r/CommercialRealEstate • • Nov 27 '23

My colleague made $1 million on commissions last year and disappeared.

1.2k Upvotes

This is not a shitpost. I’m dead serious. I was intricately familiar with his entire book of business. He sold all of it then dropped off the grid last year. I don’t think he’s closed one deal in 2023. Has anyone else seen this happen? What’s the story? Personally I think it’s hilarious. I’m wondering when, if ever, he’s coming back to work.


r/CommercialRealEstate • • Nov 04 '24

I am going to purchase a strip club. If I dont do it, I will probably regret it.

647 Upvotes

I have a opportunity to purchase a run down bar. This bar also carries a exotic license.

Which means it can operate as a strip club; municipality cannot deny it. If I sell everything, I would have about 3.5M in capital for this venture and I am debating about going all in. Ive been told that I would have to cooperate with strippernet (BC/AB) but another option is to employ foreign workers, legally of course. I have a couple of restaurants that employ seasonal foreign workers, and the same concept can be applied here.

Its been very difficult to get comments from people that have actually done this before or are already operating a exotic night club. So people of reddit, what are your thoughts?


r/CommercialRealEstate • • Jan 05 '24

Made a few million on a deal we just closed and need direction

603 Upvotes

My husband and I took a huge gamble & leveraged everything to buy a commercial property. We just made a deal and will close escrow to sell it by the end of the month and our profit is just over $3M. We have a loop hole to avoid taxes via opportunity zone. My question is, what is the best first step to grow this nest egg and make generational wealth for our daughters?


r/CommercialRealEstate • • Jan 01 '26

Market Questions I used NYC Energy Data to find "Phantom Vacancy" in Office Buildings. The results were wild.

467 Upvotes

I’ve been experimenting with a way to spot “off-market” distress in NYC CRE using public data, and I figured this sub might appreciate the logic (or tear it apart).

A lot of distressed buildings don’t look distressed in listings or broker chatter until very late. Owners often keep up the appearance of occupancy and stability even after tenants have quietly disappeared. So I tried to answer a narrow question:

Can you detect hidden vacancy and financial stress before it shows up on LoopNet or CoStar?

The experiment used two totally separate public datasets that normally don’t talk to each other.

Signal 1: Energy usage as a proxy for real occupancy, NYC requires large buildings to report annual energy benchmarking data (Local Law 84). That gives electricity and fuel usage normalized by building size and type.

I compared:

  • Expected energy usage (based on historical performance + peer buildings of similar size/type)

  • Actual reported usage

When a building that claims to be occupied shows energy usage closer to a vacant warehouse than an active office or multifamily asset, that’s a red flag. Not proof of vacancy, but a strong “something’s off here” signal. I started calling this “phantom occupancy.”

Signal 2: Quiet financial stress, Separately, I pulled NYC public records (ACRIS) and looked for early-stage distress indicators:

  • Lis pendens filings

  • Tax liens

  • Mortgages past maturity with no refi recorded

Again, none of these alone mean a deal is imminent. But they’re often precursors.

The interesting part was when I combined them. I wrote a Python script to cross-reference the datasets, and when low energy usage and financial stress showed up on the same BBL, those properties tended to be:

  1. Partially or fully vacant despite being marketed as occupied.

  2. Owned by LLCs that hadn’t yet engaged brokers.

  3. Very early in the “uh oh” phase, before widespread exposure.

I generated a "Watch List" of about ~600 buildings in an early NYC pass, then manually validated the top slice via street checks, quick calls to management, and broker conversations (without pitching anything).

The hit rate on the top tier was meaningfully higher than random cold outreach.

Big lessons so far: Energy data is surprisingly useful, but only as a time series. One-year snapshots lie. Distress is best modeled probabilistically, not as a binary “yes/no.” Public data still has alpha if you combine datasets that weren’t designed to be combined. The hardest part isn’t data science, it’s validation and interpretation.

I’m now iterating by adding year-over-year deltas instead of raw values and weighting signals instead of using hard rules.

Posting this mainly to share the approach and see how others think about detecting early CRE distress. Happy to hear critiques, edge cases I’m missing, or other unconventional signals people have found useful.

The city leaks more information than we think, it’s just scattered.


r/CommercialRealEstate • • Nov 30 '24

30 year old commercial agent realizing a lot of things right now..

