r/CatholicUniversalism • • Mar 18 '25

Catholic Universalist Quotes, Cardinal Manuel

Post image
82 Upvotes

r/CatholicUniversalism • • Sep 24 '25

Leo seems to be crossing the line from ‘implicit universalist’ to ‘overt confident universalist’…

Post image
65 Upvotes

r/CatholicUniversalism • • Mar 18 '25

Catholic Universalist Quotes, Pope Francis

Post image
57 Upvotes

r/CatholicUniversalism • • Jul 16 '25

'You Are Gods': The Ancient Theology Making a Comeback | "Now people are realizing it is a basic Christian doctrine"

Thumbnail
ncregister.com
55 Upvotes

"Over the past three decades or so, the Catholic Church has undergone a profound recovery of the theology of deification, also known as divinization. The ancient approach to the Christian life emphasizes that salvation isn’t merely about being freed from sin, but is more fundamentally about being united to God and sharing in his divine life...Although never lost, the theology of deification had long been overshadowed by more juridical approaches to salvation which emphasized concepts like expiation of guilt and deliverance from punishment...juridical accounts became especially dominant in the West during the Reformation, as Protestant emphases on justification prompted the Church to use similar legalistic frameworks in defense of its doctrines. But theosis began making its way back into the Catholic mainstream..."


r/CatholicUniversalism • • Aug 15 '25

Pope Leo: ‘Even if we fail Him, He will never fail us. If we betray Him, He will never betray us.’

Thumbnail
youtu.be
53 Upvotes

r/CatholicUniversalism • • Dec 14 '25

"There is no coming wrath. If the wrath didn't happen after the crucifixion, it isn't coming. There is just that same gaze of love for all eternity." | From my priest's incredible homily this morning.

42 Upvotes

"We are very often like John, offended by God's mercy, and longing for a coming wrath...but we get Jesus instead. Not wrath, just relentless love. The love of God revealed in Jesus never never stops pursuing us...no matter who we are or what our lives are about, He never stops showing up...like a GPS, no matter how many wrong turns we take, it just keeps re-calculating, re-calculating...God's love shows up, even nailed to a cross, victim to all those things John wanted God to stamp out...God's love remains present. John (the Baptist) wanted the Messiah to bring wrath and retribution. To set things right and right now...I submit to you that God doesn't need to be in the punishment business. The consequences of our sin are punishing enough for ourselves and others. God only does what it is in His nature to do: love...There is no coming wrath. If the wrath didn't happen after the crucifixion, it isn't coming. There is just that same gaze of love for all eternity. And each one of us must decide how our lives conform to that gaze. But it is more withering than any punishment God could mete out. That is precisely why we sometimes turn away. It's the most damnable thing about God, and the most glorious. His love is relentless, but never forced...To receive it, we must change our thinking, even John the Baptist had to...Blessed are those who take no offense in the love of God revealed in Christ Jesus our Lord."

Happy Gaudete Sunday!


r/CatholicUniversalism • • Oct 11 '24

The Catholic Church teaches hopeful universalism

38 Upvotes

People often ask whether Catholics are allowed to hope that all will be saved. The answer is clearly yes. But I think it's more than just allowed: hopeful universalism is actively taught and encouraged. It's almost required!

The Catechism of the Catholic Church, paragraph 1058:

The Church prays that no one should be lost: “Lord, let me never be parted from you.” If it is true that no one can save himself, it is also true that God “desires all men to be saved” (1 Tim 2:4), and that for him “all things are possible” (Mt 19:26).

“The Church prays” – or to put it another way, “Everyone who is part of the Church does or should pray” – “that no one should be lost”.

Likewise, paragraph 1821, part of the Catechism's definition of the theological virtue of Hope:

In every circumstance, each one of us should hope, with the grace of God, to persevere “to the end” and to obtain the joy of heaven, as God's eternal reward for the good works accomplished with the grace of Christ. In hope, the Church prays for “all men to be saved.”

Hopeful Universalism is inherent to the virtue of Hope, one of the theological virtues which “are the foundation of Christian moral activity” and “are the pledge of the presence and action of the Holy Spirit”. (And what does Scripture say about hope? “Hope does not disappoint” …!!)

The Catholic Church goes far beyond just “leaving room” for hopeful universalism. It actively teaches it!


r/CatholicUniversalism • • Nov 02 '25

Papa Leão XIV é um universalista esperançoso, amém.

