r/CatholicUniversalism • • Dec 31 '24

Universalism has poor charisma - HERE IS WHY

1 Upvotes

I am writing this post out of strong frustration. I am a Catholic. I submit to the Petrine Pontiff, the Bishop who sits on the head of Babylon, established by Christ our God and Savior. And anyone who does not accept the Supreme Roman Pontiff, scatters, and are heretics ipso facto, and not valid Christians, but at best "half-Christians" so to speak.

I have very little patience for bad methodology of hypotheses, heresy, and also ignorance of the magisterium which is infallible and ordained by God, inspired by the Holy Spirit. I am a very ardent Universalist and Catholic, and never will be a theologically progressive Catholic. I literally believe if you are not a Catholic, you are not a Christian. I am very serious of this strife which I admit, but I believe it truly.

The doctrine of Universalism, I believe is a necessary auxiliary hypothesis in order for Theism to remain a functioning theory. I have not found any convincing philosophical arguments against Universalism, and on top of this, I do not believe scripture condemns it, and I am very skeptical if the magisterium has condemned universalism implicitly or explicitly, after 270+ hours of studying the Magisterial documents. And I am not even finished. This is a project I am working on so hard, I am deeply considering writing a book on this subject matter.

Universalism has been labeled as heresy or theologically progressive, due to it being a doctrine plagued by heretics. Precisely, those who are theologically liberal Protestants, are the gravest threat to Universalism. A large reason as to why it is rejected, is because the people usually advocating this doctrine are those who not conservative, are supporters of murdering of babies in the womb, deny mysticism, deny the scriptures, see Bible scholars as their Magisterium on all subjects pertaining to scripture, and more abhorrently, hold to other heretical doctrines condemned by Holy Mother Church. Alongside this, I recognized a pattern amongst these "Christians" who in their audacity, believe homosexual practices, and transgender ideology are compatible with the sacred Magisterium and Scripture.

This infuriates me, as I am of the remnant of Catholics who are indeed extraordinarily conservative (in comparison to the vast majority of Catholics. Truly I believe I am "normal," and what we call
"radicalism" should indeed be normalized) and these who claim to be followers of Christ, are making the beautiful image of Universalism tainted and ugly.

This is not a dogma that is "liberal," this dogma was the majority opinion of the Ancient Church. A user here has even so kindly proved this, via the Papal local Synod of Rome held in 382, which issued the Tome of Damasus, agreed by the entire council, including 3 Eastern Bishop representatives alongside most religious Holy Father Damasus. Within its 24 anathemas, it anathematized anyone who rejected universalism. Indeed, it was the majority belief of the time, and indeed it was believed by the great majority that to remain a valid Catholic, you must accept Universalism. I am even currently theorizing that Universalism is not just compatible with the Magisterium, but the Magisterium in fact most likely ordained Universalism as infallible Dogma, via Vatican I's document, "Dei Filius" chapter 3 section 2, defining the Ordinary Magisterium as infallible.

The bottom line of this post I am making, is that I strongly encourage my Catholic brethren, to never fall to heresy, nor even negotiate yourselves with other "Christian" universalists. In order for one to be a true universalist, one must truly be a Christian, and to be truly be Christians, we Catholics on this subreddit, proclaim that there is no true church outside of the communion with the Pope.

I do not even consider other "Christians" or those who admit to be notorious heretics, as valid Universalists, but "wolves in sheep" whom we shall know by their fruits (Matthew 7:17).

To make Universalism as successfully recognized doctrine, all of those who are theologically liberal, I greatly desire silence on other theological or moral opinions, lest you would make this doctrine appear like poison, and destroying its reputation. And to my Catholics, I greatly desire for you to follow suit, and leave behind any doubts of the Magisterium, and leave behind any heretical opinions.

Summary: Theologically liberal "Christians" who argue for Universalism, are almost all the time bearing poisonous fruit of heresy or immoral ideas, such as promoting abortion and other liberal atrocities. This dogma must be held with the upmost respect and charisma, and not left into the hands of these ravenous wolves, who destroy it's image of true Beauty. Seeing these so called "Christians" believe in Universalism, yet outside of the Holy See, promoting their corrupt doctrines and atrocious ideas, tarnishes the true image of God, repulsing those who are interested in it, and who are in truth, yet reject it due to the suspicion it too is invalid, like the doctrines and ideas of it's most prominent preachers.


r/CatholicUniversalism • • May 19 '26

Nick Fuentes: "I tend to hope that Hell is empty… We hope that it is. We hope that God has a plan to save everybody."

14 Upvotes

r/CatholicUniversalism • • Sep 30 '26

I blasphemed the Holy Spirit, is there hope for me?