418 Upvotes

This industry is discouraging. I made $30,000 last month after not making anything for 4 months.. I have a fat pipeline but nothing is certain. I made 250k my 4th year in real estate. I made 125k last year. I’m not happy, I can’t plan my life. I have no idea how much I’m going to make, I can’t sleep at night. I don’t want to have “commission breath” anymore, I’m tired of acting, I’m tired of begging for a dollar. I don’t want to be in sales. It’s slimy. I just want a good salary and I want to start a family already.


r/CommercialRealEstate • • Oct 31 '23

Santander Plans to Sell $5.28 Billion Worth of Toxic Real Estate Assets

308 Upvotes

r/CommercialRealEstate • • May 20 '25

What is largest amount of money you've seen a mom and pop owner turn down?

272 Upvotes

Farmers, mom and pops, or just very non-institutionalized owners sitting on a gold mine. What is the largest amount you've seen turned down?


r/CommercialRealEstate • • Feb 10 '24

Wanted: $1B in distressed multifamily assets to buy

267 Upvotes

Our group is looking for $1B in multifamily real estate. We need a deal that makes you horny. Like as soon as you hear it, it should make your pee pee hard.

Criteria:

  • gotta be amazingly nice

  • will pay a 20% Cap rate, can go down to 18% depending on deal

  • will pay you all cash....10 years after closing

  • willing to consider all markets...that have had a 30% yearly increase in population

  • only class A deals...we don't want broke tenants

  • must be distressed. Like so freaken distressed but also must be in a top area like Miami Beach or Manhattan. But must also be really nice. Like the kind of place where you'd show off to your friends.

Private message me your deals


r/CommercialRealEstate • • Feb 23 '21

One of my bigger failures as a 20 year real estate developer

258 Upvotes

As I enter a new stage of my life I am looking back at what I did right, and what I did wrong. For now I will stick to the failures. I am going to write a few of these, as time allows. May you learn from my mistakes.

Year is 2003 or 04. I live in a very rural area so my numbers on a national basis are MUCH cheaper than what you're used to. NAFTA and international trade has decimated manufacturing in rural Pennsylvania. As a result lots of towns/small cities have had their local manufacturer close shop and their real estate is coming up for sale everywhere. These buildings are anywhere from 50,000 - 200,000 square feet but are 30-75 years old and most often in terrible condition. The business owners were striving to make payroll, they weren't concerned a toilet broke or the roof was leaking.

They would come on the market for sale and no one would buy them because they were in terrible condition. I would wait and pounce until the price had dropped and was paying less than $5/sft. (This part I did right, with 1 or maybe 2 exceptions I never overpaid). The name of the game here was simply patience.

After my company bought it (I had 2 partners), we would remodel the whole thing. Painting it white and putting in new lights would make the inside look fantastic, usually for around $3/sft. Of course we would have to do the garage doors, bathrooms, lunchrooms, heat, etc... These improvements cost another $10/sft and the roof would be about $4/sft. So usually we had a like new building with a new roof, painted, new lights, heat and loading docks for between $15-$20/sft. This was at a time when building that building new would usually be between $30-$40/sft.

We never would put them up for sale, just lease them usually for between $2.50-$3.00/sft net. Our cash on cash return would average between 15-20%. We would sign a lease almost immediately. Go to the bank and borrow the full cost of the building based on the lease income. Now we had no cash in the property. Pre-2008 you could borrow the full cost.

Now you have the number side of the business. Starting around 2003 we do our first project, it's around 50,000 sft, with the numbers I mention above, and almost immediately rented. So we do this every 6 months. never selling a building. By 2006, I would estimate we had done 750,000 square feet of these projects and cash flow was amazing. So 2006 one of our main tenants comes to us and asks us to do a $5M build to suit. Of course! They are in the plumbing industry and home building is booming and their financials are amazing. We move them in 2007 and backfill their old space almost immediately. 2007 we do another 250,000 sft. So now we are up to 1,000,000+ sft plus of this product and then we have this huge new build to suit project that the rent needs to be more like $5/sft, double what we get everywhere else.

I had only done retail and office leasing prior to this and I was basically in charge of the leases. I could basically agree on the terms of the leases without anyone else's approval. I was definitely the most knowledgeable person on the team, but it turns out I wasn't that knowledgeable.

You see, as I was writing the leases, I got to pick the terms. 1 year lease? Sure, no problem, you're a public company of course we can do that for your VP. Small business, don't know the future, 3 year lease? No problem!

So while I was building this 1,000,000 sft portfolio of like new but old industrial real estate all the lease terms were 1-3 years. Now 2008 hits. We all know what happened then.

