r/BitcoinCA
•
u/Fiach_Dubh
•
Dec 28 '25
r/BitcoinCA • u/Legitimate_Towel_919 • Nov 21 '25
A 2011 Bitcoin whale just cashed out to $1.3B. Zero BTC left!
Just saw this and damnâŚ
A legit OG whoâs been holding BTC since 2011 just dumped EVERYTHING. Walked away with $1.3B in profits and now sits on exactly 0 BTC. Call it risk management, call it nailing the top, or call it straight up losing faith whatever it is, you donât close a 14-year position unless something feels seriously off.Everybody screams HODL when the charts are green!
When the real heat comes, not everyone has the stomach for it.
Respect for locking in that life changing bag, but honestly⌠itâs kinda eerie. đŹ
r/BitcoinCA
•
u/originalgainster
•
Dec 04 '25
Canadian families could pay $1,000 more for groceries in 2026, report warns | Globalnews.ca
Always the same story...
r/BitcoinCA
•
u/Fiach_Dubh
•
Jul 05 '25
12 year old Canadian girl reveals the truth about the banking system.
r/BitcoinCA • u/Fiach_Dubh • Dec 15 '25
How did Canadaâs young people become its unhappiest generation? - CTV News
r/BitcoinCA • u/Fiach_Dubh • Jun 28 '25
"Canada, prepare for a decade of thrift and lower living standards" - The Globe and Mail
archive.phr/BitcoinCA • u/adequate_redditor • Oct 24 '25
B.C. woman who lost $670K in crypto scam fails to recover funds in Supreme Court
TLDR: Despite multiple warnings, emails, and calls, the victim still went ahead with large transfers to a third party wallet. It was a scam. The victim sued the exchange (NDAX), but the ruling sided with NDAX as they had provided plenty of warnings. Case closed!
r/BitcoinCA • u/Randomshortdude • Feb 03 '19
Results of the Bitcoin Chain Analysis
Hello everyone,
It has been a little over 24 hours since we last spoke with one another. Thank you very much for being so helpful in providing wallet information. It helped in the verification of fund locations significantly.
A preliminary, 4,000-word report has been compiled and published here:
I say 'preliminary' because there is even more information (via demonstrations, examples, and spreasheets) that I would like to include within the piece. However, in the interest of QuadrigaCX investors gaining more information about this situation since it is so time sensitive, I decided to publish my analysis as well as a comprehensive sample of wallet addresses and TX IDs so that other users in the community can verify all information independently as well.
If you don't feel like reading the article, here are the main conclusions that were garnered:
It appears that there are no identifiable cold wallet reserves for QuadrigaCX.
It appears that QuadrigaCX was using deposits from their customers to pay other customers once they requested their withdrawals. This did not happen in every withdrawal case by any means, but it happened very frequently toward the end of 2018 (from November onward).
It does not appear that QuadrigaCX has lost access to their Bitcoin holdings.
It appears the number of bitcoins in QuadrigaCX's possession are substantially less than what was reported in Jennifer Robertson's (Gerry's wife) affidavit.
At least some of the delays in delivering crypto withdrawals to customers were due to the fact that QuadrigaCX simply did not have the funds on hand at the time. In some cases, QuadrigaCX was forced to wait for enough customer deposits to be made on the exchange before processing crypto withdrawal requests by their customers.
After completing the analysis, it is my opinion that QuadrigaCX has not been truthful with regards to their inability to access the funds needed to honor customer withdrawal requests (specifically for Bitcoin; $ETH analysis coming very soon). In fact, it is almost impossible to believe that this is the case in lieu of the empirical evidence provided by the blockchain and corroborated by volunteered information from former customers at QuadrigaCX (i.e., most interested parties in this subreddit).
Verifying the Authorship of the Research
I posted this on Medium because it is clean and concise. However, I had to create a new Medium to do so. Thus, this is the only piece on there (at the time of writing).
I will post this link from my Telegram (t.me/MerkleTrader) and Twitter (twitter.com/@proofofresearch) as well.
If there is an alternative link circulating or an individual that is not posting from this account, or the social media platforms provided above, they are an imposter and should be ignored. I'm not invalidating any other research sources, I'm just saying if there's another individual purporting to be the author of this specific study.
