I've been thinking about the similarities between Here There Are Blueberries and Downstate, particularly in how both plays portray reprehensible people and approach the question of whether people who have done terrible things can be understood, sympathized with, or held accountable.
I think they make fascinating companion pieces because they approach a similar moral problem from almost opposite directions: What do we do when we're confronted with people whose actions are fundamentally reprehensible?
Here There Are Blueberries explores the banality of evil, complicity, and the uncomfortable realization that ordinary people can participate in extraordinary atrocities. One of the most disturbing aspects of the play is that the Nazi soldiers weren't necessarily people who appeared monstrous in their everyday lives. They had families, friendships, hobbies, and ordinary routines. They could laugh, socialize, and enjoy themselves while participating in an extraordinarily cruel system. The horror comes from recognizing how easily people compartmentalize their humanity and rationalize their actions. The play doesn't need to make these individuals sympathetic. In fact, recognizing their ordinariness makes their actions even more disturbing.
Downstate takes a different approach. It puts men convicted of sexual offenses at the center of the story and examines what society owes people who have committed terrible acts. It doesn't erase their victims or suggest that their crimes are inconsequential. Instead, it explores uncomfortable questions about punishment, rehabilitation, forgiveness, and whether someone can ever be more than the worst thing they've done. The audience is put in the position of encountering people who are difficult to sympathize with while simultaneously being asked to recognize their humanity.
I think the biggest distinction is what each play asks of its audience. Here There Are Blueberries asks us to consider how ordinary people become complicit in evil and how institutions preserve or obscure responsibility. Downstate asks us to consider what happens to people after they commit terrible acts and whether we can acknowledge their humanity without diminishing the suffering of their victims.
Both plays challenge the idea that reprehensible people must be visibly monstrous for us to recognize their wrongdoing. They also explore the uncomfortable distinction between understanding someone and excusing what they've done.
Ultimately, I think the most important takeaway from both is that humanizing someone is not the same as redeeming them. We can recognize someone's humanity without forgiving them, excusing their actions, or absolving them of responsibility.
I found it interesting how both plays force the audience to sit with these contradictions rather than offering easy moral answers. They don't necessarily give us the comfortable moral distance we'd prefer, and I think that's what makes them so effective.