r/AskHR • • Aug 24 '24

Employment Law Sexual Orientation Harassment: Should I Document w/ HR? [FL]

17 Upvotes

I overheard an unsavory conversation about trans people this morning and I decided to be brave and ask them to stop.

They responded with “we’re just talking about trans people” and I said “I know which is a protected class and an inappropriate conversation for work. It’s making me uncomfortable”.

They did stop the conversation. Should I be documenting this with HR for paper trail? This is not the first time I’ve heard employees speak on sexual/gender orientation but the first time I spoke up. TIA.


r/AskHR • • Jul 01 '25

Policy & Procedures [WA] How do you approach female employee about inappropriate workwear?

0 Upvotes

Throwaway so this doesn't get tracked back to me. I (mid 40's F) have worked at this company for 15-20 years & run all aspects of it. This is blue collar, labor intensive, shop/ warehouse work. In my entire time here, there have only been 4 females on the production floor, all within the last 5 years. It's very hard work that typically requires specialized training. We have never had, or needed, a formal dress code/ policy.

Enter newest employee (F 30's) that has been employed for 1.5 months now. There have been 2 inappropriate dress issues; both times (within the last week) she was wearing a tank top, no bra. You could see the outlines of EVERYTHING. It was only by chance that I saw her either day. I do not know if it was just at the time I saw her or if she has worn those before. The other times I have seen her have not been an issue, so I know it is not consistent daily.

She is currently the only female working alongside 8-10 males. Of course, none of the guys have mentioned anything to me. I have looked over the employee manual, checked to see if there are state guidelines for dress codes and I am coming up empty. In my head, this is a recipe for S Harrassment charges.

How do I bring this up without: 1- embarrassing her or 2- providing fuel for a harrassment charge, even to me if I am the one bringing it up?

I thought about expediting the revision of the employee manual (originally due to be done by 9/2025) and adding a dress code policy. But, would that make it seem like it was done explicitly for her? Or is there another way that won't land me, or the company, in a legal predicament?


r/AskHR • • Jun 05 '23

How to deal with over zealous HR and what are employee rights with biometrics and personal email? [MI]

6 Upvotes

Timeclock/biometrics, what are employee rights? How do you deal with overzealous HR? My employer has a new HR person, I do not see eye to eye with her, I think she's an idiot. Two weeks ago, we got into a disagreement over OT, she said a work week was 14 days (bi weekly payroll cycle, I said no 7 consecutive days and she screwed everyone on OT and that needed to be fixed.

So now she is doing some time clock biometric, face scan implementation that I can only log in on my computer. I spoke with the owner last week, told him my concerns and how she just sent timeclock links to personal email. The owner told me that until he is back from vacation, I am not to click the link and I do not need to use it. My concerns are IT security based, the fact she wants my personal email on my work computer, I leave early to run business errands, ie go to CPA 30 miles away and the payroll service has been hacked. I told the owner that there should be a policy on how our data is tracked and stored by the third party. He agreed and said HR should do a training and let people know what is going on.

So, anyway, HR came to my office today and said did you get the link, put it on your computer. I stated that I spoke to the owner and he stated that I was not to use the system until he returned. She flipped out, as in face turned all shades of red and slammed her fists on the desk, told me she was HR and I will do what she says, she doesnt care what owner says. She kept yelling at me about how she was HR. It got heated and I told her the owner was my boss and I take direction from him so take it up with him and get TF outta my office. The GM of the business has the same issues as I do.

How do I deal with HR when the owner backs me but she makes my life hell? Also, do employees have the right to know how data is stored? Is it ok to refuse to use personal email accounts on company computers?

Thanks


r/AskHR • • Jul 29 '26

Policy & Procedures [CA] Asking employee not to commute during work time?

2 Upvotes

Hello, I work at a nonprofit that serves several inner-city schools. One of my employees is salaried but consistently works 40 hours a week, about three or four days a week from home. They recently moved to a location that is 45 to 50 minutes away from our schools. What that means is that if there is a meeting or work to do at a school site, this staff person will often set a meeting for 10 AM (presumably to avoid rush-hour) and travels during work hours back and forth to the site of the meeting. Essentially, the 1.5 hour commute is being deducted out of their eight-hour day.

