r/AskHR • • Feb 02 '24

Career Development ASK YOUR CAREER QUESTIONS HERE!

72 Upvotes

How to get into HR, etc.


r/AskHR • • May 12 '26

AI posts will result in an instant ban.

55 Upvotes

Also, stop asking to post your research surveys.


r/AskHR • • 3h ago

Need advice [VA]

0 Upvotes

I did a round of interviews for a tech company and scored high on the ratings with management and the CTO. they all said they would like to work with me. I circled back a week later to ask about any updates because I had another offer pending. I did not want that other jobs that was pending.
The recruiter said everyone liked me but they are looking to me bring me on as an intermediate instead of senior. She also let me know the team is trying to figure out where I would be placed. It’s been two weeks.

Should I circle back? And in these cases does a person typically get placed.


r/AskHR • • 4h ago

Policy & Procedures [MI] - Failing pre-employment drug test because of legally prescribed drug?

0 Upvotes

I am a nervous flyer and am prescribed a small dose of valium prior to flying, bottle specifically says take 1 pill 1 hour before flight. I do not abuse it. I am expecting a drug test in the next week or two for a new job. I just flew last week and took my Valium. I’m going to fail the test. I read up on this and it looks like there are procedures in place to protect me in this scenario. Has anyone went through this so I know what to expect? Thanks


r/AskHR • • 8h ago

[MO] Need advice

0 Upvotes

In the past 4 years I have lost several family members & close friends including both parents and a boyfriend. Additionally, I've also lost 11 former employees and coworkers. Add in a career change after covid, and I've had some issues. In a nutshell, I've had 5 jobs with various reasons why they didn't work out- but mostly bc I was in one stage of grief or another for that time. My last position ended in Jan, due to a corporate restructuring.

As of now, ive been off work for 10 months. Financially, I'm fine and I've been able to heal.

My question is how do I address this in resume and interview form? The 10 month thing i can deal with- the 5 jobs in 4 years- not so much. I was in my prior career for 15 years if that makes a difference.

Any advice will be much appreciated.


r/AskHR • • 16h ago

Recruitment & Talent Acquisition [CA] Waiting on an offer for a role they're creating for me. How long before I check in again?

0 Upvotes

Hi everyone!
I interviewed with a company in October and was invited back the next week for an in-person interview and office tour with the head of HR and the head of the department I'd be joining. It went really well. I was there for 2.5 hours and also got to meet the VP briefly.
Afterward we went into the HR head's office to talk about the role. I assumed it was the one I'd applied for, but they told me they loved my experience and have been wanting to create a liaison role between departments, which is a lot of what I already do in my current job. They asked if I'd still be interested, and we talked about my current compensation and benefits. When I said yes, they told me they'd start working on it and get back to me soon.

Timeline since then:

Next day: I sent a thank-you email. They replied that they were excited too and were working on "org items."

Two weeks later: I followed up. They said they were still working on org items and asked me to hang on a little longer.

Now: It's been another two weeks with no update.

I know creating a new role takes time and approvals, and I don't want to be a bother. But I'm month-to-month on my lease in an uncomfortable roommate situation, and where I live and what I can afford depend on which job I end up in.

Should I wait another week before checking in, or is it reasonable to reach out now? And is it okay to mention my housing timeline when I do?


r/AskHR • • 9h ago

Workplace Issues [KY] Coworker got hired with a fake ID/surname and became the manager’s pet. Now everyone else is getting shortchanged. How to handle?

0 Upvotes

Hey everyone, I really need some advice because I’m at my wit's end.

I work as a server at a fine dining restaurant. A coworker of mine—who I actually knew before we even got hired here—is currently the manager’s absolute favorite. Every single night, he gets booked back-to-back with massive parties and high-volume covers (often 25+ heads a night), while the rest of us are left struggling to hit 13–15 covers.
This has been happening since we got hired (we got hired at the same time, about 2 months ago)

Tonight, he had 26 guests and I only had 13. It’s completely tanking my earnings, and it's been going on for weeks.

To make matters worse, I know for a fact that he used a fake ID and falsified his last name to get hired because he doesn't have legal work papers, and he's openly talked about planning to leave the country next year to avoid taxes.

At first, I minded my own business, but the blatant favoritism combined with the fact that he's working under a fraudulent identity is driving me crazy. I'm exhausted by the unfairness of watching him get preferential treatment every single shift.

