r/ChristopherHitchens • u/tompez • Oct 28 '24
r/ChristopherHitchens • u/lemontolha • Nov 14 '24
’Identity Politics’ Isn’t Why Harris Lost
Matt Johnson, author of "How Christopher Hitchens can save the left", on why Trump won an Kamala lost.
r/ChristopherHitchens • u/AnomicAge • Aug 11 '24
It's sad to see Dawkins devolving into a dogmatist
A man once resolved to evidence and logic now spreading disinformation that suits his anti-trans agenda (because it's more than just remonstrating against the follies of the far left by this point).
Like many 'public intellectuals' he's set his iron sights on the left more so than the right in recent years, equating wokeism to a religion unto itself.
In a time where Christofascism is threatening to poison America like never before we need religion to be the focal point of criticism now more than ever, and where are far too many red herrings being tactically tossed about to divert attention from the sinister brainwashing is being done, and moves being made behind the curtains.
The right claim to care for women's wellbeing and equality by reproaching MTF trans womens participation in sports - this is a conundrum worth discussing as is the degree to which children should be encouraged or supported in challenging their biological sex, but its painfully obvious that most who press the points are ideologically averse to transsexualism and oftentimes the broader LGTB community as a whole and this is just the lowest hanging fruit and chink in the armor since it's something that even most leftists are unresolved on. Their ideologies oppress and infantilize women and have done throughout history and now we're to believe they're distraught because of some potential unfairness in women's sporting competitions?
They lament the menace of drag queens corrupting young minds meanwhile their gun laws or lack thereof turned elementary schools into shooting galleries, and they seemingly have no qualms with delivering their dear children into the clutches of the worlds largest pedophile ring - when's the last time a transvestite was arrested for raping a child? Meanwhile child abuse and the church go together like peanut butter and jelly.
Dawkins has been spreading the fallacy that Imane Khelif has a Y chromosome despite their being no such evidence, and a boatload of evidence of corruption within the IBA. Being a biologist matters of sexual biology are more within his wheelhouse than others who feel the need to weigh in but at this point he just seems to be tarnishing his legacy.
Perhaps he feels that he's said everything that needs to be said about religion, and of course the left can become misguided and hypocritical, but to take aim at wokeism and refer to it as a religion is a gross distortion of the term.
I can't imagine Hitch taking kindly to his trajectory... while he never stood for feel good bullshit he was never one to punch down toward persecuted groups especially while parroting half baked arguments that don't hold up under the first level of scrutiny.
Anyway what do you make of it?
r/ChristopherHitchens • u/lemontolha • Jul 02 '25
If a ceasefire leaves Hamas in power, they’ll kill Gazans like me
thejc.comI'm reasonably sure, giving Christopher Hitchens support for Palestinian leftists and secularists, and his warning that Hamas will bring death and destruction to Gaza (see "How Hamas dooms Palestine"), Moumen al-Natour is one of the Palestinian voices he'd like amplified.
r/ChristopherHitchens
•
u/AnomicAge
•
Nov 06 '24
Trumps victory might very well be the deathblow to democracy in the US
Not directly related to Hitch but I really need to vent so I wrote my thoughts in longform. It didn't really provide any catharsis but I thought I would post it here anyway given his involvement in political commentary.
It's a long one but Ive got a lot to say.
Despite the comical absurdity of the past decade, witnessing the de facto death of democracy in the US still wasn’t on my bingo card for 2024.
I guess I underestimated the sheer depth and span of brain rot and or heartless bigotry infecting the divided states, and unfortunately, spreading well beyond into other fragile democracies.
There truly wasn’t much more one could do to tarnish the fat bastards reputation in the lead up to the election; if multiple criminal convictions, tenable child rape allegations, brazen sympathising and consorting with a Russian dictator to the point of being a probable Russian asset, stealing from charities, running fraudulent businesses, attempting to undermine democracy by fomenting an insurrection, threatening to tear apart a secular constitution and impose a Christian theocracy with himself at the helm, banning porn, banning abortion, banning books, endeavoring to substitute income tax with tariffs and send the global economy into free fall, releasing a sham bible, idolizing Hannibal Lecter, being referred to as American Hitler by your own running mate, and even publicly admitting that he isn’t a Christian nor does he care about his voters…wasn’t enough to deter their support, then it seems that nothing ever could. Further confirmation that Trump is effectively a cult leader, and perhaps the most dangerous since Muhammed.
