r/AskLibertarians • • Nov 25 '20

Does waking someone up violate the NAP?

190 Upvotes

In other words, does violating the nap violate the NAP?


r/AskLibertarians • • Jul 20 '20

What’s the least libertarian thing about you?

142 Upvotes

Most statist, I guess.

For me, it’s that I love the environment. I do believe that national parks should exist, and I personally think that the only feasible way is for them to be owned by the government.


r/AskLibertarians • • Apr 21 '20

Fuck China, amirite?

142 Upvotes

Not Chinese people. But the oppressive regime that rounds up political enemies into concentration camps, machine guns people who protest the government's human rights abuses, erases history that is unfavorable to them, imposes communism on people without consent of the governed.

Fuck China. And North Korea. And Russia too.

Right?


r/AskLibertarians • • Dec 12 '20

My parents called me a communist because I said the CIA is stupid.

121 Upvotes

Do you think the CIA should exist?


r/AskLibertarians • • Apr 28 '19

Can we stop down-voting genuine challenging questions on this sub?

117 Upvotes

Not every question challenging libertarianism is an attempt to soapbox.

I think it's a little normal to be a bit on the defensive as a libertarian, given that everyone wants to throw a jab at us. And it's easy to get offended by these people. But there are also some decent questions that don't have immediately obvious answers. If you see a question like that, and the OP isn't being an ass, UPVOTE! That means it's a good question that everyone can learn from!


r/AskLibertarians • • Aug 08 '20

Why isn’t libertarianism popular at all?

112 Upvotes

It’s clear that libertarianism is sort of an unpopular ideology. People don’t want authoritarianism and want a lot of freedom so there are some libertarian principles most people hold but I don’t think a lot of people want to eat the whole libertarian pie.

From what I’ve seen, no true libertarian party is popular or even comes close to being relevant in any developed country. A lot of countries do have a classical liberal party but they still believe in a welfare state and a small but strong government.

I hope this question doesn’t come off too demeaning to libertarianism. I’m not a libertarian myself but I do have respect many libertarians I know. I’m just curious.


r/AskLibertarians • • Dec 04 '20

Why is every Marxist from Upper-Middle class families when it's suppose to appeal to the poor?

104 Upvotes

r/AskLibertarians • • Nov 09 '20

It’s amazing how all the people who tell me we need the FDA are now telling me it’s crazy to doubt a manufacturer’s claim that the Covid vaccine is 90% effective.

100 Upvotes

It may be. Just funny how I need to blindly accept that as a fact without discussion but we also need the FDA to keep us safe Fran big pharma.

Edit: oops. This was meant for r/libertarian. Oh well


r/AskLibertarians • • Dec 07 '20

What’s something you wish you could ban in spite of your libertarian values?

96 Upvotes

For me, it’s slot machines. I work at a bar that has them, and the sheer number of people I’ve seen pour thousands and thousands of dollars into them and lose it all is staggering. The worst being elderly retirees burning all their life’s savings on a stupid machine that’s built to take as much money from you as possible. Just horrible


r/AskLibertarians • • Nov 29 '20

What did Milton Friedman mean when he said “if you look at the drug war from a purely economic point of view, the role of government is to protect the drug cartel”?

94 Upvotes

r/AskLibertarians • • May 13 '20

“Mitch McConnell is pushing the Senate to pass a law that would let the FBI collect Americans' web browsing history without a warrant” what do you think of this?

92 Upvotes

https://www.businessinsider.com/mcconnell-patriot-act-renewal-fbi-web-browsing-history-2020-5

The Senate is expected to vote Wednesday to renew the 2001 PATRIOT Act, and Mitch McConnell is pushing an amendment to the law that would expand the FBI's surveillance powers. An amendment proposed by McConnell would, for the first time ever, let the FBI collect records on Americans' web browsing and search histories without a warrant. Another amendment drafted by McConnell would give the attorney general more oversight of FBI investigations into political operatives, like the recent FBI investigation into the Trump campaign's alleged ties to foreign countries.


r/AskLibertarians • • Nov 13 '20

Do libertarians support defending business from looters?

