r/AskProchoice • • May 13 '26

Question from Undecided How is "terminating a pregnancy" not killing a baby?

0 Upvotes

I often hear pro-choice people say that abortion is not the act of killing a baby, but rather abortion is the act of "terminating a pregnancy". But I have never really understood this line of reasoning. It has never made sense to me, and has always just come off as mental gymnastics and rationalization. It seems obvious and indisputable to me that abortion is the act of killing a baby (or killing a child). Saying that abortion is not killing a baby but is "terminating a pregnancy" is just making a distinction without a difference.

And the two are not mutually exclusive; it is not an either/or scenario. An abortion can both kill a baby and terminate a pregnancy. An abortion can kill a baby by terminating the pregnancy. An abortion can terminate a pregnancy by killing the baby. The concept of "terminating a pregnancy" seems to commit the false dichotomy fallacy: an abortion is not necessarily either baby-killing or pregnancy-terminating -- it can be both.

It seems to me there is no question that abortion is the killing of a baby. The meaningful questions here are questions like whether the reason for the baby-killing is a good reason, and whether the baby is being killed in a phase in its development where the baby wouldn't too much mind being killed. It seems disingenuous to base the moral debate of abortion around a question whose answer is obvious and tangential to the real issue.

Can you help me understand what exactly pro-choicers mean when they use the phrase "terminating a pregnancy"? Why is that an important statement to make regarding abortion? That statement has always come off to me as euphemistic bullshit; what exactly am I missing here? How is "terminating a pregnancy" meaningfully different from "killing a baby"?


r/AskProchoice • • Jul 29 '22

Asked by prolifer Why does the government have the power to require women to dedicate their lives for 18 years (unless adoption), but not 9 months?

0 Upvotes

It just seems to me like a weird exception. The government pretty obviously has power over everyone’s bodies (vaccines mainly, and it’s used for the purpose of protecting others), and very obviously has power to punish for child neglect (again, used for the purpose of protecting others). So why shouldn’t they have the power to protect fetuses? Is it just because of how much harder pregnancy is?

This question does operate under the assumption that a fetus is alive and has moral standing, but the strongest pro choice arguments I’ve seen also operate on that, so I don’t think it’s too far. (Sorry if this counts as a gotcha question. I am actually curious about it.)


r/AskProchoice • • Aug 31 '25

Asked by prochoicer If people don't want to get pregnant, why do they knowingly have unprotected sex?

1 Upvotes

I have to start this with saying im a very pro choice person. I think anyone should be able to get an abortion whenever or for whatever reason.

One thing i dont get is people who KNOW they dont want to get pregnant and still knowingly have unprotected sex? No one wants an abortion and im sure they dont either. Then why are they having unprotected sex knowing they might get pregnant?! It makes no sense to me.


r/AskProchoice • • Jun 26 '22

Asked by prolifer Why is the suggestion of using a condom or abstinence so hated?

0 Upvotes

Exactly the title.

As someone believes life starts at conception, it appears to me that a simple way to avoid the need for an abortion for those who either can't afford a child or don't want is to simply not have sex or use a condom / other contraception. Every time I have suggested this I get a very aggressive and angry response. Being that abortion is a somewhat invasive procedure, I would think avoiding that would be preferred.

Anyone mind explaining?


r/AskProchoice • • Jun 19 '23

How is consent to sex not consent to pregnancy

0 Upvotes

Pregnancy is the direct cause of sex and we know contraceptives can fail so there is always a chance of pregnancy so how is consent to sex not consent to pregnancy


r/AskProchoice • • May 05 '24

Is a pregnant woman a mother and her fetus her child?

0 Upvotes

I understand why pro-choice people often protest terms such as "person" or "baby" when referring to the unborn. People define "person" differently and "zygote", "embryo", and "fetus" are the proper scientific term. But do the majority of you also protest the use of the term "mother" or "her child" for the pregnant woman and her fetus? I know this doesn't change any argument as it's just semantics but often an abortion discussion turns into word semantics which I always just want to avoid for obvious reasons.