Closing Remarks
I'm open to any and all responses as well as questions. I need a nap before I can get to any responses though, this consumed the majority of the weekend for me with little sleep in between. Combing through these addresses was tedious, to say the least.
Also, if anyone feels so inclined, I'd be more than happy to accept a donation or 'thanks' at this Bitcoin address: 1BxwKqfKFQhq2pyvbbcxfagN2bTK3cBqBs
This is not compulsory by any means, of course, and I will continue to investigate this and do as much due diligence as possible even if I don't receive so much as 1 satoshi. So don't feel pressured or like you're being hustled for this work. Its my pleasure. I do have to pay bills and provide for my family though, so obtaining some sort of monetary return for the time and effort invested makes the research a more sustainable use of time.
Again, thank you everyone and I look forward to reading your comments and feedback on this. If I haven't hit the nail on the head, I hope I've at least moved the needle forward on what's going on and provided enough information and leads for the us collectively as a community to quickly extract the truth.
Thank you.
r/BitcoinCA • u/Fiach_Dubh • Jul 23 '25
The average Canadian family now spends 42% of every dollar they earn on taxes. ($48,000) Up 181% since 1961, after accounting for inflation.
r/BitcoinCA • u/Fiach_Dubh • Mar 12 '25
It's really hard to tell which one of us this could be.
r/BitcoinCA • u/Fiach_Dubh • Mar 29 '26
Canada moves to ban crypto donations for election campaigns following UK
r/BitcoinCA • u/Fiach_Dubh • Oct 30 '25
Bank of Canada warns recession may already be underway
r/BitcoinCA • u/MetricsCPA • May 18 '21
2021 BULL RUN TAX UPDATE
Hi All!
Metrics CPA back with an update after the busiest tax season weâve ever had. We've been unable to contribute to the forum much due to lack of time. I just wanted to say thank you to everyone who supported us through the tax season by referring friends and giving us feedback - Thank you!
*That being said, currently, we are too busy to be taking additional clients at this time. We are closing our meeting requests on the website for crypto bookings, as we donât have the capacity to complete all the work being requested. At the moment, I expect we will start taking clients again in early July. Keep and eye on our website if you're interested.
If you have an interest in becoming a CPA, or are a CPA, and have an interest in crypto taxation, please send me a DM and tell me a bit about yourself and your experience in crypto and with accounting. We are based in Victoria, BC, but can employ a Canadian anywhere in the country.
Now that that's out of the way! I have a significant number of updates on Crypto taxes based on what Iâve seen over the last tax season - Some good, some bad. Iâll provide some notes on what makes it easy for us to do your taxes and what makes it hard. This is a continuation of my first post, which can be seen here: 2020 Post
I MUST PREFACE THIS BY SAYING THIS IS NOT FINANCIAL ADVICE. THIS IS NOT BINDING, AND YOUR SITUATION MAY VARY. YOU SHOULD ENGAGE AN ACCOUNTANT IF YOU'RE NOT CERTAIN OF HOW TO TREAT YOUR SPECIFIC SITUATION
Now,
The Biggest mistakes Iâve seen:
People doing transactions for family members/friends - DO NOT DO THIS. It will be taxed as your income. There is no way to separate it out and not include it. If it was bought under your account, it is your transaction. If you make a transaction, itâs your transaction.
You can not give crypto to your kids tax free. It counts as a taxable disposition to you and their cost basis is set at the fmv on that date The âkiddie taxâ rule has made this impossible (edit - for any income being earned) . Any and all income will be taxed in your hands, and will be yours regardless, so there is no point. If your kids are going to actually buy crypto assets, then no problem.
If you have a company, or want to incorporate, the exchange accounts you use MUST be in the name of the company - If they are in your personal name then they will be taxable to you personally.
If you are moving funds to another entity/person or buying something with crypto, just convert to stablecoins first and send stables. It will result in the same gain or loss and is just easier.
If you arenât mining, or trading and making more than $100,000 a year, or have personal income of over $180,000 a year otherwise, setting up a corporation is not worth it. There are significant accounting and legal costs that go with a corp and its just not worth the extra paperwork/time/effort for most people.
We only incorporate and do rollovers for people that are miners, high frequency traders, or are actively margin trading consistently.
