not an attack on cEDH. It's addressing 4 particularly toxic cards in the current casual EDH format, something that the RC has gone on record saying is their primary focus. The argument "Casual self-regulates it" flies out the window when you realise 80% of casual games are played with strangers at an LGS.

Should they have banned Thoracle? Yes. Will Consult Turbo decks be more prevalent? Yes.

But it remains that a cEDH-exclusive banlist is fundamentally going against the point of cEDH, which is to take EDH as far to the limits of power as possible, and trying to formulate one out of the notion of "The RC hates us precious cEDH players" is laughable and showcases the entitlement some people in this community have for playing the "superior" format.


r/CompetitiveEDH • • Aug 07 '25

Community Content No Proxies and the God of Commander Tournament

0 Upvotes

All the time, on this sub, we read posts about proxies. Generally, they are all something to the effect of "I want to play the player not the wallet" and even the extreme "cEDH without proxies isn't real cEDH".

The God of Commander Tournament, however, had no proxies. Rather than call it a "fake tournament" or "not real cEDH" everyone on the sub loved the card innovations in the various decks that were almost certainly a result of not being allowed to proxy extremely expensive cards (especially the artifacts, where virtually no deck had a complete suite of the expensive artifacts we take for granted).

In our metagame, compared to theirs, we are *incredibly* homogenous. Like, insanely so. The TnT decks here are within 10 cards of each other, and over there they had 30+ differences.

Is there an upside to not allowing proxies just to force people to be creative? Why was there such a positive response to the brewing at this event but when someone comes on here and says their event is no proxy we get 35+ replies dismissing a no proxy event as "not real" and "fake cedh" ?

Can anyone make sense of this? It seems like not having proxies made creativity explode, whereas proxies basically eventually result in everyone running the same lists within 10 cards. That seems like a really good thing? Why did everyone have such a positive response to this no-proxy event and its innovation instead of dismissing it as just "fighting against wallets" and moving on?

Is the general consensus here that this tournament was "not real cEDH" and "fake" or that there was really sick innovation decks at this event? At the risk of *gasp* suggesting proxies are a bad thing wouldn't we want to move more in this direction in terms of creativity?


r/CompetitiveEDH • • Mar 31 '24

CEDH Channel Info Wanted to alert this community about a 14-year-old CEDH channel, curated by an Old School Pro

0 Upvotes

Hey guys, hope you've had a good weekend.

For the last 14 years or so, I've been working hard on this format, playing and designing mostly on Magic Online. When decks have proved both fun and effective, I've built them in paper as well.

Over time, I've populated my Youtube channel with hundreds and hundreds of games of CEDH, played competitively and mostly 1 vs 1. I figured fans of this format might enjoy my content, particularly if they're aiming to improve their deckbuilding and their play.

Here are links to a few specifically intense games I recently added to the channel, as well as some deck techs. I welcome all comments and feedback, and I'll reply to all constructive inquiries.

Insane game featuring Rograkh/Tevesh vs. Gut and Agent of the Iron Throne

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fLbqaiTfokM

Intense game of Rograkh/Tevesh vs Skithiryx with a huge win streak on the line

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YnDz5UyYVAc&t=1s

Crazy comeback with Omnath, Locus of Mana vs Imoti, Celebrant of Bounty

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XmWgGdX56pc

Recent Minsc and Boo deck tech

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=S-0NDpW7rlY&t=3044s

Thanks for your interest!


r/CompetitiveEDH • • Jun 03 '21

Community Content/Discussion anos MH1 set review

1 Upvotes

too tired and too many cards for an intro, also changing the tiers to S through F.

S:

[[Profane Tutor]]: Profane Tutor is most likely the best suspend spell in cedh. Turning a single yidris or ESPECIALLY codie trigger into any spell in your deck is just insane. Now has a 1 card combo with any one drop and sufficient board presence. Absurd card.

[[Ragavan, Nimble Pilferer]]: This card does so much. It acts as a ramp engine similar to Malcolm, but fills the spot a dork does on the curve, whilst being annoying vs any sort of topdeck manipulation effect, and providing card advantage. Ragavan will go in almost any red deck, its just way too flexible, powerful, and adorable.

[[Ignoble Hierarch]]: Hes a dork who makes 3 colors, what more do you need? Just another consistency piece for jund dork decks like foodchain korvold/sliver, kenrith evo, najeela, and whatever else you want.

A:

[[Urza's Saga]]: A very unique card, Urza's Saga is a tutor for any 1 drop artifact you need, such as: top, voltaic key, expedition map, etc, while being a land and making a beater in the late game. Very low opportunity cost with medium upside. Cool card.

[[Dragon's Rage Channeler]]: The Channeler acts as breach fuel, clears the top for citadel, turns topdeck tutors into entomb, and is a damn good tymna beater too. Should be in basically any mardu or sans blue turbo ad nauseam shell.

[[Dress Down]]: Dress Down acts as a one turn tactical nuke vs stax decks, turning off most of the best hate in the format while drawing a card and acting as a dockside/thassa's oracle counter when you need it to. Great role player to make sure your local archon of emeria player KNOWS nobody else likes them.

[[Dauthi Voidwalker]]: Finally, we have our very own leyline of the void on a stick. However, dauthi is so much more. Not only is it not white, opening up decks like tasigur, thrasios tevesh, kroxa stax, or curious control, you get to buy back one of your opponents great spells like say, demonic tutor or ad nauseam! A staple for any of the slower grindier decks who want high impact hatebears, and even ones that lean more proactive.

B:

[[Solitude]]: Solitude is STP on a body, with the upside of also being a pitch removal spell. The body is great, not only so you can worldly tutor, fauna shaman, or survival of the fittest for it, but also as a 2 for 1 in grindy games where combat matters, and a way to bypass stax on spells like archon of valor's reach or thalia. Super sick card for lower color decks.

