r/AskLibertarians • • May 24 '25

Why are so many people who claim to be libertarians so blatantly racist?

1 Upvotes

https://www.reddit.com/r/libertarianmeme/s/jiqrQO2C45

This whole thread has some really vile racism and antisemitism.

Nothing about either racism or antisemtiism is libertarian. It’s just bigotry.


r/AskLibertarians • • Feb 08 '26

Are any Libertarians considering joining the anti-ICE protests?

1 Upvotes

I’m not talking about “Republicans who like weed” libertarians but actual libertarians. The Federal government is consolidating unprecedented amounts of power and is using it to control cities, states, corporations, organizations and universities. They’re currently using federal agents to terrorize Minnesota so that they’ll hand over their voter rolls (Trump wants to nationalize elections FOR SOME REASON.)

Anarchists and socialists are working together to prevent a fascist/authoritarian take over even though we have our differences, why can’t libertarians join? I personally think anarchists and libertarians have more similarities government wise than socialists and anarchists do, it’s just social values that socialists and anarchists tend to share (we both don’t believe in “natural” hierarchies and tend to believe in all that hippy equality stuff.)

I dunno, I grew up hanging around a lot of libertarians (most became anarchists) and I’m surprised y’all aren’t more up in arms about everything going on.


r/AskLibertarians • • Apr 06 '25

How do you feel about israel murdering 15 emergency workers and putting them in a mass grave?

0 Upvotes

Initially they lied and said that they didn't have their emergency lights on and were approaching the idf soldiers suspiciously but when the graves were dug their lies were exposed when a camera was retrieved.

It was shown that they did have their lights on and were operating normally responding to a call.

The Israeli media is having a hard time with this one as they are not able to ignore it as they usually do as it has made international news.

This is irrefutable evidence that the idf does indeed operate like a terrorist organization no different than isis but tries to keep the veneer of civilty somehow.

Also the bodies were retrieved with handcuffs from the mass graves.

Israel has admitted they were "mistaken" (lying) about the lights and the fact they were approaching idf soldiers.

Yeah you don't get to say it was an honest mistake when you get caught red handed and evidence refutes your claims.

Have your views changed at all given this irrefutable evidence of terrorism by the idf? Do you still think hamas is actually worse?


r/AskLibertarians • • Feb 16 '26

Why does Trump get away with everything?

1 Upvotes

Trump has insulted veterans, people with disabilities, women, & almost every minority group in America. He's incredibly flawed. He's run multiple scams. He's openly corrupt. Yet he keeps being rewarded by being given more power & money.


r/AskLibertarians • • Aug 05 '22

Is it crazy that Alex Jones is being sued for promoting misinformation but not the mainstream media who does that on a vastly larger scale?

0 Upvotes

r/AskLibertarians • • Mar 14 '25

Do you have to be libertarian on EVERY issue to be a libertarian?

0 Upvotes

For example, can you be a libertarian and believe children under 12 should have to wear a seatbelt? I'm all for teens and adults having that choice, but I'm not gonna risk my own young kids.


r/AskLibertarians • • Feb 10 '26

How do you expect to peacefully win against people who use force?

0 Upvotes

Ex-libertarian here.

The reason I stopped being a libertarian is because I realized that the world does not run on reason or justice. Are you guys correct about economics, and that libertarianism is the only consistent moral philsophy? Yes. But no one cares. It doesn't matter that you guys are right (which you are) because your opponents are still going to kill you anyway.

Libertarianism tries to meet its opponents on its own level, i.e. reason, which you simply cannot do. You cannot import millions of unassimilated immigrants or allow leftists to operate freely without them using the freedom (and by extension power) you gave them to dominate and kill you. For this reason I've become much more sympathetic to more hands-on right wing government.

