r/SocialismVCapitalism • • Feb 08 '21

For anyone who is afraid of Socialism

111 Upvotes

For-profit businesses did not-

  • free the slaves

  • land on the moon

  • provide free k-12 education

  • invent the internet

  • invent gps

  • do the particle physics behind today’s modern devices

  • build the interstate system

  • create National Forests and Parks (or state and local parks)

  • regulate fish and game to ensure sustainability

  • pioneer weather forecasting or launch a single weather satellite

  • build the hoover dam or any public water management systems

  • provide public safety (police, fire, etc)

  • support food safety regulations

  • support worker safety laws

  • give us the 5 day, 40 hour work week

  • create the public library system

  • protect the environment

  • enact a minimum wage

  • give us the social security system

  • do the basic research vaccines and medications are based on

  • provide a social safety net for people who can’t work

  • provide affordable healthcare with the world’s best outcomes

For-profit businesses did-

  • buy off our elected officials

  • turn mass media into a propaganda machine

  • outsource and automate millions of middle class jobs

  • devastate fisheries

  • destabilize the climate

  • lie about climate change

  • lead us into several illegal profit wars

  • increase the cost of college tuition 8x faster than wages

  • turn houses into investments

  • oppose living wages

  • oppose worker rights

  • oppose environmental regulation

  • exploit tax payer funded innovation

  • try to privatize water

  • try to privatize social security

  • try to exploit resources on public land

  • turn our justice system into a for-profit enterprise

  • lie to you about how we got to this point


r/SocialismVCapitalism • • Nov 06 '20

[Capitalists] Do you consider deaths and attrocities under capitalism just as you consider them under socialism?

70 Upvotes

If we're gonna play the numbers game, millions of people starve to death every year under global capitalism. That's millions of preventable deaths every year, in total far outnumbering deaths due to starvation under socialist countries. And if we're gonna blame socialism for the attrocities of the USSR and Maoist China, then surely we should also blame capitalism for the attrocities of the United States (all the war crimes, imperialism, slavery, and discrimination,) and of course all the attrocities done by capitalist fascist regimes such as the Nazis and Pinochet's Chile. Why the double standard?


r/SocialismVCapitalism • • Jul 02 '21

If capitalism is so good, then why are we at the brink of no return in climate change. Why has the "invisible hand" failed to promote eco-friendly technology. Why has the competative market failed to create millions, even billions, of jobs for mass production of such tech at an affordable price?

59 Upvotes

title :)


r/SocialismVCapitalism • • Jan 26 '19

Why is it that we see democracy as the ideal political system, yet the default company structure is close to being authoritarian

45 Upvotes

r/SocialismVCapitalism • • May 28 '20

The World's First Trillionaire and the 553,000 Homeless

42 Upvotes

PODCAST - Jeff Bezos is on track to be worth more than one trillion dollars by the year 2026. That's one trillion. With a capital "T". Meanwhile, the United States' homeless population hits 553,000. The top 1/10 of 1% now own more wealth than the bottom 90%. This is not the product of Jeff Bezos' "genius" or the "laziness" of the homeless. It is the product of a system that permissively allows for this to happen.

https://open.spotify.com/episode/0wJcJ3jQQQYbrehv4JyfCm?si=INPhySHWSHyIwz8Kya_bYw


r/SocialismVCapitalism • • Aug 13 '20

Corporate bailouts are a crime against humanity

37 Upvotes

That is all


r/SocialismVCapitalism • • Jun 22 '21

Capitalists: Pharmaceutical companies should be nationalized, there is no evidence that having privately owned pharmaceutical companies is more efficient, what are your thoughts

31 Upvotes

r/SocialismVCapitalism • • Sep 26 '20

Radicalize Me Podcast

30 Upvotes

Hey everyone, I humbly offer my podcast, Radicalize Me. I interview activists about what they do, how they got started, and how you can too! It's turning me into an anarcho-communist, but capitalists, you're welcome to listen and tell me how wrong I am. Enjoy!

https://anchor.fm/radicalizeme


r/SocialismVCapitalism • • Mar 24 '20

Should we be sacrificing the lives of the elderly, immunocompromised, and poor for "the good of the market?"

27 Upvotes

Lt Gov of Texas, Dan Patrick said on Tucker Carlton's show, "are you willing to take a chance on your survival in exchange for keeping the America that all America loves for your children and grandchildren? And if that's the exchange I'm all in."

So, capitalists, what's more important: American lives, or the American economy?


r/SocialismVCapitalism • • May 20 '20

Paul Field explains what current state of things reveals ...

26 Upvotes

Everyone is entitled to their own opinion, but you need to know how silly you look if you post some variation of, "Welcome to Socialism..."

