r/BitcoinCA • u/Fiach_Dubh • Jun 03 '25
Hidden inside a border security bill, Canada’s central-banker Prime Minister is going to further centralize banking: “The bill would outlaw cash transactions greater than $10,000.”
r/BitcoinCA • u/Fiach_Dubh • Jun 03 '25
r/BitcoinCA • u/Fiach_Dubh • Nov 26 '24
r/BitcoinCA • u/Fiach_Dubh • Feb 05 '22
r/BitcoinCA • u/Fiach_Dubh • Sep 11 '22
r/BitcoinCA • u/wheredoesthisgoo • Jan 06 '25
r/BitcoinCA • u/HorrorSubstantial135 • Jan 06 '25
Anyone else as happy as I am with the great hair clown quitting just now?
r/BitcoinCA • u/shmendan2 • Apr 15 '25
I want to simply buy $1000 CAD worth of BTC via e transfer from my bank account.
I’ve checked with 6 banks now. RBC, CIBC, TD, BMO, ScotiaBank and my local credit union. All of them block any transactions related to cryptocurrency. I’ve also heard that Tangerine and Simplii block transactions too.
What other option is there for me? I would like a bank account that simply allows me to transfer money in from my main bank, then transfer it out to an exchange such as Kraken. I don’t want to pay with cash at the 20% fee terminals in my town. Some have recommended WealthSimple but I heard you can’t send e-transfers out of a WealthSimple account?
Update: opened a WealthSimple account. Transferred $1000 from my RBC account. Then tried to transfer $1000 to Bitcoin Well. Blocked again!
r/BitcoinCA
•
u/MrRGnome
•
Jan 08 '25
Happy New Year Canadian Bitcoiners. As has been long promised, it's time to stop enabling scams on this platform. No more will we tolerate questions about how to buy or sell shitcoins, where the best shitcoin trading platforms are, nor will we tolerate advice given that directs users to shitcoin casinos. This content will be removed.
While about half of Canadian Bitcoiners are also involved in shitcoins, that content is under no circumstances welcome here. We invite you to take your shitcoining elsewhere.
Examples of shitcoin casinos we will not tolerate the promotion of include Kraken, Coinbase, NDAX, Newton, Shakepay. Anywhere that buys or sells shitcoins and holds custody.
There is simply no excuse for new Canadian users to be directed to these platforms. Recommended platforms include any that are peer to peer or non-custodial. This includes Bisq, hodlhodl, vexl, peach bitcoin, as well as onion hosted p2p services like robosats. It also includes low trust non-custodial Bitcoin exchanges like Beaver Bitcoin and Bitcoin Well.
No, moderators have not been paid off. We've even convinced the other mods to remove their referral links. You have only to ask the CEOs of these exchanges we do recommend to hear what a pain in their ass we are as we lobby them to protect their users and be the best in their field.
I appreciate the backlash this will inevitably cause especially among shitcoiners. No, the policy is not up for debate. Don't let the door hit ya where the dog should have bit ya, you scam enabling clowns.
Bitcoin only. No shitcoins. Those are the hard and fast rules in this subreddit. We will create a place safe for new users to be educated about Bitcoin, where we can promote the most secure and best practices first and foremost. I invite all of you to join us in onboarding a new generation of Bitcoiners without directing them to unnecessarily risky and trusting services.
Edit; Some personal thoughts, speaking for no one but myself: In additon, those of you advising users to shitcoin, nfc, and less secure wallets, please consider the alternative options and the security considerations in your recommendations. I want to convince you that recommendations like ledger and trezor and tangem and exodus are just as inappropriate as these shitcoin casino recommendations. I appreciate there is more educating to do there, and personally I will endeavor to engage these recommendations in good faith when I bring criticism to them.
Ideally, we'd have a culture that self enforced against some of these problematic recommendations. That is the ultimate goal of these changes in my mind personally - to be able to once again increase freedom and reduce moderation as a self enforcing culture of best practices Bitcoin usage emerges. To build a knowledge base of users who are eager to give back and create the community they want to see for themselves built on their ability to verify and learn about Bitcoin. And yes, indirectly through technology learn about shitcoins. There is a reason we are against this harm. If you can avoid discussing shitcoins and instead talk technology - I encourage you to discuss those things here. Just don't make it about shitcoins, make it about Bitcoin and technology it should or shouldn't adopt and explorations of how that technology works. If you have to name the shitcoin, you did it wrong.
