I have been using CATIA V5 in the automotive industry here in Europe for quite some time now. I use CATIA V5 every day for complex casting parts, plastic housings, and so on. For my private workshop at home, I needed a CAD system for 3D printing, welding and CNC milling. Because a private CATIA license with all the modules I need is way too expensive, I got Autodesk Inventor. I thought Inventor is a modern CAD system and that it would be easy and great to use, but after a few weeks I am honestly underwhelmed. For me, CATIA V5 is simply 100 times better in every single way except its pricepoint.
The biggest problem for me is how Inventor handles the model tree and part structure. At work in CATIA, me and others build super stable master models with skeleton structures, separate axis systems, and publications. I always structure my complex parts with many separate PartBodies and combine them with Boolean operations like Union Trim, Assemble, or Remove. My surfaces and wireframes are cleanly sorted in Geometrical Sets. When an input surface from one supplier changes at the very top of a 2000 feature tree, I just use the Replace command on the publication. Maybe I have to re-select one or two edges, yes. But then, the whole part updates without errors, including complex drafts, shell elements, and fillets. In Inventor, the whole logic feels weak. Multi-body modeling is not half as good, projected lines in sketches lose their reference all the time, and if you change something early in the tree, everything turns red and breaks. Inventor loves to throw error messages at you, its just insane.
When it comes to surfacing (GSD in CATIA), the difference is even more extreme. In CATIA, the mathematical kernel gives you total control. I have to say that I'm not a Class-A surfacing strak guy, so I don't use CATIA`s ICEM Surf. I just model regular engineering surfacing on the B-side and complex functional surfaces. I build surfaces using Adaptive Sweeps with Law curves, Multi-Sections Surfaces where I can control every coupling point for clean G2 curvature, and Sweeps with exact draft directions for injection molding tools. In Inventor, the “surface tools” feel like a toy. You have almost no control over the surface math, the Loft tool makes terrible dirty surfaces as soon as you want tangency on ANY 3D curves, and complex variable fillets simply fail where CATIA just calculates it without problems.
Also the automation and assembly performance is no comparison. In CATIA, I build smart PowerCopies and User Defined Features. When I need a complex screw boss or clip that adapts automatically to a curved surface and pulling direction, I just insert my PowerCopy, click three inputs, and it is done. It just works. In Inventor, iFeatures feel super clunky and iLogic needs weird coding. I mean, am I a programmer? No, I’m not. And in big assemblies, CATIA V5 lets me open a whole car section with over 30,000 parts in seconds, move things around fast, and do clash detection in real-time. Inventor already gets slow when I build smaller assemblys.
To be honest, switching to Inventor made me realize what a masterpiece of engineering CATIA V5 actually is. CATIA is the absolute spaceship among all CAD programs. People always laugh about its old Windows 98 look, but under the hood, it is an unstoppable power machine. No matter how crazy the geometry, how massive the assembly, or how deep the feature tree is.. CATIA never lets you down. 12000 features in a single casting? No problem. It just works, rock solid, every single day. There is a reason why we build whole airplanes and cars in it, while Inventor feels like you are trying to build a rocket with Lego bricks. God praise CATIA V5. It is simply the king of all CAD systems and an absolute masterpiece of software engineering.
Sorry if this sounds like a rant and sorry for my English, I am not a native speaker. Maybe I am just too used to the CATIA way of thinking. How do you guys handle Inventor? Do you encounter the same problems?