r/AskProchoice • • Jul 15 '20

Revulsion =\= downvote

30 Upvotes

Do not downvote simply because you find a post repulsive or stupid.

Did the Op ask a question respectfully & genuinely? (And no, simply being a prolife question does not make it disrespectful or disingenuous.) Then dont downvote it.

Not everyone thinks to our standards. Hence the reason for our sub; so people can understand our views.

Do not turn this into another abortiondebate voting system. If you are in the habit of downvoting prolife posts simply for being prolife, leave the sub please. This place isnt for you.

EDIT
Editing to clarify that we should take issue with seeing a genuine question that has been downvoted.

If someone asks ''why you all like murdering babies?'' that deserves a downvote. They were trying to be an ass and troll.

If someone asks questions that are indicative of what we know prolife organizations rhetoric to be, on a sub whose purpose is for prolifers to ask us questions, downvoting just shows us prochoicers to be the ass. people are put on the defensive over a meaningless downvote, setting them up to close themselves off to hearing what we have to say. It hurts our own cause.

I would rather that if people are going to be closed off to us, it is over the substance of our argument rather than a stupid downvote.


r/AskProchoice • • Jul 12 '20

Frequently Asked Questions

27 Upvotes

A growing compilation of frequently questions towards pro-choicers. Currently, they are mostly from questions in r/prochoice, but will grow as we gain posts on here. Answers are based on common consensus from those other threads, and questions are listed in order from most to least frequently asked.

Why do you say it's your body and not the baby's?

Because it is the adult's body that is pregnant. It is their body that is being used and is enduring a very significant process that alters the way it functions. The choice is whether or not to end that process that their body is going through.

When does life begin?

It doesn't matter. Someone being alive does not give them right to use another person's body against their will. Answers to the actual question vary from prochoicer to prochoicer, but most all will tell you the same thing: it isn't relevant.

Do you want people to abort/would you tell someone to abort?

No. We are pro-choice, not pro-abortion. We believe in and support everyone's choices for their pregnancy, and want each person to have whatever option is right for them. Coercing someone into an abortion is emotionally abusive, traumatic, and in many prochoicers' perspectives is on-par with forcing someone to give birth.


r/AskProchoice • • Jun 25 '22

Empathy for Fetuses?

20 Upvotes

I feel like I am crazy, but I just don't understand how people feel empathy for fetuses. Am I a sociopath?

I understand that anti-abortion folks will drudge up any number of hair splitting philosophical or scriptural arguments as to why it is wrong, but honestly there are plenty of things that I can calculate as wrong on paper, but don't actually care.

What in the world is going on in their brains that makes a fetus "feel" the same as a fully born child. Is it just indoctrination that leads to fear? What I mean is, are they forcing themselves to care or is there a base human emotion I am missing here?


r/AskProchoice • • Dec 29 '20

Asked by prochoicer My boyfriend is pro-life

18 Upvotes

So my boyfriend of almost 3 years is pro-life. I came to respect that as long as didn’t make any pro-life efforts, like he isn’t in any groups nor does he talk about it. However he recently asked me what I’d do if I got pregnant accidentally. I said I’d have an abortion and he called me gross. I really love him but I feel like he doesn’t respect my wishes. He wants biological children and we’ve talked about surrogacy but I have a DEATHLY fear of pregnancy and giving birth. I’ve told him this from the start so I guess my question is if I can make this situation better? I’ve tried to make him see my side of things but is there something I’m missing? I really don’t want to break up with him but I feel that if he really loved me he wouldn’t want me to be forced to do something that would absolutely kill me.

Thanks in advance for any help.


r/AskProchoice • • Dec 05 '24

Help us protect abortion rights in Europe!

16 Upvotes

I’m part of a European movement fighting for safe and accessible abortion in Europe called My Voice, My Choice. We are collecting 1 million signatures from all over Europe and we currently need only 100.000 more. <3

More than 20 million women in Europe don't have access to safe abortion. We want to change this.

Could you support us by signing and sharing the link to sign our initiative: https://eci.ec.europa.eu/044/public

Let’s make sure Ireland stands with the rest of Europe for safe, accessible abortion care. Every signature counts!

Thanks a million!


r/AskProchoice • • May 13 '23

Our little sub has reached 500 members!

