r/AskAPriest • • Nov 12 '20

I don't necessarily have a question, rather a statement, it's a true gift that you give each and every one of us your time, every day. I thank you, Fathers, most deeply.

839 Upvotes

r/AskAPriest • • Jan 29 '21

How should we respond to homeless people begging on street?

397 Upvotes

It’s not too uncommon to be driving and there be a homeless person begging for food/money, or one might be walking on the sidewalk near a beggar. I would normally think that I must give something to them, especially out of charity and love for them. However, some people say that giving money to a potential drug addict would be imprudent for obvious reasons, although we can’t know any particular homeless person’s situation. Some people fear getting robbed. However, should we always feel bound to give at least food/water? It feels very off to just walk by people without at least acknowledging them or saying anything, but that’s what 95% of people do. Any advice/guidance on how to treat homeless people?


r/AskAPriest • • Jul 06 '22

Will the Catholic Church Ever Formally Acknowledge That Pineapple on Pizza is Heresy and Committing the Act of Using It as a Topping a Mortal Sin?

348 Upvotes

Too long has this abomination of a “topping” been tricking the minds of the people leading that it can be used as such. It’s unnatural, inappropriate and quite frankly, disgusting.

Would love to hear your thoughts.


r/AskAPriest • • Mar 26 '21

Pastoral questions should be asked of your own priest if at all possible.

332 Upvotes

This subreddit should not be used primarily for helping ease scrupulous consciences. The primary purpose is to help answer casual questions that only the unique viewpoint of a priest can ask.

If you can, it is always best to ask your own parish priest about questions of sin or of a pastoral nature.


r/AskAPriest • • Oct 18 '22

Not religious-but will you pray for me? Im really struggling, very low, led a very tough life, and the thought of someone with faith saying a prayer for me would mean something to me. Would help me know I am not totally alone in my struggles.

322 Upvotes

r/AskAPriest • • Apr 25 '21

Please read this post before submitting a question! Your post may be removed if it doesn't follow these guidelines.

318 Upvotes

This subreddit is primarily for:

  • Questions about the priesthood

  • Casual questions that only the unique viewpoint of a priest can answer

  • Basic advice

  • Asking about situations you're not sure how to approach and need guidance on where to start

This subreddit is generally not for:

  • Spiritual or vocational advice

  • Seeking advice around scrupulosity

  • Questions along the lines of "is this a mortal sin," "should I confess this," "I'm not sure if I confessed this correctly," etc.

The above things are best discussed with your own priest and not random priest online. They are not strictly forbidden, but they may be removed at mod discretion.

The subreddit should also not be used for asking theological questions that could be answered at the /r/Catholicism subreddit.

Please also use the search function before asking questions to see if anyone else has asked about the topic before. We are all priests with full time ministry jobs and cannot answer every question that comes in on the subreddit, so saving time by seeing if your questions has already been asked helps us a lot.

Thank you!


r/AskAPriest • • Feb 16 '25

Why so much hate for Pope Francis?

288 Upvotes

I read Pope Francis was hospitalized overnight. I was appalled at the comments about him. “He’s a leftist, he needs to stay out of politics, he’s not a Catholic pope etc.” Why is he a victim of so much hate?


r/AskAPriest • • Oct 18 '24

Do priests have special PJs?

264 Upvotes

I explained to my catholic 7-year old what this subreddit is about and that she could ask a priest any question she wanted.

My daughter would love to know, do priests wear special pajamas to bed? Eg bedtime cassock?

Thanks, God bless!


r/AskAPriest • • May 13 '24

Funny babies in Mass

261 Upvotes

When my 25-year old was a talking toddler, at Mass, during the scripture-reading, the Lector said something about “the monsters of the deep”.

My son called out, “Nooo! No monsters!” A quiet chuckle arose from the crowd, and the priest’s shoulders were shaking.

Fathers, please regale us with stories of times kids made you laugh during Mass.

Asking on behalf of every mortified-in-the-moment Catholic mother who may think our kids’ behavior marks us as unfit mothers in your eyes.


r/AskAPriest • • Jun 16 '19

Happy Father’s Day to all of our priests! Thank you for your yes to God. ✝️

250 Upvotes

r/AskAPriest • • Oct 15 '25

Charlie Kirk & Sainthood Rhetoric

236 Upvotes

I really dislike the rhetoric around Charlie Kirk right now especially amongst catholics not just from lay people but also clergy. Why do people feel the need to claim he should be a saint or that he is like a saint. Am I wrong to be offended by this? I mean the man cannot even become a saint he was not even catholic.


r/AskAPriest • • Sep 17 '20

35-year devout Protestant now an RCIA candidate very impressed with the wisdom of the priests in this sub

227 Upvotes

I have been singularly impressed with the deep wisdom and knowledge demonstrated by the priests on this sub. Although many of the questions are cringeworthy, the fathers answer with the patience of a loving parent. This sub is a welcome respite from the Catholicism sub, which is rife with trad/rads, who are sincere, but can make things particularly confusing for new believers. Furthermore, I love that the priests on this sub completely embrace Vatican 2. Which from my perspective is extremely beautiful and worthy of full acceptance.

