[Edit: This was an informative exercise.
To the reasonable persons that responded, thank you for your thoughts. Turns out a few of you had very similar experiences so we appreciate the advice. Although we weren't a match with this particular AP, we at least know that 1) we must disclose fully what we mean by busy and 2) exercise careful scrutiny of the next person that comes in.
To the whiny triggered crybabies that provided me with hilarious entertainment during breaks, thank you as well. You've literally given me the blueprint for how to keep crazies like you out of our home, so cheers 🍻 Imagine suggesting that two professionals who are positively contributing to society are bad people or parents simply because they didn't give their AP enough hugs 😂.... You can all go suck on a lemon 🤟.
Knock yourself out continuing to make disparaging comments here if you wish. I killed the notifications and won't be back at this thread so I won't see em ✌🏼. Byeeeeee 🫳🏻🎤]
Hello au pairs and host families.
We are a US host family and have encountered an unfortunate and unexpected situation with our now outgoing au pair. Thought we'd lay out the facts here and get some thoughts on what (if anything) we actually did wrong and what to look out for in the future (assuming we seek another au pair).
I'll start by saying that my wife is very upset about how this happened and is strongly considering discontinuing the program.
Before au pair started:
-Our now former au pair is from a small town in Europe and in her mid 20s. -She's been here about 6 months. -We conducted several video interviews where she seemed great before we made the offer to be our au pair. The one sort of ambiguous thing that she said is that she wanted us to be like a family (e.g., family dinners, outings, etc). We didn't have a problem with this, but also ensured that she understood that we're both busy professionals (extremely busy in the case of my wife) and that we would spend time with her when we can. We added that it was important that she have some "independence" to do her own thing, and we even purchased a reliable hoopdie so that she can get around wherever she wants on her off time. -We provided a printed manual and explained what would be expected of her.
After au pair arrived:
-First and foremost, she has been absolutely terrific with our kiddo, and we truly believe that she loves our kid. No issue there. -We gave her what we think is a great schedule (M-F, weekends off). -She's been good to us and we feel we've been good to her. There have been a few minor administrative issues (some of it our fault for not explaining) but nothing substantive. -She's has her own room and we ensured all amenities are provided. -She has unlimited use of the vehicle we provided. -The area we live in is nice and there are things to do around. But we also live near a large metropolis that is easy to get to. -She's made friends and has even had a few over to the house. She goes to parties. She likes our neighbors. -She's not complained really about anything, but about 3 months in, she did mention the family connection thing again. We spend time with her on weekends (even when it's just at home), as we welcome her to be with us in most of the things we do. We literally tell her you can hang out with us for everything. However, i admit that my wife has been extremely busy including during weekends and we haven't done much activity wise as of late. Though I'm more available than my wife, I don't think it's appropriate for me the husband to go hang out with our AP and our kid alone. -It's also been hard to sit down for dinners due to work and we have only been able to do that 2-3 times with her. -Lately, when she's home, she'll occasionally hang out with us, but seems to be keeping to herself in her room a lot of the time. But she also goes out a lot, which we don't have an issue with.
Her request to rematch:
-We took her on vacation with us a week ago. We paid for flights, hotel, food, etc. -Although she had some responsibility to watch the kiddo, we also gave her plenty of time to go explore a new place she hadn't been, in addition to hanging out with us when we did things. -At the end of the vacation, she told us she would immediately be requesting to rematch. She was emotional and explained how much she loved our kiddo and how she finds us to be really nice people, but how she never really felt like part of the family. She added that she felt "the au pair program is about [her] personal experience." Her experience is certainly an aspect but not the only aspect. In any case, we didn't think it would be productive to challenge her on that last point. -We were pretty blindsided. We offered to be intentional about doing one family dinner per week and my wife's schedule is preparing to ease in about 3 weeks. But our au pair said she was not interested in mediation. She revealed that she decided on rematching about a month prior and didn't say anything, which could have given us time to find someone else. She probably withheld so that she could go on that vacation on our dime, which is unfortunate. This leaves us in a major bind for childcare that we have not solved as of yet. -We have told her that we'll support her as she rematches.
Out Thoughts:
-At the end of the day, we don't want someone who is unhappy to be caring for our child. -That said, we do not feel that she's leaving for a particularly good reason. Her reasons seem to be somewhat selfish and we thought someone in their mid 20s would be mature enough to keep a commitment. Had she at least given notice, we would have been more understanding. -We also believe that she was just about to age out of au pair eligibility when we took her on, and somewhat wonder if she partly used us to get here knowing she would eventually move on. But we're not dwelling on that thought. -Since, we're in a major childcare jam, we've asked if she'd be willing to stay on a couple more weeks, but she declined. We find it quite unprofessional that she didn't give advance notice after having decided a month prior. -Although we are probably particularly busy, we're not sure what she's expecting to find with a new family. Most people probably need help from au pairs because they are busy with work.
What do you all think?
-What did we do wrong? -By being upset with her, are we being unreasonable? -We really need a reliable childcare solution and wonder if it is worth trying again. What types of flags should we look out for to avoid a similar situation? -Au pairs, what do you feel you'd want a prospective family that was busy like us to tell you?