[[Yavimaya, Cradle of Growth]]: Yavimaya does a few unique things, notably with two lands: mystic sanctuary and gaea's cradle. Working in tandem with effects like arbor elf to untap cradle, or any of the ranger effects to reset sanctuary or cradle gives Yavimaya serious upside, and again, its only a land. The cost really isn't that large.

[[Esper Sentinel]]: Sentinel, affectionately called "Rhystic Buddy", is the newest punisher effect in cedh. While much weaker than study or remora, sentinel does absolutely provide a worthwhile amount of CA, especially for a 1 mana white permanent. Notably it scales with kenrith and heliod, becoming a legitimate annoyance in the late game.

[[Unmarked Grave]]: A much fairer entomb, Grave still provides value binning worldgorger dragon, dakmor salvage, and random stuff like dockside to pair with reanimate effects in mardu naus. More narrow than entomb but still worth playing.

[[Priest of Fell Rites]]: Priest fills a role similar to apprentice necromancer, but leans more on generic value than being specifically strong with protean hulk. Its nice that you can reanimate 2 things, or bin this and use it as a reanimation spell.

C:

[[Sanctum Weaver]]: Another dork for FFTR combos and stuff, nice how it comes down t2 not t3 like faeburrow. Idk where this will be played but it definitely will be imo.

[[Out of Time]]: Removing an entire board of important commanders, stax pieces, or just dorks for multiple turns is absolutely a powerful effect, and while you can't break parity on this effect, only interacting with creatures is an abusable asymmetry. Also, you can zur for this, pretty sick.

[[Void Mirror]]: Weird pseudo anti artifact stax and anti force of will protection piece. Probably goes somewhere, and it locks with all the shit lavinia locks with. It's a lot more narrow than other anti artifact pieces tho, so it won't be common.

[[Galvanic Relay]]: I think of this as a mini wheel for turbo decks after they shit out rocks and rituals, but don't have a true payoff atm. Being red is great with jwill, and impulse draw is great with led. This might just not be powerful enough.

[[Harmonic Prodigy]]: Prodigy doubles some sweet stuff. Inalla triggers, krark triggers, thassa's oracle triggers(?), etc. Especially for krark, this card brings some unique things to the table.

D:

[[Suspend]]: Too narrow and not permanent. The comparisons to delay lack a lot of nuance, and delay isn't exactly a top tier card rn either imo.

[[Gaea's Will]]: I'm probably too high on will, but I see potential as a yidris, codie, or bring to light target here, especially btl. Imagine casting btl with led in the yard and just chaining gaeas will+rituals into btl for a tutor for ad nauseam, fucking sick.

[[Tavern Scoundrel]]: Scoundrel provides an extremely strong engine for any deck that flips coins, especially krark the thumbless piles. Sadly those decks are still plagued by the same issues as before, being their inconsistency.

[[Grist, The Hunger Tide]]: Removal and a token maker you can neoform or finale for. Not flashy, just another role filler in green.

[[Endurance]]: A green creature that fills the role of a loop effect, niche grave/oracle hate, and it can be free? Pretty cool, the body is great too. Not dying to 3/xes is nice, especially if you have tymna or other cards that care about combat.

F:

[[Strike It Rich]]: Filtering mana is cool and all, but I really don't see the appeal of this card.

[[Serra's Emissary]]: Have you ever wanted to not die to beats in your slow durdly winconless stax deck? Rejoice, the 4 yasharn players, for you have received the ultimate answer to the bane of your existence: Kraum having flying! If you can manage to actually cast this thing, it should be good if you already turned off people's win conditions I think. This just feels worse than elesh norn in like 3 different ways tho.

[[Yusri, Fortune's Flame]]: I really struggle to imagine when this guy draws more cards than other UR commanders. Randomly doming you is an annoying downside, and you only get the omni effect 1 in every 32 combat steps. Just no.

[[Moderation]]: This card is a trap. It is a large, gaping, wide open trap. Sure it has no downside under rule of law, but how often are you casting more than 1 spell per turn cycle in your UWx rule of law deck? What about when you don't have rule of law? Fuck, this card doesn't even draw for an entire turn cycle unless you have instants you want to fire off. Pair being slow and clunky with an annoying mana cost and you have a recipe for mediocrity.

[[Garth One-Eye]]: He's worse than every other 5c commander but hes five colors and has a buried alive pile of anger, deadeye navigator, and something else and an intuition pile of faithless looting, deadeye, and anger that wins with any reanimation effect on deadeye. (U can make buried a 1 card win with priest of fell rites for a comfy total of 5WWUBBBRG spread across multiple turns).


r/CompetitiveEDH • • Sep 17 '24

Discussion Is The One Ring Really That Good

0 Upvotes

So I'm fine-tuning a deck, and have only really seen it in about 3 lists for high power, D, and C, but it's all over mid tier and I just don't get it

I will mention the decks I'm looking at are black, and for that why not just run Necropotence, and necrodo if you really feel the need to have a second draw engine

In any mixed black pairing you have Rhystic, trouble in pairs, library, I'm sure red has a good one I'm forgetting

Like I get that it being a discount T protection when it comes down is pretty solid, and I can't argue with that

But besides that and it being colorless, i just don't see the appeal given that its 4 mana and take 4 turbs to get going

Am I missing something or is it just a decently over hyped card


r/CompetitiveEDH • • Dec 06 '25

Community Content Should Orcish Bowmasters Be Banned in cEDH?

0 Upvotes

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5570n1sobAU

Howdy, it's Ganesh from Deck Check.