Post image
37 Upvotes

r/CatholicUniversalism • • Dec 26 '24

From Brad Jersak (enlarge)

Post image
35 Upvotes

r/CatholicUniversalism • • Aug 30 '26

"God would rather be our victim than be our enemy."

29 Upvotes

From my priest's homily at Mass this morning, on the readings wherein Jesus predicts His own death. He notes that self-sacrificial love was always the plan of why Jesus came, and this is why Jesus was so matter-of-fact about predicting His death. The forces of the satanas, as Jesus refers to, are those that prompt us toward selfishness and vain self-preservation. But Jesus came to do that opposite. Jesus said in effect, of course He would die to demonstrate His love for us; because, "God would rather be our victim than our enemy."


r/CatholicUniversalism • • Oct 03 '25

St. Gregory of Nyssa obliterated infernalism through reasoning alone

29 Upvotes

On the making of Man:

"Wickedness, however, is not so strong as to prevail over the power of good; nor is the folly of our nature more powerful and more abiding than the wisdom of God: for it is impossible that that which is always mutable and variable should be more firm and more abiding than that which always remains the same and is firmly fixed in goodness: but it is absolutely certain that the Divine counsel possesses immutability, while the changeableness of our nature does not remain settled even in evil. Now that which is always in motion, if its progress be to good, will never cease moving onwards to what lies before it, by reason of the infinity of the course to be traversed:— for it will not find any limit of its object such that when it has apprehended it, it will at last cease its motion: but if its bias be in the opposite direction, when it has finished the course of wickedness and reached the extreme limit of evil, then that which is ever moving, finding no halting point for its impulse natural to itself when it has run through the lengths that can be run in wickedness, of necessity turns its motion towards good: for as evil does not extend to infinity, but is comprehended by necessary limits, it would appear that good once more follows in succession upon the limit of evil; and thus, as we have said, the ever-moving character of our nature comes to run its course at the last once more back towards good, being taught the lesson of prudence by the memory of its former misfortunes, to the end that it may never again be in like case."

- Wickedness cannot prevail against the Good

- Evil does not extend to infinity but is limited

- The will by necessity turns toward the Good after reaching the limit of evil

- The will cannot remain settled in evil.

Crystal clear.


r/CatholicUniversalism • • Jan 02 '26

Bishop Barron: How can the Fátima visions of Hell be reconciled with universal salvation?

28 Upvotes

Since this question is raised occasionally on this subreddit, I thought I would share Bishop Robert Barron's answer from his "Dare We Hope?" FAQ:

Q: Didn’t Our Lady of Fatima show a vision of many people suffering in hell?

A: Yes, as a warning of the torments of hell—not as a window into an unavoidable future. We know this because in the same Fatima appearance, she also gave us the Fatima prayer, commanding us to recite it often, begging Jesus to “forgive us our sins, save us from the fires of hell, and lead all souls to heaven, especially those most in need of thy mercy” (emphasis added). Our Lady would never ask us to pray for something that’s impossible, so there must be at least a basic hope for the possibility that all souls can be led to heaven.

Although I think the good bishop errs in judgment of confident universalism, nonetheless, Catholic universalists are lucky to have Bishop Barron as the most visible modern spokesperson for the hopeful position.


r/CatholicUniversalism • • Dec 19 '25

Pope Leo: Let all be saved!

Thumbnail
youtu.be
28 Upvotes

The Good News that so many need to hear.


r/CatholicUniversalism • • Jun 03 '26

Just rediscovered this meme from a few years ago...

Post image
27 Upvotes

r/CatholicUniversalism • • Jul 19 '26

Infernalists: "God is bound by His justice! Hell is locked from the inside!" Book of Wisdom: "Your mastery over all things makes you lenient to all...those who are just must be kind"

26 Upvotes

"For your might is the source of justice;
your mastery over all things makes you lenient to all.
For you show your might when the perfection of your power is disbelieved;
and in those who know you, you rebuke temerity.
But though you are master of might, you judge with clemency,
and with much lenience you govern us;
for power, whenever you will, attends you.
And you taught your people, by these deeds,
that those who are just must be kind;
and you gave your children good ground for hope
that you would permit repentance for their sins."

