r/CivilWarDebate • u/[deleted] • Dec 03 '21
r/CivilWarDebate • u/xmattyx • Jan 10 '22
Anti-Confederate Being Black During the Battle of Gettysburg
Interesting article here about the plight of POC around Gettysburg as the battle was coming. I recommend both sides give it a read.
r/CivilWarDebate • u/Garrisp1984 • Nov 09 '24
Anti-Union The true cause of the Civil War
1787 the 3/5ths compromise A policy established to protect New England Federalist congressional control over the rest of the country.
1814-1815 The failed New England secession Federalists intent on maintaining an Utopian Ethnostate held conventions to draft articles of secession over fears of losing majority congressional control over the rest of the country.
1820. The Missouri compromise A policy established by the North to prevent the South from expanding into the North, both as a way to prevent entry of African Americans into Northern territories and to prevent the South from increasing its congressional representation allowing the North to maintain its congressional control over the rest of the US.
1840-1848 Placerita Canyon and Sutters Creek in California, gold is found in abundance outside of North Carolina. This rapidly increased westward expansion, allowing the North to not be dependent on Southern Gold and Southern resources. Thereby negating the need for Northern compromises to maintain congressional control of the rest of the US
1850. The California compromise Even though the gold located in California would technically belong to the Southern States, this compromise essentially erased the Missouri compromise allowing the North to finally be resource independent. Additionally allowing Northern states the financial means to deport non-whites back to Africa much like they deported Natives to reservations.
1850. The fugitive Slave act. When the Southern states became aware of the Norths intent to "liberate" slaves back to Liberia or Canada, they enacted a law to protect their human cattle from poachers by making the poachers responsible for returning the slaves.
1860. Lincoln is elected. And South Carolina secedes With the addition of California the new makeup of congress became and president Lincoln the North had an unchallengeable majority representation and it was unlikely to ever return to equal representation. South Carolina peacefully secedes from the US prior to the new administration. When the Lincoln administration took over they refused to allow SC to leave the US. Over the next few months the Lincoln administration blockades are harbors and ports in an attempt to isolate South Carolina from being able to continue trade with European countries. South Carolina retaliates by retaking Fort Sumter without causing injury or loss of life to US troops. South Carolina allows the military to conduct a surrender ceremony in which 1 soldier is killed and 3 are wounded by a premature mortar explosion during the ceremony. This was intentionally misrepresented in Northern media to drum up support to put down the "rebellion" (defending sovereignty)
1861 Lincoln issues proclamation 93 In where he openly declares war on US citizens and calls for a full blockade of all Southern ports and 75000 militia to retake the South. Unwilling to go to War with it's fellow Americans North Carolina, Tennessee, Virginia, and Arkansas secede and stand in solidarity with the aforementioned aggrieved states. After being informed that he would have to lead an army to fight his own children and home state, the top general of the US Army, handpicked by Lincoln to lead the War declines the order and chooses to protect his home state.
1861 a week later Lincoln has the US army confiscate, and desecrate Lee's home, the home built in honor of Mrs Lee's great grandfather President George Washington. It has since become a national cemetery continuing the legacy of burying bodies around Lee's home so he couldn't return.
So the answer to the question is the same reason why all wars are fought, gold and power. And just like every other War in recorded history we changed the reason to sound more altruistic, because nobody willingly risks their lives just to line someone else's pockets.
Feel free to what-about all you want to, the facts remain the same either way. Keeping slaves, freeing slaves, states rights, emancipations, cornerstone speeches are all examples of propaganda used by those with money and power to manipulate those without.
r/CivilWarDebate • u/IamRhodes • Dec 03 '21
Grant was basically Nazis before nazis. And a major alcoholic who also sent thousands of men into The meat grinder, not a great strategist, just had more men to throw at the enemy. So sad!
r/CivilWarDebate • u/xmattyx • Dec 03 '21
Pro-Union Seriously, don't bash the mods
The dude is from a confederate sub and got stuck modding this one. He is doing everyone a favor keeping this option open for debate so please don't hack on him too much.
Attack his ideas in the posts but lets at least get this shitshow up and running before we drive the mod away!
Goddammit you guys made me defend a mod.
r/CivilWarDebate • u/NoReallyItsJeff • Jan 12 '22
Civil War figures you find the most irritating
Take that however you choose to interpret it. From my perspective, irritating figures are those who get spoken of the most highly for reasons I don't agree with. Who is on your list?
Stonewall Jackson. A few lucky breaks and dying at the right time hides a surprisingly uneven record.
Joshua Lawrence Chamberlain. A perfectly adequate commander whose self-promotion gets accepted as history, even though a lot of his claims about his Civil War record don't stand up under close scrutiny. The Killer Angels and Gettysburg only made things worse.
Robert E. Lee. Certainly a compelling and complex figure, but you have to scrape away decades of mythology before I can tolerate reading about him.
Take your pick of Grant's favorites - Schofield, Wilson, Sheridan. Questionable talent, obnoxniously ambitious.
r/CivilWarDebate • u/xmattyx • Jan 27 '22
Anti-Confederate Shots Fired.