How can I talk with them about this? I don’t want to use the angle that they are not getting their weekly work done because we have a huge amorphous workload, and we power through it as the best we can. I am concerned about the significant block of time that is unproductive when the commute occurs during the workday.

For example, I could ask the employee to work out in the field for the entire eight hours. There are meeting rooms where they could set up their laptop to finish working after their meetings are over. I know it’s not as comfortable as working from home, but I don’t think they understand that the 1.5 hours of time not being productive is significant to our program. There is plenty of on-site work that can be stacked to make up eight hours if coordinated ahead of time.

EDIT: A lot of y'all don't understand our industry. We are not making widgets. Consider the analogy of being a primary care doctor. If you spend 15 minutes with a patient, the patient may have a lower quality, but "passable" visit than a 30-minute visit where you spend the time to listen to all their concerns and make referrals and review medications and then write up thoughtful and detailed notes for other medical personnel to have as a reference.


r/AskHR • • Jun 03 '23

[NY] Does this look as much like gender discrimination to you as it does to me? Woman in STEM

0 Upvotes

Well Reddit, this feels like discrimination, does it sound like it?

I am part of an engineering team of 5, on which I am the only woman. I was hired 2.5 years ago, 6 months before my coworker Paul (both of us to the same role).

On Friday we were set to integrate four new members into the team-- four more men. It was in this meeting in front of these new hires that I learned, through my boss' introductions, that my coworker Paul has been promoted to a level above mine and I am now the lowest-ranking member of my department.

At no point was I notified that a promotion was on the table for engineers at my level, nor did anyone notify me directly that Paul had received this promotion and subsequent raise. I inquired with my boss immediately after the meeting about it, and he responded that Paul’s promotion had been announced at a company-wide zoom meeting in April, implying that I should have heard about it then and, had I wished to, brought it up with him.These zoom meetings were not portrayed to me as mandatory, nor could I find anything to that effect in writing in any of my employment materials. I either did not attend that meeting or did not hear that announcement.

Regardless, I believe that as my manager, it was my boss's responsibility to initiate a conversation with me about it in order to help guide my trajectory for success in my role. I believe this is true even if at the time, he found my performance below the standard needed to earn the promotion.

Additionally, Paul confirmed to me that despite his new title and pay level, his job responsibilities have not changed.

Furthermore, I was given a cost of living adjustment around the time Paul must have gotten this promotion. The timing throws into question the intentions of the adjustment and to me it indicates a feeling of guilt on the part of my manager and an attempt at a conciliatory gesture. The fact that he did not announce Paul's success openly across his team is also suspicious to me.

Paul said he "didn't know how to talk to me about it in case it was a sore spot", which I find discriminatory as well, but probably not legally so.

So, please help me, Reddit HR. I understand that the first thing I need to do is talk to my manager, which I'm prepared to do. I documented all my communications about it in a timestamped email to myself.

To me it looks like my male boss quietly promoted and raised my junior male coworker behind my back without offering me the same opportunity.

How does this sound to you, and what else should I look into?

UPDATE*

Ok, 100 responses are in! Thank you so much for all of your HR wisdom. Major takeaways include:

A) No legal discrimination detected

B) An expectation that any opportunities will be presented to me directly by my manager is unrealistic, and only by aggressive competence will I achieve career progress

C) Reddit dudes get really emotional when you mention the forbidden word (sexism)

Some of you have been so kind and helpful! I appreciate your insight immensely and will move forward with your advice.


r/AskHR • • Sep 16 '24

Compensation & Payroll [DC] Male co-worker makes more than female.

13 Upvotes

Have a male co-worker that makes more than me (female). We work for the government (so pay is on a grade/step scale) and we got hired around the same time at the same pay grade and step. I have worked there a few months longer than him. We do the exact same job, exact education, and hired with the same experience level. He took a licensing exam a few months before me and that exam gives us a reclass into a higher grade and he got a step too. I then took the exam and was reclassed to the same grade, but no step. We also get our step on hire anniversary every year, it isn’t based on performance or anything. When I brought this up to HR, they told me it was illegal to talk about our pay with each other. I informed them that we are government employees so our pay is public anyway(literally you can google it). I then went to our union for help and the man there said I should worry about my pay and no look into my co-workers and that they won’t help me.

Am I wrong that I should be making the same as my male co-worker?


r/AskHR • • May 15 '23

[MA] Can I doc a worker for the half hour break they were scheduled to take?

