r/AskAPriest • • Sep 29 '26

Parish priest uses "Palestine" instead of "Israel" during homilies. Is this acceptable?

4 Upvotes

It makes me uncomfortable that he's changing the words from the Bible ("Israelites" to "Palestinians", "Israel" to "Palestine") during his homilies. He does not do this when reading the Gospel. Am I being too sensitive or is this really is problematic?


r/AskAPriest • • Nov 13 '25

I miss The Church but I don’t know if I can come back

5 Upvotes

I converted a few years ago. I am no longer practicing, but i deeply miss it. I have problems with the church and I’d love it if someone could talk through these things with me. My problems are mainly political.

  1. Abortion. I believe The Church shouldnt advocate for policies that oppress women such as anti-abortion. I understand the teachings. I also think the church’s views should not dictate politics. I really hate that my tithe might go to advocate for repressive policies like this. If the church would guarantee my money wouldn’t be used for political advocacy like this I’d be more inclined to tithe.

  2. Women. I feel like the church’s stance on women in ministry is at odds with itself. Mary Magdalene was the Apostle to the Apostles, yet women can’t be leaders in the church?

  3. Extremism. I feel like I see more and more Catholic extremism everyday. The “traditional Catholic” group seems to be particularly susceptible to extremism. I’ve not seen any work to tamper that - does the church care that that’s happening?


r/AskAPriest • • Dec 16 '24

how to handle scandal in my parish

2 Upvotes

Hello Fathers,

there is a man in our parish, who is also part of the catechesis team for our confirmation classes, who is more or less openly in a homosexual relationship. Our priest, who isn't really liberal in any meaningful way, knows about this and doesn't seem to care at all. Maybe I'm overreacting, but I am kind of scandalised that our priest gives the impression of implicit approval. I have a pretty good relationship with our priest and I was wondering if you had any idea how to handle the situation. Would it be inappropriate for me to talk about this to my priest? Im from Germany btw '. Thanks so much for your advice.


r/AskAPriest • • May 24 '25

Do you feel bad when praying in a Church built by slaves?

19 Upvotes

I live very close to a baroque town from the 17th century. There we have the most beautiful Churches in Brazil, and everytime I go there, I like to pray.

However, I have been feeling like a hypocrite because all those Churches were built by black African slaves who were violently kidnapped and brought here. There are museums displaying the horrific conditions that they were put, and we can visit the dungeons were they were kept.

How do you reconcile a holy place being made by violence? I am white and everytime I pray there I feel like a fraud.

Thanks.


r/AskAPriest • • Apr 23 '26

Question Regarding Forced Pronouns at Work

0 Upvotes

My employer is asking everyone to add pronouns to their work emails. I only believe in two genders, and feel this is in conflict with my beliefs.

I am tempted to just do it to avoid conflict, but this does not feel right to me. Thoughts?


r/AskAPriest • • Nov 30 '24

Help! A family friend gave my son a Jewish blessing, is that allowed?

0 Upvotes

Things go like this. Im Catholic, husband comes from a Jewish family but is an atheist. He agreed to get our son baptised, we did and he respects my religion, but since he was raised an atheist he has like zero knowledge of what is and isnt allowed in, well, basically any religion. Yesterday he went to a shabbat dinner at his friend's family house (I was also invited but couldn't make it due to a very nasty cold). His friend and their family are of course very religious and they gave my baby like a Jewish blessing for babies. He just told me this and I was like O_O. He told me he didn't know it wasn't allowed and honestly I don't know either! Is it OK to receive a blessing from someone from a different religion? Couldn't find anything on the internet about that. I dont think something like this will happen again but just in case I would like to know.


r/AskAPriest • • Dec 19 '24

Moral question about Santa

1 Upvotes

How do we reconcile our intuitions about the levity of lying to kids about Santa Claus when the church teaches that lying is an intrinsic evil that cannot be justified.


r/AskAPriest • • Jul 22 '26

Does the Church still excommunicate people who shoot Christians with crossbows?

2 Upvotes

We prohibit under anathema that murderous art of crossbowmen and archers, which is hateful to God, to be employed against Christians and Catholics from now on. (Canon 29, Lateran II)

I’m interested to know the answer to this! This is a very unique canon I’ve heard of from Lateran II - it was brought up in a discussion on Church teaching on nuclear weapons - where the Church excommunicated those who shot a Christian/Catholic with a crossbow or other “archers” weapon. Does this still apply these days? If 2 Catholic countries went to war tomorrow and a soldier shot an opponent with a bow, would this result in excommunication where shooting him with a gun wouldn’t? If a Catholic soldier had no means of defending himself except a crossbow, would he be forbidden to use it, but could use a gun?


r/AskAPriest • • Oct 04 '25

Is it a sin to go to another priest for confession?