Frequently Asked Questions:
âI would like to avoid taxes''
This is not a thing. There arenât any loopholes, cheat codes, or otherwise to allow you to avoid taxes. You are a Canadian. As a Canadian, you have to pay taxes. We will help you optimize as best as possible, but there is no way to get out of paying taxes.
âHow can we be creativeâ
If you are capital gains, you canât - Your only ability is timing your selling to best optimize your taxes. Use tax years to your advantage. More later. If you are business income, we can do a lot more. More later.
âAm I going to go to jail?â
No, no one is going to jail for not reporting your trades - You will get hit with interest and penalties going back to the time at which the tax payment was due, though. For the 2020 year, combined, we had clients that paid over $300,000 in interest and penalties. It can add up.
âMy info was sent to the CRA by coinsquare - I need to get my tax stuff sorted ASAPâ
I anticipate the CRA will take months, if not years to start going after people. You have time. But it's a good warning to those who werenât included - The CRA will get theirs eventually. Be proactive.
âDo you have anyone you can refer me to who is cheaper?â
No. Our services cost what they do for a reason - If you are engaging in crypto activities, you need to build the costs of sorting the taxation into your planning.
âIâm going to move to a country with no crypto taxâ
That would be fine, except, Canada has a departure tax which would require you to declare the sale at fair market value of your assets at the time of departure, and pay tax on them, even though you havenât sold.
Software
Previously, weâve instructed people to use either Cointracking.info or Koinly.io. Koinly.io will make you pay to export the trade data, cointracking.info does not. Cointracking.info also exports in a much better format, and I have seen less errors in their software than koinly.
For that reason, we will only recommend Cointracking.info going forward.
Do I need an Accountant?
If your activities are fairly simple, you can use cointracking.info in full - the calculations will work. What I mean by simple is you put some fiat into shakepay, bought eth, transferred it to binance, bought 2 or 3 altcoins, transferred those to your wallet and are holding them, or sold. you will have no problems. Use their numbers and report them on the Schedule 3 of your return on something like simpletax.
If youâre going deep into DeFi or margin trading etc, then that's when youâre going to need an accountant.
Generally, we donât take on clients with smaller portfolios and simple cases as listed above - Its easy enough to do yourself at that point.
Business Income Vs Capital Gains
I have had many, many arguments with clients and others who have just been ill-informed about this online. Let me lay it out more clearly, starting with defining a capital property:
Capital property â includes depreciable property, and any property which, if sold, would result in a capital gain or a capital loss. You usually buy it for investment purposes or to earn income. Capital property does not include the trading assets of a business, such as inventory. Some common types of capital property include:
Cottages
Securities, such as stocks, bonds, and units of a mutual fund trust
Land, buildings, and equipment you use in a business or a rental operation
Now - Most crypto can be either classified as capital property or inventory. However, capital property is reasonably assumed when you are buying something and hanging onto it for a while. If you were to buy a house, and sell it a week later, then buy another house, sell it the same day, and repeat, all year - do you think the CRA is going to look at that as capital gains? No. Youâre in the business of buying and selling houses. Why do you think crypto is any different?
Let me be clear: IF YOU ARE BUYING AND SELLING CRYPTO ASSETS CONSISTENTLY LOOKING FOR PROFIT, YOU ARE IN THE BUSINESS OF BUYING AND SELLING CRYPTO ASSETS.
Throughout the year, Iâve assessed people as business income anywhere from 150 trades in the year, to 235,000 trades in the year. And anywhere in between. We've also assessed some people with 1000+ trades as capital gains in rare cases. The number of trades is not the sole factor in determining this. Other factors include:
Do you have any other income? Is crypto your sole source of income? If it is, likely you are business income
Are you in the crypto business? Do you run a company that deals with crypto? You are likely going to be business income - (Iâm an accountant that deals with crypto - My activities are all business income as i have a basis of knowledge that is higher than that of the average person)
Are you buying and selling assets the same day? Same week? Same month? Very likely to be deemed business income.
How much time do you spend on crypto? More than an hour or two a week? Justification for business income. If youâre spending 3 or 4 hours a day trading on uniswap and pancake swap, youâre going to be business income.