Post image
14 Upvotes

r/AskProchoice • • Jun 29 '22

Asked by prolifer struggling

14 Upvotes

hey, i’ve been leaning much more pro-choice recently, but despite being progressive in basically every other aspect, i’ve always struggled with abortion. it’s hard because i feel like so many pro-lifers come from a place of hatred or feeling of wanting to control others, but i genuinely feel empathy towards fetuses.

i am 100% pro-choice in terms of legality, but these questions are asked in terms of morality. also, i’ve never encountered or experienced pregnancy first hand so i come from a place of deep ignorance.

firstly, when a pregnancy has a chance of being deadly, can that always be found out before it becomes deadly? in other words, when somebody dies due to pregnancy, were they always made aware of those chances beforehand, or are some completely unexpected?

my last question is about the fault. i am in no way shaming people for having sex the way conservatives like to do, but i feel like the act of consensual sex is always with the knowledge that there is a chance the fetus is born, and therefore you give up your bodily autonomy because it was consensual and with those costs in mind (obviously this excludes rape and SA). this feels terrible to say but it’s what i’ve struggled with the most. none of the specific reproductive processes that created the fetuses were of your control, but the act that started those processes were under your control.

if you committed an act that put someone in a position where they took control of your body, from my perspective it seems immoral to kill it in order to take control of your body again. if i was at fault for a car accident, and people in the other car were, for whatever reason, forced to use my body at all times to stay alive, i feel like it is my moral duty to do that as it was my fault in the first place, even though it was an accident.

again i feel so terrible about this because i know it must be so terrible for women to go through, including not only pregnancy but birth control and the like, but purely from a moral perspective abortion seems like the wrong choice i guess. i don’t know. i’d like to be educated


r/AskProchoice • • Sep 14 '21

Asked by prochoicer What do you hate the most about pro lifers?

14 Upvotes

For me it's the fact that they are solely pro birth. They don't give two shits about the child after it's born.

Most are against any tax dollars for welfare programs to help parents. Not to mention they are against free healthcare.

So basically have the child, but fuck if it gets born into a poverty filled household, or it gets sick and can't get health care.


r/AskProchoice • • Sep 10 '21

Asked by prochoicer As a prochoicer is it harder to debate prolife men or women?

14 Upvotes

Or are they equal?

Do you find one understands and empathizes more or no?

I naturally assumed pl women would be more sympathetic and understanding but in my experience they have been far more openly hostile and neurotic.

I wouldn't say pl men are more understanding or more good faith debators but they seem to be less openly hostile


r/AskProchoice • • Sep 13 '24

How do pro-choicers respond to data suggesting that illegalizing abortion does reduce abortions?

13 Upvotes

I know for many pro-choicers this is not an argument they use, but I was curious to see those that did use the argument, how would they respond to this data.

I'm also asking because I have such a hard time knowing which side of the moral argument is right so if we could just once and for all say that abortion legalization and illegalization do not change number of abortions, it would be easy to just say legalize it, regardless of its morality.


r/AskProchoice • • Jun 13 '24

Is the deadly outlawing of abortions a form of femicide

13 Upvotes

If restricting access to abortions results in an obvious increase in maternal and infant mortality, and not a single thing is done to address it, does that make the medical restriction femicidal and infanticidal


r/AskProchoice • • Jul 19 '22

Is there a comprehensive list anywhere for companies and brands to boycott/support?

13 Upvotes

Does anyone know if there is a full list (or being added to ) somewhere of companies/brands that give money to politicians and campaigns that are anti-abortion? I want to boycott any apps or businesses that I feel don't align with my personal beliefs. Likewise, I'd like to support ones that do. Is there any that you all know of online? I've seen Walgreens, 3M, etc. but I'm looking for a full list. Thanks.


r/AskProchoice • • Jul 26 '21

Asked by prochoicer How would you word a decent response to this argument?

13 Upvotes

Whenever i get into a discussion with a prolifer they always give me this argument: "consent to sex equals consent to pregnancy so you should take responsibility for your actions hence why you shouldn't be allowed an abortion".

This is obviously ridiculous on so many levels but I somehow never know how to concisely form my response because there's so many aspects to why this is so wrong. It's usually along the lines of 'smokers who get cancer aren't denied medical help, nor are they penalised for their life choices, pregnancy is a threat to life and health so abortion is healthcare which cannot be denied and on and on... ' and then the prolifer usually goes off on their usual spiel that abortion isn't health care, health care doesn't include murder etc...

So my question is, how would you word this concisely in a way that they realise how innapropriate their response is to the situation? Is there a stronger argument than the ones I've just stated?


r/AskProchoice • • Jul 22 '21

If being pro-choice means one should be able to choose what they do with their own body, should this include being able to commit not-living?

Post image
13 Upvotes

r/AskProchoice • • Jun 20 '21

Are these good arguments for the legalization of abortion?