To cut off my long story - by 2010, the plumber that we had done the $5M build to suit for had gone bankrupt and our occupancy dropped from 100% to 40%. I think every single lease that expired except 1 the tenant declined to renew the lease. I would estimate we were losing $100,000 per month at one point and that went on for a few years. Thankfully we had the reserves to pay them and never missed a loan payment. We basically put it all up for sale and anyone that would buy anything vacant we would sell it. We didn't really get creamed in any of the sales because we bought right. Definitely lost low 6 figures on a few though. I'm sure we breached some of our loan covenants but banks didn't want the property back and recognized we were making payments so they didn't really give us a hard time. By 2012-3 we had fully recovered the business but it was much smaller and we were much more selective in our leases.

Moral of the story is short term leases (<3 years) are almost worthless other than for nice short term cash flow. If you're signing a short term lease understand what can and does happen. Have the reserves to carry the property through the bad times. For industrial leases like that I only endorse 5 year or longer terms. Alternatively it can have a landlord kick out clause. Sure I'll rent it to you for 1 year but I am going to keep the property on the market and kick you out when I do rent it to someone more serious.


r/CommercialRealEstate • • Nov 11 '23

Commercial real estate valuations are so hard-hit that CBRE warns they could fall ‘another 10%,’ after saying earlier they ‘may come down 15%, 20%’

225 Upvotes

r/CommercialRealEstate • • Mar 01 '24

My first big closing today. Taking a moment to reflect and take a deep breath.

201 Upvotes

I don’t really have anyone to tell this to and I’m super excited. Been licensed for 4 years but working in a different industry. Worked in a small brokerage and focused primarily on commercial sales for the last year. Closing on a $2.4m property today and just needed to share my excitement with someone who can relate. I have made $3,560 total in the last 11 months. It’s been a whirlwind building my sales pipeline. Multiple large deals have fizzled out during due diligence. The validation I’m feeling today is beyond comparison.

This industry can be such a meat grinder but moments like this make it all so worth it. If you’re feeling defeated trying to wind up your book of business, keep going! Go the extra mile, do the hard stuff, build the relationships. It will happen! Happy Friday! Let’s get this bread!

Edit: thanks a lot y’all, appreciate the kind words!


r/CommercialRealEstate • • Dec 26 '23

Commercial brokers - explain what you do for a living

184 Upvotes

I'm a commercial appraiser and see $5, $10, $15+million dollar deals on the regular. The commission on one side of these deals rivals my annual salary and I'm seeing guys as young as in their early 20s closing deals.

Not to be disrespectful and oversimplify what you do, but from my perspective, it seems like a matter of landing a couple deals a year, measuring, taking photos, pulling some comps, writing up a offering memorandum broadcast it online and wait for offers to come in? Do you spend the rest of your time networking and trying to find clients? What other time consuming components of the job and I missing? Asking because I'm considering getting my brokers license and it seems like much easier money than what I do. There's has to be more to it or everyone would be doing it?


r/CommercialRealEstate • • Jan 05 '25

Do not invest with syndicators you don’t know personally. Warning

181 Upvotes

Warned a buddy of mine a couple years ago and got a call this morning. His equity is completely gone. Couple hundred thousand. He invested with a big syndicate in San Antonio. Guy over paid for everything, over improved the property and put 80% bridge debt and all caps are expiring. And apparently this guy has an income fund he raised that he’s using to bail out all his deals. Beware folks. Lots of these syndicators are about to get nuked. Survive till 25 they said. lol. The bond market is telling the fed we don’t believe you assholes. It’s about to get ugly imo.


r/CommercialRealEstate • • Dec 09 '24 Take My Silver Heart of Silver

The average day in the life of a Rialto CMBS Servicer

176 Upvotes
  • You wake up Monday morning in your Miami condo. Your heads pounding after a busy weekend of business development with models on insert CRE hardo’s yacht.

  • Luckily for you, you turn to your left and the hooker cough I mean model from last night is asleep next to you. You rail a quick line off her back, pack her shit, make sure your watch collection is locked up, and leave her a nice note and a $300 tip.

  • todays a busy day at the office. You have 20 loans flagged as troubled, and you get to googling. You look up about 5 of the assets, and figure “eh these are nice buildings, they’ll figure it out” and shut your laptop.

  • you bullshit with a few coworkers and gossip about the latest Kenny G drama for 2 hours. It’s now finally lunch time.