The minor reduction in certain civil liberties, usually self-destructive ones anyway, is simply worth the much stronger guarantee of other liberties and luxuries. Inb4 the Ben Franklin quote. It's good and necessary to preempt left wingers and others who want to destroy your civilization and culture. We can talk about hypotheticals and ideals after that problem is dealt with but for now there are far more important things to address.

I was originally going to make a much longer post going into statistics and specific arguments and such but decided that wasn't productive since it diverts focus away from my actual point to trivial source-checking and arguments.

I'm curious what you guys think of this aspect. When I was one of you guys I spent a bunch of time reading ancap theory and arguing over how private law would be implemented, and never really faced the more pressing immediate reality. So I'm curious what you guys have to say.


r/AskLibertarians • • Apr 15 '18

As a poc why should I be a libertarian?

0 Upvotes

In a libertarian utopia, racism would be allowed to persist and reinforced . I have no good examples of the free market fixing bad behavior; I've seen the opposite actually. Property rights woukd inevitably lead to far more discrimination of poc. We already have seen this. The free market failed to " sort it out". We have endemic discrimination even with govt stepping in. A strong bureaucratic hand isn't bad . "Freedom" just isn't in my best interest as a black man. It disproportionately only benefits whites and the black condition would be even worse if or society was more "free".


r/AskLibertarians • • Jun 18 '25

Doesn't Israel's attack on iran prove beyond a doubt israel is an aggressor nation?

0 Upvotes

How can someone still claim to be a libertarian and support israel?


r/AskLibertarians • • Jun 21 '24

Why do people keep insisting that im not libertarian if I am against immigration?

1 Upvotes

Some people keep telling that im not libertarian if I am against immigration, they insist that immigration is core right of libertarianism.

My Take about it is pure socioeconomic principle. Immigration don't make anything better. And libertarian society has private borders. Even if some citys are welcoming immigrants there is actually difficulty those immigrants to arrive that city course between that city and immigrants are hundreds of layers of private borders. And that couseses main problem. Theoretically if country bordering private holdings allow immigrants cross thought they land then problem will be created, that sooner or later they arrive a point where private owners don't allow tresspass anyone, so moving forward is problematic. And same time moving back might be also impossible, if private holdings don't allow to move through they land again. So what happens immigrants they didn't arrive welcoming city, they cant move forward, they cant go back and they are not allowed to stay on their current point? So big problem will be created course people have right to command they property as they wish. Main stand point why I am against immigration is, that it causes problems that conflicts libertarian rights. Country as shell entity has no right to regulate immigration, but people as private entity have right to manage they property and establish alliances to stop immigrants move forward and repressing those private entity are in conflict with libertarianism. And yet people tell me I am not libertarian.


r/AskLibertarians • • Nov 26 '22

Are Trans people the ultimate Social Libertarians? Are Trans rights Libertarian rights?

1 Upvotes

r/AskLibertarians • • Nov 01 '25

Why the sudden Bernie hate?

0 Upvotes

I’m a liberal who subs to r/libertarian as well as a bunch of other subs across the political spectrum to reduce the echo-chamberness of my feed and understand other people’s points of view. I don’t like to interact with those subs directly as I don’t want to influence them. But I am curious - I noticed in the last day or two a bunch of anti-Bernie posts suddenly appear on that sub. Did something happen recently for this to be happening? I notice one of the posts quotes Massie tweeting against Bernie, is this recent? Did something bring this on?

Thanks!

EDIT: wow, and now I’ve been banned from r/libertarian for “brigading” despite never having posted or commented there (I don’t really care as long as I can still read it but, damn, banned from a sub for asking a question on a different sub).


r/AskLibertarians • • Aug 31 '22

Is it evil to sell drugs that get unwell and unhappy individuals addicted to the poison you are peddling?

1 Upvotes

see above.


r/AskLibertarians • • Jan 01 '20

What if a draft is necessary?

1 Upvotes

When there's a threst and no one acts on it.


r/AskLibertarians • • Aug 16 '25

What is something positive to come out of the Trump 2nd term so far?