13 Upvotes

I am relatively new to the abortion debate, and am currently undecided on whether I want to label myself as pro-life or pro-choice. However, I've recently come up with two arguments in favor of the pro-choice stance that I'd like to get some feedback about. The idea is that if aborting a pregnancy is made illegal, then it would be effectively forcing a woman to be pregnant and to bring a child into her life, when that woman may have a disdain for getting pregnant or raising a child. My argument is that the coercion of a pregnancy and child upon an unwilling mother can do harm to the child and put the child at risk, potentially far more than it does to the mother.

One reason for this is a matter of physical health. When a woman gets pregnant, she is not merely carrying a child, but is also making the child during the pregnancy. The unborn child is not merely inside of the mother's body cavity, quarantined off from the rest of her physiology; as I understand it, the child is absorbing the mother's nutrients and is actively integrated into the mother's physiology.
Thus, the mother's dietary habits will affect the child's development, and poor health habits for the mother could potentially result in health problems for the child. Also, if the mother has a habit of drinking alcohol or consuming recreational drugs, this could also negatively affect the child's development. Furthermore, a woman who has been exposed to toxic radiation, radioactive substances, or toxic or poisonous materials in her food would be at risk of giving birth to a child with developmental problems and birth defects. Not to mention, a woman suffering from a microbial infection, including HIV, could pass on her infection to her unborn child. I would argue that pregnancy works out best when the mother is healthy, and not all women ought to be getting pregnant and bringing children into the world, particularly when some of those children will come into the world with health problems that arose precisely because their mothers weren't ready health-wise to be pregnant.

The other issue I would bring up pertains to the mental health of the mother. I am leery of forcing a woman to be pregnant with a child even in the event that the child is born perfectly healthy because of the matter of the mother's attitude and mentality towards the child once she is in possession of the child. I believe that people should have kids because they want them, not because they feel obligated to keep them. I want people who want kids to have kids, and I would rather those who don't want kids to go without them. This is not so much for the parents' benefit as for the children's: people who want their kids are more likely to treat and raise them well. I am leery of leaving a born child in the possession of a woman who is, for instance, mentally ill and could hurt the child. Also, there are women who are emotionally unstable and could fail to cope with some of the demands of taking care of a child and then take their exasperation out on the child in a physically abusive manner. I have become aware of a significant number of accounts of young mothers abandoning their children in garbage cans and dumpsters and left to die. There are many accounts of violence by young mothers (and even fathers) against their newborns, involving smothering, strangulation, drowning, beating to death, and other methods of infanticide. I assume these acts don't happen as frequently to the children of wanted pregnancies as to the children of unwanted pregnancies.

There is evidence that there may be an inverse correlation between the legalization of abortion and the incidence of infanticide. One study I've seen showed that while the eastern and western coasts of the US tend to be more pro-choice and the South and Midwest tend to be more pro-life, the incidence of infanticide tends to be higher in those more pro-life areas. Apparently, people are less likely to murder their unwanted children when they have the opportunity to prevent unwanted children in the first place.

In some places in India, baby girls are often unwanted, and there are many stories of baby girls being strangled, buried alive, kicked down a flight of stairs, etc., with the purpose of eliminating them. Even though this sex-selective infanticide has been a traditional practice in India, in recent times the arrival of ultrasound has brought the ability to determine a child's gender before birth, and coupled with the arrival of modern abortion procedures, instances of infanticide have decreased in favor of aborting baby girls in utero.

Now, obviously abortion is not an ideal, final solution to the underlying problems that lead to infanticide, merely a mitigation of the symptoms. But until we can figure out how to stop child murder altogether, I would prefer children be murdered as non-sentient embryos than as fully developed infants capable of pain and emotional distress. I personally have more sympathy for the suffering of sentient beings than for the cancellation-of-life inflicted upon non-sentient beings. While I don't condone unlimited ability for abortion, I also don't condone an absolute ban of abortion that would close the potential for humane destruction of children who would otherwise be destroyed painfully.

What do you think about my arguments? Are these legitimate arguments for the pro-choice stance? Are the premises and data for my arguments accurate?


r/AskProchoice • • Jun 21 '24

Seriously curious

12 Upvotes

Now that embryos have personhood in Alabama and they've been consistent enough to apply that personhood to ivf clinics, are they going to apply known abortions to their homicide rates or include abortions and miscarriages into their lifespan estimates? Also, do pregnant women get tax write offs for the kid within them? I'm just wondering how far Alabama has gone in the pro-life consistency. And how far should states go to validate their appreciation of embryos as people?


r/AskProchoice • • Dec 21 '21

Why do pro life people always bring up fetal homicide laws as some sort of gotcha question, even though they're the ones who created those laws in the first place?

