r/CapitalismVSocialism • • Dec 18 '19

[1700s Liberals] Democracy has failed every time it's been tried. Why do you shill for a failed ideology?

2.3k Upvotes

You all claim to hate feudalism, and yet you toil on the king's land? Curious. You seem to have no problem enjoying the benefits and innovations brought to you by feudalism, the clothes on your back, the road beneath your feet, the hovel you live in... without feudalism, none of these things would exist, and yet you still advocate for your failed, idealistic dream-society

Feudalism has lifted millions out of poverty, and yet you have the audacity to claim it causes it? Do you even understand basic economics? Without the incentive to keep scores of people in perpetual obligation to them, landowners would have no reason to produce, and no reason to raise the peasants out of poverty.

Greek democracy? Failed. Roman democracy? Failed and turned into a dictatorship several times. Venetian democracy? Failed. English democracy? Failed, and a dictatorship. It's failed every time it's been tried.

But, wait, let me guess. Those 'weren't real democracies', right?


r/CapitalismVSocialism • • Jan 29 '21

Too many intelligent people go into stupid careers to make money instead of going into careers that could ACTUALLY benefit our society. We do not value people who are intelligent, we value people who create capital. Hence, capitalism doesnt incentivize innovation

1.9k Upvotes

if we honestly think that capitalism is the most effective way to innovate as of now, than imagine what we could accomplish if intelligent people chose to go into careers where they can use their talents and their brain power MUCH more effectively.

And we all know how there are tons of people who face financial barriers to getting a degree who arent capable of becoming possible innovators and having the opportunity to make the world a better place.

All the degrees with higher education costs tons of money, so many of these people will go into debt, giving them more of a reason to just work at wallstreet instead of doing anything meaningful

capitalism doesnt incentivize innovation


r/CapitalismVSocialism • • Jan 11 '19

Here is proof that Communism​ is better than Capitalism

1.9k Upvotes

The proof is that communists countries make the best bread. In those communist countries, history has proven that people would wait hours and hours in line for that bread.


r/CapitalismVSocialism • • Mar 01 '22

Please Don't Downvote in this sub, here's why

1.3k Upvotes

So this sub started out because of another sub, called r/SocialismVCapitalism, and when that sub was quite new one of the mods there got in an argument with a reader and during the course of that argument the mod used their mod-powers to shut-up the person the mod was arguing against, by permanently-banning them.

Myself and a few others thought this was really uncool and set about to create this sub, a place where mods were not allowed to abuse their own mod-powers like that, and where free-speech would reign as much as Reddit would allow.

And the experiment seems to have worked out pretty well so far.

But there is one thing we cannot control, and that is how you guys vote.

Because this is a sub designed to be participated in by two groups that are oppositional, the tendency is to downvote conversations and people and opionions that you disagree with.

The problem is that it's these very conversations that are perhaps the most valuable in this sub.

It would actually help if people did the opposite and upvoted both everyone they agree with AND everyone they disagree with.

I also need your help to fight back against those people who downvote, if you see someone who has been downvoted to zero or below, give them an upvote back to 1 if you can.

We experimented in the early days with hiding downvotes, delaying their display, etc., etc., and these things did not seem to materially improve the situation in the sub so we stopped. There is no way to turn off downvoting on Reddit, it's something we have to live with. And normally this works fine in most subs, but in this sub we need your help, if everyone downvotes everyone they disagree with, then that makes it hard for a sub designed to be a meeting-place between two opposing groups.

So, just think before you downvote. I don't blame you guys at all for downvoting people being assholes, rule-breakers, or topics that are dumb topics, but especially in the comments try not to downvotes your fellow readers simply for disagreeing with you, or you them. And help us all out and upvote people back to 1, even if you disagree with them.

Remember Graham's Hierarchy of Disagreement:

https://imgur.com/FHIsH8a.png

Thank guys!

---

Edit: Trying out Contest Mode, which randomizes post order and actually does hide up and down-votes from everyone except the mods. Should we figure out how to turn this on by default, it could become the new normal because of that vote-hiding feature.


r/CapitalismVSocialism • • Jul 16 '20

Why do capitalists assume a state will be corrupt but not that a business will?

1.2k Upvotes

I see lots of people here point out abuses done by the state, without explaining why the same abuses or worse would not be done directly by capitalists in the absence of a state. Capitalists rush to fill the power vacuum caused by dismantling the state following a neoliberal model of privatization. The power still exists it's just weilded directly by the capitalists with no state middle man to soften the blows.

Edit: I think this is my first gold. Woot.

Edit 2: some really well written responses from all sides. I wish all my posts would get this kind of engagement.


r/CapitalismVSocialism • • Feb 20 '20

32 years ago, revolutionary and Marxist President of Burkina Faso, Thomas Sankara was assassinated, in a coup backed by France, the UK and the US.

1.2k Upvotes
  1. ⁠He vaccinated 2.5 million children against meningitis, yellow fever and measles in a matter of weeks

  2. ⁠He initiated a nation-wide literacy campaign, increasing the literacy rate from 13% in 1983 to 73% in 1987.

  3. ⁠He planted over 10 million trees to prevent desertification

  4. ⁠He built roads and a railway to tie the nation together, without foreign aid

  5. ⁠He appointed females to high governmental positions, encouraged them to work, recruited them into the military, and granted pregnancy leave during education

  6. ⁠He outlawed female genital mutilation, forced marriages and polygamy in support of Women’s rights

  7. ⁠He sold off the government fleet of Mercedes cars and made the Renault 5 (the cheapest car sold in Burkina Faso at that time) the official service car of the ministers.

  8. ⁠He reduced the salaries of all public servants, including his own, and forbade the use of government chauffeurs and 1st class airline tickets.

  9. ⁠He redistributed land from the feudal landlords and gave it directly to the peasants. Wheat production rose in three years from 1700 kg per hectare to 3800 kg per hectare, making the country food self-sufficient

And again

10. He opposed foreign aid, saying that “he who feeds you, controls you.”

11. He spoke in forums like the Organization of African Unity against continued neo-colonialist penetration of Africa through Western trade and finance.

12. He called for a united front of African nations to repudiate their foreign debt. He argued that the poor and exploited did not have an obligation to repay money to the rich and exploiting In Ouagadougou, Sankara converted the army’s provisioning store into a state-owned supermarket open to everyone (the first supermarket in the country).