0 Upvotes

You can find my story in my first post. I did it in 2007. I didnt mean anything bad, it just happened. Out of pride, stupidity. I know I'm going to hell, I just dont think I should be tortured forever. As universalists, do you think there is hope for blasphemers of HS? I cant make peace with my destiny, I cant make myself beleive God will torture me forever.


r/CatholicUniversalism • • Jul 03 '25

Is there an official Church document that says mortal sins are possible?

14 Upvotes

Probably silly question. But I’ve been musing on the sheer impossibility of “full knowledge and complete consent,” with our limited human understanding and temptations and anxieties and biases, and I thought, Wait, are we even required to believe that mortal sin exists as can be committed by real humans in the real world, as opposed to a philosophical concept?

The Catechism says, “Mortal sin is a radical possibility of human freedom, as is love itself.” OK, sure—sin which kills relationship with God is a “possibility” inasmuch as it‘s conceivable by human brains. We can imagine some sort of figure who sees God, goodness itself, and still says, “Nah, not for me.” But that’s an imaginary figure, a mental construct, not a person.

There’s probably some document out there that says, “Yes, it is possible for a fallible, confused human to commit mortal sin.” But—is there?


r/CatholicUniversalism • • Dec 20 '25

Infernalist Versicle In Romans?

2 Upvotes

"Ever since the creation of the world his eternal power and divine nature, invisible though they are, have been understood and seen through the things he has made. So they are without excuse" Romans 1:20

what are your thoughts about this?


r/CatholicUniversalism • • Jul 10 '24

The Promises (On First Principles, Behr translation) by the Hiero-Confessor, Origen

Thumbnail patristicapokatastasis.wordpress.com
3 Upvotes

r/CatholicUniversalism • • Jan 25 '25

Why is the Beatific Vision insufficient for salvation by itself?

3 Upvotes

Correct me if I am wrong, but I believe Universalism states that at the Final Judgment, sinners and the elect alike will receive "the Beatific Vision" which leads to repentence among sinners, who will suffer by not partaking in the Aionian age.

My Question is why is this Beatific Vision insufficient for the repentance of sinners if the Crucifixion of Jesus Christ never occured?


r/CatholicUniversalism • • Oct 27 '25

I don't see much difference between living as a Christian (even universalist) or as a nihilist

5 Upvotes

Seriously, while the two may seem like polar opposites, my experience living as a materialist with nihilistic tendencies and as a Catholic, at least in what concerns this side of the cosmos, is similarly pathetic and depressing.

If human existence can only be explained in light of a belief which entails that all human beings are so wicked as to deserve eternal, unending, perpetual torment, and that they keep validating their infinite demerit every once in a while, there's hardly any following proposition capable of wearing off the dystopian nature of such premise.

Now, I'll argue that an infernalist theodicy solidifies beyond all doubt the truth of my comments, but they don't necessarily disappear with apokatastasis. I'll say with great security that such guilt trip is quite far from what I would expect as a pleasant experience of existence and one that certainly takes away my motivation to pursue sainthood or love. What has me going on is the fact that I still believe the Gospel to be true, or so does my conscience compell me to.

Anyway, it's hard to feel how so many people live extremely happy and fulfilled lives within the Christian worldview.


r/CatholicUniversalism • • Jul 25 '25

I feel bad for Ralph Martin

6 Upvotes

So apparently Dr. Ralph Martin has been fired by Bp. Weisenberger from his teaching role at the seminary in Detroit, with the bishop reportedly not giving any specifics as to why. (There's a whole thread in r/Catholicism about it). Dr. Martin had been in that role for decades, and the new bishop had just arrived in the diocese. It's speculated that it's due to some if his critiques of the late Pope Francis' style. I'm not super familiar with Dr. Martin, but I've seen him in a few videos and podcasts essentially promoting infernalism, and saying the Church doesn't talk about the possibility of damnation enough.

Even though I disagree with some of his views, I don't celebrate this at all. Maybe it's my universalist sympathies, but I don't believe in vindictive firings. I hope he finds a great new position and livelihood (and also maybe opens his mind to the salvation of all one day!)


r/CatholicUniversalism • • Dec 12 '24

How do you guys treat the sacraments while being universalists

7 Upvotes

So a few months ago I left the Catholic Church because of a constant bombardment of lustful thoughts which caused me to live in anxiety and stress since I was constantly fearing that I was commiting mortal sins since I often willingly engaged in those thoughts after hours or days of struggling. I just couldnt bear the burden anymore of repressing my sexuality and I thought leaving the Church would make my problem better. It did, in the short term, only for me to relapse on porn and masturbation eventually. I'm now realising that I was better off before I left. I want to rejoing but I think the only way I can be a Catholic is if I dont abandon my universalist view. I find it very difficult to love a God who would send someone to Hell for eternity for skipping mass or masturbating etc. Just the belief that God would send anyone to Hell for eternity for any sin seems demonstrably cruel and not the work of a loving God. So thank you for reading my rant now I will ask my question.