0 Upvotes

The Fourth Lateran Council explicitly ordered the faithful “to confess…to their own priest” and allowed confession to another only “if they first ask and obtain the permission of their own priest”1. Thomas Aquinas, quoting the same council, stresses that a priest who lacks jurisdiction “cannot administer…the sacrament…of Penance”

Is this just an ancient thing and there has been a newer council overriding this?


r/AskAPriest • • Jan 30 '26

Working mother

2 Upvotes

It has been brought to my attention that I have not been living according to something in the Roman Catechism. I did not know it was there until I was called out for it as I had only ever read the most recent Catechism.

'To train their children in the practice of virtue and to pay particular attention to their domestic concerns should also be especial objects of their attention. The wife should love to remain at home, unless compelled by necessity to go out; and she should never presume to leave home without her husband’s consent. '

I've been carrying on as a working mother all of these years, doing my best to raise my children in the faith, and then find out that my whole adult life has been one big sin. Now that I know it has made me so upset to the point of feeling sick and I am so ashamed, but I am also not comfortable quitting my job at this point in time. How much moral trouble am I in here if I do not change my ways?


r/AskAPriest • • Oct 03 '23

What is Pope Francis doing?

10 Upvotes

The past two days Pope Francis has said several very very confusing and troubling things. Attaching one link and the other I can’t find again but basically he apparently said that divorced and remarried Catholics could receive Communion without abstaining from sexual relations.

https://www.ncronline.org/vatican/vatican-news/pope-signals-openness-blessings-gay-couples-study-womens-ordination

All of these things look to be clearly in opposition to church doctrine.

This whole Synod thing seems like the worst idea ever. It seems to me that what we think doesn’t matter, what matters is the teachings of tradition, scripture, and the Magisterium, right? What kind of harm is this going to do to the church? What if he issues something official that goes against church teaching? What do we do except pray? What do I say in defense of my faith to my Protestant friends who are rightly identifying this as a very clear weakness in church leadership?

I’m a fairly recent convert (Easter 2022) and I’m very willing to be wrong, but I just don’t know what to think.


r/AskAPriest • • May 30 '19

How do I tell a priest that his socks are distracting from mass?

0 Upvotes

I visited a very beautiful church for a mass. The priest donned his clerical robes, but he was wearing white socks with a blue bird on them. Worse, the altar was up a few steps, so they were closer to eye level. It was really distracting seeing ornate clerical robes in stark contrast with, to be frank, something I thought would be more appropriate on a child.

Is there a good way to tell a priest that his socks are distracting from mass, especially if I'm not a regular parishioner?


r/AskAPriest • • Dec 23 '25

Mass as sickness spreader events

1 Upvotes

Hi Fathers- I’m really struggling. I’m so afraid of going to mass with my small children. I’m also prone to sickness after I had Covid a couple years ago. Is it acceptable to miss mass because of this? For instance, everyone and their mother comes to Christmas mass, sniffling, coughing, with fevers, and whenever I’m in a busy mass, getting sick is all I can think about, which should obviously not be the case. Any advice on how to get through this sick season and still worship in community would be appreciated.


r/AskAPriest • • Mar 03 '25

Have you come across someone confessing killing or raping someone in the confession box & how do priests react to such confessions? Do priests immediately call Police?

0 Upvotes

r/AskAPriest • • Aug 24 '24

I stopped going to Mass

0 Upvotes

I stopped attending because I felt persecuted by our Pope’s statements against traditional Catholicism and the Latin Mass. I understand that I am in a state of mortal sin. What should I do about this?


r/AskAPriest • • Jul 30 '26

The Future of Traditional Catholicism

0 Upvotes

This days there has been some talk regarding pope Leo XIV not reversing the TLM restrictions.

Although it didn't come off as a surprise, it still provoked some though regarding the future of traditional Catholicism and I am interested in what your opinions are.