I made a video covering Bowmasters: meta strength, a recent cEDH survey, and whether it really deserves a ban. Please let me know what you think. :)


r/CompetitiveEDH • • Sep 01 '20

Discussion Should cEDH be it’s own format?

1 Upvotes

My SO and I have discussed this a couple of times. She’s on the “its already a different format, why not break away, make its own banlist so casual players can have things like flash” (im paraphrasing she’s very good with words). Me being in the boat of “but then its not edh.”

To me the point of cEDH is to play edh with a no-holds-barred strategy of playing magic at peak efficiency. Where the game is a race to the finish line. Casual edh is more of a journey where everyone is trying to “do the thing.”

Cedh and casual will always be separate “formats” persay because of differing ideology. And while they are separate beasts i dont want cedh to be “its own format.” Because then its not edh anymore. The format will split with people wanting to stay in the old edh because, you know, edh is king. And i dont think the cEDH will have the same feel.

Idk how i can convince her that it should stay edh. But maybe it shouldnt i could be wrong. Thoughts?


r/CompetitiveEDH • • Apr 17 '26

Deck Fine Tuning Etali, Primal Conqueror - cEDH Primer

0 Upvotes

I've been on Etali as my main cEDH deck for a while, and finally took a stab at writing the primer I wanted when I started. This is my current list and every number comes from simulating this exact 99 and my experience.

I ran 500,000 Monte Carlo simulations across 16 Etali builds to get real answers on T1/T2 casting, mulligans, and which cards actually pull their weight. Rules interactions are checked against the Comp Rules. Every card in the 99 is covered. This is not to say this is the best or the fastest of builds, but that it helps to define our needs as Etali pilots and how to think about achieving them. This is a working document and simulation logic is included at the end. Always open to feedback!

Examples of some things that are in this primer:

Mulligan tables down to keep-4 with T1/T2 split at every depth. You hit T1/T2 about 2 in 3 games, mulling to keep-5. Push to keep-4 with a T3 fallback and it's closer to 3 in 4.

Card tier lists for T1 rate and T2 lift Some cards that look great on paper are surprisingly mediocre when the sim runs.

5 win lines walked through step by step: Food Chain + Squee, Dualcaster loops, Off the Flips, Underworld Breach + Wheel storm, and Transform. The Twinflame + Eternal Witness + Lightning Bolt kill is written out in full because that's the one people actually make you demonstrate.

Hate piece breakdown.

Sticker rules and vowel math for ________ Goblin. Including what happens when your opponents copy it (spoiler: nothing, unless they brought their own sheets).

If you're new to the dino, start at the commander section. If you already know the deck, there's a Quick Reference at the bottom with one-line reminders for the stuff that matters.

If I got something wrong, tell me. I'll fix it.

[https://moxfield.com/decks/aqFZgJwFXU-Y04qKFRlJSA/primer]

ETALI!!!


r/CompetitiveEDH • • Sep 29 '21

Discussion cEDH has become too narrow and the database is losing it's credibility.

0 Upvotes

Edit/TL;DR: I'm complaining about some (Not all) cEDH players I observe citing the database as the "be all, end all" of what's viable to put down good ideas from other players, despite a clear lack of consistency that I point to in the post and my frustration poured over in this post.

It feels like every other post on this sub is trying to offer something "overlooked" in cEDH. It's not that it's overlooked, it's that the cEDH audience won't accept anything that isn't the de facto best of what's to offer, and honestly it drives me nuts because usually what is meant by that is "it's the lowest effective mana value of this type of spell that's playable" which I think is wrong. Usually the argument feels like anything more than a mana value of 1 or 2 is "ToO SlOw" or not the "OpTiMaL ChOiCe" or if it's any good it's "WiN MoRe". The amount of times I've looked at a Chain of Vapor and groaned because it was absolutely no use in the situation and I lost is way too damn high.

People need to get their heads out of their elitist ass and play what they want to play. That 5cmc bomb you pulled you wanna run (I.E a Scarab God)? Run it. The counters and removal in a lot of 3-5c decks are too narrow now and get much worse against certain threats. Just look at how often a Jeska/Ishai deck kills with Ishai because it can't be answered effectively. I think there is absolutely competitive viability to decks/cards that lay low and let your opponents fight it out just to deploy a game winning bomb, bonus points if you can hold up mana and interact.

"But if you're in black and not running Ad Naus you're doing it wrong". NO, I know MANY players who will target people out of the game just for the simple fact they know they're playing Ad Naus to the point I stopped running it. That's assuming you didn't kill yourself or whiff on the Ad Naus, which feels like every second cEDH youtube video at this point.

The decklist database is a joke too. The rules specifically state that decks can't be added if they're outclassed in what they do, yet there are a million mono-blue lists. What does Arcum, High Tide Jace, Chain Veil Teferi or Azami have that Urza doesn't do better? Rashmi Control I don't think has been a thing for a couple of years since Curious Control does what it wants to to but better and with more colours. Or also if a pet deck does well, all of a sudden it's on the list even though it's outclassed by better options in the same colours. Like why is Birgi and Magda on the list when there are just as potent threats that aren't Godo? For a long time nobody would even consider anything that wasn't Godo. I have a Neheb, Dreadhorde Champion deck that has absolutely overpowered decked out lists like Najeela, Selvala Brostorm, Korvold, Curious Control, Urza and funnily enough... Godo (I get to run much more interaction, despite being mono-r). Birgi gets absolutely hosed by SO many single stax pieces it's not even funny

*Cough* Chalice of the Void, Rule of Law effects, trinisphere, Narset, stony silence, collector ouphe *Cough*... The Kobolds you're running aren't gonna help you out of that one.

cEDH has become a narrow joke that seems to destroy any hint of creativity people try.