How do you guys do confessions? Since you believe in the restoration of all souls then is there really a point in going to confession for every mortal sin?

I have racked up alot of sins since I left which I will undoubtably go to confession for. However it seems kind of pointless beyond a theraputic sense since I now believe all will be saved regardless.


r/CatholicUniversalism • • Oct 16 '26

How do catholic universalists square their position with the following from the 1st Eucharistic prayer aka the Roman canon?

7 Upvotes

Therefore, Lord, we pray:

graciously accept this oblation of our service,

that of your whole family;

order our days in your peace,

and command that we be delivered from eternal damnation

and counted among the flock of those you have chosen.


r/CatholicUniversalism • • Nov 12 '24

Early Church Fathers' quotes

Thumbnail tentmaker.org
8 Upvotes

r/CatholicUniversalism • • Dec 10 '24

St Issac the Syrian

10 Upvotes

So St Issac who’s been an orthodox saint for a thousand years has just been canonised by the Pope last month.

Thing is. He is the most obvious and unquestionably universalist writer I can think of. He makes Origen look wishy washy.

But the West has condemned universalism definitely.

So how is this man a saint in the RCC now? Don’t get me wrong, he is one of my favourite saints. I’m orthodox I hope that’s okay.

But like could this be a step in the direction of universal reconciliation being affirmed by the west?

Or is Francis just ignoring his most important theological principles?

Any Catholics can yall help me out?

I mean Benedict even called Origen the greatest church father back when he was Supreme Pontiff.


r/CatholicUniversalism • • Jan 05 '26

Not All Universalisms Are Created Equal

10 Upvotes

This is a crosspost from my Substack.

Universalism is the idea that all people will ultimately be saved. But that’s not the end of the conversation. Because the natural next question is: How?

Ask any two universalists over at our ecumenical sister subreddit r/ChristianUniversalism, and you probably won’t get the same answer! Some options I’ve seen include

  1. There is no Hell.

  2. Hell exists but is temporary. Everyone in hell will “graduate” to salvation.

  3. No one actually meets the criteria for mortal sin (full knowledge and full consent), so Hell is real and eternal, but no one goes there.

  4. In sin, each person incarnates a false self. In the afterlife, when all is submerged in God’s eternal Love, this false body of sin experiences it as hellish torment, but God ultimately separates and heals the true self, bringing it to salvation.

  5. In the fullness of creation, all created things will lose their individuality and merge into God.

Now, in contrast to ChristianUniversalism, this subreddit upholds the Profession of Faith and Oath of Fidelity, which includes the Sacred Tradition set forth by the Church’s ordinary and universal Magisterium. Here are the Magisterial teachings which are relevant to universalism, as summarized by Dr. Justin Shaun Coyle:

That hell is eternal; that mortal sin is different from venial and its just desert is hell; and that subjective certainty of eschatological ends is banned [i.e., no individual should claim infallible knowledge that they are going to Heaven or Hell].

To this list I will add the 6th century condemnations of Origenism. These are heavily disputed in both status and relevance, but they have been received in the Church as if they are official and accurately describe Origen’s beliefs.

Using these teachings as our benchmarks, let’s evaluate the options listed above.

  • Positions #1 and #2 (“no Hell” and “temporary Hell”) are ruled out by the definition that Hell exists and is eternal. If you think all postmortem punishment will eventually come to an end, you should phrase it as all people going to Purgatory – not that Hell itself is finite or fictional!

  • Position #5 (“loss of individuality”) is approximately the apokatastasis idea described in the anti-Origenist condemnations, regardless of whether or not Origen himself actually taught it.

When some Catholics say that confident universalism goes against Church teaching, they usually have one of those above versions in mind. But our analysis doesn’t end there.

  • Position #3 (“no mortal sinners”) upholds the eternity of Hell and the Magisterial teaching that mortal sin sends the sinner there. There remains the requirement for subjective uncertainly about final outcomes, but how “absolutely and infallibly certain” can any of us can really be about anything? This is the interpretation defended in our “Guide”.

  • Position #4 (“false selves”) much more straightforwardly preserves the subjective uncertainty: even with faith that God will ultimately heal us, each of us must discern in each moment whether we’re incarnating our true, free self or the false self enslaved to sin. This is the stance articulated by Drs. Coyle and Jordan Daniel Wood.