13. He forced civil servants to pay one month’s salary to public projects.)

14. He refused to use the air conditioning in his office on the grounds that such luxury was not available to anyone but a handful of Burkinabes

15. As President, he lowered his salary to $450 a month and limited his possessions to a car, four bikes, three guitars, a fridge and a broken freezer

16. A motorcyclist himself, he formed an all-women motorcycle personal guard.

17. He required public servants to wear a traditional tunic, woven from Burkinabe cotton and sewn by Burkinabe craftsmen. (The reason being to rely upon local industry and identity rather than foreign industry and identity)

18. When asked why he didn’t want his portrait hung in public places, as was the norm for other African leaders, Sankara replied “There are seven million Thomas Sankaras.”

19. An accomplished guitarist, he wrote the new national anthem himself

20. He renamed his country from the derogatory " Upper volta " to " Burkina Faso, The Land Of Upright Man"

21. His foreign policies were centred on anti-imperialism, with his government eschewing all foreign aid, pushing for odious debt reduction, nationalising all land and mineral wealth and averting the power and influence of the International Monetary Fund (IMF) and World Bank.

22. Sankara's administration was the first African government to publicly recognize the AIDS epidemic as a major threat to Africa

23. Large-scale housing and infrastructure projects were also undertaken. Brick factories were created to help build houses in effort to end urban slums

24. In Ouagadougou, Sankara converted the army's provisioning store into a state-owned supermarket open to everyone (the first supermarket in the country)

He led one of the most ambitious programs of sweeping reforms ever seen in Africa It sought to fundamentally reverse the structural social inequities inherited from the French colonial order.

These inequities left a majority of marginalized, mostly rural, poor and women, at the bottom of society, often under the exploitation of a minority of bureaucrats, businessmen, military officers and traditional chiefs. Sankara focused the state’s limited resources on the marginalized majority in the countryside. When most African countries depended on imported food and external assistance for development, Sankara championed local production and the consumption of locally-made goods. He firmly believed that it was possible for the Burkinabè, with hard work and collective social mobilization, to solve their problems: chiefly scarce food and drinking water. In Sankara’s Burkina, no one was above farm work, or graveling roads–not even the president, government ministers or army officers. Intellectual and civic education were systematically integrated with military training and soldiers were required to work in local community development projects.

According to Ernest Harsch, author of a recent biography of Sankara, Burkinabe built for the first time scores of schools, health centers, water reservoirs, and nearly 100 km of rail, with little or no external assistance. Total cereal production rose by 75% between 1983 and 1986. In 1984, his government, defying skepticism from the donor agencies, organized the vaccination of 2 million children in a little over two weeks. He also championed environmental conservation with tree-planting campaigns and greening projects.

His informal style of leadership was in a league of its own. Harsch quotes a former aide describing Sankara as “an idealist, demanding, rigorous, an organizer.” This discipline and seriousness started with himself. He had been first among top leadership to voluntary declare his modest assets and hand over to the treasury cash and gifts received during trips. Harsch quotes family members as saying that Sankara told them not to expect any benefits from him because he is president. In fact, by the time of his death, his kids attended the same public school, his wife was reporting to the same civil servant job, and his parents lived in the same house.

Sankara disdained formal pomp and banned any cult of his personality. He could be seen casually walking the streets, jogging or conspicuously slipping into the crowd at a public event. He was a rousing orator who spoke with uncommon candor and clarity and did not hesitate to publicly admit mistakes, chastise comrades or express moral objections to heads of powerful nations, even if it imperiled him. For example, he famously criticized French president François Mitterand during a state dinner for hosting the leader of Apartheid South Africa.

Books by Sankara:

We are the heirs of the world's revolution

Women's liberation and the African freedom struggle

Thomas Sankara Speaks

A quote from the book - " Our country produces enough to feed us all. Alas, for lack of organization, we are forced to beg for food aid. It’s this aid that instills in our spirits the attitude of beggars. " -Thomas Sankara

" The revolution and women’s liberation go together. We do not talk of women’s emancipation as an act of charity or because of a surge of human compassion. It is a basic necessity for the triumph of the revolution. Women hold up the other half of the sky. " - Thomas Sankara.

Sankara is often referred to as "Africa's Che Guevara." Sankara gave a speech marking and honoring the 20th anniversary of Che Guevara's 9 October 1967 execution, one week before his own assassination on 15 October 1987


r/CapitalismVSocialism • • Nov 10 '20

(Capitalists) If Your Theory Is So Great, Why Can I Strawman It?

1.1k Upvotes

So, I haven't bothered reading anything about capitalism outside of Marxists saying it's bad. And my understanding is that: it is bad. I don't really feel like reading more on it and although I'm not 100% sure how it works, I have some pretty insightful questions I think destoys capitalism.

  1. Why are you evil? My moral framework says you're bad even though my moral framework was designed to morally discount capitalism, I believe that this is completely objective and you're bad people.

  2. Why do you have to write so much? I mean, come on. I can't be arsed reading that. Render it down until you can fit it on a post it note please.

  3. Why can't you all agree on every aspect of capitalism? Libertarians, ststists? Whst the hell is all this? Clearly it doesn't count as an ideology because you all disagree with each other.

  4. Why can't you write an extensive apology for every death ever caused by capitalism? From my completely unbiased calculations, I came to the conclusion that capitalism kills 300 gorillion a year. You need to give me a full report on why this happened and how you'll avoid it please.

So, anyway, your ideology is destroyed! And no, I will not consider doing any research or looking at things from your perspective. I am simply here to gloat about my superiority.


r/CapitalismVSocialism • • Mar 16 '22

[socialists] how many more people have to die before you realize that socialism doesn’t work?