You are not seeing Socialism. What you are seeing is one of the wealthiest, geographically advantaged, productive capitalist societies in the world flounder and fail at its most basic test. Taking care of its people.

This crisis is not about the virus.

This crisis is about the massive failure of our, "Booming economy," to survive even modest challenges. It is about the market dissonance of shortages in stores, even as farmers/producers destroy unused crops and products. This crisis is about huge corporations needing an emergency bailout within days of the longest Bull Market in our history ending and despite the ability to borrow with zero percent interest rates.

This crisis is about corporatized healthcare systems being unable and ill equipped to provide basic healthcare, at the same time they post record profits. It is about crisis response depending on antiquated systems nobody remembers how to operate.

But most of all, this crisis is a direct result of the politicization of every aspect of our society for the benefit of a privileged few. The vilification of education, science, media, natural rights, rural lifestyles, urban lifestyles, charity, compassion, and virtually everything else for brief political gain has gutted our society.

What you are seeing is a quarter century of technological brilliance being reduced to a narcissistic popularity contest. You're seeing the folly of basing the health and welfare of an entire society on personal greed. You're seeing all the necessary tools, for us to shrug off this crisis, go unused while people argue over who should get the credit and profit. Even worse, you're seeing vital help withheld because recipients might not, "deserve it..."

You're seeing a lot of things nobody thought they'd ever see, but you're not seeing Socialism...

"Doing nothing for others is the undoing of ourselves."
-- Horace Mann


r/SocialismVCapitalism • • Dec 27 '20

Visualization of wealth inequality in the US, and what could be done with a wealth tax

25 Upvotes

r/SocialismVCapitalism • • Nov 14 '20

Do Landlords Perpetuate Poverty?

25 Upvotes

Edit: Does the existence of landlords perpetuate poverty? (I understand that if someone decided to rent out their spare room for below market price they would be marginally alleviating poverty, but as long as landlords aim to maximize profits, I believe they’re perpetuating poverty)

I think to support the continued existence of landlords you have to disagree with at least one of these statements:

  1. The goal of renting out your private property is to profit as much as possible

  2. Landlords profit by charging as much as possible for rent

  3. Charging as much as possible for rent keeps rent high

  4. Keeping rent as high as possible makes it incredibly difficult for renters to put their paychecks towards savings (especially with employers keeping wages as low as possible)

  5. When renters can't save enough to buy their own property they have to keep renting

  6. It is in a landlord's best interest to keep their renters poor

  7. Landlords perpetuate poverty

  8. Perpetuating poverty is bad

I'm hoping someone will argue against these statements to point out their flaws so I can improve them.

I don't think every person who is a landlord is a bad person, I just think it's bad that they're profiting off of keeping people poor. Decommodifying housing shifts the goal from "profit as much as possible" to "house as many people as possible", which combats poverty instead of perpetuating it.


r/SocialismVCapitalism • • May 05 '21

Questions for capitalists: Do you acknowledge/see any problems with capitalism? (Not trolling)

24 Upvotes

In my experience, just ≈every capitalist believes that capitalism is a universal constant. By that I mean that they cannot even comprehend the idea of altering capitalism (social safety net) or moving beyond it. As a capitalist do you see any problems with capitalism?

Not looking for NPC talking points (100 million dead from communism, capitalism has lifted more people out of poverty..., socialism is when no iPhone)


r/SocialismVCapitalism • • Dec 04 '19

Why capitalists call everything under the sun "socialism"

24 Upvotes

From The Eighteenth Brumaire. The immediate context is the reaction of Bonapartists in the French National Assembly in 1849, a year after Louis Napoleon's election to the French Presidency.

Whatever amount of passion and declamation might be employed by the party of Order against the minority from the tribune of the National Assembly, its speech remained as monosyllabic as that of the Christians, whose words were to be: Yea, yea; nay, nay! As monosyllabic on the platform as in the press. Flat as a riddle whose answer is known in advance. Whether it was a question of the right of petition or the tax on wine, freedom of the press or free trade, the clubs or the municipal charter, protection of personal liberty or regulation of the state budget, the watchword constantly recurs, the theme remains always the same, the verdict is ever ready and invariably reads: "Socialism!"

This phenomenon ought to be familiar to basically anyone alive in an Anglosphere country today. It constitutes practically the whole of political discourse at this time.

Marx goes on.

Even bourgeois liberalism is declared socialistic, bourgeois enlightenment socialistic, bourgeois financial reform socialistic. It was socialistic to build a railway where a canal already existed, and it was socialistic to defend oneself with a cane when one was attacked with a rapier.

