r/AskAcademia • • 4h ago

Interpersonal Issues Advice, my professor asked to catch up over a coffee and I don’t know what to do

20 Upvotes

I graduated from my undergrad degree two months ago and am still staying in the university town. I ran into one of my lecturers at an event and she said she didn’t know I was still in the city and that we should go get a coffee sometime. She emailed me two days later saying it was nice to see me and asking when I’d be free to catch up, and I told her when I had my classes and that I’d be happy to work around her availability. She didn’t respond to that email, but sent me a link to two other networking events she was hosting.

I met her at those and also bumped into her a couple of times after- it’s a pretty small town and I’m still on the main campus. Every time I meet her we make small talk and then it ends up with her saying “let me know when you’re free” “we need to catch up” “I’ll email you about the coffee”, but I emailed her then and after that a few times said that I’d be happy to work around her availability, so I’m not sure if she’s asking out of formality or what

She’s actually been a really sweet and engaging lecturer, and she’s honestly an absolute powerhouse in everything she does. She only taught me in my first year but offered to write me a recommendation letter at the time, asked me to contribute to her reports, connected me with someone she knew from my hometown (she was also raised in the same place), reacts and comments on all my LinkedIn posts, and sends me invites to employability events she hosts. She’s also the head of prizes and out of 9 prizes given out for my degree, i won two of them, and another lecturer who was nominating her for an award asked me to be the second nominee

I’d absolutely love to meet her but I’m just not sure what this is about and I’m very unsure what to expect or what she wants out of this.

Help please (lmao)


r/AskAcademia • • 5h ago

Humanities Revise and resubmit

8 Upvotes

I’m currently revising a journal article, but I don’t think I’ll be finished with everything by the resubmission deadline. Is it ok to ask for an extension?


r/AskAcademia • • 10h ago

Interpersonal Issues Have you ever been humiliated by someone in a position of authority and struggled to move on, even years later?

7 Upvotes

I’m 23F, and there are two experiences that I still think about. I genuinely want to move on, but sometimes I get angry at myself for allowing other people’s words to affect me so deeply.
The first happened at university in 2024–2025.
I was working on my bachelor’s thesis and had a meeting with my supervisor. I asked a simple question: whether there were other research methods I could use besides interviews, questionnaires, and focus groups.
Instead of answering, she spent approximately 20 minutes lecturing me about how I was disrespecting the work of other professors, questioning how I had even made it to my third year of university, and telling me I should already know these things.
I left that meeting and cried for hours. I remember looking at a watch I’d received as a Christmas gift and feeling like I didn’t even deserve it. That’s how badly I had internalized her words.
Afterward, I stopped having video meetings with her and communicated exclusively through email.
Things didn’t improve much. I struggled to get constructive feedback on my thesis and repeatedly received warnings about using AI. At one point, after checking my thesis for plagiarism, she told me my similarity score was “suspiciously low” and suggested that I had probably used ChatGPT to remove commonly used expressions.
Yes, apparently even having a low similarity score was suspicious.
During my final thesis defense, she interrupted me while I was answering a question and warned me that I was “digging my own grave.” I stopped talking.
I graduated in 2025, but I still remember how small those interactions made me feel.
The second experience happened in April 2026.
I contacted a business networking event organizer because I wanted to get involved, gain experience, and meet professionals.
During a meeting before the event, the organizer made inappropriate comments about my appearance, including telling me not to show up “with my boobs hanging out,” not to wear leopard print, and not to talk to anyone at the event.
Yes, this was supposedly a networking event.
I laughed during parts of the conversation, not because I found his comments funny, but because I was genuinely shocked that an established professional would speak to someone like that.
I was also asked to complete some research and analysis, which I did. I never received meaningful feedback, and a promised follow-up meeting never happened.
The event itself was disappointing, but what bothered me most was the disrespect.
Here’s what both experiences have in common:
I remained polite. I didn’t insult anyone, raise my voice, or confront them. I just smiled, thanked them, and moved on.
And now, months or even years later, I sometimes get furious thinking about it.
Not necessarily because of what they said, but because I allowed their words to make me question myself. I wish I had stood up for myself.
I’m now in the final year of my master’s degree in Business Administration, studying finance and working toward a career in investments. I’ve continued learning, meeting professionals, and building my future.
But these memories still bother me.
Part of me wants to contact the dean of my former faculty and the event organizer to explain how their behavior affected me. I’m not looking for revenge, disciplinary action, or any professional advantage. I think I’d just appreciate a sincere apology, or at least knowing that I’ve finally spoken up.
Another part of me worries that contacting influential people to criticize their behavior could damage my professional reputation, even if I remain respectful.
So I genuinely want to ask:
Has anyone experienced something similar with a professor, supervisor, employer, or someone in a position of authority?
Did you ever contact them afterward, even months or years later? Did it help you find closure?
How did you stop blaming yourself for not standing up for yourself at the time?
Would you recommend sending a respectful message, or is it healthier to leave these people in the past?
I don’t want to carry resentment into my future. I just want to learn how to stop giving these experiences so much power over me.
I’d really appreciate hearing from people who’ve been through something similar.