r/CompetitiveEDH • • Jan 12 '21

Spoiler You may remember me as that goofus that thinks the flash meta was better than the naus meta, but now you can remember me as the guy who posted a deck list of the first commander that actively breaks parity on stasis. Oh and also my cedh tournament

0 Upvotes

Anyway. Jorn is best played (in the opinion of stasis) as a stax deck. We use cards like [[root maze]], [[winter orb]], [[static orb]] and most importantly [[stasis]] to slow down the game, and break parity with our commander. We do not have inherent card advantage, so i had to put quite a lot throughout the deck. The two locks in this deck are Jorn Snow, Stasis, and snow lands. this is a hard mana lock. the other that i have been enjoying recently is [[Narset, parter]]/Oppo agent+Maralen. Utilizing the strong neoform package of sultai, we can quickly find our way to maralen and oppo, then just win by stealing our opponents things.

also, i have decided that i will be hosting a cedh tournament extravaganza through the lathril server. Teams brewing each week, Rotating banlist, play paradox engine and flash rector again.

also im 100% using this as a shameless plug, so listen up. Jorn Snow's official discord is the dark corner of the Lathril server, cuz i called dibs on him, too. Damn does it feel good to have the power to shit post in announcements

https://discord.gg/UFtJA4Hz4K get in here

https://www.moxfield.com/decks/JkmVl1WsQE66gC8GrQX6Kw


r/CompetitiveEDH • • Jun 25 '23

Discussion How to deal with Orcish Bowmasters

0 Upvotes

As many of you already know, [[Orcish Bowmasters]] is really powerful and it will probably impact a lot cEDH. Here’s a very underplayed card in my opinion that is the perfect answer to the Orcs: [[Aboleth Spawn]]. You basically can copy ETBs. This is great with so many Docksides, Tivits, Atraxas around. And with this you can copy Bowmasters ETB to kill it. The amazing part is that Spawn has amazing protection, with ward 2 and a 2/3 body. I think slower decks with blue should and will play this card more and more.


r/CompetitiveEDH • • Jul 21 '19

Revised Thoughts on Urza

2 Upvotes

Disclaimers

I'm going to say a lot of things here that people may disagree with or even find personally insulting, and that definitely is not my intent. I also don't really want to create a discussion here - it's not like I'm going to go back to this deck and if people are already comitted to playing Urza then I doubt they'll listen to me anyway. My intent for this post is only to share my experiences playing Urza and my revised thoughts on the deck so that people can draw their own conclusions. So let me say a few things before I begin:

  1. I don't hate anyone in this community. I especially don't hate Sigi, Lerker, Sickrobot, or Shaper, who have been doing a fine job with the decklists and primers for Urza. I may be critical of some of their opinions in this article, but I don't mean any of them as personal attacks. All four of these men are knowledgeable, skilled players, good content producers, competent moderators and administrators on this subreddit and the CEDH discord, and generally nice people, and our community is lucky to have them. So I don't hate them because we disagree on a few decks. I HATE THEM BECAUSE THEY'RE A BUNCH OF FUCKIN WEEBS. jk, I don't hate them at all.

  2. If Urza has been working well for you and you want to stick with it, good for you. If this is the case, then you may just want to stop reading here, because it sounds like I'm not going to convince you of anything, and you definitely won't convince me of anything. I also just generally don't want to read a lot of "idk works for me" posts. If I wanted to read those, I'd go to a tech support forum. Again, this is mostly about sharing my own experience and less about creating a discussion.

  3. This is going to be long and meandering and go more than a little off topic at certain points. WOTC market research once showed that Magic players are afraid of any textbox that contains more than 6 lines of text. I've already passed that point and I haven't even said anything important yet. So don't panic, I will create a tl;dr for this post. It will either be at the end of this post after the conclusion or as a post in the comments.

Introduction

Not too long after [[Urza, Lord High Artificer]] was spoiled, there was a thread asking whether or not is was better than [[Teferi, Temporal Archmage]]. Having played Teferi as well as a few other mono-blue decks for several years, I offered my own thoughts on both decks based on my initial impressions of Urza. I highly recommend you read this post (or at least the tl;dr summary I did) before going on because I will be referencing it CONSTANTLY here, and I don't really want to repeat what I already said there. Overall, most of my opinions are the same now as they were then, but I do have some new thoughts that I will share later. My main regret from the original post is the direct comparison to partners. Obviously Urza is worse than partners, everything is worse than partners. So although I do discuss some relevant things in that section, directly comparing them was probably futile. I should have tried harder to show how Urza is also worse than the decks that are only slightly worse than partners but still super powerful (Zur, Kess, Gitrog, Najeela, FCFS), which is part of what I hope to accomplish here.

But that's not the main reason why I'm writing this article. I'm writing it because of a chain of events that started the following day on Discord.

If you've read the post I linked earlier, you'll see that one of the things I say is multiple times that mono-blue is a limited color identity and that the ceiling for mono-blue decks is not that much higher than the floor, or at least not high enough for it to compete with the best decks in the format. If you really want to stretch these words around, you could say that I think that Urza is not meaningfully better than Fblthp. For the record, I think Fblthp is terrible, and I always thought he was worse than Urza. Regardless, when I went on the CEDH Discord to talk about a card from M20 that I saw and immediately fell in love with, [[Flame Sweep]], Shaper was laughing about someone who thought "Urza is not meaningfully better than Fblthp".

