r/Ask_Politics • • Nov 30 '20

Why are US Republicans and right-wing people in the US so opposed to healthcare?

1.5k Upvotes

EDIT: To people in the us, it seems my question was understood only by a few. I am not asking why right-wing/leaning people in the US do not support healthcare, I already know their reasons and that is fine, I am asking why the right-wing of the USA opposes healthcare when the right-wing in most other countries I know of do not oppose healthcare. I am asking why the US right is an outlier.

Basically the title. For context, I'm pretty centre-left and live in Australia and we have two big parties, the more right-wing Liberal-National coalition, and the Labor party, the more left-wing party, and a bunch of smaller ones. Our healthcare was introduced by the left-wing party in the 70s and has pretty much just been added to since then. I do not support the liberal party but unlike the republicans they at least like medicare.

The thing is, right-leaning/right-wing people and the Liberal party are fine with healthcare. If you were to ask an average right-wing Australian about our medicare style healthcare, they would tell you it's a good thing that has benefited the country. As far as I know, they have not tried to remove it, and in fact, the right-wing party added subsidies for mental health care. It isn't perfect but it at least shows that even the right-wing party here supports medicare.

Asking the same thing in the US, however, many people with right-wing beliefs would say that healthcare is terrible, along with most of the republican party? Why is this? Why do the right-wing people here have no issue with healthcare, but what has caused right-wing people in the US absolutely hate the idea of medicare style healthcare? How do right-wing/right leaning people in other countries feel about healthcare, are they more like Australians or Americans?


r/Ask_Politics • • Jan 20 '21

Can someone explain what was "supposed" to happen at inauguration according to people on the Q-Anon site?

484 Upvotes

I've been seeing a lot of posts about how Trump or Q-Anon's "plan" failed and how they all feel stupid right now. From reading a couple of posts it looks like the military was also supposed to get involved? If someone could explain what their plan was and why it failed and what Qanon even is? (is it a man? a social media site? a movement? what is the "white rabbit"?) I just have a lot of questions and could use some clarity.. thanks!!!

Edit: thanks!


r/Ask_Politics • • Jul 16 '20

How come more Americans know about Antifa but don't seem to know who the Proud Boys or other far-right groups are?

464 Upvotes

I realize this is a generalization, but in the few people I asked, all claimed they knew who Antifa was and never heard of Richard Spencer, Gavin McInnes, or the Proud Boys. I find it rather disconcerting.


r/Ask_Politics • • Nov 10 '20

Why is Trump suddenly firing people like Mark Esper and Lisa Gordon-Hagerty?

423 Upvotes

It feels like an odd thing to do right as you lose an election to start firing the administrator of the National Nuclear Security Administration and the Defence Secretary as well as some others.

Why is he doing this?

From what I can tell, America doesn't have laws that allow presidential transitions to be delayed if a war were started so my first stab at a creative conspiracy theory doesn't hold up. Any other more obvious reasons?


r/Ask_Politics • • Feb 10 '21

Why isn’t the entire world, or even a few countries outraged by the Uighur Concentration camps in China?

382 Upvotes

As of a news clip I watched from earlier today, not a single nation is boycotting the Beijing Olympics. I see reporting about the camps from both left and right news sources. So it seems like everyone accepts that it’s happening, and it’s a form of genocide. Where is the outrage??? Is China that deeply intertwined with all global powers?


r/Ask_Politics • • Nov 07 '20

President Trump and the “Lame Duck” Period

354 Upvotes

Our queue is half full asking the same question. I thought I’d address it.

We are entering a period known as the “lame duck” session.

President Trump retains all powers and rights as president until the second President-Elect Biden is sworn in as president. President-Elect Biden has no presidential powers until that moment. Biden will likely begin to receive classified briefings and other important information beforehand, but he will have no power.

Inauguration is set for Wednesday, January 20, 2021.

Edit: Date mistake.


r/Ask_Politics • • Jun 05 '20

A New York judge just ruled that police can detain any person for over 24 hours in light of the recent protests. Why is habeas corpus a right that can be given and taken away? What circumstances justify this right being revoked?

353 Upvotes

It seems like it would be a right protected by the constitution, but it’s not


r/Ask_Politics • • Aug 08 '20

Why are federal and state level Republicans so insistent on reopening schools and suppressing health experts warnings against doing so

331 Upvotes

If it's so dangerous why are they doing it? Ron DeSantis has been going as far as to threaten to fire health department employees who make recommendations that go against his agenda. Why is he doing this? In Georgia some kids got suspended for posting pics of dangerously crowded hallways and the governor of that state is all so insistent on making masks optional and opening schools. It feels like they are just wanting to bury their head in the sand and pretend there isn't a problem there. Hundreds of thousands more people could die. Why are they doing this?


r/Ask_Politics • • Jul 12 '20

In European countries things like universal health care, high taxes, strict gun laws, etc. are considered as policies of "the middle", why do Americans consider these things as "Leftist policies"?

331 Upvotes

Question above


r/Ask_Politics • • Aug 08 '24

Why is Kamala heavily supported all of a sudden?

307 Upvotes

I am curious how Kamala has created such a large following and so much support in such a short amount of time? It seems like last month no one liked her and now she’s widely accepted as most likely our next president?

Has she changed her stance on things? How is she more supported now?


r/Ask_Politics • • Jun 10 '20

Should the U.S. require a licence for law enforcement?

305 Upvotes

Should the U.S. require a licence for law enforcement agents like Doctors and Lawyers?Should they have to be board certified with state wide or national records?


r/Ask_Politics • • Feb 04 '21

Has the Republican party irreconcilably splintered into conservative and “Q-anon”?