If I want to report this or handle the situation safely, what are my options? How would you handle a toxic manager playing favorites with someone who shouldn't even legally be on the payroll?


r/AskHR • • 19h ago

Question about contract/non-employer online work [TX]

0 Upvotes

Just looking to get hr's insight on a unique situation. I'm a teacher and I got approved for FMLA as a result of surgery. The surgery I'm receiving makes it so I cannot perform physical duties like lifting anything over 10 lb for 6 weeks. In my FMLA documentation it is very specific to physical restrictions and that is what was approved.

Now, I also do online contracting work that is completely independent from my employer and I have no mental impairments that will come post surgery. I'm awake and alert I just cannot do anything physical for several weeks. If I do my online contract work, would that put me in jeopardy for my FMLA? Again, this work has nothing to do with the school. It would purely be contracted work I agreed to previously and it would be 100% online.

Not sure if it matters but I did offer to do some of the online teaching responsibilities and my admin told me no + to turn my email off when it comes to school duties for my full leave. I would have happily done those things but understand why they prefer a clean cut district wise.

Thanks for any clarification + let me know if I need to add any other details!


r/AskHR • • 23h ago

[INDIA] Concerned about a potentially negative reference during background verification – impact on future opportunities?

0 Upvotes

I have recently joined a new company, and they will now be conducting background verification with my previous employer.

I am slightly concerned that my previous reporting manager might provide an unfavourable reference due to differences in our working relationship.

I have had a good performance record over the years, but I am unsure how to handle the situation if the reference feedback turns out to be negative.

I have two questions:

  1. If a negative reference is potentially influenced by differences in working relationships, how can I communicate this professionally to HR?

  2. If a company takes an adverse decision based on one negative reference, could this affect my future job opportunities or background verification with other employers?

Would appreciate any advice. Thanks!


r/AskHR • • 1d ago

Coworker seems unusually fixated on monitoring everything I do at work. Am I wrong for feeling singled out? [PA]

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/AskHR • • 13h ago Mindblown

Employment Law [PA] HR refusing to acknowledge legal name in its full entirety

0 Upvotes

My name is my name. I have not recently undergone a legal name change. My name is my name. I use my middle initial. Tomorrow will be the beginning of my 3rd week, with this employer. Once onboarding began, I had an issue logging in, after the third time. I reached out to HR. They "fixed" it. Immediately I noticed that my name was no longer accurately reflected. I reached out and stated that I noticed and I am confused.

She immediately downplayed it as no big deal, while stating that they only use first and last names. Hmmm...well thats okay I guess for system purposes, even though Ive never ever been told this (44 yo). However I made it clear that my legal name is not first and last only and it needs to be rectified.

On first day, I provided my I9 documents to include drivers license and ss card. In addition to this, I brought it to the attention of IT as that is who my recruiter tried to pin it on. Again, in that moment, it was downplayed again, "oh yea she has an issue with her middle initial." I stood firm. It said he has to take it to the system administrator. IT responded with a direct quote saying, "The administrator said employees dont just get to choose what they want to use. It is only what is on their I9." I expressed my disdain is his response and told him Ill continue my quest with HR. On November 4th, I emailed my recruiter explaining that it seems as they are receiving my ask as a personal special request. I asked for her to connect me with the next person up. This was on November 4th.

As of today, my benefits including my retirement account and payroll is inaccurate. Im frustrated, anxious, and pissed. Clearly HR intentionally did not add the initial. IT systems and HR isnt the same.

This was brought to my supervisors attention. She claims she brought it to her supervisors attention. Yet, Ive heard from no one.

If this was not a thing, Id just be a number in that company, which Im okay with because I like to lay low at work. But Im ready to address this externally. Any ideas of how I can get this rectified before filing an I9 complaint?


r/AskHR • • 1d ago

Workplace Issues [DC] How would you react if your direct report shared a company policy that contradicted your instructions?

6 Upvotes

I’m a non-exempt (hourly) employee at a large company and have been there for about 1.5 years. Our lunch breaks are unpaid.

Since I started, my manager has consistently told the hourly employees on our team that we cannot charge time to overhead for things like lunch-and-learns because they’re considered personal or professional development opportunities that benefit us, rather than actual work.

I never really questioned that until this week.
My manager told me that an all-staff meeting we were expected to attend was also considered personal time and therefore unpaid. Something about that didn’t sit right with me. If a company expects employees to attend a work meeting, how can that be considered their personal time?

That prompted me to look through our internal company portal for the actual timekeeping policy. I found a formal policy document, last updated in May 2025, that explicitly states non-exempt employees should be paid for lunch-and-learns and work-related meetings, including meetings discussing projects.
I sent the document to my manager and another supervisor in a respectful message, simply sharing what I found. Both have read it, but neither has responded. It’s been over a day.