Both of these are real possibilities for faithful Catholics, and there are surely many more.

You don’t have to pick one or another of these options to be a confident universalist. It’s enough that at least one is permissible to prove that Catholics can believe in confident universalism without any dissent from the Magisterium.

To close with some words from St. Edith Stein,

Faith in the unboundedness of divine love and grace also justifies hope for the universality of redemption, although, through the possibility of resistance to grace that remains open in principle, the possibility of eternal damnation also persists. […] As a possibility in principle, this cannot be rejected. In reality, it becomes infinitely improbable – precisely through what preparatory grace is capable of effecting in the soul.


r/CatholicUniversalism • • 22d ago

Would any of you like to join a Catholic Bible study group online?

11 Upvotes

I'd like to go through the bible chapter by chapter and study the historical, cultural, social and original meanings. I have tried to find groups in person for this but I have been left unsatisfied! I could start a discord? if you would all like or are interested in joining. please let me know. I'd like to meet online like do a group meeting once a week on video chat. if this doesn't interest you, that is ok. but I have found a massive urge in making community and I think it's a shame social media isn't really used to foster and create this, but has been more for entertainment and ??? fighting ???

please dm me! I'm 29F from Canada, though I lived in Italy (right by the vatican!!!) for a while - I speak English, Italian and a bit of Spanish/French.


r/CatholicUniversalism • • May 08 '25

Presenting Pope Leo XIV!

Post image
18 Upvotes

r/CatholicUniversalism • • Sep 25 '25

A Catholic can be, in good conscience, faithful to the magisterium, a confident universalist

20 Upvotes

It's a myth, but a common one that the Catholic Church ever condemned apokatastasis. But this is not true. The propagators of this myth appeal to the 5th ecumenical council where Origen is condemned by name, and allegedly 15 anathemas against him are cited. While it is true that Origen is condemned by name, he was not condemned for universal salvation.

A couple of things to consider: The 15 anathemas are absent from the acta synodalia, meaning that such condemnation did not happen. However, the 15 anathemas receive ecumenical authority via Nicaea II which attributes them to the 5th council. The council Fathers were familiar with the 15 anathemas cited, and thought that Origen held what the anathemas condemn. Thus Origen was anathematized by name. However, Origen actually did not belive what the anathemas condemn, so this would be an error of fact on the part of the synod, and this is in no way do away with the infallibility of ecumenical councils.

Origen is only condemned insofar as he is an Origenist. Giovanni Pico della Mirandola said during the Renaissance, that it is more rational to belive that Origen is in heaven. He initially got into trouble for this, but then he wrote an Apologia, where he defended the honour of Origen, namely by asserting that Origen was not an Origenist. (I agree with this assessment). Pope Alexander VI, in the breve catholicorum omninum, cleared Mirandola of all charges, declared him to be orthodox, and forbade inquisitors from troubling Mirandola. Pope Leo XIII in Providentissimus Deus, called Origen the greatest name in the eastern Church. Benedict XVI called Origen a maestro, and called him also a "master of faith". It is evident then, that Origen is thoroughly rehabilitated by the Church.

So anyways, what does the anathemas condemn ? Let's look at them. Anathema one concern us in our endeavour. It states: "If anyone advocates the mythical pre-existence of souls and the monstrous restoration that follows from this, let him be anathema"

The Origenist monks belived and taught that souls pre-existed in a bodiless state of pristine existence, from which they fell and became demons and men, and they taught that there will be a return to this pristine existence. Obviously, this is not apokatastasis, and no universalist today belive in what the canon condemns. What it rejects is Origenism, which is predicated upon the pre-existence of souls, which upholds spherical resurrection, and which belives that every single creature will be equal to, and identical to Christ.

Thus, as is evident, universal salvation is not condemned, nobody belives such absurd heresies.

The closest the Church ever came to condemning universalism was at Vatican 1. One of the drafts contain the following canon: "If anyone says that a person can be justified even after death, or denies that the punishments of the damned in hell will be eternal, let them be anathema. (Si quis dixerit, etiam post mortem hominem iustificari posse; aut poenas damnatorum in gehenna perpetuas futuras esse negaverit, anathema sit)"

This canon gives us a contemplation: The Church, in wanting to condemn universalism, show us that it considered the matter an open question up until that time. For, the Church only ever condemn something once, and afterwards only appeal to the same condemnation which it reinforces. Yet, Vatican 1 drawn up an anathema specifically condemning universal salvation which shows that it had hithertho been not condemned. This canon however, no doubt thanks to the Holy Spirit which protect the Church from error, has been dropped without any indication in the acta synodalia as to the question why it was dropped. It did not make the final document, it just vanished.