The goal here is harm reduction, it's best practices, and yes it's selfish. We Bitcoiners deserve spaces to discuss and grow Bitcoin, free of very poor or dangerous recommendations and offering the highest quality of advice and assistance. That's what we've developed at the Bitcoin Discord. That's where I'm coming from. That's the kind of results we want to see here, where we have seen those successes create positive, flourishing pro-bitcoin spaces grow out of initially restrictive limitations followed by dramatically broader freedoms than initially existed. To those of you who find this kind of curated content subreddit experience unacceptable, I'm sorry you feel that way. But that's what this is. We are here for bitcoin discussion, advice, growth, learning, development, and celebration. We don't want any but the best advice being given out in this so dangerous a space. We want to create a resource and place of value. Please. Consider making it with us. If you see someone making poor recommendations, explain why there might be better alternatives. Thank you.
r/BitcoinCA • u/Fiach_Dubh • Nov 02 '23
r/BitcoinCA • u/Judadiao • May 18 '24
A few months ago I posted about how BMO refused to do a wire transfer to Kraken and indicating that they do not work with crypto exchanges. However, I can at least make email transfer to both Kraken and Shakepay.
Yesterday I used Scotiabank to EMT to Shakepay and the transfer was halted. Shakepay returned with a 412 error and asked me to call the bank to make them release the money. Today when I tried to login to the online banking I found that my account was locked because of "unusual transaction".
I had to call the bank and went through several tedious security questions to prove it was me. Then they still didn't want to approve the transaction and told me they can revoke the EMT, despite I told them I have been dealing with the company for years. At last I had to promise that I will be fully responsible for the fund if anything bad happens, and then they finally released the money. However, they won't assure whether the same thing will happen if I transfer money again in the future.
These banks are like: "Hey we have all your money sitting in our pocket and you can never take your money back from us. And btw it is for your security." It is totaly bs. It is for their fortune. These old grandpas do not even know BlackRock has a Bitcoin ETF on US market. Look at how we Canadians are struggling sending money even between these big banks. In this electronic connected E-world, the fastest way to move money between banks is writing a draft from the source bank counter, then drive to the other bank and deposit it at the counter. Are we still living in 1900s???
r/BitcoinCA • u/Fiach_Dubh • Oct 05 '25
r/BitcoinCA • u/Prestigious_Fig_9984 • May 10 '26
r/BitcoinCA • u/winterwinner • Apr 29 '25
Any one else catch this? So frustrating how it continues to be brought up so negatively by CBC/Liberals to pin the Pierre Poilievre and the Conservatives. Just goes to show how little work they've done to understand it.
r/BitcoinCA • u/Nzain1 • Nov 28 '24
It’s time to be a man Canada and build up a Bitcoin reserve for our future!
r/BitcoinCA • u/Fiach_Dubh • Aug 16 '24
r/BitcoinCA • u/hiadamob • May 10 '24
r/BitcoinCA • u/jackofalltrades0505 • Feb 04 '24
Ya I know this is a bitcoin sub but looking to invest some monies into btc and eth through a registered account. There are a bunch of different ETFs for canadians. What's the best BTC and ETH ETF in Canada? Best = safest, low management fee, stuff like that.
Thanks
r/BitcoinCA • u/MrRGnome • Mar 07 '25
With all the news going on in the US about their Bitcoin strategic reserve, I'd like to discuss the ways a Canadian strategic reserve could be better implemented.
Do we like the idea of only funding it with seizures? Is that going to impact law enforcement funding?
Do we prefer the idea of using corporate custodians, multisig across government branches, or timelocks for custody? If we do use timelocks, how long should they be?
Should we be buying Bitcoin with tax dollars? Or is there a better way to fund the reserve?
If we had a Bitcoin reserve under what conditions should we start spending it? And on what?
Should the reserve be publicly auditable? Should they publish invalid signing transactions regularly as to demonstrate "proof of reserves"?
How would you design a Canadian Bitcoin Strategic Reserve?
r/BitcoinCA • u/MathSeveral8565 • Sep 18 '21
r/BitcoinCA • u/Fiach_Dubh • Feb 21 '22
r/BitcoinCA • u/breakingbets • Apr 28 '24
I deposit my BTCs to a Canada based crypto exchange which is named 'Newton exchange' few days ago, it took over 24 hours to be processed, it's way longer and quite abnormal behavior compared to those bigger exchanges, like Binance, OKX, Coinbase, Kraken etc., I asked Newton's rep, the rep told me it's just one time, it won't take that long in the future deposit.
However I'm kind of doubtful what the rep told me, so I was thinking about if the deposit took that long, how about the withdrawal? So I requested to withdraw exactly the same amount of BTCs that I deposited, then it's been over 48 hours so far, it's still the 'Pending' review status, in meantime no one from Newton contacted me to tell me what's going on there.
You can check the timeline below to get more details.
Timeline:
2024-April-26 9:44 am => I request the withdrawal of BTCs.

