Just as the Earth revolves around the Sun, a yearly Book of Mormon race relations thread will arise without fail somewhere on Reddit.
I wanted to make this thread because whenever this topics arise, I see the repetition of arguments that I feel are logically inconsistent at best and fallacious at worst. I also wanted to show support to the many people of African descent who have complained about this very topic who get drowned out by garbage arguments that are most offensive than the play itself. (P.S. I have watched all of South Park until the Lizzo special. Matt and Trey would not air this on Comedy Central circa 2011 when BoM came out. You're lying to yourself if you believe otherwise.)
Book of Mormon is a satire of Mormons.
While I understand the play is literally titled "Book of Mormon". Their is nothing unique about Book of Mormon's portrayal of religion that can't be extrapolated towards other religions. You're telling me Mormons are homophobic? I guess their isn't any homophobia in the other Abrahamic religions. Mormons believe a guy found gold tablets in his backyard? Wacky, unlike the guy who spoke to a burning bush and found 2 stone tablets on the Sinai.
Is BoM satire? Yea, but it's tired and ubiquitous critiques of religion. Mormons suffer from the fact that they're a more novel iteration of an Abrahamic religion with a prophet who arose in a time we deem not fit for religious miracles. Because of their novelty, it's easier to use them as an out-group for comedic purposes as adherents to older sects of the big 3 are less likely to feel any camaraderie with them.
2. It is alright that Book of Mormon is racially insensitive because it's from the perspective of the missionaries.
I don't understand how this perspective arose. Their is no narrator in BoM who leads the audience through the story as it develops. It's a theatrical play with multiple characters that runs with a continuous narrative. When the Ugandans are using typewriters to send texts (Now Ipads) and singing fake renditions of Hakuna Matata using made up words, it's not from the perspective of the missionaries. Matt and Trey just thought it would be funny to make fun of Lion King or that it was funny that Nabalungi can't use a typewriter.
Not to mention. How is this perspective even unique to Mormons? Overseas, the commonly stated belief (whether its a loud minority or otherwise) is that Americans are ignorant of other nations. How did an entire narrative that Mormons are the unique arbiters of ignorance arise from in defenses of BoM? Especially considering, the probability that Mormon missionaries who learn to speak other languages being ignorant to the geographical challenges and issues that people overseas face when compared to the average American is likely low. I don't see how this is a serious defense of the play. In fact, it comes off as members of the audience sincerely thinking they're somehow better than adherents of that religion solely based of their preconceived notions of members of the Mormon church. Tl;dr Any depiction of a Mormon messing up a foreigners name or referencing Star Wars to explain their beliefs is probably a widely held stereotype about the United States moreso than a joke on Mormons.
3. The Ugandans are not the butt of the joke. The Mormon Church is.
You're right, the Ugandans aren't the butt of the joke. The continent of Africa is. Uganda in the story is just an amalgam of African stereotypes with characters that serve more as comedic vehicles than actual characters.
Nabulungi is the AIDs free daughter of the village chief who is seen as the love interest of our would be hero, who continuously forgets her name in exchange for pop culture references.
The entire village has AIDs. The only Doctor in the village has scrotal parasites. The people in the village send messages on typewriters.
The inclusion of General Butt Naked who isn't even from Uganda, let alone the geographical region that Ugandan is in (One is on the west of the continent, the other is on the east). Also the raping virgins to cure aids thing is associated with South Africa and Zimbabwe. Not Uganda.
I guarantee that if you showed this to a group of 100 Ugandans, they would feel that you're tacking every African stereotype you can imagine on their country. Not to mention, if an epidemic of AIDS arose in Brooklyn, New York, GLAD is not letting you get away with making a play about AIDS victims raping babies to cure their aids.
Even the song Hakuna Matata being parodied with Hasa Diga Eebowai. Yeah man, Hakuna Matata is a song utilizing real words in the real language of Swahili. Yeah, it's a parody, but you realize in Hakuna Matata, it's the animals singing it right? Not a group of amalgam Africans singing a song about how they hate God because they all have AIDS and people are raping babies.
Edit: Obligatory "Your boos mean nothing I've seen what makes you cheer"
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5XtAHOepH94