But why? After all, surely some capitalist interests must benefit from bourgeois "socialistic" measures, no? Even reactionaries acknowledge this, under the alternate term "crony capitalism".

Marx posits an objective, empirical cause for this phenomenon.

This was not merely a figure of speech, fashion, or party tactics. The bourgeoisie had a true insight into the fact that all the weapons it had forged against feudalism turned their points against itself, that all the means of education it had produced rebelled against its own civilization, that all the gods it had created had fallen away from it. It understood that all the so-called bourgeois liberties and organs of progress attacked and menaced its class rule at its social foundation and its political summit simultaneously, and had therefore become "socialistic." In this menace and this attack it rightly discerned the secret of socialism, whose import and tendency it judges more correctly than so-called socialism knows how to judge itself; the latter can, accordingly, not comprehend why the bourgeoisie callously hardens its heart against it, whether it sentimentally bewails the sufferings of mankind, or in Christian spirit prophesies the millennium and universal brotherly love, or in humanistic style twaddles about mind, education, and freedom, or in doctrinaire fashion invents a system for the conciliation and welfare of all classes.

Engels goes on about this phenomenon at some length in §III of Socialism: Utopian & Scientific:

https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1880/soc-utop/ch03.htm

This rebellion of the productive forces, as they grow more and more powerful, against their quality as capital, this stronger and stronger command that their social character shall be recognized, forces the capital class itself to treat them more and more as social productive forces, so far as this is possible under capitalist conditions.

The phenomenon of recognizing the productive forces "more and more as social productive forces" is not unfamiliar to us today. Consider for example the internecine debates surrounding the role of Facebook and social media in bourgeois elections - previously these had been seen as nothing more than quiet places to generate ad revenue. Now they are recognized as a social force in themself.

Engels continues:

Many of these means of production and of distribution are, from the outset, so colossal that, like the railways, they exclude all other forms of capitalistic expansion. At a further stage of evolution, this form also becomes insufficient. The producers on a large scale in a particular branch of an industry in a particular country unite in a "Trust", a union for the purpose of regulating production... In the trusts, freedom of competition changes into its very opposite — into monopoly; and the production without any definite plan of capitalistic society capitulates to the production upon a definite plan of the invading socialistic society. Certainly, this is so far still to the benefit and advantage of the capitalists. But, in this case, the exploitation is so palpable, that it must break down. No nation will put up with production conducted by trusts, with so barefaced an exploitation of the community by a small band of dividend-mongers.

This can be seen at work today again with respect to the example of Facebook - even the "libertarian" Rght are increasingly calling for regulatory intervention against social media, e.g.:

https://townhall.com/columnists/kurtschlichter/2017/08/14/conservatives-must-regulate-google-and-all-of-silicon-valley-into-submission-n2368118

There’s sometimes a moment when a system is unstable because one participant has changed the rules, but the other side hasn't yet reacted – like the period after feminism demanded total female social equality with men, but men still generally picked up the check. That imbalance cannot persist forever; eventually the people on the other side feel like suckers, so they stop playing by the old rules. That’s when the new rules arise. And that's why conservatives now need to savagely regulate companies like Google, Facebook, and Twitter. We need to use our political power in Congress and red state legislatures to incentivize Silicon Valley to return to a system where its companies embrace political and cultural neutrality, or suffer crippling consequences.

To continue with the Eighteenth Brumaire:

What the bourgeoisie did not grasp, however, was the logical conclusion that its own parliamentary regime, its political rule in general, was now also bound to meet with the general verdict of condemnation as being socialistic. As long as the rule of the bourgeois class had not been completely organized, as long as it had not acquired its pure political expression, the antagonism of the other classes likewise could not appear in its pure form, and where it did appear could not take the dangerous turn that transforms every struggle against the state power into a struggle against capital. If in every stirring of life in society it saw "tranquillity" imperiled, how could it want to maintain at the head of society a regime of unrest, its own regime, the parliamentary regime, this regime that, according to the expression of one of its spokesmen, lives in struggle and by struggle? The parliamentary regime lives by discussion, how shall it forbid discussion? Every interest, every social institution, is here transformed into general ideas, debated as ideas; how shall any interest, any institution, sustain itself above thought and impose itself as an article of faith? The struggle of the orators on the platform evokes the struggle of the scribblers of the press; the debating club in parliament is necessarily supplemented by debating clubs in the salons and the bistros; the representatives, who constantly appeal to public opinion, give public opinion the right to speak its real mind in petitions. The parliamentary regime leaves everything to the decision of majorities; how shall the great majorities outside parliament not want to decide? When you play the fiddle at the top of the state, what else is to be expected but that those down below dance?