- Wisdom 12:13;16-19


r/CatholicUniversalism • • Aug 26 '25

Catholic Universalism Meme #1

Post image
26 Upvotes

r/CatholicUniversalism • • Sep 27 '26

Universal Salvation was proclaimed at every Catholic parish in the world this morning

25 Upvotes

This Sunday's epistle reading was Philippians 2:1-11. That means every Catholic parish across planet earth echoed St. Paul's declaration that:

"at the name of Jesus
every knee should bend,
of those in heaven and on earth and under the earth,
and every tongue confess that
Jesus Christ is Lord,
to the glory of God the Father."


r/CatholicUniversalism • • 16d ago

Heaven Is Full of the People You Reject

Thumbnail
newwaysministry.org
24 Upvotes

"If Heaven, by contrast, is defined by full communion, then it invites us into relationships with people we might rather avoid: people who challenge us, who don’t fit our neat categories, who may have even hurt us. Full communion prods us into dropping our defensive armor and surrendering the anesthetic of our exclusions.

Taking my cue from Pope Francis then, my hope is that we might use this feast day to stop taking solace in a crowded Hell. Perhaps if we spent less time mapping the terrains of damnation, and more time contemplating what full communion looks like, we wouldn’t spend so much time building little hells for each other on earth."


r/CatholicUniversalism • • May 13 '24

The Pope in a recent Italian TV interview

Post image
24 Upvotes

r/CatholicUniversalism • • Oct 14 '26

Basically true premises, wrong conclusion, same Straw Man: About that Catholic Answers post

23 Upvotes

So Catholic Answers has been posting some attempted defenses of ECT recently. This morning they posted:

"Hell must exist, because God will not force us to be in heaven with him.

Indeed, if God forced heaven onto those who do not want it, then heaven would feel like hell to those people."

No universalist claims that God "forces people into Heaven". That's a tired old caricature of universalism. (If anything, it's almost more akin to the Irresistible Grace doctrine of Calvinism which can still be very infernalist, that our eternal fate is unchangeable by us. But even Calvinists might say the elect are predestined to "want" Heaven, so to speak, but I digress).

In the second line, CA seems to accidentally articulate the "Hell is Heaven experienced differently" model of universalism, more common in Eastern Christianity. The idea being just that, God doesn't create a separate place of torment that He actively banishes people to, all there is is His love and people may theoretically experience it as Hell if they "hate God" (Who actually in the right mind hates God is a whole other question...).

Infernalists may accidentally like this model because it puts God in a more passive role and seems to pretzel-twist the alternative, damnation, into something that's actually compassionate and merciful, but...

These reasonable-sounding premises are used in conjuction with the snuck-premise that there are human souls that actually hate God in perpetuity, not just because of some wound they have experienced or some way that God has been misrepresented to them. Which is an assumption that I simply don't see enough evidence for. "Our hearts are restless until they rest in Thee, O God", as Augustine said. This assumption that there are people who would actually reject God underestimates the power of God's grace to convert, to "burn away the dross and re-form us to be vessels of eternal joy", as Pope Benedict XVI wrote.

On that note, St. Edith Stein's words also quite pertinent here:

"Now, can we assume that there are souls that remain perpetually closed to such love? As a possibility in principle, this cannot be rejected. In reality, it can become infinitely improbable—precisely through what preparatory grace is capable of effecting in the soul...Human freedom can be neither broken nor neutralized by divine freedom, but it may well be, so to speak, outwitted."

(And St. Edith is making that powerful argument while still maintaining a strong view of free will! One could also make the case that human free will actually has its limits and need not overpower God's will to save, but I digress). Still, St. Edith show us that even a strong view of free will need not require ECT.

Edit:

One last point I'll make about this is, if the CA post's eschatological model is true, where every soul ostensibly gets exactly what it wants, why are so many infernalist Catholics so afraid of hell? If we should just sit back and relax and not worry about the fate of the damned because, you see, they actually would be miserable in Heaven...then what's even so scary about mortal sin and hell after all? Yet so many Catholics have such crippling anxiety and scrupulosity about going to hell. How can both be true? How can one simultaneously preach that Hell is only for those who want to be there, yet at the same time be terrified of it?Their own lived experience and struggles with sin should show them that people are more complicated than the simple categories of either "love God" or "hate God". As Pope Benedict XVI said, "for the vast majority of people, we may suppose their remains in the depths of their being an ultimate interior oppenness to truth, to love to God... In the concrete choices of life, however, it is covered over by ever new compromises with evil—much filth covers purity, but the thirst for purity remains and it still constantly re-emerges from all that is base and remains present in the soul."

Anyway, that post is just another example of how infernalism often requires its defenders to talk out of both sides of their mouth and make contradictory arguments to try hold infernalism together against so many ethical and philosophical problems.


r/CatholicUniversalism • • Dec 29 '25

A universalist in the Confession line.

