r/AskEngineers • • Jul 28 '18

"My job was not what I expected?"

0 Upvotes

Today was one of our Summer interns last day- very good guy, very pleasant but I could tell he seemed a bit disappointed. I told him to consider us for future employment but I felt that he was expecting "Engineering" to be something else.

It seems like many young people have total misconceptions about what an Engineering job is- I am not sure if they were fed BS by their parents, schools or what have you but to give you an idea- I spent 2 hours doing data entry today.

There are a lot of administrative tasks that need to be done, a lot of paperwork, forms that need to be completed and processing time. I would say on an average day, I spend about 3 hours total just answering emails- I am getting about 100 emails a day- my boss get easily 500 emails a day.

Is your job not what you expected? If not, explain why please.


r/AskEngineers • • Mar 21 '24

Mechanical Why is Toyota doubling-down on hydrogen cars? Are they stupid?

0 Upvotes

Is this doomed to fail? Why would they even consider it's a smart idea to try to sell consumers hydrogen cars which they can't use.


r/AskEngineers • • Aug 27 '21

We call upon Reddit to take action against the rampant Coronavirus misinformation on their website.

Thumbnail reddit.com
102 Upvotes

r/AskEngineers • • May 14 '12

Can we please stop asking for academic or professional career advice on r/askengineers?

3 Upvotes

That's not really the intent of this sub.

AskEngineers is about getting common questions about devices/systems answered.

For questions regarding engineering school, also try posting in /r/EngineeringStudents


r/AskEngineers • • Jul 31 '24

Civil American "Iron Dome"?

0 Upvotes

One of Trump's project 47 promises is "Prevent World War three...and build a great iron dome missile defense shield over our entire country ..." is this possible at the present? I know we have way less ICBM interceptors than Russian ICBMs(I think I heard 1000 to 1, or something like that). Is this just nonsense, or is it something that could actually be engineered and built given the size of the United States and modern ICBM tracking technology?


r/AskEngineers • • 27d ago

Discussion Are there risks of storing compressed Nitrogen inside a car?

1 Upvotes

Would keeping the windows wound down help reduce them?


r/AskEngineers • • Jun 29 '21

Career Disillusioned with non inclusive engineering spaces as a queer woman

6 Upvotes

Feeling extremely disillusioned with Engineering right now and looking for some advice.

I am a queer woman and realising how exhausting it is to be in the industries that we typically work in as engineers.

For background, I did geological engineering, worked in petroleum for a few years, did my masters in construction management, and am now in the heavy civil industry.

Here in Canada, at least in my field, it is expected that new graduates spend some time in the field to gain more practical skills. While I have learned a lot technically from my 2 years in the field, I have found it has completely drained me on a personal level. I’m so exhausted of being in non-inclusive environments, of feeling uncomfortable sharing my sexuality, of the harassment, of how socially draining it is to make small talk with contractors that are predominately white middle-aged males.

When I went into eng, I heard so much “It’s so great to see more women go into engineering” – but I never really though of the flip side of that – that it means you have to be a minority in some pretty non-inclusive environments.

As a result my confidence has plummeted since I’ve been in the field. I feel really depressed and am seriously considering a career change. While I’ve always followed my heart on what interests me, I feel completely dejected by the spaces in which those interests can play out. I am willing to work hard, I have received a lot of positive recognition (especially early on when I worked in the office and was in a more inclusive environment), so I know I can be a good engineer. I know I am capable of more but I feel I am completely stuck.

I always hear people saying “with an engineering degree you can do anything” but I am really lost. I am not sure whether to give up on engineering completely, try find a more inclusive company/industry. I’m considering trying to switch into business consulting or trying to find a more progressive area such as tech (though my background/experience might limit that)

I would appreciate any advice or stories of those who have gone through a similar experience and are now (hopefully) on the other side of it!


r/AskEngineers • • Nov 04 '13

Hello r/AskEngineers, r/alienpumaspacetrain here. We're building a train based on some drawings a guy found in a box and the book of Ezekiel. Can you help us with some of the technical bits?

