I think the new Neue Klasse i3 should have its own subreddit, and r/BMWi3 should stay focused on the original 2013 to 2022 i3/i3s.
This has nothing to do with disliking the new car. I actually really like it, and would honestly be a dream car of mine. My concern is what happens to more than a decade of information already posted here.
This subreddit has been around since 2013. There are years of repair posts, REx troubleshooting, battery information, coding, wheel fitment, suspension issues, AC problems, DIY fixes, part numbers and owner experiences that all refer to the original i3.
The new i3 is a completely different car. It is a Neue Klasse electric 3 Series sedan with a different platform, drivetrain, electrical architecture, electronics and software. Other than the name, there really isn’t much technical overlap between the two.
That is going to make searching this subreddit increasingly messy.
Search “i3 wheel specs,” “i3 fuse,” “i3 12V battery,” “i3 charging problem,” “i3 suspension noise” or “i3 AC problem.”
Right now, you generally know what car those old posts are talking about. A few years from now, that won’t be true.
Flair helps, but it doesn’t solve the whole problem. Thirteen years of old posts weren’t written with generation labels because there was only one i3. People also find Reddit posts through Google and other search tools, not just by filtering flair inside the subreddit.
The biggest issue for me is the archive.
If we create a new subreddit for the original i3, none of the old information moves with us. The entire history of the original car stays here.
The Neue Klasse i3 is just starting its life. This is the easiest possible time to give it its own subreddit and let its technical archive grow there from the beginning.
Original i3/i3s stays here with the archive it has had since 2013.
Neue Klasse i3 gets its own subreddit.
Link the two communities prominently so anyone interested in both can easily find both.
I understand why the mods want to keep everything together. BMW reused the i3 name, so on the surface it makes sense. I just think the amount of technical information already attached to this subreddit makes this situation different.
Once years of posts about both completely different cars are mixed together, separating them later will be much much harder if not impossible.
I would really like to see a pinned community vote before that happens.
I think we deserve to get the chance to make a vote on it.