r/AskAcademia • • 10h ago

Interpersonal Issues Professor asked me to draft my own recommendation letter and I am not sure how much to praise my own skills?

6 Upvotes

Hello! One of my professors asked me to draft a recommendation letter for him, and I'm honestly a little confused about how to approach it.

I understand that recommendation letters should reflect how well the professor knows you, your skills, qualities, achievements, etc. But how much am I actually supposed to praise myself?

It feels a little narcissistic to write things like "one of the best students I have taught" or make really strong statements about myself. But at the same time, I'm worried that if I make the letter too modest, it might end up being weaker than other applicants' letters.

For anyone who's been in this situation, how did you balance it? Are you supposed to write a really strong recommendation and let the professor tone it down if needed, or keep it modest and let them add the praise themselves? If anyone could provide sample drafts they had to write, that would be great too! Thanks

FYI - I study computer science and I am applying to Europe for masters


r/AskAcademia • • 33m ago

Humanities PhD candidate on job market for first time: how broad should my job search be?

0 Upvotes

I'm a humanities doctoral candidate on the academic job market for the first time. I have two peer-reviewed publications in respected journals in my field, have been fortunate to get external grants and awards, and I am getting my PhD from the best program for my discipline in the country.

The thing is, my field is niche. There are so few jobs that seem like a likely fit for my work. How broadly should I be looking, and how do you know where to draw the line when deciding which applications to take a chance on and which to pass up?

Thanks


r/AskAcademia • • 16h ago

STEM Upcoming TT zoom interview at a R2 University

14 Upvotes

Hello everyone,
I’m on the tenure-track job market in the life sciences. Last cycle, I was invited for an on-campus interview, but it was canceled. This cycle, I’ve had four Zoom interviews with R2 universities across the U.S., and so far none has led to a campus visit. I have a fifth Zoom interview next month and would love advice on what I could do differently this time.
For those who’ve made it to a campus visit or served on a search committee, what helps a candidate stand out in the initial Zoom interview? I’d especially appreciate advice on how to present my research plans and funding strategy. I don’t currently have grant funding, and my K99 application received an impact score of 27 but wasn’t funded. Would you mention the score, and if so, how would you frame it?
Thanks for any advice you’re willing to share!


r/AskAcademia • • 2h ago

Interpersonal Issues Would I be crazy if I went straight for my doctorate after my masters?

0 Upvotes

I am 28f.

When I was 21 I finished my bachelors in business administration. I owned two art gallery businesses in my city from ages 21-24. I closed them at 24 to go back to school full time to get my masters in art business. At 26, I finished my masters in art business and have been working for an art company. Also, at 26 I decided to get another masters in art therapy. I am now finishing the masters in art therapy, yet for the past six months I have had this deep desire to get my doctorate in art history or dance. (I’ve been a dancer for over 10 years).