1.0k Upvotes

What never ceases to amaze me is how obtuse socialists are, especially on this subject. It’s been tried how many times and been a complete disaster? It’s said insanity is doing the same thing over and over and expecting different results, but in case you have short memories or refuse to learn from history, I’ll list a few of socialism’s failures:

-The Paris Commune, destroyed by french army, thousands killed and executed

-Bavarian Socialist Republic, destroyed by German army and freikorps paramilitaries, many of whom would later go on to join the nazi party

-Guatemala, Arbenz government pissed off United fruit co, ousted in a CIA and state dept backed coup d’etat and indigenous uprising against plantation owners genocidally suppressed by military dictatorship with help from the US state dep’t during the 80s

-Cuba, 70 years of a crippling embargo, endless sabotage and literally hundreds of assassination attempts of it’s leadership and having to be on a constant war footing with the US, which occupies Cuba to this day

-Chile, economic sabotage by Nixon administration led to massive recession, then assassinated in a US backed coup d’etat and fascist dictator Pinochet put in his place, executes 30,000

-Grenada, invaded by the US, revolutionary gov’t overthrown

-Nicaragua, after spending millions of dollars arming, death squads and financing them by running cocaine into the US and the Reagan administration clandestinely selling arms to Iran, much of the country was devastated and US backed right-wing militias, beaten over the head by the US with sanctions for decades up until this day

-Bolivia, Socialist gov’t overthrown in CIA backed coup, military dictatorship installed, years later in 2017, popular socialist president ousted in state department/CIA backed right wing coup

-Soviet Union, bankrupted by arms race with global hegemon, USA, political crisis and resurgent nationalism foments breakup, doing much better under capitalism now

-Yugoslavia, resurgent nationalism breaks up the powder keg of Europe, with a perennially unstable political history, after going bankrupt on military spending after decades of preparing for war against both nato and the Soviet Union

-Iran, democratically elected socialist government of Mossadegh ousted in coup by CIA and MI6. Murderous Shah along with his secret police, restored to the Peacock Throne.

-North Korea, became a confucian filial piety state, still crippled by sanctions with unsustainable military spending having to be on constant war footing with USA

-South Korea, socialist government of second republic overthrown, military dictatorship installed, leftist suppressed violently for years with help of CIA and state dept, but still keeps stalinist five year economic plans to develop

-venezuela, attempted coup against president in 2010, crippled by US sanctions and sabotage

-italy, months after Truman authorizes foreign intervention by CIA, the US spends millions of dollar and decades on propaganda, disrupting elections, violent suppression and getting unions black balled to,undermine socialist party

-Spain, Republican government backed by socialists and communists falls Franco’s forces with the backing of nazi Hitler and Mussolini. 10s if not 100s of thousands subsequently executed

-China despite five year economic plans that are issued by communist politburos with massive amounts of state intervention and investment, now capitalist

-Vietnam, gets bombed back to the Stone Age by global hegemon[see: china]

-USA, any radical movement that gains traction terrorized by US government, usually covertly, sometimes openly

-Burkina Faso, reformist socialist leader ousted in coup backed by French Quai d’Orsay, immediately reverses socialist gov’t policy

-The Congo, socialist president arrested and executed after coup backed by French secret service and CIA

-Brazil, interior ministry clandestinely and illegally worked with White House and the US justice department to have popular socialist ex- president imprisoned on trumped up corruption charges to try bar him from holding office, the same with his predecessor, Dilma Rousef, paving the way for far-right authoritarian Bolisarno

-Afghanistan, reformist socialist government fails after Soviet intervention and years of battle against US funded and armed muhajedeen, many of whom would later become the backbone of the taliban

-Greece, after fiercely resisting the nazi occupation, a coalition led by the Greek communist party controlled 90% of the country, after British install interim papandreou gov’t, civil war ensues with British and US backed forces, many of who, had collaborated with the nazis ending up defeating the socialists and military dictatorship was later installed, various leftist groups violently suppressed with thousands killed and imprisoned, with many more fleeing

I mean, how many more people are going to have to be killed, how many governments are going to have to be overthrow, how many more bombs must be dropped, how many more economies are going to have to be destroyed until socialists learn that in never works? If the prospect of getting beheaded by CIA funded death squads, tortured by a US backed military dictators, getting incinerated with napalm, getting harassed or killed by the FBI, or a giant piece of shrapnel that says “Northrop-Grumman” on it ripping through your apartment doesn’t lead you to figure it out, I don’t think anything will.

Some people just never learn.


r/CapitalismVSocialism • • Aug 20 '19

"An average worker needs to work a mere 11 hours per week to produce as much as one working 40 hours per week in 1950."

887 Upvotes

http://groups.csail.mit.edu/mac/users/rauch/worktime/

Why is worker productivity sky high yet wages remain stagnant and hours remain high? Some people are benefiting from workers productivity , and it isn't the workers.


r/CapitalismVSocialism • • Feb 23 '20

[Capitalists] My dad is dying of cancer. His therapy costs $25,000 per dose. Every other week. Help me understand

803 Upvotes

Please, don’t feel like you need to pull any punches. I’m at peace with his imminent death. I just want to understand the counter argument for why this is okay. Is this what is required to progress medicine? Is this what is required to allow inventors of medicines to recoup their cost? Is there no other way? Medicare pays for most of this, but I still feel like this is excessive.

I know for a fact that plenty of medical advancements happen in other countries, including Cuba, and don’t charge this much so it must be possible. So why is this kind of price gouging okay in the US?


r/CapitalismVSocialism • • Sep 25 '19

Jeff Bezos would pay $9 billion a year in wealth taxes under Bernie Sanders’ plan

750 Upvotes

Sanders’ plan starts at a lower wealth level – taxing those worth $32 million at 1% – so his tax would hit about 180,000 families while Warren’s would affect about 75,000 households.

The sliding scale of the Sanders plan quickly escalates for wealth over $500 million, which would be taxed at 4%.

Here are estimates for the wealth tax bills for several billionaires under this proposal.

https://www.cnbc.com/2019/09/24/jeff-bezos-would-pay-9-billion-a-year-in-taxes-under-sanders-plan.html


r/CapitalismVSocialism • • Oct 07 '20

“Work or Die” is a fact of life, not a problem with capitalism

745 Upvotes

I hear it a lot from socialists: “capitalism isn’t voluntary because if you don’t work for an employer you’ll starve”.

First of all this is false binary since the choice isn’t “work 100 hours a week or die”, there are varying degrees of effort you can put into a job, and you can spend your time while not working enjoying recreational activities or hobbies. Every waking second is not a choice between work and death

But second of all the fact that humans have to work for their survival is unavoidable. Food does not just materialise, and neither does literally anything else. Humans have to work to continue to ensure the survival of our species.