0 Upvotes

I think something good to come out of having someone ruthless, and haphazard from the far right in office has unified people from the center all the way to the extreme left. We now have a common cause. I think this has the potential to finally evolve the Democratic party. There hasn't been a democratic i would vote for unless I had no other choice. Its been the same with Republicans. Now that the government is leaning heavy into authoritarianism i have a feeling we could have an opposing candidate who will push for less government. There believe there will be a shift in politics.


r/AskLibertarians • • Dec 09 '21

If liberalism protects individual rights, why is it full of homelessness in liberal states?

2 Upvotes

r/AskLibertarians • • Feb 03 '21

Lib Left is an OXYMORON

15 Upvotes

Every lefty that I've ever interacted with is as Authoritarian as can be. They are maniacally supportive of Cancel Culture among other, do as I say, policies! Aren't libertarians supposed to be the opposite of authoritarian? Not looking to start shit here, I am truly curious.


r/AskLibertarians • • Jun 23 '18

CMV: I believe taxation, despite its coercive element, is morally justified for purposes of infrastructure, military, redistribution, and welfare.

1 Upvotes

Willing to have a debate on any of these topics. If you want to narrow it down to one in particular, go ahead! Or if you want clarification, also go ahead.

Hostility won't be appreciated.


r/AskLibertarians • • Apr 29 '26

Expose the Minarchist Dilemma

0 Upvotes

Do you have minarchist friends? Maybe you’ve made them retreat all the way to what they say is really a “minimum” amount of government. If you want to push them past that last objection to liberty, you could share this with them.

I am preparing to release my book Private Law, Private Order: Justice and Security Without Government Interference that touches on many of the topics this group discusses. I’d love to offer a free copy to anyone in the group in exchange for honest feedback. 

It is less than 70 pages long and very concise with a detailed table of contents. I can provide it in electronic format (pdf or epub). It would only take a few minutes to look it over, even if you only read the summary at the end. If you are interested, just DM me and let me know.

I’m also happy to let this serve as an AMA and entertain whatever kinds of disagreements you may have. If anyone has any questions, fire away!


r/AskLibertarians • • Jun 16 '26

Policy How do you think the libertarian movement and party regain credibility after supporting Trump ?

0 Upvotes

Libertarians should be having their time in the sun Trump is rapidly expanding big government as did Biden before him. Trump was allowed to speak at the 2024 libertarian party convention which should have never been allowed no matter how much he paid them. However they are irrelevant as they still have yet to match Gary Johnson's numbers in 2016. The reason why is obvious they don't care about winning.

Instead they care about doing something, no one knows what just something. Such as supporting a major party corporate politician. The libertarian party supported Trump in 2024, in fact he would have been their candidate the only reason he wasn't was because of a GOP rule against running for multiple parties.

Not only did the LP support him with angela mcardle and Austin Padgett admittig they wouldn't campaign against Trump and only try and take votes away from Biden (this was before Biden dropped out after Chase won the election) but basically every libertarian influence did. Dave Smith the most famous libertarian like hard libertarian for example endorsed Trump. This is funny because in 2016 he refused to support Gary Johnson because Gary said he didn't want to legalize every single drug he just wanted to legalize weed as a starting point and work from there and his Vice president Bill Weld worked for a law firm that lobbied for Raytheon. Well Trump has gone harder on drugs he declared drugs a national emergency said he supported the death penalty for people who sell them and has killed people accused of transporting drugs at sea in attacks that are defiantly not congruent with the NAP and are arguably illegal. Trumps running mate JD vance also takes defense lobby money and was a literal soldier. Bill Weld working for a law fir hat lobbied for Raytheon is unacceptable but JD vane being a soldier in the Iraq war is AOk ?