Look at it from an overall perspective, and just because you donât like the answer doesnât mean you can claim capital gains. We had several clients this year who chose to ignore my recommendations on filing, and thats totally fine if you want to do that, but the rules are quite clear. The only audits weâve seen are those from the classification of capital gains when they should have been business income.
So here are some general guidelines:
Less than 150 trades in a year - To clarify, DCA with fiat into crypto would not count towards this. Buying with fiat to crypto you can do as many transactions as you'd like. They are not taxable transactions.
Spend a few hours a month
Buy things and hang onto them for a few months
Buy assets that you can stake and earn income from
Don't approach it like a business - Treat it like you would your RRSPs or TFSA. Buy and hold.
Follow these rules and you will almost certainly have the ability to claim capital gains.
âBut my binance history says i have 400 trades because its broken out into limit orders that show 20 transactions per trade I placeâ
That's fine - One limit order price counts as one trade.
Capital Gains
If you are treating your activities as capital gains, then the only thing you can do is use timing to your advantage. Per the Canadian income tax brackets, the higher your income is in a specific year, the higher the tax rate you pay on that higher income. Therefore, it's best to spread your income over multiple years. Rather than sell $150,000 of BTC all at once, sell some in one year, sell some another year and split the gains over two tax years. Obviously, it depends on the market but its the only option you have. Note that you are also subject to the superficial loss rule - Meaning if you sell something for a loss and repurchase within 31 days, you can not claim that loss. Once you sell something, I recommend not buying it back. If you sell, you should sell for good. Donât ever go back to an asset once youâre done with it. This will keep you from trying to time the market, and keep you onside with capital gains treatment.
That being said - You will never pay more in tax overall than you have made - If you have an opportunity to crystallize some gains, do it. Donât not make money because of taxes. You only pay taxes on money you make.
Business income
If you have business income, you have a lot more flexibility. You can claim expenses against your income - Electricity, etc for miners, computer equipment, mining rigs, business use of home, office equipment, insurance, accounting and legal fees, software costs, advertising, etc.
If incorporated, your assets are held as inventory - this means in a down year, you can write down your assets to fair market value and claim a loss. You are also not subject to the superficial loss rule. Trade at will. Trade as much as you want if you think youâre good at it. You can also pay yourself a salary to create RRSP room for yourself if youâd like. You also do not have to file the T1135 form for business income assets held as inventory.
Data
We saw everything under the sun this year - From people who spent time meticulously combing through their cointracking.info data to correct everything and saved themselves 15+ hours of our time spent correcting stuff (thank you!), to people who literally sent us photos of their computer screens of transactions (please, please, donât do this - We have to then transcribe and type it all - You're paying us to do something at an extremely high rate that you could do yourself).
The best possible way you can provide data to an accountant is to use an aggregator like cointracking.info to put all of your details together in a concise, timeline format of transactions. It saves a ton of time over us having to piece together all of your exchange csvâs from screenshots, emails, etc. The more time you spend, the less you have to pay us to spend on the data.
In order to calculate your crypto taxes, we need ALL of the data. All of it. If you forget to send us something, or just don't include one exchange, it will throw it all out of whack. Let me reiterate. You must send us EVERYTHING. If I had a satoshi for I had to go back and ask clients about gaps in information and then they told me they didn't provide it because they didnât think it was important, I would probably have almost a full BTC. We need everything. All information since the beginning of crypto for you. The only exception to this is if you already have your cost basisâ at the end of the last fiscal/tax year - Then that's what we need, and all of your data for the current year.
If you donât want to use aggregator software, please only send us direct exports. Do not modify the files, donât add your notes, donât adjust anything. Weâve had multiple issues with damaged files/data sets that do not work properly due to modifications to it.
I will say that almost ALL of the errors that resulted this year were due to clients not providing us the correct data - They omitted or modified the information and then it resulted in us doing the calculations based on that information, and the client is then surprised at the results. We can only do with what you provide us.
Now, onto specific treatment of assets.
