I (25) was dating a girl (25) since last 4 months. We met on Hinge and had 4-5 dates but soon after meeting I had to travel so I was out of town for 3 months. Initially I was not so much into her but she was into me and over time we both were becoming sure of each other. We bonded really well in our distance apart. Before I left we had done till base 3 but not sex as I was afraid but I just said to her that we'll do later.
I came back in November and we met. For first 2 weeks (till 12th) we did everything except sex.
Context on my medical history -
Single testis: When I was very young (around 2 months) my parents didn't notice that I had hernia and undescended testis and delayed my treatment. So around age of 9 months, my right testicle was damaged due to torsion caused by hernia and it was removed surgically. Also my left testis was stitched into place to make sure it's safe and doesn't undergo any torsion. However, I developed hernia on left side too and had it removed in a surgery but testicle was fine and not hampered. So net in net I have a normal functioning left testicle only, right ain't there.
Frenuloplasty: I have phimosis and tight foreskin so to get it treated my doctor said instead of circumcision you can go with penile frenuloplasty. Net in net - it did absolute ZERO improvement and only left a scar tissue on my foreskin. I think my foreskin has got even tighter after it.
My first encounter with the girl I was dating was on 15th November I told her about my testicle thing and also that I have tight foreskin and it pains so I was afraid of having sex (I didn't tell her about Frenuloplasty). As said before, she was always very much into me and said it's all okay, she doesn't care, we will sort it out together and empathized with me.
We tried to do sex (she was on top) next day but I came within 15 seconds of penetration. I used extra lube condom but it was still little painful and I came very early. She was optimistic this day and said it'll improve in a month or so, don't worry, we are in it together.
Second encounter was 2 days after when she came drunk to my house and we tried to do it and she asked for missionary. I go into position but lost erection and couldn't get hard and we couldn't even start. She was visibly very upset and pissed off and didn't say anything and slept.
Then on 19th November we went on a date and it was good but she started giving hints that sex matters to her and she broke up with one of her ex due to poor performance by him. She said that she'll work with me on weekends (on sex thing) as weekdays are hectic for her and she wants sex as a relaxing activity and it's too consuming to be excited and then being let down on weekdays.
On 20th November (Friday) she had drinking plans with her office colleagues in evening and she texted me in morning.
She texted - "I don’t feel physical compatibility between us, and I also don’t see a future with you. My job is exhausting, and I don’t have the energy to put into that side of things physically or emotionally, the way you want. I’m sorry for any shortfall on my part sexually, and I know you’ve tried, but I don’t want to stay in something that isn’t right and risk hurting you or crossing lines. I hope you find someone better, and I’m really glad you felt comfortable sharing things with me, but I’m sorry. I can’t take this anymore. I hope you understand. Take care."
I called her after this and she said that - It already has so many complications and she didn't want to date someone based on their potential, particularly when she was looking to get married next year. Then I asked why was she okay with helping beforehand to which she said that she can help someone who's poor but not someone who can't do bare minimum and she can't accept having return back to me drunk and getting bad sex. It's too physically and emotionally consuming for her after her exhausting job. She said she needs good sex. When I tried to convince her (that I'll get treated ASAP and consult doctor today itself) she said basically she doesn't want to cheat and me and no longer holds any attraction towards me. She said that she doesn't even want to kiss me or makeout with me and that attraction isn't there. She had apparently been contemplating ending things since our second sexual encounter. The night I couldn't penetrate (second encounter) she said she was thinking why did she even come to my house after drinks and she was feeling awful after that experience and didn't want to continue.
So she ended it and it's over now.
What I'm struggling with
I'm feeling quite low. A girl who was initially very interested in me, had discussed marriage and seemed genuinely invested in our relationship, ultimately left because of our sexual incompatibility and my shortcomings. I didn't give a normal 25 year old male experience to her.
I'm now worried about whether I'll be able to have a normal sex life and whether future partners will react similarly.
I'd really appreciate advice on the:
Should I continue dating while getting medically evaluated and treated, or should I take a break from relationships until my sexual health is sorted out and I am medically fit?
In my future relationships - shall I disclose my medical history to my GF? If yes, how early? I felt this time I rushed and told too much too early, but I also don't want to hide anything important.
What should be my next steps? I am just overwhelmed. Shall I get testicle implant (silicone) or get my erectile issue treated? Or get circumcision?
A girl who was madly after me and even wanted to marry me left me because of my inability to even give bare minimum, I couldn't even penetrate. For women here, how important is penetrative sex and sexual performance in a relationship? - Please be brutally honest
Edit - I've had this erectile issue with two other casual partners also where I couldn't even start penetration and has been the case since last 1 yearish. It all started when I got extremely drunk and couldn't get erect maybe due to alcohol. It was the first time I experienced an erectile issue but after that incident I didn't have penetrative sex.