Now, I still don't know if Shaper was actually talking about me (EDIT: He wasn't) or if that was a statement made by someone else (EDIT: It was, but I won't link it), but at that time I thought it was about me and I became upset by the perceived idea that they were talking shit about me behind my back. I started arguing with him about it and he didn't seem to be taking it seriously, which only caused me to be more frustrated and argue harder. I sent a link to the post I made about my thoughts on the Urza, and Shaper responded with:

If you're not going to playtest the card/deck and make vague dismissive statements and demand respect for those untested opinions ... I just don't know what to tell you

At the time, this seemed fair. Looking at it now though, there's a sort of logical fallacy here. It implies that someone is incapable of forming a valid opinion on a deck unless they've playtested it extensively, regardless of prior experience with similar decks or general knowledge of the format. If you really want to stretch this statement to the breaking point, you could say it about decks that are obviously quite weak, like the [[Feather]] control deck. It is good that through this quote, I now have a defense to throw at people who think my [[Niv-Mizzet Parun]] deck isn't competitive once I finish writing the primer.

Regardless, this statement lit a vindictive fire inside me. I was determined to prove myself right and defend my opinion. After giving up on Teferi in the fall of 2018, I swore that I would never go back to mono-blue again. But anger makes us do things we never thought we would do. So on that day I became determined to get as many games playing Urza in as I could. That's right, my goal was to play 30 games of Urza and I was motivated purely by spite.

What people don't know is that this isn't even the first time I've done something so petty. The whole reason I started playing Niv-Mizzet Parun was borne of a grudge I had with people who disagreed with me about [[Teferi, Temporal Archmage]]. At the time, I was frustrated with Teferi and thought he was terrible and getting worse and worse every set. The main reasons that I cited were that Teferi had almost 0 board presence in the early game, that [[The Chain Veil]] combo was too expensive and slow to keep up with other decks, that Teferi couldn't outgrind Tymna and Thrasios even if he had stax in play, etc. Others assured me that having part of your win condition in your command zone in a color that had access to counterspells was so valuable that it outweighed these massive disadvantages. So I started playing Parun since he also has access to counterspells and has several one-card combos. Parun is also in a better color identity than Teferi and has access to additional stax pieces, board wipes, removal for creatures and artifacts, more ways to pressure life totals, and is a giant uncounterable dragon that passively draws cards. Parun is only just barely competitive despite having all these edges over Teferi, yet the prevailing attitude at the time was the opposite. What's funniest about all of this is that at that time, Teferi had enough going for him that his weaknesses were supposedly negligble, but when Urza was printed, people were suddenly pointing out all these weaknesses, like having 0 board presence, being slow, and not being able to grind well. "Those statements seem so familiar," I thought. "Where have I heard them before?" I guess hindsight is 20/20, huh guys?

Anyway, back to Urza. As I said, my original plan was to get 30 games in on Cockatrice. I ended up getting in only 17 games with a final record of 4 wins and 13 losses. There were 3 main reasons why I stopped playing were:

  1. I got a new job and had less time to jam games.

  2. I just couldn't take it any more. Playing Urza was too often a frustrating, miserable experience for me due to its lack of tools and overall low individual card quality. This is what happens when you cave into peer pressure and force yourself to play a deck. It was affecting my mental state considerably too. During games, I became more easily frustrated and angry and lashed out at people who I considered friends. To those people, I apologize for my behavior. Urza did this to me. I don't recommend anyone else force themselves to play any deck for any reason, ever. That is the path to madness, and I was getting pretty fucking mad.

  3. [[Paradox Engine]] was banned. I'll write more thoughts on this later, but it influenced why I stopped because I didn't want to have to split my analysis between pre-ban and post-ban and I didn't want to have to start over.

You may be concerned that people who opposed my viewpoints on Urza will now discredit my opinions because of the small sample size or because it was before an important card was banned. Don't worry though, even if I had gotten hundreds of games in and PEngine was still legal, I have the utmost faith that they'd still find a way to disregard my opinions (if I had to guess, I'd say they'd pursue the "confirmation bias" angle). So although I know that the most vocal Urza supporters won't listen to me, I am still going to post my own opinions on the deck. We're at a point in this community where people are afraid of speaking up with their opinions on decks or cards because they are afraid of backlash. Skilled players are writing primers for decks and not posting them because "many people will give it shit for not being a deck made by a mod". That's really sad, and it's not the kind of community I want to be a part of. If you take away anything from this disjointed mess of an article, it's not anything about Urza. It's to not be afraid to share your opinion. At the very least, you will be exposing people to your viewpoint so that they can draw their own conclusions.

We're 1700 words in, so let's finally start actually talking about Urza.

My Games With Urza

As I said earlier, I played 17 games with Urza, won 4 and lost 13. Throughout these games, I changed a few cards around here and there. I don't have every iteration of my list available, but I do have my final list available here along with a mostly complete changelog. My original goal was to play 30 games with the deck, and in those 30 games I wanted to also test out different backup win conditions. The plan was to test [[Voltaic Key]]/[[Manifold Key]]+[[Sensei's Dining Top]]+PEngine for 6 games, then [[Future Sight]]+[[Etherium Sculptor]]+Top for 6 games, then [[Retraction Helix]]+PEngine for 6 games, then [[Power Artifact]]+[[Grim Monolith]]+[[Stroke of Genius]] for 6 games, and then finally to spend my last 6 games without a third win condition and instead play value cards like [[Tezzeret, Artifice Master]] and stax like [[Storage Matrix]]. Obviously this didn't end up happening, but I did want to mention it to show that I did test multiple win conditions. For what it's worth, the version with Future Sight had the highest winrate (3-3), but those wins actually had nothing to do with Future Sight (in fact, I never drew the card at all and only saw it once off an [[Impulse]] and didn't pick it). Playing Cage and Future Sight in the same deck has never sat well with me, but I guess it's not the worst case scenario. I don't want to comment too much on the other win conditions because I never used them, but obviously the ones that require PEngine are no longer valid.

