r/Casefile • • Feb 06 '22

OPEN DISCUSSION Will not be paying for Casefile anymore

0 Upvotes

Yes, it’s the best true crime podcast out there but the volume of output just does not justify paying a premium. We waited two plus months of inactivity to get a case that I assume most of us have heard dozens of podcasts on (Zodiac). I will check in every couple of months to see what new episode has posted but it’s just not worth it. Shame because they are the best at what they do.


r/Casefile • • Oct 20 '24

OPEN DISCUSSION Is Casey / Casefile lacking in quality lately?

4 Upvotes

Long time listener and long time fan. I’ve posted here before and it was regarding the lack of quality of recent. I was proven wrong since that post with the odd quality episode. Look, I’m not a morbid individual, I’m all about case presentation and conclusion, with justice and investigative intrigue at heart. I wish each of the victims justice and the families of each peace and closure. However (in Casey’s now almost AI voice), the choice of cases have now become more about abuse. Again, justice to those whom are abused, subject to abuse and or any ongoing abuse. But it is just really sad and hard to listen to at times. If I hear “this episode contains crimes against children” once more I might just have to stop. It’s just constant and it’s the same and same story. The variance has lacked the criminologist at heart. Is it his writers, is it his team, or is it Casey? I listened to “missing Niamh”, again it was an incredibly hard story to listen to and follow. I am forever sorry for what happened to her and her family, and the story is truly tragic and I wish she is found and justice is brought and her soul is in peace with God, but the presentation is all off - interviews and interviews and interviews and it was very hard to follow. Am I just too harsh? Gone mad? Or all of the above. I’ve found myself listening to other better more well presented podcasts lately.


r/Casefile • • Jun 08 '21

OPEN DISCUSSION Too many ads?!

0 Upvotes

I used to listen to Casefile when it was new but stopped because it became too crowded with ads. I just listened to a new episode and it seems to have gotten worse. I understand you need to make a living but I've never listened to a podcast with this many ads, it's extreme, it's ridicolous, and a bit of bad taste considering the topic? Am I the only one of this opinion?


r/Casefile • • Oct 21 '25

OPEN DISCUSSION They're taking a 4 month winter break. That's crazy

70 Upvotes

As per their Instagram earlier:

The podcast will have it's last episode on November 1st and then not return until March 2026

Casey has given the usual "it's to maintain a high standard and we'll still be working during those 4 months" reasoning

But I think not releasing a new episode for 4 months is bonkers

They seem to be:

  • Stretching themselves too far by trying to do too many "Casefile Presents .... ' series

  • As far as I know, they also fund and produce other non Casefile podcasts

Maybe it's time for them to just get back to basics

I'm expecting the show's usual white knights to defend this, just like they defend this season's big drop in quality

Cue the "well just don't listen then" replies


r/Casefile • • Jul 22 '26

OPEN DISCUSSION Disappointed by episode 334

38 Upvotes

I’ve been going back through Casefile’s most recent episodes that I’ve missed, and I’m quite frankly very disappointed by the way they covered the Malka Leifer case.

I understand Casefile is not a political podcast, but I personally find it irresponsible to speak about the right to return and the founding of Israel as being rooted in “protecting jews” from persecution, without once mentioning the people who originally inhabited the land, and the fact that it is by definition, a settler colonial project and always has been.

Especially given the nature of this crime. It’s well documented that sexual abuse runs rampant in Israel, and that is reflected in the evidence of them using rape and sexual abuse systematically as a weapon against the Palestinians. The reason this is such a prevalent problem in Israel — why 61% of Israeli men do not consider forced sex with an acquaintance as rape — is because they receive no punishment for raping Palestinians, it’s considered completely normal by many, to the level where thousands of Israelis protested for the ‘right to rape’ Palestinian prisoners.

Ignoring this crucial context makes no sense to me.

P.S apologies if I have used the wrong flair, still finding my way around this subreddit.

P.S.S the mass downvoting has started 😂


r/Casefile • • Aug 31 '23

META Casey liking Joe Rogan

73 Upvotes

Odd that Casey hosts a true crime podcast that often brings to light racism, sexism, police corruption and general prejudice involving crimes.

Yet listens to a man who platforms very right wing nut jobs on his show all the time. The kind of people that ‘back the blue’ etc.

Edit: the JR supporters are out in full force.

Edit 2: these insane responses are something to behold. Accusing me of being American, never listening to JRE, of wanting Casefile cancelled? You guys really need help.


r/Casefile • • Aug 05 '25

OPEN DISCUSSION The last 3 episodes have been impossible to follow. Casey doesn't seem to join the dots the way he used to

35 Upvotes

Both parts of the William Tyrrell case and Saturday's GPO Girl episode have been appallingly bad at joining the dots for listeners

I understand that both cases are complex - but it's Casey and the team's job to make them easy to digest

And - having seem some other comments on both cases - it doesn't seem like I'm the only one thinking this

Is it the writing or Casey's overall direction at fault here?

There was a great writer - Eileen Ormsby - who's written some of the best Casefile episodes, but I haven't seen her name on credits in ages

They need her back or - at least - writers who can make things cohesive to listeners


r/Casefile • • Jan 25 '25

META Case File Narrator adding the word “a” to the beginning of words.