However! Would I be crazy just to go straight into school. My whole life I have been in school more than I haven’t and I’m unsure if this is a good idea.


r/AskAcademia • • 9h ago

Social Science Non TT lecturing position?

3 Upvotes

Currently in the middle writing my dissertation. I am not sure about next year’s funding so was looking what’s out there and saw a non tenure track lecturer job opening nearby. What are the pros and cons of taking that job if I get it? The pay is around 60k for 3:3 teaching load. I like teaching. The only issue for me is the non-tenure track bit…


r/AskAcademia • • 1d ago

STEM First TT job offer

48 Upvotes

Just got s verbal offer my first TT job at an R2. The problem is the salary is significantly lower than what I make right now as a research scientist (and worse benefits), although still a decent salary for my location. Also, the school is 1.5 hours from where I live. They seemed pretty set on me being in person 5 days a week but I would like to negotiate 1-2 days of remote work. Otherwise they have not given me much info to go off. I asked if there was room to negotiate on salary and they said no. The main issue with staying at my current job is the lack of job security due to funding issues. The grant funding my current team runs out next year and I have no idea if they plan to keep us on after that. Any advice?

Editing for clarification: 12 month appointment, hard money, 75% teaching (happy with this, I love teaching). I don't really need startup funds or lab space, in my field I work with data. I don't want to relocate for many reasons. Also the hiring process was weirdly easy- no campus visit, I just did a 40 min talk over zoom and then had a zoom meeting with the dean who basically talked the whole time and didnt ask me any questions.


r/AskAcademia • • 9h ago

STEM Final in-person visit for an RWTH PhD position — how close am I to an offer?

2 Upvotes

Hello Everyone!!

I’m currently in the selection process for a Research Associate/PhD position at RWTH Aachen (Institute of Heat and mass transfer), and I’m trying to understand how close I actually am to getting the position.

I’ve already had two online interviews for this. After the second one, they emailed me saying that I made a very positive impression and that I’m a “top candidate,” but they didn’t give me a formal offer.

Recently, they invited me to Aachen for an in-person visit. They’re covering my travel and hotel, will show me around the institute and labs, introduce me to the team, and we’ll also have lunch together.

I asked whether this visit is mainly for me to see the institute or whether it is still part of the selection process. They clarified that it serves both purposes and is the final step of the selection process, mainly to make sure it is a good fit for both sides before making the final decision.

So obviously I know I don’t officially have the position until I receive an offer. But for people familiar with German universities/RWTH hiring: does this usually mean that I’m essentially their preferred candidate and they just want to confirm the in-person fit before making the offer? Or is it common to bring multiple final candidates to campus and pay for their travel/hotel before deciding?


r/AskAcademia • • 6h ago

Professional Fields - Law, Business, etc. Law PhD

0 Upvotes

I've checked out a few of the posts on here and none seem related to my area which is Law. I'm looking to apply for a Law PHD at a UK University and will be self funding.

Any initial advice?

Are self funding applications still quite competitive?

At what point do you contact a potential supervisor?

For context, I've been out of academia for 9 years (Masters in 2017) and currently am self employed running my own business.


r/AskAcademia • • 11h ago

Interdisciplinary Only answer if you enjoyed doing your PhD research!

2 Upvotes

what is your PhD about? How did you end up in that research area?

Did you get interested before or during the research?

Did others also find it interesting? Why?


r/AskAcademia • • 8h ago

STEM How to make MATLAB Scope plots more legible for paper?

0 Upvotes

Hello everyone, I am writing my very first research paper these days but I am stuck on a problem. So basically I have this MATLAB model which gives the SoC v/s balancing times of 2 different cases. However, the scope of MATLAB is such that the graphs are not very legible. How do I make the scope more legible for a paper I aim to publish in some sort of conference. Also, another thing I was told was to convert it to an XY-plot with values starting from 0 but then you would have to zoom in a lot to see the changes but I was told to figure it out and do it anyway, what should I do?


r/AskAcademia • • 8h ago

Social Science Imposter syndrome kicking in with academia being so competitive

0 Upvotes

Counseling psychology phd. Defended last month now graduation is lurking in the corner. I was supposed to graduate in Summer but life happened and dissertation did not. I already feel like I am late in the game. It has been my dream to join academia since the start but seeing how competitive is, it is kicking in some serious imposter syndrome and procrastination. Writing cover letters make me sick and I keep doubting if it is good enough. Looking for advice from folks who have joined TT positions recently. How can I successfully navigate this process without falling off the rails and giving up on this dream?


r/AskAcademia • • 8h ago

Professional Misconduct in Research Does a phd help you or make it harder to find a job outside of academia?

