r/ChristopherHitchens
•
u/lemontolha
•
Mar 01 '25
r/ChristopherHitchens
•
u/Greygonz0
•
Feb 16 '25
Salman Rushdie on Elon Musk and 'freedom of expression'. I can imagine Hitch saying something very similar
r/ChristopherHitchens • u/Late_Village_1017 • Jan 04 '25
Hitchens summarized people
In this discourse of Hitchens, proclaiming that Christians are complimenting their religion with a very bogus indoctrination. Even the meekest person of thinking can't reach him/her self to that stage of saying we would simply pillage or do such a wicked act like those people. Hitchens conspicuously showed us how people are bogus and so pretentious.
r/ChristopherHitchens
•
u/[deleted]
•
Jan 01 '25
I wonder if Hitch would have been more pro-gun control today…
r/ChristopherHitchens
•
u/Old-Chip7764
•
Apr 15 '25
This doesn't deserve to lie in the shade
Apologies if this has been posted here before, but I stumbled across it and think it is still relevant currently, and besides: love hearing him anyway
r/ChristopherHitchens • u/[deleted] • Apr 01 '25
I wonder if Hitch would feel similarly to Bill Burr about the MAGA “anti-woke” crusade…
r/ChristopherHitchens
•
u/[deleted]
•
Jan 22 '25
This applies more so to the West Bank today…
r/ChristopherHitchens
•
u/[deleted]
•
Nov 24 '24
Dawkins is at an utter loss for words….
r/ChristopherHitchens • u/lemontolha • Jan 13 '25
Harris explains how he and Musk fell out.
r/ChristopherHitchens • u/snakkerdudaniel • May 13 '25
This is the future MAGA wants for the USA
r/ChristopherHitchens • u/lemontolha • Jan 26 '25
Do you think that Christopher Hitchens would disagree with his brother in this question?
r/ChristopherHitchens • u/[deleted] • Feb 05 '25
Hitch was right…This conflict was never going to be resolved peacefully with religious elements involved…
r/ChristopherHitchens • u/[deleted] • Feb 18 '25
This might be almost as quippy as Hitch's razor
r/ChristopherHitchens • u/[deleted] • Nov 10 '24
JD Vance called himself a “Christopher Hitchens-reading atheist” before College
r/ChristopherHitchens • u/[deleted] • Sep 20 '24
Mark Robinson, Endorsed by Trump for Governor of North Carolina, Called Himself a “Black Nazi” and expresses love for transgender pornography
r/ChristopherHitchens
•
u/recentlyquitsmoking2
•
Oct 24 '25
"I had imagined that the thoughtful conservative was opposed to government intervention in the economy"
I appear here as a battered old socialist and guarded admirer of that great old free trader of the 19th century, Karl Marx, and as one, furthermore, in this battered company who's been given by Firing Line among others, a bruising education in the libertarian and conservative values for which I'm grateful.
And now, what is my shock?
What is my woe to discover? That they didn't really mean what they were appearing to teach me.
For I had imagined that the thoughtful conservative was opposed to government intervention in the economy, was opposed to state manipulations of the market. I surmised that they were against the picking of winners or the surreptitious subsidizing of one competitor over another.
Now here they are appearing to tell me that government should tax some entrepreneurs and not others, should privilege one sector over another, should promote federal supervision and intervention by stealth, by surreptitious means - by the back door.
I've heard the other rhetoric, of course, all my life. Crippling taxation. Penal, socialistic imposts down to our last 10 million. Confiscatory taxation.
Of course, yet the rich as ever always seem to be doing okay and so do their fabled engines of prosperity.
Now it's being argued that this business is so profitable and such an engine of prosperity that it shouldn't be taxed at all, which seems to me to be a paradox on its face.
More dispiritingly, this comes to us in the old, stale, new frontier terms, actually.
This is Kennedy rhetoric, not proper conservative rhetoric about rising pies and sinking boats, or is it the other way around? Is it the rising pie that sinks the boat or the sinking boat that jettisons the pie? I never can remember.
The mixture of metaphor, though, I think is probably a guide to the clarity of the argument.
This I think would be to leave many of the so far technologically impoverished, people who I must say include myself, behind, as well as to argue that the super wealthy should be exempted from tax for the very reason that they are so rich and successful, a very grand self-justifying argument.
Let me close, though, in the spirit of amity and compromise, that I'm sure we'll distinguish this evening, and should.
