r/CivilWarDebate • • Dec 03 '21

Despite what you’ve been told, the civil war was about slavery

79 Upvotes

From the CSA Declaration of Independence:

The General Government, as the common agent, passed laws to carry into effect these stipulations of the States. For many years these laws were executed. But an increasing hostility on the part of the non-slaveholding States to the institution of slavery,

From: https://avalon.law.yale.edu/19th_century/csa_scarsec.asp


r/CivilWarDebate • • Dec 03 '21

Anti-Confederate 🇺🇸🇺🇸 JOHN BROWN POSTING 🇺🇸🇺🇸

Post image
62 Upvotes

r/CivilWarDebate • • Dec 03 '21

Anti-Confederate Harriet Tubman also served as a Union spy, scout, and nurse in the Civil War. She is a civil war hero.

Post image
42 Upvotes

r/CivilWarDebate • • Dec 02 '21

The Civil War was the peak of facial hair for men in the US.

36 Upvotes

Read the title.


r/CivilWarDebate • • Dec 03 '21

Pro-Union Sherman was right to burn the Confederate countryside

31 Upvotes

Sherman was way ahead of his time with his total war strategy, by destroying so much infrastructure he made sure to:

1- break the will of the Conderacy to continue fighting, as seen by the many who deserted during the Appomattox Campaign

2- deprive the CSA of the food to feed its troops

3- his goals were reached with a minimal loss of life

All in all, by making a brutal war he managed to shorten it, preventing more blooshed which would come with a longer war


r/CivilWarDebate • • Dec 03 '21

Anti-Confederate How was Confederacy Pro states rights when they violated states rights multiple times very heavily?

20 Upvotes
  1. The Fugitive Slave Act of 1850 was law that southern states supported and got federal goverment to approve. Ite required law enforcers in free states to catch escaped slaves and return them on the penalty of a fine. This violates free states rights to let everyone live free from slavery.

  2. Confederacy tried to invade Missouri and Kentucky and force them to leave the Union even tho people of thouse states did not want that.

Kentucky wanted to stay neutral but when pro union candinates won big in the election Confederacy invaded Kentucky.

Missouri voted about seceeding but voted against it. State governor and state militia then tried to conspire seccecion even tho the people did not want it, Confederacy also tried to invade the state

3. Confederate constitution denied passing laws that would end slavery thus forcing all states in the Confederacy to keep slavery legal.

It is very clear that Confederacy did not care about states rights and states making their own decicions other than states rights to PROTECT The institution of slavery.


r/CivilWarDebate • • Dec 03 '21

Pro-Union A True Southern Hero and American Patriot:George Henry Thomas United States Army general (1816–1870)

Post image
15 Upvotes

r/CivilWarDebate • • Dec 03 '21

Pro-Union McClellan wasn’t THAT bad

14 Upvotes

He was a pretty good administrator but did have his flaws as a field commander. Landing an army on the peninsula was a unique idea and it could have worked.


r/CivilWarDebate • • Dec 03 '21

Fort Sumter is a national park! The National Park Service has a wonderful overview of the fort's history on their website.

Thumbnail
nps.gov
14 Upvotes

r/CivilWarDebate • • Dec 03 '21

WHILE WE WERE MARCHING THROUGH GEORGIA

Post image
12 Upvotes

r/CivilWarDebate • • Apr 10 '22

Pro-Union Slavery and Treason Buried In The Same Grave

Post image
11 Upvotes

r/CivilWarDebate • • Dec 03 '21

Anti-Confederate But his soul is marching on!

Post image
11 Upvotes

r/CivilWarDebate • • Feb 15 '22

Our most recent episode has been released, hope you will give it a listen!

Post image
10 Upvotes

r/CivilWarDebate • • Dec 05 '21

Today In Civil War History

10 Upvotes

" The Battle of Waynesboro was an American Civil War battle fought on December 4, 1864 in eastern Georgia, towards the end of Sherman's March to the Sea. Union cavalry forces under Brig. Gen. Judson Kilpatrick defeated Confederate cavalry led by Maj. Gen. Joseph Wheeler, opening the way for William T. Sherman's armies to approach their objective, Savannah. "

- Wikipedia contributors. (2021, July 25). Battle of Waynesboro, Georgia. In Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia. Retrieved 03:50, December 5, 2021, from https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Battle_of_Waynesboro,_Georgia&oldid=1035322932


r/CivilWarDebate • • Dec 03 '21

Anti-Confederate lee Failed

10 Upvotes

So let us talk about lee, the traitor general responsible for the deaths of thousands of Americans and the deaths of a bunch of traitors.

At Gettysburg, why do you think he attacked the way he did and wasted all of those lives? I mean literally, on the third day he charged across an open field under full enemy fire across 3/4 of a mile to attack an entrenched position. That is first day general stuff they tell you not to do. It was bad enough the second day when he repeatedly had his troops storm uphill into an entrenched positions, but the third day is just ridiculous.

Why didn't he listen to the only half competent general they had and circled around the rear or moved into a defensive position?

I have some theories. First is that he was sick mentally. Maybe underlying narcissism (that would explain the slavery and the desire to murder his own countrymen).

Secondly, I just think he was an idiot. He believed the propaganda the south was putting out that they were a much better fighting force than they were and his troops let him down and failed miserably.

Lastly, since it runs in the blood of every confederate, martyrdom? A victory with losses so great that he could be consoled and handled with kid gloves?

Who knows? All i know is that for a "military genius", he did insanely stupid things that caused the deaths of thousands of people and lost anyways. He should have been court marshaled for picketts embarrassing failed charge.

Such is the life of a traitor.


r/CivilWarDebate • • Dec 03 '21

Anti-Confederate Heritage not Hate

Post image
9 Upvotes

r/CivilWarDebate • • Mar 24 '22

Lee's invasions of the North; were they sound military decisions that did not pan out, or foolish endeavors from the start?

8 Upvotes

r/CivilWarDebate • • Feb 04 '22

Opinions on the generalship of Joseph E. Johnston?

8 Upvotes

Johnston's recently had an uptick in popularity, at least online. You'll find a lot of differing opinion on him. I've met people who hail him as the best general of the Confederacy, and those who swear by him being the absolute worst. What's your guys' thoughts?


r/CivilWarDebate • • Dec 16 '21

Best and worst general of these officers; McClellan, Pope and Burnside.

8 Upvotes

r/CivilWarDebate • • Dec 03 '21

Pro-Union Seriously, don't bash the mods

8 Upvotes

The dude is from a confederate sub and got stuck modding this one. He is doing everyone a favor keeping this option open for debate so please don't hack on him too much.

Attack his ideas in the posts but lets at least get this shitshow up and running before we drive the mod away!

Goddammit you guys made me defend a mod.


r/CivilWarDebate • • Dec 03 '21

Pro-Union For the union!

Post image
8 Upvotes

r/CivilWarDebate • • Sep 08 '22

This weekend (September 10 & 11) I am leading tours of the Cedar Creek battlefield with all proceeds going to the restoration of the historic Heater House. For more information please feel free to send me a direct message on here.

Post image
7 Upvotes

r/CivilWarDebate • • Feb 19 '22

Pro-Union No Title Needed.

Post image
7 Upvotes