  • you go down to the local steakhouse with the MD and a few clients. You joke about how if you don’t get the seafood tower, it’s not even a meal. You’re a busy man, so you take a phone call mid lunch from some poor asset manager who’s seeking a loan workout & write down. You quickly tell him to go fuck himself, and that you’re in the middle of lunch and absolutely slammed this week.

  • you stroll back into the office at 2:30. You pop a zinny baninni and get a phone call from a dude whose escrow wasn’t adjusted correctly. You apologize, and immediately shift the blame to your stupid back office people. You send a total of 2 emails outlining your frustration, pat yourself on the back knowing you’ve handled the situation personally, and call the client back saying it’s been dealt with. You realize without you, the entire company would grind to a halt.

  • it’s now 3:30. 10 more loans have been flagged as troubled. You google 2 of the buildings, figure they look nice, and lay the issues to rest. It’s already a late day for you, and you figure it’s time to call it.

  • you have reservations at 5:00pm at another steakhouse. You have no idea how you’re going to eat another meal after taking 60mg of adderall today, but you’re a fucking unit and you’ll find a way to power through.

  • after dinner, you get invited to go to a clients PH in Brickel. Of course you attend, rail a few lines, and begin talking about the demise of liberal cities and how you wouldnt mind if ron desantis pegged you in front of your boss.

  • you wake up at 9:00am the next day and rinse and repeat

What would the world do without Rialto.


r/CommercialRealEstate • • Nov 20 '23

WSJ article: Office Landlords Can’t Get a Loan Anymore

175 Upvotes

r/CommercialRealEstate • • Dec 24 '18

Deal life cycle

Post image
172 Upvotes

r/CommercialRealEstate • • Sep 15 '26

Financing | Debt 10 YR is now at 5%, how screwed are we? This seems bad.

158 Upvotes

Cannot believe the 10 YR is now at 5%, first time since 2007. Not sure if that is ringing alarm bells for a recession, but with rates probably rising tomorrow, yields are going to have to come up and these delusional sellers will need to open their eyes. Has been impossible to get deals done and now it's going to be even harder. Not seeing when things are going to normalize.


r/CommercialRealEstate • • Nov 19 '24

I love it when my 2 favorite subs unexpectedly collab

Thumbnail gallery
156 Upvotes

r/CommercialRealEstate • • Jan 30 '21

Building & Selling a Multifamily Project for $12m Gain After 3 Years

148 Upvotes

Hello fellow CRE enthusiasts! I bring you a development sale of a multifamily deal that officially closed and funds have now cleared as well. I took these screenshots (https://imgur.com/a/g4PIpbv) of the bank account with the incoming wire and the second page of my closing statement. We don’t own the project entirely (we have passive partners in the deal for 50% who put the money in the project for covering some of the site work and the soft costs to get the project going). So half of what I’ve received here in my bank account from this sale will be going to this equity partner. It took a year of planning/permitting and then two years of construction and building of these 160+ units of apartments. Selling it itself was another nightmare. It began many months ago and took multiple extensions to the PSA. The covid market did not help, obviously. More details on the project: So I helped securing the equity for the deal ($6m), we put a bit of money of our own ($2m) then I closed the construction loan ($24m) with a lender which I had a previous relationship with having done deals with them before. I oversaw about 24 draws and monthly inspections of this ground up construction myself. Since the project has multiple buildings on different tax parcels, I was able to refi these multifamily buildings that finished earlier and get cheaper bridge loans on them (cheaper than the construction loan we had but still more expensive than a perm would have been). Now that the last building (the largest of them all) was completed, we were able to sell all the buildings at once. The project overall appraised (MAI appraiser) at a 4.75% cap for +$50m based on a projected stabilized NOI in year 3. And we were able to sell it for $44m!! With a project cost of $32m, we had a 75% LTC loan. I was able to perform the GC functions in addition to the developer with my project manager and the site superintendent (we collected project management fees, general conditions for site worker salaries, overhead for the back office, and then profit for the GC function too!). Overall, this was quite the model project! It was built as a mid-level luxury product too.

If anyone has questions for me, please let me know. I’m happy to help, share any insight, and answer any questions.


r/CommercialRealEstate • • Jun 22 '26

Market Questions Are we just set up for a lost decade right now? This sucks.

