r/Ask_Politics • • Apr 30 '21

Wouldn’t defunding the police just lead to vigilantism?

6 Upvotes

If the police/prison system was dismantled who would handle the inevitable anarchy, crime wave and vigilantism? What about former cops that got in trouble like Derek Chauvin ?

Edit: I know not everyone who wants to defund law enforcement seeks to abolish the police completely, but many do especially the more radical ones.


r/Ask_Politics • • Aug 11 '19

Could the death of Epstein be today's Reichtag fire?

2 Upvotes

AG Barr launching an investigation on it and Trump tweeting Clinton conspiracy theories on it, despite the fact that both Barr and Trump are connected to Epstein themselves, seems pretty shady to me and an attempt of deflecting from their own ties and possible guilt.

Could this be used as a way of putting the blame for Epstein's death on the Clinton's and the Democratic party as a whole? Trump supporters already believe in the QAnon conspiracy which is that the Democratic party establishment is basically engaged in child trafficking, pedophilia and plotting to overthrow Trump. So it doesn't seem to far out to me that Trump, the GOP and AG Barr will use this to end the Democratic party by arresting the Clinton's and possibly many other democrats.


r/Ask_Politics • • May 18 '19

How do we stop white people turning to white nationalism as they become minorities in Europe and America.

3 Upvotes

Far right agitators are promoting conspiracy theories that there is a plan to replace whites and make them minorities in their own nation which is blatantly untrue. But it seems many whites are lapping this up and as they increasingly become minorities the risk is even more pronounced. I think this could gradually get worse.

Do we need systems of re-education for whites who display nationalist views? Do we introduce tougher laws and potentially prison sentences for those who spread far right ideas. Or do we simply just sit and wait and hope white nationalism dies out?

What are your thoughts?


r/Ask_Politics • • Jul 27 '13

Why do people want Europe to be "diverse" and "multicultural", but nowhere else in the world?

9 Upvotes

After seeing a thread on Reddit about an African minister in Italy having bananas thrown at her, hundreds of Redditors were saying how Europe desperately needs more diversity, and how it would be such a great achievement for an African or a Muslim to be a Prime Minister or President of a European country. My question is...why?

Why do people want this for Europe, when these countries are not like the US or Canada which are new countries founded by immigrants, and are instead homogenous races? Why aren't people demanding a white Christian as president of Saudi Arabia or a Latino president of Japan?

Could someone please explain?


r/Ask_Politics • • Apr 23 '22

Is NATO partially at fault for the Ukraine-Russian war?

0 Upvotes

Articles such as this one:
https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2022/feb/28/nato-expansion-war-russia-ukraine

and the now famous Youtube lecture "Why is Ukraine the west's fault": https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JrMiSQAGOS4&t=1188s

propose that NATO's tone-deaf policies towards Russia and it's expansion eastwards is what pushed the current Ukraine situation to crisis.

However, there is also a counter-narrative that NATO in its current form cannot be a threat to Russia. It is a defensive alliance with no offensive capaibilites. It has no interests in attacking Russia. And prior to the invasion the budgets were being cut and NATO members were drifting apart from each other. The real reason Putin invaded is because he wants to re-create the old soviet sphere of influence, and this would've happened even if NATO did not expand.

I find both sides well articulated, but wondering if anyone with good geopolitical or historical context can shed light on which one is more right?


r/Ask_Politics • • Sep 18 '24

Help me understand how Kamela Harris' policies might play out.

3 Upvotes

Hello! Im doing my research on candidates preparing for the upcoming election. On Kamala's website she is listing her stances on certain issues. Im particularly interested in how some of her ideas would play out if she were elected and those polices came to fruition.