6 Upvotes

We have 3 reps who visit 4-5 client sites per day. They are scheduled a half hour lunch break every afternoon. Last week, two of them decided, without getting approval, to skip their lunch breaks. Now I’m over budget since they both earned overtime and fear I’m in violation of Massachusetts wage and labor laws. I want to deduct each a half hour per day, since that’s what they were scheduled. Any repercussions you foresee?

Update: Thanks to those of you who provided suggestions. Going to have a talk with them and provide a written warning. Not going to touch their pay.


r/AskHR • • Apr 02 '25

Workplace Issues Violation of fragrance-free accomodation [MN]

0 Upvotes

I no longer work for this employer and I am just curious what my options could’ve been in this situation and if this should arise in the future.

I had a co-worker I shared a work space with who used to wear a strong perfume to work. I had worked with this coworker for 2 years before they started wearing the fragrance to work. It gave me severe migraines, effected my productivity and often ended with having to leave work early quite a bit and call out sick as a result. I talked to my supervisor about it and since the company (large global corporation) had no written policies about fragrance in the work place, my supervisor said there was nothing they could do without a doctors note/an official medical accommodation. When I/my supervisor talked to my co-worker initially, they claimed they weren’t wearing any fragrance and all of a sudden they stopped wearing it for a few weeks and then started using it again. I suspect they were doing it on purpose to mess with me since we did not have the best relationship. Like they would come in the morning WREEKING and then be there for 20 min before going to the bathroom and then the scent was greatly diminished (I suspect they were washing it off). I could smell my coworker before I saw them in the mornings/after lunch and the scent would often linger in the room/hallways wherever they had been.

So I went through the accommodations process and they made my work area and “fragrance free zone” and that if I were to smell the fragrance I was to wear a half faced respirator immediately and was to also notify HR so they could come and investigate. I initially told my supervisor that while I understand the need for the respirator, it makes it impossible to do my job… without getting into too much detail about my field it is a trade/skill where I need to use mouth as well as my hands a tool to do most of what I do. They said that it is important to keep me safe, etc. which I understood but also wanted to let them know it was going to greatly effect my productivity as I am unable to do my job wearing a respirator.. mostly said this as a CMA incase I got PIP or was reprimanded for my performance due to not being to perform it.

Anyway, anytime I smelled the fragrance (whenever my co-worker would enter the room) I emailed HR and put on my respirator. It was strongest when they would come in the mornings or after lunch. Except that both HR and my supervisor worked remote, so HR could not come and “investigate” until several hours after the fact, at which point my coworker wouldve washed off the scent and it became a they said/they said situation. Only one time was HR able to make it down within an hour of reporting the scent and they had a looooong talk with my coworker (1.5 hrs from what I remember) and then coworker stopped wearing fragrance for about 2 weeks until they started again.

I am wondering if I could’ve pursued legal action either against my previous company or my coworker? What else could I have done?

Thanks in advance!


r/AskHR • • Jan 27 '23

Recruitment & Talent Acquisition [CAN] If I sent an email to an HR person starting with “Hello ___” instead of “Dear ___”, did I mess up?

2 Upvotes

An HR person was setting up a job interview with date and time for me. I sent an email response to confirm the date and time, however I started the email with “Hello ___” instead of “Dear ___”. (The blank is their first name)

Is that a red flag? Did I mess that up? Could this potentially cost me the job if another candidate started with “Dear” and I didn’t?


r/AskHR • • Feb 16 '24

ANSWERED/RESOLVED [NY] How to build an operational "Safety Net" for deal with early AM employees that are late to work.

2 Upvotes

Hello,

First time post to this thread, so please excuse my lack of understanding on this subreddit. :(

My company (based in NYC) employs hourly drivers with flexible schedules (they change weekly based upon demand) and some of these include early start times, like 430A or 5A. Some of these drivers show up late to work and it causes us issues - deliveries getting sent out late, setting us up for a delayed day for the whole company...