2 Upvotes

r/AskEngineers • • Aug 23 '24

Mechanical Since the water drop shape is the most aerodynamic shape, why aren't more cars shaped that way?

0 Upvotes

r/AskEngineers • • Feb 20 '16

What do you think about techs/non-engineers calling themselves engineers?

5 Upvotes

In my country, the title 'engineer' is protected by law. To be an engineer, you must take a 4 year bachelors of applied science degree, which only a few Universities offer, in your respective field (i.e. mech, civil, electrical, chemcial, etc), work under another engineer for 3 years, and then pass a really long exam. So, to become an engineer, it takes around 7-8 years. But to get into engineering school, you essentially have to be the top of your class in high school.

However, I've seen a lot of people who aren't engineers (such as technicians) call themselves engineers. I.e., one of my cousins has a 2 year associates degree from a college and he calls himself a civil engineer.

Engineers here essentially design things, using science and math, as well as following regulations, working in teams, and coming up with new solutions to difficult problems. Technicians just build the schematics given to them by engineers. (Also, you legally can't do any engineering job unless you're licensed with the government)

This really annoys me, because its a slap in the face to real engineers who have actually spent 10+ years of their life getting the qualifications (I'm including high school, because you have to take extra hard special courses in high school if you want to get into engineering school, as well as have 95%+ average in these courses like calculus to vector calculus, physics, chemistry, biology, computer science, etc).

Additionally, it makes engineers look lower/dumber than they are. Someone who can solder a circuit board or connect wires on a protoboard based off of a schematic is not the same as an electrical engineer who actually designs complex systems and designs integrated circuits, for instance.

Am I the only one who is bothered by this? What do you think about techs calling themselves engineers?


r/AskEngineers • • Aug 30 '25

Civil Why does adding more bolts to a bracket increase the load it can handle, when lock picking works because each pin can be individually isolated?

0 Upvotes

I was watching this video(https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q56PMJbCFXQ) about the disaster that could have been the Citycorp Center in NYC and it got me thinking…

Context: Unbeknownst to the structural engineer(William LeMessurier), his firm decided to just use bolts on the chevron beams rather than welding them together like he originally planned. Insult to injury, they only used 4 bolts when 14 should have been used.

Intuitively, I understand that adding more screws or bolts to a bracket generally increases its effectiveness. However, my understanding of lock picking is that no matter how precise manufacturers are, due to imperfections, you can always isolate one pin at a time.

  1. If this is true, why does adding more bolts increase the effective load, rather than just, one at a time, isolating and snapping each bolt?

Take two metal beams(end to end), secured with a metal bracket(front & back), with two bolts on each side of the bracket, going all the way through the beams, through the second bracket, and then all four bolts secured with a nut.

2. Would adding additional bolts to both sides of the bracket increase the force required to pull these beams apart?

3. And if so, why?

While I start this post talking about a very real world situation, I acknowledge my actual questions are more of a theoretical nature, as in practicality, I kinda already know the surface answers to my questions, I just wanna understand why! TIA


r/AskEngineers • • Jan 02 '24

Computer How close are we to full self driving?

0 Upvotes

What is your timeline for the roll-out of the following services -

  1. autonomous inner city bus on dedicated lane

  2. autonomous regional/suburban bus with no dedicated lane

  3. autonomous long haul trucks that is only driven on the highway

  4. autonomous trucks and buses in inner city

  5. autonomous taxi service

  6. autonomous eVtols

Other than regulations and liability for damages what do you will be the major bottleneck?


r/AskEngineers • • Jun 22 '15

Men vs Women Dress code, sexism?!

10 Upvotes

How is it allowed that men have to wear pants/polo shirt/dress shirt meanwhile the women get to wear shorts, skirts, all kinds of tops that are mostly "t-shirts" and so on? Isn't this sexist?

I'm complaining because I just found out I'm apparently not allowed to wear khaki shorts.


r/AskEngineers • • Sep 26 '23

Discussion Are renewables like wind and solar a viable "green" energy source or are they a scam?