0 Upvotes

I just ended my master in forestry and thinking about doing a phd, but I am not sure if I will want to stay in the research field or academia in the future, so I have a lot of doubts whether doing so will make it easier or harder for me to move on to other types of jobs later. I like the kind of work involved in a Ph.D., as long as it’s a practical subject (in my case, focused on management, projects, climate change, industry, etc.), but I’d like to eventually move into industry or companies that lead interesting projects, rather than stay in academia because I don’t like teaching. Do u think a phd is valued outside of academia and can make it easier to get competitive positions or it may be a waste of time?


r/AskAcademia • • 9h ago

Interpersonal Issues How should I go about asking about scholarship updates?

0 Upvotes

Hi all, I've been (very gratefully) nominated for a scholarship that covers my masters. The professor who is kind of the 'representative' for the scholarship asked me if I would like to be the recipient first, I obv say yes, and the next day the dean and president also ask me, and I say yes again (I think the prof is kind of like the middle man which is why they sent her first). It's a new scholarship, so it'll take some time to be 'made' they said, or be fully instated (which makes sense). I am still doing my bachelors so it's ok this is taking some time to be made, I can't use it for the next academic year anyways. Next year will be my last academic year (Graduate spring 2028), should I ask for an update to see if its still in progress, etc? I know they wouldn't just nominate someone else when theyve had people come to me to confirm I would like to have this scholarship, but because its a 2/3 year early ask, I'm slightly paranoid (as im sure you can all tell), they will want someone else more, or forget, etc. Should I 'check in' with the prof (the middle man) to see if theres 'any updates' on the scholarship news? If yes, how do you suggest I go abit asking it in a normal person way whos definitely not wanting to lose this scholarship haha. What would you suggest as a professor if you were the one having a student come up to you to ask about it?

I am from Canada, and the scholarship is related to Chinese language study.


r/AskAcademia • • 10h ago

STEM Should I mail PI?

0 Upvotes

I am applying for PhD position in MSCA DN. The application process includes sending all the required documents on an email provided. That email is not of the PI of the project I am targeting...it belongs to MSCA coordinator. So, my question is, should I separately approach the project PI as well and introduce myself and send my CV? Or would that have a negative impact?


r/AskAcademia • • 10h ago

Admissions - please post in /r/gradadmissions, not here Fordham or Pace?

0 Upvotes

So I just got into Fordham, Pace (online), Hofstra, CUNY Brooklyn and CUNY Queens (my undergrad college)— all for the master of science in computer science program. I’m trying to choose between Fordham or Pace online because I just learned about being forced to present a capstone project or a thesis at the end of your grad school journey in computer science. Now, I have classic stage fright about public speaking, I just won’t be able to speak in front of whole class for an hour or so I heard. So I’m thinking to go with Pace online program since if I’ll maybe have to present online over zoom (just a guess). But, I genuinely wanted to go to Fordham since it’s my top choice school. Can someone please confirm if I can present only in front a few professors in a separate room or even better— record my presentation and send to committee for grading at Fordham?

I was also wondering if the individual grad CS courses also required presentations about a project students might do. I seriously just cannot prepare nor imagine myself talking in front of whole class about something I did.


r/AskAcademia • • 4h ago

Interdisciplinary Thoughts on the effectiveness of APA formatting vs. others like MLA, Chicago, IEEE?

0 Upvotes

Personally, I've found APA to be rather clunky when working on research papers. IEEE has always been a good one, but at the same time I feel like there's just something missing.