My proposed solution was to have the drivers give us a call to "check-in" at a certain time, say 30-45m minutes prior to the start of their shift. If we do not receive the call, our overnight on-site employee would then attempt to callback and make sure they were en-route. If the employee did not answer the call we would "pull the ripcord" and have an emergency call to a nearby manager to fill the shift. The intent is that this early check-in would give the company actionable time to rectify the situation and ensure that the delivery goes out on time. Without the call, the company can only react at the moment the employee is tardy...but that still leaves the company with a day that is starting off on the wrong foot- with a frantic and late 1st delivery of the day.

My direct-report shift supervisor (let's call him Abe) pushed-back on this idea, and also has clocked-in the drivers at 4:30 AM (for a 5 AM shift) to account for the phone call. Abe has stated that since we require the employee to call-in, we then have to pay them from that point, which I find silly. The whole point is that our drivers have a history of showing up late to work, and I need to find a way to ensure that IF the driver is late, we as a business have actionable time to find a replacement driver!

I need to find a reasonable solution that doesn't place unreasonable constraints on the business (I don't want our overnight employee to be making regular "wake-up" calls to our early morning employees!), while also putting fair expectations onto the employees being booked for the shift.

EDIT:

Thank you all kindly for your replies and advice. I know now that I had an extremely foolish and stupid idea, and have a clear path forward.

I'm curious as to why -3 community karma was initiated once I applied the "Answered/Resolved" flair? I don't think I was being disrespectful...


r/AskHR • • Aug 31 '23

Workplace Issues [TN] Can I be fired for venting about my boss on Facebook, which led to a Corporate Investigation?

0 Upvotes

I recently expressed my frustrations about my new boss on Facebook, without naming my boss or employer. However, someone reported it to Ethics and Compliance, leading to a Corporate Investigation. The investigation is focused on determining if I have been treated illegally by the company. Although my boss's behavior has improved since the investigation started, I'm still concerned about the possibility of losing my job. I work as a case manager for executive level escalations in Tennessee for a telecom company. My overall performance has always been excellent, but my new supervisor constantly criticizes me in emails and lectures me on improvement. Additionally, my previous supervisor was understanding and supportive when I had to work from home with my sick children. I also recently had to attend jury duty, for which I was denied a 24-hour extension to complete my tasks. Could sharing my frustrations on Facebook really cost me my job, even if the investigation is ongoing?


r/AskHR • • Jan 22 '25

[WI] RTO assuming I have a vehicle

3 Upvotes

My company is requiring one day in office for those who have an hour or less commute. I have shared with my boss and HR that I do not have a vehicle I can use. I live over 50 minutes away by car, my only other option is public transportation. I do not have anyone who can drive me to and from work for 4 hours one day each week. Not everyone has a personal vehicle to use. According to Google Maps, if I take busses to work, it takes over 2 and a half hours. My question is does HR only calculate commute based on driving a car? Do I have any ability to push back?

Additional context: my team has been remote since Covid started and were told we would not be returning to office. Within the last 5 years, I got rid of my car and bought a house further away from the office, based on what I was told at work. I’ve tried offering other solutions, explaining I could work from home for an hour until I can use my fiancée’s car when he gets home and then drive in. They said I need to be in at the start of my shift for the entire day, knowing I don’t have transportation. I also asked to work at the closer campus (~40 min away) and was denied, saying I need to go to the one an hour away.


r/AskHR • • Oct 06 '26

[WI] Fake an $80k job offer to leverage a raise?

6 Upvotes

I make about $56k right now and recently interviewed for another position around $80k. I told my boss I was interviewing because I actually was, and we've already talked about what would happen if I got an offer and potentially left.

The timing is interesting because we're coming up on when raises/budgets start getting discussed, and another manager recently quit. Instead of immediately replacing him, they're spreading some of his sites/responsibilities between me and my coworker.

My boss has straight up told me that losing me right now would fuck them over. My coworker would probably leave too from the workload, and my boss has said that if he was left trying to manage everything without us, he'd probably look for another job himself. He's also told me he'd fight hard to keep me.

If I actually get the ~$80k offer, obviously I'll use the real thing as leverage. But I'm wondering what people's opinions are if I **don't** get it and I tell them I did anyway.

I'm not expecting them to match $80k. I'd be over the moon with $70k, and honestly I'd be very happy with $65k. I actually like my current job and would rather stay.

So: terrible idea even with this much leverage, or potentially worth the gamble? What risks am I overlooking?


r/AskHR • • May 20 '25

[GA] Named on a disturbing site — what should I ask HR for in terms of safety?