7 Upvotes

r/AskEngineers • • Mar 09 '17

I've been offered an internship, but I have moral concerns

7 Upvotes

So I interviewed for my industrial placement at this engineering consultancy (EE position, specifically embedded systems) a few weeks ago. The interview went quite well I think but at the end while I was in the waiting room someone came out and dropped an absolute moral bombshell on me by asking if I'd be okay with working in defence.

To be honest I haven't come this far and put this much into my education to graduate and build death machines. Defence is actually a pretty small part of what this company does, but the question took me aback and I ended up giving a shit answer where I didn't say yes or no but something flaky in between.

Today they offered me a position and I'd like to articulate my concerns - it is really a great company and I'd love to work for them, but I don't really know if the position allows for refusal to work in certain areas/on certain projects. Can anyone advise me on a polite way of contacting them and just saying that I'd really rather not work on any defence projects? I really have no experience with how the engineering profession works in the real world and have no idea on how to approach this.

Many thanks!

EDIT: This would be a 10-12 month internship!


r/AskEngineers • • Feb 09 '26

Civil Could we dig a canal and tunnel from the Gulf of California to Death Valley and reroute the Colorado River into Death Valley? Would it benefit us?

0 Upvotes

Could we dig a canal from the Gulf of California to the base of the Sierra Nevada, tunnel through the mountains, and have the water pour into Death Valley which is below sea level? At the same time, reroute the Colorado River to flow into Death Valley to open more land for irrigation. This would allow for California to have a second coastline and allow for easier shipping to Mexico's western coastline.

How much would this cost and would it actually benefit society? Could it be our generation's equivalent to the Hoover Dam or Panama Canal?


r/AskEngineers • • Apr 24 '21

Discussion Do you consider Elon Musk to be an engineer?

0 Upvotes

Just curious what you guys think. I personally do not think that he can be called an engineer, in the sense used to describe professional engineers and I get very annoyed when people call him an engineer. I know "engineer" is sometimes a general term like train engineer and in this way it makes sense to call him an engineer but I don't think someone can be an actual engineer without having a BSc degree in engineering and having experience in working in a professional engineering position. That's the metric I would use to determine if someone is an engineer or not. I don't believe it's possible to obtain a job in engineering industry without a degree. For comparison, you cannot have a self-taught doctor, who is now working in surgeon-related jobs. That's insane.

Elon Musk has a physics degree, and I don't believe that a physicist is trained the same way or qualified nearly enough to do the job of a professional engineer. I'm not saying engineering is harder than physics I'm saying it's different. Elon is a CEO. He's a businessman. At least that is how it appears to me. The actual engineering work of his companies are done by people who have spent their entire lives studying engineering. Engineering is so broad and to be able to do real engineering work it takes years and years of specialized training, study and practice and experience and it takes teams of people with these qualifications. It's quite preposterous to me that someone can be a "self-taught" engineer even if they are a genius who can memorize textbooks (as people say Elon is) when it takes so much of specialized training to reach a point where you can call yourself an engineer of a specific field. There are so many sub-disciplines too. If I'm wrong, don't insult me, but rather share your views. I don't even know that much about Elon Musk in any case, that's why I want to hear your points of view.

As most people say, what you learn at university isn't that important. You just have a paper degree to say that you are good at learning stuff and have the aptitude to do so. You learn the real stuff on the job. But my point is, you cannot get your foot in the door if you don't have that degree first. You can't get a job in engineering industry without first having a degree. That's my point.

I've read other threads that say he is a great engineer but I honestly feel a large portion of the internet is literally just a circle jerk when it comes to Elon. Huge amounts of people are like obsessed with him and have a huge boner for anything Elon Musk related. Please excuse my language, not sure how else to put it.


r/AskEngineers • • May 01 '22

Discussion In general, would you would it be more ethical to work in the fossil fuel industry or in the arms industry?

1 Upvotes

Not career advice, I just thought of this question and was wondering what other people would think.


r/AskEngineers • • Apr 30 '25

Electrical Can solar power be used to power industries? if yes then why isn't it as popular?