89 Upvotes

I got banned from r/libertarian for saying it was good that Floridas stand your ground law is expanding to protect people who defend stores from looters. Is this not the libertarian stance? I'm super confused right now


r/AskLibertarians • • May 01 '20

I am a free-stater. Ask me anything.

89 Upvotes

(This was posted with permission of the subreddit moderators).

Hello, recently there was a lot of interest in this subreddit about the Free State Project since it was brought up in a question posted here.

https://www.reddit.com/r/AskLibertarians/comments/gb5ud2/you_know_what_would_be_cool_if_a_bunch_of/

I'm a "Free Stater". That means I moved to the state of New Hampshire as part of the Free State Project.

From the website:

The Free State Project is a movement of thousands of freedom-loving people to New Hampshire.

We welcome people who already live in New Hampshire, as well as those who haven’t moved yet. More than 4,800 participants are already in New Hampshire, and about 19,000 more have pledged to move!

By concentrating our numbers, we are turning the tide against big government.

Plus – Free Staters have built an incredible community full of people who value liberty and responsibility.

Basically, it's a movement of thousands of liberty-lovers to New Hampshire to help achieve Liberty in our Lifetime (check out the subreddit, /r/LibertyInOurLifetime). Once people get here, they agree to put in their fullest practical effort to help the cause of liberty.

I'm one of those movers. I am not a member of the board of the Free State Project, or anything like that, I'm just a mover who also helps run the subreddit /r/LibertyInOurLifetime and the Free State Project discord server. I've been here for about 4 years or so, and moved from the Peoples State of New York. Ask me anything.


r/AskLibertarians • • Apr 23 '21

I'm a left leaning person, I've begun to question my left leaning surroundings. Any advice? What am I?

88 Upvotes

Hey, I'm an eighteen year old agender (assigned female at birth) person (I also have ocd and I like girls). I've lived in nyc my entire life, so basically everyone I know is politically on the left. However I've recently been questioning a lot of things I've been raised to believe are true.

I've made a lot of posts here about wanting to remove my vagina, or wanting a girl to top/dom me. Both of those are things I'm actively working on. However, im still a person, I'm honestly not sure where this paragraph was meant to go. Just don't judge me.

I've always been told right wingers we're bigoted and would want me dead for being agender or for liking girls. But I've been thinking, and I actually might be more conservative then I thought.

Here's some reasons:


A- I'm beginning to get a lot of soft bigotry from my peers. They always treat me as a prop or some sort of special person just for being enby. A lot of them are weirdly soft on me and sort of treat me like a child, pulling punches and all that. At this point it just feels like a different, candy coated, form of hate. At this point I'd rather be called dy*e then soft boi.

B- New York and America have been kind of hurt by a lot of democrats policy. Covid has been awful, and I hate the fact that I can't do things that people from Texas can. And Biden didn't follow up on a single thing he promised, we still have kids in cages and we still have drones in Iraq.

C- I honsestly hate left wing censorship. If there's one thing I will always stand for its free speech. I hate what many call cancel culture. People should not be censored by giant companies or angry mobs, and I expected the left I knew back when I was a kid to know that.

D- I hate the socail pressure. I feel super afraid to speak my mind around me freinds. A single slip up and I'm a traitor to the leftist cause. If I said a single thing I said here to my freind group I would be I'm physical danger.

E- the left just seems super anti sex. That's it.

F- I also just found myself straight up not liking socialism or gun control.


I honestly hate myself sometimes for thinking some of this stuff. These types of thoughts make me feel like such a terrible person sometimes.

Im in such a bubble here in new York. I've never even met a right winger or faced right wing bigotry.

Please don't hate me for anything I say here. I just want to understand myself better. I understand that I'm probably just a bad person.


r/AskLibertarians • • Apr 09 '22

Are you all gonna unsubscribe from Tom Woods now that hes a confirmed groomer?

84 Upvotes

UPDATED EVIDENCE

It has been revealed that Tom began a romantic relationship with his now ex wife when she was 15 and he was 26. That's underage grooming if I ever saw it.

Or is this just cancel culture gone too far and we should just give him a groomer pass?