To begin with, I truly crave deep faith and connection with God. I have had one period in life of painful spiritual dryness when I was even thinking of becoming an Eastern Orthodox believer, as I admired, and still do, how passionately they approach liturgy and tradition and how rich it is, as well as the depth of their spiritual lives. Glory be to God for he helped me stay in the Holy Mother Church, and encouraged me to search more passionately for him through the struggle. A lot of time has passed and, although I can see God through Novus Ordo masses etc., I still yearn for more mystical and richer approach to the faith. I find myself fascinated by looking at what TLM is, what certain traditions, now abandoned, looked like. It is absolutely beautiful. Now, I actually think about becoming a priest, and groups like FSSP and ICKSP have caught my eye. But then I think about whether I romanticize all of this too much? And what is the future of it all? It is usually said that younger generations crave traditionalism? At what range is it true? From what I see, it is usually mostly the people on the Internet, or at least there aren't many people with such ideals here where I live. What are your thoughts? Will traditional Catholicism see massive growth in future decades or will it continue to be passionate but minor group in the Church? Will the Vatican's approach to it all change in the next years, decades?

I am excited to hear your opinions!

God bless!


r/AskAPriest • • Jul 11 '24

What does the Church say about Halloween?

0 Upvotes

I'm aware Halloween is a pagan tradition, but is there a difference between participating in trick or treating and dressing up in scary costumes like the tradition goes, and dressing up in costumes that are pop culture related and having a halloween themed party? Or are they both to be avoided? I'm also aware of All Saints' Day being the next day

EDIT: is there a teaching on Krampus? Doing some digging and not finding a solid answer

Thank you and God bless you fathers!


r/AskAPriest • • Feb 16 '26

Mental Illness and Priests

0 Upvotes

I recently read that Christian pastors (including but not limited to Catholic priests) tend to attract narcissists who ultimately cause more harm than good to congregants. I have been fortunate to not have encountered this, but does the Church have a system of ensuring that seminarians do not have this illness, or is there a system of support for priests with narcissism so that they can serve without causing harm?


r/AskAPriest • • Jun 30 '26

May I ask an ordinary parish priest to bless holy water in the old rite?

0 Upvotes

I was looking up the old Rituale Romanum and asked AI about If me, as a lay person asking a priest to bless water and salt to make Holy Water is possible. And it replied with conflicting answers each time. It said that under Traditionis Custodes unless the priests is of a personal parish that celebrates the TLM then it’s not permitted, or they have to ask their bishop for approval, but that doesn’t really line up with the priests online that says they’re still using the old rite of blessings??? Anyways I’m just really confused. And if it’s possible, do they have to bless it in Latin or it could be done in vernacular. Thanks!


r/AskAPriest • • Apr 22 '23

How to help my Catholic clients?

0 Upvotes

Hi there, I'm not a Catholic, and am someone who would overall be regarded as an unrepentant sinner. I'm a phone sex operator and my username is... not inaccurate. But I am also a human being capable of compassion and as someone deeply religious in my own faith, who does pastoral care in my church, seeing people in spiritual distress is upsetting to me and I want to help.

I get a lot of Catholic guys who are struggling with... essentially being er... aroused by Satan, which given their faith is understandably distressing for them. As soon as they finish they're terrified and very worried about the state of their souls. I generally recommend they confess to their priests because this cycle of doing stuff and then feeling horrible about afterwards can't be psychologically healthy, and Catholicism seems to have a pretty good system for having someone to talk to about private issues such as this where maybe they could get some support and help and they almost universally tell me that they're too embarrassed to talk to their priests about these issues.

And I'm like "...the seal of the confessional is pretty much the most intense privacy agreement you can have, and you believe you're at risk of eternal punishment from an all-knowing, all-powerful god, and you're worried about embarrassing yourself in front of a guy when you're also clearly suffering?" and I was just wondering if you had any advice on ways to encourage them to actually go or resources I could direct them to that might be easier for them to make use of, if they're too embarrassed to talk to their parish priest?


r/AskAPriest • • Oct 24 '24

Are modern confirmations valid? Let me explain.