0 Upvotes

Why does he say things like “the person provided their a-contact details”. Or “Sandra and a-Deborah did …”

Edit: I’m Aussie too. Glad I’m not the only one who has noticed it.


r/Casefile • • Sep 05 '24

OPEN DISCUSSION How to change mindset around victim blaming?

0 Upvotes

This sounds horrible but I mean well. When I listen to the episodes I naturally get very upset and mad at the perpetrator, but sometimes I get almost upset and frustrated by the victims when they ignore or run toward red flags, and if poor decision making makes it easy for a criminal to victimise them.

To the point that I am thinking they are responsible to protect themselves and avoid situations if they are clearly dangerous, and it's on them to behave in a way and survive in a world with people who are not good. I only think this when it's adults, never kids who don't know better

E.g. case 232 with the other victim who was assaulted and managed to escape.. he was a complete stranger so no emotional relationship or existing trust, and no forceful coercion througu violence etc, it was all voluntary

This sounds bad and I don't want to do it, any discussion on the topic victim blaming and how to not do it?


r/Casefile • • Feb 26 '21

OPEN DISCUSSION Why does the host sound so lacking in compassion or energy now compared to the first 100 episodes?

0 Upvotes

Did something happen in his life? I'm not trolling it's just he genuinely sounds like a soundboard of pre recorded responses, listen to the east area rapist or jonestown episodes and he sounds like a human with a personality and compassionate personality. Now he just sounds so monotonous and uninterested, it's like he feels so disconnected from the script he's reading. It's still an amazingly researched podcast and I'll get shit on for this feedback but I have totally lost interest in the newer episodes, it just comes across like he's reading one long ad. I'll definitely go back to the old episodes which are some of the best podcast episodes I've ever listened to. I find the canadian true crime podcast to be much more sincere and caring. Some may not find the hosts research as in depth but she's much more human and interesting to listen to if nothing other than her voice is far more natural.

This might not even get seen with downvotes or removed by mods because I've seen loads of people with the same feedback who people seem to hate for some reason, I normally lurk and made an account just to say this.

Bye.


r/Casefile • • Oct 06 '24

PODCAST QUESTION Why does the narrators voice sound so different to earlier episodes?

3 Upvotes

I haven’t listened to casefile in a few years but today I decided to give it a listen again. I clicked on one of the latest episodes and immediately noticed how strange the hosts voice was. Every other word he pronounced sounded stilted and his voice just didn’t flow. It sounded like a robot reading the script.

I went back and listened to an older episode from 2018 when I used to listen and his voice is definitely different and much easier to listen to.

Not really a fan of whatever changes they’ve made to the podcast as I had to switch off the newer episode after a few minutes as the voice style was so jarring. Anyone else noticed this or is just because I haven’t listened in a while?


r/Casefile • • Apr 14 '24

META Should I start listening again?

0 Upvotes

Hey! I used to listen to casefile all the time, but the last maybe six months or so I ’ve kinda lost interest in it. Does anyone else feel it’s not as good as it used to be? Also in the last six months have I missed any really good episodes to try get back into it? I hope you are all having a good Sunday :)


r/Casefile • • Oct 12 '25

CASE RELATED Deidre Kennedy

0 Upvotes

I've just read a post about this case on here and I can no longer add a comment to it but it's really irritating me that I can't comment on the post, my family member is Raymond Carroll he was not in Queensland at the time and he has taken care of me since I was born I am now nearly 30... I'm a female he has NEVER touched me or done anything wrong towards me or the daughter he's taken in from his current wife. hes always treated me with respect and kindness, always fed and clothed me, he use to sit and play games with us I loved him, hes stayed in his home town and he is amazing with all the children in our family I really do not think he has done this, the only evidence is a bite mark which really doesn't even match.. the police have said the bite mark was upside down as well as it not...the fact that he wasn't in the army picture is because he was sick and wasn't at the place where the picture was taken but he was still on the base... all evidence is false and just circumstantial, with the people all saying he admitted to it being people in prison themselves who could/would possibly lie if it meant less time on their end most people in prison would do that and lie for their own benefit all evidence is circumstantial. Deidre's own uncle did this in my opinion.


r/Casefile • • May 05 '26

OPEN DISCUSSION Change in narration style?

1 Upvotes

I've been listening to a lot of earlier episodes and I've noticed a difference in narration style compared to recent ones. In the earlier episodes Casey was quite "matter of fact" in his narration. He would finish his sentences with a "neutral" ending. Now, I feel, he quite often has an inflexion at the end of his sentences. Almost like if he's asking a question. Has anyone else noticed this? Or am I imagining things? LOL!

Edit: Up talk is the term.


r/Casefile • • Mar 04 '22

Case 92 concern

0 Upvotes

One of my friends casually asked What if Russia bombs the prison with the Dnepropetrovsk maniacs and they get out? I ignored it at first but then … I don’t know. Do you think this could happen?


r/Casefile • • Apr 01 '25

OPEN DISCUSSION Optimal listening speed for Casefile

4 Upvotes

Purely a curiosity post. I listen on 1.2x for most podcasts, but will often bump Casey to 1.5x. What speed does everyone else prefer to listen to Casefile on?


r/Casefile • • Feb 15 '26

Couldn’t keep up with every Casefile episode, so I built a tool with summaries, search, & insights

0 Upvotes

(Mods approved this post - thank you!)