And if you do protest the use of these terms do you find them factually inaccurate?

This isn't really if you use the term, just if you reject the term if someone else uses it like many of you do with "baby" or "person".


r/AskProchoice • • Jun 15 '26

Asked by prochoicer Why are anti choicers criticized no matter what their position on rape abortions is?

0 Upvotes

I have asked fellow pro choicers this many times but I have yet to get an answer that I really understand. There are two options when it comes to rape abortions. Someone either believes rape victims should be able to abort those pregnancies or someone believes they shouldn’t. But something I have noticed is that anti choicers are ridiculed no matter what their position on this issue is. if anti choicers allow the rape exception, they get called out. But if they don’t allow the exception they also get criticize. I don’t understand it. What do pro choicers want them to do? Thry have to choose one of those position.


r/AskProchoice • • Apr 13 '25

Asked by prolifer Pro-Choice People, what are your thoughts on the Born-Alive Abortion Survivors Protection Act?

2 Upvotes

The act serves to make it mandated by law that any child who survives an attempted abortion procedure be given care by the doctor as opposed to the doctor allowing the child to die. A fetus surviving an abortion is very rare but it does happen and this act would hold negligent or malicious doctor's responsible.

When the bill passed the house of representatives this year, every democrat but one voted against it, with all republicans voting in favor. This surprised me, since I believe the pro-choice movement does care for born children. I'd love to hear your thoughts.


r/AskProchoice • • Sep 27 '24

Genuine question. If abortion isn't murder then when a pregnant woman is killed, why is it a double homicide?

1 Upvotes

text


r/AskProchoice • • Feb 04 '25

Why do Pro-Choice supporters focus so much on emotionally charged rhetoric/arguments when it is not effective to pro-lifers? there are better arguments imo

0 Upvotes

Edit: This post came off a lot more aggressive than I intended, and I am sorry. As I say below, I think there are many legitimate arguments Pro-choice advocates utilize, just that they are often overshadowed by other arguments that are not as effective (coming from a PL prospective anyways). Let me know if you agree that they are ineffective + what arguments you think are better / if you disagree and think these arguments are effective and I'm misunderstanding. Additionally, I intentionally did not include my specific views on abortion aside from generally saying I am pro-life, and I am certainly not saying the PL arguments are perfect or that we do not used flawed logic or emotional rhetoric. It definitely does happen (example: PLers need to stop using religion as a reason for others to be PL, it doesn't mean anything to people who are not religious and it weakens their arguments)

Additionally, I want to clarify that I do not think it is dishonest to hold the opinion that you do not value an embryo/fetus at the same level as a birthed person. I think it's a fair opinion . Biological life does not mean inherent value.

-----

Pro-life -- I come in peace, please at least wait to downvote until you've read the whole thing lol

From what I've heard from the majority of people who are pro-choice, arguments lie in things that are not academically honest. From a pro-life perspective, here are my reasons for where certain pro-choice arguments are weak, why, and what should be focused on instead:

  1. Life begins at Fertilization:

    1. This is pretty much undisputed, and I am not sure why so many people are pro-choice try and argue against it. I cannot tell if it is simply rage-bait or someone uneducated trying to parrot what they have previously heard (not unique to pro-choice people btw, I hear a lot of pro-life people do very similar things)

    2. Since the unique DNA of that zygote belongs is human DNA, we can also logically conclude it is of the human species.

      1. Disputing hurts credibility, why reject biology?

      2. you should refocus on whether said life is morally/legally valuable

  2. "My Body, My choice" is an oversimplification:

    1. If you can agree that the zygote formed is of the human species and is in fact alive with its own unique DNA, you can also conclude then that there are two organisms that are going to be affected. Therefore "my body, my choice" is a weak argument.