A friend recently commented that he was absolutely convinced Trump could rape his newborn cousin on camera and his MAGA moron uncle would almost certainly still vote for him. But this goes well beyond Trumps misdeeds – it’s a fight to uphold the constitution, the pillars of democracy, and the secular freedoms and liberties which the founding fathers fought to establish. It is a fight to protect America from itself.
(In a grim twist of irony, it’s often forgotten that besides being a vestige of antebellum America wherein slaves were unable to vote, the electoral college system was at least partly installed as an additional condition for victory, in an attempt to prevent populist demagogues from so easily securing presidency – now it simply exacerbates gerrymandering and disenfranchises great swathes of the population, and evidently does not prevent demagogues from attaining office. Though in this case, it seems Trump also won the popular vote. )
It didn’t seem too long ago that a convicted criminal sexual predator and state traitor colluding with America’s greatest enemy would see one fall out of favour with Republicans. It seems any remaining brain cells or moral fibres have been shed by the average red voter such that they can not only overlook these damning indictments but revere the perpetrator. While sheer ignorance will always account for a sizable portion of republican voters, it’s harrowing to think how utterly morally bankrupt and corrupted one must be to knowingly endorse a shameless, heartless aspiring despot whom doesn’t even attempt to wash the blood from his wretched hands.
Those who voted for him deserve what they get – the snaggletoothed hillbilly sporting shirts depicting Biden in crosshairs deserves to die broke and unable to afford basic medical care - the rest of the country deserves a respectable human being and a competent leader.
Admittedly, my morbid curiosity is interested in seeing how this plays out… and now it’s time for the mango Mussolini to put his money where his mouth is and deliver on his outrageous promises. Of course his supporters aren’t the ones who will be holding him accountable, but let them not forget that they voted for a man who promised to fix the economy, solve the immigration problem, and end all world wars among other outlandish vows.
I was initially glad he had survived the assassination attempt, only so we had the satisfaction of seeing him lose to a black woman, but I suppose fate is a cruel mistress.
More than anything it’s dispiriting to see a fugitive from justice serving no time for his crimes. What message does this send? Drop those pesky morals and lie, cheat, steal, scam, rape, hate and conspire ‘til your withered heart’s content - you might even become president of the free world, twice. And what an indictment on the electoral system that a candidate who’s felonies (and age) would disqualify him from finding employment in a fast food restaurant, is still able to run for presidency. Carroll and Kafka combined couldn’t come up with something quite so absurd and grotesque.
His 2016 win was regrettable but understandable. He was a dark horse and promised the earth to a sea of disaffected citizens…but the results are in. The dark horse lost the race. He promised the earth and didn’t even deliver an atlas; he didn’t re-domesticate manufacturing, he didn’t boost the economy, he didn’t improve international relations with China and Russia, he didn’t denuclearize North Korea (indeed he ‘fell in love’ with Kim Jong upon his 2019 visit to the prison state), he didn’t make any meaningful progress on the wall, nor did he convince Mexico to pay for it. He didn’t even repeal Obamacare, one of his main electoral talking points. He didn’t really do anything besides sully international relations, weaken the economy, withdraw from the Paris agreement and do away with various environmental policies, condemn hundreds of thousands to death for his inept response to the Covid pandemic, and of course, engage in juvenile twitter arguments with detractors.
I fear he won't be so complacent in his second term; considering he is back with an even bigger ego, with far less red tape in his way, and a desire to go out with a bang, we have a recipe for a perfect shitstorm ready to unleash hell on any who aren't already victims of the MAGA mind virus (and them as well, though they're too brain decayed to realize it).