The NH chapter straight up endorsed him over the party's own nominee. Yes I know they got kicked recently but they were still a part of the LP at the time

In return they got some concessions

Libertarians got fuck all in return for backing Trump, he pardoned Ross ulbricht but he has since killed 8 people for being accused of selling drugs without due process or warrant so was it really worth it ? On top of that Trump started another war and but hey you got one rich American free ! I want to believe we are better however it does kind of hold True there are a lot of unprincipled libertaraisn who only care about the NAP and small government for their in group and reject it for all. They want Ross Ulbricht free and are willing to sacrifice 8 Venezuelans who committed the same "crime" as him to death to do it.

All I can say is I guess Dave Smith regrets voting for Trump ? Better late then never I suppose. Angela and Austin do not though and that indicts the Mises caucus as worst then the prags of old imo.


r/AskLibertarians • • Nov 07 '22

Why are Libertarians usually against environmentalism?

1 Upvotes

r/AskLibertarians • • May 29 '22

What can you do to make your life more libertarian?

0 Upvotes

I think the title should have been what can you do to minimize the impact of the state aggressions toward you.

Yes we can choose not to rob or defraud people. But how do we prevent ourselves from being robbed or defrauded? For example, how do we lessen our tax, for example. How do we free ourselves or minimize impact of stupid regulations to us?

So? What you do about it?

For example, you probably can't change your government by much. But what can you do?

You can trade crypto, or work online to foreigners and get paid in crypto. All government rules like patriarchy, feminism, affirmative action, and so on will have no effect. If you do it right, you can even avoid paying tax legally. In Portugal, income from crypto is not taxed.

Be more powerful. I do not suggest evading tax. However, look for ways to do so anyway. If you can evade tax, chance is, there is a loophole where you can avoid it legally. For example, Google don't pay tax by simply incorporating in Ireland.

Don't get married. It goes without saying. Make your own deals with women. Make small deals first. If it works then knock her up and pay child support. Without marriage, the most you spend is child support. If you move to states or countries with max amount of child support you can limit the amount. I am sure there are ways.

If your kids can graduate by 13, go ahead. Save education cost. If not, why look for more expensive school. Just put your kids in normal school where they can graduate pass or even rank easily. Teach more education by paying private tutors.

What else can you do to make non libertarian aspect of governments much less relevant in your life?

Once you achieve near libertarian life, you can more easily help others.

Any other ideas how to prevent government from hurting us?


r/AskLibertarians • • Mar 27 '23

I feel stuck as a libertarian who is concerned about racial disparity...

0 Upvotes

Open conversation really, mostly just looking for a perspective I haven't considered before. I'm using the NFL just as an example because it's pretty easy to see and understand. Post isn't about the NFL specifically.

Besides two people (pakistani and korean), every NFL owner is white. I don't believe this is just a coincidence. I think it's because of a legacy of historical prejudice and discrimination.

I believe the Rooney rule is stupid. It's just an attempt by the NFL to not deal with the actual issue, but just look like they are doing something on the surface.

But where I'm stuck, is I have no idea how to actually resolve the real issue without infringing on liberty. They can't just force owners to sell to POC, or confiscate their teams from them.

My view is that libertarian ideals don't have an answer to this problem. Actually asking, tell me how I'm wrong.


r/AskLibertarians • • Sep 05 '23

Why do libertarians side against America in international matters?

0 Upvotes

Libertarians often have the same criticisms of foreign policy that you hear from the likes of Noam Chomsky, the latest example is the claim that Russia's invasion of Ukraine was provoked by the west because it began to medle in Russia's sphere of influence. Although I have heard even more extreme examples, for example I've seen Libertarians defend Iran's decision to nationalize the anglo-persian petroleum company that than lead to the coup in 1953.

What I don't understand is even if all of that were true, why wouldn't you still side with america on these issues. America isn't perfect but everything you could criticise america for applies much more to Russia or China, so when America increases it's influence the world becomes more free.


r/AskLibertarians • • Feb 13 '24

Advocating for the right to be racist is not the same as advocating for racism.

0 Upvotes