0 Upvotes

I know industries have high energy demands and that a solar system might be expensive, but the most expensive part of a solar system is the battery, there won't be a need for energy storage if work the industry only works in the morning and afternoon. but what do you think?


r/AskEngineers • • Aug 11 '21

Career Are Engineers Suckers? Technical track vs. business side

0 Upvotes

Provocative title. Engineering salaries at entry to mid-career level have been stagnant for years now. Meanwhile, your peers might be making twice as much in sales or project management type roles. I am early career still, but it is highly demotivating to see that even some of the so-called technical experts are pulling in paltry salaries compared to sales/management. Am I seeing different numbers than everyone else, or are mid-level technical track engineers just suckers in the end, never fighting for their fair share of company profits that originate ultimately from their own work? I'm excluding from this the highly compensated coders of Silicon Valley. They're an exception. Outside of that, if you're early career like me, do you stay the course and hope to make it to the top 1% in your specialty, or do you bail that track early on to duke it out on the business side (sales, project management, etc) where the rewards for performance seem to be so much greater? Seems to me a question of risk/reward. You can be more comfortable and less stressed on the technical track, but with lower risk comes lower reward. Reason I ask is because I'm at a bit of a fork in the road in my career and have had some interest from consulting companies which are much more business-focused and pay the same as the highly technical (mechanical eng.) specialized roles that I am looking at. In the long run, what is the better option?

Edit: Thanks for the responses. Even those who want to fight me. I guess if I start a post with a fighting word like "suckers" I should expect some reaction.

Edit 2: I want to clarify that this is not just about salary, though I wrote a lot about it above. Consider the whole package, thinking in terms of total time and effort expended in your job versus satisfaction with the work itself, career autonomy (no rigid schedule, ability to take time off as needed, etc.), and money. It may be that in general, with higher pay comes a sacrifice of something else.

Update: Based on the responses and more self-reflection, I have decided the technical track is probably the right path for me. I did an interview with a consulting engineering/management company and felt it wasn't really me, or at least, I don't think I have the energy or the inclination to maintain the jet-setter lifestyle it would require. As someone posted here, the only real "sucker" is someone trying to live a life based on how others have defined "success". Thanks again.


r/AskEngineers • • Jun 15 '26

Discussion Does data centres in space work?

0 Upvotes

So data centres in space, yes have unlimited sunlight so free energy. Need water to cool down space is cold but how does or how can you transfer the heat from the servers to atmosphere or outside since there is no air. Plus most of the data in planet go thought underwater cables like under sea etc so can you get the max speed data transfer using wireless from space to earth.


r/AskEngineers • • Jun 19 '25

Discussion If you only had fire, a stretchable plastic that can't be torn, a strong rubber, and a piece of metal—what could you create to generate electricity?

4 Upvotes

Plus no water around u


r/AskEngineers • • Feb 05 '24

Mechanical Why are car brakes are mechanically connected to the pedal instead of the pedal sending an electrical signal to the brake system?

5 Upvotes

r/AskEngineers • • Sep 18 '26

Discussion Do Star Wars 'Magic Materials' have real life equivalents

1 Upvotes

So I was reading a Star Wars book the other day and was wondering if duracrete (described as a fluid material that could be poured into any form and then hardened, resulting in a virtually impervious surface.) could just be concrete, but the duracrete in the books/movies is used for buildings that have lasted 1000's of years, I don't think that modern concrete could do that, could it?

This lead me on to thinking about durasteel (described as stronger and more durable than conventional steel) and was wondering what it could be. In the end after a brief (2 hours) research I figured the closest we have is maybe HSLA Steel, what do you guys think?


r/AskEngineers • • Jul 09 '12

How do I get a fucking job?

0 Upvotes

Recent BS in Mechanical here. Im currently using monster, linkedin, and USAjobs. I have no experience and I'm thinking about going to my alma mater's career fair. Could I get advice from the busy engineers on reddit? ;)