She wants to provide up to $25,000 to help home owners with their down payment on a house. She wants to cut taxes for the middle class and those with children. She wants to go after the cost of health care and cancel 7 billion in medical debt. She wants to raise minimum wage. This is just a handful of her talk points on her website. All of them sound really good in theory but im concerned with the logistics and how each change to the economy would affect each other. Where is all this money coming from that she is going to use to build houses, help people buy houses, cancel medical debt with, etc.? You can't just print more money. It has to come from somewhere. So if she is proposing cutting taxes as well as providing financial relief to some, how will this play out? Wont all of this make inflation worse in some way?

Can someone with more knowledge of government and economics help me understand better? Thanks.

Edit: Sorry I miss spelled her name. I corrected it in my paragraph. I can't change the tile unfortunately :(


r/Ask_Politics • • Nov 20 '24

Were democrats simply tired of fighting?

0 Upvotes

This election cycle I saw much less interpersonal discourse coming from the left or Democratic Party. I saw less explaining policies and trying to convince people even from the candidates. Were democrats simply exhausted from fighting MAGA for 9 years? I have seen many saying they do not care what happens and will not be fighting or organizing. Are they raising a white flag?


r/Ask_Politics • • May 19 '13

Why doesn't the IRS have probably cause to target Tea Party groups, considering their anti-tax platform?

1 Upvotes

We let the FBI investigate people who make pro-terrorist comments, why do we consider the IRS investigating the party of: this, this, and this unreasonable? Aren't Tea Party members reasonably likely to skip out on taxes?


r/Ask_Politics • • Feb 20 '13

If the government wants to severely restrict guns, why not regulate cars to never exceed the speed limit?

1 Upvotes

According to the DOT, "Speeding is one of the most prevalent factors contributing to traffic crashes. The economic cost to society of speeding-related crashes is estimated by NHTSA to be $40.4 billion per year. In 2004, speeding was a contributing factor in 30 percent of all fatal crashes, and 13,192 lives were lost in speeding-related crashes."

http://www-nrd.nhtsa.dot.gov/Pubs/809915.pdf

USA Today poses the question in a different light which demonstrates the effectiveness of car safety efforts. Although the gun deaths statistic includes suicides which account for more than half of the total. "In the United States in 2010, the rate of firearm deaths was 10 people per 100,000, while for traffic accidents it was 12 per 100,000. Firearm-related deaths totaled 31,672 in 2010."

http://www.usatoday.com/story/news/nation/2013/01/09/guns-traffic-deaths-rates/1784595/

So here's my question: if a near equivalent number of people are killed each year by a combination of accidental discharges (about 600 a year) and gun homicides (about 15,000 a year) to traffic accidents related to speeding (about 12-13,000), then why not govern all production cars to never exceed 75mph?

One of the gun control arguments I'm hearing a lot is that "we don't need AR15s for anything"- see Joe Biden today. However, it's actually handguns which account for the vast majority of shootings: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Ushomicidesbyweapon.svg

In contrast, driving is a privilege, not a right (like the 2nd Amendment). So why are people in favor of dramatically increased gun control, but not a possible ban on car speeds (which would be easy to implement on the ECU level)?

EDIT: Plenty of people are saying that the guns=cars is a fallacious argument. Obviously guns do not equal cars. Cars are designed for transportation while guns are designed primarily as weapons. Nobody is disputing that. However, there are parallels. Both can kill/injure if used irresponsibly, and both are currently heavily regulated by the US government. I'm not proposing a ban on cars. I'm simply drawing a comparison to how people would react if ADDITIONAL regulation was imposed on something that everyone can relate to. Going over 75mph is already a crime. So what would the harm be in making it incredibly difficult to do (without illegal modifications)? I'd like to hear the arguments for why those governors should not be in place on all US cars.

EDIT 2: I posted this below as well in response to a thread. My argument can be boiled down to justification of public policy. As evidenced in the previous assault weapons ban, very few lives are saved by these types of measures (again, see Charles Whitman as well). People say "if it saves one life then the ban is worth it." My response is that if that is your rationale for supporting gun control, then you should apply that logic to other legislation as well.


r/Ask_Politics • • Jun 17 '13

Something that has always bothered me - why aren't socialists (or those who champion workers, the poor, etc) more fiscally responsible?