This, I think, explains in a nutshell most of the political phenomena at work today: Capital has begun to be aware of the potentiality for facilitating social revolution in the instruments it has produced for its own rule.

Reactionary capitalists do not sincerely believe Google, Facebook etc. are socialist in themselves. But they do perceive something in them that, as Engels says of State capitalism, "concealed within it are the technical conditions that form the elements of that solution (to class strggle)".


r/SocialismVCapitalism • • Jan 03 '19

If (according to capitalists) socialists must admit that they created Stalin, why don’t capitalists admit that they created Hitler?

24 Upvotes

This video put this thought in my head. https://youtu.be/ntsByrhGhb0


r/SocialismVCapitalism • • Mar 31 '21

I am beginning to suspect IP rights hurt the economy and are a symptom of capitalism gone Amok.

22 Upvotes

My reasoning is based on this article from Electronic Freedom Foundation.


r/SocialismVCapitalism • • Dec 23 '20

When Capitalism is Under Threat It's Not So Free - Polish Communist Party Faces BAN: Interview With Polish Communists About Their Legal Struggle

22 Upvotes

The Polish Communist Party has been facing legal persecution for years at the hands of the state - led by the right-wing populist Law & Order Party. Providing us with more insight into the situation is Polish Communist Party co-founder Marcin Adam and member of the Party's Control Committee Bartosz Bieszczad.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xknoVDlkEo0&list=PLPQ9l31hIsNFqFPGxKrf-wGR3-RaHuB2Z&index=5

Make sure to subscribe to TheRevolutionReport for more content!


r/SocialismVCapitalism • • Jul 01 '18

Marx remains the accepted authority on the analysis of capitalism and the way forward as it collapses

21 Upvotes

Every socialist and every communist in my experience declares themselves "Marxist". Every communist party that led a revolutionary war declared themselves to be "Marxist". So any question about what, exactly, socialism is, or communism is, would be answered by quoting or referencing Marx.

Marx analyzed capitalism, but he also revealed the consequences of class society and the succession of class societies as they methodically led from one to another beginning with ancient slave societies, through feudalism, to capitalism, and then he pointed beyond. He said little about how socialism would be organized, structured, or function but he analyzed and discussed the transitions based on class interests and class analysis.

His class analysis remains the weapon of choice of those who would replace capitalism with a new system today. And he remains the authority on the class structure of socialism and how communism will one day evolve from socialism. And yet I see great confusion on this forum regarding these very basic issues.

I therefore propose that we discuss socialism, what it is based on according to Marx, and communism and what it is based on according to Marx; the difference between the two, and get our definitions and facts straight on them so we can communicate more effectively. I think it's time we came together on the most simple, most fundamental two subjects of socialism and communism so we can intelligently discuss them as possible alternatives to capitalism.

(Flamebaiting and trolling will be ignored.)


r/SocialismVCapitalism • • Feb 22 '24

A country that can’t absorb immigrants is a bad country

20 Upvotes

Conservatives talk a lot about how much of business geniuses they are and how materialist they are , yet shit their pants at the idea of millions of new workers coming to America . In a logical world , we could build these new people cities and put them to work and train their kids to be inventors and scientists . In America , on the other hand , we use the government to try and stop peoples natural freedom of movement and work because we have shit so backwards that it actually HURTS us to have more people wanting to work here.

Sorry but that’s called being bad at doing countries .

Not being able to absorb the poor people your empire creates is actually a big ass reason Rome fell into IMPERIUM.

I’m not saying other people have invented this , cause I can’t pretend . No country is good at this . China isn’t good at this either .

But , I think as a human race we should probably get good at this (number 1) I think it would be good for all of civilization to get better at absorbing immigrants and building cities quickly . Number 2, this would require the government to lead the way and have poor working peoples interest in mind , in which the investment thereupon will reap centuries of fruits and riches .


r/SocialismVCapitalism • • Apr 02 '20

Neoliberalism and unfettered market capitalism to blame for delayed COVID19 response?

20 Upvotes

Clearly, this crisis reveals an ugly truth about the free market, that corporations have the authority to make decisions from observations like that there isn’t profit in preventing catastrophes.

The weight of these decisions are evident. Failures like the lack of ventilators.

The Department of Health and Human Services actually foresaw the problem, and contracted with a small firm to produce inexpensive, easy-to-use ventilators.

But then capitalist logic intervened.

The firm was bought by a major corporation, Covidien, which sidelined the project, and in 2014, with no ventilators having been delivered to the government, Covidien executives told officials at the biomedical research agency that they wanted to get out of the contract, according to three former federal officials. The executives complained that it was not sufficiently profitable for the company.

