r/AskHistory • u/Froggymushroom22 • 5h ago
Are there are historical “mysteries “ that my eighth graders can solve? Preferably around 1800 america
I’m having to make some extra lessons for my eighth graders this week. We got talking last week about actually “doing” history which got us talking about events like Roanoke. I asked them how we know what happened in the past even when it’s not written down. They were completely engaged in the discussion. But it didn’t have a satisfying conclusion (even though I think a lot of people agree with happened with Roanoke). Is there a historical “mystery” that we can examine archeological evidence and other primary sources to find out the truth. I mainly want it to be that has a big question that needs answering and a story they likely haven’t heard before. We’re also around 1800 in America so if it could be around that time period, that would be great. But it doesn’t matter much if it’s not.
I tried making a PowerPoint surrounding the sinking of the Heroine in Oklahoma, but I don’t think the sources I was using were reliable. I’ve tried looking up different packets and stuff that do this, but you have to pay for all of them and I don’t even think they are exactly what I want.
I basically want to do like a murder mystery where clues are slowly revealed and need to be analyzed, but instead of a murder, it’s some other type of mystery. Although a murder might be cool.