To that end, I've created a set of bespoke formatting guidelines that aim to improve upon APA's shortcomings. It is christened:

Dimbulon's Magnificent Strictures of Writing That Everyone Must Follow Or Else Something Not Good Will Happen To Them, Like A Thief Will Rob Them Or Maybe They Will Lose Their Wallet.

It is exactly the same as APA, save for three main changes.

1: Mandatory Ordinal Dates

All dates under Dimbulon's Magnificent Strictures of Writing That Everyone Must Follow Or Else Something Not Good Will Happen To Them, Like A Thief Will Rob Them Or Maybe They Will Lose Their Wallet.'s system must include proper ordinal suffixes. For example, when writing the date on the title page, you would write "November 18th, 2026" rather than "November 18, 2026". This is because it looks better and everybody, obviously, thinks it would be much better this way. Of course.

2: Willy-Nilly Citations

Nobody cares about proper citations at all, so under Dimbulon's Magnificent Strictures of Writing That Everyone Must Follow Or Else Something Not Good Will Happen To Them, Like A Thief Will Rob Them Or Maybe They Will Lose Their Wallet.'s system, you can basically cite things however you want. Be as detailed and exact or vague and incomprehensible as you want! With this standard, every research paper will come with a fun citation treasure hunt component!

3: You are NEVER allowed to abbreviate or un-bold or edit in any way Dimbulon's Magnificent Strictures of Writing That Everyone Must Follow Or Else Something Not Good Will Happen To Them, Like A Thief Will Rob Them Or Maybe They Will Lose Their Wallet. when referring to Dimbulon's Magnificent Strictures of Writing That Everyone Must Follow Or Else Something Not Good Will Happen To Them, Like A Thief Will Rob Them Or Maybe They Will Lose Their Wallet..

In order to preserve the natural respect commanded by Dimbulon's Magnificent Strictures of Writing That Everyone Must Follow Or Else Something Not Good Will Happen To Them, Like A Thief Will Rob Them Or Maybe They Will Lose Their Wallet., no one is ever allowed to abbreviate or change it's name when referring to it. That includes the period at the very end, which is a critical part of Dimbulon's Magnificent Strictures of Writing That Everyone Must Follow Or Else Something Not Good Will Happen To Them, Like A Thief Will Rob Them Or Maybe They Will Lose Their Wallet.'s identity as an academic standard.

That's the basic rundown of my idea! I'd appreciate any critique or thoughts on Dimbulon's Magnificent Strictures of Writing That Everyone Must Follow Or Else Something Not Good Will Happen To Them, Like A Thief Will Rob Them Or Maybe They Will Lose Their Wallet., because I'm still trying to work out the kinks before presenting it directly to every ivy league university in the world and begging venture capitalists to give me money. Thanks!


r/AskAcademia • • 13h ago

Interpersonal Issues How do you set daily research goals? Do you aim for a certain word count, specific tasks, or something else?

1 Upvotes

I've been struggling with how to set realistic daily goals for my research.

Unlike other types of work, research never seems to have a clear endpoint. There's always another paragraph to revise, another paper to read, another experiment to run, or something that could be improved.

Sometimes I spend an entire day working on my research, but I still don't feel a sense of accomplishment because everything feels unfinished.

I'm curious how other researchers define a productive day.

Do you set measurable goals, like writing 500 words, reading two papers, completing one experiment, or revising a specific section?

Or do you simply work for a certain number of hours and call it a day?


r/AskAcademia • • 14h ago

Humanities How many Mentors is too much for a History Project

1 Upvotes

Hello, I am a medical student who will be partaking on an archival summer research project outside of my home country. History is completely outside my field but I'm thinking with the help of mentors it should be doable. I have confirmed 2 mentors, one in my home country who reached out to the 2nd in the UK on my behalf.

Is it useful and appropriate to bring on more mentors?