145 Upvotes

Have been thinking about this a lot since the Fed meeting - CRE has, broadly, sucked since summer of ‘22 when the hikes started. Now here we are 4 years later, inflation is accelerating, consumers are stretched, treasuries are “perma stuck” in the 4-5% band for 4 years now and it’s looking more likely than not SOFR gets at least one bump. For 3.5 years we’ve been looking to “the year after next” - but like, is that realistic?

I think of all of the floaters barely holding on, the pileup of cheap 5/7 year fixed about to roll over in the next 12-24 months, the continuation of that for the clobbered multi people who hopped on the GSE 5 year train in 23/24. That’s real maturity into a real rate environment that, as we sit today, doesn’t look like it’s breaking towards 0 - if anything, cost of debt at best stays flat, at worst we do some dumbass thing to push the 5y/10y/SOFR up more. And then what - do cap rates finally expand?

And re negative leverage buys today - ok - your pro forma cap is positive leverage once you get thru concessions / roll to market leases so that cap rate inside debt maybe sort of makes sense… until you exit you’ve shaken out the upside NOI growth from pent up demand and then cap rates what, pump up 100+ at exit since buyers aren’t getting the growth? And sure deliveries are down today but if the market does heat up sidelined developers are absolutely coming to close the gap after eating shit and getting sidelined for years. And also population growth is slowing ! Im addition to population growth re-accelerating, you also need to believe the narrative that there is a true gap in housing supply in America. Aside from the big “where is everyone then” question which has been hanging for years, let’s suppose their Is a shortage in places where people want to be - but - is that structurally true in a country where people are moving to big southern cities with functionally no governor on supply or reason for land values to compress when there’s always one more ranch to build on? You can build exurban real estate in Texas, for example, as far as the eye can see.

That all doesn’t even touch the CLO market non-sense where the controlling class controls both the bonds AND the loans - sorry higher tranches no markdown and loss of control if we keep doing control shifts and indefinite amendments to the loans. Are these zombie assets ever going to come to market - and if so, at what terms?

Anyways I’m just bearish. This sucks, feels like a set up for a totally lost decade. What am I missing?


r/CommercialRealEstate • • Jun 11 '25

Representing Mom and Pop Landlords is physically Painful.

140 Upvotes

I’m representing a mom-and-pop landlord on a small retail strip center, and I just had one of those lease negotiations that makes me question my life choices.

Here’s the situation:

We’re negotiating with a good prospective tenant—solid local business, simple deal. Everything was moving forward until we hit a wall… over parking.

The tenant wanted to include standard lease language for unreserved parking—basically just stating that tenants and their customers can use the shared lot. Totally normal, right?

But the landlord refused. Said he doesn’t want anything in writing about unreserved parking, because he got burned at another property years ago. Apparently, a tenant tried to claim part of the lot as their own, and now he’s completely paranoid. So now, even if the parking spots are first-come, first-served and there’s way more parking than needed, he won’t allow even a mention of unreserved use in the lease.

The tenant, understandably, won’t sign a lease without it. They’ve had bad experiences, too, and want that basic protection. So now we’re stuck—completely deadlocked over something that’s usually boilerplate.

This kind of thing happens constantly with mom-and-pop landlords. I get that they’re trying to protect themselves, but past baggage from other properties just torpedoes perfectly good deals sometimes.

Anyone else deal with this kind of thing? How do you navigate it without losing your mind (or the deal)?


r/CommercialRealEstate • • Mar 31 '20

It's funny that business owners don't share the extra profits with landlords in the good years, but they want the landlord to share in the losses in the bad years.

140 Upvotes

Just a thought on this new pervasive expectation that landlords should be the providers of loss abatement during the pandemic, as if we are somehow equity partners in the tenants businesses but only when things get rough.

If I were a commercial landlord right now I'd be negotiating huge profit sharing deals for years if tenants couldn't pay rent for a few months in 2020.


r/CommercialRealEstate • • Aug 27 '25

Brokerage | Leasing What I've learned using AI as a Multifamily Broker over the last 6 months

135 Upvotes

Most of the other brokers I talk to have no idea how to use AI for their businesses. Six months ago, I was one of them.

I started experimenting with AI tools after I realized I was spending 15+ hours a week on stuff that wasn't actually selling deals - market research, comps analysis, writing property summaries, chasing down property details. I was told this when I moved from a bigger shop to a smaller one, but it was real.

What actually worked:

Deal sourcing: Built an AI system that scans new listings, OCR's rent rolls, and flags properties that match my buyers' criteria. Went from manually reviewing 200+ listings weekly to having 15-20 deals emailed to me every morning. Found 3 deals this way that I never would have spotted manually.