The only alternative to "work or die" is "free ride or die". I.e. if you're not going to allow people to suffer the consequences of their decision not to contribute to their own wellbeing, you necessarily are saying that your society will maintain a quality of life even for those who do absolutely nothing, and that responsibility will fall on other people. Thus, even under socialism workers do not own the product of their labour, since some of the product of their labour can go towards feeding another.

If they do, then socialism also is completely involuntary since you still must work or die.

The third point I want to make is that if you're going to define "voluntary" such that any choice which involves a decision with potential negative consequences is no longer voluntary, then "voluntary" as a concept just doesn't exist for anything other than the most trivial of matters.

If I'm sky-diving, is choosing to pull my parachute a voluntary choice? Did I do it according to my own free will? And if I didn't, then who forced me to? If my pulling the parachute wasn't a choice I made with free will, then someone else must have acted to cause me to open my parachute. The parachute didn't open magically of its own accord, so who decided to pull the cord?


r/CapitalismVSocialism • • Feb 19 '19

Socialists, nobody thinks Venezuela is what you WANT, the argument is that Venezuela is what you GET. Stop straw-manning this criticism.

723 Upvotes

In a recent thread socialists cheered on yet another Straw Man Spartacus for declaring that socialists don't desire the outcomes in Venezuela, Maos China, Vietnam, Somalia, Cambodia, USSR, etc.... Well no shit.

We all know you want bubblegum forests and lemonade rivers, the actual critique of socialist ideology that liberals have made since before the iron curtain was even erected is that almost any attempt to implement anti-capitalist ideology will result in scarcity and centralization and ultimately inhumane catastophe. Stop handwaving away actual criticisms of your ideology by bravely declaring that you don't support failed socialist policies that quite ironically many of your ilk publicly supported before they turned to shit.

If this is too complicated of an idea for you, think about it this way: you know how literally every socialist claims that "crony capitalism is capitalism"? Hate to break it to you but liberals have been making this exact same critique of socialism for 200+ years. In the same way that "crony capitalism is capitalism", Venezuela is socialism.... Might not be the outcome you wanted but it's the outcome you're going to get.

It's quite telling that a thread with over 100 karma didn't have a single liberal trying to defend the position stated in OP, i.e. nobody thinks you want what happened in Venezuela. I mean, the title of the post that received something like 180 karma was "Why does every Capitalist think Venezuela is what most socialist advocate for?" and literally not one capitalist tried to defend this position. That should be pretty telling about how well the average socialist here comprehends actual criticisms of their ideology as opposed to just believes lazy strawmen that allow them to avoid any actual argument.

I'll even put it in meme format....

Socialists: "Crony capitalism is the only possible outcome of implementinting private property"

Normal adults: "Venezuela, Maos China, Vietnam, Cambodia, USSR, etc are the only possible outcomes of trying to abolish private property"

Socialists: Pikachu face

Give me crony capitalism over genocide and systematic poverty any day.


r/CapitalismVSocialism • • Jun 12 '21

Capitalism has caused tremendously more suffering than Communism has

719 Upvotes

edit: not getting a lot of responses, just a lot of insults. If you guys cant see how the profit motive started so many of these historical events, idk what to tell you

Really tired of hearing reactionaries on this sub claim that communism or socialism or whatever is the worse thing to ever exist. Lets talk about how much human suffering has been caused and will continue to exist thanks to the malignant nature of capitalism. To begin on a high note:

According to UNICEF, WHO, and other sources: somewhere between 6-10 million children die per year from preventable diseases and malnutrition. Thats at least 60 million every decade or at least 300 million every 50 years. And thats being generous considering how poverty is supposed to have been reducing over the last half century. We have enough food to feed 10 billion people but we dont because its expensive and "inefficient" and disprupts the market.

Great Bengal Famine: killed 10 million of the 30 million overtaxed Bengalis, starved to death.

Opium Wars: millions of Chinese died, struggled with drug addiction and then millions more died when they fought to stop Britain from flooding the Chinese market with opium.

Indian Rebellion of 1857: Uprising against the rule of the British East India Company. Almost 800,00 Indians died from the rebellion as reprisals for the 2,000 British deaths and from famines and epidemics that resulted there after

The Upper Doab Famine of 1860-1861: Up to 2 million people killed by Queen Victoria

The Orissa Famine of 1866: at least 2 million killed under Queen Victorias rule, starving farmers werer forced to export large quantities of rice to Great Britain

The Great Famine of 1876-1878: a famine in India under British rule, per Queen Victoria, which killed an estimated 5.6 million people

Urabi Revolt: Nationalist uprising in Egypt in response to British and French influence.

Indian Famine of 1896-1897: about one million people are thought to have died again thanks to Queen Victoria

The Indian Famine of 1899-1900: killed another 4 million under British ruled provinces

Boxer Rebllion of 1899-1901: a total of up to 100,000 or more died in the conflict. It was a violent anti-imperialist insurreciton in China

Great Potato Famine: 1 million people died in this Irish Famine

Persian Famine 1917-1919: which killed about 8-10 million people. A variety of factors caused and contributed to the famine, including the confiscation of foodstuffs by occupying armies such as the British soldiers, hoarding and speculation.

The Indonesian Massacres 1965-1966: also known as the Indonesian communist purge were large scale killings and civil unrest that occured over several months targeting the Communist party, often instigated by armed forces and the government which were supported by the US and other western countries. 500,000 people died

East Timor Genocide 1975-1999: In December 1975, the US supplied weapons for the Indonesian invasion of East Timor. Daniel Moynihan, U.S. ambassador to the UN. said that the U.S. wanted “things to turn out as they did.” The result was an estimated 200,000 dead out of a population of 800,000.

Bengal Famine 1943: about 3 million people died. Many observers in Modern India and Great Britain blame Winston Churchill for his deliberate actions of ordering the diversion of food away from Indians toward British troops around the world. This famine killed as many people in Holodomor, in less time.

The Bangladesh Famine of 1974 which killed about 1 million people. Scholars argue that the Bangladesh famine was not caused by a failure in availability of food but in distribution (or entitlement), where one group gained "market command over food".