0 Upvotes

I would like to use the word "conservative" in terms of being careful, rather than the political connotations of the word.

Part of me simply doesn't understand it. If you promote the benefits of workers, pensions, healthcare, welfare, etc, it would seem you should have more interest in making sure the fiscal realities stay in line for those promises to become reality. Seems almost a worst sin to promise something, have those workers rely upon that and then tell them "Sorry!" than to simply not offer it at all.

Reading about what is happening in Detroit and how dire of straights it is in, I can't help but wonder why they would let it get this bad. Yes, there were issues outside the realm of their control, but at the same time... why make promises you cannot keep?


r/Ask_Politics • • Apr 08 '22

Is it normal to vote in a new SCOTUS Justice when there’s not a vacancy?

0 Upvotes

I tried googling this but couldn’t find an answer. Seems odd to me that we have a new Justice locked and loaded for an upcoming vacancy, I’m wondering if this is something that has been done before.


r/Ask_Politics • • Aug 25 '16

How is Debbie Wasserman Schultz not immediately kicked out of her South Florida congressional seat after being exposed in the DNC email scandal?

3 Upvotes

I live in Florida and receive her direct mail postcards and see her tv ads constantly. Not sure why she's still fighting after being exposed in the WikiLeaks DNC email scandal helping Hillary and pushing Bernie out of the way. Also how is she allowed to be on Hillary's campaign? How is her political career not over by now!?


r/Ask_Politics • • Jul 07 '13

Why is the government allowed to have secret documents from the people they represent?

0 Upvotes

I know hardly anything about politics and have an extreme dislike for most of it but i do want to find a couple of things out. I was under the impression that the government is a collection of individuals appointed by the public to organise and allocate resources. This should be a job that has no secrecy. NEXT QUESTION What warrants the amount of money that the average politician gets? It seems like a fairly simple job with a lot of terminology that anyone could do by just putting forward an opinion. THIRD QUESTION Are there places one could go to where there is little focus on money and more focus on living? Money seems to be the only important thing in the world. Everyone wants money and everyone is forced into needing money. Nothing is free around me. Im currently reduced to just eating reduced bread from the supermarket because pasta is just too expensive. I hate the world i live in and i cant even afford to get out of it.


r/Ask_Politics • • Jul 13 '24

What if "Biden-Harris" becomes "Harris-Biden?"

1 Upvotes

Just have Biden and Harris trade positions so she is the president and he is the vp. There's no term limit for Vice presidents. She can lead the Free World with a mind free of dementia, while being able to call upon his wisdom and experience as needed. Best of both worlds.


r/Ask_Politics • • Nov 27 '24

Where does the “Kamala is for They/Them” advertisement rank in terms of the most successful political advertisements in (recent) American history?

10 Upvotes

I’m not sure how one can quantify an advertisements success, but I don’t remember ever hearing about how effective a specific ad was from sources on both sides. According to NYTimes the Harris campaign saw a 2.7% point switch to Trump due to the ad and none of the ads tested as a direct response to the ad did much.

There has also been a huge amount of media coverage on the the effect of trans issues on the election largely spurred by ad. Trans issues feel like they are being discussed even more than illegal immigration (another controversial set of issues pushed by activist groups) as a leading issue.

Due to the amount of attention placed on this issue largely due to this ad how does this ad compare to ads in recent political campaigns? Has there been an ad in the social media era that has led to this amount of soul searching?


r/Ask_Politics • • Dec 18 '12

Should judges have lifetime tenure?

0 Upvotes

If not, how should they be "removed"? Age cap (all judges must go at age 75, for example)? Year cap (15 years on the bench max)? Or a political process like voting them out?


r/Ask_Politics • • Dec 10 '12

Why has there been so little bipartisanship in the past 4 years, while the 8 years of the Clinton administration showed that the two can indeed work together?

