r/AskHistory • • Nov 17 '24

Why was communism such a failure?

8 Upvotes

I live in a Chinese household and my grandparents have always been Mao’s fans and I never understood why. I know that China during and after communism had the worst time. But why is it so? Keep in mind that I’m not too familiar with communist politics so a general insight of that could be helpful for me to understand better the theme.


r/AskHistory • • May 01 '24

What has this narrative that the USA did not loose the Vietnam war endured?

0 Upvotes

The Vietnam was a defining moment for the United States, Leading to many culture changes and movements in the nation. But one narrative that keeps being Propped up is the United States did not loose the War . Even though that's what did happen?

What are the reasons for this ?


r/AskHistory • • Aug 09 '25

I listened to a recording of a guy that fought for the Confederacy during the American Civil War. He claimed it was “states rights.” Was he in denial or did he just not understand the reality of what he did?

0 Upvotes

I’m obviously no lost causer and I know the Confederacy existed because they thought the institution of slavery was being threatened. That being said, the guy who’s recording I listened to was around 16 when he fought for them. Would he truly have understood that it was for slavery or was he just an ignorant teenager?

Did confederate veterans deny why the short lived country existed years later because they didn’t want to admit they were on the wrong side of history or did they legitimately believe the lost cause propaganda that happened years later?


r/AskHistory • • Mar 12 '24

Is it rational to dislike the Roman Empire?

36 Upvotes

I somehow feel more on the side of the Barbarians and other cultures the Romans saw as lesser. Yeah and the Sassanids, too. I think a lot of people only think of the Romans cultural achievements and their badass army, but they could be very cold blooded when it comes to civilians. Think Germania or Gaul, they massacred entires tribes from time to time, right? Like their great Germanicus. "They make a desert and call it peace." - Indeed. And those Barbarians can´t have been too bad, I mean Theoderic reigned pretty well, or was he already too integrated in Roman affairs?? That might be a good question it its own right. I guess as a historian I would have to be unbiased, but as a writer I am leaning towards an anti Roman position.


So I heard repeatedly I am somehow leaving out none Roman massacres? I know a few, they still don´t compare to what Rome did in my view. Maybe its me siding with the underdog but I sure don´t want to sugarcoat what the others did. Its Nazis vs Isis, but I still feel like the Nazis were a whole lot worse.


r/AskHistory • • Apr 27 '24

If Hitler had not killed the jews/put them in camps, but had still put gays gypsies and the disabled in camps, would he have been so reviled.

0 Upvotes

This question popped into my head this morning. If you ask your average American or Western European most of them will cite the jewish holocaust as the reason Hitler was evil (rightly so). However he also exterminated other minority groups.

So if he had not hated/killed the Jews, but still did everything else he did, how would he be remembered?


r/AskHistory • • Apr 07 '24

Why don’t we learn the History of Africa in school?

25 Upvotes

It’s seems like the history of Africa is frequent overlooked. I’m an adult and I can’t remember ever being given an in depth understanding of African history like what is given to other continents.

It’s so bad because most westerners virtually know nothing about the continent not even knowing like a fraction of the names of the countries in the continent. It’s just so horrible that there is just a total absolute lack of knowledge regarding the largest continent on Earth. Like this is where the human race literally originated?

Some say “ they didn’t have a written history” but that’s not necessarily true. There were massive civilizations like Kush, Axum, Mali, Egypt etc that all have written records of their history yet absolutely nothing for the most part is taught in school.

You get like one blip of info regarding the Bantu migration and like 8 chapters worth of slavery. As an African this is problematic because as a result the only thing westerners know about Africa is poverty and slavery. Also people form incorrect assumptions like “Africans didn’t have civilization untill Europe arrived in Africa”. This is purely because our civilization are NOT taught to westerners. Very upsetting.


r/AskHistory • • Jan 10 '25

Who were some the worst and most egregious soviet apologists in the western world in academia during and even a little after the Cold War?