    2. It simply just doesn't hit.

      1. The more honest pro-choice argument is: Does a woman's right to autonomy override the fetus's right to life?

  3. Emotional appeals over logical consistency:

    1. Many pro-choice advocates use emotionally charged rhetoric rather than logically sound reasoning.

      1. "The fetus is a parasite." (A fetus is not a parasite—it is the natural result of reproduction.)

      2. "It’s just a clump of cells." (At what point does it stop being a "clump of cells"? If you cannot define that, your argument is weak.)

      3. "Pregnancy tissue." (This term ignores that the fetus is a developing human organism.)

    2. As we established above, this is a living organism of the human species. why dehumanize it? Why can't you acknowledge its humanity? Is it because it makes it harder to devalue it? It simply just isn't honest to dehumanize something human.

    3. If you have to dehumanize the pre-born, you do not have a good argument. If you have to rely on emotionally charged rhetoric, again, your argument is weak.

  4. Arbitrary Standards on what makes someone "Valuable" and therefore worthy or protection:

    1. What defines this? Viability? consciousness? Birth?

    2. If these define personhood, then many born humans would also not qualify as persons:

      1. newborns -- not self-aware

      2. comas, dementa, disabilities

      3. is a 5 year old less of a person than a 25 year old because their brain is not fully developed?

      4. viability would be altered based on our technologies too. would that change your thought process?

    3. There needs to be a standard in order to argue this point.

  5. Emphasis on Wantedness over objective criteria (kind of continued from pt. 4)

    1. The argument that abortion should be allowed because a fetus is unwanted is based on subjectivity rather than a fixed moral principle.

    2. If unwantedness determines rights, this could be applied inconsistently to newborns, the disabled, or other vulnerable individuals.

    3. A fetus does not gain or lose value based on whether someone wants it

What I think Pro-choicers should focus more on is:

  1. Impact on woman's health and well-being

    1. more evidence based understanding for how abortion may improve one's life, although longitudinal studies are very scarce

    2. what medical risks could be associated with unwanted pregnancies?

    3. real-world consequences of banning abortions

  2. Discussing the morality of an zygote/embryo/fetus

    1. IF you can also acknowledge that is alive and of the human species, then we can argue this point all day long. There may not be a true consensus to reach, but we have to start on a middle ground.

    2. Lean heavy on developmental levels of an embryo and zygote, and have a good understanding of what it means. Allow this to guide what you think is right vs. wrong, but if you can't even speak to when an embryo is no longer a clump of cells, you really should not be arguing.

    3. Be prepared to explain why it applies to the unborn differently than newborns or disabled individuals.

  3. Reality of pregnancy and parenting

    1. physical, mental, economic burdens

  4. Lean heavy into statistics of the most common age of abortion

    1. do not invalidate late-term abortions as they do happen, but redirect to the most common kinds

I believe pro-choice advocates have arguments worth exploring/ are legitimate, but they are often overshadowed by emotionally charged rhetoric, denial of biological facts, and inconsistent definitions of personhood. As someone who is more pro-life leaning, I find myself asking: if your goal is truly to change people's opinions, why keep reusing the stuff that doesn't stick?

I am genuinely curious to hear what people think in the comments, if you have similar frustrations with your pro-choice counterparts. I know I have my fair share of frustrations with some pro-life counterparts.

Maybe you disagree and think that these arguments are helpful? Edit: If so, why? Help me understand. I am open to other opinions.