For context, my manager has a tendency to give guidance that sometimes contradicts previous instructions, which can make expectations confusing. I’m not trying to get anyone in trouble or demand back pay. I just want to understand the actual policy and ensure we’re being given accurate information.
I also have no problem being told I’m wrong if there’s another policy that supersedes what I found. I’d just like to see it.

My questions are:

  1. If you were my manager, how would you perceive an employee sending you a formal company policy that appears to contradict your instructions?

  2. Would you view this as an employee being proactive and advocating for themselves, or as someone challenging your authority?

  3. Is it reasonable for a company to expect hourly employees to attend an all-staff meeting but classify that time as unpaid personal time?

  4. Should I have approached this differently?

I’m genuinely interested in hearing perspectives from managers, HR professionals, and other hourly employees.


r/AskHR • • 23h ago

Tenured employee quitting with no notice. [VA]

0 Upvotes

Current job went thru restructuring. In the last year 1/3 of the office has quit/retired. I’m one of the very few left with tenure (12 years).
Highly tempted to give notice same day in order to secure annual bonus, But I don’t want to risk new job. What’s the best course of action?
Give notice and loose bonus? I doubt they’d give anything once they know I’m leaving.
Give notice that morning? If new job reaches out to current company regarding dates of employment I don’t want to risk loosing the new job.


r/AskHR • • 1d ago

Leaves [TX] does using sick time count as "returning to work" after FMLA?

0 Upvotes

I'm currently on leave and my 12 weeks of FMLA ends on 12/20 which would make my RTW date 12/21. My company closes the last week of the year so if possible I wanted to use a few days of PTO sick days (12/21-12/23) to get me through the end of the year and then start working again on 1/4.

How should I go about this, should I put my official RTW date as 12/21 or 1/4? I already spoke to my direct manager and she is fine with this plan, I'm just not sure what to tell HR.


r/AskHR • • 1d ago

[TX] Should I be worried about this meeting?

0 Upvotes

Friday afternoon I got a meeting put on my calendar for Monday afternoon titled “HR follow up w (my initials)” with the description of “Happy Friday (my name), I’d like to get your perspective on a matter, so I’ve place 30 minutes on your calendar based on your availability Monday–Wednesday next week. If the time doesn’t work, please feel free to suggest a better time within these days.”
For context I recently started a new position in a company I’ve worked at for a few years. This role is 100% remote but I have regular meetings with my team members and we aren’t friends but I get along well with all of them. I get great feedback from my boss regularly as recently as last week she has been using my work as an example for other team members and any other feedback has always been “make the font bigger” or “copy me on that e-mail next time so if they ignore you I can add pressure for you”. My boss is not in the meeting, it is only the organizer “senior employee relations specialist”, I even double checked that there isn’t even a tentative hold on my boss’s calendar for that time period.

So I don’t think I did anything wrong? I will scroll on my phone sometimes or look up something personal on my work computer like a real estate website, but never anything inappropriate. But I always meet deadlines and I’ve worked here for almost 3 years with no problems. However, since my team is fully remote I can’t imagine I was a witness to anything recently. My previous team had some turnover for a while but nothing crazy and it was months ago that I was working with them.

Do I have to be worried about this meeting? People keep telling me I’m fine but I’m anxious. And I haven’t talked about it to any of my coworkers obviously so idk if it’s something they are also getting.


r/AskHR • • 1d ago

Verbally informed about a promotion but received no comms from HR. Is this normal? [UK]

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/AskHR • • 1d ago

Compensation & Payroll Question about PTO payout/ [AZ]

0 Upvotes

Below is the exacting wording in the handbook regarding PTO. I find it to be very confusing. Does it mean if I give notice, doesn’t mean if they terminate, how much notice does it mean. The handbook does not specify what the sufficient notice is.

Upon termination of employment, employees will be paid for all vacation time that has accrued but remains unused through the last day of work provided proper notice has been given. Vacation will be paid at the employee’s base salary or base hourly rate of pay at the time of termination, unless otherwise required by applicable law.


r/AskHR • • 1d ago

California [CA] Experiencing a medical event but out of sick time and just came off FMLA

0 Upvotes

Hi, I just need some advice. I came off FMLA 3 weeks ago for a health event. I was in the ER Thursday for a separate health event that is currently leaving me bedridden, unable to stand walk or drive. My job involves mostly driving and lifting. Even if I could get myself to work, I wouldn't be able to fulfill my duties. The pain I am in may not go away soon.