0 Upvotes

By apologist I'm talking about people who denied or waved off obvious things and events like the Holodomor and the gulags. I'm not talking about what someone from a John birch society type of group would consider to be an apologist, so no low level so called "useful idiots".


r/AskHistory • • Dec 14 '23

Why didn't Cuba develop its own nukes after Khrushchev withdrew the missiles?

0 Upvotes

Cuba was pretty annoyed when Khrushchev decided to withdraw the nukes and end the missile crisis, because it meant there was no longer a strong deterrent to America invading.

They had the motivation as they wanted to deter invasion by America and they had the means as they had connections to African states they could buy the uranium from. Also Israel developed nukes and Israel had a much smaller population, there would be nothing stopping Cuba from doing the same.


r/AskHistory • • Sep 07 '23

Is colonialism really the reason why many countries such as India and African countries are poor?

11 Upvotes

Can you really blame colonialism that happened hundreds of years ago on a country’s economic condition today? Or are there other factors to blame such as corruption and lack of investment in education and infrastructure?


r/AskHistory • • Feb 18 '24

Which non-western country has the most evil past?

0 Upvotes

So we often hear about the bad stuff western countries have done(Native American genocide, Holocaust, colonialism, slavery, exc) and deservedly so because it has the most impact today, but I’m curious which non-white, non western country comes to mind first for you when it comes to having a lot of skeletons in the closet, past and/or present


r/AskHistory • • Dec 16 '24

How many people died because of Stalin?

0 Upvotes

r/AskHistory • • Oct 21 '24

Which country has a bloody history few people know about?

0 Upvotes

Britain, the USA, France, Spain, Germany, and Russia are well-known for having bloody histories because they committed so many warcrimes. What countries have committed a lot of warcrimes but few people know about?


r/AskHistory • • Oct 16 '24

Mentioning colonial crimes often feels like saying you are a vegan. How do you think academics doing public outreach should communicate their findings?

0 Upvotes

I've noticed that almost every time someone points out that colonialism was not spontaneous, that is, one group of humans actively decided to take something away from another group, many members of the wider public respond by almost instinctively mentioning that the indigenous peoples were not saints, killed others too, were "uncivilized", etc., despite the fact that the first person never claimed that the previous inhabitants were perfect.

Do you think that historians of colonalism can ever talk about their subject without so many aficionados wanting to tell them why they are wrong? Or is there something inherent in the subject that makes people feel they are being judged, similar to when someone lets out that he/she is a vegan?

  • For the record, I like meat


r/AskHistory • • Nov 26 '24

How much did American eugenics inspire the Nazis?

1 Upvotes

I've heard it stated that the Nazis based their eugenics laws on those in America. My question is, how much did they take from America? Between Jim Crow, the extermination of Native Americans, Manifest Destiny, and other horrendous things like the Tuskegee syphilis experiment, I could see why someone like Hitler would look to the US for inspiration.


r/AskHistory • • Feb 19 '25

How accepted was homosexuality in major cultures before the Abrahamic religions came along?

0 Upvotes

Like, could there have been Sumerian gay couples, and people would have no problems with it?


r/AskHistory • • Nov 03 '24

Why did America use the idea of ‘Manifest destiny’ to colonise the rest of North America?

1 Upvotes

r/AskHistory • • Jun 06 '25

Why did the Americans rebel against the British even though the British treated the Americans much better than their other colonies?

10 Upvotes

As far as I know, the Americans rebelled against the British because they were unhappy with the taxes and the politics. However, the British did not really treat the Americans badly. The British did not cause terrible famines among the Americans like they did in Ireland and India. The British did not brutally exploit the Americans. The British did not build concentration camps and put Americans in them like they did in South Africa.

As far as I can see, the Americans weren't really treated that badly. The British seemed to be more tolerant of the Americans than other people under their rule.

In the Russian Empire, people were brutally oppressed but they endured. There were many repressions and famines in Russia but the Tsarist regime remained strong. It was not until World War I that the Tsar lost control of the situation and was overthrown.

Considering the above factors, I wonder why the Americans rebelled against the British even though the British did not treat them badly. I know the British did some bad things to the Americans but the British treated the Americans much better than the people who were conquered by the British Empire.


r/AskHistory • • May 05 '25

Could Yahweh have been a historical figure/king that was later mythologized?