EDIT: link to the full evidence compiled by Fakertarians

https://fakertarians.wordpress.com/2022/04/10/your-facebook-friends-are-wrong-about-tom-woods/

The 26-15 start to the relationship seems to be legit based on comments his wife made about the timeline of theie relationship. Tom lied about the timeline in response (saying they started dating after they got engaged), admitted he lied, and then provided no further detail against the claims.

Oh wow his ex wife's mom worked for Tom at his magazine at the time they started dating. Yikes.

Edit: I've learned a lot about how all of a sudden grooming is ok in this thread or that it isn't grooming by some roundabout method. Shout out to those who actually reckoned with the allegations.


r/AskLibertarians • • Sep 30 '17

What is Aleppo?

84 Upvotes

r/AskLibertarians • • Nov 26 '20

Is capitalism involuntary because you either work or starve?

82 Upvotes

Edit: i really don't get this sub. This is a sub for asking questions about libertarianism, but if a ask a question that you don't like you downvote me? wtf


r/AskLibertarians • • Jul 11 '20

Why are Libertarians so mad about Jorgensen's progressive tweets?

82 Upvotes

It isn't like she wants to put in progressive government policies. She's just pointing out that racism is wrong but people are pulling support because of it. I dont get it.


r/AskLibertarians • • May 27 '21

Why is it so hard for people who endorse government to prevent monopolies to admit that government IS a monopoly that does everything they claim monopolies do?

81 Upvotes

r/AskLibertarians • • Jan 26 '21

Harvard study finds that Quality of government, not size of government, determines prosperity

81 Upvotes

Hey, I'm a libertarian, and I try to always question my own beliefs and change them.

Recently, while doing work for my school, I came accross this article:

https://www.niskanencenter.org/quality-government-not-size-key-freedom-prosperity/

Which basically says that a "quality of governance" variable constructed from the LPI(Legatum prosperity index from the legatum institute) is the best predictor for prosperity, and when making QGOV constant, government size and economic freedom become irrelevant factors.

Is this a good counter to the general libertarian idea that deregulation of economies is always good?


r/AskLibertarians • • Jan 28 '21

What happened with GameStop stock and hedge funds? Is this good or bad? I'm confused.

79 Upvotes

r/AskLibertarians • • Aug 24 '20

Can you be an enviromentalist libertarian?

79 Upvotes

Like I believe that the goverment should have little to no interference with people's lives, I want to end welfare and taxes, I oppose the war on drugs, I think every citizen should be able to arm themselves to their liking etc you know the basic stuff however I just can't bear to see companies ruining the enviroment. It not only hurts the beauty of the planet it also has a negative effect on people's lives. The only times I want to put regulation on stuff is when it hurts the planet (and I'm not stupid. I want to have the most efficient energy sources that produce the least waste. I know some will always be produced I just want to make it so it's as green as it can be. Like I think Nuclear energy is still the best for the enviroment despite it's producing waste because the waste it produces is significantly less than the materials we'd need to discard after they're old from renewable energy sources.)

So is this still Libertarianism?


r/AskLibertarians • • Sep 19 '19

Wal Mart pushes for minimum wage increase. 👀

78 Upvotes

https://www.pymnts.com/news/retail/2019/walmart-ceo-raise-minimum-wage/

Is Wal Mart doing this because they want to screw their competitors?

If they just wanted THEIR employees to get paid $15 per hour they’d do it themselves and leave it at that. I smell a fucking rat. 🐀


r/AskLibertarians • • Feb 05 '25

Does anyone else feel like a lot of "libertarian" online spaces are infiltrated by people who aren't actually libertarian?

77 Upvotes

I just feel like a lot of "libertarians" in online spaces, especially the subreddits, are often just conservatives who call themselves libertarian or just straight up alt-rightists. I swear half of the posts I see on r/libertarianmeme nowadays are just mfs dick riding Trump or bitching about "wokeness" rather than about actual libertarianism.


r/AskLibertarians • • Jan 14 '21

How *dare* you still believe in capitalism after it created that cringy Grubhub ad that I saw in all those memes?

77 Upvotes

How frickin dare you?