0 Upvotes

Recently, a good friend of mine asked me to be his godfather for confirmation.
He was confirmed a long time ago by a catholic bishop. I was also confirmed by the same bishop a long time ago.
We are both traditional catholics and we both know that confirmation must be done once in our lifetime. It would be a sin to do it again as far as I know.
The problem is that my friend wants to be confirmed in the old rite. He argues that there might be some problems in the new confirmation rite that would render the new rites invalid. An example he gave me is that instead of using olive oil as the matter of the sacrament there have been some instances of people using vegetable oil. This is just an example of what he argues might render the sacrament invalid, or at least doubtful.
I honestly dont know enough to make a decision in this. I trust the Church that the new rites are valid, but if there is any reasonable doubt that a sacrament was administered invalidly what can I do or whom can I ask for guidance?


r/AskAPriest • • Feb 02 '22

does all sex have to result in child birth? NSFW

1 Upvotes

Title says it all. I know the medieval and renaissance church was super anal about this so I wanna ask some priests what they think today. Is it a sin if you have sex with the intention of NOT having children, and is sodomy really a sin if both sides are enjoying themselves?


r/AskAPriest • • Apr 13 '24

Can a Priest incorporate TLM practices into Novus ordo Masses?

1 Upvotes

I am a 16-year-old discerning a vocation to the priesthood. The increasing prevalence of liberal practices within the post Vatican II Church has been troubling for me and sometimes makes me question my vocation. While I feel a deep connection to the Mass of 1962 and traditional (or rigid as Pope Francis would say) Catholicism, I am also considering the stability and virtuous obedience that comes with joining diocesan priesthood rather than the FSSP or something similar, especially given the current liberal trends in the Church.

I understand a lot of this may be controversial, which I don't know why. But as a potential future priest, I'm interested in knowing if I can incorporate many amazing and reverent elements of the TLM into the Ordinary Form Mass autonomously. A list of some are below:

  • Celebrate Mass Ad Orientem

  • Use Latin in the liturgy for parts of the Mass such as the Kyrie, Gloria, Sanctus, and Agnus Dei.

  • Use majority Gregorian chant for the prayers and responses, and all choir music

  • Use Eucharistic Prayer 1

  • Use more traditional vestments like the Roman chasuble, baretta, and maniple.

  • Communion at Altar Rail, as in, install an altar rail b/c most novus ordo parishes had them removed

  • Promote reception of Holy Communion on the tongue while kneeling, not denying anyone of course

  • No extraordinary ministers of holy communion!!!

  • No altar Girls

  • No sign of peace

Can these changes be implemented by a priest on his own, or would they require approval from the bishop? Because I quite frankly don't feel comfortable celebrate the Novus ordo mass with many of these liberal practices. Any advice or insights from those familiar with both forms of the Mass would be greatly appreciated. And feel free to call me out if I'm misinformed.


r/AskAPriest • • Dec 06 '23

Does the Pope's firing of Bishop Strickland show that there is a low level civil war ongoing between liberal Pope Francis and conservative American bishops?

0 Upvotes

r/AskAPriest • • Mar 07 '25

Under what circumstances is it permissible to ask for a dispensation from perpetual vows in a religious congregation?

0 Upvotes

I am a young man discerning a vocation. Initially, I felt called to the priesthood, but since the seminary in my diocese is extremely corrupt (doctrinally and morally), I ruled out that possibility. I've considered secular lay celibacy, but within that, I could not think of a very magnanimous way in which I, in my conditions and talents, could offer my life to God and to the brothers - it's hard to beat the priesthood and the religious life in this sense. And I see that people really need good priests. I am now a postulant in a monastery in my hometown, which serves several chapels in the city. My calling here would be to serve God and my brothers as a religious priest.

But, if I could, I believe I would choose the secular priesthood... I believe that many of you know the state of degradation in which many religious congregations find themselves. In this scenario, I don't see much point in cutting off ties with my family and uplifting friendships because of the cloister. Furthermore, the relationship with the superior ends up being more like that of a boss and employee (but every day and 24/7) than that of a spiritual father and his disciple, and the living with the other monks is not always the most edifying.

For this reason, the idea of ​​taking perpetual vows in the monastery distresses me. While I am a postulant or novice, and even when I make temporary profession, there is a certain reversibility to the situation. But my fear is that after taking perpetual vows, the situation will change here. Whether another abbot will no longer allow certain contact with the family, or moral degradation will take over, or the monastery will close and I will have to be transferred to another city/country...

That is why I sometimes feel that I am not being authentic in my monastic vocation, but merely embracing it out of love for God so that I can serve Him as a priest.

I have been dealing with this resistance with my spiritual director, but I confess that I am not getting very clear guidance.

Hence the question: under what conditions could I request a dispensation from perpetual vows?

If the monastery deteriorates further or closes and I have to be transferred to another one (considering that I am well-established in the city and chose this one precisely because of this), would that be sufficient grounds for such a request for dispensation?

Furthermore, what advice would you give me in my current situation?