0 Upvotes

I work for a large global company and was recently named on a site that targets Executives involved in diversity equity and inclusion work. My name, picture, job title and city were listed along with about 30 of my present/former colleagues.

I’m scared and unsure how to make sure my employer takes this seriously. They have referred us to EAP and said they’ll pay for a data privacy service for one year (though no recommendations were given…)

They also assured me that all our offices security teams will monitor the campuses.

I want to ask for protections but don’t know what’s reasonable. Can I ask for a title change? if this continues would I have grounds to ask to transfer teams?

Has anyone dealt with anything like this? Are their ways to advocate for more advanced executive data security? What can/should I ask for from HR or Legal.

Thanks in advance!


r/AskHR • • Jul 26 '23

[NY] I realized when I got home that my fly was undone and my coat wasn't fully zipped. How do I address this?

33 Upvotes

I [20F] was mindlessly getting ready in the morning and when I came home after work, I realized that my fly was undone and my jacket was not zipped up all the way. I was not wearing anything underneath, unprofessionally exposing my chest. I am deeply disappointed in myself. I did not realize that this was happening and I'm hit with an avalanche of embarrassment. My boss [35M] and co-workers [36-40M] saw me this way. Do you have any advice for me on what to do now? Do I apologize to my boss, do I say nothing and move on? Please help


r/AskHR • • Sep 05 '24

[IL] Gender Wage Gap - My male colleague makes $40k more than me.

19 Upvotes

I work at a nonprofit in Illinois. My colleague (M) has less work experience, a lower title, for lack of a better word, it's Sr. Director has no direct reports and is not a revenue generator. I am a Chief Officer, I am responsible for raising millions of dollars, I have one direct report and have worked here longer yet he makes $40k more than me. Does that sound right? Is there any way for me to push for a higher wage?


r/AskHR • • Oct 21 '24

Workplace Issues [MD] offensive sign in office

4 Upvotes

Hi Reddit! I work in engineering. I am a woman and my officemate is a man. He hung this in our shared office and I’m kinda offended by it. It’s a Babylon bee article where the women on the view are replaced by shrieking feral pigs and no one notices. I don’t even like the show “the View” but as a woman in male dominated field, I just don’t like the parallel between women and shrieking pigs especially in my office space. I told my boss about it and my group supervisor about it last week and it’s still up. Just want to know peoples opinions. Am I overreacting?

https://babylonbee.com/news/no-one-notices-as-entire-cast-of-the-view-replaced-with-shrieking-feral-piglets

UPDATE: Thank you for everyone's responses. There were a lot of good ones (and some very weird ones lol). Some context I didn't include: My officemate works very odd hours so it's rare to see him and if I do, it's only for an hour or two and we're both very busy. That's why I took it to my boss and my group supervisor because they actually see him. I did NOT take it to HR. I brought it to reddit's AskHR to try to get opinions of people who actually work in HR and I'm glad I did (although seriously, some of these responses are WILD- Like are you ok?).

I got asked why I find this offensive and I wanted to genuinely answer that: I find it offensive because of the stereotype that women are nags. The old ball and chain. A shrieking witch. So calling women (even if they’re annoying as the hosts of the view) shrieking feral pigs is just fitting into the stereotype that women are annoying and you shouldn’t listen to what they have to say.

It’s unprofessional at best. It’s not even a good joke and there’s no need to be comparing people to animals.

Some people found the article offensive but said to ignore it. And I hear you. But engineering has a lot of problems with boys clubs. There's a LOT I ignore (rape jokes, comments about womens bodies, etc). One person even said they dont think engineering is the right fit for me if I can't handle these types of things. To this, I say fuck you. No explanation needed. Its hard to complain about these types of things but this was something that lived inside my office and I had to look at every day.

Some comments I found weird: Someone said to take it down myself. Our office is a small room with just our two desks in it. I really didn't want to touch his property. I feel like that would have escaladed the situation. Someone said to put something equally offensive up. I don’t want to be offensive. I want people to feel respected when they’re at work. We can have fun and make jokes not at other peoples' expense (and I do with my work friends!)