23 Upvotes

So this morning I went to Confession. For logistical reasons I had to drive across town to a parish not my regular one which was literally the only one in the metro area which had a confession time on a Monday morning. Allegedly, as the infernalists argue, the only reason I would inconvenience myself in this way is if I were afraid of hellfire.

But there I was, a convinced universalist, who had driven across town on a Monday morning to drink from the fount of mercy.

And not to be judgemental, but what about the countless "lukewarm" Catholics who don't go to Confession, maybe not even Mass? Is it because they've all read the works of Fr. Hans Urs von Balthasar, Cdl. Ratzinger, Fr. Karl Rahner, and St. Edith Stein, and are convinced universalists as a result? Probably not.

All of this to say, I don't see how having "reasonable hope" in the salvation of all makes one less inclined to cooperate with one's own salvation. We all are responsible to the degree that we understand that God desires to save us through the sacraments. As the saying in catechetics goes, "We are bound by the sacraments, but God is not". Or put another way, "God is not bound by His sacraments, but we are."

I think that whatever one thins about the number of the saved; those who understand the sacraments and believe that God desires to save us through them will not absent themselves from them.

I hope this post doesn't come off as prideful, I don't intend it as such; my point is simply, as I once explained to a infernalist, we can believe that hell will be empty; and live in a way to help make that true! Our reasonable hope in the salvation of all should make us even more open to God's sanctifying grace in us, not less.


r/CatholicUniversalism • • Sep 01 '25

This subreddit upholds the Catholic Profession of Faith 😊

Thumbnail vatican.va
22 Upvotes

r/CatholicUniversalism • • May 13 '24

A Guide to Catholic Universalism

Thumbnail
self.christianuniversalism
22 Upvotes

r/CatholicUniversalism • • Aug 24 '25

What did your priest say about today's Gospel reading?

21 Upvotes

As this Sunday's reading was on "the narrow way", and Jesus being asked how many will be saved, I figure it'd be a good discussion on how this reading was framed during the homily you heard today.

My priest pointed out that Jesus actually side-stepped the question of how many will be saved and instead urged the questioner to focus on his own salvation (v. 24).

Regarding those to whom Christ would say "I never knew you", my priest highlighted the aspect of being "known" by Jesus, said that the text doesn't say that "they won't be let in because they were bad or did bad things", it's that "they made no effort to be in relationship with Christ". Thus, he said that even if you aren't sure if you believe in Christ or even want to believe in Christ, "tell Him that". He said the story is not about a bouncer keeping out the riff-raff, it's about the importance of staying in relationship with Jesus no matter where you are spiritually, keep the lines of communication open with Him.

I think that's an excellent take on the passage, I think my priest handled it much like Jesus Himself handled the question. So I really appreciated this homily.

What was the homily you heard this morning?

PS.

For those interested, Bishop Barron has written on how this Gospel passage can be interpreted in light of the reasonable hope that all would be saved on the Word on Fire's Dare We Hope FAQ page

"First, this passage cannot be taken in isolation from other passages that suggest a more “hopeful” outcome. Moreover, this passage (or others like it) cannot be isolated without proper consideration of what Jesus accomplished on his cross. This passage reveals an important truth: most people—indeed, most Christians—are not saints.

If not for God’s grace, in fact, none would be saved. But even though the majority of us are stuck most of the time trudging along the “broad way,” there is still ultimately hope for us in the end, like the thief on the cross. 

Note that Jesus describes many people entering through the gate that leads to destruction. He doesn’t say all those people—or any of those people—necessarily arrive at that destination. Perhaps they repent and turn around at some point after entering. Perhaps they encounter Christ along the way, and their sinful orientation shifts. In fact, Christ himself on the cross, as St. Paul says, has “become sin,” which means he has gone to the very end of that road to meet those who have wandered far from God."


r/CatholicUniversalism • • May 29 '25

The idea that "we all deserve eternal hell" is making me fear for my life

21 Upvotes

Seriously, I keep hearing this not just from Protestants but from Catholics and I'm afraid I might be endangering myself because I don't want to live. Living with this thought every walking minute is too much. I know I probably have depression but I can't explain my nonreligious family that what makes me want to stop living is belief that they might go to hell forever and that it is just for God to do that. I really don't know what to do. I have OCD, I'm afraid of I stop believing in eternal hell God will send me there. I feel like I'm trapped and have no way out of this pain. I want to be happy again.