"White Terror" Spanish Civil War 1936-1945: killed between 50,000-200,000 people, more than double the number of people killed by so-called "Red Terror"

Look how many famines occured in Ethiopia: its worse one lead to 1 million deaths There are famines constantly, they still happen today: Theres the 2017 South Sudan Famine and the Yemen Famine 2016-present and then there was that Food crisis in 2005-06 which left millions vulnerable to food insecurity.

The American Slave trade resulted in 1.2-2.4 million dying during the voyage and about 5 million more died in seasoning camps in the Caribbean. Millions more died as a result of slave raids, wars, etc. Thats at least 8 million

Lets discuss genocides committed by capitalist countries or under capitalist rule

The Herero and Namaqua Genocide: genocide against indigeneous people in German Colony of Southwest Africa to gain access to their land. 35k to 100k dead

Rwandan Genocide at least 500k dead

The Assyrian Genocide

Armenian Genocide: 600k to 1.5 million dead

Many examples of massacres where leftists and other citizens were killed

Srebrenica massacre: 10k dead

Bodo League Massacre: 60k to 200k dead all communists and communist sympathizers

Thammasat University Massacre

Jeju Uprising

Red Drum Killings

US labor disputes where workers fought for better rights against capitalists interests. Often at least 50 people were killed in many of these disputes

Look at all these other wars started in the name of capitalism

Anglo-Zulu war 1879: War between Zulu and British over already claimed Zuzuland.

First Boer War and Second Boer War: high in civilian casualties, war following a Boer ultimatum that the British cease building up forces in the region and stop expanding British Rule

Second Congo War

Dirty War: A part of operation condor, during which military and right wing death squads hunted down political dissidents, anyone associated with leftism inlcuding students, militia, trade unionists, writers, journalists, etc. About 9000-30,000 people were killed/disappeared. Operation condor was a US backed terrorist campaign and some estimates say lead to at least 60,000 deaths.

Salvadoran Civil War: Included deliberate terrorizing and targeting of civilians by US trained government death squads including clergymen, recruimtment of child soldiers, and other human rights violations. UN reports that the war killed more than 75,000 people and and unknown number of people disappeared. 4 years into the 12 year war, US officers had top positions in the Salvadoran military, directly running the war.

Chiliean Coup 1973: desposed of popular president Aalvador Allende, Pinochet seized power. Pinochet's US supported regime was known for political suppresion and persecution. Operation Colombo: 1975 undertaken by Chiliean police, intended to make political dissidents disappear. 11,000 at least killed. Over 200,000 people exiled

Operation Menu: Cover US Strategic Air Command tactical bombing campaign conducted in eastern Cambodia. Speaking of Cambodia, apparently the US offered miltiary support to the Khmer rogue and was instrumental in preventing UN recognition of the vietnam-aligned government. They cared more about stopping Vietnamese communists than they cared about the atrocities commited by the Khmer Rogue, killing at least 1.5-2M people in the Cambodian Genocide.

Brazillian Coup: Overthrow of President Goulart by Brazilian Armed Forces supported by the US government.

1954 Guatemalan Coup: Occured after the Guatemalan revolution in 1944 which lead to the democratic election of Juan Arevalo who introduced the minimum wage, near-universal suffrage, and turned their country into a democracy. Then Arbenz was elected and made land reforms that benefited peasants. The United Fruit Company whose profitable business had been affected by the end to exploitative labor practices in Guatemala, engaged in influential lobbying campaign to persuade the US to overthrow them. So the coup was carried out by the US CIA, desposing of the democratically elected president, installing the military dictatorship of Carlos Armas.

There are a lot of coups guys, America loves attempting to overthrow governments. There was an American history post that might have covered most of this stuff. Capitalist countries love spreading freedom and democracy.

Should we include the war on terror or the considerable amount of people who died to COVID due to lack of healthcare or because they haven't managed to get a vaccine shot since capitalism oh so cares about the lives of people?

Here are some right wing dictators:

  • Alfredo Stroessner of Paraguay: Strongly free market, 90,000 people disappeared in a country, mass graves were found near Chaco River

  • Antonio Salazar of Portugal: totalitarian, people who criticized him disappeared, highly xenophobic, pro-colonialism

  • Mobutu Sese Seko of Zaire: totalitarian, robbed Zaire's wealth, responsible for the 2nd Congo war by proxy of the USA

  • Rafael Trujilo of Domanican Republic: capitalist, tens of thousands disappeared during regime

  • Francois Duvalier of Haiti: killed tens of thousands, strongly pro-market and anti-communist

  • Ngo Dinh Diem of South Vietnam: hundreds of thousands were tortured in executed especially Buddhists

  • Ferdinand Marcos of Philippines: close to 120,000 tortured and imprisoned, billions stolen from Filipino economy

  • Anastazio Somoza Debayle of Nicaragua: Autocrat, tens of thousands killed, tens of thousands disappeared, hundreds of thousands tortured and jailed, mass malnutrition and disease

I haven't even spent any time talking about the prisoners doing slave labor in many countries such as America. Or how many people die in these prisons. Even after they leave the prisons, many felons dont have voting rights, they are ineligible for government benefit programs like welfare and food stamps, they face barriers to find stable housing and employment. And they are taught very few skills relevant to the labor market so the 33 cents an hour they made is all they have, that is if their state pays them in the first place. Sounds like America has its own set of gulags.

Heres something interesting, since 2012, the US military has had astate-run and funded astroturfing campaign to manipulate public opinion online, and spread pro-US propaganda, calledOperation Earnest Voice. Sounds like "communist" China

Other useful links:

List of Atrocities commited by US authorities

More than 1.5 million people worldiwde die from preventable diseases each year, thats like 15 million every decade? 75 million every 50 years?

So if I were to be completely generous, only considering the last 50 years for preventable deaths due to poverty and disease, thats at least 400 million. At least 750 million over the last century alone. Then we can start adding all the death from everything I listed above. And it is impossible to quantify the amount of destruction countries western countries havee done by destroying democracy whereever they see fit. The amount of refugees and vicitms of war thanks to imperialist nations. The number of extreme weather events, dangerous wildfires and loss of biodiversity thanks to the self-interested nature of capitalism. The sheer amount of exploited workers around the globe that make YOUR lives go round. The only reason first world nations are doing so well is becuse they are riding on the backs of the global south, on the backs of overexploited nations.


r/CapitalismVSocialism • • Aug 05 '20

[Both sides] Can we agree Joe Biden is a bad candidate?

