r/Casefile • • Jan 22 '25 Helpful

Motion to ban x / twitter links from this community

1.2k Upvotes

We don’t see a lot of them, so not a major change, but still important.

Voice your approval or objections here

Edit: Thank you for everyone's input. Changes to community have been incorporated. This post has been locked.


r/Casefile • • Jan 03 '25

OPEN DISCUSSION Casefile made me realize I dont like True Crime podcasts--just Casefile.

805 Upvotes

After years of listening, I've concluded that Casefile is so good that it has become its own genre that stands out from what is understood as "true crime". It's more akin to old school radio drama than a caddy gossip session with cackling drunk women or snickering, unfunny bros.

Casefile doesnt take lazy, unethical, exploitative shortcuts to shock you, like playing horrific audio of real human suffering. It is pure storytelling

The scripts are straight up, well, scripts, not summarized (or plagiarized--Rotten Mangos) published sources, complete with competently performed dramatic narration and tastefully subtle score. The effect is a dramatic mes-en-scene that would be at home on the stage or screen.

the persona of the narrator is entirely non-existent, foregrounding the drama listeners are coming to witness. This is appropriate, and effective, because the show understands when you are dealing with the unimaginable suffering of real humans nothing can be more interesting than that--certainly not how long your million dollar flat in london was in escrow (red handed) or self depricating jokes about your dick (last podcast on the left, or right, or whatever).

after listening to essentially all other true crime I've realized I actually find the genre repulsive at worst, cringe at best but mostly just boring.

when your business model is the suffering of real people, no other approach than this is appropriate, or effective.

Thank you, Casefile. You're really the best.


r/Casefile • • Sep 10 '19

OPEN DISCUSSION Respect to Casefile for naming the episodes after victims rather than perpetrators

678 Upvotes

I want to commend Casefile on naming the episodes after the victims rather than the perpetrators, when possible. Too often the victims are forgotten amidst the murderers' notoriety and fame in the media.

For example, it would have been easy to name the most recent episode 'Adolfo Constanzo' or 'The Godfather murders' or 'The Narcosatanists', etc - perhaps it would have even garnered more listeners out of recognition. Calling it 'Mark Kilroy' instead keeps the focus on the victim, his suffering and his memory and diminishes the perpetrator.

Thank you Casefile for always being such a respectful and considerate true crime podcast.


r/Casefile • • Sep 21 '21

I worry about casefile team member Jess

630 Upvotes

Sure, she's enjoying great audiobooks through audible and eating well with Noom, but I think she might be addicted to podcast advertised subscription services. It seems like every time Casey plugs a service, Jess is already there.

She may need to call Better Help to get herself back under control


r/Casefile • • Sep 10 '25

OPEN DISCUSSION I strayed from Casefile and immediately regretted it

616 Upvotes

This is only loosely Casefile-related, but I need to yell into the void.

I usually don’t like to yuck someone’s yum, but I heard about a case I wanted to listen to and couldn’t find it on Casefile—only on Morbid. And wow… it was painful. The commentary was unbearable, the “jokes” weren’t funny but delivered like they were, and they constantly talked over each other. I couldn’t even follow the actual case because they interrupted every other sentence with some terrible quip. A literal quote I just heard: “she was like Elsa with a balloon, she needed to let it go” 💀

All that to say: Casefile, I appreciate you more than ever.


r/Casefile • • Feb 25 '22

META Casefile be like

544 Upvotes

"Salt Lake City Police did interview Michelle's husband, Donald, in connection with her brutal slaying. However, although Donald's criminal record included numerous petty crimes and connections to more than 17 wife-murders in the past, investigators ultimately dismissed him as a suspect, stating that he did not fit the police's working theory that 56-year old Michelle had been killed as a result of a Colombian dog-fighting cartel lesbian love triangle."


"The man stepped out of the thick treeline into the clearing, where he was spotted by a patrol officer. The officer immediately noted that the heavy-set man was covered in what appeared to be blood. When the officer asked the man whose blood it was, the man replied: 'Uh, if it's from a woman I murdered, will I like, be in trouble?' When the officer replied that he would be in trouble, the man remained silent for 45 minutes, before stating, 'Okay, then it's probably not that.' The officer waved the man along, advising him to be careful, as 170 female corpses had been recently discovered in the area."