3 Upvotes

This thought occured in my head. I have no basis to explain why it came to me, but I wanted to see if others thought there may be something too it, or if it is not a real possibility. What do you think?


r/AskHistory • • Jul 14 '24

Was the American civil war *just* about slavery?

5 Upvotes

I know it was over slavery, but was that the only issue?


r/AskHistory • • Aug 11 '24

Why didn't the Europeans colonize entirely of Europe to the same extent as they did for the rest of the world?

0 Upvotes

The might of the Spanish empire that conquered the Americas and beyond, surprisingly didn't turn internally towards the rest of Europe. The British who went to great lengths to rule at least a quarter of this world, somehow didn't expand their colonies into the mainland Europe. The only forces who ever attempted this feat in its entire history are the Romans, Napoleon of France, and of course Hitler. What prevented the rest from gaining the same motivation? Europe after all is just a tiny fraction of all the other places they willingly conquered.


r/AskHistory • • Jan 25 '25

Why was FDR able to serve 4 terms as U.S. president?

2 Upvotes

I thought there was a two term limit.


r/AskHistory • • Sep 11 '24

Why is Germany one of only few countries to openly acknowledge its past mistakes?

0 Upvotes

The fact that we know so much about WWII is in large part because it happened not very long ago and how massive the conflict was, but we often take for granted just how incredible it is that so much information about it is still widely known by the public, and that even the German government itself teaches it in schools.

When you think about it though, there have been HUNDREDS of genocides, wars and conflicts throughout history that were just as bad, if not worse than WWII, and most countries responsible for these atrocities aren't very open about it.

The Americans hardly ever talk about their history of colonialism in the Carribbean and Polynesia that would be considered just as bad as the British if it wasn't so much smaller in scale. The Turks hardly ever talk about the many war crimes the Ottomans committed in the Balkans, and probably a few more in Arabia and Africa that I'm unaware of. The Belgians hardly ever talk about the sh*t Leopold II did in his spare time when he went on vacation to the Congo. Even Japanese people seem fairly unaware of the many things they did during WWII, and the Americans don't seem too uncomfortable that they also had concentration camps for them. Greece and North Macedonia are still arguing over who the real heritage of Alexander The Great belongs to, as if he wasn't responsible for the deaths of hundreds of thousands of people. And who knows what else I'm missing here? If anything, that only further proves the point.


r/AskHistory • • Aug 02 '26

Did medieval Christians not keep cats around for pest-control?

6 Upvotes

I saw a post on tumblr which really pissed me off, it was a reblog to a post where the OP said that Trump's cuts to the CDC's funding will mean that jews will be treated with suspicion and hostility again because they would suffer less from food-borne illnesses thanks to kosher food restrictions, just as they were persecuted during the plague due to higher survival rates from better hygiene.

In the reblogs theres a statement that really bothered me, it said that "Muslims and Jews also didn't share Medieval Christians' fear of cats as evil animals connected to witches and Satan." They said that the plague was spread by fleas and rats were a common vector, and medieval Christian's homes were "shock-full" of rats because "in one of the stupidest cultural shifts in human history" they no longer kep cats around for pest control, European Christians decided that cats were evil vermins, started hunting and killing them in the cruelest way possible and "more importantly, stopped keeping them as domestic pets and farm animals".

'"Like, they looked at the animal species that literally domesticated itself to become rodent and pest control when we developed agriculture and went 'nah fam, we're good'. "

Since muslims and jews didnt share this "irrational fear" of cats they werent impacted as much by plague as their Christian contemporaries.

In the tags, they said that "medieval christians nearly erased themselves out of the gene pool in the dumbest way possible" which pissed me off really bad, its a harmful idea that medieval christians were uniquely and inherently more dirty and ignorant compared to other cultures and modern people, which is what the post enforces.


r/AskHistory • • Mar 08 '24

Which US president has the most blood on his hands?

3 Upvotes

That line that Truman supposedly said Oppenheimer has me wondering?