290 Upvotes

I see some dems already calling some representatives by Q instead of R. Will this be embraced? Is there enough mainstream support for Q anon for politicians to make political hay by totally remaking party affiliation?


r/Ask_Politics • • Oct 15 '20

If supreme court nominees can't speak about any issues that may come before the court, what is the point of the senate holding a hearing?

286 Upvotes

Amy Barrett seems to not answer any questions of substance in the hearing. Why can't she answer questions about her views?


r/Ask_Politics • • May 21 '15

Does (D) Bernie Sanders have a chance of making the ballot?

286 Upvotes

He seems to support all the right things, why?

Edit: Why is this blowing up now?


r/Ask_Politics • • Oct 25 '24

What do liberals/progressives who don’t vote for Kamala because she hasn’t spoken out much against Israel expect from a Trump presidency?

285 Upvotes

Genuinely curious. He is very explicitly pro-Israel and IMO will let Israel completely level Gaza if he takes office. Do progressives think that by withholding their vote for Kamala over this issue will actually affect any meaningful change? Let me know because the logic surrounding these people is confusing to me.


r/Ask_Politics • • Sep 15 '20

Would Bernie Sanders and Alexandra Ocasio Cortez really be considered "moderates" in other countries?

281 Upvotes

I see this argument on left wing outlets all the time. How true is it?

Specifically for countries like Norway, UK, Canada. Thoughts?


r/Ask_Politics • • Nov 11 '20

With Trump's loss, will 2024 see the rise of a new and more competent authoritarian "outsider"?

280 Upvotes

Much of Trump's appeal was that he was supposedly an "outsider".

I'm kinda thinking that 2024 will see the rise of another so-called "outsider" (I.e..someone who isn't a politician). This person will have charisma and confidence, but be much more intelligent and competent than Trump - like a Michael Corleone esque person. I think this person would run for the GOP nomination too.

Does anyone else share these concerns? Or am I just getting carried away? Thoughts?


r/Ask_Politics • • May 11 '20

Tomorrow the supreme court will hear arguments regarding documents that trump is refusing to hand over. Technically he's telling his banks to keep them. What happens if they rule against trump and trump still doesn't allow them to hand them over? How the supreme court enforce it? The DOJ?

268 Upvotes

Since the DOJ is under the executive branch would they be called to enforce it? Are there other ways the supreme court could make the banks comply?


r/Ask_Politics • • Dec 08 '20

Whats the point of a political debate if the candidates are always accusing each other of lying or exaggerate dirt they dug up about their opponent?

266 Upvotes

And if this wasnt common before this election, will it be the norm from now on?

I should mention first that i already have a very bad taste for these debates since I actually havent watched many. I watched both trump v biden debates and both town halls. I watched the And today i watched the loeffler v warnock just cus this is the last one. Along with clips of debates of the past.

I was extremely frustrated with the loeffler v warnock debate. Loeffler spent the whole time calling warnock a radical liberal, repeating the same lines that had nothing to do with the topic. She obviously was more concerned with making her opponent look bad than showing her intentions as a senator

Like, as long as you repeat the words green new deal, defund police, raise taxes, socialism or communism, Pelosi, etc- you can ensure that youll get votes. Its insane.


r/Ask_Politics • • Aug 20 '20

Russia is not much of a power and has roughly the GDP of Italy. Why does the Russian government behave the way they do?

261 Upvotes

I know they have nukes and everything, but I can't understand why they just can't sit back and keep to themselves.


r/Ask_Politics • • Jan 14 '26

Why doesn't Trump send ICE en masse to red states? Wouldn't they cheer them on?

256 Upvotes

https://youtu.be/zna-pwxuGsg

What Mayor Jacob Fraid said got me asking this question....


r/Ask_Politics • • Dec 26 '20

Why is the omnibus bill so long, 5500 pages? And why is there not more time for senators to read it before a vote?

255 Upvotes

Why is it so easily passed if many senators have not read it? Who is deciding where all this money goes?

Why does one bill have so many different and seemingly unrelated effects? Including;

$ for Space Force

Tax break for race horse owners

$ for sexual abstinence

A provision that China must not choose the Dalai Lama

Illegal Streaming is now a felony

Climate relief measures link

And end to some surprise medical billing

Two new museums

Rural broadband expansion

Criminal justice and higher education reform

Medicaid for Marshall Islanders

4 billion to the US navy for weapons procurement

500 million to Israel and Jordan

Plus more

https://www.nytimes.com/2020/12/22/us/politics/whats-in-the-covid-relief-bill.html

Looking for something besides 'it's just what Congress usually does' or 'Don't you know how Congress works'


r/Ask_Politics • • Feb 09 '21

This article by Axios says that European countries are 35 years ahead of the US in deprogramming efforts to combat extreme ideologies. What exactly have European countries done in this regard?

253 Upvotes

I'm wondering how they have succeeded in ways in which the US can learn from as we combat this plague to our democracy.

https://www.axios.com/fighting-online-radicals-extremism-90b8dcb6-31a7-4321-a53a-c8be5643f7d6.html


r/Ask_Politics • • Nov 03 '20

Why is the American political debate so much about personalities and so little about ideas?

253 Upvotes

I'm from Canada and it seems to me that most of what i read or hear about politics in the US is about how Trump or Biden are like this or like that. The debate does not seem to focus on the issues. Why is that?


r/Ask_Politics • • Oct 17 '20

Why is there such a prevalent belief among conservatives that you can’t be a non-Trump supporting conservative?

252 Upvotes

It’s seen all over the /r/conservative sub and other right-leaning political communities. If anyone identifies as conservative but says they don’t support Trump they get called a RINO or whatever other derogatory term that can be thought up. So why is this? Why is there such a prevalent belief that conservatives HAVE to support Trump?

Also I tried asking this on /r/conservative a week ago and the mods wouldn’t approve it. So that’s something.