As I enter a new stage of my life I am looking back at what I did right, and what I did wrong. For now I will stick to the failures. I am going to write a few of these, as time allows. May you learn from my mistakes.
Year is 2003 or 04. I live in a very rural area so my numbers on a national basis are MUCH cheaper than what you're used to. NAFTA and international trade has decimated manufacturing in rural Pennsylvania. As a result lots of towns/small cities have had their local manufacturer close shop and their real estate is coming up for sale everywhere. These buildings are anywhere from 50,000 - 200,000 square feet but are 30-75 years old and most often in terrible condition. The business owners were striving to make payroll, they weren't concerned a toilet broke or the roof was leaking.
They would come on the market for sale and no one would buy them because they were in terrible condition. I would wait and pounce until the price had dropped and was paying less than $5/sft. (This part I did right, with 1 or maybe 2 exceptions I never overpaid). The name of the game here was simply patience.
After my company bought it (I had 2 partners), we would remodel the whole thing. Painting it white and putting in new lights would make the inside look fantastic, usually for around $3/sft. Of course we would have to do the garage doors, bathrooms, lunchrooms, heat, etc... These improvements cost another $10/sft and the roof would be about $4/sft. So usually we had a like new building with a new roof, painted, new lights, heat and loading docks for between $15-$20/sft. This was at a time when building that building new would usually be between $30-$40/sft.
We never would put them up for sale, just lease them usually for between $2.50-$3.00/sft net. Our cash on cash return would average between 15-20%. We would sign a lease almost immediately. Go to the bank and borrow the full cost of the building based on the lease income. Now we had no cash in the property. Pre-2008 you could borrow the full cost.
Now you have the number side of the business. Starting around 2003 we do our first project, it's around 50,000 sft, with the numbers I mention above, and almost immediately rented. So we do this every 6 months. never selling a building. By 2006, I would estimate we had done 750,000 square feet of these projects and cash flow was amazing. So 2006 one of our main tenants comes to us and asks us to do a $5M build to suit. Of course! They are in the plumbing industry and home building is booming and their financials are amazing. We move them in 2007 and backfill their old space almost immediately. 2007 we do another 250,000 sft. So now we are up to 1,000,000+ sft plus of this product and then we have this huge new build to suit project that the rent needs to be more like $5/sft, double what we get everywhere else.
I had only done retail and office leasing prior to this and I was basically in charge of the leases. I could basically agree on the terms of the leases without anyone else's approval. I was definitely the most knowledgeable person on the team, but it turns out I wasn't that knowledgeable.
You see, as I was writing the leases, I got to pick the terms. 1 year lease? Sure, no problem, you're a public company of course we can do that for your VP. Small business, don't know the future, 3 year lease? No problem!
So while I was building this 1,000,000 sft portfolio of like new but old industrial real estate all the lease terms were 1-3 years. Now 2008 hits. We all know what happened then.
To cut off my long story - by 2010, the plumber that we had done the $5M build to suit for had gone bankrupt and our occupancy dropped from 100% to 40%. I think every single lease that expired except 1 the tenant declined to renew the lease. I would estimate we were losing $100,000 per month at one point and that went on for a few years. Thankfully we had the reserves to pay them and never missed a loan payment. We basically put it all up for sale and anyone that would buy anything vacant we would sell it. We didn't really get creamed in any of the sales because we bought right. Definitely lost low 6 figures on a few though. I'm sure we breached some of our loan covenants but banks didn't want the property back and recognized we were making payments so they didn't really give us a hard time. By 2012-3 we had fully recovered the business but it was much smaller and we were much more selective in our leases.
Moral of the story is short term leases (<3 years) are almost worthless other than for nice short term cash flow. If you're signing a short term lease understand what can and does happen. Have the reserves to carry the property through the bad times. For industrial leases like that I only endorse 5 year or longer terms. Alternatively it can have a landlord kick out clause. Sure I'll rent it to you for 1 year but I am going to keep the property on the market and kick you out when I do rent it to someone more serious.