Years ago, spain used to have a large seasonal population of workers from north africa. For various reasons they tried to end/curtail the scheme and it actually led to more north africans coming over, but coming over permanently instead for a few months every year. This kind of counterintuitive logic has been at play with migration policy (particularly asylum policy) for decades.
We've seen the same thing play out with brexit. The beauty of freedom of movement is that people can leave. Barriers to entry are low, but barriers to exit are also low. People haven't spent years investing a fortune in visa fees and complying with restrictive immigration laws, creating a sunk cost. This led to significant 'churn' for sure, but it also has its own benefits; many people came here very short term to improve their language skills etc. Instead now we have a system whereby people need to completely upend their lives with a view to permanent relocation, jump through all sorts of hoops and pay a fortune. They're not going to be temporary or transient.
So now we've got the 'boris wave' and the response as ever is for the government to continually fuck over ordinary british people with policies making it harder to bring in spouses etc. Great stuff.
Europe-wide asylum policy failures IMO can be traced back to a single key, fairly trivial moment. The EU caved to (pretty tepid) anti-asylum rhetoric and made airlines responsible for ensuring the visa status of all passengers. Sounds sensible right? But in practice what this did was to completely shut off asylum routes across Europe. We stopped handing out visas to countries or people 'at risk of asylum' (employing some laughably broad criteria) so those people just never arrived and never claimed asylum.
Ironically whilst looking up said EU law i came across this pesky comment from the human rights commissioner from 2010 which loosely makes my own point for me.
This policy creates other problems as well. In order to reach safe havens, refugees may instead be obliged to use the services of smugglers who provide them with false documents in order to get around the vigilance of the carriers.
The 'migrant crisis' never needed to happen in the way it did, with the chaos it did (ignoring that we played a key role in creating it in the first place with our actions to destabilise syria).
Small boats were never a thing previously. Now they are and there's so much money to be made that they're unlikely to ever go away.
Even when we ostensibly have 'open routes' for asylum like the afghanistan scheme, we make a point of not allowing people to use it.... meaning we have afghans who were eligible via genuine routes still getting here via small boats.
Another consequence is that the asylum population has become massively warped in favour of males for a number of reasons which didn't previously exist. The actual asylum seeking population is objectively 'worse' than it ever was before.
We have far less control and oversight of the asylum seeking population and process when it's entirely based on irregular entry as opposed to happening in airports and embassies. Which has led to local services being swamped in places that have never had to deal with such problems.
We have an asylum population that is worse documented because we've incentivised them to destroy documentation creating all sorts of other problems.
By further pandering to anti-asylum campaigns and 'banning' irregular entry, we've (previously at least) just stopped processing claims, creating a backlog of chaos, making deportations harder etc.
The only thing it maybe hasn't made worse is the overall numbers, but it's an impossible counterfactual to run. Historically asylum has always come in 'bursts' anyway.
Over and over again, anti-migrant policies have backfired horribly. Instead of having the 'reasonable discussion' we're allegedly not allowed to have, we just keep doubling down and making things worse.
That doesn't mean anti-migrant policies aren't possible or are inherently undesirable, but surely there needs to be a point where we actually take a step back and reflect on what has historically worked and what hasn't, rather than always doing the same things??
ETA: To be crystal clear, I'm quite open to both immigration and asylum, but I (and everyoen else i've encountered) also recognise that the current situation is farcical. Somehow the debate has been warped into a false dichotomy of 'zero migrants' vs 'open the floodgates'. I will always argue against what i consider to be terrible anti-migrant policies, but that doesn't mean i'm defending the status quo or don't think there are problems that need solving.
Sensible policy leading to reduced immigration is absolutely fine. I don't think i've ever met anyone who actually thinks it's all great and we should fling open the borders, but i've met plenty who think we have a duty to deal with the current shitty situation in a sensible, humane way whilst also fixing the system. IMO there's far less disagreement between people on this topic than the toxic political debate suggests.