DeFI
Where do I start with this - This is EXTREMELY complicated, and is only getting more so. It's going to get to a point where we wonât be able to calculate the taxes owing on it because of the multiple levels and layers. For example, imagine the following scenario (all imaginary numbers but real transactions), with (T) denominating a taxable transaction and (NT) not taxable:
Client, Vitalik, has decided he wants to get into DeFi. Vitalik has 20 Eth. He wants to keep his eth but get some exposure to defi. Vitalik takes 10 of his eth to Maker, opens a CDP vault, deposits 10 eth, and draws out 10,000 DAI (NT). He now has 10,000 Dai and and 10 eth (but 20 eth overall because he never sold his 10 eth, just locked it in a vault). He takes the 10,000 DAI and buys 5 Alchemix tokens (ALCX)(T). He takes the 5 ALCX and 5 eth and goes to Sushi. Deposits the 5 ALCX and 5 eth into SLP pool, receiving 5.4 SLP tokens(T). Vitalik takes his 5.4 SLP tokens and goes to pickle.finance and pickles them, exchanging his 5.4 SLP for 2.26 pSLP tokens(T). Then takes the 2.26 pSLP tokens and puts them into a pickle jar staking and earning 347% APY(NT). That sits there for a couple weeks. He then draws out 2.97 pSLP tokens(T). Unpickles them and receives 5.98 SLP tokens(T). Takes the 5.98 SLP tokens and exchanges them back for 5.5 eth and 6.2 ALCX (T). All the while, each of these assets is volatile in price and changes in value by the second.
Figure out the taxes on that. Good luck! We can do it, but its only getting more difficult. There will be people who come back to us for 2021 that we will not be able to help, because this stuff is just getting more and more complicated.
If you engage in defi transactions like this, expect to pay a LOT for tax services next year. Sorting out the numbers on one batch of transactions as above would cost about $250-300 CAD. Multiply that by however many times youâve done something like this.
Crypto is passing the point where we are able to actually calculate the direct result and taxable income in the way the CRA requires. For that reason, you should purposefully make all your transactions. Limit your transactions to those you judge as important or will provide you value, or else you will end up with a huge headache.
Shitcoins
There has been a huge increase in shitcoins this cycle - Dog tokens, safemoon, token burning/transaction tax coins, RFI/AMPL clones, etc. If youâre playing with these, theyâre speculative, it is the equivalent of gambling. Buying stuff like this is going to be looked at with high scrutiny for business income. If youâre in deep enough to get in bed with things like this then you have enough knowledge/spend enough time to be speculating/deemed business income.
BSC - Binance Smart Chain
At this time, I donât have an automated solution for sorting/tracking bsc transactions and it is all manual.
It looks like cointracking.info and koinly can both pull BSC transactions. BSC just started this year so I haven't seen a lot of it come through, and I don't have a reference as to the quality of the data yet.
If youâre playing on BSC/pancake swap, keep track of all of your transactions. Track the following:
What you bought (ticker)
When you bought it (2021-03-15)
What you sold to buy it (BNB)
How many you bought
How much X you sold to buy it or the price in the asset you bought (0.000000453 BNB per)
Other Chains/Cross Chain
You will have to keep track of all of this stuff yourself. We donât yet have a way to track this information. For example, if you use a bridge to convert USDT ERC-20 to BSC USDT there is no way for us to follow that. You sent USDT on the eth network somewhere. It's now gone. You also received BSC USDT somewhere - We donât have the ability to link these transactions unless we do so manually. This is why we recommend using an aggregator like cointracking.info. You will have to go in and tie these two transactions together so that we can see that that's what happened. Otherwise, it looks like you just spent 1000 USDT and then received 1000 USDT, which are two separate taxable transactions and will result in you paying double tax. This goes for FTM, AVAX, etc. Anything that's cross-chain does not have a suitable tracking system yet.
Staking
Not much has changed here - Depending on the protocol this can be deemed as active business income or Investment income. Regardless, the fair market value of the token received on the date received is added to your income.
Interest - Nexo, Blockfi, Celsius
This is simple, and is added to your income as the interest is received. This will always be deemed investment income.
NFTs This is an interesting one and not one I thought would blow up as much as it did. You have to track each individual asset separately. Ie if you buy NFT 456 for $20 and sell it for $250, you need to record these transactions as though each NFT is a different token. This may be something you need to do manually. If you buy a pack and it contains 4 or 5 different NFTs, the cost of the pack is split across each asset equally as your cost basis. You will need to track this, I recommend you keep records of all NFT transactions you do. I wonât be able to work any magic with it if I donât have the details. I can, of course, go on chain and track it all, but it will be painstaking and take a ton of time (think $10,000+) if you have more than 3 or 4 transactions.