Long story short: the ending to this is not exciting at all. My officemate's schedule overlapped with mine this morning and I was able to chit chat with him. We talked about stuff going on in our lives (normal small talk) and then as I was heading out, I pointed to his poster and: I said/(lied) "that's really funny". He responded something midly sexist (but I dont care enough). I then said "I dont know if it's super professional for our office though". He said "its not but I dont care". I said "I dont think [insert major female client's name] would like it though. He said "finneeee I'll take it down".

I went to my boss and supervisor and said it was handled.

The end.


r/AskHR • • Aug 19 '25

Leaves Plan is to be a SAHM, but what should I tell my employer?? [WI]

0 Upvotes

I’m currently 13 weeks pregnant and planning out when/what I should disclose to my boss and HR for the inevitable day I tell them I’m pregnant.

My boss is a great guy that actually had his wife stay at home when they had their 2nd and 3rd kids, so I’m sure he’d be very understanding, BUT I’m not sure what he’d be required to tell HR. HR is the reason I’m tiptoeing around this because I’d still like to be able to use the maternity and short term disability benefits, but the end goal would be to not come back to work.

I’m having trouble figuring out what the best course of action is so that my boss isn’t disappointed and caught completely unaware of my plans, but I also don’t want to be at risk of being let go while being pregnant. What should I do??


r/AskHR • • Jul 21 '23

Workplace Issues Coworker constantly ignores my husband's Celiac disease and eats wheat at their shared desk. [AZ]

4 Upvotes

My husband works the night shift while his new coworker works during the day. Despite my husband explaining his severe allergy to wheat and requesting that his coworker refrain from eating at their shared desk, the coworker continues to do so. My husband even documented this in his personal notes and took a picture of a note he left for the coworker.

Yesterday, as my husband was clocking out, he noticed the coworker eating a sandwich at their desk. He politely approached the coworker once again, emphasizing the importance of avoiding cross-contamination. However, the coworker responded rudely and dismissively, and later sent a message saying, "hope you're not allergic to wipes too so I can scrub the desk."

My husband is now experiencing cross-contamination symptoms at work, and on one occasion, he became so ill that he had to leave early. As Celiac disease is considered a disability, should my husband take this matter to HR? He wants to handle it without being dramatic, but his health is at risk. Any advice would be greatly appreciated.


r/AskHR • • May 19 '24

California [CA] Husband having a work affair. How to tip off HR anonymously.

0 Upvotes

Need advice on how to inform HR my husband is having a work affair [CA]

As title says. Husband is having an affair with coworker. [CA] I’m dealing with it under the hood as small children and babies involved but I’d like to ping HR in his company to start an investigation. Lots of emails and teams (he’s deleted them) that if an investigation occurs will come to surface. Conduct doesn’t allow relationships unless disclosed - clearly he’s married, she’s not. I’d like to ping them anonymously - please no judging here I’m already having a horrible time dealing with this so just give me your best advice on how to go about this. Thanks!


r/AskHR • • Aug 06 '24

Update: Got my VP of HR fired [WA]

0 Upvotes

Hi all,

Original post here: https://www.reddit.com/r/AskHR/s/V6gTdocvDQ

I’ve posted here a few times and got very skeptical (and somewhat mean) responses so I thought I would update. After being abused by my HR VP for over two years for calling him out publicly for pandering to anti-vaxers I have had to go through two discrimination investigations. As a tenured employee I knew I would be the org way after he was gone and forgotten. He made dumb documented mistakes that made it clear that he targeted me and was biased against me. I showed all the evidence to his boss and two weeks later he is GONE. There were other issues but I gave them the evidence they needed to get rid of him. It was so satisfying to email him today and get an auto replay that he’s no longer at our organisation. I was tempted to tell him what I thought about him him on his social media but I’m bigger than that. I just want to say that I have never before wanted someone fired even if they wronged me. In this case, I was afraid from being retaliated by this guy at work. This went on for two years and when I complained about him he buried it and continued his abuse. I really ask that this group be more supportive of people like me that are being abused by HR and need help. Thanks.

Question: will this help me when I sue my organisation for mistreatment. I have evidence of retaliation, bias, and discrimination on disability and religious/ethnic/national origin. Will them firing him help my case or make it weaker? Thanks again!


r/AskHR • • Aug 03 '25

Workplace Issues Employer offering me $4,937 severance if I waive all claims, worth it? [IL]

0 Upvotes

Looking for some outside perspective here. I’ve been with my current company since March 6, 2025. It’s a small manufacturing company, and I recently filed an HR complaint (June 10) about my manager for racism, retaliation, and harassment.

