I’m writing this because I honestly don’t know if what I’m feeling is just my personal frustration after a painful experience, or if it is something many academics experience.
I recently applied for a permanent academic position in Spain (Assistant Professor level). I ended up second, and what has really devastated me is not simply losing the position, but the way the evaluation system seems to work.
I have always been aware that academia is not a perfectly meritocratic system. I know that networks, institutional prestige, and having senior academics supporting you can make a huge difference. In my case, I don’t have a “godfather” inside academia, I don’t have someone advocating for me behind the scenes, and I have always felt that the only way I could compete was by building a strong research record.
So that is what I did. I published extensively, worked constantly, and tried to make my CV strong enough that, even without connections, I could at least compete on relatively equal terms with people who might have institutional advantages.
The most frustrating part is the evaluation of academic publications. In this section, the winning candidate had around 27 points, while I had over 120 points before the application of the scoring limits. However, the system establishes a maximum cap of 30 points for this section. After applying this cap, that enormous difference in actual publication record was reduced to only three points.
When a difference of almost 100 points in research output is reduced to just three points, it feels like the system is actively preventing highly productive researchers from being rewarded for their work.
There is also a technical issue that I am currently considering challenging. The call includes a proportional scaling formula intended to preserve differences between candidates when scores are adjusted. However, in my case it seems that this formula was applied only at the level of the main sections, not at the level of the individual sub-sections. This means that large differences inside the publication category were flattened before the proportional adjustment could properly reflect them. I am planning to submit an appeal, although I honestly have no idea whether it will be taken seriously or whether it will change anything.
What is especially frustrating is the contradiction: academia constantly says that excellence, internationalization, publications, and research impact matter. But then mechanisms are introduced that can neutralize precisely those achievements.
Another thing that frustrates me is how much emphasis is sometimes placed on factors that depend heavily on institutional circumstances. For example, certain doctoral distinctions can receive a lot of weight, but some universities simply do not promote or prioritize those distinctions in the same way. Candidates can end up being penalized for circumstances that are not entirely under their control.
I think what hurts the most is that I genuinely believed that, despite the unfairness of academia, working extremely hard could allow someone without connections to compete. I knew that having no “inside support” would make things harder, but I thought that a very strong research record could compensate for it. This experience has shaken that belief.
So I wanted to ask: is this a common feeling among academics? Do people in other countries experience similar situations, where evaluation systems unintentionally (or intentionally) flatten differences between candidates and make it harder for independent researchers to advance? Or am I simply reacting emotionally to a very painful rejection?
I would genuinely like to hear other experiences.