695 Upvotes

Joe Biden angered some leftist extremists, as he specifically addressed rioters in a statement, condemning “violence and destruction of property,” and calling for the prosecution of “arsonists and anarchists”.

https://summit.news/2020/07/30/leftists-freak-out-after-biden-calls-for-prosecution-of-arsonists-and-anarchists/

Former VP Joe Biden revealed that he has not taken the cognitive abilities test that President Trump spoke about last week and lashed out at CBS's Errol Barnett for asking about it.

Biden was taking part in an interview with a group of Black and Latino journalists.

"No, I haven’t taken a test. Why the hell would I take a test?" Biden replied. "C'mon man, that’s like saying, 'You — before you got on this program you took a test where you’re taking cocaine or not, what do you think? Huh? Are you a junkie?'"

"If he can’t figure out the difference between an elephant and a lion, I don’t know what the hell he’s talking about," Biden said laughing at Trump. "Look, c'mon man, I know you’re trying to goad me... And by the way, as I joked with -- you, know, I probably shouldn't say."

"I am willing to let the pubic judge my physical as well as mental fitness," he said.

https://www.realclearpolitics.com/video/2020/08/05/biden_snaps_at_reporter_why_the_hell_would_i_take_a_cognitive_test_are_you_a_junkie.html

So far looks bad for both sides of the political spectrum.


r/CapitalismVSocialism • • May 01 '20

Why we only talk about failed socialist states but never failed capitalist states?

675 Upvotes

Why we don't talk about weimar republic? Countless poor countries in africa, middle east, america's and asia? Im fact there is a lot more failed capitalist states than succesful. Why is it a fact that capitalism works when clearly it usually doesn't?


r/CapitalismVSocialism • • Jan 09 '18

Please Don't Downvote in this sub, here's why

670 Upvotes

So this sub started out because of another sub, called r/SocialismVCapitalism, and when that sub was quite new one of the mods there got in an argument with a reader and during the course of that argument the mod used their mod-powers to shut-up the person the mod was arguing against, by permanently-banning them.

Myself and a few others thought this was really uncool and set about to create this sub, a place where mods were not allowed to abuse their own mod-powers like that, and where free-speech would reign as much as Reddit would allow.

And the experiment seems to have worked out pretty well so far.

But there is one thing we cannot control, and that is how you guys vote.

Because this is a sub designed to be participated in by two groups that are oppositional, the tendency is to downvote conversations and people and opionions that you disagree with.

The problem is that it's these very conversations that are perhaps the most valuable in this sub.

It would actually help if people did the opposite and upvoted both everyone they agree with AND everyone they disagree with.

I also need your help to fight back against those people who downvote, if you see someone who has been downvoted to zero or below, give them an upvote back to 1 if you can.

We experimented in the early days with hiding downvotes, delaying their display, etc., etc., and these things did not seem to materially improve the situation in the sub so we stopped. There is no way to turn off downvoting on Reddit, it's something we have to live with. And normally this works fine in most subs, but in this sub we need your help, if everyone downvotes everyone they disagree with, then that makes it hard for a sub designed to be a meeting-place between two opposing groups.

So, just think before you downvote. I don't blame you guys at all for downvoting people being assholes, rule-breakers, or topics that are dumb topics, but especially in the comments try not to downvotes your fellow readers simply for disagreeing with you, or you them. And help us all out and upvote people back to 1, even if you disagree with them.

Thank guys!


Edit: Remember Graham's Hierarchy of Disagreement:

https://imgur.com/FHIsH8a.png


r/CapitalismVSocialism • • Oct 08 '20

[feudalists] Strange women laying in ponds distributing swords is no basis for a system of government.

655 Upvotes

Your ideology rests on the belief that The Lady of the Lake, her arm clad in the purest shimmering samite, held aloft Excalibur from the bosom of the water signifying by Divine Providence that Arthur was to carry Excalibur. And that is why he was king!

This is absurd. Supreme executive power derives from a mandate from the masses, not from some farcical aquatic ceremony. You can't expect to wield supreme executive power just 'cause some watery tart threw a sword at you!

I mean, if I went around sayin' I was an empereror just because some moistened bink had lobbed a scimitar at me they'd put me away!

So now we've got a king, eh, very nice. An' how'd we get that, eh? By exploitin' the workers -- by 'angin' on to outdated imperialist dogma which perpetuates the economic an' social differences in our society! In reality feudalism is a dictatorship. A self-perpetuating autocracy in which the working classes are repressed.

Those on the periphery of your system live in an autonomous collective. An anarcho-syndicalist commune. They take it in turns to act as a sort of executive officer for the week. But all the decisions of that officer have to be ratified at a special biweekly meeting. By a simple majority in the case of purely internal affairs -but by a two-thirds majority in the case of more fundamental structural matters.

Of course when peasants insist on this arrangement they are met only with physical resistance. There we see the violence inherent in the system.


r/CapitalismVSocialism • • Sep 14 '20

The government doing things is not socialism

643 Upvotes

It is truly insane how often I see this take repeated here. It's become almost comical. FYI:

  • Public services are not socialism

  • Free healthcare is not socialism

  • High taxes are not socialism

  • Government investing in technology is not socialism

  • Government bailing out companies is not socialism

  • Sweden is not socialist

  • Denmark is not socialist

  • Germany is not socialist

  • Canada is not socialist

  • Cooperatives are not socialist

This has been a friendly PSA.


r/CapitalismVSocialism • • Jun 07 '21

To those who defend the USA, know what you are defending.

626 Upvotes

The United States of America is a brutal nation run by an ideological elite who, in the pursuit of their "utopia", murdered 30-40 million people based on their ethnicity and nation, and enslaved 10s of millions more for their profits.

I am glad to see that those who defend the USA as a success are in the minority here but they exist, and this is meant for them, to show that regardless of your ideology, no side, left or right, fascist or communist can't commit horrific crimes.


r/CapitalismVSocialism • • Feb 28 '19

How would anime be produced in a communist society ?

589 Upvotes

Anime requires long hours to produce the animation and voice actors, writers , ect. There are attempts to get people to work on projects as a community for free to bring animation to life but usually fail.