One example: on May 12, my manager made a racial “joke” toward me. HR investigated and confirmed it happened. They said no other racial remarks were found but admitted I was also given incorrect/confusing info during a write‑up over phone use. They “formally disciplined” him and warned him further incidents could lead to termination.

After I complained:

  • My overtime got cut.

  • I was reassigned to a different department.

  • My work environment got noticeably worse.

Now the company is offering me a severance agreement:

  • $4,937.80 gross (W‑2, taxed).

  • 27 hours of unused PTO.

  • Health insurance subsidy until Aug 31, then I pay COBRA if I want to keep it.

  • Strings attached:

    • I have to waive almost every possible legal claim up to now, including discrimination/retaliation claims.

    • I can’t talk about the agreement publicly.

    • I can’t disparage the company.

    • I can never work there again in any capacity.

I’ve only been there about 5 months, so I know severance isn’t guaranteed, but the amount seems… low? Especially given the circumstances and the fact they’re asking me to give up a lot of rights.

My gut says this is more about protecting themselves than helping me. But I don’t want to walk away from money if it’s actually fair.

Questions:

  • Does ~$5k seem reasonable here, or is this lowballing?

  • Is it normal to demand a release of all claims for such a small severance?

  • If you were me, would you take it or negotiate for more?

Would love to hear from people who’ve been in similar situations or who know how these agreements usually play out.


r/AskHR • • Apr 21 '25

[PA] Racism at Work

2 Upvotes

Workplace Racism

Workplace Racism

I currently work at a small company (less than 50 employees). On paydays, a few of the employees will get chinese food as like a payday reward. The problem, a few individuals call it "cat". These individuals happen to be the older white male conservative, Republican types of people if that brings any implication. There was one day one of the managers that usually picks up the chinese food told the vice president, "going to pick up cat", and the vice president found it funny. It has now become an on going joke between those two. So every pay day I have to hear them say, "gonna get cat", "gotta pick up the cat", "are you getting cat today?"... The vice president had said a cat joke to the ceo before and the ceo had also thought it was funny, and he too has made "cat" jokes before but not regularly like the other two. I should've said something the first time I heard them say it but I'm not very outspoken on social and racial issues. I thought the joke would've died out by now but it's been a while and they've been at it since. The other day on a non payday, the vice president had asked "is today cat day?", I got even angrier than usual and I am eager to talk to them about it this week. We also don't technically have an HR, it seems to be the vice president who does the hiring and firing of employees, so I don't exactly have someone I can report them to.

As a Chinese-American, I do find this incredibly offensive, and the fact that people still make the stereotypical "chinese people eat cats and dogs" racist jokes in these current times is absurd and abhorrent to me.

I would like to know peoples thoughts and opinions on this, what would everyone do in this situation, how would you address this/them?


r/AskHR • • Sep 11 '25

Recruitment & Talent Acquisition [CA] Is it fair to hold someones social media behavior against them when hiring / backing their reference for a position?

0 Upvotes

Long story short, I used to work with someone for, who all intents and purposes, can likely do the job my company is hiring for. He was referred to the position by another employee that I worked with, so we all mutually know each other from the same company.

I rarely use Facebook and noticed some questionable behavior that seems a bit unhinged when I logged in recently, as I have him added as a friend from knowing him from my past job. My say likely carries a lot of weight, considering I am the most senior member of my team.

Basically, he just constantly very far left toxic stuff, calling for CEOs to be "luigi'd" (killed), celebrating a very recent public murder of a conservative, etc. He reposts memes about how if people aren't killed, then "nothing will change" from tongue-in-cheek "Revolution" pages.

I'm conflicted about okaying or backing up his reference as this behavior seems pretty unhinged, and at any point, a customer could Google him and see this pretty extreme rhetoric.

I think he is more than capable of doing the job, but I'm a bit uneasy about sharing a team with someone who, in their free time, publicly calls for people he disagrees with to be killed.

I'd be curious to hear what others think. I agree with him on a lot of fundamental political stuff so it's not really a "I don't want to work with someone that shares different views", but I can't shake his behavior as being unhinged and since it's on a public platform, that it's not unfair to consider this when backing or considering him.