That if the whole economy be taxed, perhaps Mr. Kemp would agree, that if it was all to be included, the tax could be flat. And so I propose that we have a flat tax of internet commerce, and hope that my generous offer will be taken up by you gentlemen. Thank you.
---
Christopher Hitchens argues against "The federal government should not impose a tax on e-commerce".
r/ChristopherHitchens • u/[deleted] • Oct 20 '24
Let’s be honest. We ignore Congo’s atrocities because it’s in Africa
r/ChristopherHitchens
•
u/lemontolha
•
Feb 06 '26
Ralph Leonard: Noam Chomsky’s reputation will never recover from the Epstein files
This article by Hitchenite Ralph Leonard features the beef of Hitchens vs. Chomsky and Hitchens ostracism from the regressive left:
In a 2003 philippic against Christopher Hitchens, Finkelstein observed that “bashing Noam Chomsky” was a rite of passage for apostates because he “mirrors their idealistic past as well as sordid present, an obstinate reminder that they once had principles but no longer do, that they sold out but he didn’t”. Finkelstein was turning Chomsky into a messiah figure. The latter was adamantine in his political consistency, in contrast with “apostates” like Hitchens, a former Chomsky enthusiast who had turned to the dark side when convenient.
Given Chomsky, aged 97, is unwell and rarely makes public statements, it would be easy to use the Chomsky revelations to ostracise him (as much of the left ostracised Hitchens for his support of the Iraq War in the early 2000s). Indeed, Chomsky’s silence has created a vacuum for the speculation of his critics. Many on the right have straightforwardly pounced on his associations with Epstein to discredit his wider politics. But on the left, too, those who always saw Chomsky as the establishment’s favourite pseudo-dissident have taken this episode as evidence that Chomsky was a wimpish liberal all along. (Of course, the anti-Semitic groypers have added Chomsky to the globalist Jewish cabal that rule the world.) But character assassination is rarely a good method of intellectual surgery. And for those more baffled or wounded by these Chomsky revelations, there is a more tempered conclusion: Chomsky was never a beacon or a sage, and was susceptible to these lapses of judgement long before he met Epstein.
Finkelstein is a demagogue of course. Hitchens was not "bashing" Chomsky, merely disagreeing with him. It's rather Finkelstein who is bashing Hitchens there, by mischaracterizing the Hitchens vs. Chomsky exchange as one sided. Go and read the whole thing, in The Nation, it's instructive.
If you read all those former Chomsky-fans now being dissapointed you start to wonder what actually was it that they saw in Chomsky other than somebody who was famous for being a sage and talked of with reverence. If you started to look at his actual moral arguments, this definitely didn't hold up. So you were ok with the guy denying the genocide of Bosnians and doing PR for Milosevic and others, but you draw the line at him consorting with Epstein?
r/ChristopherHitchens • u/recentlyquitsmoking2 • Oct 08 '25
Tell me again why you don't 'believe' in reason?
Hitchens: We don't indulge in wish thinking, we don't assert as true what we've just been asked to prove. I have to say I think that's a methodological difference worth observing in an institution of higher education.
Wilson: Tell me again why you don't believe in reason.
Hitchens: Because reason is by definition not something that is a matter of faith.
Wilson: It's axiomatic.
Hitchens: No, it's a process.
Wilson: Kind of like the Bible.
Hitchens: It's a process.
Wilson: I begin with the Bible, you begin with reason, I have faith in the Bible, you have faith in reason. If I ask you to justify...
Hitchens: ... You're a man of one book.
Wilson: And you're a man of one thought.
Hitchens: If you laugh at that, you'd laugh at, I think you'd probably be like Bill Maher's audience, you'd laugh at anything.
To say that you believe in the process of reason, inquiry, skepticism, and the measurement of evidence against interest so that you would doubt most of all something that favored your own conclusion, you'd subject that to more scrutiny, you call that one thought?
You have contempt for thought if you think that. I'm sorry, I have to stop trying to be funny here.
Wilson: Why can't you say I have confidence in reason, I have faith in reason, I trust in the reasoning process? You won't say that because it will reveal that both our positions are faith positions. If you ask me why I believe in the Bible and I flip open the Bible and show you a verse, you say "you're appealing to what you need to prove." If I ask you why do you believe in reason and give me a reason, then you open your book, you open the reason and give me a reason.
Hitchens: No, no, you're again, you're making a huge leap. I say that the Bible, like the Quran, and like the Torah, is man-made, not God-made. It's a human-made literary accretion full of plagiarism, contradiction, fragmentation, and so on. It's like every other book ever written.