If people aren't paid how are we going to motivate them to produce our anime.

This is what I call the Anime Theory of Failure. Which states people will not produce anime without money incentive thus communism fails us


r/CapitalismVSocialism • • Jul 27 '21

A capitalist Country with a welfare state is NOT socialist

579 Upvotes

Just a friendly reminder. Lots of stupid people these days have colloquially used “socialism” for things that it’s not

Socialism =/= social programs :)

“The confusion today is that people, embarrassed by the utter failure of socialism in the real world, have tried to reuse that term by applying it to capitalist economies with welfare states that they like. So it is like the term "liberal" today, where it can mean quite different things depending on the context. Using either term, without definition, leads to pointless arguments.”


r/CapitalismVSocialism • • Nov 12 '20

Why do people on here call out fallacies like they're Yu-Gi-Oh Cards?

578 Upvotes

I will just scroll through the comments and there are always some people calling out fallacies like they're fucking Yu-Gi-Oh cards and it hurts my soul.

"I PLAY NO TRUE SCOTSMAN AND BLOCK YOUR ATTACK AS YOU ARE CLAIMING THAT TIT IS NOT TAT DESPITE TIT BEING CAPABLE OF TATTING AND DO 500 POINTS OF DAMAGE!"

"I SUMMON STRAWMAN FROM THE BONEYARD AND COUNTERATTACK AND DO 1000 POINTS OF DAMAGE AS YOU ARE OVER EXAGGERATING! I SAID TIT IS NOT TAT BECAUSE WHILE TIT IS INDEED CAPABLE OF TATTING IT IS NOT IN ITS NATURE TO TAT AND IS THUS NOT TAT IN AND OF ITSELF!"


r/CapitalismVSocialism • • Oct 16 '19

The Definitive Capitalism vs. Socialism Rap Battle: MISES vs. MARX

Thumbnail
youtube.com
577 Upvotes

r/CapitalismVSocialism • • Feb 08 '20

These studies suggest that becoming a billionaire (or successful CEO) is largely a matter of luck.

575 Upvotes

“I begin my course in strategic management by asking all the students in the room to stand up,” she says. “I then ask each of them to toss a coin. If the toss comes up tails, they are to sit down, but if it comes up heads, they are to remain standing. Since there are around 70 students in the class, after six or seven rounds there is only one student left standing. With the appropriate theatrics, I approach the student and say, ‘How did you do that? Seven heads in a row! Can I interview you in Fortune? Is it the T-shirt? Is it the flick of the wrist? Can I write a case study about you?’”

Professor Rebecca Henderson


It appears from the following statistical studies and simulations that excelling in the current market economy is largely a matter of luck. I am curious if anyone has some empirical study to counter this.


Study 1:

When I started looking into this I was just wondering

1: If CEO's were actually worth what they were being paid. If not how rational are shareholders really?

2: If business schools and elite job history were predictive of success in executives.

3: Whether a CEO's record had bearing on future performance (if it didn't then CEO are not really in control, they just ride waves).

The 2nd and 3rd question would answer the 1st. So let us start with number 2

According to this analysis by Institutional Investor

We tagged CEOs by the MBA programs they attended, formed monthly portfolios of companies broken down by the business school each CEO attended, and compared the returns of these portfolios to the broader market. "

"We found no statistically significant alphas — despite testing every possible school with a reasonable sample size. MBA programs simply do not produce CEOs who are better at running companies, if performance is measured by stock price return."

We ran similar regressions controlling for industry and found that — even after controlling for industry — elite MBAs did not produce positive statistically significant alpha.

" Elite MBAs did perform relatively well as CEOs in healthcare and consumer staples, but relatively poorly in energy and materials businesses, though those results were not statistically significant. Our study is not the only one to come to this conclusion. A study by economists at the University of Hawaii asked similar questions and found that firm performance is not predicted by the educational background of the CEOs."

The perceived quality of each institution appeared to have no correlation with stock price returns. Northwestern led with an alpha of 0.58 percent per month. Stanford eked out a barely positive alpha of 0.03 percent per month. Harvard and Wharton had negative alphas of -0.15 percent and -0.19 percent, respectively, per month.

"These rankings likely occurred by sheer chance"

So to summarize. They found no statistically significant correlation between the attendance of elite MBA programs and the performance of firms run by the alumni of those programs.

They also looked at whether having previously been part of an elite consulting firm (e.g. Mckinsey) or investment bank (e.g. Goldman Sachs) had any bearing on the success of company the CEO was running.

We thus formed monthly portfolios for bankers and consultants. As we did with MBAs, we then ran industry-controlled Fama-French three-factor regressions. The result: Neither bankers nor consultants produced statistically significant alphas. We also back-tested portfolios designed to favor ex-bankers and consultants and found no significant edge (though consultants had a statistically insignificant edge on bankers).

This suggests that the “best and brightest” do not have a statistically significant edge when it comes to managing public companies. An elite pedigree — the type of pedigree favored by headhunters and corporate boards — is not predictive of superior management

-On to question 3-

*Is CEO performance persistent? Are some people simply better managers, able to consistently generate high returns for investors? And can we identify these people based on an examination of their track records? *

We looked first at performance persistence within companies: whether a CEO’s early track record predicts later performance. We filtered our database for CEOs who had tenures longer than six years at one company. We then separated each CEO’s return record into two buckets: Years 1–3 and Years 4–6. To eliminate the confounding effect of different market conditions, we adjusted returns by the performance of the S&P 500 index. Within each of the two time-horizon buckets, we sorted the CEOs’ market-adjusted returns into quartiles. We then identified the CEOs who were above the median twice and those who were in the top quartile twice.

To interpret the results, it’s important to consider what we would expect to see by random chance.

Similar to a coin flip, 50 percent of CEOs should be above-average performers, and 50 percent of CEOs should be below-average over each three-year time horizon. And just as a coin has a 25 percent chance of landing on heads twice in a row (50 percent x 50 percent), we should expect 25 percent of CEOs to be above average in both Years 1–3 and Years 4–6, purely by chance. But if we were to believe that CEO performance is always persistent, we would expect to see 50 percent of CEOs perform above average in the two successive three-year periods (50 percent x 100 percent).