A local papal synod actually teaches universal salvation. I'm speaking of the council of Rome in 382, which compiled the canon of Scripture. In canon 21 it states: "If anyone does not say there are three true persons of Father, and of Son, and of Holy Spirit, equal, immortal, containing all visible and invisible, ruling all, judging all, vivifying all, creating all, SAVING ALL, he is a heretic"

The same all that God rules, judges, vivifies, creates, that is, all rational creatures, is the same all that He saves.

Lumen Gentium solemnly declared: "The Church, to which we are all called in Christ Jesus, and in which we acquire sanctity through the grace of God, will attain its full perfection only in the glory of heaven, when there will come the time of the restoration of all things.(237) At that time the human race as well as the entire world, which is intimately related to man and attains to its end through him, will be perfectly reestablished in Christ."

Gaudium et Spes declared: "ALL MEN possess a rational soul and are created in God's likeness, since they have the same nature and origin, have been redeemed by Christ and enjoy the SAME divine calling AND DESTINY"

All men have the same destiny. Therefore either all are saved or all are damned. If some are eternally damned while others are saved they have a different destiny. And obviously, you cannot thwart nor avoid destiny, it's inevitable.

St. John Paul II say in a homily in 1985: "This is the covenant which embraces all. This Blood reaches all and saves all."

Furthermore, he says in Redemptoris Missio: "The Redemption event BRINGS SALVATION TO ALL, ‘for EACH one is included in the mystery of the Redemption and with EACH ONE Christ has united himself FOREVER through this mystery"

This same pontiff declared elsewhere: "Time after time with renewed faith the Church repeats her desire for the final encounter with the One who comes to bring His plan of universal salvation to COMPLETION"

In Redemptor Hominis, St. John Paul II teaches: "We are dealing with each man, for each one is included in the mystery of the Redemption and with each one Christ has united Himself forever through this mystery. [..] Man [..] destined for grace and glory-this is "each" man"

EACH MAN IS DESTINED FOR GLORY CAN IT BE ANY MORE CLEAR THAN THAT????

And to the Abbess General of the Order of the Most Holy Saviour of St Bridget, this same pontiff said: "Christ, Redeemer of man, now for ever 'clad in a robe dipped in blood' (Apoc, 19,13), the everlasting, invincible guarantee of universal salvation"

From all these, it is evident that universal salvation is, the teaching of the Magisterium. The Magisterium cannot teach heresy, therefore universal salvation is not a heresy, but a solid doctrine.

Objection: The Magisterium asserted that hell is eternal and perpetual. This seems to be against universalism, therefore, etc.

Reply:The Magisterium uses the word aeternus and perpetuo to describe hell, but we can suppose that these are merely proposed translations of aionion rather than assertions of aidios. The reason is because as Vatican 1 says: "For the holy Spirit was promised to the successors of Peter not so that they might, by his revelation, make known some new doctrine, but that, by his assistance, they might religiously guard and faithfully expound the revelation or deposit of faith transmitted by the apostles." In other words, the Magisterium is limited to the deposit of faith, to revelation. So we cannot presuppose that the Magisterium wants to say more than what is contained in Scripture, but only that it teach what is in Scripture. So I would view these teachings as proposed translations of aionios, rather than assertion of aidios. Translating aionios as everlasting/eternal/perpetual is perfectly acceptable for poetic reasons, but the translation by itself does not rule out that the punishment will have an end. If such were the case, we would be obligated to convert to judaism due to Exodus 12:14. Furthermore, in Leviticus the law enacted against eating blood is called olam, the same word which is in Daniel talking about „eternal” punishment, and which word in the septuagint is rendered aionios. Yet, we know from the council of Florence that we can eat blood, so it cannot be a truly perpetual statute. But it is acceptable to use the word perpetual, as it denotes a long period of time, and indeed St. Jerome, himself a universalist, used the word perpetuo to translate the word olam in this very passage. So just because the magisterium used these words as translations of aionios, doesn’t rule out anything. And the Vatican knew this, for the first vatican ecumenical council drew up an anathema against those who admitted that repenting post mortem is possible, and that hell is not endless. If it was already settled, why do that? The Church only judges things once, and afterwards maintain its position. But of course, this canon from Vatican 1, located in the acta synodalia was dropped, and not promulgated. This was obviously the work of the Holy Spirit, who, far from permitting the truth to be anathematized, protected the Church, against which the gates of hell, the tongues of heretics shall never prevail.