There is a 3rd advisor from the UK that I'd like guidance from as there work is in the same timeframe that I'll be studying. But I am worried if this looks bad to the first 2 mentors that confirmed to help me, if it's overkill, might it affect authorship, and anything else.

This is my first historical project and first personal led project so honestly I got no clue.


r/AskAcademia • • 5h ago

Interpersonal Issues Seeking Advice Regarding Missed Examss

0 Upvotes

Good afternoon, I hope that you are all doing well. I am studying a finance-related field, and have received a great job offer for after I graduate next spring, which I am extremely thankful for, which is why I am so concerned about this issue.

I am in a course that is not related to my major, and in the syllabus, in one portion, states "for maximum time flexibility, exams will be available anytime you want to take them. will appear on Blackboard on the dates listed in section IV." I interpreted this as meaning they could be taken throughout the semester, and the dates listed later were when they opened. As such, I did not take 2 exams, and am in a position to fail the course. I am a consistently good student, president of the honors organization within my college, and have never had a situation where I have been close to failing a class. There have been some extenuating circumstances (mother getting divorced and needing financial support, disabled father needing continued financial support and breaking his hip/leg) but I have persevered in my other classes, so I do not know if there is any merit to me saying that caused me to misinterpret the syllabus.

I am just asking if there is a course of action to be able to retake the exams, withdraw, or otherwise avoid failing the course and subsequently losing my job offer. Thank you in advance for help.


r/AskAcademia • • 20h ago

Social Science Visiting Researcher at a Chinese university – what commitments are normally expected?

2 Upvotes

Hi there!

I'm a psychology professor at a European public university and I'm arranging a three-month research stay at a Chinese university (January–March 2028).

In previous international research stays, I've worked quite independently: conducting my own research, using the university library, meeting local academics, perhaps giving one or two seminars, and travelling around the country to learn about its culture and society.

However, this university (that I prefer not to mention) wants to appoint me as a Visiting Researcher under a two or three-year appointment. The position is unpaid, and they require an activity plan. Their policy mentions activities such as regularly contributing to teaching, seminars and workshops, or conducting collaborative research with university academics.

I'm wondering whether this is standard practice.

I don't mind giving an occasional lecture or seminar, but I don't want regular teaching duties or ongoing institutional commitments. My intention is primarily to conduct independent research and use the university as an academic base while exploring China.

A few questions:

Is a three-year Visiting Researcher appointment normal for someone only staying physically for three months?

Can the activity plan be limited to independent research and occasional academic contributions?

Is it reasonable to negotiate a flexible arrangement without regular teaching or other ongoing obligations?

I'd appreciate hearing from anyone with experience of similar arrangements, particularly in China.

Thanks!


r/AskAcademia • • 1d ago

STEM Feeling Hopeless RE: Tenure Track Positions

41 Upvotes

Leave it to days where a paper gets rejected to boil up these feelings again. But I could appreciate a venting session and maybe some advice.

I am a Research Scientist (basically non-tenure track faculty) at a Microbiology and Immunology department at an R1 state institution, and have been for the past 3 years after 3 years as a postdoc. I have 20 publications with a good mix of first author, second author, middling authorships and co-corresponding authorship. I am Co-PI on a $4 million dollar grant that I pretty much run, but is in my faculty sponsor's name as PI because I am not in a tenured position. I have teaching experience through assistantships and as instructor of record. I have won awards for my research and mentorship. I am internationally recognized in my community and have lead several international collaborative teams. I have ideas for a research program that is not only important, but also is very fundable and has a lot of traction. I am, on paper, basically everything that people describe in what they look for when hiring tenure track faculty. I have submitted 70 applications. I only heard back from one who after the virtual interview both the committee and I decided that the position was not quite what I was looking for (entirely soft money, much like my current position).

I don't even know any more. It is so difficult to stay motivated. I look back to some of the positions I've put in for, and over 75% of them ended up being filled by people at the associate or full levels despite being advertised at the assistant level or open rank. How are we supposed to compete with people that have decades on us and have had significant institutional startup to build their program and are just hopping institutions for better pay?

What the hell am I missing?