Notable cards I did not test include:

  • Power Artifact: Like I said, I didn't have time. That's really the only reason I didn't test it.

  • [[Legacy's Allure]]: I honestly can't remember why I didn't test this. The card seems totally fine. I think I was running [[Reality Shift]] instead, probably for [[Timetwister]] looping purposes.

  • [[Howling Mine]]: LOL

  • [[Key to the City]]: Unlike Howling Mine, this draw engine actually seems pretty decent. If I were still to test this, I'd probably run it in place of TAM, though it's hard to say which is better. Obviously Tezzeret has a higher initial cost, but draws more cards and doesn't require a mana investment. However, Key comes down earlier and produces mana, which TAM can't do without wasting a turn making a thopter. Key is probably the right choice between the two of them, but I can't say for sure.

  • [[Saprazzan Skerry]]: I get it. UU in the casting cost of your commander can be awkward, and you want to get to 4 as soon as possible. But after turn 3, this is the worst land to draw in your entire deck. If you have [[Back to Basics]] out, the card is completely dead. I'm just not sold on this card at all.

  • [[The Tabernacle at Pendrell Vale]]: Tabernacle is an incredibly powerful card, but since you always want both Urza and the construct in play, it seems like too much of a tax on your mana. That and the anti-synergy with [[Sai, Master Thopterist]] makes it a less attractive card to run in this deck than in Teferi or Baral. Maybe I was being too cautious, but it just didn't sit well with me.

Back to the games, of the 17 I played, I think I played most of them pretty well. There were 3 games that I lost to punts and one game that I feel I won simply through luck:

  • The first punt was on my literal first game with the deck due to me not tapping Static Orb on the turn before mine. Whoops. This left me with insufficient mana to deal with what Gitrog was doing and the Gitrog player won. It was my first game with the deck, but that's not really an excuse for such a boneheaded play.

  • The second punt was due to a mis-sequencing. An opponent had mana to cast [[Mana Drain]] and I suspected that they had it in hand (it's been too long and I don't remember if it was because they had revealed it to us or if I was just paranoid). I had the option to play either Sai or Urza along with about 3 other artifacts. Not fully thinking my turn through, I played out my artifacts followed my Sai, and then immediately realized my sequencing error. The extra thopters Sai would have given me would have let me have additional mana to stop the Graftmage Hulk player, so it was a big mana shortage on my part and I should have thought through my turn more.

  • The final game I lost due to punts was not due to a single punt but a series of punts. For starters, I kept a relatively bad hand that had [[Grafdigger's Cage]] and not much else going on. It couldn't even cast Urza on turn 4, that's how bad it was. But with two Hulk players at the table (Shuffle Hulk and Graftmage Hulk), I wasn't going to turn away a Cage, despite all my rage. So whether or not this is a punt was kind of debatable. What was a more obvious punt came later in the game. I had the option to either play Urza, then Static Orb, then Gilded Drake a creature (my main targets were either a 6/6 [[Toothy, Imaginary Friend]] or [[Seedborne Muse]]), or to play it safe and only Gilded Drake a creature. I chickened out and went with the second choice, but the even bigger punt was that I chose Seedborne Muse anyway when I could have had a huge Toothy. I should have tried to land the Static Orb.

  • The stroke of luck I had was in a pod with Shuffle Hulk, Consultation [[Golos]], and [[Ob Nixilis, the Fallen]]. I mean no disrespect to the Ob-Nixilis player, but it was almost certainly going to turn into a 3 player pod due to the rather lacking nature of mono-black. But it actually ended up effectively being a 2-player pod because the Shuffle Hulk player mulled to 4. The game wasn't a cakewalk - the Ob Nixilis player had a [[Dark Impostor]] in play with a ton of mana which made casting Urza before the combo turn rather awkward - but it still felt easier than it should have.

If we discount these 3 dumb decisions and 1 extreme display of luck, my record goes from 4-13 to 3-10. Funnily enough, this doesn't change my win percentage much - it goes from 23.5% to 23.1%. What can I conclude from all my games and results? A lot of things. I'll start with a conclusion that surprised me.

Urza is not as bad as I thought

I honestly didn't expect to say that going into this. I thought that Urza would be completely unbearable and miserable every game and get dumped on by the other decks at the table, but that only happened a few times. To my surprise, Urza held his own reasonably well against several of the top decks in the format. Being able to effectively have doubled my mana from casting Urza and keeping him alive until my next turn was a big deal and breaking parity on orbs really helped let me keep up with my opponents. There were also several other cards in the deck that really impressed me with how well they worked, including:

  • The construct token: This thing is a weapon to surpass Metal Gear. It gets huge very quickly and does an excellent job blocking any grounded creatures your opponents try to throw at you. It can also get to the point where late game you can use it to pressure players' life totals and force them to throw their mana dorks in front of it so that they don't take 9. It's a big deal.

  • [[Static Orb]]: I have to admit, I initially undervalued Static Orb. It was definitely the card I was most happy to see in my opening hand, and any hand that could cast Urza and also had a Static Orb was a snap keep. Static Orb isn't always super backbreaking, but the fact that it has such a low opportunity cost makes it an invaluable card here. But [[Cursed Totem]] is still better.

  • [[Spellskite]]: This little guy is great. One of the biggest problems in Urza is that you will cast Urza and someone will steal it to double their mana and rob you of your best mana source and win condition. Protecting your stax pieces and misdirecting [[Oblivion Crowns]] is also pretty valuable, and since this deck doesn't extensively use life as a resource you can redirect all day. And he blocks Tymna and taps for mana. It's everything you'd want in a utility creature!