One must appreciate the irony of a population who are obsessionally antagonistic toward the phantom menace of drag queens endorsing a man who wears makeup, wigs, girdles and platform shoes.
The brutal truth is that whilst Kamala was worlds more competent than Trump – as is likely a hobo plucked at random from Skid Row – she was not a strong runner in this particular race; while she put in a commendable effort in debate and interviews in the lead up, being a woman of colour with a less than impressive track record who switched places with an enfeebled Biden just months prior to the election didn’t do much to sway any fence-sitters, nor did it exude the same charismatic air of self-possessed uplift and revolution that carried Obama to victory in 2008. More than ever the Democrats needed a younger, stately, male non-polarizing yet uncompromising candidate with skeletons that could be dug up to discredit them. Of course a candidates sex and race shouldn’t be salient factors when apposed to their background and policies, but the reality is that for much of the population, they are deciding factors, especially in swing states.
We can only hope that one of his many faults is a saving grace; that the man is all talk – that he won’t attempt to silence the media that he deems to be fake news, that he won’t lock up those who have criticized him over the past four years, that he doesn’t implement project 2025 and mutilate the US into a Christian theocracy – which I had thought would surely turn away any fence-sitting republicans – that he doesn’t allow his Russky buddy to steamroll the Ukraine, that he doesn’t indiscriminately round up and deport minorities, that he doesn’t eliminate taxes and impose severe tariffs in a way that would cripple the economy, that he doesn’t alter the constitution such that he may serve for as long as it takes mother nature to rid us of him (which shouldn’t be particularly long) or to prevent democrats from ever being elected again, that he doesn’t allow his galere of even madder men to call the shots, that he doesn’t impede AI development such that the US is overtaken by adversarial nations, that he doesn’t vitiate the education system any further.
Public political commentators, podcaster and so-called intellectuals including RFK “tinfoil hat and straitjacket’ Jr, Jordan ‘tower of babble’ Peterson, Ben ‘facts over feelings except in matters of religion and politics’ Shapiro, Russel ‘rather baroque rape allegations’ Brand, and Joe “don’t listen to me, I’m just a dumb meathead” Rogan, who once prided themselves on being critical thinking and nonpartisan have by and large crept to the right, spreading self-serving conspiracies and regurgitating points that validate conservative audiences - and being paid Pro Russian propaganda puppets in the case of Dave ‘gays for god’ Rubin and co. – with rich filth the likes of Elon ‘Tony stark wannabe turned emperor Palpatine’ Musk and fellow Paypal mafia associate Peter ‘freedom and democracy are incompatible’ Thiel directly promoting said propaganda among other scumbaggery. If the world was in a moral limbo contest – as it seems to be among such circles - these money grubbing scum would surely go lower than almost anyone else. Unfortunately, there's a far stronger financial incentive to pander to the right, as they are much more likely to throw money toward any who tell them what they want to hear, no integrity necessary - it's the easiest money.
Even if someone were to take a bullet in the most literal sense and managed to put down this sick dog and his couch fucking handler, it seems the termites have already spread and eaten through the foundations of Democracy - and it’s not obvious at this point it time that it can ever truly rebuild. Especially not when said termites comprise half of the population.
It is often said how empires rise and fall, and modern day empires – a republic in this case – are no exception (speaking of the fall of empires, the imagery of crazed hillbillies storming the capitol has undeniable parallels to the barbarian invasion of Rome, except that the Goths were effective refugees and were far more justified in doing so). Perhaps I was the fool for believing that we had collectively reached a point of sufficient moral and intellectual development and legal checks and balances such that the sun would never set on western democracy, at least not within my lifetime.
But here we are – the inmates are running the asylum, the animals have broken free of their cages, and this time they’ve got the Senate, the House of Reps, SCOTUS, and less to lose.