I have no sick time and my job does not allow use of vacation for health issues. I understand my only option is unpaid leave. Should I contact HR instead of my bosses? Do Dr notes really help at all? have missed SO much work this year I am afraid of repercussions. I can't help but feel like I am a nightmare employee. I am just very unlucky this year.


r/AskHR • • 1d ago

What to expect from HR regarding a long time toxic employee [Mi]

0 Upvotes

I have a toxic coworker in a lead position (not my lead) who has been toxic for lack of a better word to just about everyone except immediate supervisors obviously. She has repeatedly gone behind my back to call me lazy (I suspect due to my different job roles and my appearance, I am obese), despite there being no evidence to support it. However recently she felt confident enough to explode at me for no reason on teams and I forwarded it to HR with the support of my team lead and another in different facility. This plus having the department manager admit that he has me visit another site in order to separate us instead of trying to deal with the personality conflict has me apprehensive of the interview with HR on Monday. I plan to bring up her prior behavior towards the other coworkers as well as myself in the interview prior to this event as well as the now mutual animosity between her and my department, is there anything I should avoid/include?


r/AskHR • • 1d ago

Off Topic / Other [IL] I want to move out of HR. What’s something I can do while I figure out my transition

0 Upvotes

Currently working in employee benefits at a large company and have over 10 years of benefit and LOA experience. I’m starting to realize I don’t have any passion for this field and the stress is not worth it. Not sure what I would enjoy doing in the long run, but I know it would be minimal work with adults. Is there something I could try to transition to while I figure out what I want to do? I wouldn’t leave unless I had something else lined up, but I interested in what I could apply for.


r/AskHR • • 1d ago

I don't know what my pay really is. [IL]

0 Upvotes

Odd situation here. Started current job about 7 months ago. In sales. I had a three month ramp. I have a base salary and OTE. Well, that's been changed. I ended up with a 4th month ramp, then nothing for October other than base. Now they've changed the terms, I still haven't received any bonus for October, but what they're forecasting it to be is $600 (ramp was $2500, OTE bonus should be $3000). This 'deal' is only through the end of the quarter and then will re-evaluate. Sales are up. I don't know what to do. Yes I have talked to my leadership and HR, I feel like a broken record. They keep telling me 'just wait, we are going to be really big, you'll make more than you ever thought you would'. I can't walk away either. I don't know what to do. Part of me wants to just say okay I'll wait. Anything extra I make at this point will be eaten up in taxes anyway.


r/AskHR • • 2d ago

[INDIA] I want to go back to my old org because the new org has no projects

0 Upvotes

I'd worked for an MNC for 5 years and I quit because I wanted a jump in my salary. But in my new org there are no active projects and I'm on the bench. I want to go back to my old org but I don't want to compromise on the salary. It's been 1 year since I left the org and I want to go back.

What are some negotiation tips or things that I should do to get back to my previous MNC org?


r/AskHR • • 2d ago

Leadership [BE] Teamlead stuck between 'no overtime'-rule and reality

0 Upvotes

Not sure this is the right sub, but here goes.

I lead a 14-person team in an office environment. HR has a strict policy: no compensation for overtime. In practice, some of my team members put in a lot of extra hours in crunch-periods, followed by calmer weeks, and there's no official way to make up for it.

My informal fix has been to encourage them to take the time back themselves by blocking it in their Outlook as a later start, an earlier finish, a longer lunch, etc. We work from home 3 days a week, so that's easy to do.

The problem is that it is dangerous to make that an official policy: every honest hard worker who genuinely needs some time back now and then, there's someone who logs every extra hour and tries to claim it all back.

I don't feel very supported by HR. Their position is that the team lead has to make sure people can finish their work within 38 hours. With no new hires and a growing workload, that's just not realistic.

Any insights? Has anyone dealt with something similar, or found a better way to handle it?

In essence: not trying to whip my team into structural overtime. On the contrary, I want to protect them by having a compensation method, because some overtime is sometimes natural in crunch periods, followed by calmer periods.


r/AskHR • • 2d ago

Compensation & Payroll [NY] Quick question: how does sterling verify the legitimacy of the a small start up firm just created 2 years ago

0 Upvotes

Is there place for them to check the legitimacy of the firm? Or they check the legitimacy based on the company’s EIN on W2, which is their only source?

Separately, I also heard of this PEO payroll system, which one of my employers use. So the sterling checks with the PEO, the middleman, about the candidates’ employment detail? So the BGC can verify the beginning and ending date with PEO