"Unfortunately, due to a local law, German police official's hands were tied - the statue of limitations for violent sexual assault, which at the time was 25 minutes, had long since passed."


"Friends and family of Joanna Heathersbee spoke out publicly about the systemic issues surrounding the crime, supporting a bill that would prevent convicted child cannibals from opening secluded orphanages in the state. Though the bill received widespread public support, it was struck down by the House of Commons, with officials later stating that, quote, "It was Friday afternoon, and it just, like, ugh, you know?"


"Police assured Robert's worried parents that their fears were unfounded, and that their son had probably spent a late night enjoying the city's many local pubs and forgotten to charge his phone. When the parents mentioned the disturbing package they had received that morning, police told Robert's parents that their son had probably cut his own head off and mailed it to them as a teenage prank."


r/Casefile • • Feb 17 '25

OPEN DISCUSSION Casefile has ruined true crime podcasts….

526 Upvotes

It’s ruined podcasts for me. I used to be an avid listener of anything true crime related but since I’ve started listening to casefile a year ago, nothing else will do.

I love the story telling, the creepy music, Casey’s monotone AI voice everything. It was amazing when I first found the podcast and had soo much content to listen to but now I’m caught up and have to wait weekly for uploads, it’s too much waiting.

Is there anything else out there like casefile? I dont want anything with the silly fake banter, I don’t want to hear anyone’s opinions and thoughts, I don’t even like podcasts with more than 1 host anymore. Just straight story telling.

Please help, the weekly waits are killing me.


r/Casefile • • Jul 08 '24

OPEN DISCUSSION Thank you Casefile for finding my soulmate for me!

481 Upvotes

Sorry if this is off topic, just thought I’d share something nice.

In December of 2019, I was sick and hospitalized for 3 weeks. I had nothing to do and felt too sick to scroll endlessly on my phone, so listened to a Casefile episode on the Janabi Family killings. I loved Casefile.

I found the situation horrifying and fascinating and did some research. Eventually, I found a man on Reddit who was linked in real life to the case. I messaged him with some questions and we ended up having a conversation.

He eventually gave me his phone number as he was interested. We became friends, then a couple, and now are married!


r/Casefile • • Feb 24 '25

META I just realized Casey isn’t his real name

425 Upvotes

It’s a play on Casefile. This took me 5 years


r/Casefile • • May 22 '18

META When you see a better True Crime podcast.....

Post image
422 Upvotes

r/Casefile • • Apr 14 '26 Heartwarming

does anyone else have 0 problems with the podcast?

411 Upvotes

i have listened to every episode apart from 3 or 4 random ones there, and i have loved every one.

i have been reading other peoples posts complaining about certain cases or the way the narrator speaks but in my personal opinion i have not heard a single better narrator for true crime on all of spotify, and i am actually a big fan of the pacing of each episode as a couple hour long episodes will last me my whole shift at work.

the only thing that im not a fan of PERSONALLY is the cold cases as i just love finding out who did it and how they were brought up to be the way they were.

so what are your favourite or least favourite things about casefile, and what is your favourite episode or series and why?


r/Casefile • • Feb 06 '21

META Casefile’s website now has filters for case type.

Post image
391 Upvotes

r/Casefile • • Mar 10 '19

DISCUSSION How lucky we are to have Casey as a host

378 Upvotes

The recent drama with Sword and Scale is a stark reminder of why Casey chooses to remain anonymous. He understands that, rather than profiting off of other peoples’ pain, true crime podcasts are supposed to be providing a public service; they are supposed to be telling the victims’ stories, raising awareness of their cases, and assisting in the advancement of justice for their suffering.

He understands that by hosting one, he’s putting himself in a position of trust. And he understands that if he became a notable public figure on the back of it, his public personality, and personal conduct affects both the trust of his listeners in him, and the value of the service his podcast is providing. And worse, it distracts attention from the victims and their stories.

By remaining anonymous, he’s keeping the show on point, and not making the show about himself.