  • [[Sapphire Medallion]]: This is a solid card in any mono-blue deck, but it's especially good here, and I don't think I need to explain why. Still, when I noticed just how good it was I was a little blown away.

  • Sai: In addition to being a 1/4 who can block Tymna, Sai's ability to not only double up all your artifacts but also turn the less useful ones into cards in the mid-late game makes him probably the most important creature in the deck.

  • [[Trail of Evidence]]: Similar to Sai, it creates tons of artifacts very quickly and can turn them into cards. It was so good for me that if I were to go back to other mono-blue decks (which I won't but let's pretend for a little bit), I would make sure to test it, because in a deck with ~30 instants and sorceries it would be a great way to keep up with partners.

  • [[Recurring Insight]]: Why did we cut this from Teferi again? This card is amazing. It should probably be in every mono-blue deck.

  • I'm going to marry [[Narset, Parter of Veils]]: While playing, I finally got my first taste of Narset+[[Windfall]] and it was one of the best moments I've ever had while playing CEDH. Narset is simply incredible. She warps the game around her in a way that few other stax pieces do and can still be cashed in for additional card advantage if needed. Being able to [[Mind Twist]] your opponents while still getting a new hand is one of the best ways to get ahead in a low-color blue deck. She's what got me into Oathbreaker, even though she'll probably get banned from Oathbreaker. I don't have a whole lot else to say about how good she is - she's great, she's amazing, she's beautiful, she's perfect, I love her, she's muh waifu, and I want her to step on me.

So playing the deck changed my mind about a lot of things I thought about Urza. I do now think that there is a pretty big gap between Urza and the second best mono-blue commander, and that Urza can sit at a table with the best decks and do reasonably well, even if it's not exactly favored. However, there were still some areas that I found Urza to be lacking.

...but he's not as good as the hype.

Let's go back to the winrate. 23% is close enough to the expected average winrate of 25% that I don't want to say that Urza is below average. But is it what you'd expect from a deck that people are lauding as one of the top decks in the format? I don't think so. I'd expect it to be more like 30% at least. A 25% winrate is something from a deck that people were saying was as good as, like, Godo, not a deck people were saying is as good as Kess, Zur, Najeela, etc.

But that winrate is just me. I don't think I'm a bad player, but I'm not the best player in the world either, and as I said before, I did punt a few games. How are other people doing with the deck? Well, I don't know. I couldn't find any data on any other players' winrates with Urza - not on PlayEDH or on CEDH Ranked - so I have only my own experiences to look at. If you would like to share your winrate with Urza, please feel free to do so, but I would also like to know what the pod composition of each of your wins was.

Speaking of pod composition, let's talk about matchups next. I'll skip the partner matchups since I talked about them extensively before. Instead I'll talk about what I consider to be the other best decks in the format, as well as my other game losses.

  • Najeela: In my previous post I said that Urza and his construct are good at blocking 2 warriors but bad at blocking 10 warriors. This is true and it's a relevant weakness, but it's ultimately not why I lost 2 games to Najeela. One loss was because the Najeela player was able to dump his hand into play turn 1, get WUBRG by turn 2, and play a protected Derevi turn 3. Another loss was due to a Najeela Aluren deck. The line the Aluren player was using was to find [[Cavern Harpy]] and [[Derevi]] to make infinite mana, tutor [[Lightning Helix]] with [[Spellseeker]], and loop it with [[Eternal Witness]] and [[Shrieking Drake]]. So one loss was to a conventional line and was was to an unconventional line. But you know what card could have stopped them both? Cursed Totem. And you know what stax piece Urza can't run? Cursed Totem. So although Urza is probably the best choice mono-blue has against Najeela, it's still an uphill battle.

  • Gitrog: Speaking of decks that get shut down by Cursed Totem, two of my losses were to Gitrog. Mono-blue tends to struggle with Gitrog because the combo is so reslient, can be done at instant speed, and there are about a dozen ways for them to protect it. Mono-blue really needs to stop frog when it gets cast, steal it when it's been around for a turn, or play Cursed Totem to stop them. Since Urza can't play Cursed Totem, losing to [[Cavern of Souls]], [[Savage Summoning]], and [[Autumn's Veil]] seem all but unavoidable. On top of all that, the construct can't beat Gitrog in combat because of Deathtouch (because a 6/6 really needed deathtouch, apparently). So this is another deck that I think Urza will really struggle with going forward.

  • First Sliver, Kess, Zur: Weirdly, I didn't play against any of these while testing. I don't really know why and I can't draw a ton of conclusions about the matchups, but if I had to guess I'd say that they're probably even at best for Urza with Silver being the hardest to play against. Sliver is only affected by a few of Urza's stax pieces, and they mostly only hurt it if they're not on a Food Chain line. You still basically play the same way against all three - counter their threats, make sure they don't get too much value out of their commanders (this part shouldn't be too hard against Sliver lol), and try to win before they can.

  • My other losses: I lost one game to another Urza player, but I don't remember much about it. I lost one game to a Yawgmoth player, but mostly because I had to mull to 5 and the player playing GW Sisay Pure Stax got a turn 1 [[Null Rod]]. A lot of people think Null Rod doesn't affect Urza. That's not true. It just affects him less than it does other mono-blue decks. I lost one game to a 5C Sisay Stax deck that was basically 5C Blood Pod. The Blood Pod matchup has never been good for mono-blue, and when you lose Cursed Totem and they go up a color, it gets even worse for you. Urza doesn't change that. And then I lost one game to Yuriko because he swung with 2 ninjas and flipped 26 damage worth of nukes to burn us out. #JustYurikoThings

Since I talked about cards that impressed me above, I'll talk now about cards that I was underwhelmed by:

  • Lands that don't tap for blue mana: I never thought [[Buried Ruin]] would disappoint me, but it has. Who would have thought that UU would be hard to get to in a mono-blue deck? And yet there were several games I lost because I didn't have enough colored mana sources early on to actually cast Urza in a timely manner.