Thank you fathers! May God bless you and keep you in His great love!


r/AskAPriest • • May 10 '25

Is it worth it for a gay person to try going to mass

219 Upvotes

Im sure this post seems pointless, but I am a women who is with another woman. I myself am atheist, but my partner is a lapsed Catholic. We have both been incredibly, shockingly, moved by pope Leo's appointment (not sure that is the correct word) and my partner expressed a great interest in going to mass this weekend as a result of the new pope. I want to support her and would even go with her and be in the closet for mass, but is it even worth it? Would a priest be offended by our presence?

We live in Florida (US) and she was born and raised in Italy, when we go back home to Italy we go to mass with her family and it's never been an issue, but we fear it would be here. Is it even worth it to try going? How do we find a parish?


r/AskAPriest • • Feb 13 '25

I am going to die soon. Help me die

199 Upvotes

UPDATE: withdrawal likely. thank you for your kindness, i’m going to the doctor today. OCD. alcoholic . i feel less dread than before having had something to drink. will update

Lifelong atheist/agnostic until the last few months. I am developing meningoencephalitis. It will kill me. I am certain of exposure and I am beginning to feel the weight of it. My head aches. I am nauseous. My right arm is growing weak. My neck is stiff. I cannot think or type properly. I am falling apart. I will die soon.

I do not have denomination. But I am a terrible human— suppose I thought I’d have more time to turn myself around before I got killed, I was working in therapy to get rid of my fetishes and my addictions… please help me. Help me repent, help me pray, help me do anything. I don’t want to die. I am in despair. I have no right to eternal life with Him. I don’t, I never did, I forsook my place there at the time of my many awakenings. I am trying to be rid of it so earnestly. But I am still having those thoughts, of drinking, of gross other things, help me

Help me go there, help me see Him


r/AskAPriest • • May 13 '25

Have you accidentally said "Francis our Pope" instead of "Leo our Pope" yet?

194 Upvotes

For some reason my priest said "John Paul our Pope" the other day


r/AskAPriest • • Oct 05 '25

Do you guys know you are awesome?

192 Upvotes

Priests are simply underrated. God bless all your souls.


r/AskAPriest • • Jun 27 '25

Why is no one going to Confession but everyone receiving Communion?

188 Upvotes

Every Sunday, the Communion line is packed but the Confession line is empty.

We all sin, Mortal sin isn’t rare, so why is everyone receiving like it’s automatic?

I asked the local priest afterwards and he said “It’s not really our place to judge.”

This feels like a crisis. Either people don’t know the teaching or they’re ignoring it.

Receiving in mortal sin is a grave offense. Why aren’t more priests talking about this?


r/AskAPriest • • Apr 21 '21

Please use the search function

188 Upvotes

Hello r/AskAPriest

As this forum has grown and more folks have joined us there are often questions which are asked which have already been answered.

Please do search for the topic that you are curious about. See if it has been asked before and what was said. Then if you don't find an answer to your question feel free to ask.

I'm not sure if another mod could make this a stickie as I don't have that ability.


r/AskAPriest • • Oct 25 '20

Is it permissable for a Catholic to oppose Pro-Life legislation because he believes they are an ineffective way to prevent abortion?

182 Upvotes

I hope this question hasn't been asked before; if it has a couldn't find it. So the title pretty much says it all. If a Catholic believes in the sanctity of life from conception and wants to minimize the number of abortions, but believes that Pro-Life laws do little but cause women to seek unsafe abortions and would instead prefer focusing on solving the problems that lead women to get abortions, is this a permissable view to hold in light of Church teaching? I do not want to oppose the teaching of the Church and so would very much appreciate correction if I am in the wrong. Thank you for taking the time to read my question and I apologise if this is the wrong place to ask this.

