r/AskHistory • • 5h ago

Are there are historical “mysteries “ that my eighth graders can solve? Preferably around 1800 america

14 Upvotes

I’m having to make some extra lessons for my eighth graders this week. We got talking last week about actually “doing” history which got us talking about events like Roanoke. I asked them how we know what happened in the past even when it’s not written down. They were completely engaged in the discussion. But it didn’t have a satisfying conclusion (even though I think a lot of people agree with happened with Roanoke). Is there a historical “mystery” that we can examine archeological evidence and other primary sources to find out the truth. I mainly want it to be that has a big question that needs answering and a story they likely haven’t heard before. We’re also around 1800 in America so if it could be around that time period, that would be great. But it doesn’t matter much if it’s not.

I tried making a PowerPoint surrounding the sinking of the Heroine in Oklahoma, but I don’t think the sources I was using were reliable. I’ve tried looking up different packets and stuff that do this, but you have to pay for all of them and I don’t even think they are exactly what I want.

I basically want to do like a murder mystery where clues are slowly revealed and need to be analyzed, but instead of a murder, it’s some other type of mystery. Although a murder might be cool.


r/AskHistory • • 6h ago

Why is religious extremism more prominent in the US than in other Western English speaking countries?

0 Upvotes

What if any is he historical reasons the US followed such a different religious trajectory from countries like the UK and Australia. These societies share substantial cultural and religious roots, yet religion seems to retain far more political power in America, including fundamentalist movements seeking to shape laws and public life around their beliefs.

Why did secularization become more widely accepted elsewhere, while parts of the US developed such intense religious resistance to it?

More broadly, why have other Western societies seemingly been more successful at developing sources of meaning, belonging and collective identity outside religion, while secularization in the US appears to provoke a deeper crisis of national identity? What historical differences explain why religion remains so central to American ideas of moral order and national purpose?


r/AskHistory • • 6h ago

What was the Cossack’s involvement in the 18th century Russian colonization of Alaska?

1 Upvotes

What roles did the Cossacks play in the Russian empire’s colonization of Alaska during the 18th century? Where the Cossacks involved in colonizing Alaska as they were in Siberia? If not, what was the major differences between the Russian colonizations of Alaska and Siberia that shifted Cossack participation?


r/AskHistory • • 10h ago

1. What would happen if a central nyc grocery store for instance put a job advertisement "apply within" board out on the street in the middle of the great depression?

0 Upvotes

Just how desperate were people back then? Would queues form? Fights break out?

I was also wondering if maybe outside food markets suffered from lots of theft as unemployed nyc residents try to avoid starving? Surely that would have been the method since you can probably run away if you are caught and the vendor can't exactly leave their stand. Would it have been enough of a thing to make food stands less numerous? Or was their a better bet for the unemployed hungry man back then?


r/AskHistory • • 18h ago

What is the History of Simulation?

1 Upvotes

Recently I was watching videos themed about simulation and wondered if there existed a Document/Video of the brief History of Simulation.

I've searched everywhere, youtube, reddit, google, wikipedia and so on but there isn't a video or document about The History of "Simulation" in general, only gaming simulation, computer simulation, virtual Reality, Videos or documentaries that use simulation to explain something or that we live in a Simulation.

The History of Simulation would have included the earliest possible idea of Simulation, like dreams or the allegory of the cave and games like Catch(a simulation of a hunt) and then go through verious technology like wargaming, 3D simulation, simulation of illnesses on rats, videogames, VR, Reality Simulation, Ai as simulation of a person and so on.

Have you found anything in this direction?


r/AskHistory • • 21h ago

Não temos dimensão do que é uma WW, somos sortudos demais

2 Upvotes

Estava aqui refletindo sobre Mrs. Dalloway e pesquisando sobre a WW1.

70 milhões de pessoas morreram na Primeira Guerra, isso é gente para um cacete até nos dias atuais (seria o mesmo que dizimar todo o sudeste do Brasil em 6 anos). Isso levando em consideração que 100 anos atrás a população da Europa e Ásia era ainda menor do que hoje.

