GODDAMN IT i just spent almost two hours writing this before I DELETED IT ALL by pressing CMD+Q instead of CMD+A in a tragic attempt to backup my work that went horribly wrong. FUCK YOU, UNIVERSE.
I'll try to recreate it. But it's the second version. The first version, lost in the universe like tears in rain.
Sigh.
There's a trope amongst sexually active twentysomethings that the first time you have sex with someone, it's going to suck. The common wisdom says that the first time together, you don't know what the other person wants, you don't know how to please each other. Sure, the more time you spend with someone, and the more times you sleep with each other, the better the sex gets, and hopefully, it becomes amazing. But that first time is always, consistently, bad. It's the smelly manure from which the beautiful flower of your relationship grows.
I believed this for most of my life. I'm a 27-year-old straight male and have slept with maybe 20 women. My personal experiences confirmed it. Every time I slept with someone new, it invariably was awkward and riddled with performance anxiety, sometimes even erection issues. It wasn't pretty. Of course, the sex always improved and became fantastic, but that first time never was.
In February 2013, after a traumatic and scarring breakup of a three-and-a-half year relationship, I started practicing BDSM. And every BDSM relationship I've had since then has been filled with sweaty, animalistic, mindblowingly good sex. From the beginning.
There's a simple reason, really. Communication. Every safe, sane consensual BDSM experience begins with both partners explicitly and directly communicating what they like and what turns them on. So when the clothes come off, there's no ambiguity, just unadulterated passion.
This simply just doesn't happen in vanilla hookups. Women (and that's the only group I can speak of from personal experience; sorry everyone else!) seem to get uncomfortable talking about their sexual desires; that stigma of being a "slut" or that fear that guys don't like "sluts" is still pretty damn strong, even among college-educated, successful women.
I recently moved. After spending my whole life in one state, I now find myself in a new state and a new city in which I know nobody. One of the first things I did was acquaint myself to the local TNG group, but my experience there was just so-so. I looked elsewhere for partners.
I found a girl on a vanilla dating site who had everything I look for in a partner -- she's smart, funny, intellectually curious, and super cute to boot. We chatted, I asked her out, and we set up a date. There was definitely mutual attraction. We grab drinks at one bar, then another, then end up at my place taking our clothes off. I had dropped some hints and performed some subtle tests to see if she was at all submissive, and she wasn't -- disappointing, but since Dan Savage always recommends showing someone who isn't kinky that you can have great vanilla sex too, I figured, what the hell? So we were naked on my bed, and I was focusing on her pleasure, performing oral sex, trying to make her aroused and relaxed. I'm trying to establish what the feminists call "enthusiastic consent" -- i.e., get her so aroused and tease her so magnificently that she just begs me to fuck her. I put a condom on and though she clearly wants me to (being on your back, spreading your legs around me and pulling my groin towards your pussy is pretty crystal clear, as far as body language goes), she just won't say it. There's something that makes her uncomfortable about telling me to fuck her. So after trying a few times, I finally get a nod, and slide myself deep into her. The rest of the sex was a mesh of different variations on missionary, and I came and she didn't.
It was extremely mediocre sex. I did all the work, eating her out and teasing her with my hands, trying to make her comfortable and relaxed. She didn't even so much as look at my cock. I had mediocre sex with someone whose personality I'm definitely attracted to. Disappointing.
The sad thing, it didn't have to be that way. The open and honest discussions inherent happen before every safe and sane BDSM encounter just doesn't happen during vanilla hookups. And the sex suffers.
When I tell fellow kinksters that I don't know if I can ever date a vanilla girl again, it's not about ropes, dominance and sadomasochism. It's about the communication. From great communication comes great relationships. And I'm done settling for anything less.