1 Upvotes

Tried to phrase this as neutrally as possible, because I have seen each side blame the other for the current lack of bipartisanship. My question is: what is different now that prevents the two sides from working together?


r/Ask_Politics • • Nov 18 '19

Does it really matter who the President is?

0 Upvotes

Sometimes I see articles about on how California tries to push minimum wage to $15, but Trump is the President and very much against a raise of minimum wage.

Bernie Sanders is popular because of his $15 minimum wage policy. If he ends up winning the election, how will he be able to make it a nationwide policy? That requires the senate to vote for the bill, but the senate is always Republican majority. So in the end, isn't it up to the governors of the states to implement $15 minimum wage law?


r/Ask_Politics • • Sep 16 '16

If Congress has more power, then why would any Congressman want to be President?

0 Upvotes

r/Ask_Politics • • Oct 23 '14

Has WW2 paid for itself?

1 Upvotes

I found that the total monetary cost of WW2 was $11,292,682,078,166.46 (in 2005). http://caseagainstbush.blogspot.com/2005/04/financial-cost-of-world-war-ii1u.html

But has the profit from media about WW2 (movies, books, games, etc) offset the cost of damage?


r/Ask_Politics • • Jun 22 '21

Why did socialism gain popularity in the US?

0 Upvotes

It seems like it happened over night around 2016. Major changes seem to usually happen gradually, though.


r/Ask_Politics • • Mar 31 '13

Is China, who just started their economy thirty years ago, really that different than the US was a hundred years ago?

0 Upvotes

The US used to be considered the factory of the world, which polluted the environment (some days in Detroit the sky couldn't be seen from all the factory smoke); the US gradually had to implement reforms to protect workers' rights e.g. overtime and minimum wage laws; civil rights was inequal e.g. disenfranchisement of minorities/Native Americans; and the US still has problems with the abuse of prisoners and by the police e.g. shutting down of peaceful protesters of Occupy Wall Street, unjustified officer-related shootings and rapes; the govt still executes its own people through the death penalty, and governmentally the US is plagued with corrupt, selfish officials.


r/Ask_Politics • • Jul 13 '16

Why are so many Democratic voters concerned about police militarization, racism, and brutality but also endorsing gun control? Wouldn't gun control make citizens less safe from police abuse?

0 Upvotes

I'm just concerned that the police are becoming more and more well armed and the citizens seem to not want their second amendment rights in full. If the police can have fully automatic weapons, grenade launchers, armored vehicles, why not citizens? I feel like people need protection from corruption. Some people pretend police abuse doesn't exist, but I've been a victim of it. And although I would never even think of harming an officer who was truly doing their job, if another police officer was abusing his power and doing me harm, it would be nice to have some defense.


r/Ask_Politics • • Jul 10 '24

Why don't some democrats in New York and California move to "swing states" like Wisconsin/Pennsylvania/Michigan/Georgia/Arizona to guarantee an electoral college victory? Biden won NY and CA by over 5 million votes in each state.

5 Upvotes

Liberals in NY and CA wringing their hands about the chances of Trump winning the electoral college could strategically move to states with much smaller margins, instead of running up the vote totals, which does no good at the end of election day. 500k voters spread over just a couple of those states could guarantee a Trump loss. He won in 2016 by something like 50k total votes spread amongst Michigan/Wisconsin/Pennsylvania. It has been done before. Liberals moved west in the 1850s to vote against slavery expanding into the Kansas-Nebraska territories. And that was way before remote work and wifi.

Probably too late for this election cycle, but something I've been thinking about and have only heard one journalist talk about something similar (Charles Blow advocating for black people to move to southern states like Georgia to reclaim majority status and maximize political power). It seems like a relatively simple solution to what many fear is an immediate existential crisis, and much more achievable than a new constitution or new states or constitutional amendment(s).


r/Ask_Politics • • May 21 '20

If Trump has done a lot of bad things then what about the good things?

2 Upvotes

I keep hearing and seeing trump does a lot of bad things in reddit but what about the good stuff?

Can anyone do a pros and cons without bias?