If you have objections to my comments as well, I am all ears. I am also happy to elaborate on more of my opinions if you are curious as I did not really talk about my specific perspective.


r/AskProchoice • • Sep 27 '25

Asked by prolifer Selective Abortion

1 Upvotes

Hi

How do you guys feel about the availability of sex-selective abortion? Is it okay, just as any other type of abortion (in your beliefs)? I'm curious because many pro-choicers come at abortion from the angle of "Oh if she doesn't want her organs used against her consent, the government shouldn't force her to sustain a fetus' life" or some other kind of bodily autonomy/organ donation arguments. But in sex-selective abortions, it's not that one doesn't want their body used, or isn't ready for a child; it's simply because it's a girl. Considering that abortion rights are often framed as women's rights, how do you guys feel about this?


r/AskProchoice • • Jun 25 '25

Asked by prolifer When do you think a human life becomes a human person and why?

1 Upvotes

Or if you don't think a fetus/zygote/embryo is a human life, when does it become a human life?

What are your requirements for personhood? What are your requirements for life?


r/AskProchoice • • May 09 '26

If abortion is all about informed consent... Should you be informed on pro life options

4 Upvotes

I feel that anyone who wants an abortion should have access to pro life options. I personally would say that would be every planned parenthood having a pro life office where a volunteer can talk to the person. It would be completely voluntary but it would be required of planned parenthood to ask at least. " Before we proceed im legally obligated to ask if your interested in pro life options. We have a pro life volunteer on site who would love to sit down with and discuss what options are available to help you. You're not obligated to talk to them and what you choose is entirely your choice". I think this is completely reasonable and to be honest if the "interest" of the woman is what "matters" then shouldn't pro choicers be for this? Since this is giving women the option to be fully informed of all their options.


r/AskProchoice • • Mar 04 '26

Question from Undecided Adoption instead of Abortion?

0 Upvotes

I do lean a lot more towards pro choice, I believe women should have the right to abortion. I do wonder though why a woman wouldn’t just give their baby up for adoption? Is it pain? I heard abortions will cause cramps and make it sore so I don’t think so. Is it to put your fetus out of misery? I know it depends on the woman’s reason but I would like scenarios where abortion is a better option than adoption.


r/AskProchoice • • Dec 05 '21

If women are allowed to have an abortion because it's "her body her choice", then why aren't men allowed to decide whether they want to have their genitals mutilated?

0 Upvotes

And before anyone talks about how they feel personally, keep in mind that one is a hot button issue and it's legal in every civilized country while on the other hand thousands of people have their rights violated every day without anyone giving it a second thought.


r/AskProchoice • • Aug 16 '25

Asked by prochoicer Do you view the fetus as human/having personhood?

0 Upvotes

Do you think fetal personhood should be a thing? If the mother’s body/autonomy was not on the line, and it could be carried to term without her having to keep it inside or her or otherwise support it, do you think the fetus has a right to be kept alive/growing into a life?


r/AskProchoice • • Jun 01 '22

Asked by prochoicer Should rape victims have a choice?

0 Upvotes

If a man is raped, and his rapist is impregnated as a result... Should he have the choice to terminate her pregnancy?


r/AskProchoice • • Jun 12 '22

I have a few questions.

0 Upvotes

I remember a youtuber saying that his child remembered music he and his wife played for her in utero, and another case where doctors ruled a fetus should be anesthetized.

Does thia change anything or is it covered by a FAQ I couldn't find?


r/AskProchoice • • Jul 02 '26

Asked by prolifer Here’s a hypothetical abortion ban scenario. What would life be like?

0 Upvotes

So here’s a hypothetical abortion ban.

1: Any form of medical abortion is now illegal. All clinics for abortion are to be closed down. If you are pregnant then you give birth. End of story.

2: Contraceptives, Birth Control, Sterilization are also banned as well

3: Underground abortions, street alley abortions, or any kind of home made abortion is also illegal

4: You cannot leave the country to get an abortion, and there will be enforcement to make sure of it

5: If you see any signs of someone about to have an abortion or try to circumvent the laws, you have to report her to the police

What do you think life would be like?


r/AskProchoice • • Apr 12 '24

If restricions on abortion are purely to 'control women's bodies', what other laws are being pushed to do that?