  • [[Tezzeret the Seeker]] - I guess I'm only disappointed in this because of the years I spent playing Teferi, where Tezzeret was effectively a second copy of The Chain Veil. If he started at 5 loyalty he would have been fantastic here, but since he doesn't he's a little bit underwhelming, especially if you already have Static Orb in play. I probably expected too much and I know that mono-blue is very lacking in tutors, but I just don't like him here.

So a lot of what I said previously about mono-blue being a limited color identity still applies, and, as strong as he is, Urza doesn't really help fill in the holes. He also opens up some new holes since he can't play Cursed Totem. Previously I said that Cursed Totem is one of the best stax pieces in the format. I no longer believe that. I now think that it's THE best stax piece in the format. Cage is second, and although there isn't a huge gap between them, it's still a noticeable one. Some people may say I love Cursed Totem too much, but you know what? Ever since I threw out my old mattress and replaced it with a pile of Cursed Totems, I've gotten the best sleep of my life.

Pour One Out for Paradox Engine

The banning of Paradox Engine was unfortunate for Urza, both because it shut off several alternate win lines and because it just makes the deck less effective at accumulating value. There seem to be two opposing schools of thought on how much Urza is actually affected by PEngine's ban. In one corner we have Chicken Little, who thinks that this ban spells doom for this deck and that the sky is falling, and in the other we have The Immovable Object who thinks that the ban doesn't affect Urza at all. I'm in between these two groups. I think that the loss of PEngine makes it harder for Urza to win since now he has to rely on two-card combos, and tutoring 2 cards is harder than tutoring 1 card (twice as hard, in fact). However, a lot of other decks that were affected by this ban were hurt just as much, if not more, so Urza's overall position in the CEDH meta at large isn't really going to change.

Conclusion

Ultimately, when I think about how good a deck is in CEDH, I ask my self "Would this deck be good going into a meta blind?". The answer to this is definitely yes for Shuffle Hulk and CST, and I'd probably say yes to Zur too, but I can't answer yes for Urza. If the answer to that is no, I ask "What meta would this deck be good in?". I can think of metas where Najeela, Kess, Gitrog, and Sliver would all be good, but I still can't think of one for Urza. Urza is definitely the best mono-blue commander, and he can sit at a competitive pod and do reasonably well, but he doesn't do enough to be one of the top decks of the format. I definitely wouldn't put him on the level of partners, and I also wouldn't put it on the level as the big 5 (I'm tired of listing them out, you should know who I'm talking about by now). Urza is definitely better than Parun, which is more than I can say for other mono-blue commanders. I'm not even sure Simic Partners is better than Urza anymore - they're probably about the same. I'd put Urza on the same level as Breya, Godo, Jhoira, or Yisan - all of them can thrive in the right environment, but in a high stakes situation I wouldn't play them. I wouldn't play Urza in such a situation, and I can't recommend them to others either.

So those are all the thoughts I have on Urza right now. I don't particularly care if you agree or disagree with me, what's important to me is that whatever conclusion you came to, you came to on your own based on what you've read from both the pro-Urza side and me, as well as your own experience playing with or against Urza (if you have any). And I hope that if any of you have an unpopular opinion about a deck that you're not afraid to share it or talk about it. Thank you.


r/CompetitiveEDH • • Sep 19 '26

Spoilers! Card Discussion Samut, Tyrant of Naktumun is fine, actually~

0 Upvotes

Hello, all~

I want to make the counter a bit of hysteria I am seeing over one [[Samut, Tyrant of Naktumun]].

It is my opinion that this card is actually just fine. While not averse to "slop" or "draw meta" myself, I know a lot of people really hate those things. This card encourages winning the game, and can be a break from casting worse split-second options.

But, also...this card is Grand Abolisher. Sure, it's in blue, but ultimately it's Grand Abolisher that needs very particular sequencing in order for it not to be effectively "worse" Grand Abolisher. There are specific ways in which it is better, but largely it's more open to interaction than other options.

White has been getting so many good cards that make me personally feel behind at start of game whenever I reveal a commander without a white color identity, it's nice to have the Silence creature that forces the end game in midrange/control decks outside of Esper/Jeskai shells.

Samut is good. Very good. But it's not going to spell the end of the format. Thank you for coming to my TED Talk~


r/CompetitiveEDH • • Mar 04 '26

Discussion Can People Stop Telling New Players Etali Is The Easiest Commander?

110 Upvotes

It seems every post involving a new player asking advice I see 50 comments saying along the lines of “just pick Etali, count to 7 and go brrr for win.” She’s NOT that easy and honestly probably demands the highest game and specifically card knowledge of any commander in MTG to play even moderately well.

She isn’t a very intuitive commander. You have to not only know your own win lines, which do happen to be easy (just food chain and squee), but you also HAVE to know the win lines (and honestly all the cards) of EVERY other deck in the format to make use of them.

imagine, if you will, a completely new player coming from precons and b2 flipping a [[Lim-Dul's Vault]] , [[Chains of Mephistopheles]] or [[Praetor's Grasp]] and expecting them to know how to cast and use them effectively when they’ve never seen the card before in their life. At a tournament you’d have to force a draw because of how long someone would take trying to figure them out, and I doubt anyone’s gonna help them to their own detriment when there’s say, a judges foil Gaea’s Cradle on the line for top prize.

you also have to have extremely in depth knowledge of the stack and how it affect the order of etb’s, what may affect the next card in the order, interaction targeting one of the 4 spells you’re casting with it and so on, so forth etc…