12 Upvotes

They always claim it's some double standard where a fetus is considered a person and if you kill it you're charged with murder, or if you kill a pregnant woman you're charged with two, but they somehow manage to forget who wrote those laws to begin with.


r/AskProchoice • • Dec 11 '21

Asked by prochoicer Do you support the abortion pill being available over the counter in chemists?

12 Upvotes

I feel like this would be ideal and greatly reduce time waiting and having to book in at a clinic

Thoughts?


r/AskProchoice • • Dec 05 '21

Asked by prochoicer How would you feel about a pro life person who holds consistent pro life values outside of abortion issues?

12 Upvotes

For example, I'm pro choice but I could agree to disagree with someone who's consistent. Such as someone who takes steps to reduce the number of abortions, such as affordable birth control and contraceptives and better sex education and more aid for single mothers. And someone who opposes war or supports gun control and universal healthcare or other "pro life" issues that aren't related to the unborn. And someone who wants to make sure children are cared for after they're born, such as making sure they have enough food and get a good education.


r/AskProchoice • • Dec 02 '21

Asked by prochoicer Do you support Banning protestors within 150m of abortion clinics?

12 Upvotes

My country has a thing called "safe zones", where protestors and sidewalk counsellors are actually banned from being within 150meters of abortion clinics.

Do you like and approve of this idea?

Also if its breached they get jail time/and or a $5000~ fine


r/AskProchoice • • Jan 24 '26

Asked by prochoicer Do you believe there is a connection between the anti choice movement and rape culture and if so, how?

11 Upvotes

Is there any way anti abortion sentiments in law or society lead to the existence of rape culture?


r/AskProchoice • • Aug 05 '25

Asked by prochoicer What did you think of Cynthia Nixons "Make Abortion Great Again" hat?

11 Upvotes

You might have seen this, but a couple of months back the actress Cynthia Nixon had a picture of her wearing a "Make Abortion Great Again" hat as a promotion for an abortion rights merch line (i think) and ive seen conflicting views online, from both side. Some have praised it, while others have said that its extreme, and that we should not be "glorifying" abortion, that its offensive to women who have had abortions. Me, i really dont know how to feel. So i was wondering, what do you all think?


r/AskProchoice • • Aug 30 '23

Asked by prolifer Do you believe that abortion kills a human being?

11 Upvotes

I'm (mostly) pro-life, but I'm open to reconsidering my position. The main reason why I am pro-life is that I believe abortion ends a human life, and that all human beings should have the right to live. The only times I think abortion should be allowed are when the pregnant individual is a minor or when it is medically necessary. My question is this: do you believe abortion ends a human life? If so, why are you pro-choice? (I know that wording sounds bad but it's a genuine question, I promise.) If not, why not? What makes the fetus/embryo/whatever not a separate, living individual deserving of life?


r/AskProchoice • • Dec 13 '21

Asked by prochoicer This pro-life website reeks of false info but I can't counter their info well enough ...

11 Upvotes

Bumped into this website while looking up info about abortions. They make it sound like the D&E procedure is incredibly risky for the woman. The way they explain it makes sense but as far as I know it's not true? I had a miscarriage and they explained the procedure to me to move things along, it didn't sound risky at all (opted for miso eventually).

The scraping tools and their descriptions just seem ... not right?

Also, is a regular abortion procedure really so morbid as to 'ripping limbs off'? I read somewhere else that something is injected first or the neck is cut first?

(I'm pro choice, it just bugs me that there is so much misinformation and I'm not yet informed enough to easily spot all wrong info).

This is the website, could be triggering for some: https://www.abortionprocedures.com/


r/AskProchoice • • Sep 04 '21

Asked by prolifer Would you say being actively pro-choice can be tiring at times?

11 Upvotes

Thought I'd ask a different sort of question to usual- do people on the other side of the debate tend to find that it can be tiring to be vocally very pro-choice? The reason I ask this is because I tend (as a pro-lifer that's genuinely far-left on most stuff) to find that it does get tiring (particularly since I live in a very pro-choice country) constantly debating if I'm being sexist, thinking I'm pro-Trump or at least knowing that large numbers of other Brits are going to think this. And obviously stuff like the Irish abortion referendum not going the way I had hoped and thinking that I'm overall losing ground globally (exceptions apply) and fighting a losing battle (in part due to other pro-lifers, who I often tend to disagree with outside of on abortion) is a bit demoralising at times.

I'm curious as to how much pro-choice people have similar experiences of finding it exhausting to be actively pro-choice when e.g a Texas bill to restrict abortion rolls around or it looks likely that Roe V Wade might fall (and when more to the point access within the has drifted towards being harder to access the last few years)- are your experiences of finding pro-choice (or other) activism tough similar at all? Most interested in open-ended answers on this one actually- the longer and less scripted the better.