Leverage trading - Margin, short, futures, etc
All of this is deemed business income regardless, no matter what. Always business income. It is speculative by nature and will be taxed as such. You can not be classified as capital gains when engaging in this type of activity.
This leads me to another question I get a lot:
âCan I be both business income and capital gains?â
The answer is⌠sometimes. Maybe. It depends.
There are times where someone might have 100 ETH in a stash that they donât touch. They also have some BTC they use for margin or leverage trading. This BTC is traded on margin or leverage and is deemed as business income. But the stash of eth thats been sitting there for years untouched can also be claimed as capital gains.
Where it does not work is if those lines are blurred. For example - Say you have 5 BTC in cold storage that youâve held for forever. You also have 1.5 BTC you use on bitmex to margin trade. This BTC would be considered business income/activity - your income PnL is added or deducted from your income. But as the BTC in your wallet are identical properties, the cost basis is going to be affected by this - Its in this type of situation that we donât have a clear answer. We often present the facts to the client and offer them a choice as to how they would like to file, but our default is to play it safe and claim the lowest common denominator which results in all of it being claimed as business income.
Costs
Finally, Iâll end with another question I get a lot.
How much does this all cost?
The answer is, it varies. We charge hourly for services. It costs as much time as it takes to sort through your info. If it takes me 3 hours to sort through your information and send you 3 emails because you donât have the info we need, then that will obviously add time. Its why we always recommend using an aggregator. It takes a lot of time out of the requirements.
In short, if you have a simple portfolio, I recommend just using the tax softwares available. If you are one step above that and have DeFi stuff and need help, you should expect at least $1,500 to be able to sort out your transactions and file your T1 return. For corporate returns, that goes up by double or more, and if you are a big DeFi junkie or heavy trader, or otherwise have extra complicated stuff, expect a lot more. We have had clients weâve invoiced $20,000 plus for one years worth of work due to the amount of time it took to sort out. It can be anywhere in between.
As I mentioned, weâre not taking clients at this time. But we will eventually open up to accepting new clients again - its best to check our website for updates - https://getmetrics.ca/
Iâll be around for the next couple of weeks to answer comments or questions, but some of the hostility I received against my last post is unnecessary - I donât make the rules, Iâm not the CRA, Iâm not out to make you pay your taxes - What you do is your choice. Iâm here to interpret the rules and be the middleman between you and the CRA. This information is meant to be a guide for you to help you out in navigating some of this stuff - Iâm not being paid to do this and I hope it can assist you in some way.
**EDIT - Its come to my attention that there are now DEFI transactions (pooling, liquidity, etc) that are happening on Tron, Zilliqua, Solana, etc - We don't have any tools to handle this at the moment, and can not pull this info from the chain to a reasonable format. If you are trading on defi on networks other than eth, you must manually track all of your transactions! It is your responsibility to record this info. We will need to know the name/ticker of the asset traded, the date, the price of the asset sold, price of the asset bought, and the volume of what was bought **
r/BitcoinCA • u/Fiach_Dubh • Mar 31 '26
"The War in Iran will Push up Inflation... Canada's Economy is Dealing With A Lot" - Governor of The Bank of Canada - Prepare Accordingly
r/BitcoinCA • u/Fiach_Dubh • May 21 '25
Bitcoin surpasses $150,000 CAD as it breaches USD all time high of 109k
r/BitcoinCA • u/Fiach_Dubh • Jun 23 '25
A Ban on Paying Cash For Anything Costing More Than $10000 CAD - Mark Carney's Bill C2 - The National Post
epaper.nationalpost.comr/BitcoinCA • u/drippyginger23 • Dec 16 '24
150 000$ đ
Congrats all 𼳠We're flying high, at 151 000$ already
r/BitcoinCA • u/Fiach_Dubh • Oct 05 '25
Bitcoin is up over 500% since Justin Trudeau said anyone who bought Bitcoin would have lost more than half their life savings. đ
r/BitcoinCA • u/Fiach_Dubh • Feb 02 '26