I shall close this post with a quote from Sacred Scripture, and its interpretation by Doctor of the Church, St. Jerome: "I will endure the wrath of the Lord, for I have sinned against Him, until He justifies my cause and executes my judgment, and brings me out into the light; and I will see His righteousness" (Micah 7:9)

"All correction at the moment does not seem to be one of joy, but of sorrow, and afterward it yields the peaceful fruit of righteousness to those who have been trained by it. Therefore, when the soul feels that it has sinned, bears the wounds of sin, lives in the dead flesh, and needs cauterization, it resolutely says to the physician: Burn my flesh, cut away the wounds, bind all the humors and harmful rheum with the harsh potion of hellebore. It was my fault that I was wounded; let it be my suffering to endure all these torments so that afterward I may receive health. And the true physician, now showing the cause of the medicine to one who is healed and secure, teaches that he acted rightly in what he did. Finally, after suffering and punishment, the soul, led out of outer darkness and having paid the last penny, says: I will see His righteousness, and I will say: 'Your judgments are justified, O God.' But if Christ has been made for us wisdom from God, and righteousness, and sanctification, and redemption (1 Cor. 1), then whoever says he sees righteousness after the wrath of God is promising himself a vision of Christ. And this applies specifically to the penitent. However, it is much better not to have wounds and not to need a physician." (Jerome, Commentary on Micah)


r/CatholicUniversalism • • Dec 12 '24

The Catholic Church never condemned universal salvation

21 Upvotes

It's a myth, but a common one that the Catholic Church ever condemned apokatastasis. But this is not true. The propagators of this myth appeal to the 5th ecumenical council where Origen is condemned by name, and allegedly 15 anathemas against him are cited. While it is true that Origen is condemned by name, he was not condemned for universal salvation.

A couple of things to consider: The 15 anathemas are absent from the acta synodalia, meaning that such condemnation did not happen. However, the 15 anathemas receive ecumenical authority via Nicaea II which attributes them to the 5th council. The council Fathers were familiar with the 15 anathemas cited, and thought that Origen held what the anathemas condemn. Thus Origen was anathematized by name. However, Origen actually did not belive what the anathemas condemn, so this would be an error of fact on the part of the synod, and this is in no way do away with the infallibility of ecumenical councils.

So what does the anathemas condemn ? Let's look at them. Anathema one concern us in our endeavour. It states: "If anyone advocates the mythical pre-existence of souls and the monstrous restoration that follows from this, let him be anathema"

The Origenist monks belived and taught that souls pre-existed in a bodiless state of pristine existence, from which they fell and became demons and men, and they taught that there will be a return to this pristine existence. Obviously, this is not apokatastasis, and no universalist today belive in what the canon condemns.

Verdict: The 15 anathemas against Origen doesn't condemn universal salvation.

Our next stop is the 9 anathemas of Justinian. Of these, anathema 9 concern us. It states: "If anyone says or thinks that the punishment of demons and of impious men is only temporary, and will one day have an end, and that a restoration (ἀποκατάστασις) will take place of demons and of impious men, let him be anathema."

This condemn universal salvation, and it was signed by Pope Vigilius. However, despite this, it's not magisterial. Pope Vigilius signing it only show that he personally subscribed to the anathema, yet his signature does not render this canon magisterial. For example, Pope Francis has signed the heretical abu dhabi document which stated that the diversity of religions are willed by God. Nor can the apogolist make a distinction between God's permissive will and positive will, for it lists the diversity of religions among things such as colour, sex, race and language, ie: things positively willed by God. The notion that diversity of religion is permissive will only whereas the rest is positive will is the height of absurdity. Yet, there is no one alive who ever thought that this heretical document is magisterial, despite bearing the Pope's signature. He did not issue it in his own name, therefore it is not magisterial. In the same way, what Vigilius signed under questionable freedom, is not magisterial because he did not issue it in his own name, nor did he ever indicate that it binds the whole Church.

Verdict: Not magisterial, thus without all authority.

The closest the Church ever came to condemning universalism was at Vatican 1. One of the drafts contain the following canon: "Si quis dixerit, etiam post mortem hominem iustificari posse; aut poenas damnatorum in gehenna perpetuas futuras esse negaverit, anathema sit"

This canon gives us a contemplation: The Church, in wanting to condemn universalism, show us that it considered the matter an open question up until that time. For, the Church only ever condemn something once, and afterwards only appeal to the same condemnation which it reinforces. Yet, Vatican 1 drawn up an anathema specifically condemning universal salvation which shows that it had hithertho been not condemned. This canon however, no doubt thanks to the Holy Spirit which protect the Church from error, has been dropped without any indication in the acta synodalia as to the question why it was dropped. It did not make the final document, it just vanished.