A similar calculation would apply to the top-quartile CEOs. If every CEO randomly has a 25 percent chance of being in the top quartile over a three-year period, then we should expect about 6 percent of CEOs to be in the top quartile in two successive three-year periods (25 percent x 25 percent) due to luck alone. If, however, there is full performance persistence, then 25 percent of CEOs would be in the top quartile in Years 1–3 and Years 4–6.

The actual CEO performance results line up very closely with what we would expect to see by chance.

Twenty-five percent of the 2,420 CEOs in our database had above-average performance in two successive three-year periods, and 7 percent of CEOs had top-quartile performance in two successive three-year periods.

They also analysed the performance of CEO's who had run multiple companies.

Once again, there is little to no persistence in CEO performance from one company to the next. Again, these results held when controlling for industry and the Fama-French factors.

The proportion of CEOs who continue to perform well is in line with what we would expect under random conditions.


Study 2:

The previous study had answered my questions in the negative. This lead to follow up questions which drew on my prior knowledge of the proportion of failure in businesses in 3 years. The question I sought to answer this time was whether very successful companies were really just lucky.

I found this article from Harvard Business Review.

**We can credibly claim that a firm is remarkable only when its performance is so unlikely that systemic variation alone cannot account for its results. **

Most success studies don’t address this fact, relying instead on the “self-evident” nature of exceptional performance.

"To understand how lucky some firms might get because of systemic variation alone, we looked at the performance of a broad sample of companies traded on U.S. exchanges from 1966 to 2006—more than 230,000 company years’ worth of data."

We ranked each company’s performance in each year by deciles (0 to 9) and observed the frequency of transitions between deciles. Using that frequency to estimate the probability that an unexceptional firm would move from one decile to another simply because of systemic variation, we ran simulations that gave us a picture of how firms might do if they differed only in their luck. Finally, we compared actual results with simulated results, which allowed us to determine which firms had delivered performance so unlikely that it was probably due to something remarkable about them.

"Using this method, we evaluated 287 allegedly high-performing companies in 13 major success studies. We found that only about one in four of those firms was likely to be remarkable; the rest were indistinguishable from mediocre firms catching lucky breaks. By our method, even in the study with the best hit rate, only slightly more than half the high performers had profiles that were credibly attributable to something special about the firms. "

This means the difference between a mediocre firm and big firm that ends up employing 1000s is largely a matter of random chance.


Study 3:

😕But what about billionaires then? I asked. Presumably the most common way to be a self made billionaire is to be a CEO(or equivalent) of a successful company you have a large share in. If being a CEO is a mostly matter of luck and having a successful company is a matter of luck, would one not be compelled to assume that becoming a billionaire is a matter of luck?

So I searched that on google and found this article from MIT Technology Review which referred to a simulation which had been made pertaining to power law distributions we observe in real life and whether they entail a natural meritocracy.

Today we get an answer thanks to the work of Alessandro Pluchino at the University of Catania in Italy and a couple of colleagues. These guys have created a computer model of human talent and the way people use it to exploit opportunities in life. The model allows the team to study the role of chance in this process.

"The results are something of an eye-opener. Their simulations accurately reproduce the wealth distribution in the real world. But the wealthiest individuals are not the most talented (although they must have a certain level of talent). They are the luckiest. "

Pluchino and co’s model is straightforward. It consists of N people, each with a certain level of talent (skill, intelligence, ability, and so on). This talent is distributed normally around some average level, with some standard deviation. So some people are more talented than average and some are less so, but nobody is orders of magnitude more talented than anybody else.

"This is the same kind of distribution seen for various human skills, or even characteristics like height or weight. Some people are taller or smaller than average, but nobody is the size of an ant or a skyscraper. Indeed, we are all quite similar."

The computer model charts each individual through a working life of 40 years. During this time, the individuals experience lucky events that they can exploit to increase their wealth if they are talented enough.

"However, they also experience unlucky events that reduce their wealth. These events occur at random."

At the end of the 40 years, Pluchino and co rank the individuals by wealth and study the characteristics of the most successful. They also calculate the wealth distribution. They then repeat the simulation many times to check the robustness of the outcome.

When the team rank individuals by wealth, the distribution is exactly like that seen in real-world societies. “The ‘80-20’ rule is respected,

"Since 80 percent of the population owns only 20 percent of the total capital, while the remaining 20 percent owns 80 percent of the same capital,” report Pluchino and co."

"That may not be surprising or unfair if the wealthiest 20 percent turn out to be the most talented. But that isn’t what happens. The wealthiest individuals are typically not the most talented or anywhere near it. “The maximum success never coincides with the maximum talent, and vice-versa,” say the researchers."

So if not talent, what other factor causes this skewed wealth distribution? “Our simulation clearly shows that such a factor is just pure luck,” say Pluchino and co.

"The team shows this by ranking individuals according to the number of lucky and unlucky events they experience throughout their 40-year careers."

“It is evident that the most successful individuals are also the luckiest ones,” they say. “And the less successful individuals are also the unluckiest ones.”


So these 3 studies appear to indicate empirically and mathematically that billionaires and probably multimillionaires are mostly just lucky. One can have a few philosophical conclusions to this. For example that the free market does not ensure that people who deserve wealth get wealth. It may undermine the personal responsibility theory of poverty. It may even justify taxing the wealthy.

All that aside, even an Apriori argument can be used here.

If you assume that 1) determinism is true, then you have to assume

2) If determinism is true, then the everything that happens to us is a function of the possible universe we are in. If we were in another possible universe, then things would be different.

3: We could have been in another possible universe, and we have no choice about what possible universe we are in. If you believe in God, god could have have put you in another possible universe.

4: So the fact that we are in this universe is a matter of luck (whether good or bad) and everything we have done and every idea we have had follows from that.

5: 4 is true for all possible humans, including millionaires, multimillionaires, billionaires and heads of state. All human outcomes are a chiefly a matter of luck.

6: If any human gains success by luck, then they did not earn that success.

Therefore

7: No human has earned their success.

Therefore

8: No human billionaire has earned their wealth.

This conclusion, if true, could undermine some theories of private property, I think. It can also significantly undermine meritocracy based justifications for the current wealth distribution.

Feel free to dispute the premises of the above argument, I will refine accordingly. But please address the empirical studies first.