Hi everyone!
I recently moved to the UK from South America to work as an au pair, and I’m looking for some advice from people who have been in similar situations.
For context, my responsibilities are fairly straightforward in terms of hours. I take the children to school, pick them up, and look after them until their parents get home. Depending on the day, that usually means spending around 3–4 hours with the children.
However, the experience has been considerably more difficult than I anticipated, particularly because of the relationship I’ve developed with the mother.
The lack of training
The family has had previous au pairs, and apparently their usual arrangement was for the outgoing au pair to stay an additional week to help train the incoming one. Unfortunately, because of the timing of my Youth Mobility visa and the paperwork involved, that wasn’t possible in my case.
The parents are also extremely busy, so my training was very limited and incomplete.
I had babysat before, so I wasn’t completely unfamiliar with looking after children. However, being an au pair is very different from occasional babysitting. You’re expected to know the children’s routines, personalities, schedules, preferences, household systems, how the parents want things done, and all sorts of little details that you can only really learn by spending time with the family.
I wasn’t given much opportunity to learn these things gradually. Instead, I was expected to adapt almost immediately and become completely independent.
I’m also an only child, so there are certain dynamics involving siblings, particularly when it comes to managing arguments, disagreements and their individual personalities, that I’m still learning. I don’t mind learning at all. In fact, I want to become better at my job. But I don’t think it’s reasonable to expect someone to instinctively know things they’ve never been exposed to. The mother knew im one before hiring me too.
The mother’s attitude towards mistakes
The mother is quite cold and straightforward in her communication. What I find particularly difficult is that she seems to automatically assume that whenever I don’t do something correctly, it’s because I lack common sense, initiative or simply don’t want to do it.
There’s very little consideration that perhaps I wasn’t given the information in the first place, that instructions were unclear, or that I simply made an honest mistake.
She also frequently compares me to previous au pairs, which I find frustrating because we’re different people with different backgrounds and experiences.
For example, she recently told me that she didn’t understand why I lacked common sense regarding something, particularly because it was something she had already needed to explain to previous au pairs. She said she was explaining it to me to avoid further frustration.
But that’s precisely my point. If something needed to be explained to previous au pairs as well, why is it suddenly something I should instinctively know?
There is also a considerable amount of miscommunication within the household. Her husband tells me one thing, she tells me another, her mother gives me different instructions, the housekeeper has her own understanding of how things should be done, and even the previous au pair sometimes gives me different information.
I’ve realised that I probably need to direct every question to the mother to avoid misunderstandings, but it’s frustrating that this wasn’t established from the beginning.
The driving incident
Another thing that really affected my experience was driving.
I’m from South America, where driving is very different from driving in the UK. I was expected to start driving the family car during my first week, despite having very little experience driving on the opposite side of the road, dealing with British roundabouts and navigating unfamiliar roads.
On my seventh day in the UK, I had an accident with the car.
I take responsibility for the accident, and I subsequently arranged driving lessons, which were genuinely helpful. My instructor taught me things about British roads and driving conventions that I could never have simply figured out through experience or following a GPS.
Before moving to the UK, I regularly drove for approximately an hour a day, including on highways, and had never had an accident. This was the first car accident of my life.
I genuinely believe that having professional driving lessons before being expected to drive independently would have made a significant difference.
Instead, I was put in a position where I was expected to figure things out as I went along. I eventually paid £600 for the car insurance excess and another £300 for driving lessons.
I understand that driving is part of the arrangement, but I also think families should recognise that moving to another country means adjusting to an entirely different driving environment. A few professional lessons before handing someone the keys would have made a huge difference.
We agreed to start over, but nothing changed
About a month after the accident, the family bought a new car. We had a conversation where they told me that we would turn the page, start over and move forward. I genuinely appreciated that because I wanted a fresh start too.
However, despite that conversation, the mother’s attitude towards me hasn’t really changed. She continues to be hostile and disproportionately critical over the smallest things.
I completely understand that the accident was serious. I’m not trying to minimise what happened or avoid responsibility. But I also feel that the circumstances leading up to it should be considered.
I was a new arrival in the country, had received very little driving preparation, and was expected to drive independently in an environment I was unfamiliar with.