Now, there are popes who wrote documents in which hell is called everlasting, eternal, perpetual, etc. But these can be written off as pious deceit, not intending to bind consciences, but intending to frighten the soul into obedience. The Church guards the mystery of apokatastasis scrupulously, only occasionally lifting the veil.

A local papal synod actually teaches universal salvation. I'm speaking of the council of Rome in 382, which compiled the canon of Scripture. In canon 21 it states: "If anyone does not say there are three true persons of Father, and of Son, and of Holy Spirit, equal, immortal, containing all visible and invisible, ruling all, judging all, vivifying all, creating all, SAVING ALL, he is a heretic"

The Council of Trent states: "But though He died for all, yet not all receive the benefit of His death, but only those whom the merit of His passion is imparted." This is to be understood as limited to this life only, since some will only receive the benefit of His death in the age to come. To substantiate this, I appeal to Pope Benedict XV who taught that all will receive the benefit of this death. Thus, only in this way can contradiction be avoided. He says: "For the whole of mankind was freed from the slavery of sin by the shedding of the blood of Jesus Christ as their ransom, and there is NO ONE who is excluded from the benefit of this Redemption" (Ad Beatissimi Apostolorum)

Conclusion: Catholics are absolutely free to embrace hard/dogmatic universalism and are not forced to remain hopeful universalists.


r/CatholicUniversalism • • Jan 02 '26

Bishop Barron: How can the Fátima visions of Hell be reconciled with universal salvation?

28 Upvotes

Since this question is raised occasionally on this subreddit, I thought I would share Bishop Robert Barron's answer from his "Dare We Hope?" FAQ:

Q: Didn’t Our Lady of Fatima show a vision of many people suffering in hell?

A: Yes, as a warning of the torments of hell—not as a window into an unavoidable future. We know this because in the same Fatima appearance, she also gave us the Fatima prayer, commanding us to recite it often, begging Jesus to “forgive us our sins, save us from the fires of hell, and lead all souls to heaven, especially those most in need of thy mercy” (emphasis added). Our Lady would never ask us to pray for something that’s impossible, so there must be at least a basic hope for the possibility that all souls can be led to heaven.

Although I think the good bishop errs in judgment of confident universalism, nonetheless, Catholic universalists are lucky to have Bishop Barron as the most visible modern spokesperson for the hopeful position.


r/CatholicUniversalism • • Dec 19 '25

Pope Leo: Let all be saved!

Thumbnail
youtu.be
28 Upvotes

The Good News that so many need to hear.


r/CatholicUniversalism • • Mar 18 '25

Catholic Universalist Quotes, Pope Francis

Post image
57 Upvotes

r/CatholicUniversalism • • Sep 24 '25

Leo seems to be crossing the line from ‘implicit universalist’ to ‘overt confident universalist’…

Post image
65 Upvotes

r/CatholicUniversalism • • May 20 '25

Universalist Quotes by St Hilary of Poitiers!

6 Upvotes

If he was seeking a foundation of authority for what he was doing, and wishing to show who had gone before him in this path he had at hand the Confessor Hilary, who translated the books of Origen upon Job and the Psalms consisting of forty thousand lines. He had Ambrose whose works are, almost all of them, full of what Origen has written; and the martyr Victorinus, who acts really with 'simplicity,' and without setting snares for others.

(Jerome Apology Against Rufinus, Book 1, Chapter 2, Newadvent)

‘Sic petitas atque obtentas bæreditatis sue gentes Drus confiinget et conteret, ut reformet.’

"Thus, the nations, having been sought and obtained as His inheritance, God will break and crush, in order to reform them.

(Hilary of Poitiers, Sancti Hilarii Pictaviensis episcopi tractatus super Psalmos., Tractatus in II Psalmum, Page 283-284, Commenting on Psalm 2:8-9)

The one sheep should be understood as a man, and by a single man we are supposed to comprehend that the Lord is speaking of all mankind. The entire race of humanity strayed by the error of the one Adam.* The ninetynine who did not stray should be reckoned as the multitude of the heavenly angels, who are happy and have the care of human salvation.** Christ is the one who seeks the man; the ninety-nine that are left are the multitude of heavenly glory. The man who strayed is led back into the body of the Lord with greatest rejoicing. For good reason this number is in the form of a letter which was added to [the name of] Abraham and completed in [the name of] Sarah.** [The name] Abraham is derived from [the name] Abram, and Sarah from Sara. We are all in the one man, Abraham,” and we are all together, those in whom the number of the heavenly Church will be accomplished.*’ For that reason, every creature waits for the revelation of the sons of God, sighing and grieving

(Hilary of Poiters, Commentary on Matthew Chapter 18, Verse 6, The Fathers of the Church, Volume 125, Page 196, Translated by D.H Williams)


r/CatholicUniversalism • • May 20 '25

Universalist Quotes by St Eusebius of Caesarea

6 Upvotes

What else does the phrase “until the time for restoration” wish to convey to us than [the] coming age, in which all things must be completely restored?...