Neoliberal logic then intervened, dictating that the government could not act to overcome the gross market failure, which is now causing havoc.

THE SURVIVAL OF HUMANITY IS AT RISK ON OUR CURRENT COURSE.

PROFITABLE SUSTAINABLE ENERGY PROJECTS ARE NOT BEING PURSUED BECAUSE THERES MORE PROFIT TO BE MADE DESTROYING LIFE ON EARTH.

Not a soul can refute this: Milton Friedman was WRONG that the task of corporate managers is to maximize profits, where any deviation from this moral obligation would shatter the foundations of “civilized life.”

My question is, how can free market capitalism possibly be rationalized even in the midst of a global crisis it failed to respond adequately to?


r/SocialismVCapitalism • • May 18 '21

Someone I know keeps saying liberals, communists, and socialists all believe in the same ideology. How do I explain to them the main differences in simple terms?

19 Upvotes

I'm also asking because as someone who's both autistic & ADHD....politics are extremely hard to get into. I look up what a certain thing is and then I see like 8 words that I don't understand and then I have to look up what those words mean but then I feel confused and like I don't know what I'm doing. I want to get into them because I want to do what's right and I want to fight for what's right, but damn my brain can't process a single thing and I don't want to fight without knowing what exactly I'm doing.

BUT, from the small amount that I do know ,, I know that I'm probably a socialist and that socialism is not that same as liberalism. I hear that liberal ideology is closer to center than leftist, but I never really understand 100% what liberal beliefs are other than on very niche topics.

Could it be explained to me so I can explain to said person what are the main beliefs that separates socialist beliefs from liberal beliefs (and then also communist beliefs if it's alright)?

( I'm also asking because said person called me and my friends liberals during an argument and we all thought if was really funny but never got the chance to correct him )

Prooobably gonna sound really out-of-place posting this but I'll give it a shot anyways!


r/SocialismVCapitalism • • Mar 30 '21

Space X would be better under Socialism

19 Upvotes

Big fan of space exploration here. Keeping my fingers crossed for a major socialist revolution hopefully soon. We would've gotten to Mars already if SpaceX was absorbed and run by the state, with workers able to vote on all decisions with decentralized leadership, that way everyone would feel invested and included and be happier in their work and more productive. I'm frustrated that Elon Musk, a greedy capitalist with low IQ, is failing spectacularly with all rockets blowing up who would want to get on a starship? Am I right? Don't you think the state would be more innovative, cost efficient, and far more productive if they could absorb Space X and jail Musk for labor theft?


r/SocialismVCapitalism • • Dec 09 '20

Have you seen a capitalist argue against socialism/communism WITHOUT using straw-mans?

19 Upvotes

Whether it’s pointing to the USSR, a blanket statement about authoritarianism and starvation, and any other talking about anything that isn’t related to the tenets of socialism, is there someone who has either defended capitalism or argued against socialism that hasn’t used the above as a crutch?

To clarify, I’m not a socialist, and don’t find the collectivist nature of the system as well ridding markets and denying people being able to start their own businesses appealing. But I also seen most capitalist group to be right-wing circle-jerks that just parrot weak talking points.


r/SocialismVCapitalism • • Jun 15 '20

Should there be capitalist moderators?

19 Upvotes

I'm not going to talk about moderation directly so as to not break rule 4, but I will ask whether it would be wise for a subreddit about debate between socialist and capitalist, to have at the very least one moderator that's pro-capitalism. I wouldn't fault pro-capitalist for looking at the list of moderators and then notice that the subreddit is exclusively moderated by members of the opposing ideology, and notice that you're not allowed to talk about the moderation taking place (rule 4), and notice that comments may be deleted based on a subjective judgement call (rule 7) and then conclude that this might not be the best place to debate. Again I'm not breaking rule 4 here, I'm not criticizing the mods themselves. I'm just saying it's bad optics.


r/SocialismVCapitalism • • Mar 13 '19

Open Socialism: Let's work on a capitalism alternative!

19 Upvotes

Hi, I created open socialism as an open source project to work on a new societal system. Capitalism is outliving its usefulness as problems of environmental destruction and wealth inequality worsen. (https://thisistheworld.net is my take on the problems with capitalism coupled with globalization.) With modern science and technology, we must be able to do better than a 300 year old system.

https://opensocialism.com/tldr is a tl;dr. In short:

  • Like communism, a cooperative base system with no free enterprise.

  • Like capitalism, there is financial reward for doing great work and rising up in society.

  • Openness to deal with classical corruption issues with communism.

The best system lies somewhere in the middle!

All feedback appreciated!