To be continued
r/ChristopherHitchens • u/No-Measurement8081 • Dec 28 '23
‘Screams Without Words’: How Hamas Weaponized Sexual Violence on Oct. 7
r/ChristopherHitchens • u/Stupid_smart_owl • Dec 13 '23
Missing Hitchens so damn much
I'm so so so done with the free Palestine crap all over the internet and wish Hitchens was here to give us a piece of his mind ffffffff
r/ChristopherHitchens • u/BaggyBoy • Nov 21 '23
What are your thoughts on Jordan Peterson?
I've noticed a considerable amount of criticism directed at Peterson, often accompanied by labels like 'alt-right,' 'misogynist,' or even 'incel' guru, but never really explained why.
While I don't align with Peterson on all issues, such as religion and climate change, I do appreciate the thorough political insight he brings from a psychological perspective.
His book is often criticised as being academically basic, but it doesn't claim to be anything more than self-help guide for a general audience, not a scholarly treatise.
Peterson's audience is so large is undeniable his audience will include some individuals with dodgy viewpoints, such as those who are actual misogynists. But does this make him guilty by association?
I find critiques often lack a nuanced examination of Peterson's ideas, reducing him to labels that may not fully capture the complexity of his ideas.
What are your thoughts on this? Is the critique deserved or or is it a matter of misinterpretation and oversimplification of his ideas?
r/ChristopherHitchens • u/flawless_victory99 • Jun 17 '25
Hitchens: U.S. Obligated to Defeat the Iranian Regime
JG: This is going to be hard for you, but if you were Benjamin Netanyahu, but still possessing Christopher Hitchens's knowledge of the Holocaust and of Jewish history, and of the protean, eternal nature of anti-Semitism, what would you do? Just assume the shoes of a leader of a country of six million Jews, whether you agree with the founding of that country or not.
CH: It's just as likely that I'd be president of the United States. In fact, slightly more so. Why not that, because that's really where the question has to be asked.
JG: Well, why don't you answer both.
CH: The United States is the host country of the United Nations, the promulgator of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and the Geneva Convention. The U.S. is not just a signatory but they're people who cause other people to sign all these things. The Iranian regime has several times publicly not just sworn but signed its name to documents in front of the International Atomic Energy Agency, the United Nations, and the European Union, that it has no ambitions to weaponize its nuclear capacity. If, after that, it is found that they have such impulses, then there is no such thing as international law anymore that would meant that we watched while that was contemptuously dismantled, trampled. In that case I see no reason not to take out the regime.
r/ChristopherHitchens • u/Kooky_Masterpiece_43 • Jun 03 '26
sam harris: “we dropped two atomic bombs on japan to end world war ii… amnesty international does not call that a genocide. but do you know what they call the war in gaza? a genocide. that’s the moral confusion… people don’t know what actual genocides are if they think [there’s a genocide in gaza].”
r/ChristopherHitchens • u/okcthunder78 • Mar 20 '24
In light of Galloway's disgraceful election, the man who stood side by side with Assad, who has found reinvigoration in his search for a tyrannical fatherland, let us recall when Hitchens shredded him to pieces. (Also for the idiots who think Hitch would favor Hamas terrorists over Netanyahu)
r/ChristopherHitchens • u/llehsadam • May 13 '24
Douglas Murray: What It Means to Choose Life
r/ChristopherHitchens • u/MyGenerousSoul • Dec 26 '23
Decade-long fan of Peter Hitchens here choosing to cancel him after this disgusting display. Did Christopher Hitchens ever bully youth like this?
r/ChristopherHitchens • u/OneNoteToRead • Oct 11 '23
Dawkins on Woke Religion
His response to Peterson’s cheap shot.
My personal reactions:
There’s a, to me, more compelling reason why Woke is a religion. It deals in nebulous, quasi-unfalsifiable ideas of “systems” or “systemic”, which conveniently expands to remain a tautology. And it’s used by other humans to tell us what to do.
It’s so surprising to me that people who have read Hitchens on religion can fail to grasp this essential question. Especially when almost every one of his new atheist comrades independently came to the same conclusion. Dawkins names an extensive list at the end - and it’s not even fully inclusive.
r/ChristopherHitchens • u/Kooky_Masterpiece_43 • Apr 23 '26
The Bigotry of Sam Harris Continues to Hit New Lows
r/ChristopherHitchens • u/AnimateDuckling • Sep 07 '26
Christians Get Scrutinized. Islam Doesn't. Why?