As pessoas eram trancadas em suas casas sendo incediadas, morriam de fome e frio extremo, sofriam abusos coletivos por soldados, viam e sentiam o cheiro dos cadáveres nas trincheiras, sofriam bombardeios que destruiam cidades em minutos, os soldados com TEPT eram fuzilados, internados ou torturados. É bizarro como na escola não temos noção da dimensão real desses acontecimentos.

Por isso, temos muita sorte de morar no Brasil e nascer em uma época de paz (mesmo que o país tenha defeitos, muito melhor do que dizimarem SP, RJ, MG, ES em tão pouco tempo).

Fico pensando, para onde levaram corpos de 70mi de pessoas, será que a maior parte nem está em cemitério? Como que alguns conseguiam sobreviver nesse caos (fugiam para outro país ou existiam locais seguros)? Por que ninguém tentou matar Hitler vendo os absurdos que ocorriam? Por que os soldados simplesmente não se juntaram para matar seus líderes?

Tudo isso foi por ideologia extremista mesmo, ou foram obrigados?


r/AskHistory • • 23h ago

What exactly was the party switch in the USA and what time period did it happened in?

17 Upvotes

So I'm not from the USA but I am really interested in US politics and i have heard about this party switch between the democratic and republican parties that happened in the past but i don't know what it was really, for example i have many times seen people bring this up when someone is talking about how republicans freed the enslaved people in the late 1800s.
Someone please educate me on this!
Thank you!


r/AskHistory • • 1d ago

How did slaves look like in Egypt at Cleopatra times?

2 Upvotes

I have encountered an argument on the net about depicting slaves in Egypt near Cleopatra. One side argued mostly all blacks are what slaves were, other that there were much more ethnics variation. What do history tells about it? BTW was it different for males vs. females?


r/AskHistory • • 1d ago

Who throughout history best signifies the phrase. “You can kill the man but not the idea.”

16 Upvotes

I’ve just watched the “I’m Spartacus” scene from the 1960 movie; and it struck me that the average person may be more likely to have heard of Spartacus than other contemporary figures such as Pompey or Crassus. So I’d like to know who embodies this idea to y’all.


r/AskHistory • • 1d ago

Was there any diseases that spread through the Americas because of Viking contact?

28 Upvotes

I know there were many diseases brought over since Columbus and I was curious if there is any record of similar diseases being spread by the Vikings. Thank you for any info


r/AskHistory • • 1d ago

When did colonists and then Americans in North America start talking without British accents?

65 Upvotes

Was wondering this while my wife was watching Outlander and they’re in the colonies and everyone is fully in their British accents still, which makes sense.


r/AskHistory • • 1d ago

Has any ruler humiliated their spouse in public?

14 Upvotes

I'm interested in researching how to depict an abusive royal marriage based on historical facts, and I would like to ask if a ruler would humiliate their consort in front of the court and important guests and dignitaries, possibly at an important political event. I imagine that depending on the status of the humiliated spouse this would cause great political consequences for the ruler.

This post was mostly inspired by the Book of Esther, wherein the king asks his queen to appear before his guests to show off her beauty, which is implied to be far below her station.

Ive always been aware that this doesnt seem to make sense, because family honor was extremely important back in the day, and historically offenses against the wife were considered offenses against her husband. Wouldnt humiliating a royal wife by reducing her to a serving girl be an insult to the royal family?


r/AskHistory • • 1d ago

Why did Chinese capital move from Nanjing to Beijing?

5 Upvotes

I get that one part of the reason was to distance itself from the painful memories of Nanjing massacre committed by the Imperial Japanese Army and the fact that prior to the CPC’s victory in 1949 it was a seat of the KMT government. Aside from that, was there any particular reason why the capital was moved to Beijing- was it geography, history or just politics?


r/AskHistory • • 1d ago

At what point did Christianity formally separate itself from Judaism?

31 Upvotes

I'm aware of the early years of Christianity originating as a movement within Judaism, and then a few centuries later when you had prominent figures like Constantine converting specifically to Christianity. What happened in the in-between? At what point were they no longer Jews?


r/AskHistory • • 2d ago

What non-European country emerged the most unscathed from European colonialism?

9 Upvotes

Take Siam/Thailand as an example. While it was never officially colonised, it had to make many concessions in order to stay independent: it gave up roughly half the land it used to control to Britain and France, and signed unequal treaties à la Qing China with all the major Western powers granting their citizens and subjects extraterritorial rights.