There's nothing divine about it, and the appeal to it saying, "I can trump anything you say because here's God's word on the page," is a contemptible way of arguing.
Wilson: I wrote a logic textbook. Does that make logic man-made?
Hitchens: Logic is man-made, yes. [laughter] Logic is the attempt by humans to make sense. It isn't a divine endowment that we possess. Same with philosophy. Philosophy means the love of wisdom. We don't say it's the revelation by ... you say what you have is revealed.
Now, here's the way of clarifying the difference between us. Somebody asked earlier.
I don't claim to know more than I can. Everything I've said this evening I've backed by assertions, evidence, argument.
Douglas Wilson, who's just as modest and friendly and tender a chap as I am, says, "Yeah, but I have an advantage over Christopher, because I know what God wants, and I know what he says in his book, I have access to a higher authority." Now, I'll ask him, but I don't care. I've asked him before. You have to ask him.
How does he know that, and by what right does he claim to know the mind of God?
And if you were a serious spiritual person, wouldn't you think it was a bit much that someone said they could come before you and tell you what God wanted?
As long as they don't call it modesty, I don't mind. As long as they don't call it humility, I don't mind. But I don't like being told that my arguments aren't as good as his, because he has divine information that's withheld from me.
r/ChristopherHitchens
•
u/recentlyquitsmoking2
•
Sep 21 '25
I find it extraordinary that it can be said on a university campus that "without god, humans are capable of anything."
I find it extraordinary that it can be said on a university campus in this year of grace that without God, humans are capable of doing anything. That there is no moral restraint upon us if we don't concur in the idea that we are the property and creation of a supreme being.
I'm making the assumption that all of you check in every now and then with some kind of news outlet and have a view of what's going on in the rest of the world. Isn't it as plain as could be that those who commit the most callous, the most cruel, the most brutal, the most indiscriminate atrocities of all, do so precisely because they believe they have divine permission?
Shall I answer my own question? Shall I insult you by adding more?
Who can't think of an example of this kind? Let me put the question in another form that I've put in now. Every forum from YouTube to C-SPAN to the wireless to the print to the radio to the television and innumerable forums to those who say that without God there can be no morality.
You are to ask yourself two questions.
You are to name a moral action undertaken or a moral and ethical statement made by a believer. I daresay you can do it. You are then to say that you cannot imagine a non-believer making this moral statement or undertaking this moral action.
Can you think, can you now think, can any of you think, you don't have to answer now, it's a little night and you have my email and I've done this with everyone from the Archbishop of Canterbury to even lower people. You name me the ethical and moral actional statement that a believer can make and an unbeliever cannot and there's a prize and I'll tell you about that later.
Now there's a second question.
2. Think of something wicked that only a believer would be likely to do or something wicked that only a believer would be likely to say.
You've already thought of it.
The suicide bombing community is entirely religious. The genital mutilation community is entirely religious. I wouldn't say that the child abuse community is entirely religious. I wouldn't, but it's bidding to be entirely religious.
It operates on the old Latin slogan, no child's behind left.
How dare anybody, how dare anyone who speaks for religion say of us, the secular and the non-believers that we are the immoral ones. It is itself a wicked thing to say, itself an absolutely indefensible thing to say
r/ChristopherHitchens • u/[deleted] • Feb 08 '25
Trump's FBI pick received payment from pro-Russian filmmaker….I wonder how Hitch would feel about Kremlin meddling so much with our republic
r/ChristopherHitchens • u/recentlyquitsmoking2 • Oct 29 '25
The person who says that of Marxism that it is deterministic convicts himself, at once, of never having opened a book by Marx or by Marxists.
It is the single most vulgar misrepresentation of Marxism to say that it's determinist. The person who says that of it convicts himself, at once, of never having opened a book by Marx or by Marxists.
It was, for its time and remains, the most determinedly and avowedly anti-determinist mode of thought in philosophy.
Most famously, and you'll see why I'm stressing this in a second, Marx began his most famous account of history and revolution, the 18th Brumaire of Louis-Napoleon, by saying, "Men make history, but they do not make it under circumstances of their own choosing. They make it, but under circumstances directly transmitted and engaged from the past. The traditions of all the dead generations," he then famously added, weigh like a nightmare on the brain of the living."
That's not determinism, self-evidently not determinism.
Now, let me say why I think this bears on the question of violence.
Men make history, but they can't choose when and how they're going to make it.