Underwriting speed: AI pulls comparable sales, analyzes rent trends, and creates initial pro formas in about 10 minutes vs the 2-3 hours it used to take me. Still need to verify everything, but it gets me 80% there instantly. I have a google sheet that I still manually fill out with all the real comp data, not on Costar, but it connect to my system so just need to update that. (Would love if someone could help me with this)

Client communication: Use AI to draft market summaries, property descriptions, and follow-up emails. I use an app called Fyxer for draft replies and I really don't know how I used email before it.

What didn't work:

AI valuations: Tried using AI for property valuations. Complete disaster. AI doesn't understand local nuances like that one apartment complex that looks great on paper but has foundation issues, or how the new Metro line actually affects different neighborhoods. Still do all valuations manually/ or assisted in the initial pro forma numbers.

Cold outreach: AI-generated prospecting emails perform worse than my personal ones. People can tell when it's generic.( I know there is a way to make it sound personal, I haven't cracked it yet.)

Complex negotiations: AI is useless for the relationship management and creative deal structuring that actually closes transactions. It is great for using my own knowledge and playing devil's advocate though.

The biggest surprise:

The time savings didn't come from replacing my expertise - it came from eliminating the mundane stuff so I could focus on the high-value relationship work that only humans can do. My deal velocity increased from 5 to 20 listings because I'm spending time on actual deal-making instead of the admin BS.

The reality check:

AI won't replace brokers who understand their market and can build relationships. But brokers who use AI effectively are going to outpace those who don't. The technology is advancing so fast that what seemed impossible 6 months ago is now possible. Very excited to see where I can take it.

Anyone else in CRE experimenting with AI tools? What's working (or not working) for you?


r/CommercialRealEstate • • Dec 20 '23

Roofer I Did Not Go with Sent Me an Invoice for Several Thousand

132 Upvotes

TLDR: Roofer that I did not sign anything with and who I did not go with for the job, but who I discussed roof claim with and pulled into the loop with insurance, sent me an invoice for $5,200

Hi All,

We noticed some leaks in our commercial property roof and engaged a roofer to get an estimate. I met with the roofer on-site a few times and called him a few times about this whole ordeal. I then introduced him as 'my roofer' to the insurance and copied him on correspondences with the insurance, as this was my first time dealing with a roof claim. The insurance company ended up sending out their own adjuster and also separately sent out their own engineer before paying out their own justified / calculated claim, which was approximately $50k.

I was initially intending to use this roofer for the job as I had seen his work, but I never signed a commitment letter or a contract. Two reasons I did not end up using this roofer - (1) he told the insurance company he did a 'repair' which he never did. In fact I told him to do the 'repairs' and charge me separately to slow down the leaks, but he basically ignored my requests and never did them, and (2) once he knew from me the claim was approved (which took 3 months), he kept pressuring me and border line harassing me to book the job without caring to answer the questions I had, and all the time making it seems like this was the most urgent roof replacement ever.

Now some nine months after this whole ordeal had started, he sent me a invoice for $5,200 for 'inspecting roof and assisting with insurance claim'. I agree his insights and what not were somewhat helpful to me as a commercial roof claim newbie, but the charges seems ridiculous. Reminder - I never signed a contract or an engagement letter of any kind. I am personally upset that he would send me an invoice for this exorbitant amount, which seems purely out of spite for not giving him the job.

Does this roofer actually have a legitimate claim to these charges? Should I be consulting with a lawyer? There are several emails and texts back and forth between this roofer and I where I was asking for advice on how to deal with the insurance company etc. that he could use as evidence, but nothing where I agree to giving him the contract or agree to pay him anything. Also, these same texts show the several texts where he is repeatedly trying to get me to book the job and claiming impending doom that the roof replacement is absolutely urgent! So it could go both ways, I think.

I want to respond and / or close this one way or another because I don't want there to be a lein of any kind put on my property. I am thinking of responding with something like this - "You provided an estimate like any other roofer and provided some documentation material to the insurance company, but the insurance estimate was vastly different than what you had provided. And the insurance company sent their own separate adjuster and own separate engineer to arrive at the conclusion for their claim. I never signed any sort of engagement letter or contract with you, nor did you provide any notice or pricing of these services you believe to have provided. If I would have known copying you on emails to the insurance company or talking to you on the phone was going to cost even remotely this much, I would never have engaged you." Thoughts? Any other insights are appreciated. Thank you!