Of the countries that were able to avoid outright European colonisation during the Age of Imperialism, which had to make the fewest concessions like I described above?


r/AskHistory • • 2d ago

Could prisoners of war rank up, during the Great War?

3 Upvotes

I have two letters written by a Hungarian girl to her brother who was a prisoner of war in Russia. One was written in 1917. X. 19., the other in 1918. III. 16. The first page, which shows the data of the soldier and the sender also says the rank of the PoW, which in the earlier letter is Unterjager, while in the second it is Officier. It was written to the same person, who was not in active military service. How did he go from Unterjager to Officier?


r/AskHistory • • 2d ago

Why didn't people just eat mint and drink normal water when cold water was expensive?

0 Upvotes

Back in the days when refrigeration wasn't common and getting cold water was difficult or expensive, why didn't people just eat mint leaves and drink regular room-temperature water?
Mint creates a cooling sensation in your mouth, so wouldn't that have been a cheap alternative to drinking cold water? Was there a reason people didn't rely on this?


r/AskHistory • • 2d ago

How did banking work in the ancient world?

6 Upvotes

I’m curious as to how people stored and secured their wealth in the ancient world. I’m sure the average person may have simply stashed away their meager coins in some hiding space in their home but what would the wealthier people do if they wanted to go the next step and increase their security? I’m thinking from the middle class such as a moderately successful merchant all the way too the uber wealthy such as a Crassus type figure.

Maybe we can focus on the ancient/classical world? If possible, I’d like to ask how it may have changed into the feudal/Middle Ages.

Thanks.


r/AskHistory • • 2d ago

RAMC helmets

0 Upvotes

So basically I have this Brodie helmet ( not a real one ) and I painted 4 medical crosses onto each side thinking it would be accurate ( I think it looks cool) but it turns out it isnt. Now, I know painted helms with crosses on were not given out by the gov but did any ww2 British medics paint their helms with crosses?


r/AskHistory • • 2d ago

What is the explanation for the Erdstall tunnels?

12 Upvotes

Erdstall tunnels are a set of about 2,000 man-made tunnels, apparently made during the medieval period, typically only barely wide enough for an average person to crawl through and seemingly leading nowhere, but with a complex layout. Most of them are in Germany and Austria. Anyone have any idea what these are and why they were made?


r/AskHistory • • 2d ago

What was Jack the Ripper's real name?

0 Upvotes

Why has it been so difficult to determine his identity despite his fame? For those who don't know, he was a criminal who murdered a series of prostitutes in London's Whitechapel district in 1888. He would slit their throats and then remove internal organs from the abdominal area .


r/AskHistory • • 2d ago

What was the purpose and construction methods of the massive stone heads on Easter Island?

2 Upvotes

I've seen some attempted explanations of the "moai" (big stone heads) on Easter Island, but many of them seem farfetched to me. Are there any good explanations, both of the purpose of these things (what do they represent?) and the methods used to haul them over such a long distance and hoist them in place?


r/AskHistory • • 2d ago

What evidence was there that Joan Of Arc was practicing witchcraft?

4 Upvotes

Looking to build a case around Article 2 of the Libellus: That Joan practiced sorcery and that it constituted heresy. Which sources show this? Is there use anything outside of Hobbins’ record?


r/AskHistory • • 2d ago

Why didnt the islamic world alter the Quran to prevent slave rebellions?

9 Upvotes

In colonial america, the bibles intended for slaves were edited to remove any liberational elements like the Exodus, to prevent slaves from getting ideas about freedoms. This is as far as I know something unique from any slave society.

Christianity is an universalist proselytizing religion which wants everyone to follow it, and therefore every single human has theoretically an inherent dignity which are incompatible with the conditions of slavery, especially the system of chattel slavery in the US.

However, islam is also a proselytizing, universalist religion, it includes the Exodus just like the bible and there were large numbers of slaves in parts of the islamic world. Muslims werent allowed to be enslaved, and islamic law stipulates that slaves become free if they convert.

But Id like to receive a detailed explanation for why there was no incentive for slave-owners in the muslim world to alter the Quran, or prevent slaves from becoming literate out of fear of rebellion?