" No matter how discredited, no matter how much mainstream historical scholarship and teaching curricula expose and explain the Lost Cause traditions, they endure—especially for those in search of a past that they believe will relieve them of the present. Some Americans are forever in search of safe havens for racial ideologies that reject the dynamism of the multiethnic America the nation has become. "
r/CivilWarDebate • u/xmattyx • Feb 17 '22
Pro-Union Greatest Civil War Artillery Video Ever
r/CivilWarDebate • u/ericlindblade • Aug 29 '22
Our latest episode has been released, hope you will give it a listen!
r/CivilWarDebate • u/xmattyx • Dec 03 '21
Anti-Confederate lee Failed
So let us talk about lee, the traitor general responsible for the deaths of thousands of Americans and the deaths of a bunch of traitors.
At Gettysburg, why do you think he attacked the way he did and wasted all of those lives? I mean literally, on the third day he charged across an open field under full enemy fire across 3/4 of a mile to attack an entrenched position. That is first day general stuff they tell you not to do. It was bad enough the second day when he repeatedly had his troops storm uphill into an entrenched positions, but the third day is just ridiculous.
Why didn't he listen to the only half competent general they had and circled around the rear or moved into a defensive position?
I have some theories. First is that he was sick mentally. Maybe underlying narcissism (that would explain the slavery and the desire to murder his own countrymen).
Secondly, I just think he was an idiot. He believed the propaganda the south was putting out that they were a much better fighting force than they were and his troops let him down and failed miserably.
Lastly, since it runs in the blood of every confederate, martyrdom? A victory with losses so great that he could be consoled and handled with kid gloves?
Who knows? All i know is that for a "military genius", he did insanely stupid things that caused the deaths of thousands of people and lost anyways. He should have been court marshaled for picketts embarrassing failed charge.
Such is the life of a traitor.
r/CivilWarDebate • u/Maestro_Titarenko • Dec 03 '21
Pro-Union Sherman was right to burn the Confederate countryside
Sherman was way ahead of his time with his total war strategy, by destroying so much infrastructure he made sure to:
1- break the will of the Conderacy to continue fighting, as seen by the many who deserted during the Appomattox Campaign
2- deprive the CSA of the food to feed its troops
3- his goals were reached with a minimal loss of life
All in all, by making a brutal war he managed to shorten it, preventing more blooshed which would come with a longer war
r/CivilWarDebate • u/xmattyx • Dec 03 '21
Anti-Confederate lee quotes
Here I Will deposit a number of quotes from the traitor general himself to try to dispel some of the lost-cause BS.
" I have always observed that wherever you find the negro, everything is going down around him, and wherever you find the white man, you see everything around him improving. "
" Remember, we are all one country now. Dismiss from your mind all sectional feeling, and bring them up to be Americans. " (ahem you confederates)
" I believe it to be the duty of everyone to unite in the restoration of the country and the reestablishment of peace and harmony. " (again you confederates)
" The enemy never sees the backs of my Texans! " (LOL @ Little Round Top)
" Abandon your animosities and make your sons Americans! "
It seems the traitors can't even read and abide the words of their traitor saint!
r/CivilWarDebate • u/thegr8dictator • Dec 03 '21
Pro-Union McClellan wasn’t THAT bad
He was a pretty good administrator but did have his flaws as a field commander. Landing an army on the peninsula was a unique idea and it could have worked.
r/CivilWarDebate • u/[deleted] • Dec 03 '21
Pro-Union A True Southern Hero and American Patriot:George Henry Thomas United States Army general (1816–1870)
r/CivilWarDebate • u/ExistCat • Dec 03 '21
Despite what you’ve been told, the civil war was about slavery
From the CSA Declaration of Independence:
The General Government, as the common agent, passed laws to carry into effect these stipulations of the States. For many years these laws were executed. But an increasing hostility on the part of the non-slaveholding States to the institution of slavery,
From: https://avalon.law.yale.edu/19th_century/csa_scarsec.asp
r/CivilWarDebate • u/[deleted] • Dec 02 '21
The Civil War was the peak of facial hair for men in the US.
Read the title.
r/CivilWarDebate • u/xmattyx • Mar 10 '25
Pro-Union Thoughtcrime
Hello All, Due to Reddit choosing to censor contributors and sending them threats based on vague violations involving words like “Luigi”, I will be moving the forum over to Lemmy. This is not a terribly busy sub, but I would rather not continue on a site that is censoring people that do not align with their political leanings or their shareholders wishes. I’ll still be checking this sub, but most likely will not be posting. Thanks, -Luigi
r/CivilWarDebate • u/xmattyx • Jan 24 '22
Currently Reading.....
I am working my way through Jack Kunkels "Our Fathers at Gettysburg" and so far it has been outstanding. The digital version even has links to maps and youtube videos to help understand the movement of troops better. It has helped to answer several questions I have had for years surrounding the second days action, and this book literally covers every action. I highly reccomend it.
Anyone else reading anything good? how about you rebs, anything you are reading we can talk about?