I built StrawberryData.com as a side project because I wanted to explore podcasts like a dataset, and I didn’t have tons of free time to keep up with every episode.

For Casefile, you can:

  1. Browse episode pages with quick summaries

  2. See lightweight episode stats (for example: sentiment, profanity rate)

  3. Discover other related podcasts in the catalog

Link to an episode: https://strawberrydata.com/podcast/casefile-true-crime/casefile-archives-5-lauria-bible-ashley-freeman

How to use:

  • Start on the episode page above

  • Use search to find other episodes or podcasts

  • Click through and explore

Notes:

  • This is an MVP & definitely not perfect yet

  • I’m still backfilling older episodes & improving update frequency

If you try it, I’d love feedback on what’s useful vs what’s noise - and maybe one feature you’d want most for Casefile.


r/Casefile • • Jun 04 '22

Case 213 Alison’s life saving efforts from Tiaan

0 Upvotes

Tiaan was a vet student at the time of the attack. Near the end of the episode it’s noted that “he went on to become a doctor instead of a vet”

I’d just like to make mention that veterinarians are indeed doctors and had he stayed on the veterinary medicine track he would have still become a doctor. I know this is a very minor detail in this horrific case but I felt it should be mentioned as doctors of veterinary medicine deserve all the respect for what they do.


r/Casefile • • Sep 25 '24

META A short rant from an entitled listener about listening to Casefile and Advertising.

99 Upvotes

Disclaimers:

I understand I am getting an excellent podcast episode for free. Casefile is my most favorite podcast of all time. I even replay episodes when waiting for new ones to drop since I prefer single narrator podcasts. I admittedly do not subscribe to their Patreon because I already spend too much money on Amazon music and other subscriptions.

Rant: After I started this latest episode, I hopped in the shower to get ready for work. I endured FOUR minutes of advertising before the podcast even started. Four! Good God. I was going to just tough it out because my hands were wet, and the phone was on my counter. So 6ish percent of the show before it even starts was advertising, not even counting the other ad breaks. Half of my shower was just listening to ads.

Anyway, thanks if you read this far and I apologize in advance if anyone gets upset over this.

Edit: clearly by the immediate downvotes and the random asshole DM I received within minutes of posting this, people are having a hard time realizing this was slightly tongue-in-cheek.


r/Casefile • • Oct 16 '26

PODCAST RELATED Are we on another break?

2 Upvotes

It’s a casefile revisited this weekend - did I miss a break announcement or has Casey adopted a new approach for a mini break between episodes by doing a re-run, which by the way before anyone reacts, I’d actually prefer rather than an extended break - loads of other podcasters do this!


r/Casefile • • Feb 18 '21

Narrator’s change in meter/delivery: Why?

0 Upvotes

Just jumped from original EAR-ONS series to the update that came out in December. Really awful narration technique, obviously took voice classes. I don’t know why this style is popular in true crime voiceover, it’s almost disrespectful to victims to be describing an assault and quoting what the killer is saying like ‘Yeahhhhh and now I’ll.... cuuuUuut your throooat’ in a faux over-dramatic voice. Really bums me out, was one my favorite pods.

All dark and mysterious: ‘And then he took off his pants and sexually assaulted herrrrr’ like these are real people dude, this isn’t a D&D session.


r/Casefile • • Feb 24 '18

PRO-PERP A good place to start if Case 76 has you upset

Thumbnail
freeross.org
0 Upvotes

r/Casefile • • Feb 06 '25

OPEN DISCUSSION Its February. Been 2 months! Does anyone know when the new episode is gonna be out?

0 Upvotes

I mean I get the holiday break, but its been while!


r/Casefile • • Jan 28 '20

OPEN DISCUSSION Case 08: unnecessary and biased remark?

9 Upvotes

The narrator said "and of course all this was done at the expense of the taxpayer", when referring to measures aimed at preventing vigilante attacks on the girlfriend of the murderer of Holly Wells and Jessica Chapman. I thought that was a bit unnecessary, and a style break with the neutrality of other cases.

I understand that a critique of incompetent law enforcement is acceptable, but this seemed a reasonable measure for such a high-profile case. I also understand negative emotions in a case like this, but this wasn't even aimed at the perp, but someone who only provided a fake alibi - which is a crime, but not to the extend that you deserve a lynching.

I just thought it was a weird remark. What do you think?


r/Casefile • • Jan 31 '26

CASE RELATED Casefile Archives #3 missing content warnings

0 Upvotes

For some reason, archives #3 (Tina Herrmann et al) does not have any content warnings, despite it containing:

  • child victim

  • child sexual assault

  • mutilation

  • animal cruelty (in passing)

I don't usually post on reddit, but I just listened to this episode and was upset to find it had content I usually avoid. I wanted to share for the sake of others.