What’s particularly frustrating is that I feel like I’m still being treated as though I deliberately caused the accident, even though we supposedly agreed to move forward.
Even small mistakes become disproportionately big issues
A recent example: I spent an evening cleaning the kitchen, doing considerably more than what would normally be expected of me as an au pair. I accidentally missed one thing.
Instead of simply saying something like, “Hey, please remember to clean this next time,” the mother immediately told me that it was common sense that if I used something, I should clean it, and that I shouldn’t expect the housekeeper to do it for me.
I wasn’t expecting anyone to clean it for me. I had simply overlooked one thing while cleaning everything else.
What bothers me isn’t being corrected. I understand that I’m working in someone else’s home, and I’m perfectly happy to receive feedback and improve. It’s the assumption behind the feedback. There’s never any acknowledgement that I might have made an honest oversight, especially when I’ve clearly been making an effort.
It feels as though every mistake becomes evidence of some bigger character flaw.
She has told me that she doesn’t expect perfection, but sometimes her reactions make me feel like perfection is exactly what she expects.
I also want to clarify that I’m an au pair, not a housekeeper. I understand that there are household responsibilities involved in the arrangement, but sometimes I feel that expectations extend beyond my actual role.
The cultural adjustment seems to be a one-way street
The mother is from a Nordic country, and sometimes I wonder whether some of this comes down to cultural differences in communication. I understand that some cultures are more direct than others, and I’m not expecting everyone to communicate the way I’m used to.
But cultural differences cannot be a blanket justification for hostility or disrespect.
I’m the one who has immigrated. I’m adapting to an entirely different country, culture, household, family structure and set of expectations. I’m learning how things work in a home that already has established routines and dynamics that existed long before I arrived.
Yet I constantly feel that I’m expected to understand her perspective, anticipate her preferences and adapt to her way of doing things, while there is very little effort to understand mine.
It’s as though she cannot step outside her own perspective and consider that something obvious to her might not be obvious to someone who has never lived in her household or experienced her particular family dynamics.
I don’t expect special treatment because I’m an immigrant. I simply expect some understanding that adjusting to a completely new environment takes time, especially when the initial training was so limited.
And I’m honestly getting tired of feeling like I have to justify every little mistake.
The car accident was one thing. But now we’re talking about tiny household oversights, misunderstandings and things that could easily be resolved through a simple conversation. Instead, everything seems to become another opportunity to criticise me.
I don’t think it’s reasonable to expect someone to constantly accommodate your expectations when you’re unwilling to show the same consideration in return.
Where I am now
The children actually love me, and I really enjoy spending time with them. The father is also very kind and understanding, partly because he comes from South America himself and understands some of the cultural adjustments I’m going through.
Unfortunately, my relationship with the mother is becoming increasingly difficult.
I feel like I’m constantly walking on eggshells, trying to anticipate what might upset her next. I’m putting a lot of effort into improving, but I feel that the lack of proper training is directly affecting my performance, and somehow all the responsibility for that falls on me.
I’m also starting to feel genuinely burnt out. I’ve been under so much stress that it’s beginning to affect my mental well-being.
The difficult part is that moving to the UK has been a dream of mine for a long time. I’m here on a Youth Mobility visa, and I really wanted to make the most of this experience. The family would ideally like me to stay for one or two years, and I initially hoped this could be a positive, long-term arrangement.
I don’t want to give up on the experience or move back home because of one difficult situation. But I also don’t think I should have to tolerate constant criticism and disrespect just to make it work.
I understand that being an au pair involves adapting to another family’s routines, respecting their home and learning how they do things. I’m not expecting everything to revolve around me. But I also think there’s a responsibility on the family’s side to provide proper training, communicate consistently and understand that a new person needs time to adjust.
So, what would you do in my position?
Would you try to have an honest conversation with the mother and explain that the lack of training is contributing to these issues?
Would you give the arrangement more time, hoping things improve once you’ve settled into the household?
Or would you start looking for another family before the situation affects your mental health even more?
I’d particularly appreciate advice from former au pairs, host parents or anyone who has experienced a similar dynamic.
I genuinely want to make this work, but I’m beginning to question whether I’m being unreasonable in expecting a little more patience, guidance and basic respect.