I hope this sort of post is acceptable on this sub.
I was walking the high streets of Birmingham today, and I couldn't help but notice a couple of Islamic preaching stands (which I also saw in other parts of the UK).
I fully respect their right to preach their religion (I am an ex-Muslim atheist), but one thing that pesters me is that I theoretically wouldn't even be able to hold a counter-Islamic stand on that same street without running into legal issues.
These people promote Islam via fallacious arguments (so-called scientific "miracles" in the Qur'an, literary divinity, etc) that fully deserve to be scrutinised and challenged just as freely as they are offered on the street. However, imagine I were to set up a nearby stand near their stands with a banner that read: "Counterarguments to Islamic apologetics!" What do you think the general reaction would be? Would I be as welcomed as they are? Would challenging their arguments at my own stand be considered acceptable by most Muslims and others?
I have a feeling it'd likely go south. Suddenly, once Islam is attacked, it's racist/xenophobic/islamophobic. Such a stand would probably not be approved for "hate speech" and "targeted hostility," even though the Qur'an itself contains a fair amount of hate speech (which gets a free pass on UK streets, like the Bible; which, again, I respect, but I wish we could apply the same standards everywhere).
Imagine I opened the same stand near a Christian one, specifically dedicated to promoting counterarguments to Christian apologetics. I have a strong feeling that things wouldn't go as bad as if the other scenario.
What are your thoughts?