Edit: I was just reading over my post and realized it might sound a little combative. I assure you that was not my intention and I am only here to be informed and, if necessary, corrected. I sincerely apologise if I gave anyone the wrong impression.


r/AskAPriest • • Jun 15 '26

I saw a man pocket the eucharist

181 Upvotes

Hello. Recently, I was at the funeral mass for my mother in law who passed on. During communion, I was kneeling in the front pew, and I noticed a man who took the eucharist from the eucharistic minister, but as he walked away he put it in his pocket. He looked as though he didn't know what to do. When mass was over, we were all outside getting ready to get in the cars, and I saw him. I approached and introduced myself. I politely told him that it looked as if he didn't consume the eucharist and put it in his pocket. He said he wasnt catholic and didnt know what to do. I asked him if since he isnt catholic and isnt going to consume it if he wouldn't mind giving it to me, and he agreed and I did consume it. I told him not to be embarrassed or feel badly, just next time when he goes up to cross his arms over his chest so the priest or eucharist minister will know he doesnt want the sacrament only a blessing.

So did I handle this correctly?


r/AskAPriest • • Jun 23 '20

I'm accepted into the seminary! ( Need some guidance or tips)

175 Upvotes

After a long journey of discovery and prayer. The bishop accepted me into the seminary. This is a milestone and I'm so excited. I also want to be prepared for it. Are there things that I can do to help me prepare?


r/AskAPriest • • Jun 21 '20

I’m a atheist.... I guess. But I feel drawn to Catholicism

167 Upvotes

Felt this way for sometime and seeing someone else on here very similar made me post. I’ve got some disagreements with the church but I still feel drawn to it. I feel as if theism is illogical but I still feel drawn to it

I’m afraid to join the church as my reasons will be baseless and won’t last I’m afraid.

Should look into joining?

Would it be wrong to join on something this hollow?

What should I do?


r/AskAPriest • • Aug 28 '25

Are the children who died in the Catholic school shooting martyrs?

159 Upvotes

Hello father's. The recent catholic school shooting is weighing heavy on me today as a mother and former school teacher. I was just wondering what the terms are for martyrdom. Are these children considered a victim of circumstance or martyrs. Praying heavily for their souls and for the families. Thank you.


r/AskAPriest • • Apr 19 '22

Are husbands allowed to bless their wives and children??

157 Upvotes

A Catholic “influencer” I know of has shared that her husband gives her blessings/has the authority to give blessings to his family. Is this true? Is this a church teaching? I am not looking to argue with her or call her out for blasphemy or anything (I don’t follow closely and am not Catholic), I had just never heard of this before.


r/AskAPriest • • Aug 13 '19

What do you do if you can't find joy in a celibate life?

157 Upvotes

I'm a gay guy in his late thirties. I've been a Catholic my whole life, so I've always been celibate. When I realized I was gay and that wasn't going to change in my late teens, I didn't even question that I would have to be single for the rest of my life. I thought sexually active gay men were excessively lustful, unable to be faithful, and incapable of really loving each other the way straight couples do. I was devastated about not being suited for marriage and fatherhood, but I didn't think I would be missing out on anything of value by refraining from acting on my feelings for men.

It was a painful and scary awakening, and too long in coming, but I've learned over the years from experience of real gay people that those views were misguided. Regardless of the sinfulness of gay sex, gay couples are just as capable of sincerely loving, caring about, and faithfully committing to each other as straight couples, they experience sexual intimacy as unitive in the same way straight couples do, they make good adoptive parents, and they seem just as able to find real support, belonging, and fulfilment in their relationships. And as I've come to these realizations, it's made me question the need to live a celibate life seriously for the first time. I've talked to my pastor about some of these doubts, but there are some things I'm a little afraid to ask him, since I have to face him outside the confessional. So I thought I'd ask you.

First of all, I feel exhausted and persistently unhappy with celibacy. I live a chaste life, but I feel suffocated and lonely and like I'm white knuckling my way through this one day at a time. There have been stretches where I accepted this as a dreary necessity of my life without getting too down about it, but I've never found any joy in living this way. I know that Jesus calls us to take up our crosses and follow him, I know God may call us to make great sacrifices, and that we are not promised happiness all the time. But we are also promised that the burden will be light, and that one of the fruits of the Spirit is joy. In twenty years of living this commitment to celibacy out, I haven't found any joy in it, and I don't know what else to do. Without feeling like my celibacy is for something, it feels like a life sentence for being different. It feels like God hates me, or at least this really big part of me that I can't change.

Have any of you felt similarly and moved past it? I want to trust the church, I want to have faith that my sacrifices haven't been in vain. But I feel like I've been lied to about a lot of things, and that doesn't make it easy. I know celibacy is part of your calling to the priesthood, and that gives it a built-in purpose and institutional support I lack, but I thought maybe your experience could still help me to find joy in a life without romantic love and a family of my own.

Thank you in advance for giving me your consideration and putting up with my complaining.