An example that a certain other true crime podcast host would do well to follow.


r/Casefile • • Oct 04 '25

OPEN DISCUSSION "Girl Meat Hunter," another example of my problem with recent episodes

350 Upvotes

Hour and a half episode. First hour specifically crafted to make the guy seem like he may genuinely be kidnapping and eating women. At the hour mark, for the first time, Casey reveals that from day one, the suspect FREQUENTLY specifically disclosed that this stuff isn't real, it's all roleplaying. For example, the episode focuses a bit on a chat with another user in England, IIRC, who wrote about hiring the suspect to kidnap and rape/eat someone. When telling that part of the story, the writer deliberately left out that the suspect told the other guy,. paraphrasing here, "I'm not really doing this stuff, it's just fantasy," and then added it back in at the end of the episode.

This is disingenuous storytelling! I miss when all the details were presented up front, chronologically, so you could make up your own mind about what you thought was happening. I feel I can't trust the story because who knows what details they're leaving out to make things more interesting, and as a result I'm barely invested at all.


r/Casefile • • Jun 03 '25

OPEN DISCUSSION Patreon Message

348 Upvotes

It makes me sad that they had to send out this message, the patreon is so high quality for for such a low price. The accusation that they are misleading people or being deceitful seems absurd to me, they could be making so much more money and churning out way loewr quality content, but they clearly care about their work.

If you're reading this Casefile team, you do an amazing job and thank you for the incredible amount of content you give us to listen to.


r/Casefile • • Jul 10 '22

Casefile cases pre 1990s be like…

348 Upvotes

“After being found guilty of the rape of the 7 year old John Smith was released back into the community after 3 months” 🤦‍♂️🤦‍♂️🤦‍♂️


r/Casefile • • Jul 21 '21

ANNOUNCEMENT He’s back in action!!

Post image
336 Upvotes

r/Casefile • • Sep 17 '19

CASE RELATED The Janabi Family

335 Upvotes

Hey guys, I’ve had a number of you reach out over the past few months after the podcast came out, and I really just wanted to post a thank you.

Thanks for taking the time to write, the support, and the empathy for the family.

Another big thank you is owed to the researchers, who honestly did a better job than most msm outlets during the actual events.

I realize this is all a bit late, I’m just not very good at this reddit thing, and I had no idea there was actually a sub for casefile, so - my apologies.

I hope you all have a great day!

Justin


r/Casefile • • Jun 26 '21

SHOW NEWS Casefile taking an unexpected Break

326 Upvotes

Copied from the patreon.

Hi everyone, Mike here.

We want to let you know that Casefile will be taking a short, unexpected break while our beloved host recovers from a medical issue. We should be back to our usual schedule very soon.  Maybe a few weeks.

The latest Casefile Presents podcast series, The Invisible Hand, is set for a release on the 1st, so we will still do that. After that, there will be a few weeks off from the episodes. We will let our listeners know about the break next Saturday; however, we wanted to let our Patreon supporters know first.

The entire Casefile team looks forward to sharing new episodes with you very soon. We'll keep you updated along the way.

Thank you. Casefile team


r/Casefile • • May 05 '20

CASE RELATED HBO is producing a 6-part documentary series on "I'll Be Gone in the Dark" about the East Area Rapist; premieres June 28.

Thumbnail
refinery29.com
318 Upvotes

r/Casefile • • Nov 11 '24

CASE RELATED Case 119: Abigail Williams & Liberty German (Update) Richard Allen found guilty

307 Upvotes

r/Casefile • • Dec 31 '20

CASEFILE OFFICIAL From the Casefile Podcast Instagram

Post image
305 Upvotes

r/Casefile • • Sep 20 '24

CASE RELATED Arrest in Easey Street murders almost 50 years after deaths

Thumbnail
smh.com.au
299 Upvotes

r/Casefile • • Jul 15 '26

OPEN DISCUSSION Casefile has been killing it lately

292 Upvotes

Since their break starting with Test A.RTF, every episode has been unique and crazy interesting with top notch pacing. Luckily, 90% of the episodes I had never heard of before but even the one I did (BTK) I was enthralled all 4 parts.

This weeks episode (347) is probably the best one in recent memory. I won't spoil anything but it's an emotional ride. Whoever wrote this one deserves some praise. You will probably listen to it once, but it will leave a mark on you.

Not in a long time have I been waiting with excitement until Monday mornings when I can listen to a new episode on my way to work.


r/Casefile • • Aug 21 '20

CASE RELATED Golden State Killer sentenced to life in prison.

Thumbnail
bbc.com
291 Upvotes