(Against Marcellus, Book 2, Verse 11, Page 149-150, Translated by Kelley McCarthy Spoerl in “The Fathers of the Church”)

On this account, just as Physicians prescribe their remedies to those who are sick and debilitated by pains and sufferings, not the healthy food proper for the robust, but things that give uneasiness and pain; and, should it be necessary, do not excuse themselves from applying cauteries and bitter draughts, to coerce the disease: not the aliments proper for the healthy, but those suitable to the sick: but, when they have become convalescent, they will henceforth allow them to partake of wholesome and strengthening food : So likewise the common Saviour of all, as the Shepherd and Physician of His rational flocks on earth, taught those who had previous to His last divine manifestation entered into the many follies of a plurality of Gods, and had been maddened by the evils and fierceness attending (this) corruption of mind, by bitter punishments, by pestilences, famines, and the continuance of wars against each other.

(Theophania, Book 2, Chapter 94-95,

https://www.tertullian.org/fathers/eusebius_theophania_03book2.htm)

Now the laws of love summoned Him even as far as Death and the dead themselves, so that He might summon the souls of those who were long time dead. And so because He cared for the salvation of all for ages past, and that "He might bring to naught him that hath the power of death," as Scripture teaches, here again he underwent the dispensation in His mingled Natures: as Man, he left His Body to the usual burial, while as God He departed from it. For He cried with a loud cry, and said to the Father: "I commend my spirit," and departed from the body free, in no wise waiting for death, who was lagging as it were in fear to come to Him; nay, rather, He pursued him from behind and drove him on, trodden under His feet and fleeing, and He burst the eternal gates of his dark realms, and made a road of return back again to life for the dead there bound with the bonds of death. Thus, too, His own body was raised up, and many bodies of the sleeping saints arose, and came together with Him into the holy and real City of Heaven, as rightly is said by the holy words: "Death has prevailed and swallowed men up"; and again: "The Lord God has taken away every tear from every face." And the Saviour of the Universe, our Lord, the Christ of God, called Victor, is represented in the prophetic predictions as reviling death, and releasing the souls that are bound there, by whom He raises the hymn of victory, and He says these words: "From the hand of Hades I will save them, and from death I will ransom their souls. O Death, where is thy victory? O Death, where is thy sting? The sting of death is sin, and the strength of sin is the law." Such was the dispensation that brought Him even unto death, of which one that wishes to seek for the cause, can find not one reason but many. For firstly, the Word teaches by His death that He is Lord both of dead and living; and secondly, that He will wash away our sins, being slain, and becoming a curse for us; thirdly, that a victim of God and a great sacrifice for the whole world might be offered to Almighty God; fourthly, that thus He might work out the destruction of the deceitful powers of the daemons by unspeakable words; and fifthly also, that shewing the hope of life with God after death to His friends and disciples not by words only by deeds as well, and affording ocular proof of His message, He might make them of good courage and more eager to preach both to Greeks and Barbarians the holy polity which He had established. (Demonstration of the Gospel, Book IV, Chapter 12, https://www.tertullian.org/fathers/eusebius_de_06_book4.htm)

This clearly gives the good news of the Descent of God the Word from heaven, Who is named, and of the result of His Coming. For it says, "He sent his Word and healed them." And we say distinctly that the Word of God was He that was sent as the Saviour of all men, Whom we are taught by the Holy Scriptures to reckon divine. And it darkly suggests that He came down even unto death for the sake of those who had died before Him, and in revealing the redemption of those to be saved by Him it shews the reason of His Coming. For He saved without aid from any one those that had gone before Him even to the gates of death, healed them and rescued them from their destruction. And this He did simply by breaking what are called the gates of death, and crushing the bars of iron.. (Demonstration of the Gospel, Book VI, Chapter 7.https://www.tertullian.org/fathers/eusebius_de_08_book6.htm)

He escaped not from death; for this would have been pusillanimous, and it would have been thought that He was inferior to death. But, by this contention with Death as with a contemporary, He established the immortality of that which was mortal; and, this last conflict which was for the salvation of all, secured (for all) the life which is immortal. (Theophania, Book 3, Chapter 55

https://www.tertullian.org/fathers/eusebius_theophania_04book3.htm)