2024-April-26 5:26 pm => After about 8 hours, a rep named Kruger emailed me to ask me to verify the destination address.

2024-April-26 06:04 pm => After about 30 minutes I replied to the rep Kruger to confirm my withdrawal address.

2024-April-27 06:13 pm => Since it's been over 24 hours I did not get any response from Newton, so I contact them from their official website 'Contact us' section.

2024-April-27 06:29 pm => Then I received a rep who named Obaid and replied to me shortly, however this rep looks like don't know what's going on, he just asked me to verify my withdrawal destination address again, so I have to reply to him to verify my address again immediately at 6:33 pm, then this rep disappear as well.

2024-April-28 10:49 am => Now it's been over 48 hours, my withdrawal request is still 'Pending' review status. No one from Newton contacted me to tell me the process or what happened. It's overdue what Newton promised "Crypto transfers are usually instant but can take up to 48 hours."

2024-April-28 11:28 am => Then after over another 12 hours, the previous rep Obaid finally replied to me, and all bullshit, no any information but keep waiting! And the original processing of my withdrawal rep Kruger is still disappearing.

My last time using their service was about 3 years ago, the deposit, withdrawal took about 8 hours for each to be processed, no big issue at all, and that's why I went back this time.

I'm trying to tell those replies who post things like "I'm all good to deposit/withdraw by using Newton for xxx years", My bad experience concluded that the company's previous behavior cannot represent what they do now or later.
(Assume you are not a Newton’s 'undercover') Put yourself in my shoes and think about what you would be like if this happened to you one day in the future?
I just have few assets in Newton, and not that rush to use it, but what I'm concerned about is compared to bigger Crypto exchanges such as Binance, OKX, Coinbase, Kraken, did any of them hold your money for over 48 hours and without any further information as what Newton did?
2024-April-29 10:09 am => It's been over 72 hours, Newton is still holding my withdrawal BTCs without any further information.
2024-April-29 10:41 am => Finally I got the response from Newton, guess what, after hold my withdrawal BTCs for over 72 hours then tell me my destination withdrawal address is "with connections to illegal drugs, fraud and other scam related occurrences"? Why don't they also add "child trafficking, organ trafficking, arms trading, funding of Palestinian, etc."?If really like what Newton claimed, why shouldn't they frozen the money and report to police RCMP or even FBI? Why they will push me to use the money of "connections to illegal drugs, fraud and other scam related occurrences" to sell to Canadian dollar and then send to my local bank? If we follow their logic, so is Newton helping criminals right now lol.
Also they told that they will suspense my Newton account in 3 days. But this is the only thing we all agree on so far, if not doing so, Newton really think they hold a customer's withdrawal money for over 72 hours then the customer would still like to continue using Newton? lol

If the real reason for your rejection is that you just think that the destination withdrawal address is the address of your competitor, you can directly take downgrade measures and tell the customer that you cannot withdraw money to this address and please change to a new withdrawal address.
It's just like a customer trying to transfer money from a small bank such as National Bank to a large bank such as TD bank, shouldn't the normal approach be for National Bank to provide better offers to retain customers? Instead of slandering competitor TD’s account as "with connections to illegal drugs, fraud and other scam related occurrences". It’s even more inappropriate to label customers as “bad actors” like Newton’s CEO commented below. My individual case cannot fully reflect the entire company, the attitude of the company's CEO can completely reflect how this company treats to their customers.

What's more, my situation is like what I mentioned above, because their deposits are too slow, so I just want to try if Newton's withdrawal process is also slow, that's all.
And my previous deposit into Newton was Bitcoin, why did Newton force me to sell it for Canadian dollars on their exchange? Instead of directly returning the Bitcoin to my original wallet? Because by returning the Bitcoin directly to the wallet I previously deposited from, you won't be able to earn commission, right?
Finally, under Newton's pressure, I had to sell the assets in Newton's account. At the same time, Newton tearfully earned $1,996.90 CAD commission from the suspect account which is "with connections to illegal drugs, fraud and other scam related occurrences".

Great job Newton!
Conclusion, I have been involved in cryptocurrency for almost 10 years and have used almost all mainstream cryptocurrency exchanges and some Canada based small exchanges, Newton has the worst user experience, bar none so far.
The overall feeling is that Newton does not seem to have much financial strength to handle large amounts transactions, but given that they are regulated by OSC&FINTRAC, I believe the money is safe (if they don’t suddenly file for bankruptcy). If you only deal with small-amount transactions, such as transactions under $10,000 CAD, you can basically use it with confidence, but for large amounts trading, it is recommended that you switch to a larger exchange, such as Binance, OKX, Coinbase, Kraken, etc.
BTW I just realized the Newton exchange earned 1/5 stars in BBB(Better Business Bureau®), and if you check the reviews, it's full of complaints.https://www.bbb.org/ca/on/toronto/profile/cryptocurrency-exchange/newton-crypto-0107-1391172