“For some reason, the left in America and in the West understands the problem when it comes in Christian form, right? They know that every Democrat understands that the religious beliefs of Christians, of fundamentalist Christians, matter and have political consequences. They form their political priorities and inform what they will do in the world.
So Christian opposition to abortion or same-sex marriage or teaching evolution in schools—every Democrat, every person left of center in our politics, understands that those are religious convictions that are affecting the lives of everyone, not just Christians, right?
And yet, for some reason, Islam never affects anything, right? These heartfelt religious beliefs of 2 billion Muslims never make contact with structural reality. It doesn't matter if embassies burn over cartoon controversies. It doesn't matter if Jews are getting stabbed on the streets of London as recently as last week. Religion is never to blame for any of this, right?
People like Mamdani and Mehdi Hasan and Reza Aslan, and then all the useful idiots who don't happen to be Muslim—you know, Glenn Greenwald and Chris Hedges and Rory Stewart, and all these people who I've collided with over the years—I mean, there's just a massive double standard preventing an honest discussion of psychological, social, and political reality.
And if you're going to recognize it in our own religious maniacs, right? If I have a devout Christian on who happens to be Pete Hegseth's pastor, who is open-minded about chattel slavery because it's in the Bible, and you see the problem with all of that, you have to see the problem with people who chant ‘Globalize the Intifada,’ knowing what the Intifada was.”
What is the reception of this take of Sam Harris's here?
r/ChristopherHitchens • u/[deleted] • Dec 23 '24
Liberalism Not Socialism
r/ChristopherHitchens • u/CommonWild • Mar 08 '23
Well, you're not that great yourself, Mr. Hitchens: A review and fact-checking of god is not Great: How Religion Poisons Everything.
self.badhistoryr/ChristopherHitchens • u/OneNoteToRead • Feb 27 '25
Douglas Murray Uncancelled History Series
I’ve been listening to this series hosted by Douglas Murray, with a focus on revisiting historical ideas and figures from a first principles approach. He usually invites a historian or author to dissect the topic. The main thesis is a rebuttal of progressive/woke cancel culture, addressing the common targets head on - ie addressing Thomas Jefferson’s slave ownership or Churchill’s racism. But it’s a good listen for everyone from left to center to right.
https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PLqoIWbW5TWd-hL5VKufKFfUEL8a0JNTmp
He is an excellent interviewer - keeping the guest on topic and probing to cover the important directions.
r/ChristopherHitchens • u/StevenColemanFit • Feb 05 '24
Who is the closest thing to hitchens in the modern public intellectual space. Sam Harris? Douglas Murray? Alex o Connor?
For me, combined they all bring their unique element that ads up to a potential hitch
r/ChristopherHitchens • u/melbtest05 • Oct 14 '24
How might either or both of the Hitchens bros respond to this proposition: “through incantation, you believe that the water and wine changes into the flesh and blood of Jesus Christ. Then why when I as a biological man utter ‘I am a Woman’, you don’t believe it?”
r/ChristopherHitchens • u/odiousyak1889 • Sep 01 '25
Hitchens and Ai
I am sure I will get a lot of hate for this , but it's something that made me smile. Hopefully you'll enjoy it as well.
I recently had a run in with, what I claim to be, an unjust city council.
I wrote a letter and then asked chatGPT to help me write it in the style of Christopher Hitchens. It wasn't perfect; Hitch would have eviscerated the council in a much more poetic way, but it did a good job. I found myself laughing and having a good time rewriting a scathing letter with his words. It was nice to read something some new "from" Hitch. It's the closest I've found.
r/ChristopherHitchens • u/Bright-Chocolate9112 • Apr 18 '25
So can we all agree now that Douglas is a fraud intellectual?
can we?!?!
r/ChristopherHitchens • u/Melbtest04 • Jan 27 '25