If it was up to me, and I think I would carry John Judas with me here, the Russian Revolution would have happened in 1905, when there was a large democratic revolution led by socialists that was put down by the Tsar, and which, with tremendous bloodshed and repression, and which paved the way for a ghastly imperialist war in which millions of Russians were killed under the leadership of the system of hereditary God-given monarchy, which was the system with which capitalism in Russia was at that time coexisting.
Now, it is not, therefore, by the socialist choice that revolution took place in Russia at the close of that gigantic war and bloodletting and gigantic tearing apart of the fabric of Russian society to the point where cannibalism had reemerged in the countryside.
An emergence, in my submission, that is not unrelated to the later course of events in the Soviet Union. It's quite simply unhistorical to say that, well, 'revolutionists devour their children'.
You then surrender the need to analyze history, and you can simply look at history as the working out of that proposition. Very good means of economizing on thought, and one that I think should be repudiated by any thoughtful objectivist.
r/ChristopherHitchens
•
u/recentlyquitsmoking2
•
Oct 11 '25
I'll get to the end of this sentence if it ...
The point of social democracy is so that we don't need to rely on the whim of organisations who deem some people more deserving than others.
-
Transcript:
Hitchens: Towards the tail of the last question I asked the lady from the Sydney Institute. whether these institutions you're talking about...
Anne Henderson: I'm Anne.
Hitchens: Well I don't know you well enough yet.
Anne Henderson: I'll just introduce myself.
Hitchens: Perhaps we'll be more bonded by the end of the...
Anne Henderson: Some would say not much of a lady.
Hitchens: We'll be more intimate by the end of the...
Tony Jones: None of us would say that.
Anne Henderson: Well I know people who would.
Hitchens: It's just not the way I was brought up. Perhaps by the end of the show we'll be more intimate.
She wasn't content just to say religious people volunteer for charities, if that was news to anybody but she had to couple it with a smear against Fabianism and social democracy. Now as a matter of fact...
Anne Henderson: Well they weren't there Christopher. That's all I was saying.
Hitchens: I'm so sorry to say that without...
Anne Henderson: I didn't say it was a smear. But you're good at smears.
Hitchens: The efforts of Fabianism...
Anne Henderson: What's wrong with a smear?
Hitchens: I don't...
I'll get to the end of this sentence if it kills you.
[Laughter]
Hitchens: The efforts of socialists and social democrats to make sure that things like education and health do not depend upon private charity given by rich people and religious institutions to the deserving poor are the reasons why a lot of it's taken care of because "it's taken care of".
Anne Henderson: Hang on. I wasn't ...
Hitchens: Because we have welfare and ...
Anne Henderson: .. But just a minute there's another smear. I wasn't a rich person giving charity where it wasn't got and you have to understand the problem.
Hitchens: I didn't say that you were.
Anne Henderson: Well it seemed to come across that way.
Hitchens: I didn't even imply that you were. No. The efforts of Fabianism and social democracy (socialism) were to make sure that these things didn't depend on the voluntary whim. Or the idea of the deserving poor. Now that's the first point.
Anne Henderson: I know about this.
Hitchens: The second point... Well because it's so taken for granted now I love to remind people actually this...
Anne Henderson: That was a long time ago.
Hitchens: This meant social political action -- as you correctly say, as you quite correctly say and I can help you out here by emphasising it -- quite a while ago. That's why I said not to forget it. Now to the point about religious activism.
Isn't it true, haven't you all heard that Hamas does so well because it supplies social services? Are you going to say that it's the same is true for Hamas and Islamic Jihad? Never mind that they're. religious. They distribute services where otherwise there'd only be secularism and corruption. Well, if you want to claim that you can't just claim the charitable part of it it seems to me.
Mother Teresa, endlessly praised for work that most of the time she actually never did. I went to watch her very closely in Calcutta. You don't mind that she thinks that what Bengal and Calcutta mainly needs is a campaign, a clerical campaign against birth control and family planning.
Has anyone here ever been to Bengal and concluded that's what it really needs? That's what she was really campaigning for in case you worry. But never mind. She gives a wonderful impression of being a charitable person. So what Indians need is more missionaries to cure poverty.
When everybody knows there's only one cure for poverty which is the empowerment of women.
Which means giving them some control over their reproductive ...
You name me a Catholic or Muslim charity that goes into the fields determined to secure the empowerment of women and you'll have the ghost of a point.
Tony Jones: Let's see if Frank Benning...
Hitchens: Up till now you don't.
Tony Jones: Let's see if Frank...