3 Upvotes

I've repeatedly heard the argument that illegalizing abortion is an attempt to control women's bodies. But other than abortion, I don't see any other laws that are trying to control women's bodies exclusively.

All of the rest of the laws are restrictions to control both men's and women's bodies (for a greater good). For example: no smoking inside, no drunk driving, vaccine mandates.

What is the proof that abortion laws are to control women's bodies and what would be the gain of that? Am I missing any laws that are being pushed to control women's bodies exclusively?


r/AskProchoice • • Aug 29 '23

Asked by prolifer How does abortion empower women when it's used as a form of genocide against women?

0 Upvotes

Little girls around the world are aborted at a higher rate than boys just for being female. How is abortion empowering or helping women's rights when it's used as a tool to genocide women from existing in this world?

Studies on Sex-Selective abortion:

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3168620/

https://bmjopen.bmj.com/content/3/5/e002612

https://elifesciences.org/articles/79853

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4902709/

https://www.newscientist.com/article/2199874-sex-selective-abortions-may-have-stopped-the-birth-of-23-million-girls/


r/AskProchoice • • Jun 16 '25

Asked by prolifer Would you say a reason Pro Choicers would allow abortion in cases of rape would be because the rapist would try to get child support money out of their victim?

0 Upvotes

I feel like that’s something they would do. And I do not support rape under any circumstances. I made a similar post about this and it flew into my head on this possibility. Is it true?


r/AskProchoice • • Sep 12 '24

Question about late-term abortion survivor beliefs/laws

2 Upvotes

I'm a pro-lifer, but I come in peace with a genuine question because I've never seen pro-choicers IRL/in debate spaces talk about this, and I'm not sure where to find your reasoning on this issue.

Essentially, what do you believe ought to be done if an abortion fails and the fetus/child is alive when extracted from the uterus? Do you believe the survivor should be given life-saving care? Why or why not? Is the survivor a person that has been born or not, in your eyes? Given your feelings on these issues, how do you feel about "Born Alive" laws that are sometimes brought up?

When pro-lifers bring this issue up, the most common response is that this doesn't happen enough to warrant discussion. I understand that reasoning based on the data, but I wanted to set that aside and just ask the question on the merits.

If you have a problem with my premise (other than "this doesn't happen") please address that, or feel free to just send a link to a pro-choice argument you like.

Edit: Thanks everyone for your informative responses. I have more questions, but asking them would verge on debate territory, so in keeping with the original purpose of this post, I'll refrain. Enjoy your weekend!


r/AskProchoice • • Feb 27 '25

Asked by prolifer Got banned from the debate sub so I’m posting here instead NSFW

8 Upvotes

TW: assault

The entire pro-choice argument hinges on consent to the use of the mother’s body. If the mother doesn’t consent, philosophically and legally, the fetus is assaulting the mother and the mother is within her rights to defend herself using lethal force.

However, it’s also my understanding that consent can be revoked at any time, up to and including after birth. If I’m misunderstanding that, correct me.

Some women are mentally scarred by assault and not realizing they are assaulted until long after the assault has occurred. So theoretically could a mother accuse their now-adult child of assaulting them as a fetus and seek damages?


r/AskProchoice • • Jul 13 '25

Question from Undecided Would prochoice laws and policies have more support if the prochoice side just appealed to the right-wings dislike of the poor, undesirables and welfare?

3 Upvotes

Instead of making prochoice arguments about women's rights which most MAGA/conservatives don't really care for would appealing to the right-wings dislike of the poor, undesirables and welfare make prochoice laws and policies more palatable to those on the right?

Selling legalized abortion as getting rid of future welfare leeches and pointing out that abortion reduces the future crime rate because allot of those babies would've been born into unstable environments and unfit mothers that cause crime and deviancy would get MAGA/conservatives onboard to support legalized abortion. I know that allot of those on the left don't want to demonize those who are marginalized but it could be the best way to get the right to support legalized abortion.